Attachment B - Approval Report 220030.pdf

City of Phoenix — Formal (2023-03-01)

View PDF Meeting page

Extracted text (via pymupdf) 5163 characters
1 
 
 
 
 
Planning and Development Department  
 
 
 
 
 
CONDITIONAL APPROVAL – ABND 220030 
 
 
 
   
 
Your abandonment request was granted CONDITIONAL APPROVAL by Christopher DePerro, 
Abandonment Hearing Officer.  
  
This request will NOT be completed until all the stipulations have been met and this request is 
formally adopted by City Council. It is the APPLICANT’S RESPONSIBILITY to ensure that all 
stipulations are satisfied. Please contact Alyssa Neitzel at 602-534-7321 for questions and 
notification of your completion of the stipulations.  
 
Upon completion of the stipulations your request will be scheduled for City Council action.  
 
If the stipulations of abandonment are not completed within two years from the date of your 
conditional approval (your expiration date is September 22, 2024), this request will then expire.  
At that time a new submittal will be required along with the required payment for the abandonment 
process. A one time, one year extension can be requested prior to the expiration date, with 
applicable extension fee due. 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
ATTACHMENT B

2 
 
 
Planning and Development Department  
 
 
September 22, 2022 
Preliminary Abandonment Staff Report: ABND 220030 
Project# 22-3137 
 Quarter Section: 18-36 
Council District: 6 
 
 
 
Location: 
37th Street and Elm Street 
 
 
Applicant:  
Meredith Esner 
 
 
Request:  
To abandon the length of alley bounded by 
37th Street on the west, 38th Street on the 
east, Elm Street on the north and Highland 
Avenue on the south. 
 
 
Purpose of request:  
The applicant states, “closing the alley will 
increase security and safety of our homes. It 
will also increase privacy as well as buildable 
area of the lots. Recently there has been an 
increase of nonresidents utilizing our alley for 
various purposes. We have found drug 
paraphernalia that was disconcerting.” 
 
 
Hearing date:  
September 22, 2022

3 
 
 
Hearing Summary 
Mr. Christopher DePerro, the Abandonment Hearing Officer calls the meeting to order at 9:32 
a.m. on September 22, 2022. 
Ms. Alyssa Neitzel, the Abandonment Coordinator, introduced abandonment ABND 220030 and 
read the case into the record by stating the applicant, location, and purpose of the request, as 
well as City staff research. 
 
Mr. DePerro then started the discussion by asking the applicant if they would like to add any 
additional comments regarding the abandonment request. 
Ms. Meredith Esner, applicant summarizes purpose of request and clarifies stipulation verbiage 
and Public Utility Easements. 
 
Mr. DePerro asks if there is any opposition to this abandonment request. 
 
Ms. Neitzel confirms there is not and proceeds with reading stipulations. 
 
Ms. Maja Brkovic, Streets Transportation Representative, reads stipulations 2 and 3 regarding 
monument lines. 
 
Mr. DePerro reads stipulation 5. 
 
Ms. Esner requests estimated cost of consideration fee and instructions on how to pay. 
 
Mr. DePerro asked if there were any attendees with additional questions or comments. No 
attendees had any questions or comments.

4 
 
The Hearing Officer grants conditional approval for abandonment 220030 subject to stipulations 
in staff report. 
 
Stipulations of Conditional Approval 
 
The request of abandonment is conditionally approved by the Abandonment Hearing Officer. 
The following stipulations will need to be met:  
 
1. Either a or b shall be complied with: 
a. All utilities shall be relocated to locations approved by each affected utility company.  
All work is to be done by each affected utility company at no expense to the affected 
utility company.  
b. All right-of-way shall be retained as a public utilities easement with 24-hour vehicle 
maintenance access.  
 
2. Consideration which provides a public benefit to the City is required in accordance with 
City Code Art. 5, Sec. 31-64 and Ordinance G-5332. Cost for abandoned Right-of-Way 
adjacent to property not zoned single family residential will be $500 OR Fair Market 
Value whichever is greater.  Cost for property zoned single family residential is $1.00 a 
square foot for the first 500 square feet, $0.10 a square foot thereafter: OR Fair Market 
Value at the option of the Planning and Development Director or designee. The applicant 
shall submit calculation and fee to Planning and Development Department. The 
applicant shall request a selection of approved appraisers from the current list 
maintained by the Real Estate division of the Finance Department. 
 
3. No right-of-way within 30-feet of the 37th Street monument line may be abandoned.  
 
4. No right-of-way within 25-feet of the 38th Street monument line may be abandoned.  
 
5. All stipulations must be completed within two years from the Abandonment Hearing 
Officer’s decision.  
 
 
This conditional approval has been reviewed and approved by the Abandonment Hearing Officer. 
 
 
 
Hearing Officer Signature: ____________________________________    Date: __________ 
 
 
REPORT SUBMITTED BY: Paulina Hernandez, Abandonment Secretary 
 
cc: 
Applicant/Representative, Meredith Esner 
Christopher DePerro, Abandonment Hearing Officer 
1/30/23