Attachment I - In Favor-Support - Z-37-19-2
Extracted text (via pymupdf)
23386 characters
1 David O Simmons From: David O Simmons Sent: Tuesday, May 19, 2020 9:10 AM To: 'Paige Balduzzi' Cc: 'Dave Cisiewski' Subject: RE: Zoning Case GPA-DV-2-19-2 Mr. & Ms. Balduzzi, Thank you for reaching out in regard to Rezoning Case No. Z-37-19-2 and General Plan Amendment Case No. GPA-2-19- 2. Your support has been noted and added to the case file to be included as part of the public record. I have also forwarded your email to the applicant as well as to the members of the Deer Valley Village Planning Committee so they are aware of your support. If you wish to speak at the virtual meeting, please submit a request to David Simmons, Deer Valley Village Planner, via email at David.Simmons@phoenix.gov at least 48 hours prior to the start of the meeting (I am adding your names to the speaker list as you mentioned you would like to speak in your message below). Please indicate the item(s) number on the agenda if you wish to speak. Staff will provide you further instructions on the process for public comment during the virtual meeting. Staff will make every effort to accommodate requests to speak submitted beyond the 48 hour period. Due to the added demands of facilitating the virtual environment for the public, applicants and other staff members, we cannot consider any request less than six business hours before the start of the meeting. I encourage you to virtually attend all public hearings moving forward. The Deer Valley Village Planning Committee meeting is scheduled on May 21, 2020 at 6:00 PM. The meeting agenda has been posted outlining detailed instructions on how to access the meeting via telephone (land line or cell phone) and via the internet. The Planning Commission meeting is scheduled on June 4, 2020. For more information, please see: https://www.phoenix.gov/cityclerk/publicmeetings/notices The City Council meeting is scheduled on June 24, 2020 at 2:30 PM. For more information, please see: https://www.phoenix.gov/cityclerk/publicmeetings/city-council-meetings The staff report and applicants hearing draft are available for review on the City’s website: https://www.phoenix.gov/pdd/planning-zoning/pzservices/pud-cases Please let me know if you have additional comments or concerns. Respectfully, David Simmons, MA Planner II* Village Planner 200 West Washington Street 3rd Floor Phoenix, AZ 85003 602-262-4072 david.simmons@phoenix.gov From: Paige Balduzzi <mrs.balduzzi@gmail.com> Sent: Tuesday, May 19, 2020 8:30 AM ATTACHMENT I 2 To: David O Simmons <david.simmons@phoenix.gov> Subject: Zoning Case GPA-DV-2-19-2 David, My name is Paige Balduzzi. My husband, Anthony, and I would both like to speak in support of zoning case GPA-DV-2- 19-2 and companion case Z-37-19-2 at the Deer Valley Village meeting on Thursday, May 21st. We will be speaking separately, but will be using the same computer to join the video call. Thanks, -- Paige Balduzzi 1 David O Simmons From: Stanley.Foreman@pinnaclewest.com Sent: Wednesday, May 20, 2020 9:37 AM To: David O Simmons Subject: register to speak David, My name is Stanley Foreman. I would like to speak in support of zoning case GPA-DV-2-19-2 and companion case Z- 37-19-2 at the Deer Valley Village meeting on Thursday, May 21st. Please let me know if there is anything else I need to do to be registered as a speaker. Thanks, Stanley Stanley Foreman Jr. | Senior Attorney | Pinnacle West Capital Corporation Office 602-250-4697 | Palo Verde 623-393-4697 | Cell 480-622-1414 | stanley.foreman@pinnaclewest.com --- NOTICE --- This message is for the designated recipient only and may contain confidential, privileged or proprietary information. If you have received it in error, please notify the sender immediately and delete the original and any copy or printout. Unintended recipients are prohibited from making any other use of this e-mail. Although we have taken reasonable precautions to ensure no viruses are present in this e-mail, we accept no liability for any loss or damage arising from the use of this e-mail or attachments, or for any delay or errors or omissions in the contents which result from e-mail transmission. 1 David O Simmons From: Bryan Barrett <bryan@barrettz.net> Sent: Sunday, April 26, 2020 7:51 PM To: David O Simmons Subject: Union Foothills Estates Question - Village Planning Committee Meeting 21 May 2020 Hi David, I own a home and 6.4 acres in this area and want to say that I could be in full support the support of the subdivision if I could see a plan for what they intend to do and if it will bring city services closer to our residences and may even help us get annexed into Phoenix so we can have city services and roads. Could this subdivision help get us annexed? Gratefully, Bryan Barrett On Sun, Apr 26, 2020 at 10:48 AM Verno Associates <VA4613@msn.com> wrote: Thank you Mr. Finley for your e-mail. For all concerned: This meeting, along with other near-term meetings, are being proposed as a “Virtual” meeting(s). We are trying to fight this approach to satisfy the process because of the amount of community residences interested in this rezoning effort. I have attached the document we received from the CoP representative. Please feel free to pass this on to any and all of the community residences. William (Bill) Verno Verno & Associates, Inc. va4613@msn.com 623-587-4613 (Office/Fax) 602-291-3194 (Cell) [CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE: This e-mail transmission may contain privileged, confidential and/or proprietary information that is covered by the Federal Electronic Communications Privacy Act and/or Client privileges. This e-mail transmissions is intended only for the person(s) named and if you are not the intended recipient, please destroy this message, and any attachments, and notify the sender by return e-mail. If you are not the intended recipient(s), or the employee or agent responsible for delivering the message to the intended recipient(s), you are hereby notified that any dissemination, disclosure or copying of this communication is strictly prohibited. This message is intended only for the use of the person(s), (intended recipient), to whom it is addressed. It may contain information that is 2 privileged and confidential. If you are not the intended recipient, please reply to the sender as soon as possible and delete the message from your computer. Any dissemination, distribution, copying or other use of this message or any of its content by a person other than the intended recipient is strictly prohibited.] From: Kevin Finley <kjfinley.email@gmail.com> Sent: Sunday, April 26, 2020 8:44 AM To: Verno Associates <VA4613@msn.com> Subject: Re: Village Planning Committee Meeting 21 May 2020 I plan to attend. Right-click or tap and hold here to download pictures. To help protect your privacy, Outlook prevented automatic download of this picture from the Internet. [avg.com] Virus-free. www.avg.com [avg.com] On Wed, Apr 22, 2020 at 1:09 PM Verno Associates <VA4613@msn.com> wrote: Attached is a picture of the new Village Planning Meeting schedule as of this morning. The next Committee meetings scheduled for 21 May 2020 and we haven’t had our second community meeting.re [meeting.re] doesn’t seem to be any Some people may receive a duplicate of this, please let me know if you do, William (Bill) Verno Verno & Associates, Inc. va4613@msn.com 623-587-4613 (Office/Fax) 602-291-3194 (Cell) [CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE: This e-mail transmission may contain privileged, confidential and/or proprietary information that is covered by the Federal Electronic Communications Privacy Act and/or Client privileges. This e-mail transmissions is intended only for the person(s) named and if you are not the intended recipient, please destroy this message, and any attachments, and notify the sender by return e-mail. If you are not the intended recipient(s), or the employee or agent responsible for delivering the message to the intended recipient(s), you are hereby notified that any dissemination, disclosure or copying of this communication is strictly prohibited. This message is intended only for the use of the person(s), (intended recipient), to whom it is addressed. It may contain information that is privileged and confidential. If you are not the intended recipient, please reply to the sender as soon as possible and delete the message from your computer. Any dissemination, distribution, copying or other use of this message or any of its content by a person other than the intended recipient is strictly prohibited.] 1 David O Simmons From: Bryan Barrett <bryan@barrettz.net> Sent: Saturday, May 16, 2020 5:45 PM To: David O Simmons Cc: Kristi Trisko Subject: Fwd: SUBJECT: NOTICE OF PUBLIC MEETING; DEER VALLEY VILLAGE PLANNING COMMITTEE MEETING ON 21 APRIL 2020 Hi David, I just want to share that, unlike some of my more vocal neighbors, I am in full support of the community development project on Deer Valley and 7th street as long as roads are improved and there’s beautification of the area. I’d love to see the city of Phoenix annex the Union Foothills estates. We are surrounded by the city of Phoenix and being a county island has drawbacks such as no access to city services like water and roads. My hope is this development brings us closer to having city services. Thanks, Bryan ---------- Forwarded message --------- From: Verno Associates <VA4613@msn.com> Date: Sun, May 17, 2020 at 5:11 AM Subject: SUBJECT: NOTICE OF PUBLIC MEETING; DEER VALLEY VILLAGE PLANNING COMMITTEE MEETING ON 21 APRIL 2020 To: nynative2206@yahoo.com <nynative2206@yahoo.com>, diane.hubbard@dvusd.org <diane.hubbard@dvusd.org>, hoover42@aol.com <hoover42@aol.com>, ashprag73@gmail.com <ashprag73@gmail.com>, normmaul@normmaulinsurance.com <normmaul@normmaulinsurance.com>, Andrea Jurewicz <ajurewicz@me.com>, Karie Engstler <engstlerkarie@gmail.com>, snipermt@hotmail.com <snipermt@hotmail.com>, drevs@hotmail.com <drevs@hotmail.com>, Robert Hanson <linda@phoenixprecastproducts.com>, melodybyerrum@gmail.com <melodybyerrum@gmail.com>, shopjulienow@gmail.com <shopjulienow@gmail.com>, vac1104@aol.com <vac1104@aol.com>, kjjetjockey@msn.com <kjjetjockey@msn.com>, RONALD G LETNER <ronpamletner@msn.com>, rosemaryvogt22@gmail.com <rosemaryvogt22@gmail.com>, Phyllis Carter <phyllis.carter.de@gmail.com>, darla.bland.we@gmail.com <darla.bland.we@gmail.com>, magaw79@gmail.com <magaw79@gmail.com>, ryanjparks@ymail.com <ryanjparks@ymail.com>, roseannaball@ymail.com <roseannaball@ymail.com>, GloriaBurson@aol.com <GloriaBurson@aol.com>, John Brennard <johnbrennard@hotmail.com>, mpcc5@msn.com <mpcc5@msn.com>, zack41@cox.net <zack41@cox.net>, michelelauchner@msn.com <michelelauchner@msn.com>, toninoffz@msn.com <toninoffz@msn.com>, onelnorberg@aol.com <onelnorberg@aol.com>, ksandy1117@msn.com <ksandy1117@msn.com>, ciridean@yahoo.com <ciridean@yahoo.com>, bobbjos@aol.com <bobbjos@aol.com>, apaaronmpeterson@gmail.com <apaaronmpeterson@gmail.com>, james@bellroadrv.com <james@bellroadrv.com>, Kristi Johnson <kzjohnson65@gmail.com>, pauley1950@yahoo.com <pauley1950@yahoo.com>, Daniel McDermott <ddmcdermott@gmail.com>, mwebert2828@yahoo.com <mwebert2828@yahoo.com>, jwwells3@cox.net <jwwells3@cox.net>, George Skoubis <geo.skoubis@gmail.com>, blazinbbq@icloud.com <blazinbbq@icloud.com>, patmosby@yahoo.com <patmosby@yahoo.com>, dyndalamaide@msn.com <dyndalamaide@msn.com>, Laurie De La Cruz <lauriedlc@outlook.com>, adamocarol@yahoo.com <adamocarol@yahoo.com>, susdecat@yahoo.com <susdecat@yahoo.com>, loganbryce82@gmail.com <loganbryce82@gmail.com>, impressivethreads.cindy@gmail.com <impressivethreads.cindy@gmail.com>, jeanne christiansen <jmchristiansen904@gmail.com>, h925a@earthlink.net 2 <h925a@earthlink.net>, Janet M <janetm@normmaulinsurance.com>, chevelledood@gmail.com <chevelledood@gmail.com>, paul-mona@outlook.com <paul-mona@outlook.com>, pinniclepeak@aol.com <pinniclepeak@aol.com>, sluke@amasscapital.com <sluke@amasscapital.com>, Bool, Mark <Mark.Bool@cvshealth.com>, russkyl49@msn.com <russkyl49@msn.com>, prillas@q.com <prillas@q.com>, danbeate@msn.com <danbeate@msn.com>, hurlygurl160@hotmail.com <hurlygurl160@hotmail.com>, peteolari@msn.com <peteolari@msn.com>, potterleroy@yahoo.com <potterleroy@yahoo.com>, bmsandy5@msn.com <bmsandy5@msn.com>, greggmosby@msn.com <greggmosby@msn.com>, nealdorothyhome@hotmail.com <nealdorothyhome@hotmail.com>, bgm_523@yahoo.com <bgm_523@yahoo.com>, Sandy Powers <powerssandy@msn.com>, kathy@sombreropainting.com <kathy@sombreropainting.com>, mdspicer@msn.com <mdspicer@msn.com>, tbird46@hotmail.com <tbird46@hotmail.com>, Charly Donelson <cdgd2623@hotmail.com>, Terri B <makasha21@hotmail.com>, Valerie Pieraccini <valpierac@gmail.com>, Robin McDermott <recmcdermott@gmail.com>, Janet Schilling <Janet@rjschilling.com>, Michael Harrison <cull302@gmail.com>, Meredith Harrison <merri916@gmail.com>, Zandra OKeefe <zokeefe.8@gmail.com>, fbff8@yahoo.com <fbff8@yahoo.com>, Joon Albany <joonandsteve@msn.com>, Toninoffz@gmail.com <Toninoffz@gmail.com>, jan.riley@advcomsolutions.biz <jan.riley@advcomsolutions.biz>, Flong8904@gmail.com <Flong8904@gmail.com>, Bryan Barrett <bryan@barrettz.net>, C_U_L8TR@hotmail.com <C_U_L8TR@hotmail.com>, johnsk823@hotmail.com <johnsk823@hotmail.com>, dfouts58@gmail.com <dfouts58@gmail.com>, sidhe001@yahoo.com <sidhe001@yahoo.com>, tictocdoc3@aol.com <tictocdoc3@aol.com>, Julia & KJ Guenther <gunruner@juno.com>, E Yearling Bob Johnson <bobsue3541@q.com>, Glenn True <N81cw@aol.com>, Nicole Childers <lvnchilders@gmail.com>, Connie @ MSN <bverno5813@msn.com>, Dave Riley <driley7@msn.com>, dmverno@yahoo.com <dmverno@yahoo.com>, E Yearling Allen Larsen <bigalarsen@aol.com>, E Yearling Anthony on 2nd St <Agraziano@cox.net>, E Yearling Bob Hanson (roberthanson1950@outlook.com) <roberthanson1950@outlook.com>, E Yearling Brenda Hamer <brenda.hamer@thrivent.com>, E Yearling Dennis Noffz <prescottmaaco@hotmail.com>, E Yearling Jim Collum <collumdrilling@msn.com>, E Yearling Julie Bradfeldt (julie@bradfeldt.com) <julie@bradfeldt.com>, CJ Blue <cjblue218@gmail.com>, E Yearling Kevin Finley 2nd St <Kjfinley.email@gmail.com>, E Yearling Sanders <saundersmasonry@msn.com>, skmeier18@hotmail.com <skmeier18@hotmail.com>, E Yearling Stuart Hamer <stuart.hamer@verizonwireless.com>, E Yearling Sutton <6232587502@vzwpix.com>, Heather Lennon (HeatherLennon@me.com) <HeatherLennon@me.com>, Verno Associates <va4613@msn.com>, A. Wendy Smith <wendysmith85085@gmail.com>, kcollum22@gmail.com <kcollum22@gmail.com>, Bill Sandy <Bill@sombreropainting.com> The attached public notice provides the meeting guidelines for submissions to be submitted by e-mail no-later-than 48 hours (i.e., 6PM) on the 19th of April 2020. It also states that they cannot consider any submissions less than 6 hours before the meeting start time. We received a number of inquiries from the community about submitting requests to speak at the Deer Valley Village Planning Committee virtual meeting scheduled for 21 May 2020. We suggest that every residence needs to voice their concerns about the applicant’s submission identified in the following Public Notice topics: 1. Item 5, GPA-DV-2-19-2 (Companion Case Z-37-19-2) is a Planned Unit Development (PUD) submission request to amend the General Plan Land Use Designation and allow the entire 156.96 acres to be broken up into three (3) separate parcels. 2. Item 6, Z-37-19-2 (Companion Case GPA-2-19-2) is a request to rezone the PUD Parcel 1 into a residential section. They seem to be using the entire 156.96 acres the PUD has divided into three parcels and to justify the Parcel 1 (78.3 acres) density from the current 1 dwelling/acre to 2.0 to 3.5 dwelling/acre which nearly equals the amount of dwellings as if there were no restrictions. 3 Again, please note that the item 5 and item 6 are Companion Cases, so we suggest you identify which of these your submission is addressing or state it is for both. 1. Submit your written request to speak along with the subject and a brief description to David Simmons (davidsimmons@phoenix.gov) by 6PM on the 19th of April 2020. However, they will consider submissions at least six (6) hours before the meeting time. We suggest you include, as a “cc”, Dave Riley (driley7@msn.com [msn.com]), Robert Hanson (roberthanson1950@outlook.com [outlook.com]), and myself (va4613@msn.com) in the e-mail. 2. Remember your submission should identify the specific topic of your submission. If there are submissions with same subject the committee chair has the options to select one spokes-person for that subject. As such, be specific in the topic subject you want to speak to. 3. If you have any questions about the formalities of the meeting call David Simmons at 602-262-4072. We also suggest you include the following as “cc” precipitants mayor.gallego@phoenix.gov; nbarto@azleg.gov; John.allen@azleg.gov; julie.riemenschneider@phoenix.gov; leverock.anthony@azdeq.gov; rosanne.albright@phoenix.gov; nancy.allen@phoenix.gov; zach.schira@maricopa.gov; Sal.Diciccio@phoenix.gov; Malone.laura@azdeq.gov; Jim.Waring@phoenix.gov; council.district.1@phoenix.gov; kristi.trisko@phoenix.gov; Samantha Keating samantha.keating@phoenix.gov; Kristi Trisko <kristi.trisko@phoenix.gov> William (Bill) Verno Verno & Associates, Inc. va4613@msn.com 623-587-4613 (Office/Fax) 602-291-3194 (Cell) [CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE: This e-mail transmission may contain privileged, confidential and/or proprietary information that is covered by the Federal Electronic Communications Privacy Act and/or Client privileges. This e-mail transmissions is intended only for the person(s) named and if you are not the intended recipient, please destroy this message, and any attachments, and notify the sender by return e-mail. If you are not the intended recipient(s), or the employee or agent responsible for delivering the message to the intended recipient(s), you are hereby notified that any dissemination, disclosure or copying of this communication is strictly prohibited. This message is intended only for the use of the person(s), (intended recipient), to whom it is addressed. It may contain information that is privileged and confidential. If you are not the intended recipient, please reply to the sender as soon as possible and delete the message from your computer. Any dissemination, distribution, copying or other use of this message or any of its content by a person other than the intended recipient is strictly prohibited.] 15125 N. Scottsdale Road Suite 200 Scottsdale, AZ 85254 June 3, 2020 City of Phoenix Planning Commission Paradise Valley Village Planning Committee City of Phoenix Planning and Development Department 200 West Washington Street 3rd Floor Phoenix, AZ 85003 RE: Rezoning Case Z-61-19-2 - Embrey PUD Proposal Planning Commission Members, This letter is concerning the rezoning Case Z-61-19-2 (Embrey Project), which proposes to rezone the parcel located at 15826 N. Scottsdale Road. Lennar Multifamily Communities (LMC) is in support of this project. As some of you may be aware, LMC owns a 3.8 acre parcel that is currently under construction to the immediate west of the subject parcel. We are proud to be a part of the evolution that is taking place in Kierland and understand that the redevelopment of other properties in the area is an important part of Kierland’s growth and continued relevance. LMC previously communicated publicly at Monday’s Paradise Valley Village Planning Committee meeting that it was generally supportive of the redevelopment of the subject parcel but not in support of the project as currently proposed. After considering the results of the Village Planning Committee and subsequent discussions with Embrey and Nick Wood, LMC has determined that it would like to see this project approved and support the PUD application as it stands. For additional context, LMC regrets not getting involved with the applicant sooner in the process where some additional collaboration may have occurred and acknowledges that the applicant and Nick Wood contacted LMC during the process. Any additional initiative to discuss the details of the project should have come from LMC. Sincerely, Nate Stum Vice President, Development Lennar Multifamily Communities 1 Racelle Escolar From: Matthew Kenney <matthewjkenney85@gmail.com> Sent: Thursday, August 6, 2020 2:29 PM To: PDD Planning Commission Subject: Z-37-19-2 (Central Foothills PUD) (Companion Case GPA-DV-2-19-2) Chairman and members of the Commission, My name is Matt Kenney and I’m reaching out in support of items 3 and 4 as a village member of the Deer Valley Village Planning Committee. We saw this case in front of us twice, once for informational and the second for a vote, and each time we saw the developer’s willingness to communicate with the neighboring county community through constant outreach via knocking doors in the community or trading emails and phone calls back and forth. From what we saw, the developer had made compromises with the community to ensure this development was something everyone could be comfortable with. No doubt when you’ve lived in an area for some time, it can be hard to see the surrounding properties change and develop. As the City of Phoenix continues to grow in population, our need for housing grows as well. The City has a severe lack of housing, so when a developer comes along and offers to not only provide additional housing in what appeared to be a well designed community, but also to supply millions in infrastructure costs to help make future annexations and developments possible for Phoenix’s continued growth, it was easy for vote yes on this project. As a member of the committee overseeing this village, I strongly ask that you all consider voting yes on this development. Thank you, Matt Kenney 1 Racelle Escolar From: Ann O'Brien <annobrienaz@gmail.com> Sent: Thursday, August 6, 2020 11:08 AM To: PDD Planning Commission Subject: Approve Central Foothills Project Chairman Johnson and Members, My name is Ann O'Brien. I sit on the Deer Valley Village Planning Committee. Please approve the Central Foothills Project, GPA‐DV‐2‐19‐2 and Z‐37‐19‐2. While many of us would prefer our communities stay the same, it is important to recognize and pursue the right opportunities to grow and improve our neighborhoods. I believe this is one of those opportunities. The developers have worked diligently to address the neighboring community's concerns. Compromises made by the developer include reduced density, additional neighborhood access off of Central Avenue, and a traffic light at Central Avenue and Happy Valley Road, just to name a few. Additionally, the Central Foothills Project will provide $7‐$10 million of infrastructure to the area by bringing access to water and sewer. Please vote to approve the Central Foothills Project. ‐‐ Respectfully, Ann O'Brien 602‐318‐4616 “Every child should have the opportunity to receive a quality education!” Bill Frist