Attachment A - Request for Reconsideration of Item 50.pdf

City of Phoenix — Formal (2024-05-15)

View PDF Meeting page

Extracted text (via ocr_local) 3047 characters
Attachment A

G

City of Phoenix

OFFICE OF THE CITY COUNCIL

KESHA HODGE WASHINGTON
COUNCILWOMAN DISTRICT 8
602-262-7493
FAX: 602-495-0587
TY: 7-1-1

COUNCIL.DISTRICT.8@PHOENIX.GOV

May 8, 2024

City Clerk Denise Archibald
Phoenix City Hall

200 W. Washington St., 15th Floor
Phoenix, AZ 85003

Dear City Clerk Denise Archibald:

Pursuant to Rule 7(n) of the Rules of Council Proceedings I am submitting this Request to
Reconsider May 1, 2024 Formal Agenda Item #50, Amend Phoenix City Code Chapter 20: Office
of Accountability and Transparency (Ordinance G-7258) *** REVISED ***. I would further
request that this item be scheduled for reconsideration by the City Council at the next Formal

Meeting on May 15, 2024.

If successful, | would urge the adoption of the attached changes/additions to Section 20-
14(A)(1). I would not be asking for any other material changes to the balance of the ordinance.

Thank you,

Kes| ashington
Councilwoman

ce:
Mayor Kate Gallego
City Manager Jeff Barton

SS Wd O~ Ave 202
‘Ld3G 4YBID ALID

200 W. Washington St., 11th Floor, Phoenix, Arizona 85003-1611  phoenix.gov/district8
Recycled Paper

ARTICLE III.
PHOENIX CIVILIAN REVIEW BOARD

SEC. 20-14. PHOENIX CIVILIAN REVIEW BOARD ESTABLISHED: SELECTION
PROCESS; TERMS.
A. THE PHOENIX CIVILIAN REVIEW BOARD (THE “BOARD”) IS ESTABLISHED
AND SHALL BE COMPRISED OF NINE VOTING MEMBERS.

I. ALL VOTING MEMBERS SHALL EITHER RESIDE OR WORK IN THE CITY
OF PHOENIX. MEMBERS MUST BE AT LEAST 21 YEARS OF AGE, NO CURRENT OR
FORMER SWORN LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER IS ELIGIBLE TO SERVE AS A
VOTING MEMBER OF THE BOARD. NO INDIVIDUAL WHO HAS A PENDING CLAIM
OR LAWSUIT OR WHO WITHIN THE TEN YEARS PRECEDING APPOINTMENT HAS
FILED A CLAIM OR LAWSUIT RELATED TO ACTIONS BY THE CITY OF PHOENIX
POLICE DEPARTMENT AS STATED IN SECTION 20-6 MANDATORY OVERSIGHT BY
THE OAT IS ELIGIBLE TO SERVE AS A VOTING MEMBER OF THE BOARD.

a. MEMBER RESPONSIBILITIES.

i. EACH MEMBER SHALL CONDUCT THEMSELVES AT ALL
TIMES IN A MANNER THAT WILL MAINTAIN PUBLIC CONFIDENCE IN THE
FAIRNESS, IMPARTIALITY, AND INTEGRITY OF THE BOARD AND REFRAIN FROM
MAKING ANY PREJUDICIAL COMMENTS WITH RESPECT TO THE BOARD OR THE
CASES SUBJECT TO THE BOARD’S REVIEW.

il. EACH MEMBER SHALL REVIEW CASES ON’ AN
INDIVIDUAL BASIS AND MAKE DECISIONS BASED ONLY UPON THE FACTS AND
THE EVIDENCE BEFORE THEM. TO ENSURE ALL BOARD MEMBERS HAVE ACCESS

TO THE SAME EVIDENCE IN MAKING THEIR DETERMINATION. A REQUEST FOR

ADDITIONAL OR SUPPLEMENTAL INFORMATION IS TREATED AS AN ITEM
REQUIRING ACTION UNDER SECTION 20-15 AND MUST RECEIVE THE AFFIRMATIVE
VOTE OF FIVE MEMBERS BEFORE IT IS TO BE PROVIDED. ALL INFORMATION
RECEIVED THEREFROM MUST BE SHARED WITH ALL MEMBERS OF THE BOARD.
iil. EACH MEMBER SHALL BE SUBJECT TO AND BOUND BY
THE PROVISIONS OF THE CITY’S ETHICS AND GIFT POLICIES AND SHALL EXCUSE
THEMSELVES FROM PARTICIPATING IN THE REVIEW OF ANY COMPLAINT IN
WHICH THEY HAVE A PERSONAL OR FINANCIAL INTEREST.
b. FAILURE TO COMPLY WITH THE MEMBER RESPONSIBILITIES

MAY CONSTITUTE GROUNDS FOR REMOVAL FROM THE BOARD.