1. PZ RPT GP Amendment: Vision Assets, LLC
Extracted text (via pymupdf_layout)
21790 characters
STAFF REPORT TO THE PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING AND NEIGHBORHOOD SERVICES COMMUNITY PLANNING CASE TYPE – GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT Case Planner: Erika Peterson Hearing Date: December 8, 2025 Case Number: GP-44387-2025 Project This is a Minor General Plan Amendment request by Dahl, Robins & Associates, Description/ Inc., on behalf of Vision Assets, LLC, to change the land use designation from Low Location: Density Residential to Medium Density Residential for approximately 2.49 acres, for the property located at 2080 W. 27th Street, Yuma, AZ. Existing Zoning Use(s) on-site General Plan Designation City Residence-Manufactured Site Undeveloped Low Density Residential Housing (RMH-20) County Manufactured Home North Undeveloped Mixed Use Subdivision (MHS-20) City Low Density Residential South Yuma Catholic High School Public/Quasi Public (R-1-6) County Manufactured Home Mobile home park & single- East Subdivision (MHS-4.5/MHS- Low Density Residential family homes 10/MHS-20) City Residence-Manufactured West Housing (RMH-20) and Single-family homes and vacant Low Density Residential County Suburban Ranch (SR-1) Location Map GP-44387-2025 December 8, 2025 Page 1 of 15 Prior site actions: Annexation, Ord. 2025-025, effective 8/15/2025 Staff Staff recommends the Planning and Zoning Commission APPROVE the Recommendation: request to change the land use designation for approximately 2.49 acres from Low Density Residential to Medium Density Residential. Suggested Move to APPROVE the request to change the land use designation for approximately Motion: 2.498 acres from Low Density Residential to Medium Density Residential. Staff This is a Minor General Plan Amendment request by Dahl, Robins & Associates, Inc., Analysis: on behalf of Vision Assets, LLC, to change the land use designation from Low Density Residential to Medium Density Residential for approximately 2.49 acres, for the property located at 2080 W. 27th Street, Yuma, AZ. The existing Low Density Residential land use designation supports the following types of zoning: Suburban Ranch (SR-1), Residential Estate (RE-12, RE-18, RE-35), Low Density Single-Family Residential (R-1-5), Low Density Residential (R-1-6, R-1-8, R- 1-12, R-1-20, R-1-40). The proposed Medium Density Residential land use designation supports the following types of zoning: Medium Density Residential (R-2), Medium Density Single-Family Residential (R-2-5). The applicant’s intent in changing the land use designation is to pursue a rezoning of the site to Medium Density Residential (R-2) to allow the development of multi-family residential lots with a duplex on each lot. Density The current land use designation of Low Density Residential would allow from 3 to 12 dwelling units to be constructed on 2.49 acres. The proposed Medium Density Residential land use designation would allow 12 to 32 dwelling units to be developed. Population Information from the 2023 American Community Survey provides data on population by housing unit type. The information results in an average household size for 2-4 units of 2.2 persons per dwelling in the City of Yuma. Comparing the densities allowed within the General Plan, the potential persons expected are: - Low Density: Minimum 3 homes – Expected population: 7 Maximum 12 homes – Expected population: 26 - Medium Density Residential: Minimum 12 homes – Expected population: 26 Maximum 32 homes – Expected population: 70 The 2020 Census identified that 20% of the population within the City of Yuma was between 5 and 17 years of age. Therefore, the expected school-age population is estimated at: - Low Density Residential: Minimum expected population: 7 – School Age: 1 Maximum expected population: 26 – School Age: 5 - Medium Density Residential: GP-44387-2025 December 8, 2025 Page 2 of 15 Minimum expected population: 26 – School Age: 5 Maximum expected population: 70 – School Age: 14 Transportation The property is located on the northwest corner of 27th Street and 20th Avenue. Vehicle access to the property will be from 27th Street and 20th Avenue, both Local Roads with the nearest Collector on 21st Drive. There are two existing bus stops on 21st Drive near Yuma Catholic High School, Purple Route & Yellow Route 95, and an existing bike lane on 21st Drive and bike route on 27th Street. The City of Yuma Transportation Master Plan identifies 27th Street and 20th Avenue as Local Roads and 21st Drive as a Collector Road. According to the City of Yuma Transportation Master Plan, 21st Drive operates at a Level of Service (LOS) of C or above, meaning that there are stable conditions with movements somewhat restricted due to higher volumes but not objectionable to motorists. In addition, the daily traffic count identified by the Yuma Metropolitan Planning Organization for 2024 on 21st Drive, south of 28th Street is 7,071. Housing The Housing Element of the City of Yuma 2022 General Plan addresses the need to provide safe, decent, sanitary, and affordable housing for all residents. And specifically Objective 1.3 notes providing a variety of housing types: Objective 1.3: Encourage a variety of housing types to meet all socioeconomic segments of the population, considering both full time and seasonal residents. An Action Item of the Housing Element is to consider rezoning land for higher density residential development to promote additional rental and lower cost ownership options. The General Plan amendment request is to provide a housing choice other than Low Density Residential single-family homes, which is the predominant housing option in the City of Yuma. Public Services It is a requirement of State Statute for a General Plan to identify public schools and other public buildings. The City of Yuma General Plan Public Services Element identifies the location of public/charter schools within the 3 school districts in the General Plan area. The request is located within the district boundaries of the Crane Elementary School District and the Yuma Union High School District. According to the Crane Elementary School District Boundary Map, the elementary students in the subject area are within the boundary of Gary A. Knox Elementary School located at 2926 S. 21st Drive and junior high school students are within the boundary of Centennial Middle School at 2650 W. 20th Street. According to the Yuma Union High School District, the high school students are within the boundary of Kofa High School located at 3100 S. Avenue A. Growth Areas The Growth Areas chapter identifies those parts of the Planning Area ideal for a concentration of a variety of land uses, including higher densities and intensities or GP-44387-2025 December 8, 2025 Page 3 of 15 uses. Equally essential is the need for growth to occur close to existing or planned public facilities and services. The General Plan request is located within the Avenue B and 32nd Street Growth Area, which features a mix of development including schools, medical and dental offices, a library, government facilities, as well as commercial and residential uses. The Yuma Valley area receives water service from the Main Street Water Treatment Plant and wastewater service from the Figueroa Water Pollution Control Facility. All new development must secure water and sewer entitlements prior to construction approval. With established transportation infrastructure and a strong commercial presence, this area is well-positioned for continued strategic growth. Encouraging new high- and medium-density residential projects here is recommended, as there is currently limited land designated for higher-density housing within this growth area. The YCAT bus system serves the area with two routes, emphasizing connectivity to the commercial center located at the southeast corner of 24th Street and Avenue B. 1. Does the proposed amendment impact any elements of the General Plan? No. The proposed amendment does not impact any of the element of the General Plan. Transportation Element: FACILITY PLANS Transportation Master Plan Planned Existing 27th Street – Local Street 29’ HW Varies 21st Drive – 2 Lane Collector 40’ HW Varies 2. Does the proposed amendment impact any of the facility plans? No. 3. Is the proposed amendment in conflict with Council’s prior actions? Yes. This area has been designated with the Low Density Residential land use designation since the adoption of the 2012 City of Yuma General Plan, adopted on June 6, 2012, R2012-29. Scheduled Public Hearings: X City of Yuma Planning and Zoning Commission: December 8, 2025 City of Yuma City Council: January 7, 2026 Public Comments Received: See Attachment A Agency Comments: See Attachment B Neighborhood Meeting Comments: See Attachment D Final staff report delivered to applicant on: Applicant agreed with staff’s recommendation: Applicant did not agree with staff’s recommendation: X Final report has been emailed to applicant on 11/23/2025 and awaiting response. GP-44387-2025 December 8, 2025 Page 4 of 15 Attachments A B C D E F Neighborhood Neighbor Public Agency Staff Meeting Notification Aerial Photo Comments Comments Worksheet Comments List Prepared By: Date: 11/12/2025 Erika Peterson Erika Peterson Senior Planner (928) 373-5000, x3071 Erika.Peterson@YumaAz.Gov Reviewed By: Jennifer L. Albers Date: 11/13/25 Jennifer L. Albers, Assistant Director of Planning Approved By: Alyssa Linville Date: 11/26/25 Alyssa Linville, Director, Department of Community Development GP-44387-2025 December 8, 2025 Page 5 of 15 ATTACHMENT A PUBLIC COMMENTS Name: Miguel Aguirre Contact Information: (928)261-9718 Method of Contact: Phone X FAX Email Letter Other Comment: Mr. Aguirre called to inquire about the request. He wanted to know what was going to be built, who approves the annexation and who requested it. In addition, he had questions about the location map and how he could hook up to City sewer. GP-44387-2025 December 8, 2025 Page 6 of 15 ATTACHMENT B AGENCY COMMENTS DATE: 9/12/2025 NAME: Javier Barraza TITLE: Senior Planner Yuma County Department of Development AGENCY: PHONE: (928)817-5150 Services Enter comments below: DATE: 9/15/2025 NAME: Omar Peñuñuri TITLE: Sr. Engineering Tech AGENCY: Yuma County Water Users’ Assoc. PHONE: (928)512-5531 Enter comments below: Hi Erika, Please let me know if the new development would involve multiple lots? Will the landowner be proceeding with a water conversion at this time? I'm not sure if there is information available for the two questions at this time. Please let me know about any questions. Thanks! Omar Peñuñuri DATE: 9/18/2025 NAME: Antonio Martinez TITLE: Community Liaison Specialist AGENCY: MCAS PHONE: (928)269-2103 Enter comments below: GP-44387-2025 December 8, 2025 Page 7 of 15 ATTACHMENT C STAFF WORKSHEET STAFF RESEARCH – GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT CASE #: GP-44387-2025 CASE PLANNER: ERIKA PETERSON I. PROJECT DATA Project Location: 2080 W. 27th Street Parcel Number(s): 694-14-006 Parcel Size(s): 2.49 acres Total Acreage: 2.49 Proposed Dwelling Units: Maximum: 32 Minimum: 12 Address: 2080 W. 27th Street Applicant: Vision Assets Applicant’s Agent: Dahl, Robins & Associates, Inc. Land Use Conformity Matrix: Current Zoning District Conforms: Yes No X Zoning Overlay: Public AO Auto B&B Historic Infill None X Airport Noise Contours 65-70 70-75 75+ APZ1 APZ2 CLEAR ZONE Existing Zoning Current Use General Plan Designation Residence-Manufactured Housing Site Undeveloped Low Density Residential (R-MH-20) County Manufactured Home North Undeveloped Mixed Use Subdivision (MHS-20) City Low Density Residential South Yuma Catholic High School Public/Quasi Public (R-1-6) County Manufactured Home Mobile home park & single- East Subdivision (MHS-4.5/MHS- Low Density Residential family homes 10/MHS-20) City Residence-Manufactured Single-family homes and West Housing (RMH-20) and Low Density Residential vacant County Suburban Ranch (SR-1) Prior Cases or Related Actions: Type Conforms Cases, Actions or Agreements Pre-Annexation Agreement Yes No N/A Annexation Yes No Ord. 2025-025, effective 8/15/2025 General Plan Amendment Yes No N/A Development Agreement Yes No N/A Rezone Yes No N/A Subdivision Yes No N/A Conditional Use Permit Yes No N/A Pre-Development Meeting Yes X No Date: 11/14/2024 PDM-43408-2024 Enforcement Actions Yes No N/A Land Division Status: Legal lots of record Irrigation District: Yuma County Water Users’ Adjacent Irrigation Canals & Drains: East Main Canal GP-44387-2025 December 8, 2025 Page 8 of 15 Water Conversion: (5.83 ac ft/acre) 14.52 Acre Feet a Year Water Conversion Agreement Required Yes X No II. CITY OF YUMA GENERAL PLAN Land Use Element: Land Use Designation: Low Density Residential Issues: Historic District: Brinley Avenue Century Heights Main Street None X Historic Buildings on Site: Yes No X Transportation Element: FACILITY PLANS Transportation Master Plan Planned Existing Gateway Scenic Hazard Truck 27th Street – Local Street 29’ HW Varies 21st Drive – 2 Lane Collector 40’ HW Varies Bicycle Facilities Master Plan 27th Street - Bike Route YCAT Transit System 21st Drive - Purple & Yellow Routes Issues: Parks, Recreation and Open Space Element: Parks and Recreation Facility Plan Neighborhood Park: Existing: Ponderosa Park Future: Ponderosa Park Community Park: Existing: Yuma Valley Park Future: Yuma Valley Park Linear Park: Existing: East Main Canal Linear Park Future: East Main Canal Linear Park Issues: Housing Element: Special Need Household: N/A Issues: Redevelopment Element: Planned Redevelopment Area: Adopted Redevelopment Plan: North End: Carver Park: None: X Conforms: Yes No Conservation, Energy & Environmental Element: Impact on Air or Water Resources Yes No X Renewable Energy Source Yes No X Issues: Public Services Element: Population Impacts Dwellings & Type Projected Police Water Wastewater Population projection per 2023 5-Year American Community Survey 2-4 Units Population Impact Consumption Generation Police Impact Standard: Maximum Per Unit Officers GPD AF GPD 1 officer for every 530 citizens; 2020 Conservation Plan: 32 2.2 70 0.13 14,573 16.3 4,928 Water demand: 207 gallons/day/person; Minimum Wastewater generation: 70 gallons per day per person 12 2.2 26 0.05 5,465 6.1 1,848 Fire Services Plan: Existing: Fire Station No. 6 Future: Fire Station No. 6 Water Facility Plan: Source: City X Private Connection: 6” PVC on 20th Ave & 8” PVC on 27th St Sewer Facility Plan: Connection: Manhole & stubout on 27th Treatment: City X Septic Private St. between 20th Ave & 19th Ave Issues: GP-44387-2025 December 8, 2025 Page 9 of 15 Safety Element: Flood Plain Designation: 500 Year Flood Liquefaction Hazard Area: Yes No X Issues: Growth Area Element: Growth Araby Rd & Interstate 8 Arizona Ave & 16th St Avenue B & 32nd St. X Area: North End Pacific Ave & 8th St Estancia None Issues: GP-44387-2025 December 8, 2025 Page 10 of 15 NOTIFICATION o Legal Ad Published: The Sun 11/15/25 o Site Posted: 10/4/2025 o Display Ad Published: 11/15/25 o Neighborhood Meeting: 10/7/2025 o 660’ Vicinity Mailing: 9/16/25 o Hearing Dates: 12/8/25 & 01/07/26 o 54 Commenting/Reviewing Agencies noticed: 09/09/25 o Comments Due: 11/08/25 External List Response Date “No Written Received Received Comment” Comments Yuma Metropolitan Planning Organization (ARS) NR Yuma County Engineering NR Yuma County Flood Control District NR Yuma County Planning & Zoning (ARS) YES 9/12/2025 X Yuma County Public Works NR Yuma County Airport Authority YES 9/9/2025 X Yuma County Chamber of Commerce NR Yuma County Assessor NR Greater Yuma Econ. Development Corp. NR Yuma County School Superintendent NR YUHS District #70 (ARS) NR Yuma Elementary School District #1 (ARS) NR Crane School District #13 (ARS) NR City of San Luis (ARS) NR City of Somerton (ARS) NR Imperial County, California (ARS) NR Qwest Communications (ARS) NR Arizona Public Service (ARS) NR Time Warner Cable (ARS) NR Southwest Gas (ARS) NR Arizona Department of Transportation NR Arizona Game & Fish Dept. NR Arizona Department of Commerce (ARS) NR Arizona State Attorney General (ARS) NR Arizona Dept. of Water Resources (ARS) NR Arizona State Land Department (ARS) NR MCAS / C P & L Office (ARS) YES 9/18/2025 X Bureau of Land Management (ARS) NR US Border Patrol NR US Postal Service NR Quechan Tribal Office YES 9/9/2025 X Cocopah Indian Tribe NR Yuma County Water Users’ Association YES 9/15/2025 X Yuma Irrigation District NR Yuma Mesa Irrigation Drainage District NR Unit B Irrigation District NR Yuma County Association of Realtor’s NR Yuma County Contractor’s Association NR AZ Society of Military Engineers (ASME) NR AZ Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) NR AZ Society of Professional Engineers (ASPE) NR El Paso Natural Gas Co. NR Western Area Power Administration YES 9/1/2025 X GP-44387-2025 December 8, 2025 Page 11 of 15 City of Yuma Internal List Response Date “No Written Received Received Comment Comments ” Thomas Garrity, Police NR Rod Hamilton, Police NR Eric Urfer, Parks and Rec – Admin NR David Wostenberg, City Engineer NR Andrew McGarvie, Engineering NR Kayla Warren, Fire – Prevention YES 9/9/2025 X Randall Crist, Building Safety NR Jeremy McCall, Utilities NR Joel Olea, Public Works NR NR=None Received NR Neighborhood Meeting Comments Available October 7, 2025 See Attachment D Prop. 207 Waiver Received by Owner’s signature on the application for this land use action request. GP-44387-2025 December 8, 2025 Page 12 of 15 ATTACHMENT D NEIGHBORHOOD MEETING COMMENTS Date Held: 10/7/2025 Location: 2080 W. 27th Street Attendees: Staff: Erika Peterson; Applicant: Alejandro Carlos, Adrian Vega- Dahl, Robins & Associates Neighbors in attendance: Miguel Aguirre, Maria Aguiree, George Daniels, Karla Daniels, Carlos Gonzalez, Jesus Aguirre SUMMARY OF ATTENDEE’S COMMENTS RELATED TO THE PROJECT: • Staff explained the applicants request to change the land use designation from Low density residential to medium density residential to pursue a rezoning of the site to Medium Density Residential. • The applicant explained that the property was annexed into the City and now the request is to change in land use designation to build duplexes. • The applicant/owner would like to rezone and then subdivide into ten (10) lots and build a duplex on each lot, total of twenty (20) units. • Adrian Vega explained the plating process for the subdivision. The new development would include a paved road on 20th Avenue, with City lights, hydrants and connection to City sewer, new development will be accessed from 20th Avenue. Currently, the applicant and property owner do not have a design for the duplexes but will meet the City’s density and development standards. Each duplex will feature a garage and driveway, landscaping required in the ROW would be maintained through a MID, and the development would have CC&R’s. • A neighbor wanted to know if the units were all going to be rental units and if there would be a fence/wall. • Neighbors wanted to know if the property owner owned other properties within the City or County and what made him choose to develop on this site. • A neighbor wanted clarification on the paved road on 20th Avenue. • Adrian Vega stated that the City would require the half width of 20th Avenue to be paved, all of which would be right-of-way. • Neighbors wanted to know if this development would cause their property values to go up. GP-44387-2025 December 8, 2025 Page 13 of 15 ATTACHMENT E NEIGHBOR NOTIFICATION LIST Zip Property Owner Mailing Address City State Code AGUIRRE FAMILIA TRUST 4-7-2017 3760 W 20TH LN YUMA AZ 85364 AGUIRRE FRANCISCO S 3760 W 20TH LN YUMA AZ 85364 AWARS LTD AZ LLC 3205 S PINTO WAY YUMA AZ 85365 AWARS LTD LLC AND 3205 S PINTO WAY YUMA AZ 85365 BALDERAMA MARICELA 2646 S 18TH DR YUMA AZ 85364 CABRERA ROSALINDA LEPE AND 202 S 15TH AVE YUMA AZ 85364 CONDE MARIA P 2688 S 18TH DR YUMA AZ 85364 COVARRUBIAS ADRIAN 2130 W 27TH ST YUMA AZ 85364 COVARRUBIAS IGNACIO R 2130 W 27TH ST YUMA AZ 85364 DANIELS REVOCABLE LIVING TRUST 2101 W 26TH ST YUMA AZ 85364 GARCIA JOSE RAMOS 2698 S 18TH DR YUMA AZ 85364 GONZALEZ CARLOS ABEL ACOSTA & 2602 S 19TH AVE YUMA AZ 85364 GUERRERO ISMAEL I MD 1488 W 18TH ST YUMA AZ 85364 JMF FAMILY LIMITED PARTNERSHIP 1445 W 18TH STREET YUMA AZ 85364 LE TRI HUYNH MINH 2650 S 18TH DR YUMA AZ 85364 LOPEZ BELEN 2604 S 18TH DR YUMA AZ 85364 MARTINEZ MARCELINA 2893 W JULIE LN YUMA AZ 85365 MCGINNIS MICHAEL R LIVING TRUST 8- 15-2013 3465 S SIESTA RD YUMA AZ 85365 MIRANDA ALEJANDRO & MERCEDES JT 2616 S 18TH DR YUMA AZ 85364 OASIS INSTITUTE AZ LLC & 2095 W 24TH ST STE C YUMA AZ 85364 ORTEGA JOSEFINA F 2622 S 19TH AVE YUMA AZ 85364 PASQUE PARTNERS AZ LP 2144 W 24TH ST STE 1 YUMA AZ 85364 PEREZ RAMON C & AVELINA JT 3585 W VENUS DR SOMERTON AZ 85350 PEREZ SONIA 2694 S 18TH DR YUMA AZ 85364 PUEBLO HOUSING AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT 1670 W MAIN STREET SOMERTON AZ 85350 RAY CYNTHIA ANN SUB-TRUST 23 OXFORD DR LATHAM NY 12110 RODRIGUEZ GABRIEL & NILZA C JT 2676 S 18TH DR YUMA AZ 85364 RVCBD AZ LLC PO BOX 330 YUMA AZ 85366 SIMIEN DONNA 2634 S 18TH DR YUMA AZ 85364 TMD25 LLC 2093 W 25TH ST YUMA AZ 85364 UBLA PROPERTIES LLC PO BOX 6531 YUMA AZ 85366 VALDEZ JORGE L 2615 S 20TH AVE YUMA AZ 85364 VELARDE ROSAMARIA D 2628 S 18TH DR YUMA AZ 85364 VILLARREAL HECTOR & CIRA C JT PO BOX 1215 YUMA AZ 85366 VISION ASSETS LLC 1036 S MUSTANG AVE YUMA AZ 85364 WAL-MART STORES INC DE CORP PO BOX 8050 BENTONVILLE AR 72712 YCHS PROPERTY HOLDINGS LLC 2100 W 28TH ST YUMA AZ 85364 YUMA COUNTY OF 198 S MAIN ST YUMA AZ 85364 YUMA REAL ESTATE INVESTORS TN LLC PO BOX 3480 CLEVELAND TN 37320 YUMA REGIONAL MEDICAL CENTER 2400 S AVEUE A YUMA AZ 85364 GP-44387-2025 December 8, 2025 Page 14 of 15 ATTACHMENT F AERIAL PHOTO Subject Property Avenue 20th Drive 27th Street 21st GP-44387-2025 December 8, 2025 Page 15 of 15