Extracted text (via pymupdf_layout)
15090 characters
ITEM 9.a. TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS STAFF REPORT Meeting Date: 10/20/2026 Meeting Type: Town Council Regular Meeting Submitting Department: Development Services Prepared by: John Wesley, Development Services Director Staff Contact Information: Phone: 480-816-5138 Email: jwesley@fountainhillsaz.gov Request to Town Council Regular Meeting (Agenda Language) PUBLIC HEARING, with CONSIDERATION AND POSSIBLE ACTION: Relating to Ordinance 26-12 repealing and replacing Zoning Ordinance Chapter 17, Wireless Telecommunication Towers and Antennas. Staff Summary (background) In their January 2025 meeting, the Town Council directed staff to work with the Planning and Zoning Commission to update all the Town's ordinances and other regulatory documents regarding wireless telecommunications towers and antennas. To help complete this project, with direction from the Town Council, staff entered into a contract with McCollough Law Firm PC to assist staff in the drafting of the updates to the ordinances and associated documents. This firm was selected based on their expertise in this field of law and their responsiveness to working with staff to complete this project in a timely manner. This project involved reviewing and making recommendations for changes to Chapter 17 of the Zoning Ordinance and Articles 16-2 and 16-3 of the Town Code along with the associated documents for small cell facilities in the Town rights-of-way. The Planning and Zoning Commission held a work session on July 28 to review the draft ordinances to amend Chapter 17 and Articles 16-2 and 16-3. Based on the input received at that meeting, the consultant and staff prepared a final draft ordinance amending Zoning Ordinance Chapter 17 for consideration at a public hearing of the Planning and Zoning Commission on September 14, 2026. The ordinance provided to the Commission for their public hearing included responses to comments made by the Commission at their work session as well as addressing comments received from the public following the work session. The consultant and staff have worked to revise Chapter 17 to provide the maximum protection for the town while also complying with legal requirements and providing reasonable means to have adequate wireless communication coverage throughout the Town. Overarching purposes of the update were to: •Preserve local authority to the fullest extent allowed by federal and Arizona law •Protect Fountain Hills' desert character, scenic views, historic resources, residential properties, and neighborhoods •Implement comprehensive permit application requirements and review procedures •Improve transparency, accountability, and defensibility of permitting decisions At the public hearing on September 14, the public and Commissioners expressed strong support for the revised ordinance. Through the discussion, a few additional recommendations were made for inclusion in the ordinance. Those changes have been made and are reflected in the attached ordinance. Attached are two copies of the final draft ordinance. One is a strike-through version of Chapter 17 as presented to the Commission at the public hearing with the changes made based on the recommendation of the Commission and the second version is a clean copy of the ordinance with all the new changes accepted. Also attached is a copy of the strikethrough version of the draft ordinance presented at the July work session. This version provides a review of the changes made to the current Chapter 17. This report provides an overview of the final draft ordinance, including changes made in response to the stipulations included in the motion for approval by the Planning and Zoning Commission. Section 17.01 Purpose, Intent, and Applicability The list of purposes for the ordinance has been expanded to a more comprehensive description of the goals for the ordinance. The intent provisions have been expanded to more fully capture the intent to comply with Federal Communication Commission rules while protecting the Town's natural and cultural resources. This section now expressly states the requirement to comply with radiofrequency exposure guidelines. The applicability section now has a statement that clearly requires existing towers and antennas to comply with the new regulations when they are modified in any manner. Section 17.02 Definitions Over 80 new definitions were added to clarify important legal and technical terms. Two changes made in this section in response to the stipulations of the Planning and Zoning Commission were: • add a definition "Mobile or temporary tower" to help address the comments on temporary towers; and • a change to "Pre-existing towers and pre-existing antennas" to address a concern regarding the potential there are existing towers that the Town may not have documented permits for. Section 17.03 Requirements This section of the ordinance sets out the basic requirements to be followed when making an application for new towers or upgrading existing towers and antennas. Much of Section 17.03 A, General Requirements, has remained unchanged from what was reviewed by the Planning and Zoning Commission. There are, however, a few significant additions to this section compared to the existing ordinance. Those changes include: • Section 17.03 A 3 e i. Removed the language regarding certain types of designs that could be used to camouflage a tower and antennas. The concern was that by stating specific types of camouflage, applicants would design to those choices rather than provide a more site-specific solution. • Section 17.03 A 3 h i. Removed the last sentence regarding using additional palm trees to help screen a tower. This was removed as a companion to the change in A 3 e i regarding specific design solutions. Additional trees may still be required, but it is not limited to palm trees. • To address the topic of facilities that are data only, added Section 17.03 A 3. j. Data-Only and Information Service Facilities. To the maximum extent permitted by federal and state law, any wireless facility used exclusively for the provision of an information service, data collection, telemetry, machine-to-machine communication, sensing, monitoring, or another service that does not constitute a personal wireless service under 47 U.S.C. ss 332(c)(7)(C) or a telecommunications service protected by 47 U.S.C. ss 253 shall be installed underground or flush with grad, including its antenna, antenna equipment and accessory equipment, where technically feasible. An applicant seeking above-ground installation shall demonstrate through clear and convincing technical evidence that underground or flush-to-grade installation would prevent the facility from performing its intended function and that the proposed above-ground installation is the least visually intrusive technically feasible alternative. Nothing in this subsection shall require underground placement to the extent the applicant demonstrates that such requirement is expressly prohibited or preempted by applicable federal or Arizona law. • Section 17.03 A 14 was added to ensure there is parking available around a tower site to provide for maintenance activities. • Section 17.03 A 15, Minimum Height of Antennas, was added to ensure all antennas are placed above head height. • Section 17.03 A 16 was added to clarify regulations regarding fall zones and to ensure that if a tower falls it will not fall on neighboring property or any adjacent public streets or sidewalks. Compared to the current ordinance, a couple of significant changes were made to Section 17.03 B Minimum Setbacks and Separations. Section 17.03 B 2 a currently has a table with setback requirements for towers requiring a separation between 100' and 200' from residential properties. The new ordinance requires all towers to be at least 500' from any residential use or zoning district. There is a provision, however, that the Town Council a reduction down to 300' if the applicant provides information and data showing the goals of the ordinance are better served at the reduced distance. Section 17.03 B 2 b includes a table for separation distances between towers. Table 17.03 B 2 b was amended to increase the separation distance by 500' for most tower heights. The separation distance between towers less than 40' in height was just increased 250'. In the new ordinance the minimum distance between towers will range from 1000' for two towers of less than 40' in height to 2,500' for towers that are 65' tall or taller. Section 17.03 C has two primary changes from the current ordinance. Sec. 17.03 C 1 was amended to require all equipment vaults to be placed underground unless Council approves above-ground equipment placement through good cause shown. At the Planning and Zoning Commission work session, several Commissioners expressed support for requiring a specific type of battery to decrease potential fire hazards. This language was added in Section 17.03 C: 4. Battery Safety. Any battery energy storage or backup power system installed in connection with a PSWF shall utilize lithium ion phosphate (LiFePO4 or LPE) batteries, which are less prone to thermal runaway and fire hazard. All battery systems shall comply with applicable fire, electrical, building, and product-safety codes and standards. Section 17.03 D, Co-location, has remained largely unchanged. A change made to address the stipulations of the Planning and Zoning Commission recommendation was to amend 17.03 B 2 a to address the concern for wireless facility separation from schools and daycare facilities. This will now require wireless facilities to be at least 500' from schools and daycare facilities unless Council approves a reduction down to 300'. Section 17.04 Application Types This section defines what types of applications can be reviewed administratively and which require public review. This section was modified to require all new towers to go through a public review process. A change made to address the stipulations of the Planning and Zoning Commission recommendation was to amend Section 17.04 A 6 to provide more detail on what information is needed for the review and approval of a temporary wireless facility. Section 17.05 Application Submittal, Review, and Processing This section of the ordinance defines what type of information is required for the different application types and the review process that will be followed for administrative and public review applications. Section 17.05 A regarding general application requirements has been significantly modified to increase the General submission requirements. Items 5 - 18, which include things such as fire safety information, visual impact analysis, FCC compliance report, and effective prohibition claims, were all added to the items required. Several changes were made to this section based on feedback received at the Commission work session. Section 17.05 B regarding shot clocks and tolling has remained largely unchanged from the current ordinance. Section 17.05 C has been updated to require some additional information to be submitted with the application. Subsections C 1 h - l are all new. Subsection C 3 b in the new ordinance regarding factual determinations which need to be made as part of the review and approval process is all new. This section requires Council to use factual determinations based on both local zoning requirements and Telecommunications Act of 1996 (TCA) requirements. Section 17.05 C was also expanded to add review items 4, Environmental Impacts; 5, Historic Sites Impacts; 6, Tribal Site Impacts; and 7, Force Majeure. A change to address the stipulations of the Planning and Zoning Commission recommendation was to amend Sec. 17.05 A 11 to increase the time for a balloon test from four hours to eight hours. Section 17.06 Maintenance and Operation This section addresses the ongoing maintenance and operations of a tower, antennas, and the associated equipment. This also includes provisions for the removal of the tower and equipment if the site is abandoned. Section 17.06 A regarding removal of abandoned antennas has been expanded to require a bond for the cost of removal and Section 17.06 B 2 regarding state and federal requirements has been greatly expanded to address excessive radiofrequency (RF) emissions. The following additional sections have been added: • Section 17.06 E, Maintenance. This requires ongoing maintenance of the tower and tower site and includes a requirement for a maintenance bond the Town can call if needed to perform needed maintenance. • Section 17.06 F, Maintenance Contact Information. This has been added in response to comments about ensuring ongoing maintenance. This will ensure the Town has a contact for any required maintenance issues. • Section 17.06 G, Indemnity and Liability for damages. • Section 17.06 H Certificate of Insurance required. This section outlines in detail the insurance requirements needed for the installation and operation of a wireless communications tower. • Section 17.06 I, ADA Accommodations. • Section 17.06 J, Decommissioning and Reclamation Plan. This section sets standards for the restoration of a site if a tower is decommissioned and removed. Changes to address the stipulations of the Planning and Zoning Commission include: • Amending Sec. 17.06 A 2 regarding the amount of the bond required. The revised language requires the estimate to be approved by a certified engineer and that the bond be 125% of the estimate. • Amending Sections 17.06 B 2 b and 17.06 B 3 to provide more direction and a cure period when addressing issues of excessive RF emissions. • Amending Sec. 17.06 E to provide the requirements for the required maintenance bond for wireless facilities. Section 17.07 Nonconforming Uses This section remains largely unchanged. Section 17.08 Retention of Consultants This is a new section which provides the process for the Town to hire consultants to help administer the requirements of the ordinance. Related Ordinance, Policy or Guiding Principle N/A Risk Analysis N/A Recommendation(s) by Board(s) or Commission(s) The Planning and Zoning Commission has been working on the review and update to this ordinance and related ordinances and requirements since March 2025. They have reviewed the ordinance at multiple meetings, including two sessions with the consultant hired by the Council to complete the ordinance amendments. The Commission held a public hearing on September 14, 2026, to receive comments from the public regarding the proposed revisions. At that meeting, the Commission voted 7-0 to forward a recommendation for approval to the Council with five stipulations. Each of those stipulations has been address with the revised ordinance attached to this report. Staff Recommendation(s) Staff recommends adoption of Ordinance 26-12. Suggested Motion MOVE TO approve Ordinance 26-12. FISCAL IMPACT Fiscal Impact: N/A Budget Reference: N/A Funding Source: N/A ATTACHMENTS 1. Ordinance 26-12 Chapter 17 2. Ch 17_Sep 14 P&Z Stipulations 3. Draft Chapter 17 for P&Z study session with strikethrough