Attachment E - Support - Z-78-24-5.pdf

City of Phoenix — Formal (2024-10-02)

View PDF Meeting page

Extracted text (via pymupdf) 20995 characters
CAUTION: This email originated outside of the City of Phoenix.
Do not click links or open attachments unless you know the sender and were
expecting this email.
  Report Suspicious  
‌
From:
Amy Schwabenlender
To:
Chase Hales
Cc:
Amy Schwabenlender
Subject:
supportive senior housing (Z-78-24-5)
Date:
Wednesday, August 21, 2024 10:00:36 AM
Dear Mr. Hales,
My name is Amy Schwabenlender, and I’m reaching out as a resident of the City of
Phoenix, the CEO of Keys to Change, and as a supporter of the Home is Where it All Starts
campaign, a campaign that envisions a future where every Arizonan has a place to be at
home. I write to express my support for the conversion of a hotel near Interstate 17 and
Northern Avenue, into supportive senior housing (Z-78-24-5). 
According to a new report by the Morrison Institute, rents in Arizona increased by 72% from
2010 to 2022. This greatly affects vulnerable communities like seniors, who often do not
have the ability to keep up with these rapid price changes. Homelessness has also
increased and is at the highest level since 2010. In 2023, there were 14,237 people who
experienced homelessness, including over a thousand older adults. Keys to Change is
working to end homelessness through a variety of programs. One of them is the
coordinated entry system for single adults in Maricopa County. In the System we manage a
list of 8,000 unique individuals who are unhoused and waiting for affordable housing.
This project proposes to convert a hotel into permanent supportive housing for seniors. The
state’s housing crisis and increasing rents have put additional pressure on our seniors, who
deserve support and shelter. While this project alone will not solve the homelessness crisis,
we must do everything we can to ensure that every Arizonan can be at home and live a
stable, purposeful life.
For these reasons, I and Keys to Change support this project.
Thank you,
Amy
Amy Schwabenlender​ | CEO
Keys to Change | Working Together. Ending Homelessness.
amys@keystochangeaz.org
ATTACHMENT E

August 21, 2024 
 
Dear Mr. Hales, 
 
My name is Bruce Weber and I’m reaching out as a resident of the City of Phoenix and as a 
supporter of the Home is where it all starts campaign, a campaign that envisions a future 
where every Arizonan has a place to be at home, to express my support for the conversion 
of a hotel near Interstate 17 and Northern Avenue, into supportive senior housing (Z-78-24-
5).  
 
According to a new report by the Morrison Institute, rents in Arizona increased by 72% from 
2010 to 2022. This greatly aSects vulnerable communities like seniors, who often do not 
have the ability to keep up with these rapid price changes. Homelessness has also 
increased and is at the highest level since 2010. In 2023, there were 14,237 people who 
experienced homelessness, including over a thousand older adults.  
 
This project proposes to convert a hotel into permanent supportive housing for seniors. The 
state’s housing crisis and increasing rents have put additional pressure on our seniors, who 
deserve support and shelter. While this project alone will not solve the homelessness 
crisis, we must do everything we can to ensure that every Arizonan can be at home and live 
a stable, purposeful life. 
 
For these reasons, I support this project. 
 
Sincerely, 
Bruce Weber

CAUTION: This email originated outside of the City of Phoenix.
Do not click links or open attachments unless you know the sender and were
expecting this email.
     Report Suspicious     ‌
From:
Jeff Letey
To:
Chase Hales
Subject:
Supportive Senior Housing (Z-78-24-5)
Date:
Wednesday, August 21, 2024 11:11:03 AM
Dear Mr. Hales,
My name is Jeff Letey and I’m reaching out as a resident of the City of Phoenix and as a
supporter of the Home is where it all starts campaign, a campaign that envisions a future
where every Arizonan has a place to be at home, to express my support for the conversion
of a hotel near Interstate 17 and Northern Avenue, into supportive senior housing (Z-78-24-
5). 
According to a new report by the Morrison Institute, rents in Arizona increased by 72% from
2010 to 2022. This greatly affects vulnerable communities like seniors, who often do not
have the ability to keep up with these rapid price changes. Homelessness has also
increased and is at the highest level since 2010. In 2023, there were 14,237 people who
experienced homelessness, including over a thousand older adults. 
This project proposes to convert a hotel into permanent supportive housing for seniors. The
state’s housing crisis and increasing rents have put additional pressure on our seniors, who
deserve support and shelter. While this project alone will not solve the homelessness crisis,
we must do everything we can to ensure that every Arizonan can be at home and live a
stable, purposeful life.
For these reasons, I support this project.
Sincerely,
Jeff Letey

Violence Impact Project Coalition 
VISION:  An Active, safe and welcoming community with vibrant retail and sustainable housing. 
The Coalition will focus on education, partnerships, outreach and strategic planning within the VIP 
boundaries of Dunlap to Indian School and 19th Avenue to 35th Avenue. 
 
August 21, 2024 
 
NORTH MOUNTAIN  VILLAGE PLANNING COMMITTEE 
ATTN:  CHASE HALES 
 
 
REF: Z-78-24-5 
 
The Violence Impact Project Coalition submits this letter of support for the proposed zoning change 
from C-2 (Intermediate Commercial) to C-2 DNS/WVR (Intermediate Commercial, Density Waiver) to 
allow a community residence center (supportive senior housing). 
 
27th Avenue “To Do List” The “To Do List” was developed by the community with assistance by the 
Planning and Development Department. The guide applies to the area from 23rd Avenue to 29th 
Avenue and from Indian School Road to Dunlap Avenue. The neighborhood-led effort focuses on 
achieving “an active, safe, and welcoming community with vibrant retail and sustainable housing.” The 
guide articulates goals and strategies focused on pedestrian-friendly design and connectivity, pedestrian 
safety on roadways, branding, advocacy, and placemaking initiatives. To promote Crime Prevention 
Through Environmental Design (CPTED) principals to enhance neighborhood safety, a security guidelines 
section has been provided within the PUD narrative that includes standards for natural surveillance, 
secured access, lighting, landscaping, and activation of space.   
 
The VIP Coalition supports this project as it is consistent with our goals and vision for An active, safe, 
and welcoming community with vibrant retail and sustainable housing. This project also leverages one of 
our key community assets, The Helen Drake Senior Center, The Haven and Innovation 27 with the need 
for affordable housing, especially for seniors.  
 
We want to note that the community negotiated a Good Neighbor Agreement along with a plan to 
address crime and safety on Northern Ave near The Haven and this proposed zoning case to ensure that 
seniors would have a safe environment from which to come and go.  There has been progress since the 
agreement was made with the City and CASS, but there is still much work to be done to ensure the 
safety of our vulnerable seniors living in The Haven and the newly proposed senior housing permanent 
supportive housing project.  We expect the City to ensure that these agreements are upheld before the 
opening of either The Haven or this proposed senior housing project.   
 
We look forward to seeing this project move forward through the zoning process so that we can get this 
project built and serving vulnerable seniors in our community.   
 
Sincerely,  
 
 
 
Jeff Spellman 
VIP Coalition Leadership Team 
phoenixvipcoalition@gmail.com 
602-499-2038

CAUTION: This email originated outside of the City of Phoenix.
Do not click links or open attachments unless you know the sender and were
expecting this email.
     Report Suspicious     ‌
From:
Jessica Mitchell
To:
Chase Hales
Subject:
Support for Home is Where it All Starts
Date:
Wednesday, August 21, 2024 12:08:11 PM
Dear Mr. Hales,
My name is Jessica, and I’m reaching out as a resident of the City of Phoenix and as a
supporter of the Home is Where it All Starts campaign. This campaign envisions a future
where every Arizonan has a place to be at home. I want to express my support for
converting a hotel near Interstate 17 and Northern Avenue into supportive senior housing
(Z-78-24-5). 
According to a new report by the Morrison Institute, rents in Arizona increased by 72% from
2010 to 2022. This dramatically affects vulnerable communities like seniors, who often
cannot keep up with these rapid price changes. Homelessness has also increased and is at
its highest level since 2010. In 2023, 14,237 people experienced homelessness, including
over a thousand older adults. 
This project proposes to convert a hotel into permanent supportive housing for seniors. The
state’s housing crisis and increasing rents have put additional pressure on our seniors, who
deserve support and shelter. While this project alone will not solve the homelessness crisis,
we must do everything we can to ensure that every Arizonan can be at home and live a
stable, purposeful life.
For these reasons, I support this project.
Sincerely,
-- 
Jessica Mitchell
Doctor of Naturopathic Medicine

CAUTION: This email originated outside of the City of Phoenix.
Do not click links or open attachments unless you know the sender and were
expecting this email.
     Report Suspicious     ‌
From:
Lauren Grucky
To:
Chase Hales
Subject:
Senior Supportive Housing | North Mountain Village
Date:
Wednesday, August 21, 2024 9:10:10 AM
Dear Mr. Hales,
My name is Lauren Harkins Grucky and I’m reaching out as a resident of the City of
Phoenix and as a supporter of the Home is Where it All Starts campaign, a campaign
that envisions a future where every Arizonan has a place to be at home, to express
my support for the conversion of a hotel near Interstate 17 and Northern Avenue,
into supportive senior housing (Z-78-24-5). 
According to a new report by the Morrison Institute, rents in Arizona increased by
72% from 2010 to 2022. This greatly affects vulnerable communities like seniors,
who often do not have the ability to keep up with these rapid price changes.
Homelessness has also increased and is at the highest level since 2010. In 2023,
there were 14,237 people who experienced homelessness, including over a thousand
older adults. 
This project proposes to convert a hotel into permanent supportive housing for
seniors. The state’s housing crisis and increasing rents have put additional pressure
on our seniors, who deserve support and shelter. While this project alone will not
solve the homelessness crisis, we must do everything we can to ensure that every
Arizonan can be at home and live a stable, purposeful life.
For these reasons, I support this project.
Sincerely,
Lauren Harkins Grucky
(614) 301-8000
Home Address: 8517 North 15th Drive
Phoenix, AZ 85021

CAUTION: This email originated outside of the City of Phoenix.
Do not click links or open attachments unless you know the sender and were
expecting this email.
     Report Suspicious     ‌
From:
McCady Findley
To:
Chase Hales
Subject:
I-17 and Northern Ave Hotel Conversion
Date:
Wednesday, August 21, 2024 12:30:07 PM
Dear Mr. Hales,
My name is McCady Findley and I’m reaching out as a resident of the City of Phoenix and
as a supporter of the Home is where it all starts campaign, a campaign that envisions a
future where every Arizonan has a place to be at home, to express my support for the
conversion of a hotel near Interstate 17 and Northern Avenue, into supportive senior
housing (Z-78-24-5). 
According to a new report by the Morrison Institute, rents in Arizona increased by 72% from
2010 to 2022. This greatly affects vulnerable communities like seniors, who often do not
have the ability to keep up with these rapid price changes. Homelessness has also
increased and is at the highest level since 2010. In 2023, there were 14,237 people who
experienced homelessness, including over a thousand older adults. 
This project proposes to convert a hotel into permanent supportive housing for seniors. The
state’s housing crisis and increasing rents have put additional pressure on our seniors, who
deserve support and shelter. While this project alone will not solve the homelessness crisis,
we must do everything we can to ensure that every Arizonan can be at home and live a
stable, purposeful life.
For these reasons, I support this project.
Sincerely,
McCady Findley
720.939.9083 | mccady.findley@gmail.com
LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/mccadyfindley/ [linkedin.com]

CAUTION: This email originated outside of the City of Phoenix.
Do not click links or open attachments unless you know the sender and were
expecting this email.
     Report Suspicious     ‌
From:
Natalka Zeleny
To:
Chase Hales
Subject:
In Support of Senior Housing Northern and I17
Date:
Wednesday, August 21, 2024 10:16:03 AM
Dear Mr. Hales,
My name is Natalka Zeleny and I’m reaching out as a resident of the City of Phoenix
and as a supporter of The Home is Where It All Starts campaign, a campaign that
envisions a future where every Arizonan has a place to be at home, to express my
support for the conversion of a hotel near Interstate 17 and Northern Avenue, into
supportive senior housing (Z-78-24-5). 
According to a new report by the Morrison Institute, rents in Arizona increased by
72% from 2010 to 2022. This greatly affects vulnerable communities like seniors, who
often do not have the ability to keep up with these rapid price changes. In 2023, there
were 14,237 people who experienced homelessness, including over a thousand older
adults. 
This project proposes to convert a hotel into permanent supportive housing for
seniors. The state’s housing crisis and increasing rents have put additional pressure
on our seniors, who deserve support and shelter. While this project alone will not
solve the homelessness crisis, we must do everything we can to ensure that every
Arizonan can be at home and live a stable, purposeful life.
For these reasons, I support this project.
Sincerely,
Natalka L. Zeleny

1
Racelle Escolar
From:
Lauren Grucky <lauren.e.harko@gmail.com>
Sent:
Thursday, August 29, 2024 3:12 PM
To:
PDD Planning Commission
Subject:
9/5 Agenda | Senior Supportive Housing
 
CAUTION: This email originated outside of the City of Phoenix.  
Do not click links or open attachments unless you know the sender and were expecting this 
email.  
    Report Suspicious     
 
Dear Planning Commission Members, 
 
My name is Lauren Grucky and I’m reaching out as a resident of the City of Phoenix and as a supporter of the 
Home is where it all starts campaign, a campaign that envisions a future where every Arizonan has a place to 
be at home, to express my support for the conversion of a hotel near Interstate 17 and Northern Avenue, into 
supportive senior housing (Z-78-24-5). This is Item #12 on the September 5 Planning Commission Agenda. 
 
According to a new report by the Morrison Institute, rents in Arizona increased by 72% from 2010 to 2022. This 
greatly affects vulnerable communities like seniors, who often do not have the ability to keep up with these 
rapid price changes. Homelessness has also increased and is at the highest level since 2010. In 2023, there 
were 14,237 people who experienced homelessness, including over a thousand older adults.  
 
This project proposes to convert a hotel into permanent supportive housing for seniors. The state’s housing 
crisis and increasing rents have put additional pressure on our seniors, who deserve support and shelter. 
While this project alone will not solve the homelessness crisis, we must do everything we can to ensure that 
every Arizonan can be at home and live a stable, purposeful life. 
 
For these reasons, I support this project. 
 
Sincerely, 
Lauren Grucky 
 
8517 N 15th Drive 
Phoenix, AZ 85021 
 
(614) 301-8000

August 29, 2024 
 
 
City of Phoenix Planning Committee 
pdd.planningcomm@phoenix.gov. 
 
re: Z-28-24-5 
 
Dear Planning Commission Members: 
 
 
My name is Tom Kelly, and I’m reaching out as a resident of the City of Phoenix and as a 
supporter of the Home Is Where It All Starts campaign, a campaign that envisions a future 
where every Arizonan has a place to be at home. I want to express my support for the 
conversion of a hotel near Interstate 17 and Northern Avenue, into supportive senior housing (Z-
78-24-5). This is Item #12 on the September 5 Planning Commission Agenda. 
 
According to a new report by the Morrison Institute, rents in Arizona increased by 72% from 
2010 to 2022. This greatly affects vulnerable communities like seniors, of whom a majority are 
on fixed incomes and who rarely have the ability to afford these price increases.  
 
This project proposes to convert a hotel into permanent supportive housing for seniors. The 
conversion of hotels is a proven effective solution - older facilities often crime-ridden and in 
disrepair are transformed into an quiet, attractive community. 
Traffic is reduced.  
 
While this project alone will not solve the homelessness crisis, we must  
 
For these reasons, I support this project. 
 
Sincerely, 
 
 
 
 
Tom Kelly 
30 E Saint Anne Ave 
Phoenix, AZ 85042-4223

1
Racelle Escolar
From:
Jessica Mitchell <jessmitchellnd@gmail.com>
Sent:
Saturday, August 31, 2024 7:20 AM
To:
PDD Planning Commission
Subject:
Healthy Neighborhoods
 
CAUTION: This email originated outside of the City of Phoenix.  
Do not click links or open attachments unless you know the sender and were expecting this 
email.  
    Report Suspicious     
 
Dear Planning Commission Members, 
 
My name is Jessica Mitchell and I’m reaching out as a resident of the City of Phoenix and as a supporter of the 
Home is where it all starts campaign, a campaign that envisions a future where every Arizonan has a place to 
be at home, to express my support for the conversion of a hotel near Interstate 17 and Northern Avenue, into 
supportive senior housing (Z-78-24-5). This is Item #12 on the September 5 Planning Commission Agenda. 
 
According to a new report by the Morrison Institute, rents in Arizona increased by 72% from 2010 to 2022. This 
greatly affects vulnerable communities like seniors, who often do not have the ability to keep up with these 
rapid price changes. Homelessness has also increased and is at the highest level since 2010. In 2023, there 
were 14,237 people who experienced homelessness, including over a thousand older adults.  
 
This project proposes to convert a hotel into permanent supportive housing for seniors. The state’s housing 
crisis and increasing rents have put additional pressure on our seniors, who deserve support and shelter. 
While this project alone will not solve the homelessness crisis, we must do everything we can to ensure that 
every Arizonan can be at home and live a stable, purposeful life. 
 
For these reasons, I support this project. 
 
Sincerely, 
Jessica Mitchell 
Doctor of Naturopathic Medicine 
 
723 W Cactus Wren Dr. 
Phoenix, AZ 85021

1
Racelle Escolar
From:
McCady Findley <mccady.findley@gmail.com>
Sent:
Saturday, August 31, 2024 1:47 PM
To:
PDD Planning Commission
Subject:
Re: Item #12 on the September 5 Planning Commission Agenda
 
CAUTION: This email originated outside of the City of Phoenix.  
Do not click links or open attachments unless you know the sender and were expecting this 
email.  
    Report Suspicious     
 
Dear Planning Commission Members, 
 
My name is McCady Findley and I’m reaching out as a resident of the City of Phoenix and as a supporter of the 
Home is where it all starts campaign, a campaign that envisions a future where every Arizonan has a place to 
be at home, to express my support for the conversion of a hotel near Interstate 17 and Northern Avenue, into 
supportive senior housing (Z-78-24-5). This is Item #12 on the September 5 Planning Commission Agenda. 
 
According to a new report by the Morrison Institute, rents in Arizona increased by 72% from 2010 to 2022. This 
greatly affects vulnerable communities like seniors, who often do not have the ability to keep up with these 
rapid price changes. Homelessness has also increased and is at the highest level since 2010. In 2023, there 
were 14,237 people who experienced homelessness, including over a thousand older adults.  
 
This project proposes to convert a hotel into permanent supportive housing for seniors. The state’s housing 
crisis and increasing rents have put additional pressure on our seniors, who deserve support and shelter. 
While this project alone will not solve the homelessness crisis, we must do everything we can to ensure that 
every Arizonan can be at home and live a stable, purposeful life. 
 
For these reasons, I support this project. 
 
Sincerely, 
 
McCady Findley 
1411 E Orangewood Ave Unit 239 
Phoenix, AZ 85020