Project Narrative
City of Mesa — Planning and Zoning Board - Public Hearing (2026-10-28)
Extracted text (via pymupdf_layout)
13296 characters
VIEW 202 MULTIFAMILY REZONE (ZON26-00126 and GPA26-00248) Mesa, Arizona 21.62 acres Rezone and Minor General Plan Amendment Narrative Submitted by: Sean Lake/Vanessa MacDonald Pew & Lake, PLC 1744 South Val Vista Drive, Suite 217 Mesa, AZ 85204 480-461-4670 On behalf of: Sunbelt Investments Holdings, Inc. Submitted to: The City of Mesa Planning & Zoning Division September 25, 2026 Table of Contents Introduction ..................................................................................................................... 3 Existing Land Use Designations, Zoning and Uses ......................................................... 3 Surrounding Context ....................................................................................................... 5 Requests ......................................................................................................................... 6 Proposed Land Use and Zoning ...................................................................................... 6 Proposed General Plan Amendment ............................................................................... 8 General Plan Analysis ..................................................................................................... 8 Council Use Permit (CUP) Analysis................................................................................. 9 Conclusion .................................................................................................................... 11 Introduction Pew & Lake, PLC (the “Applicant”) on behalf of Sunbelt Investment Holdings, Inc., (“Sunbelt”), is pleased to submit this project narrative to the City of Mesa (the “City”) for a request for a Rezone and General Plan amendment on nearly 22 acres of property located at the southwest corner of Starfire Avenue and Ellsworth Road (the “Property”). The Property is shown below and is comprised of two parcels known as Maricopa County Assessor parcel numbers 304-31-045A and 304-31-045B. The boundary of the entire parcel is shown below, outlined in red. It is Sunbelt’s desire to ultimately develop this property in a manner that is compatible with the existing and proposed uses in the immediate vicinity. Existing Land Use Designations, Zoning and Uses As shown in the graphics on the next page, the Property (outlined in red) has a Land Use placetype of Urban Residential and is surrounded by land with a Regional Employment Center placetype. City of Mesa General Plan 2050 Existing Land Use Map The vacant Property is split between two zoning districts: 17.5 acres is currently zoned Multiple Residence-4 (RM-4) and slightly over 4 acres is zoned Limited Commercial (LC), as shown in the graphic on the following page. The Property is also subject to a Planned Area Development (PAD) Overlay. The PAD applicable to the Property was approved in June of 2020 in Ordinance No. 5575 and is called the Ellsworth & Point 22 PAD. City of Mesa Existing Zoning Map Surrounding Context As shown in the graphic below, the Property has frontage along Ellsworth Road and is adjacent to several existing industrial buildings. North of the Property is Super Radiator Coils, an engineering and production company specializing in heat transfer components, located in the Warner Gateway 202 light industrial development. To the west of the Property are two industrial buildings that serve Safelite Auto Glass, a moving and storage company, and a distributor of water treatment chemicals. As development has occurred in this area since the zoning was approved in 2020, it has become apparent that the properties west of Ellsworth Road are most appropriate for industrial and commercial development, while the properties east of Ellsworth Road, in the Eastmark community, are appropriate for residential and neighborhood-serving uses. Surrounding Context and Uses Requests The specific request to the City of Mesa is for approval of the following: • A Rezone of 17.08 acres of property to Light Industrial, • A Rezone of 4.54 acres of property to Limited Commercial, and • A Council Use Permit (CUP) to allow a large format retailer in the LI zoning district. Proposed Land Use and Zoning Sunbelt is interested in removing the multifamily entitlements on this property to allow it to develop uses that are consistent with other existing and approved uses in the immediate vicinity. To allow for the development of uses that are marketable, viable and profitable, Sunbelt is seeking Light Industrial (LI) and Limited Commercial (LC) zoning on the Property, shown in a preliminary configuration depicted below. Proposed Zoning Additionally, to further enhance the flexibility of development potential, we will be seeking a Council Use Permit (CUP) to allow for a Large Commercial Development in the LI zoning district. A Large Commercial development is defined in the zoning ordinance as a single building over 25,000 square feet, or four or more individual buildings that combined, have over 25,000 square feet. The required criteria for approval of a CUP is discussed later in this narrative. Finally, these properties will still be required to comply with the Ellsworth & Point 22 Design Guidelines. Future Design Review approvals will use the Guidelines as the basis on which future development will be approved. Proposed General Plan Amendment To affect these zoning changes, a minor General Plan Amendment is also required. The General Plan land use placetype most appropriate for the uses envisioned on this property is Local Employment Center and is depicted below. Proposed General Plan Placetype General Plan Analysis The proposed Local Employment Center placetype includes Retail, Office, Medical Facilities and Light Industrial as Principal Land Uses. Supporting Land Uses include Public Facilities and Easting/Drinking Establishments. Local Employment Centers are characterized by a variety of low intensity business operations that don’t include residential uses but are compatible with them. Typical uses include offices, medical facilities, research and development centers, and other small-scale employment-focused activities. Local Employment Centers generate low to moderate traffic volumes and are often found along collector or arterial streets. Many times, a Local Employment Center will have a business park-like setting and incorporate elements that minimize negative impacts on surrounding properties. By creating more Light Industrial property at this location, and maintaining commercial opportunities along the arterial frontage, Sunbelt will be able to complete the pattern of development already established on the south side of Starfire Avenue, while reconfiguring the size of the commercial property along Ellsworth to create more marketable opportunities for commercial users. The existing residential zoning and General Plan designations on this property have proven to be inappropriate, particularly as the surrounding properties have developed. It has become abundantly clear to Sunbelt, surrounding property owners and City Staff that residential development at this location is not viable, and would not provide a livable residential environment for future residents, sandwiched in between industrial buildings, and limited commercial uses. Successful development depends on the ability to objectively evaluate a real estate portfolio, and pivot from pre-conceived ideas to more realistic designations. With this minor General Plan Amendment request, Sunbelt is retooling its offerings in this area to respond to market demands and provide opportunities for this area to develop in a way that will advance the City’s vision and expectations. Council Use Permit (CUP) Analysis As shown in Table 11-7-2 of the Mesa Zoning Ordinance, a Large Commercial Development proposed to be located in the Light Industrial zoning district requires approval of a Council Use Permit. While a specific, large format commercial user hasn’t been identified, it is easy to evaluate the standard CUP criteria against the operating characteristics of typical large-format users. Typical users include Costco, Sam’s Club, grocery stores and fitness centers. Pursuant to City of Mesa Zoning Ordinance Section 11-70-6(D), prior to approval of a Council Use Permit, the City Council must determine that a project meets certain criteria. Each criterion is shown below in italics, with the way in which this proposed CUP meets each one in bold text. 1. Approval of the proposed project will advance the goals and objectives of and is consistent with the policies of the General Plan and any other applicable City plan and/or policies. RESPONSE: As previously noted, the removal of this project from a residential land use placetype is consistent with the City’s vision for this area. The proposed Local Employment placetype will complete the pattern of Land Use designations west of Ellsworth Road and will allow for further industrial development of the property, or a large format commercial use. By granting the requested CUP, for a large commercial development at this location, Sunbelt will retain maximum flexibility to attract a range of commercial users. Individuals within the City have expressed a desire for a large retail user at this location, and to entice such a user, an approved CUP will allow for development of the property upon Development Plan Review approval for an Initial Site Plan. 2. The location, size, design, and operating characteristics of the proposed project are consistent with the purposes of the district where it is located and conform with the General Plan and with any other applicable City plan or policies. RESPONSE: The Limited Commercial zoning district allows a large commercial development by right. Light Industrial allows it only upon the approval of a CUP. While this property will have two zoning districts the CUP, if approved will allow the property to be developed for two distinct uses, or as one, cohesive development. The size of the LI property, at slightly over 17 acres, will be self-limiting in the size and type of user that can successfully develop at this location. For example, a Walmart store requires almost 18 acres of property, without a fuel center. A Costco with a fuel center requires about 19 acres. Realistically, this location would be most suitable for a niche Grocer like Sprouts or Trader Joes, or a fitness Center such as EOS Fitness. 3. The proposed project will not be injurious or detrimental to the adjacent or surrounding properties in the area of the proposed project or improvements in the neighborhood or to the general welfare of the City; and RESPONSE: A large commercial development would have little-to-no- impact on the adjacent industrial or commercial users. The closest residential development is across Ellsworth Road, and any traffic generated from this development would be directed to Ellsworth Road, a major arterial that could accommodate any traffic that could be generated from a large commercial development. 4. Adequate public services, public facilities and public infrastructure are available to serve the proposed project. RESPONSE: This Property is within a part of the City that has undergone explosive growth in recent years. That growth has required extensive improvements to water, drainage and sewer infrastructure, and the widening of Ellsworth Road. Fire Station #221 is on Point Twenty-Two Boulevard, across Ellsworth Road, which would provide fire and medical response when necessary. This development will not produce any increase in residents, so will not require other public services like schools, libraries or community facilities. Additionally, Chapter 31 of the Zoning Ordinance establishes standards for Specific Uses and Activities. Section 11-31-16D, establishes standards and regulations for Large Commercial Developments. The standards found in 11-31-16D are in addition to the regular site development standards for Commercial Developments found in Section 11- 6-3 (Development Standards) and Section 11-6-4 (Site Planning and Design Standards). The criteria outlined for a CUP for a specific Large Commercial Development are site and user specific and rely upon the review and approval of a Site Plan, Plan of Operation and Good Neighbor Policy. Since Development Plan Review is not being requested at this time, the Applicant and Property Owner anticipate that a Condition of Approval will be placed on the future Zoning Ordinance for this case that requires an update to the Good Neighbor Policy and Plan of Operation that have been submitted with this application. Conclusion The requested land use changes will provide a range of benefits for the City of Mesa. Foremost, the existing multifamily entitlements will be removed from this location, which will underscore the idea that future residential development in this area should take place east of Ellsworth Road. The new designations will also allow for the established pattern of development in the area to be continued, and to allow the vision for this important part of the City to be completed in a way that will enhance the southeast Mesa community. The Applicant and Sunbelt respectfully request approval of the Council Use Permit, Rezoning and Minor General Plan amendment requests.