Extracted text (via pymupdf_layout)
12184 characters
ITEM 6.b. TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS STAFF REPORT Meeting Date: 10/15/2026 Meeting Type: Board of Adjustment Regular Meeting Submitting Department: Development Services Prepared by: John Wesley, Development Services Director Staff Contact Information: Phone: 480-816-5138 Email: jwesley@fountainhillsaz.gov Request to Town Council Regular Meeting (Agenda Language) CONSIDERATION AND POSSIBLE ACTION: Request for a variance to reduce the rear yard setback in the R1-8 zoning district from 25' to 15' to allow construction of a shade cover for property located at 11037 N. Indian Wells Dr. Staff Summary (background) Applicable Ordinance Requirements Town Code Article 2A-2 Board of Adjustment Section 2A-2-4 Duties B. It shall be the duty of the Board of Adjustment to hear and decide appeals for variances from the terms of the zoning code only, if because of special circumstances applicable to the subject property, including its size, shape, topography, location or surroundings, the strict application of the zoning code will deprive such property owner of privileges enjoyed by owners of other property of the same classification in the zoning district. Any variance granted is subject to such conditions as will assure that the adjustment authorized shall not constitute a grant of special privileges inconsistent with the limitations upon other properties in the vicinity and zone in which such property is located. C. The Board of Adjustment may not: 1. Make any changes in the uses permitted in any zoning classification or zoning district, make any changes in the terms of the zoning code or make changes to the zoning map; provided, the restriction in this subsection shall not affect the authority to grant variances pursuant to this Article. 2. Grant a variance if the special circumstances applicable to the property are self-imposed by the property owner. Zoning Ordinance Chapter 2 Procedures Section 2.07 Appeals and Variances C. Variance. 1. Purpose. Any aggrieved person may apply to the Board of Adjustment for a variance from the terms of the Zoning Ordinance if, because of special circumstances applicable to the property, including its size, shape, topography, location, or surroundings, the strict application of the Zoning Ordinance will deprive such property owner of privileges enjoyed by owners of other property of the same classification in the same Zoning District. Nothing herein contained shall be construed to empower the Board to change the terms of this section, to authorize uses which violate any other Town ordinance, to effect changes in the zoning map, or to add to or change the uses permitted in any zoning district. 6. Findings. a. A variance shall not be granted unless the Board finds sufficient evidence to make a determination that: i. There are special circumstances applicable to the property, including its size, shape, topography, location, or surroundings; and ii. Such special circumstances are preexisting and not created by the property owner or appellant; and iii. The strict application of the Zoning Ordinance will deprive such property of privileges enjoyed by other property of the same classification in the same zoning district; and iv. Any variance granted will ensure that the adjustment authorized shall not constitute a grant of special privileges inconsistent with the limitations upon other properties in the vicinity and zone in which such property is located. b. No nonconforming use or violations of this section with respect to neighboring lands, structures, or buildings in the same zoning district, and no permitted use of lands, structures or buildings in other zoning districts, shall be considered grounds for granting a variance. 7. Action. In granting a variance, the Board may impose such conditions and safeguards as are appropriate to ensure that the purpose and intent of this section remain intact. Every variance shall be personal to the applicant therefor and shall be transferable and shall run with the land only after completion of any structure or structures authorized thereby. Chapter 5 General Provisions Section 5.06 Yard, Lot, and Area Requirements Sub-section B. Application B. Application: No building shall be erected, nor shall any existing buildings be altered, enlarged, moved, or rebuilt, nor shall any open space surrounding any building be encroached upon or reduced in any manner, except in conformity with the yard, lot, area and building location regulations hereinafter designated for the zone in which such building or open space is located, except as otherwise specifically provided. Chapter 10 Single Family Residential Zoning Districts Section 10.09 Density, Area, Building and Yard Regulations Zoning Ordinance Summary Chart Zoning District: R1-8 - Rear Yard Setback - 25' Variance Request The applicant has requested the Board of Adjustment grant a variance to the required rear yard setback to provide the opportunity to construct a shade structure over the existing pool. 2024 aerial image of the lot, house still under construction Spa permit application, under review Location of proposed patio cover and setback variance The applicant has provided a written justification statement which is attached to this report. Staff's review of the required findings for approval of a variance are noted below. 1. There are special circumstances applicable to the property, including its size, shape, topography, location, or surroundings. Applicant: The fixed, in-ground location of the existing pool relative to the rear property line is precisely that kind of circumstance: it is a physical fact about this lot, not a preference or a design choice being made now. The 25-foot rear setback, applied strictly, places the shade structure directly on top of the pool. No structure that shades the pool can be built in a conforming location. That is a location-based special circumstance squarely within the statutory language, even though it does not involve topography or rock outcroppings. Both A.R.S. 9-462.06(G)(2) and (H)(2) and the Town's own Zoning Ordinance 2.07(B) authorize a variance where, because of special circumstances applicable to the property — including its size, shape, topography, location, or surroundings — strict application of the ordinance would deprive the property of privileges enjoyed by other property of the same classification in the same zoning district. “Location” is its own category in the statute, separate from topography and shape. Staff: This property is zoned R1-8, which requires a minimum 8,000 sq. ft. lot. This lot is over 18,000 sq. ft. in size, more than double the minimum required lot size. The lot is nearly rectangular in shape, consistent with the other lots in the neighborhood. The lot is nearly flat and does not present any impediments to development consistent with code requirements. Construction on rebuilding of this house was completed in July 2025. The existing pool received final inspections in August 2025. There is a current permit application for an adjacent spa and for a shade cover that would cover the south end of the pool and the spa. The current owners purchased the property in September 2025. The house constructed on the lot is essentially in the middle of the lot, similar to the adjacent properties. It is a large, two-story home with a footprint of approximately 5,000 sq ft., resulting in approximately 30% lot coverage. The maximum allowed lot coverage in this district is 35%. The zoning ordinance allows pools within 3' of a rear property line. There are many properties in Fountain Hills with pools that encroach into the standard building setback area. There is an area in excess 1,400 square feet north of the pool open and available for placement of a shade structure that will comply with all setback requirements. Immediately behind this property is a town-owned tract and then the Fort McDowell Yavapai Indian Reservation. Development on this property is unlikely. Finding: Staff does not find any special circumstances or conditions regarding the land, building or use referred to in the application which does not happen to other properties in the district. 2. Such special circumstances are pre-existing and are not created or self-imposed by the owner or appellant. Applicant: The pool here is an existing permitted improvement whose siting predates this application and was not established by the current owner for the purpose of manufacturing a variance. The relevant inquiry is not whether a decision was made at some point in the property's history, but whether this applicant created the constraint to engineer eligibility. We did not. Staff: Staff did not identify any special circumstances that apply to this property; therefore, staff cannot provide a finding to satisfy this provision. The location of a pool in a setback area is not a special circumstance and is a common feature throughout the Town. The Zoning Ordinance allowing pools to encroach into the building setback area does not create a condition that then allows a structure to encroach into that same setback. 3. The strict application of the Zoning Ordinance will deprive such property owner of privileges enjoyed by other property of the same classification in the same zoning district. Staff: Strict application of the Zoning Ordinance will not deprive the property owner of privileges enjoyed by other property owners. There is plenty of room in the rear yard for one or more shade covers. There is the possibility of a cover over a portion of the northern end of the pool. The permit for the spa has not been issued, it could be relocated. There are many other lots in town with pools in the rear setback and none of them have shade structures built in the required setback. Staff finds that this requirement has not been met. 4. Any variance granted will ensure that the adjustment authorized shall not constitute a grant of special privileges inconsistent with the limitations upon other properties in the vicinity and zone in which such property is located. Applicant: The rear setback ordinarily protects a neighbor's light, air, privacy, and views. In our case that interest is not implicated: the rear lot line at 11037 N. Indian Wells Dr. backs to open reserve rather than another residence, so there is no adjacent property whose views, privacy, or use would be affected by the requested encroachment. Shading a pool is an ordinary and common use of residential property in this district, and the requested 15'6" clearance leaves the great majority of the required 30-foot setback intact. The request is limited to the 16'×16' patio cover shown in the application plans and does not change the property's residential use or extend to any other portion of the lot. Staff: Given the lack of identified special circumstances that limit the options of the property owner to use their land, other than the fact the pool existed when they bought the property, granting the requested variance for this lot would be considered a grant of special privilege inconsistent with the limitations placed on other properties. There are 35 lots east of Saguaro from the north side of Niblick Dr. to the north side of Zaharas Dr. Of these, 24 properties have pools. Only three appear to have a shade structure near the pool. All of them meet the setback requirements. Related Ordinance, Policy or Guiding Principle Town Code Section 2A-2-4, Board of Adjustment Duties Town Code Section 2A-2-6, Variances Zoning Ordinance Section 1.12 Definitions, Rear Yard Zoning Ordinance Section 2.07 C Variances Zoning Ordinance Section 5.06 B Yard, Lot, and Area Requirements Zoning Ordinance Section 10.09 Density, Area, Building, and Yard Regulations Arizona Revised Statute 9-462.06 Board of Adjustment Risk Analysis N/A Recommendation(s) by Board(s) or Commission(s) N/A Staff Recommendation(s) Given that staff could not find the justifications necessary to approve a variance, staff recommends denial. Suggested Motion Move to adopt the findings outlined in the staff report and deny the applicant's requested variance. ATTACHMENTS 1. Baca Case Details Map 2. Meyen Final Supplemental Information - Variance Request