Attachment G - Support of VPC Rec - Z-60-20-8

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
Brent Bialik <brent@gowindspear.net>
Sent:
Monday, April 26, 2021 2:56 PM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina
Cc:
Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC 
Recommendation
Planning Commission Members, 
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the 
Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high 
density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO 
case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, 
the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input 
throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of 
the April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of 
density and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 
46 lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community, as opposed to the high density plan the applicant 
presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that 
result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community 
with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
V/R 
Brent 
Attachment G

1
Racelle Escolar
From:
rmp5s <rmp5s1@gmail.com>
Sent:
Monday, April 26, 2021 2:57 PM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina
Cc:
Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC Recommendation
Planning Commission Members, 
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the 
Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high 
density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO 
case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, 
the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input 
throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of 
the April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of 
density and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 
46 lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community, as opposed to the high density plan the applicant 
presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that 
result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community 
with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
‐‐Brent

1
Racelle Escolar
From:
Donis Canisales <cyrannn@hotmail.com>
Sent:
Monday, April 26, 2021 3:18 PM
To:
Racelle Escolar
Subject:
Case pud z-60-20-8
 
Subject:  Case PUD Z‐60‐20‐8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC Recommendation 
  
Planning Commission Members, 
  
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the 
Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high 
density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO 
case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, 
the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input 
throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
  
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of 
the April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of 
density and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 
46 lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community, as opposed to the high density plan the applicant 
presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that 
result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community 
with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
  
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Best regards, 
  
Donis and Frank Canisales, Jr 
11020 S 35th Ave  
Laveen, Az. 85339 
 
Esperanza and Frank Canisales  
11631 S 51st Ave 
Laveen, Az 85339 
 
Francisco and Becca Canisales iii  
9411 S 33rd Ave 
Laveen Az. 85339 
 
Antonio Canisales  
2305 w Tuckey lane 
Phoenix, Az. 85015 
Sent from my iPhone

1
Racelle Escolar
From:
Cyd Manning <SweetBeat@q.com>
Sent:
Monday, April 26, 2021 3:56 PM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina
Cc:
Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing - Request to Support LVPC Recommendation
Importance:
High
Good afternoon Racelle and Sofia, 
 
Please ensure my below letter is provided to all Planning Commissioners and also included in the subject case file.  I 
would also appreciate letting me know when the May 6 agenda will be posted and when the Commissioners will receive 
their packets for that meeting.  Thank you. 
 
Best regards, 
Cyd Manning 
 
**** 
Planning Commission Members, 
 
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the 
Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high 
density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO 
case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, 
the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input 
throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
 
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of the 
April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of density 
and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 46 lots 
total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community, as opposed to the high density plan the applicant 
presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that 
result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community 
with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
 
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Best regards, 
 
Cyd Manning 
sweetbeat@q.com 
480‐747‐0769 
3220 W. Ceton Drive

1
Racelle Escolar
From:
Vializ, Lisa <Lisa.Vializ@Honeywell.com>
Sent:
Monday, April 26, 2021 4:12 PM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina
Cc:
Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC Recommendation
Importance:
High
Planning Commission Members, 
 
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the 
Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high 
density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO 
case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, 
the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input 
throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
 
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of the 
April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of both 
density and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 
46 lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community, as opposed to the high density plan the applicant 
presented), with a minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft. which results in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 
density, along with enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations.  Again..a far superior plan to 
that of the PHO Case.  Important to note is that Councilmember Garcia has supported the community with a  46‐lot, R1‐
18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
 
I have lived in Arizona since 1979, where I spent approximately the first 20 years in Glendale, then a handful of years up 
in Anthem, before a friend told me about Laveen.  I work at Honeywell by the airport and drove over after work one day 
in 2005 and couldn’t believe this hidden gem.  Close to downtown, right up against South Mountain, cotton fields and 
dairy’s, still had that wonderful rural feel with wide open spaces…beautiful!  I told my husband all about it and we came 
back out together a few days later and the rest is history.  We have lived out here ever since!   Since that time we have 
also purchased 3 acres of land to build a custom home.  Folks are drawn to Laveen for the breathing room…Laveen has a 
General Plan for a reason..let’s stick to the Plan and not get wrapped up in politics or pressure from 
investors/developers.   
 
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Best regards, 
 
Lisa Vializ 
8921 S. 53rd Dr. 
Laveen, AZ 85339 
 
AND 
 
3200 W Ceton Dr. 
Laveen, AZ 85339

1
Racelle Escolar
From:
Robert Chappell <robcii01@gmail.com>
Sent:
Monday, April 26, 2021 4:48 PM
To:
Sofia Mastikhina; Racelle Escolar
Cc:
Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC Recommendation
Planning Commission Members, 
  
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the 
Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high 
density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO 
case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, 
the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input 
throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
  
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of 
the April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of 
density and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 
46 lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community, as opposed to the high density plan the applicant 
presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that 
result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community 
with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
  
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Best regards, 
 
Robert Chappell 
4707 W Maldonado Rd, 
Laveen, AZ 85339

1
Racelle Escolar
From:
Sarah VanSchyndel <sarah.vanschyndel@gmail.com>
Sent:
Monday, April 26, 2021 5:13 PM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina; Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for 5/6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC Recommendation
Planning Commission Members, 
 
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the 
Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high 
density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO 
case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, 
the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input 
throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
 
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of the 
April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of density 
and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 46 lots 
total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community, as opposed to the high density plan the applicant 
presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that 
result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community 
with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
 
 
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
 
Best regards, 
Sarah Johns 
3913 W Carver Rd, Laveen Village, AZ 85339

1
Racelle Escolar
From:
brian hicks <handymanhicks@gmail.com>
Sent:
Tuesday, April 27, 2021 3:50 PM
To:
Sofia Mastikhina; Racelle Escolar; Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC Recommendation
Planning Commission Members, 
  
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen 
known as the Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid-last year and the outpouring of 
community opposition to high density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia 
led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and 
requested the applicant process a “down-zoning”.  Since that time, the applicant has pursued the 
subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input throughout 
the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
  
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend 
approval of the April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC 
resolved the structural issues of density and zoning, and made this a much better development than 
the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 46 lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth 
by the community, as opposed to the high density plan the applicant presented), minimum lot size of 
8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that result in 
compatible land use and is equivalent to R1-18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the 
community with a  46-lot, R1-18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of 
the LVPC recommendation. 
  
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Best regards, 
  
Brian Hicks 
4715 W Carver Rd, Laveen 85339 
  
Attachments area

1
Racelle Escolar
From:
Jonathan Clauss <jkclauss@mac.com>
Sent:
Tuesday, April 27, 2021 9:56 PM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina; CCcouncil.district.7@phoenix.gov
Subject:
 Subject:  Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC 
Recommendation
Planning Commission Members, 
 
  
 
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the Quarry.  
You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high density and 
incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO case at the 
October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, the applicant 
has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input throughout the 
PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
 
  
 
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of the 
April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of density 
and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 46 lots 
total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community, as opposed to the high density plan the applicant 
presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that 
result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community 
with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
 
  
 
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. Thank you for your time 
and attention. 
 
Sincerely, 
 
Jonathan and Kandy Clauss 
7345 W Desert Ln 
Laveen AZ  
85339

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
Jonathan Clauss <jkclauss@mac.com>
Sent:
Tuesday, April 27, 2021 9:56 PM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina; CCcouncil.district.7@phoenix.gov
Subject:
 Subject:  Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC 
Recommendation
Planning Commission Members, 
 
  
 
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as 
the Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid-last year and the outpouring of community opposition 
to high density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a 
continuance of the PHO case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a 
“down-zoning”.  Since that time, the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  
The LVPC and community provided input throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC 
meeting. 
 
  
 
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval 
of the April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural 
issues of density and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote 
approved a maximum of 46 lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community, as opposed to 
the high density plan the applicant presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture 
and landscaping standards stipulations that result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1-18 density.  
Councilmember Garcia has supported the community with a  46-lot, R1-18 plan throughout the PHO case last 
year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
 
  
 
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. Thank you 
for your time and attention. 
 
Sincerely, 
 
Jonathan and Kandy Clauss 
7345 W Desert Ln 
Laveen AZ  
85339

1
Racelle Escolar
From:
Karen Allen <karen.allen789@gmail.com>
Sent:
Tuesday, April 27, 2021 8:36 PM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina
Cc:
Council District 8 PCC; Council District 7 PCC
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC Recommendation
Planning Commission Members, 
 
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the Quarry.  
You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high density and 
incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO case at the 
October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, the applicant 
has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input throughout the 
PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
 
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of the 
April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of density 
and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 46 lots 
total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community, as opposed to the high density plan the applicant 
presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that 
result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community 
with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
 
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Best regards, 
 
  
 
Karen Allen 
 
2617 W Piedmont Rd 
Phoenix, AZ 85041

1
Racelle Escolar
From:
Brian & Karie <carvercottage2018@gmail.com>
Sent:
Tuesday, April 27, 2021 3:52 PM
To:
Sofia Mastikhina; Racelle Escolar; Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC Recommendation
Planning Commission Members, 
  
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen 
known as the Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid-last year and the outpouring of 
community opposition to high density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia 
led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and 
requested the applicant process a “down-zoning”.  Since that time, the applicant has pursued the 
subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input throughout 
the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
  
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend 
approval of the April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC 
resolved the structural issues of density and zoning, and made this a much better development than 
the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 46 lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth 
by the community, as opposed to the high density plan the applicant presented), minimum lot size of 
8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that result in 
compatible land use and is equivalent to R1-18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the 
community with a  46-lot, R1-18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of 
the LVPC recommendation. 
  
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Best regards, 
  
Karie Hicks 
4715 W Carver Rd, Laveen 85339 
Attachments

1
Racelle Escolar
From:
Patricia Saya <saya.patricia@yahoo.com>
Sent:
Tuesday, April 27, 2021 12:06 PM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina
Cc:
Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC Recommendation
Subject:  Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC Recommendation 
  
Planning Commission Members, 
  
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the 
Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid-last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high density 
and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO case at 
the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down-zoning”.  Since that time, the 
applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input 
throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
  
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of the April 
12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of density and 
zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 46 lots total 
(which conforms to the plan put forth by the community, as opposed to the high density plan the applicant 
presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that 
result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1-18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community 
with a  46-lot, R1-18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
  
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Best regards, 
  
Patricia Saya and William Orr  
 
9607 S. 35th Avenue  
Laveen AZ 85339

1
Racelle Escolar
From:
Scott Trainor <trainorscottm@gmail.com>
Sent:
Tuesday, April 27, 2021 7:54 PM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina
Cc:
Council District 8 PCC; Council District 7 PCC
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC Recommendation
Planning Commission Members, 
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the Quarry.  
You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high density and 
incompatible land use in this area. 
 
Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO case at the October 2020 City Council meeting 
and requested the applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case 
that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input throughout the PUD process and during the April 
12, 2021 LVPC meeting.  
 
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of the 
April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of density 
and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 46 lots 
total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community, as opposed to the high density plan the applicant 
presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that 
result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community 
with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
 
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Best regards, 
 
Scott Trainor 
6602 W Ellis Dr 
Laveen, AZ 85339

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
Maria Zavala <mariazavalar14@gmail.com>
Sent:
Wednesday, April 28, 2021 8:27 PM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina
Cc:
Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC 
Recommendation
Planning Commission Members, 
  
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the 
Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high 
density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO 
case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, 
the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input 
throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
  
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of 
the April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of 
density and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 
46 lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community, as opposed to the high density plan the applicant 
presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that 
result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community 
with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
  
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Best regards, 
 
Maria Zavala Roman 
4115 W Calle Poco 
Laveen, AZ, 85339

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
Bret Burchard <bretburchard3@yahoo.com>
Sent:
Wednesday, April 28, 2021 2:27 PM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina
Cc:
Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC 
Recommendation
Planning Commission Members, 
 
I'm writing in regards to the Carver Canyon case that will come before you during the May 6 Planning 
Commission Hearing. The proposed PUD is the second active zoning case for this site at the corner 
of 35th Ave and Carver Rd. You heard the PHO version of this case in the middle of last year and the 
outpouring of community opposition to high density development in this area. Now the applicant is 
repackaging their plan into a PUD proposal, I assume as a show of compromise with the community. 
But they still did not address the community's biggest concern, which is the incompatible density with 
the surrounding area.  
 
Since the continuance of the PHO case last fall at the City Council meeting, the community and LVPC 
have provided input into the PUD process to create a superior site plan. Last month, the LVPC 
approved a recommendation for a PUD proposal that includes 46 lots total with a minimum lot size of 
8700 sq. ft. This is equivalent to the R1-18 zoning that the community has offered as a compromise 
and satisfies our biggest concerns with the development of this property.  
 
I ask that you please vote to approve and recommend the LVPC version of this PUD when you hear 
the case on May 6.  
 
 
Thank you, 
 
Bret Burchard 
11244 S 35th Ave 
Laveen, AZ 85339

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
gjnorton0744@gmail.com
Sent:
Wednesday, April 28, 2021 1:15 PM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina
Cc:
Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing - Request to Support LVPC 
Recommendation
 
Planning Commission Members: 
 
 
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the 
Quarry. You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high 
density and incompatible land use in this area. Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the 
PHO case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down‐zoning”. Since 
that time, the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6. The LVPC and community 
provided input throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of 
the April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6. The LVPC resolved the structural issues of 
density and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO case. Their vote approved a maximum 
of 46 lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community, as opposed to the high density plan the 
applicant presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards 
stipulations that result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 density. Councilmember Garcia has 
supported the community with a 46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support 
of the LVPC recommendation. 
 
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Best regards, 
 
Chris and Gloria Norton 
10823 S 29th Ave 
Laveen, AZ  85339

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
Dan Braner <dan.braner@gmail.com>
Sent:
Wednesday, April 28, 2021 6:43 PM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina; Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC 
Recommendation
Planning Commission Members,  
 
   
 
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen 
known as the Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of 
community opposition to high density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia 
led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and 
requested the applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, the applicant has pursued the 
subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input throughout 
the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting.  
 
   
 
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend 
approval of the April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved 
the structural issues of density and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO 
case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 46 lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the 
community, as opposed to the high density plan the applicant presented), minimum lot size of 8700 
sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that result in 
compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the 
community with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of 
the LVPC recommendation.  
 
   
 
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
 
Best regards, 
 
Daniel J Braner 
10623 S 34th Ave 
Laveen, AZ 85339

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
E douglas <lizesd@gmail.com>
Sent:
Wednesday, April 28, 2021 4:56 PM
To:
racell.escolar@phoenix.gov; Sofia Mastikhina
Cc:
Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing - Request to Support LVPC 
Recommendation
Planning Commission Members, 
  
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the 
Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high 
density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO 
case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, 
the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input 
throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
  
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of 
the April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of 
density and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 
46 lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community, as opposed to the high density plan the applicant 
presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that 
result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community 
with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
  
My neighborhood has been allowed to be overdeveloped.  Fifty‐first Avenue is going to have more traffic than it can 
handle. Again.  Please save some part of what used to be rural Laveen.  Please stand with the LVPC and community and 
support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Best regards, 
 
Elizabeth Douglas 
4726 W. Olney Avenue 
Laveen, AZ 85339

1
Racelle Escolar
From:
Jen Leitch <4jenleitch@gmail.com>
Sent:
Wednesday, April 28, 2021 9:13 PM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina; Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC Recommendation
Hello and Good Day, 
  
I am writing about the above PUD which is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen 
known as the Quarry.   
  
Finally, I am pleased to say I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission 
recommend approval of the April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.   
 
As we've said from the beginning, we understand that this site will be developed and we are looking for a project that 
"fits" in our area.  The LVPC has recognized that this site needs less density and made this a much better development 
than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 46 lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the 
community, as opposed to the high density plan the applicant presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced 
building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 
density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last 
year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
 
  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high density and 
incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO case at the 
October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, the applicant 
has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input throughout the 
PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting.  We are so pleased that the LVPC has recognized the 
importance and value of our contributions. 
  
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Best regards, 
Jen Leitch 
10109 S. 29th Dr.

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
John Bzdel <bzdel@earthlink.net>
Sent:
Wednesday, April 28, 2021 5:10 PM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina; Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing - Request to Support LVPC 
Recommendation
Planning Commission Members, 
 
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the 
Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high 
density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO 
case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, 
the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input 
throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
 
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of the 
April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of density 
and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 46 lots 
total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community, as opposed to the high density plan the applicant 
presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that 
result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community 
with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
 
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
You had the opportunity earlier to address this case as PHO‐1‐19‐Z‐165‐7/8 and should have reverted the case back to 
R1 zoning per your County Documentation for that case, however, this wasn’t done.  Now is your 2nd opportunity to act! 
 
Best regards, 
 
John Bzdel  
12120 S. 39th Ave 
Laveen, AZ 85339

1
Racelle Escolar
From:
Margaret Shalley <margaretshalley92@gmail.com>
Sent:
Wednesday, April 28, 2021 3:20 PM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina
Cc:
council.district.7@phoenix.goc; Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC Recommendation
Planning Commission Members, 
 
I am a resident in Laveen since 2005 and also have family members with roots here.  As 
such, I wanted to share input regarding the above‐referenced case. 
 
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the 
Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high 
density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO 
case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, 
the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input 
throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
 
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of the 
April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of density 
and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 46 lots 
total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community, as opposed to the high density plan the applicant 
presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that 
result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community 
with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
 
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Sincerely, 
 
Margaret Shalley  
6830 W St. Catherine Avenue  
Laveen, AZ

1
Racelle Escolar
From:
Maria Zavala <mariazavalar14@gmail.com>
Sent:
Wednesday, April 28, 2021 8:27 PM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina
Cc:
Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC Recommendation
Planning Commission Members, 
  
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the 
Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high 
density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO 
case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, 
the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input 
throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
  
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of 
the April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of 
density and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 
46 lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community, as opposed to the high density plan the applicant 
presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that 
result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community 
with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
  
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Best regards, 
 
Maria Zavala Roman 
4115 W Calle Poco 
Laveen, AZ, 85339

1
Racelle Escolar
From:
Nicole Glasgow <blue_eyes821@aol.com>
Sent:
Wednesday, April 28, 2021 3:47 PM
To:
Sofia Mastikhina; Council District 8 PCC; Racelle Escolar
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC Recommendation
Planning Commission Members, 
  
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the 
Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high 
density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO 
case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, 
the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input 
throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
  
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of 
the April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of 
density and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 
46 lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community, as opposed to the high density plan the applicant 
presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that 
result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community 
with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
  
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Best regards, 
Nicole Glasgow  
3717 west Carver rd  
Laveen, AZ 85339

1
Racelle Escolar
From:
Steven Dougherty <steven@stevendougherty.com>
Sent:
Wednesday, April 28, 2021 1:17 PM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina
Cc:
Steven Dougherty; Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC Recommendation
Planning Commission Members, 
  
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the 
Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high 
density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO 
case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, 
the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input 
throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
  
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of 
the April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of 
density and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 
46 lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community, as opposed to the high density plan the applicant 
presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that 
result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community 
with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
  
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Sincerely,  
Steven Dougherty 
Steven@StevenDougherty.com 
480‐430‐6130 Cell 
11222 S 39th LN 
Laveen AZ 85339 
 
 
CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE ‐ This e‐mail transmission and any documents, files or previous e‐mail messages attached to 
it may contain information that is confidential or legally privileged.  If you are not the intended recipient, or a 
person responsible for delivering it to the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that you must not read or play 
this transmission and that any disclosure, copying, printing, distribution or use of any of the information contained in 
or attached to this transmission is STRICTLY PROHIBITED.  If you have received this transmission in error, 
please immediately notify the sender by telephone or return e‐mail and delete the original transmission and its 
attachments without reading, forwarding, saving or re‐distributing in any manner.  The use or any action or reliance 
on the communication is strictly prohibited by the Electronic Communication Privacy Act, 18 U.S.C. 2510‐2521.

1
Racelle Escolar
From:
Nicole Glasgow <blue_eyes821@aol.com>
Sent:
Wednesday, April 28, 2021 3:49 PM
To:
Sofia Mastikhina; Racelle Escolar; Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC Recommendation
Planning Commission Members, 
  
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the 
Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high 
density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO 
case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, 
the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input 
throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
  
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of 
the April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of 
density and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 
46 lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community, as opposed to the high density plan the applicant 
presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that 
result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community 
with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
  
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Best regards, 
Thomas Glasgow  
3717 west Carver Rd  
Laveen, Az 85339

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
Eternal Sunshine <sunshine.eternal1111@gmail.com>
Sent:
Wednesday, April 28, 2021 5:26 PM
To:
Sofia Mastikhina
Subject:
Subject:  Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC 
Recommendation
 
Attention Planning Commission Members: 
  
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the 
Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high 
density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO 
case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, 
the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input 
throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
  
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of 
the April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of 
density and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 
46 lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community, as opposed to the high density plan the applicant 
presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that 
result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community 
with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
  
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Best regards, 
Tia Kaiia, resident

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
Tiah Horn <tiah4bostons@gmail.com>
Sent:
Wednesday, April 28, 2021 5:06 PM
To:
Sofia Mastikhina; Racelle Escolar
Cc:
Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC 
Recommendation
 
Planning Commission Members, 
  
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the Quarry.  You 
heard the PHO version of this case mid-last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high density and incompatible 
land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO case at the October 2020 City 
Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down-zoning”.  Since that time, the applicant has pursued the subject 
PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input throughout the PUD process and during the 
April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
  
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of the April 12 
LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of density and zoning, and 
made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 46 lots total (which conforms to 
the plan put forth by the community, as opposed to the high density plan the applicant presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. 
ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that result in compatible land use and is equivalent to 
R1-18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community with a  46-lot, R1-18 plan throughout the PHO case last 
year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
  
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Best regards, 
  
Tiah Bialik 
Laveen, AZ

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
David Baker <david@beinphoenix.com>
Sent:
Thursday, April 29, 2021 7:45 AM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina
Cc:
Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC 
Recommendation
Planning Commission Members, 
 
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the 
Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high 
density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO 
case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, 
the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input 
throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
 
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of the 
April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of density 
and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 46 lots 
total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community, as opposed to the high density plan the applicant 
presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that 
result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community 
with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
 
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Best regards, 
 
 
Best Regards 
David Baker ‐ homeowner 
11908 S 41st Ave 
Laveen Arizona 85339 
 
 
 
 
David Baker 
Keller Williams Realty Phoenix 
Cell:602.373.6345 
E‐mail: david@beinPhoenix.com  
Visit my websites at 
http://www.PhoenixLaveenHomes.com [phoenixlaveenhomes.com] 
http://www.LaveenRealEstate.co [laveenrealestate.co] 
http://www.LaveenAz85339.com [laveenaz85339.com] 
http://www.CasasLaveen.com [casaslaveen.com] 
http://www.Laveenhomesforsale.net [laveenhomesforsale.net]

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
Donna Snow <carart617@hotmail.com>
Sent:
Thursday, April 29, 2021 8:47 AM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina
Cc:
Council District 8 PCC; Donna Snow
Subject:
Subject:  Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC 
Recommendation
Planning Commission Members, 
 
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the 
Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high 
density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO 
case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, 
the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input 
throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
 
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of the 
April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of density 
and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 46 lots 
total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community, as opposed to the high density plan the applicant 
presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that 
result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community 
with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
 
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Best regards, 
 
Donna Snow       
6806 W Desert Lane 
Laveen, AZ 85339

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
Jen Leitch <4jenleitch@gmail.com>
Sent:
Wednesday, April 28, 2021 9:13 PM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina; Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC 
Recommendation
Hello and Good Day, 
  
I am writing about the above PUD which is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen 
known as the Quarry.   
  
Finally, I am pleased to say I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission 
recommend approval of the April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.   
 
As we've said from the beginning, we understand that this site will be developed and we are looking for a project that 
"fits" in our area.  The LVPC has recognized that this site needs less density and made this a much better development 
than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 46 lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the 
community, as opposed to the high density plan the applicant presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced 
building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 
density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last 
year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
 
  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high density and 
incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO case at the 
October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, the applicant 
has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input throughout the 
PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting.  We are so pleased that the LVPC has recognized the 
importance and value of our contributions. 
  
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Best regards, 
Jen Leitch 
10109 S. 29th Dr.

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
Joan Howell <joan.ferguson14@outlook.com>
Sent:
Thursday, April 29, 2021 10:52 AM
To:
Sofia Mastikhina; Racelle Escolar
Cc:
council.district8@phoenix.gov
Subject:
Support- Quarry Case PUD Z-60-20-8
 
 
  
Planning Commission Members, 
  
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known 
as the Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community 
opposition to high density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City 
Council in a continuance of the PHO case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the 
applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case 
that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input throughout the PUD process and 
during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
  
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend 
approval of the April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved 
the structural issues of density and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO 
case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 46 lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the 
community, as opposed to the high density plan the applicant presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. 
ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that result in compatible land 
use and is equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community with a  46‐
lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC 
recommendation. 
  
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Best regards, 
 Joan B Howell 
1810 Palmcroft Dr NE 
Phoenix AZ 85007

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
Judy Brown <DT_Jbrown@q.com>
Sent:
Thursday, April 29, 2021 9:45 AM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina
Cc:
Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing - Request to Support LVPC 
Recommendation
Planning Commission Members, 
 
The community is still engaged and ready to right a wrong… 
 
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the 
Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high 
density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO 
case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, 
the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input 
throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
 
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of the 
April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of density 
and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 46 lots 
total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community, as opposed to the high density plan the applicant 
presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that 
result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community 
with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
 
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Kind regards, 
 
Judy Brown 
3220 W. Ceton Drive 
Laveen, AZ 85339

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
Ken D <tadcomanaz@gmail.com>
Sent:
Thursday, April 29, 2021 6:57 AM
To:
Council District 8 PCC; Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina
Subject:
Fwd: FW: UPDATE & ACTION NEEDED - Quarry Case PUD Z-60-20-8
 
<Hangarhaciendas@gmail.com> 
 
  
 send to  racelle.escolar@phoenix.gov and sofia.mastikhina@phoenix.gov and 
CC council.district.8@phoenix.gov 
  
Subject:  Case PUD Z‐60‐20‐8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC 
Recommendation 
  
Planning Commission Members, 
  
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as 
the Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community 
opposition to high density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City 
Council in a continuance of the PHO case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the 
applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that 
you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input throughout the PUD process and during 
the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
  
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend 
approval of the April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the 
structural issues of density and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their 
vote approved a maximum of 46 lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community, as 
opposed to the high density plan the applicant presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced 
building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that result in compatible land use and is 
equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 
plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation.

2
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Best regards, 
  
Ken Diaz 
2923 W. Avion Way 
 
Laveen , Az. 85339 
  
Attachments area 
To help protect y
Micro so ft Office p
auto matic downlo
picture from the 
 
Done. 
Will do. 
Will do, thanks. 
ReplyReply allForward 
 
[drive.google.com] 
[google.com] [google.com] [google.com] 
 
‐‐  
Hangar Haciendas Homeowners Association 
Laveen, AZ 85339

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
Kristofic, Stephanie L. <Stephanie.Kristofic@va.gov>
Sent:
Thursday, April 29, 2021 9:40 AM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina; Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC 
Recommendation
Planning Commission Members, 
 
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the 
Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high 
density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO 
case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, 
the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input 
throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
 
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of the 
April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of density 
and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 46 lots 
total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community, as opposed to the high density plan the applicant 
presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that 
result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community 
with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
 
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Best regards, 
 
 
 
Stephanie Kristofic RN, BSN, CDCES, CPT 
10826 S 30th Ave 
Laveen, Az 85339

1
Racelle Escolar
From:
Robert Minard <rvminard@hotmail.com>
Sent:
Thursday, April 29, 2021 3:31 PM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina; Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC Recommendation
Planning Commission Members, 
  
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen 
known as the Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid-last year and the outpouring of 
community opposition to high density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia 
led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and 
requested the applicant process a “down-zoning”.  Since that time, the applicant has pursued the 
subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input throughout 
the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
  
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend 
approval of the April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved 
the structural issues of density and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO 
case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 46 lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the 
community, as opposed to the high density plan the applicant presented), minimum lot size of 8700 
sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that result in 
compatible land use and is equivalent to R1-18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the 
community with a 46-lot, R1-18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of 
the LVPC recommendation. 
  
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Best regards, 
 
Vicki Minard 
3107 W. Avion Way 
Laveen, AZ  85339

1
Subject:
FW: Case PUD-Z-60-20-8
From: Millie Strauss <milliestrauss@gmail.com>  
Sent: Thursday, April 29, 2021 10:54 AM 
To: Sofia Mastikhina <sofia.mastikhina@phoenix.gov> 
Subject: Case PUD‐Z‐60‐20‐8 
Subject:  Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to 
Support LVPC Recommendation 
Planning Commission Members, 
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road 
in Laveen known as the Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid-last year 
and the outpouring of community opposition to high density and incompatible land use in 
this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO case 
at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down-
zoning”.  Since that time, the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will 
hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input throughout the PUD process 
and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission 
recommend approval of the April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on 
May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of density and zoning, and made this a 
much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 46 lots 
total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community, as opposed to the high 
density plan the applicant presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building 
architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that result in compatible land use and 
is equivalent to R1-18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community with 
a  46-lot, R1-18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the 
LVPC recommendation. 
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in 
this case. 
Best regards, 
Mildred Strauss 
3007 W. Ceton Dr. 
Laveen, AZ 85339

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
Mindy Erskine <regul8r2@aol.com>
Sent:
Thursday, April 29, 2021 3:29 PM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina
Cc:
Council District 8 PCC; Council District 7 PCC
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC 
Recommendation
 
 
Planning Commission Members, 
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue 
and Carver Road in Laveen known as the Quarry. You heard the PHO 
version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community 
opposition to high density and incompatible land use in this area. 
Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO 
case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the 
applicant process a “down‐zoning”. Since that time, the applicant has 
pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6. The LVPC 
and community provided input throughout the PUD process and during 
the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the 
Planning Commission recommend approval of the April 12 LVPC 
recommendation when you hear this case on May 6. The LVPC resolved 
the structural issues of density and zoning, and made this a much better 
development than the PHO case. Their vote approved a maximum of 46 
lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community, as 
opposed to the high density plan the applicant presented), minimum lot 
size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping 
standards stipulations that result in compatible land use and is 
equivalent to R1‐18 density. Councilmember Garcia has supported the 
community with a 46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year 
and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC 
recommendation in this case. 
Best regards, 
Mindy Erskine 
12010 S 48th Dr Laveen AZ 85339 
 
Sent from my iPhone

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
Neal Haddad <neal.haddad@gmail.com>
Sent:
Thursday, April 29, 2021 9:43 AM
To:
Racelle Escolar
Cc:
Sofia Mastikhina; Council District 8 PCC; Paul Barnes
Subject:
COMMENT TO FILE: PUD Z 60 20 8
RE: PUD Z‐60‐20‐8, 5.6.21 agenda 
VIA EMAIL  
  
Members of the Planning Commission: 
 
Like many others in the Laveen community and across the city, we have taken an active interest in the subject 
case for years. As members know, Laveen is a unique area within the 519 sq. mi. that comprise the City of 
Phoenix. We believe the Laveen community's special attributes must be considered. 
 
We support the recommendations passed by the Laveen Village Planning Committee (LVPC) earlier in the 
month. As neighbors believe, the LVPC addressed and resolved the structural issues of density and zoning, 
making this a much better development than previous applications for this site.  
 
The plan that the LVPC passed: 
 
Includes a maximum of 46 lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community) 
 
Rejects the high-density plan presented by the applicant 
 
Requires minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft. 
 
Enhances building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that result in compatible land 
use 
 
Provides density in the PUD equivalent to R1-18 
Please stand with the LVPC and community: please support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Respectfully, 
 
B. Paul Barnes 
Neal Haddad 
Neighborhood Coalition of Greater Phoenix

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
Robert Minard <rvminard@hotmail.com>
Sent:
Thursday, April 29, 2021 3:33 PM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina; Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
 Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC 
Recommendation
Planning Commission Members, 
  
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen 
known as the Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid-last year and the outpouring of 
community opposition to high density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia 
led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and 
requested the applicant process a “down-zoning”.  Since that time, the applicant has pursued the 
subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input throughout 
the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
  
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend 
approval of the April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved 
the structural issues of density and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO 
case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 46 lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the 
community, as opposed to the high density plan the applicant presented), minimum lot size of 8700 
sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that result in 
compatible land use and is equivalent to R1-18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the 
community with a 46-lot, R1-18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of 
the LVPC recommendation. 
  
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Best regards, 
  
 
Robert Minard 
3107 W. Avion Way 
Laveen, AZ   85339

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
Scott Johnson <sjohnson@scottjce.com>
Sent:
Thursday, April 29, 2021 11:18 AM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina; Council District 8 PCC
Cc:
'Cyd Manning'
Subject:
Quarry Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing - Request to Support LVPC 
Recommendation
Importance:
High
Dear Planning Commission Members: 
 
In addition to the comments below I would like to add the community’s heartfelt thanks to the Laveen Village 
Planning Committee for adopting the very reasonable 46‐lot maximum proposal that we have been proposing 
for this project. 
 
As a reminder, had City staff enforced the zoning reversion stipulation from the 2007 case on this property in 
2011 as they should have, the owner would currently be entitled to 20 lots on the subject 19+ acres. 
 
The community proposed 46 lots is a 230% increase over that baseline number, while the current application 
proposes over 300% of the density they should rightfully be allowed. We feel that the community proposal 
which is reflected in the current LVPC recommendation is a very reasonable compromise as to density. 
 
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the 
Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community opposition to 
high density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a 
continuance of the PHO case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a 
“down‐zoning”.  Since that time, the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 
6.  The LVPC and community provided input throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC 
meeting. 
 
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval 
of the April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural 
issues of density and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote 
approved a maximum of 46 lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community, as opposed to 
the high density plan the applicant presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building 
architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐
18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the 
PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
 
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Thank you for your time and consideration,  
 
Scott Johnson

2
Scott Johnson 
President 
Hangar Haciendas HOA 
602‐320‐2382  
sjohnson@scottjce.com

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
Tayler Bell <taylerbell691@yahoo.com>
Sent:
Thursday, April 29, 2021 12:12 PM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina
Cc:
Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC 
Recommendation
Planning Commission Members, 
 
I'm writing in regards to the Carver Canyon case that will come before you during the May 6 Planning 
Commission Hearing. The proposed PUD is the second active zoning case for this site at the corner 
of 35th Ave and Carver Rd. You heard the PHO version of this case in the middle of last year and the 
outpouring of community opposition to high density development in this area. Now the applicant is 
repackaging their plan into a PUD proposal, I assume as a show of compromise with the community. 
But they still did not address the community's biggest concern, which is the incompatible density with 
the surrounding area.  
 
Since the continuance of the PHO case last fall at the City Council meeting, the community and LVPC 
have provided input into the PUD process to create a superior site plan. Last month, the LVPC 
approved a recommendation for a PUD proposal that includes 46 lots total with a minimum lot size of 
8700 sq. ft. This is equivalent to the R1-18 zoning that the community has offered as a compromise 
and satisfies our biggest concerns with the development of this property.  
 
I ask that you please vote to approve and recommend the LVPC version of this PUD when you hear 
the case on May 6.  
 
 
Thank you, 
 
Tayler Burchard 
11244 S 35th Ave 
Laveen, AZ 85339

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
BDM <ben.meyer3456@gmail.com>
Sent:
Friday, April 30, 2021 9:13 PM
To:
Sofia Mastikhina
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 PCH – In support LVPC's recommendation
To whom it may concern, 
In regards to PUD Z-60-20-8 (aka the applicant's way of trying to get around the similar PHO case that the 
community also doesn't agree with), I would support the LVPC recommendation of 46 lots, lower sq ft, and 
other architecture improvements.  I live very close to this location and the amount of houses that the applicant 
wants to put here is way too many.  The community doesn't want high density housing. We 
have a "country" feeling on this side of Carver Mountain and that will be taken away with the high density that 
was proposed.  Please do not approve more than 46 lots.   
Sincerely, 
Ben Meyer 
3535 W Bohl Street 
Laveen

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
peekayphx@aol.com
Sent:
Friday, April 30, 2021 7:38 AM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC 
Recommendation
Subject:  Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC 
Recommendation 
  
Planning Commission Members, 
  
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen 
known as the Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid-last year and the outpouring of 
community opposition to high density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia 
led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and 
requested the applicant process a “down-zoning”.  Since that time, the applicant has pursued the 
subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input throughout 
the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
  
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend 
approval of the April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC 
resolved the structural issues of density and zoning, and made this a much better development than 
the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 46 lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth 
by the community, as opposed to the high density plan the applicant presented), minimum lot size of 
8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that result in 
compatible land use and is equivalent to R1-18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the 
community with a  46-lot, R1-18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of 
the LVPC recommendation. 
  
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Best regards, 
  
Cynthia Pepin 
4601 W. Crivello Ave 
Laveen AZ, 85339

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
D in AZ <darcy3535@gmail.com>
Sent:
Friday, April 30, 2021 8:45 PM
To:
D M
Subject:
Quarry Case PUD Z-60-20-8 NWC comment
Planning Commission Members, 
  
On April 12th, the LVPC had recommended a max of 46 lots, min lot size of 8700 and other stipulations for the Quarry 
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 NWC.  The neighbors do not want high density for this area so I urge you to also make the 
recommendation when you hear this case on May 6th. 
 
The excessive building in Laveen is way beyond what it should be to the point that Laveen doesn't have the same charm 
anymore. Thus, I am asking you to protect us from high density in our area.   
  
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case.   
Darcy Meyer 
3535 W Bohl St, 
Laveen

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
EMAIL TEAM <garyinlaveen@yahoo.com>
Sent:
Friday, April 30, 2021 10:08 AM
To:
Sofia Mastikhina
Subject:
PUD  Z-60-20-8
Hello, 
please support the Laveen Planning Committee decision on Quarry Case PUD Z-60-20-8. 
Sincerely, 
Gary Jordan

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
Irma Cazarez <irmacazarez@gmail.com>
Sent:
Friday, April 30, 2021 11:44 AM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina
Cc:
Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC 
Recommendation
  
Planning Commission Members, 
  
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the 
Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high 
density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO 
case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, 
the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input 
throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
  
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of 
the April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of 
density and zoning and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 
46 lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community, as opposed to the high‐density plan the applicant 
presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture, and landscaping standards stipulations that 
result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community 
with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
  
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Best regards, 
  
Irma Cazarez 
3517 W Shawnee Dr.  
Laveen, AZ 85339

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
Orlando Cazarez <orlando.cazarez@gmail.com>
Sent:
Friday, April 30, 2021 12:23 PM
To:
Council District 8 PCC; Sofia Mastikhina; Racelle Escolar
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC 
Recommendation
Planning Commission Members, 
  
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the 
Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high 
density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO 
case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, 
the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input 
throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
  
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of 
the April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of 
density and zoning and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 
46 lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community, as opposed to the high‐density plan the applicant 
presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture, and landscaping standards stipulations that 
result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community 
with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
  
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Best regards, 
  
Orlando Cazarez 
3517 W Shawnee Dr.  
Laveen, AZ 85339

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
Paul Franckowiak <paul.franckowiak@outlook.com>
Sent:
Friday, April 30, 2021 8:52 AM
To:
Sofia Mastikhina
Subject:
Support for LVPC recommendations on 35th and Carver
Ms. Mastikhina‐ 
 
Regarding Case PUD Z‐60‐20‐8 for the May 6 Planning Commission Hearing:  
 
 I hope you will adopt the Laveen planning commission's recommendations in this case. 
 
We have attended a bunch of meetings and voiced opposition to high density development at 35th and Carver 
for several years now.   This is probably the tenth letter I have written on this subject to either the city council 
or the planning commission.   
 
Please don't just count our current round of letters when determining the case.  Please count the letters you 
have received about the development of this parcel in sum over the course of this dispute.  Also, please 
consider our community's hours spent at dull meetings having to object to high density development on that 
exact piece of land.  We are not paid to attend those meetings, yet we are required to attend if we want to 
oppose high density development in our area.  
 
You know the history of zoning on that parcel.  We have spent a lot of time trying to keep someone from 
taking advantage of an oversight by the city (During Mayor Gordon's time). 
 
Why even have these meetings if opposition such as ours cannot change things?  Don't think that people just 
want to be heard and then told how it is going to be.  That is being managed, not listened to.  We want you to 
listen our community and honor our time and effort by approving the recommendation of the LVPC on this 
case. 
 
You stopped a cannabis dispensary from opening in District 3 just a few weeks ago because of community 
opposition.  We are not asking for you to do the unprecedented, we are just asking you to do the right thing 
from a community perspective.   
 
Paul Franckowiak  
10019 S. 29th drive  
Laveen Az 85339

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
Dan Downs <dannyboyphx69@gmail.com>
Sent:
Saturday, May 1, 2021 11:34 AM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina; Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC 
Recommendation
Planning Commission Members, 
 
 
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the 
Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high 
density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO 
case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, 
the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input 
throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
 
 
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of the 
April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of density 
and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 46 lots 
total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community, as opposed to the high density plan the applicant 
presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that 
result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community 
with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
 
  
 
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
 
Respectfully. 
 
Daniel Downs 
10623 S 34th Ave  
Laveen, AZ  85339

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
Amy Weibel, Ph.D. <acweibel@msn.com>
Sent:
Sunday, May 2, 2021 2:49 PM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina
Cc:
Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC 
Recommendation
Planning Commission Members, 
  
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the 
Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high 
density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO 
case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, 
the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input 
throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
  
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of 
the April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of 
density and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 
46 lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community as opposed to the high density plan the applicant 
presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that 
result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community 
with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
  
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Best regards, 
 
 
 ‐‐Amy‐‐   
  
DNA*DNA*DNA*DNA  
Amy C. Weibel, Ph.D.  
Cell: (602) 373‐6344  
acweibel@msn.com  
DNA*DNA*DNA*DNA  
  
“Somewhere, something incredible is waiting to be known.”  ― Carl Sagan [goodreads.com] 
"How wonderful it is that nobody need wait a single moment before starting to improve the world." ‐ Anne 
Frank (1929‐1945) 
 
For exceptional professional real estate services - visit us at www.PhoenixLaveenHomes.com 
[phoenixlaveenhomes.com].

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
Bernadette Buehlmann <bernadettebuehlmann@gmail.com>
Sent:
Sunday, May 2, 2021 2:18 PM
To:
Sofia Mastikhina
Subject:
 Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing - Request to Support LVPC 
Recommendation
Hello 
 
Subject:  Case PUD Z‐60‐20‐8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC Recommendation 
 
Planning Commission Members, 
 
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the 
Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high 
density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO 
case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, 
the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input 
throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
 
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of the 
April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of density 
and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 46 lots 
total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community as opposed to the high density plan the applicant 
presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that 
result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community 
with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
 
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Best regards, 
 
Bernadette Buehlmann 
3026 W Ceton Dr 
Laveen, AZ 85339

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
Bryan Peltzer <bpeltzer@pgg-eng.com>
Sent:
Sunday, May 2, 2021 9:26 PM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina
Cc:
Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Subject:  Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC 
Recommendation
 
Planning Commission Members, 
 
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the 
Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high 
density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO 
case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, 
the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input 
throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
 
The applicant’s desire to have the property rezoned to a density that meets their investment objectives is wholly 
unacceptable and would be completely incompatible with the surrounding neighborhood (the area between Carver and 
South Mountains). This ordeal has drug on for several years, with the applicant biding their time in an attempt to outlast 
members of the community. With each day that passes, the need to put an end to the stalemate has come.  
 
While the LVPC recommendation falls short of what was agreed to by the City Council under s deal brokered by then 
Mayor Phil Gordon, I would begrudgingly accept their recommendation and request the Planning Commission 
recommend approval of the April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the 
structural issues of density and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote 
approved a maximum of 46 lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community as opposed to the high 
density plan the applicant presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping 
standards stipulations that result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has 
supported the community with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the 
LVPC recommendation. 
 
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Best regards, 
 
Bryan Peltzer 
3725 W. Fox Rd. 
Laveen, AZ

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
Dan Penton <dpenton85339@gmail.com>
Sent:
Sunday, May 2, 2021 2:13 PM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina
Cc:
council.district8@phoenix.gov; Council.district7@phoenix.gov
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC 
Recommendation
Attachments:
Z-60-20-8_LV.DOC
Planning Commission Members, 
 
My name is Daniel Penton , and I reside at 8216 S 42nd Ave, Laveen Village, AZ 85339. Thank you for the opportunity to submit 
my comments to the record regarding Case # Z-60-20-8 
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the Quarry.  You 
heard the PHO version of this case mid-last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high density and incompatible 
land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO case at the October 2020 City 
Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down-zoning”.  Since that time, the applicant has pursued the subject 
PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input throughout the PUD process and during the 
April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
  
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of the April 12 
LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of density and zoning, and 
made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 46 lots total (which conforms to 
the plan put forth by the community as opposed to the high density plan the applicant presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. 
ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that result in compatible land use and is equivalent to 
R1-18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community with a  46-lot, R1-18 plan throughout the PHO case last 
year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
  
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Best regards, 
DAN PENTON 
 
8216 S 42ND AVE 
Laveen, AZ 85339

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
Ol' West <davidinlaveen@gmail.com>
Sent:
Sunday, May 2, 2021 7:46 PM
To:
PDD Planning Commission; Racelle Escolar; Council District 8 PCC; Sofia Mastikhina
Subject:
Quarry Case PUD Z-60-20-8 NWC comment
I support this case as recommended by the Laveen Village Planning Committee. 
 
Planning Commission Members, 
  
On April 12th, the LVPC had recommended a max of 46 lots, min lot size of 8700 and other stipulations for the Quarry 
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 NWC.  The neighbors do not want high density for this area so I urge you to also make the 
recommendation when you hear this case on May 6th. 
 
The excessive building in Laveen is way beyond what it should be to the point that Laveen doesn't have the same charm 
anymore. Thus, I am asking you to protect us from high density in our area.   
  
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case.   
 
David Meyer 
3535 W Bohl St, 
Laveen, AZ

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
Donna Schober <donna.schober@gmail.com>
Sent:
Sunday, May 2, 2021 8:48 PM
To:
Sofia Mastikhina; Racelle Escolar; Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8
Dear Planning Commission Members, 
 
My husband and I have lived in Laveen for more than 20 years.  We are very concerned about the proposed 
development in PUD Z‐60‐20‐8.  This is the second zoning case at the NorthWest corner of 35th Avenue and 
Carver Road in Laveen known as the Quarry.  You heard the PHO development version in the middle of last 
year.  There was strong opposition from the entire community to the proposed high density and incompatible 
land use in this special area of Laveen.    
 
Council Member Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO case at the October 2020 City Council 
meeting.  He requested that the applicant process a "down‐zoning".  Since that time, the applicant has 
pursued the PUD case before you on May 6.  The Laveen Village Planning Committee (LVPC) and community 
provided input throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
 
We support the LVPC recommendation and we respectfully request that the Planning Commission recommend 
approval of the April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the 
structural issues of density and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO case 
proposed.  Their vote approved a maximum of 46 lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the 
community as opposed to the high density plan the applicant presented), minimum lot size use and is 
equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Council Member Garcia has supported the community with a 46‐lot, R1‐18 plan 
throughout the PHO cse last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation.   
 
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case.  We are all 
working toward the goal of sound, sensible  development in this area of Laveen.  Please help us with that. 
 
Sincerely, 
 
Donna J. Schober and Marvin A. Sondag 
10840 S. 30th Ave 
Laveen, AZ  85339

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
Elizabeth Banta <ebanta3938@gmail.com>
Sent:
Sunday, May 2, 2021 6:28 PM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina
Cc:
Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC 
Recommendation
Dear Planning Commission Members, 
  
I have lived for 46 years in the City of Phoenix, including 12 years in the Carver Foothills area.  The first time I drove over 
the foothills by 35th Avenue next to the quarry, I sensed the very unique nature of this community, which taps into both 
the beauty of South Mountain and the Carver Foothills, and features large lots and solitude. I realize how lucky I am to 
live in such a rare location in our Valley. Preserving these attributes not only will be good for all who live in the area 
nestled between South Mountain and Carver Foothills, but it will be good for the City of Phoenix as as whole  to retain 
variety in its neighborhoods. 
 
Case PUD Z‐60‐20‐8 is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the 
Quarry. The Planning Commission heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year.  Our community is strongly opposed 
to high density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of 
the PHO case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since 
that time, the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community 
provided input throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
  
I urge the Planning Commission to recommend approval of the April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case 
on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of density and zoning, and made this a much better development 
than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 46 lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the 
community, as opposed to the high density plan the applicant presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced 
building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 
density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last 
year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
  
I implore you to join with the LVPC and community by supporting the Laveen Village Planning Committee's 
recommendation in this case. with no higher density than 46 lots total. You may contact me at this email, or 480‐353‐
6019 for any questions you may have.  Thank you. 
 
Sincerely,

2
Elizabeth Banta 
3938 W Kayenta Trail 
Laveen, AZ 85339

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
Gina Abbott <abbogina0@gmail.com>
Sent:
Sunday, May 2, 2021 8:47 PM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina
Cc:
Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing-Request to Support LVPC 
Recommendation
 
  
Subject:  Case PUD Z‐60‐20‐8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC Recommendation 
  
Planning Commission Members, 
  
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the 
Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high 
density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO 
case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, 
the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input 
throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
  
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of the 
April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of density 
and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 46 lots 
total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community as opposed to the high density plan the applicant 
presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that 
result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community 
with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
 I personally bought land out here and then just last year just constructed a house on this property. It is a little over 1 
acre and one acre is what the limit was that someone had to have in order to build a house in this area. I love the rural 
setting and that’s why I bought out here and that’s why I wanted to build my house out here and I plan on living here 
when I retire. If we let this PUD have their way, I fear that others will follow and it will no longer be the quiet, peaceful 
place that we all love! 
  
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Best regards,

2
 
Regina Abbott 
3832 West Fox Road 
Laveen AZ 85339

1
Racelle Escolar
From:
Ines Hughes <ines.hughes@googlemail.com>
Sent:
Sunday, May 2, 2021 11:28 AM
To:
Sofia Mastikhina; Council District 8 PCC; Racelle Escolar
Subject:
Fwd: Quarry Case PUD Z-60-20-8
 
  
Dear Planning Commission Members, 
 
I am a resident of the Carver Valley area of Laveen, which is one of the few rural areas that are left in Laveen. It sits in 
the vicinity of the development item "Quarry Case PUD Z‐60‐20‐8". As neighbors in concert, we have deliberated, voiced 
our concerns, and came to consensus with the developer in this case and the Laveen Village Planning Committee (LVPC). 
I urge the Commissioners to adopt the proposed recommendations from the LVPC as they reflect the vision of both us 
neighbors and the fruits of negotiation with the current property owner and their representatives. 
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of 
the April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of 
density and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 
46 lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community, as opposed to the high density plan the applicant 
presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that 
result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community 
with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
  
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
 
Thank you. 
Best regards, 
 
Ines Hughes 
4206 W Carver Rd 
Laveen, AZ ‐ 85339  
 
‐‐  
Anything is good if it is made of chocolate. 
 
Knowledge is knowing that a tomato is a fruit; 
Wisdom is not putting it in a fruit salad. 
Philosophy is wondering if a Bloody Mary counts as a smoothy.

1
Subject:
FW: Quarry Case PUD Z-60-20-8
From: James Hughes <perldude69@gmail.com>  
Sent: Sunday, May 2, 2021 10:52 AM 
To: Sofia Mastikhina <sofia.mastikhina@phoenix.gov>; Council District 8 PCC <council.district.8@phoenix.gov> 
Cc: Ines Hughes <ines.hughes@gmail.com> 
Subject: Quarry Case PUD Z‐60‐20‐8 
Hello Planning Commission Members,  
I am a resident of the Carver Valley area of Laveen, which sits in the vicinity of the development item "Quarry Case PUD 
Z‐60‐20‐8". As neighbors in concert, we have deliberated, voiced our concerns, and came to consensus with the 
developer in this case and the Laveen Village Planning Committee (LVPC). I urge the Commissioners to adopt the 
proposed recommendations from the LVPC as they reflect the vision of both us neighbors and the fruits of negotiation 
with the current property owner and their representatives. 
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of 
the April 12 LVPC recommendation. Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation 
in this case. 
Thank you, 
James Hughes 
4206 W Carver Rd 
Laveen, AZ ‐ 85339  
‐‐  
Cooking is just the art of finding new and interesting ways to ingest more olive oil.....

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
Val Marquez <adalinered@gmail.com>
Sent:
Sunday, May 2, 2021 11:53 AM
To:
Racelle Escolar
Cc:
Sofia Mastikhina; Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC 
Recommendation
Planning Commission Members, 
  
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the 
Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high 
density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO 
case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, 
the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input 
throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
  
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of 
the April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of 
density and zoning and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 
46 lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community, as opposed to the high‐density plan the applicant 
presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture, and landscaping standards stipulations that 
result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community 
with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
  
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Best regards, 
  
Kathryn Marquez 
11424 S. 35th Ave 
Laveen, AZ 85339

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
Paul Banta <pwbantaz@gmail.com>
Sent:
Sunday, May 2, 2021 8:00 PM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina
Cc:
Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8
Dear Sirs: 
 
I live at 3938 W Kayenta Trail, Laveen Village, AZ 85339.  I would like to register my SUPPORT of the Laveen 
Planning Committee recommendation that this property development be limited to 46 homes.  There was a lot of 
information presented by the developer at this meeting, but the contentious issue is that they want to build 61 houses. 
 
This proposed development is located in a narrow valley along Carver Road.  There is no high density housing in this 
valley.  The standard for this area is no more than 1 house per acre.  There are many houses set on multiple acres. 
 
I understand that this property is zoned for high density housing.  This is the result of an action taken about 15 years ago 
by the city; against the wishes of the local community.  High density was wrong for this location then and is wrong now. 
 
There is lots of high density housing being built within a couple of miles of this property for people who want this 
lifestyle.  The ONLY rationale for allowing higher density is so that the developers can make MORE money. 
 
The local community leaders have proposed an alternate plan with 46 houses on this site.  This is higher density than any
other local property.  I think that is a pretty good compromise.  REMEMBER, this case will set a precedent for this whole 
area.  If a plan with more than 46 houses is approved there will really be no way to prevent other properties in this area 
from being rezoned for higher density. 
 
PLEASE SUPPORT a plan that limits the number of homes to 46. 
 
Paul Banta 
480 353 6014

1
Subject:
FW: Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing-Request to Support LVPC Recommendation
From: Gina Abbott <abbogina0@gmail.com>  
Sent: Sunday, May 2, 2021 8:47 PM 
To: Racelle Escolar <racelle.escolar@phoenix.gov>; Sofia Mastikhina <sofia.mastikhina@phoenix.gov> 
Cc: Council District 8 PCC <council.district.8@phoenix.gov> 
Subject: Case PUD Z‐60‐20‐8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing‐Request to Support LVPC Recommendation 
Subject:  Case PUD Z‐60‐20‐8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC Recommendation 
Planning Commission Members, 
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the 
Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high 
density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO 
case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, 
the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input 
throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of the 
April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of density 
and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 46 lots 
total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community as opposed to the high density plan the applicant 
presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that 
result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community 
with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
 I personally bought land out here and then just last year just constructed a house on this property. It is a little over 1 
acre and one acre is what the limit was that someone had to have in order to build a house in this area. I love the rural 
setting and that’s why I bought out here and that’s why I wanted to build my house out here and I plan on living here 
when I retire. If we let this PUD have their way, I fear that others will follow and it will no longer be the quiet, peaceful 
place that we all love! 
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
Best regards, 
Regina Abbott 
3832 West Fox Road 
Laveen AZ 85339

1
Subject:
FW: Subject:  Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC 
Recommendation
From: Rochelle Peltzer <rochellepeltzer@gmail.com>  
Sent: Sunday, May 2, 2021 9:37 PM 
To: Racelle Escolar <racelle.escolar@phoenix.gov>; Sofia Mastikhina <sofia.mastikhina@phoenix.gov> 
Cc: Council District 8 PCC <council.district.8@phoenix.gov> 
Subject: Re: Subject: Case PUD Z‐60‐20‐8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC 
Recommendation 
Planning Commission Members, 
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known 
as the Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community 
opposition to high density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City 
Council in a continuance of the PHO case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the 
applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case 
that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input throughout the PUD process and 
during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
The applicant’s desire to have the property rezoned to a density that meets their investment objectives 
is wholly unacceptable and would be completely incompatible with the surrounding neighborhood (the 
area between Carver and South Mountains). This ordeal has drug on for several years, with the applicant 
biding their time in an attempt to outlast members of the community. With each day that passes, the 
need to put an end to the stalemate has come.  
While the LVPC recommendation falls short of what was agreed to by the City Council under s deal 
brokered by then Mayor Phil Gordon, I would begrudgingly accept their recommendation and request 
the Planning Commission recommend approval of the April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear 
this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of density and zoning, and made this a much 
better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 46 lots total (which 
conforms to the plan put forth by the community as opposed to the high density plan the applicant 
presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards 
stipulations that result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Councilmember 
Garcia has supported the community with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and 
we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
Best regards, 
Rochelle Peltzer 
3725 W. Fox Rd. 
Laveen, AZ

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
Ruth Franklin <ruthie_franklin@yahoo.com>
Sent:
Sunday, May 2, 2021 10:28 AM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina
Cc:
Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Subject:  Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC 
Recommendation
Dear Planning Commission Members, 
  
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the 
Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid-last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high density 
and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO case at 
the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down-zoning”.  Since that time, the 
applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input 
throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
  
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of the April 
12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of density and 
zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 46 lots total 
(which conforms to the plan put forth by the community, as opposed to the high density plan the applicant 
presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that 
result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1-18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community 
with a  46-lot, R1-18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
  
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Best regards, 
Ruth Franklin 
3143 W Avion Way 
Laveen, AZ 85339

1
Racelle Escolar
From:
ruth kennedy-iwai <ruthanniwai@yahoo.com>
Sent:
Sunday, May 2, 2021 10:35 PM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina; Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8zoning".  Since that time the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear 
on for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing-Request to Support LVPC Redommendation
Planning Commission Members,  
 
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the Quarry.  You heard 
the PHO version of this case mid-last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high density and incompatible land use in 
this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO case at the October 2020 City Council  and 
requested the applicant process a "down-zoning." Since that time, the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on 
May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input throughout the PUD process and during the April 12 2021 LVPC meeting.  
 
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of the  April 12 LVPC 
recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.    The LVPC resolved the structural issues of density and zoning and made this a 
much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 46 lots total [which conforms to the plan put forth 
by the community as opposed to the high density plan the applicant presented] minimum lot size of 8700 sq.ft. enhanced building 
architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1-18 
density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community with a 46 lot, R1-18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we 
expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
. 
Please stand with the LVPC and the community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Best Regards,  
 
Ruth Kennedy-Iwai 
3412 W. Ansell Rd. 
 
P.S. 
 
I am submitting the letter composed by our much loved and respected community group, who have worked tirelessly to preserve our 
unique area from irresponsible and incompatible development.  I agree totally with both their sentiments and arguments regarding the 
Quarry case.  Since I couldn't say it any better I am sending you their words.  Again, however, I repeat that I support the LVPC 
recommendation and hope as our elected representatives you will as well.  I have lived in Laveen for over 40 years enjoying 
mountains and peaceful desert.  We have little enough left in our urban sprawl.  Keep some places to renew our souls. 
RKI

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
Amy Luley <amyluley@gmail.com>
Sent:
Monday, May 3, 2021 3:40 PM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina
Cc:
Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Subject:  Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC 
Recommendation
 
Planning Commission Members, 
  
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the 
Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high 
density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO 
case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, 
the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input 
throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
  
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of 
the April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of 
density and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 
46 lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community as opposed to the high density plan the applicant 
presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that 
result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community 
with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
  
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Best regards, 
  
Amy Luley 
4030 W Carver Road 
Laveen, AZ 85339 
 
510.508.9598 
amyluley@gmail.com

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
Chris <chris@candssweeping.com>
Sent:
Monday, May 3, 2021 1:32 PM
To:
Sofia Mastikhina
Subject:
Subject:  Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to 
Support LVPC Recommendation
Subject:  Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC Recommendation 
 
Planning Commission Members, 
 
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the 
Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid-last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high 
density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO 
case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down-zoning”.  Since that time, 
the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input 
throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
 
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of the 
April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of density 
and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 46 lots 
total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community as opposed to the high density plan the applicant 
presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that 
result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1-18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community 
with a  46-lot, R1-18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
 
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Sincerely,, 
 
Christine Danielson          
2943 W. Ceton Dr. 
Laveen, AZ 85339

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
Stilgar the Freeman <clluley@gmail.com>
Sent:
Monday, May 3, 2021 3:18 PM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina
Cc:
Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC 
Recommendation
Planning Commission Members, 
  
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the 
Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high 
density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO 
case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, 
the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input 
throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
  
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of 
the April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of 
density and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 
46 lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community as opposed to the high density plan the applicant 
presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that 
result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community 
with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
  
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Best regards, 
  
Christopher Lee Luley 
(aka Stilgar the Freeman) 
4030 West Carver Road 
Laveen, Arizona [85339] 
clluley@gmail.com

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
Darren Kristofic <dlkristofic@gmail.com>
Sent:
Monday, May 3, 2021 7:01 PM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina
Cc:
Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC 
Recommendation
Planning Commission Members, 
  
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the Quarry.  You 
heard the PHO version of this case mid-last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high density and incompatible 
land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO case at the October 2020 City 
Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down-zoning”.  Since that time, the applicant has pursued the subject 
PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input throughout the PUD process and during the 
April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
  
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of the April 12 
LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of density and zoning, and 
made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 46 lots total (which conforms to 
the plan put forth by the community as opposed to the high density plan the applicant presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. 
ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that result in compatible land use and is equivalent to 
R1-18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community with a  46-lot, R1-18 plan throughout the PHO case last 
year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
  
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Best regards, 
Darren Kristofic 
10826 S 30th Ave 
Laveen AZ 85339

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
Diane Leos <diane_leos@yahoo.com>
Sent:
Monday, May 3, 2021 11:42 AM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina
Cc:
Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Property on 35th Ave and Carver Road
As a member of the Laveen community who will be personally impacted by the proposed development on the 
property located at 35th Ave. and Carver Rd (also known as the the “Quarry” I am in support of and urge the 
acceptance of the proposal submitted by the LVPC. 
Diane Leos 
4327 W. Calle Poco 
Laveen, AZ 85339 
 
 
Sent from my iPad

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
DONNA SILBER <adjsil@msn.com>
Sent:
Monday, May 3, 2021 8:03 PM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina
Cc:
Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing - Request to Support LVPD 
Recommendation
Planning Commission Members,   
 
 
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known 
as the Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid-last year and the outpouring of community 
opposition to high density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City 
Council in a continuance of the PHO case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the 
applicant process a “down-zoning”.  Since that time, the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that 
you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input throughout the PUD process and during 
the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting.  
 I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend 
approval of the April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the 
structural issues of density and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO 
case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 46 lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the 
community as opposed to the high density plan the applicant presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., 
enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that result in compatible land use 
and is equivalent to R1-18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community with a  46-lot, 
R1-18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation.  
 Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case.  
 
Best regards,  
 Donna Silber  
11619 S. 39th Avenue   Laveen

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
2017 Camaro <lvializ@cox.net>
Sent:
Monday, May 3, 2021 9:22 AM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina
Cc:
Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC 
Recommendation
Planning Commission Members, 
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35thAvenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the 
Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high 
density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO 
case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, 
the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input 
throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of 
the April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of both 
density and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 
46 lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community, as opposed to the high density plan the applicant 
presented), with a minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft. which results in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 
density, along with enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations.  Again..a far superior plan to 
that of the PHO Case.  Important to note is that Councilmember Garcia has supported the community with a  46‐lot, R1‐
18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
My wife and I found Laveen by chance through a friend and once we saw it, we fell in love with the area.  It is close to 
downtown yet maintains a rural feel with wide open spaces.  We love it out here so much that not only do we have a 
home over on 51st and Dobbins, but we also purchased 3 acres of land to build a custom home.  Folks are drawn to 
Laveen for the breathing room…Laveen has a well thought out General Plan for a reason and thus has something for 
everyone.  ..let’s stick to the Plan and not get wrapped up in politics or pressure from investors/developers.  
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Best regards, 
Ivan Vializ 
8921 S. 53rdDr. 
Laveen, AZ 85339 
AND 
3200 W Ceton Dr. 
Laveen, AZ 85339

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
Jane Craig <eddibtyboop@hotmail.com>
Sent:
Monday, May 3, 2021 7:49 AM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina
Cc:
Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing - Request to Support LVPC April 12th 
Recommendation
Planning Commission Members, 
 
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the 
Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community opposition to 
high density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a 
continuance of the PHO case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a 
“down‐zoning”.  Since that time, the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 
6.  The LVPC and community provided input throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC 
meeting. 
 
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval 
of the April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural 
issues of density and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote 
approved a maximum of 46 lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community as opposed to 
the high density plan the applicant presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building 
architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐
18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the 
PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
 
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
We are always placed at the end of the “Agenda” and through all these years (2008‐2021) and meetings I’ve 
attended, I truly have a respect for your positions and the long days you put in as Planning Commission 
Members.  It has been a very difficult 14 months not being able to meet in person, you hear our voices but you 
truly do not “see” US—you get to deal with US through a computer; those who choose not to speak into their 
computer would probably speak in person!  Please take that into consideration as well, as I feel you should 
represent US too! 
 
Sincerely, 
 
Jane Craig 
2905 W Ceton Drive 
Laveen, AZ  85339‐1744 
 
Sent from Mail [go.microsoft.com] for Windows 10

1
Racelle Escolar
From:
Kyle Bronson <bronson.groen@me.com>
Sent:
Monday, May 3, 2021 4:19 PM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina
Cc:
Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC Recommendation
Planning Commission Members, 
 
 
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35thAvenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the 
Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high 
density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO 
case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, 
the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input 
throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
 
 
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of 
the April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of 
density and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 
46 lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community as opposed to the high density plan the applicant 
presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that 
result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community 
with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
 
 
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case.  
 
 
Thank you,  
 
 
Jason Groen 
4034 W Carver Rd  
Laveen, AZ 85339

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
Jen <2jsilber@gmail.com>
Sent:
Monday, May 3, 2021 6:10 PM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina
Cc:
Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC 
Recommendation
 
 
 
Planning Commission Members, 
  
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the 
Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high 
density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO 
case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, 
the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input 
throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
  
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of 
the April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of 
density and zoning and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 
46 lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community, as opposed to the high‐density plan the applicant 
presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture, and landscaping standards stipulations that 
result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community 
with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
  
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Best regards, 
Jennifer Silber 
3821 W. Calle Poco 
Laveen, AZ 85339 
 
Sent from my iPhone

1
Racelle Escolar
From:
JK Bronson-Groen <bronson-groen@hotmail.com>
Sent:
Monday, May 3, 2021 4:17 PM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina
Cc:
Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC Recommendation
Planning Commission Members, 
  
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35thAvenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the 
Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high 
density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO 
case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, 
the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input 
throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
  
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of 
the April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of 
density and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 
46 lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community as opposed to the high density plan the applicant 
presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that 
result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community 
with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
  
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Thank you,  
 
Kyle Bronson  
4034 W Carver Rd  
Laveen, AZ 85339

1
Racelle Escolar
From:
Linda Santellanes <aaa.sii.corp@gmail.com>
Sent:
Monday, May 3, 2021 10:59 PM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8
Subject:  Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC 
Recommendation 
  
Planning Commission Members, 
  
I support this case as recommended by the Laveen Village Planning Committee and I respectfully 
request the Planning Commission recommend approval of the April 12 LVPC recommendation when 
you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of density and zoning, and 
made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 46 lots 
total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community as opposed to the high density plan the 
applicant presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and 
landscaping standards stipulations that result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1-18 
density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community with a  46-lot, R1-18 plan throughout 
the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
  
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Linda Santellanes 
11224 South 35th Ave Laveen

Rcvd 5/3/2021 
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known 
as the Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community 
opposition to high density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City 
Council in a continuance of the PHO case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the 
applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case 
that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input throughout the PUD process and 
during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting.  
I support the LVPC recommendation, and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend 
approval of the April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved 
the structural issues of density and zoning and made this a much better development than the PHO 
case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 46 lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the 
community, as opposed to the high density plan the applicant presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. 
ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that result in compatible land 
use and is equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community with a 46‐
lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC 
recommendation.  
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Best regards,  
Lisa K. Pike 
4824 West Estrella Drive 
Laveen, Arizona 85339

1
Racelle Escolar
From:
Michael Craig <mcraig1947@hotmail.com>
Sent:
Monday, May 3, 2021 10:22 AM
To:
Racelle Escolar; sophia.mastikhina@phoenix.gov
Cc:
council.distrit.8@phoenix.gov
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing - Request to Support LVPC April 12th 
Recommendation
Planning Commission Members, 
 
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the 
Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community opposition to 
high density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a 
continuance of the PHO case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a 
“down‐zoning”.  Since that time, the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 
6.  The LVPC and community provided input throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC 
meeting. 
 
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval 
of the April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural 
issues of density and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote 
approved a maximum of 46 lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community as opposed to 
the high density plan the applicant presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building 
architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐
18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the 
PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
 
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Best regards, 
 
Michael Craig 
2905 W. Ceton Drive 
Laveen, AZ  85339‐1744 
Sent from Mail [go.microsoft.com] for Windows 10

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
nancy harris <nharris526@yahoo.com>
Sent:
Monday, May 3, 2021 9:28 AM
To:
Sofia Mastikhina
Subject:
The Quarry at 35th Ave in K=Laveen
I support the LVPC recommendations for the Quarry in Laveen and ask you to support 
them too, as the right yhing to do.  Thank you.  Nancy Harris....2910 W Ceton 
Drive...Laveen

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
Naoma Holmes <Naoma.Holmes@live.com>
Sent:
Monday, May 3, 2021 10:16 AM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina
Cc:
Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC 
Recommendation
Planning Commission Members, 
 
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the 
Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high 
density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO 
case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, 
the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input 
throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
 
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of the 
April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of density 
and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 46 lots 
total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community as opposed to the high density plan the applicant 
presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that 
result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community 
with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
 
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Best regards, 
 
Naoma Holmes 
10909 S. 29th Avenue 
Laveen, AZ 85339 
 
 
 
Sent from Mail [go.microsoft.com] for Windows 10

1
Subject:
FW: Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing - Request to Support LVPC Recommendation
From: Peter Buehlmann <peterbuehlmann2007@gmail.com>  
Sent: Monday, May 3, 2021 10:20 AM 
To: Racelle Escolar <racelle.escolar@phoenix.gov> 
Subject: Case PUD Z‐60‐20‐8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing ‐ Request to Support LVPC Recommendation 
Hello 
Subject:  Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC 
Recommendation 
Planning Commission Members, 
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as 
the Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid-last year and the outpouring of community opposition 
to high density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a 
continuance of the PHO case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a 
“down-zoning”.  Since that time, the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 
6. The LVPC and community provided input throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC
meeting.
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval 
of the April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural 
issues of density and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved 
a maximum of 46 lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community as opposed to the high 
density plan the applicant presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and 
landscaping standards stipulations that result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1-18 
density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community with a  46-lot, R1-18 plan throughout the PHO 
case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
Best regards, 
Peter Buehlmann 
3026 W Ceton Dr 
Laveen AZ 85339

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
Holmes, Randy L <randy.l.holmes@intel.com>
Sent:
Monday, May 3, 2021 7:50 AM
To:
Council District 8 PCC; Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC 
Recommendation
Planning Commission Members, 
 
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the 
Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high 
density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO 
case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, 
the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input 
throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
 
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of the 
April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of density 
and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 46 lots 
total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community as opposed to the high density plan the applicant 
presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that 
result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community 
with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
 
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Best regards, 
 
Randy Holmes 
10909 S. 29th Ave 
Laveen AZ 85339 
 
 
Randy L. Holmes 
Global Security Technologies Manager 
Intel Corporation 
(480) 715‐3490 ‐ Work 
(480) 619‐1136 – Cell

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
Randy Jen SILBER <silbercom@msn.com>
Sent:
Monday, May 3, 2021 6:01 PM
To:
Sofia Mastikhina; Racelle Escolar
Cc:
Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC 
Recommendation
Planning Commission Members, 
  
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the 
Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high 
density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO 
case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, 
the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input 
throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
  
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of 
the April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of 
density and zoning and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 
46 lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community, as opposed to the high‐density plan the applicant 
presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture, and landscaping standards stipulations that 
result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community 
with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
  
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Best regards, 
Randy Silber 
3821 W. Calle Poco 
Laveen, AZ  85339

1
Racelle Escolar
From:
Ron Opatril <ron@rockharddesigns.net>
Sent:
Monday, May 3, 2021 10:09 AM
To:
Council District 8 PCC
Cc:
Racelle Escolar
Subject:
Fwd: REMINDER: UPDATE & ACTION NEEDED -  Quarry Case PUD Z-60-20-8 
 
 
Planning Commission Members, 
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known 
as the Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community 
opposition to high density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City 
Council in a continuance of the PHO case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the 
applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case 
that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input throughout the PUD process and 
during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend 
approval of the April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved 
the structural issues of density and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO 
case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 46 lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the 
community, as opposed to the high density plan the applicant presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. 
ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that result in compatible land 
use and is equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community with a  46‐
lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC 
recommendation. 
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. Stay 
true to the original plan for Laveen, it is the reason most of us live there. 
Thank you in advance for your help! 
 
 
Best regards, 
  
Ron Opatril 
3131 West Avion Way 
  
Laveen, AZ 85339

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
scott daniels <azscott.j.daniels@gmail.com>
Sent:
Monday, May 3, 2021 9:23 PM
To:
Sofia Mastikhina; Racelle Escolar; Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8
 
Subject:  Case PUD Z‐60‐20‐8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC Recommendation 
  
Planning Commission Members, 
  
I support this case as recommended by the Laveen Village Planning Committee and I respectfully request the Planning 
Commission recommend approval of the April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC 
resolved the structural issues of density and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO 
case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 46 lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community as 
opposed to the high density plan the applicant presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building 
architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 
density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last 
year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
  
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Scott Daniels 
11224 South 35th Ave Laveen

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
Chris <chris@candssweeping.com>
Sent:
Monday, May 3, 2021 10:37 PM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina
Cc:
Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC 
Recommendation
Planning Commission Members, 
 
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the 
Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high 
density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO 
case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, 
the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input 
throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
 
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of the 
April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of density 
and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 46 lots 
total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community as opposed to the high density plan the applicant 
presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that 
result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community 
with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
 
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Best regards, 
 
Steven Danielson              
2943 W. Ceton Drive 
Laveen, AZ 85339

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
Charla Fogle <charla-f@hotmail.com>
Sent:
Tuesday, May 4, 2021 10:56 AM
To:
Sofia Mastikhina
Cc:
Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC 
Recommendation
Dear Sofia and Planning Commission Members, 
  
I'm reaching out regarding the above referenced PUD case, the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and 
Carver Road in Laveen known as the Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of 
community opposition to high density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City 
Council in a continuance of the PHO case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process 
a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, the applicant has pursued PUD Z‐60‐20‐8 that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and 
community provided input throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
  
As a resident in the area, I support the LVPC recommendation, and respectfully request the Planning Commission 
recommend approval of the April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the 
structural issues of density and zoning and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote 
approved a maximum of 46 lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community as opposed to the high 
density plan the applicant presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping 
standards stipulations that result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has 
supported the community with a 46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the 
LVPC recommendation. 
  
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Best regards, 
Charla Fogle 
3303 W McNeil Street 
Laveen, AZ  85339

1
Racelle Escolar
From:
Heather Lott <hlott1@gmail.com>
Sent:
Tuesday, May 4, 2021 2:07 PM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina
Cc:
Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC Recommendation
 
Planning Commission Members, 
  
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the 
Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high 
density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO 
case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, 
the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input 
throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
  
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of 
the April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of 
density and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 
46 lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community as opposed to the high density plan the applicant 
presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that 
result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community 
with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
  
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Best regards, 
  
Heather Lott 
11610 S. 43rd Ave 
Laveen, AZ  85339 
...

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
Jo Ann Valenta <jovalenta@gmail.com>
Sent:
Tuesday, May 4, 2021 7:39 AM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina; Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC 
Recommendation
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the 
Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high 
density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO 
case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, 
the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input 
throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
  
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of 
the April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of 
density and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 
46 lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community as opposed to the high density plan the applicant 
presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that 
result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community 
with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
  
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Best regards, 
  
JoAnn Valenta 
3224 W Carver Rd 
Laveen, AZ 85339

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
Kitty A <thesanctuarysouthmountain@gmail.com>
Sent:
Tuesday, May 4, 2021 8:17 AM
To:
Sofia Mastikhina
Subject:
Fwd: Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC 
Recommendation
Follow Up Flag:
Follow up
Flag Status:
Flagged
 
Sent from my iPad 
 
Begin forwarded message: 
From: Kitty A <thesanctuarysouthmountain@gmail.com> 
Date: May 4, 2021 at 8:13:26 AM MST 
To: racelle.escolar@phoenix.gov, sofia.mastikhina@phonix.gov, council.district.8@phoenix.gov 
Subject: Case PUD Z‐60‐20‐8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC 
Recommendation 
 
Sent from my iPad 
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road 
in Laveen known as the Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year 
and the outpouring of community opposition to high density and incompatible land use 
in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO 
case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a 
“down‐zoning”.  Since that time, the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that 
you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input throughout the PUD 
process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
  
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission 
recommend approval of the April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on 
May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of density and zoning, and made this a 
much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 46 
lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community as opposed to the 
high density plan the applicant presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced 
building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that result in compatible 
land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the 
community with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect 
his support of the LVPC recommendation.

2
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in 
this case. 
 
Best regards, 
  
Kitty Adlington 
3224 W Carver Rd 
Laveen, AZ 85339

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
Mark Fogle <mrfxd45@gmail.com>
Sent:
Tuesday, May 4, 2021 11:21 AM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina
Cc:
Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC 
Recommendation
Planning Commission Members, 
  
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the 
Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high 
density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO 
case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, 
the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input 
throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
  
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of 
the April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of 
density and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 
46 lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community, as opposed to the high density plan the applicant 
presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that 
result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community 
with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
  
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Best regards, 
 
Mark R Fogle  
3303 W McNeil St 
Laveen, AZ 85339

1
Racelle Escolar
From:
Heather Lott <hlott1@gmail.com>
Sent:
Tuesday, May 4, 2021 2:09 PM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina
Cc:
Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC Recommendation
Planning Commission Members, 
  
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the 
Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high 
density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO 
case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, 
the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input 
throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
  
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of 
the April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of 
density and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 
46 lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community as opposed to the high density plan the applicant 
presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that 
result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community 
with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
  
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Best regards, 
  
Michael Lott 
11610 S. 43rd Ave 
Laveen, AZ  85339

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
Steven Dougherty <steven@stevendougherty.com>
Sent:
Tuesday, May 4, 2021 12:17 AM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina
Cc:
Steven Dougherty; Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC 
Recommendation
Planning Commission Members, 
  
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the 
Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high 
density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO 
case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, 
the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input 
throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
  
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of 
the April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of 
density and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 
46 lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community as opposed to the high density plan the applicant 
presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that 
result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community 
with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
  
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Sincerely, 
Steven Dougherty 
Steven@StevenDougherty.com 
11222 S 39th Ln 
Laveen AZ 85339 
 
 
CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE ‐ This e‐mail transmission and any documents, files or previous e‐mail messages attached to 
it may contain information that is confidential or legally privileged.  If you are not the intended recipient, or a 
person responsible for delivering it to the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that you must not read or play 
this transmission and that any disclosure, copying, printing, distribution or use of any of the information contained in 
or attached to this transmission is STRICTLY PROHIBITED.  If you have received this transmission in error, 
please immediately notify the sender by telephone or return e‐mail and delete the original transmission and its 
attachments without reading, forwarding, saving or re‐distributing in any manner.  The use or any action or reliance 
on the communication is strictly prohibited by the Electronic Communication Privacy Act, 18 U.S.C. 2510‐2521.

1
Sofia Mastikhina
From:
C Gunderson <carrsgun@gmail.com>
Sent:
Wednesday, May 5, 2021 1:22 PM
To:
recelle.escolar@phoenix.gov; Sofia Mastikhina; Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC 
Recommendation
Planning Commission Members, 
  
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the 
Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high 
density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO 
case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, 
the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input 
throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
  
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of 
the April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of 
density and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 
46 lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community as opposed to the high density plan the applicant 
presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that 
result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community 
with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
  
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Best regards, 
 
Carolyn Gunderson 
3514 W Cheyenne Dr. 
Laveen, AZ 85339

1
Racelle Escolar
From:
Bernadette Buehlmann <bernadettebuehlmann@gmail.com>
Sent:
Wednesday, May 5, 2021 1:45 PM
To:
Sofia Mastikhina; Racelle Escolar; Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing - Request to Support LVPC Recommendation
Subject:  Case PUD Z‐60‐20‐8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC Recommendation 
 
Planning Commission Members, 
 
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the 
Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high 
density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO 
case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, 
the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input 
throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
 
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of the 
April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of density 
and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 46 lots 
total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community as opposed to the high density plan the applicant 
presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that 
result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community 
with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
 
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Best regards, 
 
Roxanne Screptock 
3108 W. Ceton Drive 
Laveen, AZ 85339 
Roxanne was unable to submit this on her own and gave me permission to do it for her.  
(Bernadette Buehlmann)

1
Racelle Escolar
From:
Bernadette Buehlmann <bernadettebuehlmann@gmail.com>
Sent:
Wednesday, May 5, 2021 1:49 PM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina; Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
 Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing - Request to Support LVPC Recommendation
 
Subject:  Case PUD Z‐60‐20‐8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC Recommendation 
 
Planning Commission Members, 
 
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the 
Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high 
density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO 
case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, 
the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input 
throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
 
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of the 
April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of density 
and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 46 lots 
total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community as opposed to the high density plan the applicant 
presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that 
result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community 
with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
 
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Best regards, 
 
Joe Sturt 
3108 W. Ceton Drive 
Laveen, AZ 85339 
Joe was unable to submit this on his own and gave me permission to do it for him.  
(Bernadette Buehlmann)

1
Racelle Escolar
From:
D in AZ <darcy3535@gmail.com>
Sent:
Sunday, May 2, 2021 7:23 PM
To:
PDD Planning Commission
Subject:
Quarry Case PUD Z-60-20-8 NWC comment/Item #16
Item #16 On April 12th, Quarry Case PUD Z-60-20-8 NWC:  
 
Planning Commission Members, 
 
I am in opposition of the applicant's 61+ high density plan to put in our community.   The excessive building in Laveen is 
way beyond what it should be to the point that Laveen doesn't have the same charm anymore. Thus, I am urging you to 
protect us from this high density in our area.  It means the world to the residents that live north and south of Carver Rd 
to keep the rural and peaceful setting that we currently have.   
 
On April 12th, the LVPC had recommended a max of 46 lots, min lot size of 8700 and other stipulations for the Quarry 
case.  If this is brought up as fact, I would ask that you stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC 
recommendation in this case.   
 
Otherwise, if this is not taken into consideration, this PUD case needs to be denied. 
Respectfully, 
 
Darcy Meyer 
3535 W Bohl St, 
Laveen

1
Racelle Escolar
From:
Margaret Anderson <mhanderson007@gmail.com>
Sent:
Thursday, May 6, 2021 9:30 AM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina
Cc:
Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Subject:  Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC 
Recommendation  
Planning Commission Members, 
  
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the 
Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high 
density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO 
case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, 
the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input 
throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
  
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of 
the April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of 
density and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 
46 lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community as opposed to the high density plan the applicant 
presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that 
result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community 
with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
  
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Best regards, 
 
Margarete Anderson 
2010 W Olney Ave 
Phoenix AZ 85041

1
Racelle Escolar
From:
Margarete Anderson <mha406@comcast.net>
Sent:
Thursday, May 6, 2021 9:32 AM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina
Cc:
Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Subject:  Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC 
Recommendation  
Planning Commission Members, 
  
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the 
Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high 
density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO 
case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, 
the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input 
throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
  
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of 
the April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of 
density and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 
46 lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community as opposed to the high density plan the applicant 
presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that 
result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community 
with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
  
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Best regards, 
 
Tiffany Beyer 
2010 W Olney Ave 
Phoenix AZ 85041

1
Racelle Escolar
From:
Margarete Anderson <mha406@comcast.net>
Sent:
Thursday, May 6, 2021 9:33 AM
To:
Sofia Mastikhina; Racelle Escolar
Cc:
Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Fwd: Subject:  Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC 
Recommendation  
Planning Commission Members, 
  
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the 
Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high 
density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO 
case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, 
the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input 
throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
  
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of 
the April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of 
density and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 
46 lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community as opposed to the high density plan the applicant 
presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that 
result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community 
with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
  
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Best regards, 
 
Vanessa Anderson 
2010 W Olney Ave 
Phoenix AZ 85041

1
Racelle Escolar
From:
Margarete Anderson <mha406@comcast.net>
Sent:
Thursday, May 6, 2021 9:34 AM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina
Cc:
Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Subject:  Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing – Request to Support LVPC 
Recommendation  
Planning Commission Members, 
  
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the 
Quarry.  You heard the PHO version of this case mid‐last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high 
density and incompatible land use in this area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO 
case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and requested the applicant process a “down‐zoning”.  Since that time, 
the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input 
throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
  
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of 
the April 12 LVPC recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of 
density and zoning, and made this a much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 
46 lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth by the community as opposed to the high density plan the applicant 
presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that 
result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1‐18 density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community 
with a  46‐lot, R1‐18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
  
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Best regards, 
 
Joe Anderson 
2010 W Olney Ave 
Phoenix AZ 85041

1
Racelle Escolar
From:
sbarbara74@aol.com
Sent:
Thursday, May 6, 2021 1:12 PM
To:
Racelle Escolar; Sofia Mastikhina
Cc:
Council District 8 PCC
Subject:
Case PUD Z-60-20-8 for May 6 Planning Commission Hearing - Request to Support LVPC April 12th 
Recommendation
Planning Commission Members, 
  
The subject PUD is the second zoning case at the NWC of 35th Avenue and Carver Road in Laveen known as the Quarry.  You heard 
the PHO version of this case mid-last year and the outpouring of community opposition to high density and incompatible land use in this 
area.  Councilmember Garcia led the City Council in a continuance of the PHO case at the October 2020 City Council meeting and 
requested the applicant process a “down-zoning”.  Since that time, the applicant has pursued the subject PUD case that you will hear 
on May 6.  The LVPC and community provided input throughout the PUD process and during the April 12, 2021 LVPC meeting. 
  
I support the LVPC recommendation and I respectfully request the Planning Commission recommend approval of the April 12 LVPC 
recommendation when you hear this case on May 6.  The LVPC resolved the structural issues of density and zoning, and made this a 
much better development than the PHO case.  Their vote approved a maximum of 46 lots total (which conforms to the plan put forth by 
the community as opposed to the high density plan the applicant presented), minimum lot size of 8700 sq. ft., enhanced building 
architecture and landscaping standards stipulations that result in compatible land use and is equivalent to R1-18 
density.  Councilmember Garcia has supported the community with a  46-lot, R1-18 plan throughout the PHO case last year and we 
expect his support of the LVPC recommendation. 
  
Please stand with the LVPC and community and support the LVPC recommendation in this case. 
 
Best regards, 
  
Barbara J. Sherman 
1731 W. Steinway Drive 
Phoenix, AZ 85041