Extracted text (via pymupdf_layout)
34627 characters
DESIGN REVIEW NARRATIVE GATEWAY CROSSING (RETAIL SHOPS, HOTELS, & LARGE COMMERCIAL DEVELOPMENT WITH SERVICE - GAS – STATION) CASE NO.: DRB25-00684 (COMPANION CASES: ANX25-00682 / ZON25-00660) LOCATION: SOUTHWEST CORNER OF WILLIAMS FIELD ROAD AND STATE ROUTE 24 (SR-24) (PARCEL NUMBERS: 313-25-859Z AND A PORTION OF 313-25-859Y) SUBMITTED: AUGUST 19, 2025 2ND SUBMITTAL: NOVEMBER 14, 2025 3RD SUBMITTAL: APRIL 8, 2026 4TH SUBMITTAL: JULY 13, 2026 5TH SUBMITTAL: AUGUST 31, 2026 Overview Pacific Proving, LLC, the property owner, in collaboration with Vestar are planning to develop approximately 37-acres located at the southwest corner of Williams Field Road and State Route 24 (“SR-24”) (the “Property”) for a mixed-use retail/quick service restaurants/hotels’ development (“Gateway Crossing”). The Property encompasses portions of Maricopa County Assessor’s Parcel Numbers: 313-25-961 & 313-25-859P. It is worth noting that there are approximately 4-acres of the Property (i.e., Parcel Number: 313-25-859P) that are in Maricopa County and zoned Maricopa County IND- 2 (Light Industrial Zoning District), which will need to be annexed into the City of Mesa. A concurrent annexation request will be processed for the entire parcel with this application request. Upon annexation the City of Mesa will assign a zoning designation of Light Industrial (“LI”) that will be applied to the annexed property, which is consistent with prior annexation cases approved in the area and comparable to the existing County zoning designation of IND-2 (Light Industrial Zoning District). It is worth noting that most of the Property is a part of what was the original zoned in 2021 (ZON20-00846) along with an approved site plan and design review approval (DRB20-00679) for the “Legacy Sports Family and Entertainment Park” (currently known as the “Arizona Athletic Grounds”). The majority of the Property is currently zoned Light Industrial (LI), within Airfield Overflight Area-2 (“AOA-2”), and has an approved Special Use Permit (“SUP”) for the following: (1) reduction in the number of required vehicular parking spaces from 3,532 to 2,625 spaces and reduction in the number of required bicycle parking spaces from 202 to 160 spaces; and (2) increase to the allowed maximum height in the Airfield Overflight Area (AOA) designation on the property from 40-feet to 58-feet for proposed buildings within the development and 99-feet for proposed lighting structures. The initial phase of Arizona Athletic Grounds is currently built and operating, the remaining phases/expansion are no longer occurring, and the Property is being repositioned to allow the development of this mixed-use development to support a variety of the existing uses in the area (e.g., residential areas north and east; industrial south and west; Arizona Athletic Grounds, and Mesa Gateway Airport – the second busiest airport serving the Greater Phoenix metro region) and the future developments planned/zoned in the immediate area. Additionally, the Property has convenient access to the nearby State Route 24 freeway extension and Loop 202 freeway, which are important regional transportation corridors to the burgeoning East Valley and beyond. The City of Mesa 2050 General Plan currently designates the Property as “Regional Center” which supports the proposed development plan. City of Mesa 2050 General Plan “Regional Center” Description. Of note from the above description, Regional Centers (emphasis added): “Regional Centers are typically developed with a common design theme or character. The densities, building heights, and overall character of a Regional Center will depend on its location; however, compared to other GATEWAY CROSSING DESIGN REVIEW NARRATIVE (RETAIL SHOPS, HOTELS, & LARGE COMMERCIAL DEVELOPMENT WITH SERVICE - GAS – STATION) Page 2 of 15 commercial centers, Regional Centers will have the highest intensity and feature the largest scale of development.” The Property is also located within the Mesa Gateway Strategic Development Plan (the “GSDP”), specifically the Airport/Campus. Per the GSDP, the Airport/Campus District is generally the area encompassing the ASU Polytechnic/Chandler-Gilbert Community College Campus, the Mesa Gateway Airport, and the area immediately outside the airport’s future main terminal. The Property is envisioned as a mixed-use district compatible with increasing over-flight activities associated with airport. The proposed development plan for the Property meets the intent of the GSDP as well as being compatible with Mesa Gateway Airport’s operations. The development plan for the Property provides opportunities and support for travelers and visitors to the area consistent with the Airport/Campus District. The proposed development will provide easy accommodations/services within walking distance for those visiting the Arizona Athletic Grounds as well as residential communities across the freeway. The proposed development will be a major contributor to the realization of the vision embodied within the Airport/Campus District. As noted previously, the Property is located within Airfield Overflight Area Two (AOA- 2), due to its general proximity to the Mesa Gateway Airport. The purpose of the Airfield Overlay District is to acknowledge the proximity of the airport, the potential uses that should be located close to the airport, the impacts from the airport, and mitigating those impacts from the airport. Future uses encouraged by the airport, specifically for this Property, are industrial and commercial uses, which are more compatible with airport operations. The proposed uses are optimal/allowed (i.e., the hotels and large retail user with approved CUP’s) within the AOA-2 and, as such, the development plan fits within the Airfield Overflight Area. Finally, according to Section 11-7-1(B)(2) of the City of Mesa’s Zoning Ordinance, the purpose of the LI zoning district is to provide areas for limited manufacturing and processing, wholesaling, research, warehousing, and distribution activities which take place in enclosed buildings. However, the zoning district also provides a full range of commercial activities, generally on a limited scale, including high-impact commercial uses, outdoor display, and outdoor sales. Hotels and retail uses are permitted within the LI district. Specifically, the proposed development of two (2) hotels, a large (anchor) retail user with a separate service station (i.e., a gas station) located by the Arizona Athletic Grounds, and a mix of smaller commercial/retail/quick service restaurants (i.e., Large Commercial Development) complement and fit the LI zoning district/context of the area. The Requests Note: The following requests are being processed concurrently with this Design Review application. They are: (1) Council Use Permits for a large commercial GATEWAY CROSSING DESIGN REVIEW NARRATIVE (RETAIL SHOPS, HOTELS, & LARGE COMMERCIAL DEVELOPMENT WITH SERVICE - GAS – STATION) Page 3 of 15 development in LI and hotels when in AOA-2; (2) Special Use Permits for a maximum height allowance of 65-feet for each of the hotels and a service station accessory to the large retail user; (3) Master Site Plan (Note: A waiver for the quick service restaurants or the drive-thrus was approved by the City of Mesa on September 23, 2025); (4) Administrative Use Permit to exceed required parking on-site by more than 125%; (5) A Comprehensive Sign Plan; (6) Minor Subdivision Plat, and (7) Annexation of approximately 4-acres (Parcel Number: 313-25-859P). With that said, the Design Review requests are for a large retail user with a separate service (gas) station located by the Arizona Athletic Grounds, the retail shops buildings, and the two (2) hotels proposed (i.e., Large Commercial Development). Note: The hotels and large retail user are also seeking alternative design compliance requests submitted separately. The overall proposed Master Site Plan provides for the following: Two (2) hotels (±212 rooms, 55-feet maximum height). Note: We are seeking a building height of 65-feet maximum to provide for any dimensional changes to the building height for the end user(s) (e.g., floorplate heights/number of floors, rooftop auxiliary space/architectural features, etc.) A large retail (anchor) user at ±164,000 sq. ft., 45-feet maximum height along with a separate ancillary service station (gas station). Two (2) multi-tenant retail (shop) buildings (±28,000 sq. ft. total). Two (2) quick service restaurants (i.e., drive-thrus) along Williams Field Road, conceptual site layouts only. Final design layout/architecture of each to be approved with the individual end user via separate review process later by the City of Mesa. Direct/signalized access to Williams Field Road and the Arizona Athletic Grounds. A buffer/transition to State Route 24 freeway/SRP electrical easement (i.e., the power poles) with easy access to the regional transportation corridors. All the proposed uses fit well within the City of Mesa General Plan, AOA-2, Arizona Athletic Grounds, the freeway, and within the overall context of the larger area. Upon approval of these requests the Property will be ready for future construction of cohesive, compatible, well-designed, and needed mixed-use retail/quick service restaurants/hotels’ development. GATEWAY CROSSING DESIGN REVIEW NARRATIVE (RETAIL SHOPS, HOTELS, & LARGE COMMERCIAL DEVELOPMENT WITH SERVICE - GAS – STATION) Page 4 of 15 The proposed Design Review package will begin the process of developing the mixed- use development plan/vision. The Design Review Criteria Mesa Zoning Ordinance Section 11-71-6 sets forth the following review criteria as outlined below. 1. The project is consistent with: a. Applicable goals, objectives and policies of the general plan and any applicable sub-area or neighborhood area plans; b. All of the development standards of this Ordinance; c. Other adopted Council policies, as may be applicable; and d. Any specific conditions of approval placed on the zoning of the property. Responses to 1a.-1d: The proposed mixed-use development directly aligns with City of Mesa 2050 General Plan designation of “Regional Center” as noted below (emphasis added). “Regional Centers are typically developed with a common design theme or character. The densities, building heights, and overall character of a Regional Center will depend on its location; however, compared to other commercial centers, Regional Centers will have the highest intensity and feature the largest scale of development.” The Property is also located within the Mesa Gateway Strategic Development Plan, specifically the Airport/Campus District. Per the Airport/Campus District, the Property is envisioned as a mixed-use district compatible with increasing over-flight activities associated with airport. The proposed mixed-use development meets the intent of the Airport/Campus District as well as being compatible with Mesa Gateway Airport’s operations. As noted, the Property is located within Airfield Overflight Area Two (AOA- 2). Future uses encouraged by the airport, specifically for this Property, are industrial and commercial uses compatible with airport operations. The proposed uses are optimal/allowed (i.e., the hotels and large retail user with approved CUP’s) within the AOA-2 and fits within the Airfield Overflight Area. GATEWAY CROSSING DESIGN REVIEW NARRATIVE (RETAIL SHOPS, HOTELS, & LARGE COMMERCIAL DEVELOPMENT WITH SERVICE - GAS – STATION) Page 5 of 15 Finally, according to Section 11-7-1(B)(2) of the City of Mesa’s Zoning Ordinance, the LI zoning district allows the full range of commercial activities, including high-impact commercial uses, outdoor display, and outdoor sales. Hotels and retail uses are permitted within the LI district. The proposed development of two (2) hotels, a large (anchor) retail user with a separate service station (i.e., a gas station) located by the Arizona Athletic Grounds, and a mix of smaller commercial/retail/quick service restaurants (i.e., Large Commercial Development) complement and fit the LI zoning district/overall context of the area. In summary, the proposed mixed-use development is consistent with the City’s General Plan and the zoning of nearby properties. Gateway Crossing (i.e., the mixed-use development plan) is well-suited for the immediate area and compatible with planned and existing developments. The Property is ideally located east of Mesa Gateway Airport – the second major airport serving the Greater Phoenix metro region – and within easy access to the nearby State Route 24 freeway extension and Loop 202 freeway, which are important regional transportation corridors. The proposed uses are consistent with the desired land uses for the area as identified in the City’s planning and policy documents, which include evolving/compatible industrial, retail/commercial, employment, support services, and tourism/hospitality uses. The proposal is compatible with the increasing over-flight activity of the adjacent airport. Gateway Crossing will deliver a compatible mix of hospitality, fueling (gas), services, and commercial/restaurant uses consistent and conforming with the adopted General Plan, sub-area plan, and consistent with the development standards City of Mesa’s Zoning Ordinance/guidelines. 2. The overall design of the project including its scale, massing, site plan, exterior design, and landscaping will enhance the appearance and features of the project site, the street type, and surrounding natural and built environment. Response: The massing and scale of the buildings will be broken up using wall texture, color, material changes, shadow lines, roof plan changes/overhangs, and other façade treatments. The buildings massing and scale are compatible with existing and anticipated developments in the area which are, currently, predominately industrial and manufacturing in nature and the abutting Arizona Athletic Grounds/freeway/SRP power poles, which includes enhanced building/structure heights. GATEWAY CROSSING DESIGN REVIEW NARRATIVE (RETAIL SHOPS, HOTELS, & LARGE COMMERCIAL DEVELOPMENT WITH SERVICE - GAS – STATION) Page 6 of 15 The proposed architectural vernacular provides for ample articulation along the façades. Articulation includes the suite entries, windows, changes in tonality and pattern, and the provision of building height/roof changes (appropriately located) to enhance the visual overall appeal of the buildings/pedestrian spaces/connections. Articulation provides for added visual interest and a design theme for future users to utilize. The design team has worked diligently to ensure that there are visual elements of interest via colors, materials and/or texture, windows, etc. along the façades. The streetscape and onsite landscaping will blend naturally. Proposed landscape standards for the development will equal or exceed the size and quantities of plant material referenced in Chapter 11, Section 33 of the Mesa Zoning Ordinance. The proposed landscape theme has been prepared as a “Preliminary Landscape Plan” that illustrates the layout, quantities, and sizes of plant material. The landscape plan has been prepared to provide an appropriate level of detail to illustrate the landscape theme for the common areas and the required foundation landscape. Placement and massing are intended to show compatibility with the architectural design and the uses proposed as well as for pedestrian comfort. The goals for the landscaping include the following: Create an attractive low water landscape design that presents a lush and distinctive landscape, enhancing the arterial frontages and screening. Allow for the spacing and concentration of required quantities to create view corridors into the Property and at strategic locations based on the location’s architectural features. Where public viewing or utilitarian uses need to be screened, screen walls/fencing and a mix of deciduous and non-deciduous plant materials are used. Design hardscape features and site furniture within the common open space areas that compliment with the proposed architecture/setting envisioned (i.e., communal outdoor play areas/seating) in a meaningful and complementary manner. Design the landscaping within the common areas and beyond to make the pedestrian network visible and convenient with as much shade/comfort as possible. GATEWAY CROSSING DESIGN REVIEW NARRATIVE (RETAIL SHOPS, HOTELS, & LARGE COMMERCIAL DEVELOPMENT WITH SERVICE - GAS – STATION) Page 7 of 15 Plant material selected for color, texture, scale, and seasonal flowering placed in a thematic pattern can reinforce the landscape theme throughout. The common/amenity areas will be designed and arranged as usable, functional spaces and be furnished with shaded and open-air eating, seating, and gathering amenities. Building/site lighting will also comply with Ordinance Section 11-30-5 and the fixture design will complement the architectural theme. The building entry areas will be accentuated with accent lighting to help create a focal point. Energy efficient lighting, such as LED, will be used throughout the development and glare will be minimized using soft or reflected lighting. Good and proper lighting design helps to elevate the architecture/landscaping/pedestrian experience as well as security. Primary pedestrian circulation includes a 6’ wide minimum sidewalk with enhanced landscaping and additional trees to provide more inviting, cooler, shaded walkways. The primary pedestrian pathway connects the building entries to the closest public sidewalk with public plazas placed in key locations across the center. A secondary sidewalk connection will have a minimum 5’ width with smaller bushes and plants. Secondary circulation provides additional access points to the building entrances. Creating a cohesive site-wide pedestrian circulation network. The proposed routes provide the shortest, safest pathways, connecting the main building entries to the primary pedestrian circulation. Capitalizing the use of the shadier pedestrian friendly primary circulation. A clear pedestrian hierarchy has been considered for this project which incorporates a primary pedestrian pathway with enhanced planting with additional shade trees and wider sidewalks. Circulation clearly distinguishes safe and inviting zones for pedestrians from the automobile travel zones. Thus, the overall design will enhance the appearance and features both onsite and offsite for the betterment of the surrounding environment. 3. The overall design will create a distinctive and appealing community by providing architectural interest in areas visible from streets, sidewalks, and public areas. Response: The overall design will contribute to the creation of an inviting and interesting mixed-use (regional) development. The development takes GATEWAY CROSSING DESIGN REVIEW NARRATIVE (RETAIL SHOPS, HOTELS, & LARGE COMMERCIAL DEVELOPMENT WITH SERVICE - GAS – STATION) Page 8 of 15 into context its surroundings by articulating and orienting the building entrances towards more prominent/visible areas and locating loading and parking areas between, rear of the Property, or behind the buildings, if possible. In addition, the buildings designs create attractive street frontage by providing direct pedestrian connections/amenities (i.e., node area by the hotels) from the street, enhanced building design, plenty of open landscaped areas/entry enhancements that create an elevate/unique (for the area) experience. 4. The project site plan is appropriate to the function of the project and will provide a suitable environment for occupants, visitors, and the general community. Response: Buildings have been placed on the site in a coordinated manner to provide order, enhanced pedestrian circulation, comfort/interest for both vehicles/pedestrians traversing the Property, and a “sense of place” for the community. Outdoor public spaces for sitting, eating, gathering, etc. are strategically provided throughout and where appropriate. The large retail user is strategically located further in and away from Williams Field Road or less visually appealing areas of the Property (e.g., by the SRP power poles, closer to industrial developments, by the freeway, etc.). By locating the large commercial development building away from and abutting/buffering the industrial projects helps support/minimize impacts with the smaller users proposed within the development and enhances the streetscape. The proposed development provides for a sufficient level of vehicle parking spaces to accommodate the large commercial development users’ needs as well as the retail shops/quick service restaurants/hotels. Moreover, bicycle parking spaces for employees as well as visitors are provided as an additional option to driving. Pedestrian connections/circulation are designed (as much as possible) to separate car traffic and provide a safe environment for both cars and pedestrians. The proposed entry drive areas will be enhanced with ornamental landscaping and/or decorative/stamped paving/asphalt to emphasize these highly traveled access points/corridors and to slow traffic. Specifically, primary pedestrian circulation includes a 6’ wide minimum sidewalk with enhanced landscaping and additional trees to provide more inviting, cooler, shaded walkways. The primary pedestrian pathway connects the building entries to the closest public sidewalk with public plazas placed in key locations across the center. A secondary sidewalk connection will have a minimum 5’ width with smaller bushes and plants. GATEWAY CROSSING DESIGN REVIEW NARRATIVE (RETAIL SHOPS, HOTELS, & LARGE COMMERCIAL DEVELOPMENT WITH SERVICE - GAS – STATION) Page 9 of 15 Secondary circulation provides additional access points to the building entrances. Creating a cohesive site-wide pedestrian circulation network. The proposed routes provide the shortest, safest pathways, connecting the main building entries to the primary pedestrian circulation. Capitalizing the use of the shadier pedestrian friendly primary circulation. A clear pedestrian hierarchy has been considered for this project which incorporates a primary pedestrian pathway with enhanced planting with additional shade trees and wider sidewalks. Circulation clearly distinguishes safe and inviting zones for pedestrians from the automobile travel zones. 5. Project details, colors, materials, and landscaping, are internally consistent, fully integrated with one another, and used in a manner that is visually consistent with the proposed architectural design and creates a safe, attractive, and inviting environment at the ground floor of buildings on sides used by the public. Response: The proposed robust building architecture, colors/materials, lighting, and landscaping design provides a successful combination of aesthetics and function. These elements provide interest, safety, etc. for both vehicles and pedestrians alike. The buildings have both horizontal and vertical delineations to provide visual interest. Windows, rooflines, overhangs/structures, and doors are strategically provided to assist in breaking down the mass and scale, where necessary, and identifying entrances/amenities/visual interest. The proposed landscape theme has been prepared to illustrate the layout, quantities, and sizes of plant material. The landscape plan has been prepared to provide a level of detail to illustrate the landscape theme for the common open space areas and the foundation base landscaping. Placement and massing are intended to show compatibility with the proposed overall architectural design theme. 6. The project is compatible with neighboring development by avoiding big differences in building scale and character between developments on adjoining lots in the same zoning district and providing a harmonious transition in scale and character between different districts. Response: The proposed mixed-use development is consistent with and compatible with the larger buildings built or planned to be built in the area. The GATEWAY CROSSING DESIGN REVIEW NARRATIVE (RETAIL SHOPS, HOTELS, & LARGE COMMERCIAL DEVELOPMENT WITH SERVICE - GAS – STATION) Page 10 of 15 massing and scale provide a transition (i.e., character change) between Arizona Athletic Grounds’ large buildings west and the industrial and manufacturing buildings (over 1-million sq. ft.) being built south of the Property. Moreover, the freeway and SRP power poles along the Property’s east side creates a transitional edge to the residential homes further east/north, while also maintaining easy accessibility for the end users. Moreover, the proposed buildings abut the freeway and SRP power poles (100-150 feet in height) enhancing the need for height (visibility). The proposed building heights are consistent with the airport’s allowance (200-feet), the existing Arizona Athletic Grounds approved heights (58- feet and 99-feet), as well as surrounding industrial buildings (+60-feet). The proposed development design and landscape theme are compatible with and will blend/transition well with those existing/future developments occurring in the area (as well as the residential areas further east) while also providing a “sense of place” for the community. 7. The project contributes to the creation of a visually interesting built environment that includes a variety of building styles and designs with well-articulated structures that present well designed building facades on all sides, rooflines, and building heights within a unifying context that encourages increased pedestrian activity and promotes compatibility among neighboring land uses within the same or different districts. Response: The overall design provides architectural interest and variety that relate to the human scale in the following ways. Changes in plane - As identified on the elevations and on the building plans with enlarged plan details/foundation landscaping. Recessed entries, open space areas, overhangs/structures, etc. also create additional visual depth/interest. Change in texture - Through use of materials, patterns, and colors. Pattern - Reveals are utilized to significantly break up large wall expanses. Windows – Use of glass strategically throughout and at focal/entry points. The architecture is designed to be visually interesting and well-articulated within a unifying context. The architecture along with the site design GATEWAY CROSSING DESIGN REVIEW NARRATIVE (RETAIL SHOPS, HOTELS, & LARGE COMMERCIAL DEVELOPMENT WITH SERVICE - GAS – STATION) Page 11 of 15 elements will increase pedestrian activity. Pedestrian connections/circulation are designed (as much as possible) to separate car traffic and provide a safe environment for both cars and pedestrians. The proposed entry drive areas will be enhanced with ornamental landscaping and/or decorative/stamped paving/asphalt to emphasize these highly traveled access points/corridors and to slow traffic. Primary pedestrian circulation includes a 6’ wide minimum sidewalk with enhanced landscaping and additional trees to provide more inviting, cooler, shaded walkways. The primary pedestrian pathway connects the building entries to the closest public sidewalk with public plazas placed in key locations across the center. A secondary sidewalk connection will have a minimum 5’ width with smaller bushes and plants. Secondary circulation provides additional access points to the building entrances. Creating a cohesive site-wide pedestrian circulation network. The proposed routes provide the shortest, safest pathways, connecting the main building entries to the primary pedestrian circulation. Capitalizing the use of the shadier pedestrian friendly primary circulation. A clear pedestrian hierarchy has been considered for this project which incorporates a primary pedestrian pathway with enhanced planting with additional shade trees and wider sidewalks. Circulation clearly distinguishes safe and inviting zones for pedestrians from the automobile travel zones. Suffice to say, the proposed Gateway Crossing works with, and addresses/enhances, the site’s impediments/opportunities effectively and is compatible with the zoning district, and the surrounding area. 8. The project creates visual variety and relief in buildings and avoids a large-scale, bulky, or box-like appearance. Response: The hotels and large commercial development’s exterior wall design is concrete construction, with semi-uninterrupted volumes, with focus on the corners of the building for the suite entry points. Main entry points have identifiable design/attributes. The use of texture, color, material changes, glass, shadow lines, and other façade treatments will be used to add visual interest and avoid monotonous facades. Building facades and entries on the short sides are oriented towards, as much as possible, the internal private drives, providing easily recognizable entry areas and providing a more attractive look/pedestrian focus. Additionally, foundation landscaping, special paving, lighting in the parking lot areas, and along pedestrian walkways will enhance the GATEWAY CROSSING DESIGN REVIEW NARRATIVE (RETAIL SHOPS, HOTELS, & LARGE COMMERCIAL DEVELOPMENT WITH SERVICE - GAS – STATION) Page 12 of 15 architectural features of the building structures and reinforce design concepts/pedestrian corridors. The building massing and scale for the smaller retail shops is compatible with existing and anticipated developments in the area across Williams Field Road and the residential developments east. 9. The streetscapes, including street trees, lighting, and pedestrian furniture, are consistent with the character of activity centers, commercial districts and nearby residential neighborhoods. Response: Enhanced landscaping, buffering, and architectural quality along Williams Field Road will contribute to an attractive and cohesive streetscape environment. The development plan is designed to integrate seamlessly with nearby developments, reinforce the area’s identity as a destination, and introduce uses that are less sensitive to overflight impacts while also servicing the area/nearby residential neighborhoods. 10. Street frontages are attractive and interesting for pedestrians and provide for greater safety by allowing for surveillance of the street by people inside buildings and elsewhere. Response: The landscape design will create an attractive street frontage along Williams Field Road. The unique constraints of the site being within a predominately industrial and manufacturing area, abutting Arizona Athletic Grounds, freeway, and SRP power poles creates challenges. However, the design team was able to provide decorative paving, enhanced landscaping, interesting pedestrian scaled architecture that provides a softer “edge” and transition along the streetscape as well as onsite. The proposed mixed-use development plan avoids creating a sterile/utilitarian environment and works to provide (to the best of its abilities) visual interest/surveillance, pedestrian safety, and overall a safe circulation network both internally and externally. 11. The proposed landscaping plan is suitable for the type of project and site conditions and will improve the appearance of the community by enhancing the building and site design; and the landscape plan incorporates plant materials that are drought-tolerant, will minimize water usage, and are compatible with Mesa's climate. GATEWAY CROSSING DESIGN REVIEW NARRATIVE (RETAIL SHOPS, HOTELS, & LARGE COMMERCIAL DEVELOPMENT WITH SERVICE - GAS – STATION) Page 13 of 15 Response: Landscaping will consist of all Low Water Use Plant Materials. A lush landscape appearance will be achieved through the careful placement of colorful shrubs and flowering ground covers. The landscape design is a combination of formal and semi-formal masses of singular plants in rows with colorful accent plants that will look good year-round and create a dynamic landscape theme. The development proposal features well- landscaped parking areas to create a shaded pedestrian friendly atmosphere. All parking areas include planted landscape islands to add visual appeal and breakup the pavement. Thus, the impression is a well- designed, lush, and interesting/biodiverse landscape environment. 12. The project has been designed to be energy efficient including, but not limited to, building siting, and landscape design. The project also mitigates the effects of solar exposure for users and pedestrians. For purposes of this criterion, buildings that meet environmental standards such as LEED™, Green Globes, or equivalent third-party certification are considered to be energy efficient. Response: The buildings are designed to provide some flexibility. However, the site lends itself nicely to allowing a north/south orientation, which is optimal in hot climates to minimize exposure along the hottest east/west elevations. Through this orientation areas can also be screened internally, somewhat, by the buildings themselves, which allows for shade/cooling for pedestrians. The proposed landscape design provides screening, visual interest and shade to the site using low water use desert adapted planting material and is compliant with city of Mesa code requirements, ADA requirements, and (where possible) crime prevention through environmental design guidelines. As a result of the above, the buildings and landscaping will be a successful combination of both aesthetics and function, providing interest for vehicles and pedestrians on the street and the users of all the adjacent properties. Conclusion The design team has used a combination of design characteristics (i.e., form, color, texture, landscaping, and materials) to provide enhanced building/site visual interest and appropriate scale, where possible. The proposed Gateway Crossing’s overall GATEWAY CROSSING DESIGN REVIEW NARRATIVE (RETAIL SHOPS, HOTELS, & LARGE COMMERCIAL DEVELOPMENT WITH SERVICE - GAS – STATION) Page 14 of 15 design is appropriate for the area and consistent with prior approvals as well as provides the necessary flexibility needed for current/future end-users. Special attention to screening, building placement, vehicular access along with unique and interesting architectural features/open spaces were primary design objectives when developing the design program that can last or be modified to maintain the quality of the development vision. GATEWAY CROSSING DESIGN REVIEW NARRATIVE (RETAIL SHOPS, HOTELS, & LARGE COMMERCIAL DEVELOPMENT WITH SERVICE - GAS – STATION) Page 15 of 15