Ex. 1 P-26-64-PZ-Project Narrative
Extracted text (via pymupdf_layout)
13582 characters
Project Narrative Watermill Express Self-Service Water and Ice Kiosk City of Apache Junction, Arizona Purpose: To amend the table of approved uses under Ordinace No. 1443 to allow”Vending Machine Sales” and “Tobacco Sales” Applicant and Property Information Project name: Watermill Express / Red Star Vapor & Smoke Property address/location: 2540 W Apache Trail, Apache Junction, AZ 85120 - Mustang Center Property owner: McLean Holdings, LLC Property operator/applicant: Watermill Express, LLC and Red Star Vapor & Smoke Owner/Operator Description The subject property is owned by McLean Holdings, LLC and is proposed to lease a 325sf area of the property to Watermill Express for “Vending Machine Sales” and continue to lease space in Suite 103 to Red Star Vapor & Smoke for “Tobacco Sales”. Watermill Express is a self-service water and ice kiosk that fits within the existing developed commercial site. Watermill Express, LLC is the operator of the kiosk and specializes in purified water refill stations and bagged or vended ice sales through unattended, self-service equipment designed for customer convenience and limited on-site duration. All operation and maintenance is provided by Watermill Express employees through multiple times a week visits to clean, sanitize and provide continuous, high quality operational standards. The kiosk has a self-contained water filtration and purification system that uses a 12 step process to provide water and ice. Customers bring their own 1, 3 or 5 gallon containers to refill and can get a 10lb bag of ice or use their own cooler to have 10 or 20lbs dropped directly into it. The units are computer monitored and Watermill Express techs are alerted if there is anything that needs to be addressed to continue providing the best water available. The use is low-intensity, generates a small customer footprint, and does not function as a traditional retail store, restaurant, or drive-through business. Customers typically arrive, fill water containers or purchase ice, and depart within a short period of time. The unit accepts coins, cash and credit cards. Red Star Vapor & Smoke has operated in the center since October 0f 2018. It sells vapor, nicotine and tobacco products and accessories in a storefront location. Project Proposal The applicant proposes to install and operate a self-service water and ice kiosk on the subject property. The kiosk is to provide purified drinking water refill service and ice sales to the public through an automated, unattended unit. The kiosk is a State of Arizona approved modular building made of concrete, which weighs over 40,000lbs and is set on a structurally engineered pad with utility connections. The proposed installation consists of: • Removal of one small landscape island to reduce the removal of one more parking space(only 1 will be removal overall) and eliminate a potential tripping hazard as customers will be carrying a heavy filled water bottle or cooler to their vehicle • Construction of an engineered 15’x15’pad with 2 stubs for utilities • One freestanding 108sf, automated water and ice kiosk made of materials and colors, which happen to be similar to the existing shopping center. • Associated customer access area(part of the 15’x15’ pad) and short-term parking. • Utility connections necessary for operation, including water, sanitary sewer, and electrical service. • Included are bollards, striping, signage, pedestrian and ADA safety features and any other requirements by the City. The kiosk is intended to function as a neighborhood-serving convenience use that is subordinate in scale to the principal commercial development on the site. It is designed to occupy a limited footprint and to integrate with the existing parking lot and circulation pattern without altering the character of the property. Red Star Vapor & Smoke plans to continue to sell vaping and tobacco products in Suite 103, which it has since 2018. Current Site Conditions The subject site is currently a 44,000sf retail shopping center on 4.55 acres of land at 2540 W Apache Trail. There is one right in/right out access drive to the property and one shared full access, signalized drive on the adjacent parcel. There are 168 parking spaces provided for a ratio or 3.82/1000. The tenants include Purple Heart Desert Thrift Shoppe, Dollar Tree, Cato Fashions, The Laundry Place and Jersey Mike’s Subs. This is a nicely landscaped and well maintained shopping center that is a great asset to the Apache Junction community. The proposed kiosk location is within an area of the site that can accommodate the use without interfering with safe vehicular circulation, required parking, fire access, or pedestrian movement. The selected placement is intended to be compatible with the existing development pattern and to minimize impacts on adjacent properties and on-site operations. Data shows this area to be lightly used and sufficient for the low intensity use of a Watermill Express kiosk. The adjacent property to the west with the shared access drive includes a Starbucks and Jack in the Box; each with drive-thru operations. Wal Mart is across the signalized intersection. There is no cross access with the property to the east. Residential lies to the north. Red Star Vapor & Smoke currently occupies Suite 103 in the shopping center. No changes are planned to the premises. Conformance with the 2020 General Plan The proposed Watermill Express kiosk and the continued occupancy of Red Star Vapor & Smoke are consistent with the City of Apache Junction 2020 General Plan to the extent that it supports neighborhood-serving commercial activity, convenient access to daily goods, and efficient use of already developed commercial property. The proposed use advances several common General Plan objectives typically associated with commercial and community development, including: • Convenient neighborhood services: The kiosk provides residents with access to drinking water refill and ice sales in a convenient, low-intensity format. • Efficient use of developed sites: The proposal activates an existing commercial property with a small-footprint use rather than requiring expansion of a larger building area. • Compatibility with commercial areas: The kiosk is appropriately located in a commercial context where short-duration customer visits and vehicle access are already expected. • Consumer service and sustainability benefits: Water refill services can reduce reliance on single-use bottled water and provide a practical, everyday service to local residents. Although the use is commercial in nature, it operates with a much smaller physical scale, lower occupancy, reduced traffic intensity, and fewer impacts than many other permitted commercial uses. For that reason, the applicant is seeking formal recognition or clarification that this type of kiosk is an appropriate use within the City's development framework. Hours of Operation, Noise, Vehicles, and Outdoor Storage Hours of operation: The kiosk will operate 24 hours per day, 7 days per week. The automated nature of the use allows customers to access water and ice on a short-duration basis at times that are convenient to household and work schedules. Red Star Vapor & Smoke operate 9am-10pm Monday-Saturday and 9am-9pm on Sunday Expected noise generation: Noise generated by the kiosk is minimal and substantially lower than many other commercial uses. Typical sound sources are limited to: • Ice dispensing equipment and refrigeration components. • Customer vehicle arrival and departure. • Occasional customer interaction with the machine. Red Star Vapor & Smoke is an inline tenant, which does not have any noise concerns. Noise mitigation: The use is expected to create negligible off-site noise impacts due to its small scale and brief customer visits. Noise mitigation may include: • Placement away from adjoining residential property lines where feasible. • Installation in an existing commercial parking field rather than adjacent to sensitive outdoor spaces. • Use of modern enclosed equipment designed for commercial operation. • Limiting maintenance and servicing activities to normal daytime business hours whenever practical. Business-related vehicles parked on the property: Business-related vehicles are expected to consist only of periodic service or maintenance vehicles used to inspect, clean, repair, or restock the kiosk. These visits are short in duration. No fleet parking or long-term storage of commercial vehicles is required on site for either concept. Outdoor storage location: No outdoor storage is needed for either use. Any maintenance supplies, replacement parts, or operational materials associated with the kiosk are either inside the kiosk or are carried by our own service personnel. Proposed On-Site and Off-Site Improvements On-site improvements may include: • Installation of the freestanding kiosk unit. • Utility connections for water, wastewater, and electrical service. • Concrete pad and foundation for the kiosk. • Protective bollards. • Pavement striping and signage for customer parking. • Minor downward facing lighting on the structure compliant with City standards. • Any required screening improvements. The kiosk will be placed to preserve safe ingress and egress, maintain visibility, and avoid conflicts with existing parking, pedestrian travel paths, and emergency access requirements. No changes to the Red Star Vapor & Smoke premises. Off-site improvements: No off-site improvements are anticipated. Projected Timeline Subject to City review and approval, the anticipated project timeline is as follows: 1. Entitlement / zoning and land use approval: 180 days 2. Construction drawings and permit review: 90 days 3. Utility coordination and site preparation: 5-10 days 4. Installation of kiosk and site improvements: 10-30 days 5. Final inspection and commencement of operation: 1-2 days In general, because the proposed use is limited in scale, construction and installation are expected to be relatively short in duration compared to a traditional commercial building project. Once approvals and permits are secured, installation can typically be completed in a matter of weeks rather than months, subject to utility coordination, contractor scheduling, and inspections. Better design without strict application of zoning district provisions A better site design can be achieved by allowing flexibility from strict application of conventional zoning provisions because a self-service water and ice kiosk is a specialized, small- footprint commercial use that differs from traditional tenant spaces and freestanding retail buildings. Applying standards written for larger commercial buildings may not result in the most functional or efficient layout for this type of use. The proposed kiosk can be better integrated into the site through tailored placement, circulation, screening, and parking design that reflects the brief stop nature of the use. This flexibility allows the kiosk to function safely and efficiently while preserving the overall character and utility of the existing commercial property. Health, safety, and welfare Strict adherence to conventional zoning provisions is not required to ensure the health, safety, and welfare of development occupants or the public, provided that the kiosk complies with applicable building, fire, engineering, utility, and operational standards. The proposed use is low- intensity, unoccupied, and limited in footprint. It does not create the same demands associated with larger retail, restaurant, or automotive uses. Public health and safety will be protected through proper utility connections, site visibility, traffic circulation, equipment maintenance, sanitation practices, and compliance with all applicable regulatory requirements. Any conditions of approval imposed by the City can further ensure that the use operates safely and appropriately. Adjacent property values Strict adherence to conventional zoning provisions is not required to ensure that adjacent property values will not be reduced because the proposed kiosk is compatible with existing commercial development patterns and is expected to have minimal external impacts. The use involves limited customer duration, low noise generation, no outdoor seating, no substantial outdoor storage, and no intensive operational activity. When properly sited and maintained, the kiosk is not expected to negatively affect adjacent properties. Instead, it may enhance the convenience and service offerings available within the surrounding area, supporting the functionality and attractiveness of the commercial site. Conclusion The proposed Watermill Express self-service water and ice kiosk is a low-impact, neighborhood- serving commercial use that is appropriately scaled for an existing commercial site in Apache Junction. The use is expected to provide a convenient public service while generating minimal traffic, noise, and operational impacts. Its small footprint, limited duration of customer visits, and compatibility with commercial development make it a reasonable candidate for approval and for clarification within the City's land use and development regulations. Red Star Vapor & Smoke has operated in the center since 2018 with no issues from the general public regarding operations or parking. The proposal represents an efficient use of developed property and supports community access to essential daily-use services in a format that is modern, practical, and operationally low intensity. EXHIBITS Site Plan Kiosk Details