Extracted text (via pymupdf_layout)
11661 characters
CITY OF MESA | 2026 BOARD TRAINING Arizona Open Meeting Law + Conflict of Interest + Required Findings Board of Adjustment Practical guidance for hearings, deliberations, and decisions ORIENTATION Three Duties Guide Every Meeting OPENNESS: IMPARTIALITY: DECISION: Open Meeting Law Conflict of Interest Findings The public can see how the Members decide cases without Where required by law, make Board receives evidence, a disqualifying financial or the required findings as a part deliberates, and acts ownership interest of the Board’s decision Open Meeting Law: A.R.S. §§ 38-431 to 38-431.09 Findings: Mesa City Code 11-67-7 02 Conflict of Interest: A.R.S. §§ 38-501 to 38-511 OPEN MEETING LAW Open Meeting Law: Core Concepts (A.R.S. §§ 38-431 to 38-431.09) Public Policy of the State: Meetings of public bodies be conducted openly and that notices and agendas be provided that contain information reasonably necessary to inform the public of the matters to be discussed or decided. WHAT IT REQUIRES The Board conducts its business in meetings that are open to the public WHY IT EXISTS The public can attend, listen to deliberations, and observe decisions as Public access allows the community to see how its government conducts public business they happen A.R.S. § 38-431.01(A) 03 OPEN MEETING LAW Why the Rules Apply to the Board Arizona law expressly includes boards and commissions of a BOARD OF political subdivision and all quasi-judicial bodies within the definition of a public body subject to the Open Meeting Law ADJUSTMENT Public body includes boards and commissions of the City and all quasi-judicial bodies. Quasi-judicial body means a public body (other than a court) that hears disputed matters between a private person and a public agency and decides them in the general manner of a court. 03 A.R.S. § 38-431(6) and (7) OPEN MEETING LAW What Counts as a Meeting A meeting occurs when a quorum gathers, in person or through technology, and discusses, proposes, or takes legal action, and includes serial meetings QUORUM LEGAL ACTION COMMUNICATION Enough Board members A matter likely to come Discussion, deliberation, to conduct Board before the Board for a proposal, or a collective business* action decision A.R.S. § 38-431(3) and (4) 04 *BOA Bylaws Section II(C): Quorum is 4 members OPEN MEETING LAW Electronic Communications HIGH RISK • Reply all to an email with your view of a pending case • Ask staff to relay one member's position to others • Use a group text or social media thread to discuss a matter • Forward comments in a sequence that reaches a quorum LOWER RISK PRACTICE • Receive staff materials without responding to the group • Send scheduling or logistical information without discussing merits • Ask the Board attorney or liaison an individual procedural question • Save deliberation for the noticed public meeting A.R.S. § 38-431(4)(b); Ariz. Att'y Gen. Op. I05-004 06 OPEN MEETING LAW Notice and Agenda The Agenda Controls the Discussion • Lists specific matters to be discussed, considered, or decided 24 • Discuss and decide only listed matters and matters related to them • Do not deliberate on or discuss an unlisted topic raised by a speaker HOURS’ NOTICE • An actual emergency follows a separate statutory process Notice and the agenda must be available at least 24 hours before the meeting, subject to statutory counting rules and emergency exceptions A.R.S. § 38-431.02(C), (G), and (H) 06 OPEN MEETING LAW During the Public Meeting ACCESS Allow the public to attend and listen. RECORDING A person may record unless the recording actively interferes with the meeting. Take all legal action in public and record motions, discussion, action, and each ACTION member's vote. Members may respond to criticism or request later staff review but may not CALL TO PUBLIC discuss or act on an unlisted matter. A.R.S. § 38-431.01(A)–(G) and (I) 07 OPEN MEETING LAW Consequences for Violations LEGAL ACTION ENFORCEMENT Action taken at a meeting held in violation is null An affected person, the Attorney General, or the and void unless properly ratified county attorney may file suit in Superior Court INDIVIDUAL PENALTIES REMOVAL AND COSTS Against each person who knowingly violates the A court may remove an officer who knowingly OML or who knowingly aids, agrees to aid or acted with intent to deprive the public of attempts to aid (up to $500 for a second offense information and may assess costs and fees and up to $2,500 for a third or later offense)* A.R.S. §§ 38-431.05 and 38-431.07 Does not include consequences related to Executive Session (Criminal/Civil) 09 *City can’t defend or pay fine for violation CONFLICT OF INTEREST Conflict of Interest Law: Core Concepts (A.R.S. §§ 38-501 to 38-511) The object of conflict of interest statutes is to remove or limit the possibility of personal influence which might bear upon an official’s decision. WHAT IT REQUIRES Disclose the substantial interest in the official record and do not participate in the matter WHY IT EXISTS The law limits personal influence on official decisions and prevents self-dealing A substantial interest may belong to the member or a statutory relative A.R.S. §§ 38-501 to -511; §§ 38-502(9), (11), 38-503(A)-(B); Ariz. Att'y Gen. Agency Handbook § 8.2.1 03 CONFLICT OF INTEREST Conflict of Interest Test: Substantial Interest Ask whether the decision could create a direct, nonspeculative financial or ownership benefit or detriment for you or a statutory relative PECUNIARY OR 2 DIRECT OR 3 NOT A REMOTE 1 PROPRIETARY INDIRECT INTEREST Money, property, or The interest may belong The statute lists interests ownership to you or a relative treated as remote If all three apply disclose the substantial interest and do not participate A.R.S. §§ 38-502(10)–(11) and 38-503(A)–(B) 10 CONFLICT OF INTEREST Whose interests count? The statute defines “relative” for the purpose of conflict of interest YOUR HOUSEHOLD YOUR SIBLINGS YOUR SPOUSE'S FAMILY LINE •Spouse •Brother or sister, whole or •Parent half blood •Brother or sister •Child and child's child •Spouse of that brother or •Child •Parent and grandparent sister A.R.S. § 38-502(9) 11 CONFLICT OF INTEREST Remote Interests: A.R.S. § 38-502(10) A listed remote interest does not become a substantial interest under the general statute NONPROFIT Non-salaried officer of a nonprofit corporation SMALL STOCK INTEREST Less than 3% ownership in a for-profit corporation, provided annual income from dividends does not exceed 5% of total annual income CERTAIN RELATIVE A relative employed by an entity with at least 25 Arizona employees, EMPLOYMENT without management or budget control PUBLIC OFFICER OR Public officer or employee, or relative of same, unless the decision EMPLOYEE would confer a direct economic benefit or detriment Remote-interest exceptions are technical. Confirm the facts with the Board attorney before participating. Examples from A.R.S. § 38-502(10) 12 CONFLICT OF INTEREST What Recusal Requires A substantial interest requires disclosure in the official record and no participation in any manner DISCLOSE STATE WITHDRAW FOLLOW PROCEDURE Notify staff and the At the meeting, state Do not question staff or Board attorney early. that you have a applicants, deliberate, Leave the dais. Complete the required conflict and will not influence other Welcome to sit in the disclosure record with participate. members, or vote. audience. the City Clerk’s Office. Additional BOA Requirement: Board member must disclose if they’ve been a board member or officer of any entity that appears before the Board and is disqualified from participating if served within the last 5 years. 13 A.R.S. §§ 38-502(3)–(4), 38-503(A)–(B), 38-509, and 9-462.06(L) APPLY THE RULES Board Scenarios: Open Meeting Law and Conflict of Interest A group email from a Board member asks questions or provides information about an applicant and their property with a pending variance application Do not reply to the group. Save the discussion for the noticed meeting. A speaker raises a new issue that is not on the agenda Do not deliberate on it unless the agenda permits. Ask whether staff review or a future agenda item is appropriate. 14 APPLY THE RULES Board Scenarios: Open Meeting Law and Conflict of Interest Your sibling is the project manager and will receive a bonus if the application is approved Contact the Board attorney. A direct economic benefit to a statutory relative points to a substantial interest. You own property next to the subject site Seek advice before the hearing. The facts may show a direct, nonspeculative property interest. 14 REQUIRED FINDINGS Why the Board Must Make Findings CONNECT THE RECORD TO THE CODE Findings explain how the evidence satisfies, or does not satisfy, the governing criteria. CREATE THE OFFICIAL DECISION The written minutes must state the Board's findings, and the decision notice must include them. SUPPORT REVIEW OF THE DECISION A clear record shows that the Board applied the correct standards and relied on evidence in the record. The motion should state or adopt the required findings. Approval or denial alone does not identify the findings. Mesa City Code § 11-67-7(A)–(C) | A.R.S. § 9-462.06(B) and (G) 18 REQUIRED FINDINGS Board Decisions That Require Findings PERMIT AND APPROVAL DECISIONS • Variances § 11-80-3 • Substantial Conformance • Special Use Permits § 11-70-5(E) Improvement Permits § 11-73-3 • Community Residence SUP • Development Incentive Permits § 11-31-14(B) & Reasonable § 11-72-3 Accommodation § 11-31-14(D) • Comprehensive Sign Plans § 11- 46-3 Each case type has its own required APPEALS AND REFERRED DECISIONS findings. MCC Section 11-67-7(C) requires the Board to place its • Appeals from Zoning Administrator decisions §§ 11-66-3(C), findings in the written record. 11-77-4(D), 11-77-5 • Interpretations and matters referred by the Zoning Administrator or City Council § 11-66-3(C) Mesa City Code §§ 11-31-14(B) & (D), 11-46-3, 11-66-3(C), 11-70-5(E), 11-72-3, 11-73-3, 11-77-4(D), 11-77-5, and 11-80-3 19 REQUIRED FINDINGS Examples of Motion Language That Places Findings in the Record CONSENT AGENDA “I move to approve the consent agenda as presented, including the recommended action and conditions for each item, and adopt the findings in each staff report as the Board's findings based on the administrative record.” INDIVIDUAL ITEM OFF CONSENT, BOARD AGREES WITH STAFF “I move to approve Case No. _____, subject to the staff conditions, and adopt Use “administrative record” or “staff report and hearing record,” the staff findings in each staff report as the Board’s findings based on the rather than “information provided administrative record.” to the Board.” BOARD MODIFIES A STAFF FINDING BOARD DENIES DESPITE STAFF RECOMMENDATION “I move to approve Case No. _____, subject to _____, “I move to deny Case No. _____, as required Finding and adopt the staff findings in the staff report, with No. _____ is not satisfied because the administrative Finding No. _____ modified to state _____ because the record shows _____.” administrative record shows _____.” Mesa City Code §§ 11-67-7(C) and 11-77-5 | Board of Adjustment Bylaws §§ III(A)(2) and (5) 20 Tips to Remember Short Checklist ✓ Have I discussed this case with enough members to create a quorum? ✓ Does the agenda clearly cover the matter before us? ✓ Do I or a statutory relative have a financial or ownership interest? Questions ✓ Does my motion include the required findings for approval or When unsure, pause and state the finding not met for denial? ask Board counsel before participating City of Mesa Board of Adjustment | 2026