Extracted text (via pymupdf)
12462 characters
Board of Supervisors' Agenda
2020: TX2019-001378 (El Fenix LLC) Represented by Mooney, Wright, Moore & Wilhoit
PLLC;
2021: TX2020-001133 (Madison Gardens/Phoenix LP) Represented by Dickinson Wright
PLLC; TX2020-001059 (IP BPG City Square LLC) Represented by Frazer, Ryan, Goldberg &
Arnold LLP;
2021/2022/2023: TX2020-001100 (Macys West Stores Inc.) Represented by Mooney,
Wright, Moore & Wilhoit PLLC;
2022: TX2021-000534 (Northern Gardens II/Phoenix LP) Represented by Dickinson Wright
PLLC; TX2021-000538 (Madison Gardens/Phoenix LP) Represented by Dickinson Wright
PLLC;
2022/2023: TX2021-000489 (Tatum & Dynamite Self Storage Partners LLC) Represented by
Frazer, Ryan, Goldberg & Arnold LLP;
2023: TX2022-000347 (3131 Camelback Road LLC) Represented by The Cavanagh Law Firm;
2020
Date:
06/20/2023
2 Parcels
Prepared by:
Parcel #s:
See Attached
Plaintiff:
LAND
IMPS
FCV
RATIO
CURRENT
10,277,400
321,500
10,598,900
See Parcel
RECOMMENDED:
5,520,000
320,000
5,840,000
TASRs
Hoover/Procaccini
Tax Case: TX2019-001378
Tax Year: 2020
EL FENIX LLC
*** C O V E R S H E E T ***
_____________________________________________________________
TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION
Maricopa County
301 West Jefferson
Phoenix, AZ 85003
County Atty: MUTHIG KLAUS PETER
Current:
Parcel
Class
PUC
LPV
Class
13222034
2.R @15.0%
N/C
N/C
13222035
1.12 @18.0%
N/C
N/C
5,520,000
320,000
5,840,000
10,277,400
321,500
10,598,900
6,589,853
4,340,000
0
4,340,000
B1
3710
3,106,500
321,500
3,428,000
2,502,440
1,180,000
320,000
1,500,000
B2
0021
7,170,900
0
7,170,900
4,087,413
Recommended:
PUC
Land
Impr
FCV
LPV
Land
Impr
FCV
Rule
Tax Case:
TX2019-001378
Attorney:
MUTHIG KLAUS PETER
Number of
Parcels:
2
Date: 06/20/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1
Tax Year:
2020
Plaintiff:
EL FENIX LLC
Appraiser:
HOOVER TOM
2021
Date:
07/10/2023
1 Parcel
Prepared by:
Parcel#:
See Attached
Plaintiff:
LAND
IMPS
FCV
RATIO
CURRENT
3,174,500
12,698,100
15,872,600
See Parcel
RECOMMENDED:
3,174,500
566,283
3,740,783
TASRs
Hoover/Diaz
Tax Case: TX2020-001133
Tax Year: 2021
MADISON GARDENS/PHOENIX LP
*** C O V E R S H E E T ***
_____________________________________________________________
TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION
Maricopa County
301 West Jefferson
Phoenix, AZ 85003
County Atty: MUTHIG KLAUS PETER
Current:
Parcel
Class
PUC
LPV
Class
16207232
4.1 @10.0%
N/C
N/C
N/C
566,283
3,740,783
A2
3,174,500
12,698,100
15,872,600
4,181,099
3,174,500
566,283
3,740,783
0374
3,174,500
12,698,100
15,872,600
4,181,099
Recommended:
PUC
Land
Impr
FCV
LPV
Land
Impr
FCV
Rule
Tax Case:
TX2020-001133
Attorney:
MUTHIG KLAUS PETER
Number of
Parcels:
1
Date: 07/10/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1
Tax Year:
2021
Plaintiff:
MADISON GARDENS/PHOENIX LP
Appraiser:
HOOVER TOM
Date:
07/11/2023
3 Parcels
Prepared by:
Parcel #s:
See Attached
Plaintiff:
LAND
IMPS
FCV
RATIO
CURRENT
19,625,300
78,501,300
98,126,600
See
RECOMMENDED:
19,625,300
27,374,700
47,000,000
Attached
Chappell/Procaccini
Tax Case: TX2020-001059
Tax Year: 2021
IP BPG CITY SQUARE LLC
*** C O V E R S H E E T ***
_____________________________________________________________
TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION
Maricopa County
301 West Jefferson
Phoenix, AZ 85003
County Atty: O'CONNOR JACK
Current:
Parcel
Class
PUC
LPV
Class
11831007A
1.12 @18.0%
N/C
N/C
11831008
1.12 @18.0%
N/C
N/C
11831009
1.12 @18.0%
N/C
N/C
N/C
11,701,811
20,091,011
A2
19,625,300
78,501,300
98,126,600
51,682,128
19,625,300
27,374,700
47,000,000
1574
8,389,200
33,556,800
41,946,000
21,948,086
N/C
7,233,531
12,419,331
A2
1574
6,050,300
24,201,200
30,251,500
16,099,909
N/C
8,439,358
14,489,658
A2
1574
5,185,800
20,743,300
25,929,100
13,634,133
Recommended:
PUC
Land
Impr
FCV
LPV
Land
Impr
FCV
Rule
Tax Case:
TX2020-001059
Attorney:
O'CONNOR JACK
Number of
Parcels:
3
Date: 07/11/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1
Tax Year:
2021
Plaintiff:
IP BPG CITY SQUARE LLC
Appraiser:
CHAPPELL NED
2021/2022/2023
Date:
06/27/2023
1 Parcel (Last 1 of 4)
Prepared by:
Parcel #:
See Attached
Plaintiff:
LAND
IMPS
FCV
RATIO
CURRENT
3,176,700
12,751,400
15,928,100
See Parcel
RECOMMENDED:
3,176,700
9,913,300
13,090,000
TASRs
Hoover / Procaccini
Tax Case: TX2020-001100
Tax Year: 2021
MACYS WEST STORES INC
*** C O V E R S H E E T ***
_____________________________________________________________
TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION
Maricopa County
301 West Jefferson
Phoenix, AZ 85003
County Atty: JEFFREY MESSING
Date: 05/25/2023
Parcel Allocation
Page: 1 of 1
Tax Year:
2021
Plaintiff:
MACYS WEST STORES INC
Appraiser:
TOM HOOVER
Tax Case:
TX2020-001100
Attorney:
JEFFREY MESSING
Number of
Parcels:
1 (Last 1 of 4)
Ü¿¬»æ êóîéóîí
Date:
06/27/2023
1 Parcel (Last 1 of 4)
Prepared by:
Parcel#:
See Attached
Plaintiff:
LAND
IMPS
FCV
RATIO
CURRENT
2,931,000
11,577,900
14,508,900
See Parcel
RECOMMENDED:
2,931,000
8,919,000
11,850,000
TASRs
Hoover / Procaccini
Tax Case: TX2020-001100
Tax Year: 2022
MACYS WEST STORES INC
*** C O V E R S H E E T ***
_____________________________________________________________
TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION
Maricopa County
301 West Jefferson
Phoenix, AZ 85003
County Atty: JEFFREY MESSING
Date: 05/25/2023
Parcel Allocation
Page: 1 of 1
Tax Year:
2022
Plaintiff:
MACYS WEST STORES INC
Appraiser:
TOM HOOVER
Tax Case:
TX2020-001100
Attorney:
JEFFREY MESSING
Number of
Parcels:
1 (Last 1 of 4)
Ü¿¬»æ êóîéóîí
Date:
06/27/2023
1 Parcel
Prepared by:
Parcel #:
See Attached
Plaintiff:
LAND
IMPS
FCV
RATIO
CURRENT
5,304,600
8,648,300
13,952,900
See Parcel
RECOMMENDED:
5,304,600
6,545,400
11,850,000
TASRs
Hoover / Procaccini
Tax Case: TX2020-001100
Tax Year: 2023
MACYS WEST STORES INC
*** C O V E R S H E E T ***
_____________________________________________________________
TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION
Maricopa County
301 West Jefferson
Phoenix, AZ 85003
County Atty: JEFFREY MESSING
Tax Case:
TX2020-001100
Attorney:
JEFFREY MESSING
Number of
Parcels:
1
Date: 06/21/2023
Parcel Allocation
Page: 1 of 1
Tax Year:
2023
Plaintiff:
MACYS WEST STORES INC
Appraiser:
TOM HOOVER
Ü¿¬»æ êóîéóîí
2022
Date:
06/27/2023
1 Parcel
Prepared by:
Parcel #:
See Attached
Plaintiff:
LAND
IMPS
FCV
RATIO
CURRENT
2,125,100
8,500,600
10,625,700
See Parcel
RECOMMENDED:
2,125,100
4,374,900
6,500,000
TASR
Hoover / Procaccini
Tax Case: TX2021-000534
Tax Year: 2022
NORTHERN GARDENS II/PHOENIX LP
CARDEN LIVESAY LTD
*** C O V E R S H E E T ***
_____________________________________________________________
TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION
Maricopa County
301 West Jefferson
Phoenix, AZ 85003
County's Atty: JOSHUA W. CARDEN
Current:
Parcel
Class
PUC
LPV
Class
15721003A
4.1 @10.0%
N/C
N/C
N/C
4,374,900
6,500,000
B6
2,125,100
8,500,600
10,625,700
7,119,219
2,125,100
4,374,900
6,500,000
0364
2,125,100
8,500,600
10,625,700
7,119,219
Recommended:
PUC
Land
Impr
FCV
LPV
Land
Impr
FCV
Rule
Tax Case:
TX2021-000534
Attorney:
Number of
Parcels:
1
JOSHUA W. CARDEN/CARDEN LIVESAY LTD
Date: 06/27/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1
Tax Year:
2022
Plaintiff:
NORTHERN GARDENS II/PHOENIX LP
Appraiser:
TOM HOOVER
Date:
07/10/2023
1 Parcel
Prepared by:
Parcel #:
See Attached
Plaintiff:
LAND
IMPS
FCV
RATIO
CURRENT
3,481,000
13,924,000
17,405,000
See Parcel
RECOMMENDED:
3,481,000
574,333
4,055,333
TASRs
Hoover/Procaccini
Tax Case: TX2021-000538
Tax Year: 2022
MADISON GARDENS/PHOENIX LP
*** C O V E R S H E E T ***
_____________________________________________________________
TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION
Maricopa County
301 West Jefferson
Phoenix, AZ 85003
County Atty: MUTHIG KLAUS PETER
Current:
Parcel
Class
PUC
LPV
Class
16207232
4.1 @10.0%
0374
4.1
N/C
574,333
4,055,333
A2
3,481,000
13,924,000
17,405,000
4,390,154
3,481,000
574,333
4,055,333
0374
3,481,000
13,924,000
17,405,000
4,390,154
Recommended:
PUC
Land
Impr
FCV
LPV
Land
Impr
FCV
Rule
Tax Case:
TX2021-000538
Attorney:
MUTHIG KLAUS PETER
Number of
Parcels:
1
Date: 07/10/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1
Tax Year:
2022
Plaintiff:
MADISON GARDENS/PHOENIX LP
Appraiser:
HOOVER TOM
2022/2023
Date:
07/11/2023
1 Parcel
Prepared by:
Parcel #:
See Attached
Plaintiff:
LAND
IMPS
FCV
RATIO
CURRENT
2,512,800
13,060,900
15,573,700
See Parcel
RECOMMENDED:
2,512,800
9,712,200
12,225,000
TASR
Chappell/Procaccini
Tax Case: TX2021-000489
Tax Year: 2022
TATUM & DYNAMITE SELF STORAGE PARTNERS LLC
*** C O V E R S H E E T ***
_____________________________________________________________
TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION
Maricopa County
301 West Jefferson
Phoenix, AZ 85003
County Atty: MUTHIG KLAUS PETER
Current:
Parcel
Class
PUC
LPV
Class
21218201
1.12 @17.5%
N/C
N/C
N/C
9,712,200
12,225,000
B5
2,512,800
13,060,900
15,573,700
11,368,801
2,512,800
9,712,200
12,225,000
2830
2,512,800
13,060,900
15,573,700
11,368,801
Recommended:
PUC
Land
Impr
FCV
LPV
Land
Impr
FCV
Rule
Tax Case:
TX2021-000489
Attorney:
MUTHIG KLAUS PETER
Number of
Parcels:
1
Date: 07/11/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1
Tax Year:
2022
Plaintiff:
Appraiser:
CHAPPELL NED
TATUM & DYNAMITE SELF STORAGE PARTNERS LLC
Date:
07/11/2023
1 Parcel
Prepared by:
Parcel #:
See Attached
Plaintiff:
LAND
IMPS
FCV
RATIO
CURRENT
2,273,700
19,424,400
21,698,100
See Parcel
RECOMMENDED:
2,273,700
10,681,300
12,955,000
TASR
Chappell/Procaccini
Tax Case: TX2021-000489
Tax Year: 2023
TATUM & DYNAMITE SELF STORAGE PARTNERS LLC
*** C O V E R S H E E T ***
_____________________________________________________________
TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION
Maricopa County
301 West Jefferson
Phoenix, AZ 85003
County Atty: MUTHIG KLAUS PETER
TATUM & DYNAMITE SELF STORAGE PARTNERS LLC
Current:
Parcel
Class
PUC
LPV
Class
21218201
1.12 @17.0%
N/C
N/C
N/C
10,681,300
12,955,000
B6
2,273,700
19,424,400
21,698,100
14,103,765
2,273,700
10,681,300
12,955,000
3730
2,273,700
19,424,400
21,698,100
14,103,765
Recommended:
PUC
Land
Impr
FCV
LPV
Land
Impr
FCV
Rule
Tax Case:
TX2021-000489
Attorney:
MUTHIG KLAUS PETER
Number of
Parcels:
1
Date: 07/11/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1
Tax Year:
2023
Plaintiff:
Appraiser:
CHAPPELL NED
2023
Date:
07/11/2023
2 Parcels
Prepared by:
Parcel #s:
See Attached
Plaintiff:
LAND
IMPS
FCV
RATIO
CURRENT
19,128,600
60,385,900
79,514,500
See Parcel
RECOMMENDED:
19,128,600
53,656,400
72,785,000
TASRs
Chappell/Procaccini
Tax Case: TX2022-000347
Tax Year: 2023
3131 CAMELBACK ROAD LLC
*** C O V E R S H E E T ***
_____________________________________________________________
TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION
Maricopa County
301 West Jefferson
Phoenix, AZ 85003
County Atty: O'CONNOR JACK
Current:
Parcel
Class
PUC
LPV
Class
16312051
1.12 @17.0%
1524
1.12
16312052
1.12 @17.0%
2610
1.12
19,128,600
53,656,400
72,785,000
19,128,600
60,385,900
79,514,500
61,924,065
8,514,893
44,179,429
52,694,322
B7
2610
10,613,707
11,334,500
21,948,207
17,092,759
10,613,707
9,476,971
20,090,678
B7
1524
8,514,893
49,051,400
57,566,293
44,831,306
Recommended:
PUC
Land
Impr
FCV
LPV
Land
Impr
FCV
Rule
Tax Case:
TX2022-000347
Attorney:
O'CONNOR JACK
Number of
Parcels:
2
Date: 07/11/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1
Tax Year:
2023
Plaintiff:
3131 CAMELBACK ROAD LLC
Appraiser:
CHAPPELL NED