Meyen Final Supplemental Information - Variance Request
Extracted text (via pymupdf_layout)
13861 characters
SUPPLEMENTAL MEMORANDUM Board Precedent and Statutory Basis Supporting the Requested Variance Consolidated version — incorporates August 25, 2026 response to Town staff preliminary review Re: Case Review — Rear-Yard Setback Variance, 11037 N. Indian Wells Dr., Fountain Hills, AZ 85268 (proposed 16'×16' / 256 sq. ft. aluminum patio cover over existing pool), APN 176-08-555 | Fountain Hills Arizona No. 401-A, Lot 21 | R1-18 To: John Wesley, AICP, Development Services Director, Town of Fountain Hills From: John Meyen, Property Owner · Nick Lockwood, Modern Valley Patio (ROC-339167) Date: August 27, 2026 Subject: Board precedent (October 16, 2025 and June 18, 2026 cases) and statutory basis supporting approval of the requested 15'6" rear-yard setback variance This memorandum consolidates and supersedes our prior supplemental memorandum. It incorporates the legal analysis from our August 25, 2026 response to the Town's preliminary staff evaluation, so that the full record: Board precedent, applicable statutory standard, and impact analysis is presented together in a single document ahead of the hearing. 1. Case #VAR25-000002 (Baca Drive) is the closest precedent, and it was approved The Baca Drive case sought a variance to reduce the rear-yard setback from 25' to 10' — a 15-foot, 60% reduction — for a detached backyard gazebo intended for shade and outdoor gathering. That is a larger percentage reduction than the 15'6" (approximately 52%) relief requested here for the 16'×16' (256 sq. ft.) patio cover at 11037 N. Indian Wells Dr. The Board of Adjustment APPROVED the request in full. Staff's approved findings for that case map closely onto ours: ● Special circumstance: Staff found that the home's builder — not the current owner — sited the house so far back on the lot that the rear yard became too shallow to accommodate an accessory structure under the standard setback. This is functionally identical to our circumstance: an existing, immovable improvement (the pool) whose location was fixed before this owner acquired the property, leaving no conforming location to build a shade structure. “Not self-imposed”: Staff explicitly found that “the placement of the house on the lot creating the nearly unbuildable rear yard was not created by this property owner” and this is the same reasoning that applies to the house and pool's pre-existing location on our property. Deprivation of privileges enjoyed by others: Staff found that other homes in the same area, with the same zoning, that did not have this same siting constraint were able to add usable accessory structures in their rear yards and that the Baca Drive property, absent a variance, could not. Patio covers are permitted residential improvements in the R1-18 district where site conditions allow compliance with setbacks; shading a pool is an ordinary use enjoyed elsewhere in the district, denied to us only by an existing physical constraint. No inconsistent grant of special privilege: Staff acknowledged that granting the variance meant “the Board would be hard-pressed to not come to the same findings for many of the other lots” along that street and approved it anyway, because the practical impact on neighboring and adjacent property was minimal. The same is true here: our rear property line backs to open reserve, not another residence, so there is no adjacent property to be affected at all. The Baca Drive case (Case #VAR25-000002, heard October 16, 2025) also confirms, independent of its findings, that a rear-yard setback variance for a detached shade structure is a request the Town routinely accepts for hearing and evaluates on its merits not a novel or categorically disfavored type of application. We respectfully ask that the outcome and findings from that case be included in the record for comparison. 2. Case #VAR25-000001 (Trevino Drive) confirms the Board credits circumstances created by a prior owner, not the applicant The Trevino Drive case involved a front-yard setback reduction from 40' to 20' (a 50% reduction), approved as amended. Staff's findings turned on the fact that the lot's buildable constraints traced back to a 1995 replat and site grading performed by a previous owner, not the applicant. Staff found squarely that “the lot shape and topography were not created by this property owner” even though, as in our case, a decision made in the property's history is what produced the constraint. The Board's own orientation materials from its April 17, 2025 meeting make the same point directly: Development Services Director John Wesley explained that a variance applicant's back-yard addition may qualify precisely because “there may be a unique circumstance there that wasn't their doing because they didn’t build the house originally, kind of created the situation.” That is the exact reasoning that supports our request: the house and pool's location were established before this application, by parties other than the current owner. 3. “Location” is an independent statutory basis for special circumstances, and is not limited to topography or lot shape Both A.R.S. 9-462.06(G)(2) and (H)(2) and the Town's own Zoning Ordinance 2.07(B) authorize a variance where, because of special circumstances applicable to the property — including its size, shape, topography, location, or surroundings — strict application of the ordinance would deprive the property of privileges enjoyed by other property of the same classification in the same zoning district. “Location” is its own category in the statute, separate from topography and shape. The fixed, in-ground location of the existing pool relative to the rear property line is precisely that kind of circumstance: it is a physical fact about this lot, not a preference or a design choice being made now. The 30-foot rear setback, applied strictly, places the shade structure directly on top of the pool. No structure that shades the pool can be built in a conforming location. That is a location-based special circumstance squarely within the statutory language, even though it does not involve topography or rock outcroppings. 4. The ordinance bars variances that are “self-imposed,” not those where some earlier decision was ever made A board may not grant a variance where the special circumstance is self-imposed by the property owner. That is narrower than asking whether “a decision was made” at some point in the property's history. Nearly every constraint on a developed lot traces back to some earlier decision where the house was sited, where utilities run, where the pool was installed. If “a decision was made” were sufficient to defeat a variance, no developed residential lot could ever qualify, which cannot be the intended reading of a statute written specifically to address existing, developed property. The pool here is an existing permitted improvement whose siting predates this application and was not established by the current owner for the purpose of manufacturing a variance. The relevant inquiry is not whether a decision was made at some point in the property's history, but whether this applicant created the constraint to engineer eligibility. We did not. 5. Case #VAR26-000001 (Desert Tortoise Trail) confirms the Town's current, consistent standard for setback relief tied to lot-specific constraints At its June 18, 2026 meeting, the Board considered Case #VAR26-000001, 14522 E. Desert Tortoise Trail (APN #217-76-007), a request to reduce the required rear-yard setback from 40' to 30', which is a 25% reduction, to accommodate new single-family home construction on an irregularly shaped, sloped 1.95- acre lot in the R1-43 district. Although that case involves a different relief category (a primary residence rather than a detached accessory shade structure), it reflects the Town's most recent application of the same four-part standard under Zoning Ordinance 2.07(C)(6)(a) that governs our request: ● Special circumstance: Staff found the lot's irregular shape and steep grading to be a special circumstance which is the same kind of site-specific, non-generic constraint we cite here with respect to the house and pool's fixed location. ● Not self-imposed: Staff found that because the lot was platted in 2004 and the current owners purchased in 2025, the owners did not create the situation which mirrors our position that the pool's location predates this application. ● Deprivation of privileges: Staff found the requested reduction would allow a home comparable in size to others in the neighborhood, framing the variance as restoring parity with neighboring properties rather than granting an advantage. ● No special privilege / minimal impact: Staff found the encroachment would not affect neighboring residents’ views and would have no negative impact on other properties, given that development behind the lot was unlikely which is the identical minimal-impact reasoning that applies to our lot, which likewise backs to open reserve. Staff's written recommendation was to find all four criteria met and approve the requested reduction. As with our prior memorandum, we note that this section relies on the June 18, 2026 staff report; we have not independently confirmed the Board's summary of action or minutes for the final vote on this case, and recommend confirming that outcome before it is treated as a fully adjudicated precedent alongside the October 16, 2025 decisions. 6. The requested variance would not affect any privilege or interest of neighboring property, and the record supports Findings 3 and 4 The rear setback ordinarily protects a neighbor's light, air, privacy, and views. In our case that interest is not implicated: the rear lot line at 11037 N. Indian Wells Dr. backs to open reserve rather than another residence, so there is no adjacent property whose views, privacy, or use would be affected by the requested encroachment. Shading a pool is an ordinary and common use of residential property in this district, and the requested 15'6" clearance leaves the great majority of the required 30-foot setback intact. The request is limited to the 16'×16' patio cover shown in the application plans and does not change the property's residential use or extend to any other portion of the lot. 7. Clarification regarding Zoning Ordinance 5.06.D.4 For completeness, we note one clarification to our original application narrative: Zoning Ordinance 5.06.D.4 (patio cover projections) by its terms applies to front- or street-side-yard projections, not rear yards, and is not independently dispositive of this rear-yard request. We cite it only as evidence of the Town's general policy tolerance for a limited setback patio-cover intrusion (up to 15 feet) which is a policy judgment our request tracks closely in degree, even though that specific section does not extend to the rear yard. Conclusion The property's special circumstance is the fixed location of an existing, non-relocatable pool relative to the rear setback line which is a location-based circumstance the statute and ordinance expressly recognize, independent of topography or lot shape. That circumstance was not self-imposed by the current owner; it predates this application. The Board's own recent decisions confirm this reasoning: Case #VAR25-000002 involved the same relief category (a detached rear-yard shade structure), a larger percentage setback reduction, and findings built on the same reasoning we advance here. Case #VAR25- 000001 and Case #VAR26-000001 confirm that this four-part reasoning: a pre-existing, non-self-imposed constraint; deprivation of a privilege enjoyed elsewhere in the district; and minimal impact given the property's surroundings is the Town's current, consistently applied standard, not an isolated result from 2025. Because the rear property line here adjoins open reserve rather than a residence, the impact this setback ordinarily guards against is not present. We respectfully ask that the Board weigh this precedent and statutory analysis, together with our July 30, 2026 application narrative, and approve the requested 15'6" rear-yard setback variance. Respectfully submitted, John Meyen, Property Owner Nick Lockwood, Modern Valley Patio (ROC-339167) Sources Cited ● Arizona Revised Statutes 9-462.06(G)(2), (H)(2) — Board of Adjustment variance standard. ● Town of Fountain Hills Zoning Ordinance, Ch. 2, 2.07(B), (C)(6)(a) — Appeals and Variances. ● Town of Fountain Hills Zoning Ordinance 5.06.D.4 — Patio cover projections, front/street-side yard (cited for policy context only; not dispositive of this rear-yard request). ● Town of Fountain Hills Zoning Ordinance 5.06.G — Large accessory building setbacks, >120 sq. ft. ● Town of Fountain Hills Board of Adjustment, Meeting Packet, October 16, 2025 (Items 6.a. and 6.b., Staff Reports for Case #VAR25-000001 and Case #VAR25-000002). ● Town of Fountain Hills Board of Adjustment, Summary of Action, October 16, 2025 (confirming APPROVED AS AMENDED for Case #VAR25-000001 and APPROVED for Case #VAR25-000002). ● Case #VAR25-000002, 17324 E. Baca Dr., Staff Report Findings 1–4, Applicant Written Statement (Permit #B25-000259), and Public Notice, hearing 10/16/2025. ● Case #VAR25-000001, 16512 E. Trevino Dr., Staff Report Findings 1–4 and Applicant Narrative. ● Town of Fountain Hills Board of Adjustment, Summary Minutes and Verbatim Transcript, Regular Meeting of April 17, 2025 (Board orientation on Section 2.07 findings). ● Case #VAR26-000001, 14522 E. Desert Tortoise Trail, Staff Report (Meeting Date 6/18/2026), Findings 1–4 and Case Details Map — outcome/summary of action not yet confirmed. ● Modern Valley Patio, Application Narrative — Request for Rear-Yard Setback Relief, 11037 N. Indian Wells Dr., July 30, 2026. ● John Meyen / Modern Valley Patio, Memorandum — Response to Town Staff Preliminary Review, August 25, 2026.