Appellant Appendix_C_West_Second_Street_Property_List
Extracted text (via pymupdf)
6279 characters
APPENDIX C West Second Street Historic District, Contributing and Non-Contributing Property List, City of Mesa Historic Preservation, updated November 7, 2024 Property 260 N. Center Street, Mesa, Arizona 85201 (APN 138-59-045) Appellant Alicia Rodriguez, owner Appeal of Denial of Certificate of Appropriateness, Case ADM26-00657, dated August 10, 2026 Related permit PMT26-01976 Prior approval Certificate of Appropriateness, Case ADM25-00154, issued June 11, 2025 Hearing Historic Preservation Board, Tuesday, September 1, 2026, 5:00 p.m., Mesa City Hall, 20 E. Main Street Document reproduced The City of Mesa Historic Preservation Office's official contributing and non-contributing property list for the West Second Street Historic District, as updated November 7, 2024. Why this document is offered 1. The City classifies numerous contributing properties in this district in styles defined by the arch. The list includes, among others, 148 N. Macdonald (ID 191, 1906, Mission Revival); 136 W. 2nd Street (ID 153, 1940 to 1946, Spanish Eclectic); 215 N. Robson Street (ID 150, 1932, Spanish Eclectic); 204 N. Macdonald (ID 156, 1931, Spanish Eclectic); 128 N. Macdonald (ID 190, 1915, Spanish Revival); and 46 W. 2nd Street (ID 165, 1928, Pueblo Revival). A rounded opening is not a conjectural feature in a district the City itself catalogs this way. 2. The list confirms the status and classification of both properties. 260 N. Center Street appears as ID 177, construction date c. 1946, classified Ranch. 250 N. Center Street appears as ID 178, construction date c. 1945, classified National Folk. Both are on the contributing list. The appellant notes that Attachment 1 of the Certificate of Appropriateness gives the construction date of 260 N. Center Street as 1945, while this list gives c. 1946. 3. The list does not support treating the Ranch style as rare in this district. Attachment 1 of the Certificate of Appropriateness describes "the few Ranch-style homes on the edges of the district," but this list classifies more than a dozen contributing properties as Ranch, Ranch Apartments, or Transitional Ranch, including 143 W. Third Place, 257 N. Drew Street, 259 N. Drew Street, 220 N. Center Street, 237 N. Drew Street, 227 N. Drew Street, 207 N. Drew Street, 215 N. Drew Street, 119 to 121 W. 2nd Street, 139 W. Third Place, 12 W. Third Place, 120 W. 2nd Street, 217 N. Drew Street, and 112 W. Third Place. City of Mesa – Historic Preservation 55 N. Center St. Mesa, AZ 85201 480-644-4273 | Website Updated: 11/07/2024 West Second Street Historic District Contributing & Non-Contributing Property List Page | 1 City of Mesa – Historic Preservation 55 N. Center St. Mesa, AZ 85201 480-644-4273 National Register ID Address Construction Date Architectural Style 102 156 W THIRD PL 1928 MINIMAL TRADITIONAL 103 150 W THIRD PL C. 1935 TUDOR REVIVAL 105 136 W THIRD PL 1937 MODERNE 106 130 W THIRD PL C. 1935 MINIMAL TRADITIONAL 108 300 N MACDONALD C. 1945 MINIMAL TRADITIONAL 109 119 W THIRD PL 1919-1920 BUNGALOW 110 145 W THIRD PL 1922 BUNGALOW 148 265 N ROBSON ST 1922 BUNGALOW 149 253 N ROBSON ST 1932-1937 MINIMAL TRADITIONAL 150 215 N ROBSON ST 1932 SPANISH ECLECTIC 151 146 W 2ND ST 1910-1915 BUNGALOW 152 142 W 2ND ST 1908-1910 BUNGALOW 153 136 W 2ND ST 1940-1946 SPANISH ECLECTIC 154 130 W 2ND ST 1930 PERIOD REVIVAL / BUNGALOW 156 204 N MACDONALD 1931 SPANISH ECLECTIC 157 208 N MACDONALD 1929-1930 TUDOR REVIVAL 158 216 N MACDONALD 1935-1940 TUDOR REVIVAL 159 228 N MACDONALD 1914 BUNGALOW 160 254 N MACDONALD 1937 POST REVIVAL 161 264 N MACDONALD 1939 MINIMAL TRADITIONAL 162 221 N MACDONALD 1933-1939 BUNGALOW 163 207 N MACDONALD 1928 TUDOR REVIVAL 164 203 N MACDONALD 1926 BUNGALOW 165 46 W 2ND ST 1928 PUEBLO REVIVAL 171 143 W THIRD PL C. 1940 RANCH Page | 2 City of Mesa – Historic Preservation 55 N. Center St. Mesa, AZ 85201 480-644-4273 172 257 N DREW ST C. 1945 RANCH 174 12 W THIRD PL 1951 RANCH 176 259 N DREW ST C. 1945 RANCH 177 260 N CENTER ST C. 1946 RANCH 178 250 N CENTER ST C. 1945 NATIONAL FOLK 179 240 N CENTER ST C. 1945 RANCH APARTMENTS 180 389 N CENTER ST C. 1945 RANCH APARTMENTS 181 140 N CENTER ST 1919 BUNGALOW 182 148 N CENTER ST 1919 BUNGALOW 183 160 N CENTER ST 1896 QUEEN ANNE COTTAGE 184 53 W 2ND ST C. 1946 MINIMAL TRADITIONAL 185 159 N MACDONALD 1884 (1937) TUDOR REVIVAL 187 236 N CENTER ST C. 1945 RANCH APARTMENTS 189 122 N MACDONALD 1905 QUEEN ANNE COTTAGE 190 128 N MACDONALD 1915 SPANISH REVIVAL 191 148 N MACDONALD 1906 MISSION REVIVAL 192 156 N MACDONALD 1908-11 QUEEN ANNE COTTAGE 193 162 N MACDONALD 1906-08 BUNGALOW 194 115 W 2ND ST C. 1918 BUNGALOW 195 123 W 2ND ST 1929 TUDOR REVIVAL 196 135 W 2ND ST 1908-1910 BUNGALOW 198 165 W 2ND ST 198-1923 BUNGALOW 199 137 N ROBSON ST 1927 BUNGALOW 203 130 W 1ST ST 1927 TUDOR REVIVAL 204 124 W 1ST ST 1900-1908 QUEEN ANNE 209 220 N CENTER ST C. 1945 RANCH 214 237 N DREW ST C. 1945 RANCH Page | 3 City of Mesa – Historic Preservation 55 N. Center St. Mesa, AZ 85201 480-644-4273 223 135 W UNIVERSITY DR 1937 MINIMAL TRADITIONAL 224 131 W UNIVERSITY DR 1937 MINIMAL TRADITIONAL 225 127 W UNIVERSITY DR 1937 TUDOR REVIVAL 226 121 W UNIVERSITY DR 1937 TUDOR REVIVAL 227 304 N MACDONALD 1937 TUDOR REVIVAL 242 227 N DREW ST 1940 RANCH 601 120 W 2ND ST 1947 TRANSITIONAL RANCH 605 207 N DREW ST 1947 RANCH 606 215 N DREW ST C. 1948 RANCH 607 217 N DREW ST 1947 TRANSITIONAL RANCH 609 119-121 W 2ND ST 1946 RANCH 610 144 W 3RD PL C. 1937 MINIMAL TRADITIONAL 611 126 W 3RD PL C. 1937 MINIMAL TRADITIONAL 612 112 W 3RD PL C. 1940 TRANSITIONAL RANCH 613 139 W 3RD PL C. 1945 RANCH Non-Contributing Properties 163 W 2ND ST 155 W 2ND ST 152 W 2ND ST 131 W 2ND ST 50 W 2ND ST 26 W 2ND ST 16/18 W 2ND ST 231 N ROBSON ST 248 N MACDONALD 141 N MACDONALD * 155 N MACDONALD * 161 W UNIVERSITY DR 151 W UNIVERSITY DR 164 W THIRD PL 214 N DREW ST 220 N DREW ST 245 N DREW ST 264 N CENTER ST 216 N CENTER ST 210 N CENTER ST * Not within Local District