Extracted text (via pymupdf_layout)
50191 characters
Board of Supervisors' Agenda April 25, 2018 2016: TX2015-000216; TX2015-000239; 2016/2017: TX2016-001299; 2017: ST2017-000159; TX2016-000884; TX2016-001028; 2017/2018: TX2017-000077; 2018: 5T2017-000007; 5T2017-000097; ST2017-000172; 5T2017-000173; 5T2017- 000278; TX2017-000472; TX2017-000514; TX2017-000551; 2016 SP2706: *** COVER SHEET *** TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Date: 04/16/2018 Maricopa County 9 Parcels 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 Cty Atty: COMUS Prepared by: DEPAULO / LYLES Employee #: 7818 / 3683 Tax Case: TX2015-000216 Parcel #: see attached Tax Year: 2016 PlaWAT: SUN MP INVESTMENT PROPERTIES LLC LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 14,687,200 0 14,687,200 see parcel RECOMMENDED: 6,481,438 N/C 6,481,438 TASR' s Personal Property: See attached Reason: CODE 19 - Per Judgment TX2015-000216 Current Tax: N/A The Maricopa County Assessor's Office does not provide estimates of recommended Recommended taxes or tax refunds. Tax: N/A Total Refund: N/A Half Refund: N/A Totals: 500-07-030 500-07-022P 500-07-011B 500-07-0100 500-07-009F 500-07-0083 500-07-007H 500-07-007G 500-07-001 Parcel Current: Number Tax Tax Date: Case: Year: of 16-APR-18 0024 0014 0022 0022 0022 0022 0022 0022 0022 PUC TX2015 2016 Parcels: 9 -00021 PARCELS 14,687,200 541,600 72,700 3,462,000 2,858,400 3,272,000 1,796,600 878,900 1,370,300 434,700 Land 500-07-009C O O • O O O O O lmpr Reason: Attorney: Plaintiff: -AND- 14,687,200 541,600 72,700 3,462,000 2,858,400 3,272,000 1,796,600 878,900 1,370,300 434,700 CODE COMuS SUN TAX FCV MP 500-07-027E: 19 - APPEAL Per INVESTMENT TO Judgment BE 2.R 2R@ 2.R 2R@ 2.R 2.R 2.R 2R@ 2.R Class PROPERTIES SETTLEMENT @ @ @ @ @ @ 15% 15% 15% 15% 15% 15% 15% 15% 15% TX2015-000216 LLC DISMISSED N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C PUC Recommended: from RECOMMENDATION 6,481,438 239,007 32,082 1,527,777 1,261,407 1,443,928 792,837 387,857 604,711 191,832 Land Case/Action. Basis: Specialist: Appraiser: 0 N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C lmpr LYLES DEPAULO DEBRA 6,481,438 239,007 32,082 1,527,777 1,261,407 1,443,928 792,837 387,857 604,711 191,832 FCV Page: N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C Class 1 of SP27070 89 B9 B1 B9 B1 B1 B9 1 Al A @ @ @ @ @ @ @ Rule 67 67 67 67 67 67 67 SP27060 TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 Ciy Atty.. COMUS Prepared by: BELLJ / LYLES Date: 04/05/2018 Employee #• 7795 / 3683 Tax Case: TX2015-000239 Parcel #: 504-16-020B Year: 2016 Plantiff: WORTH LIVING TRUST LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 634,300 0 634,300 15.00 % RECOMMENDED: 32,500 N/C 32,500 N/C °A) Personal Prop: N/A Basis: Reason: CODE 19 - Per Judgment TX2015-000239 Current Tax: N/A The Maricopa County Assessor's Office does not provide estimates of recommended Recommended taxes or tax refunds. Tax: N/A Total Refund: N/A Half Refund: N/A LEGAL CLASSIFICATION : LAND 100 % CLASS 2.R @ 15.00 % 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 °A) 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % PUC IMPS 0 % CLASS 0024 0 % CLASS 0 % CLASS 2016 / 2017 SP2706: *** COVER SHEET *** TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Date: 04/10/2018 Maricopa County 98 Parcels 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 Cty Atty: PATTERSON Prepared by: DEVINE / LYLES Employee #: 7813 / 3683 Tax Case: TX2016-001299 Parcel #: see attached Tax Year: 2016 Plantiff: 44 AIRPORT AG OWNER LLC / 668 NORTH LL LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 2,332,400 16,369,100 18,701,500 see parcel RECOMMENDED: 1,247,148 8,752,852 10,000,000 TASR I s Personal Property: See attached Reason: CODE 19 - Per Judgment TX2016-001299 The Maricopa County Assessor's Office Current Tax: N/A does not provide estimates of recommended Recommended taxes or tax refunds. Tax: N/A Total Refund: N/A Half Refund: N/A 125-25-205 125-25-204 125-25-203 125-25-202 125-25-201 125-25-200 125-25-198 125-25-193 125-25-192 125-25-191 125-25-190 125-25-189 125-25-188 125-25-187 125-25-186 125 -25 Parcel Current: Number Tax Tax Date: -185 Case: Year: of 10-APR-18 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 PLIC Parcels: 2016 TX2016-001299 98 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 Land 56,400 713,100 432,700 75,000 369,400 2,817,100 145,300 47,800 194,900 273,600 68,400 76,900 194,900 354,000 95,700 395,100 Impr Reason: Attorney: Plaintiff: 80,200 736,900 456,500 98,800 393,200 2,840,900 169,100 71,600 218,700 297,400 92,200 100,700 218,700 377,800 119,500 418,900 FCV CODE 44 TAX 19 PATTERSON AIRPORT - APPEAL Per AG Judgment OWNER 1.8 @ 1.8@ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8@ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 1.8 @ 1.8@ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ Class TX2016 LLC / 668 SETTLEMENT 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% @18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C PLIC -001299 NORTH Recommended: LLC RECOMMENDATION 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 Land Basis: Specialist: Appraiser: 30,158 381,306 231,372 40,104 197,524 1,506,383 77,694 25,559 104,216 146,298 36,575 41,120 104,216 189,290 51,172 211,266 Impr LYLES DEVINE PETER 42,884 394,032 244,098 52,830 210,250 1,519,109 90,420 38,285 116,942 159,024 49,301 53,846 116,942 202,016 63,898 223,992 FCV Page: N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C Class 1 of SP27070 7 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 Rule 125-25-221 125-25-220 125-25-219 125-25-218 125-25-217 125-25-216 125-25-215 125-25-214 125-25-213 125-25-212 125-25-211 125-25-210 125-25-209 125-25-208 125-25-207 125-25-206 Parcel Current: Number Tax Tax Date: Case: Year: of 10-APR-18 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 PUC Parcels: 2016 TX2016-001299 98 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 Land 46,100 141,900 236,000 129,900 104,300 210,300 384,800 145,300 326,700 95,700 95,700 309,600 191,500 106,000 106,000 58,100 IMpr Reason: Attorney: Plaintiff: 69,900 165,700 259,800 153,700 128,100 234,100 408,600 169,100 350,500 119,500 119,500 333,400 215,300 129,800 129,800 81,900 FCV CODE 44 TAX PATTERSON AIRPORT 19 - APPEAL Per AG Judgment OWNER 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ L8© 1.8 @ 1.8@ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8@ 1.8@ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ Class LLC / 668 SETTLEMENT 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% TX2016-001299 I N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C PUC NORTH Recommended: LLC RECOMMENDATION 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 Land Basis: Specialist: Appraiser: 24,650 75,876 126,193 69,460 55,771 112,451 205,759 77,694 174,692 51,172 51,172 165,548 102,398 56,680 56,680 31,067 Irnpr DEVINE LYLES PETER 37,376 88,602 138,919 82,186 68,497 125,177 218,485 90,420 187,418 63,898 63,898 178,274 115,124 69,406 69,406 43,793 FCV Page: N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C Class 2 of 7 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 Rule 125-25-237 125-25-236 125-25-235 125-25-234 125-25-233 125-25-232 125-25-231 125-25-230 125-25-229 125-25-228 125-25-227 125-25-226 125-25-225 125-25-224 125-25-223 125-25-222 Parcel Current: Number Tax Tax Date: Case: Year: of 10-APR-18 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 PLIC Parcels: 2016 TX2016-001299 98 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 Land 133,400 104,300 109,400 109,400 131,700 104,300 114,600 112,800 87,200 87,200 87,200 150,500 169,300 150,500 87,200 80,300 lmpr Reason: Attorney: Plaintiff: 157,200 128,100 133,200 133,200 155,500 128,100 138,400 136,600 111,000 111,000 111,000 174,300 193,100 174,300 111,000 104,100 FCV CODE 44 TAX 19 PATTERSON AIRPORT - APPEAL Per AG Judgment OWNER 1.8 1.8 1.8 1.8© 1.8 1.8 1.8 1.8 1.8 1.8 1.8 1.8 1.8@ 1.8 1.8 1.8@ Class LLC / SETTLEMENT @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ 668 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% TX2016-001299 NORTH N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C PUC Recommended: LLC RECOMMENDATION 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 Land Basis: Specialist: Appraiser: 71,331 55,771 58,498 58,498 70,422 55,771 61,279 60,316 46,627 46,627 46,627 80,475 90,527 80,475 46,627 42,938 lmpr LYLES DEVINE PETER 84,057 68,497 71,224 71,224 83,148 68,497 74,005 73,042 59,353 59,353 59,353 93,201 103,253 93,201 59,353 55,664 FCV Page: N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C Class 3 of 7 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 Rule 125-25-253 125-25-252 125-25-251 125-25-250 125-25-249 125-25-248 125-25-247 125-25-246 125-25-245 125-25-244 125-25-243 125-25-242 125-25-241 125-25-240 125-25-239 125-25-238 Parcel Current: Number Tax Tax Date: Case: Year: 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 PLIC of 2016 10-APR-18 Parcels: TX2016-001299 98 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 Land 119,700 104,300 111,100 97,400 95,700 87,200 87,200 217,200 200,100 217,200 87,200 87,200 87,200 99,200 99,200 104,300 Impr Reason: Attorney: Plaintiff: 143,500 128,100 134,900 121,200 119,500 111,000 111,000 241,000 223,900 241,000 111,000 111,000 111,000 123,000 123,000 128,100 FCV CODE PATTERSON 44 TAX 19 AIRPORT APPEAL - Per AG Judgment OWNER 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8© 1.8© 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8@ 1.8@ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8@ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ Class TX2016 LLC / 668 SETTLEMENT 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C PLIC -001299 NORTH Recommended: LLC RECOMMENDATION 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 Land Basis: Specialist: Appraiser: 64,006 55,771 59,407 52,081 51,172 46,627 46,627 116,140 106,997 116,140 46,627 46,627 46,627 53,044 53,044 55,771 lmpr LYLES DEVINE PETER 76,732 68,497 72,133 64,807 63,898 59,353 59,353 128,866 119,723 128,866 59,353 59,353 59,353 65,770 65,770 68,497 FCV Page: N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C Class 4 of 7 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 Rule 125-25-269 125-25-268 125-25-267 125-25-266 125-25-265 125-25-264 125-25-263 125-25-262 125-25-261 125-25-260 125-25-259 125-25-258 125-25-257 125-25-256 125-25-255 125-25-254 Parcel Current: Number Tax Tax Date: Case: Year: of 10-APR-18 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 PLIC Parcels: 2016 TX2016-001299 98 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 Land 41,000 85,500 94,000 80,300 90,600 111,100 95,700 104,300 90,600 82,100 95,700 92,300 191,500 83,800 111,100 109,400 Impr Reason: Attorney: Plaintiff: 44 TAX 64,800 109,300 117,800 104,100 114,400 134,900 119,500 128,100 114,400 105,900 119,500 116,100 215,300 107,600 134,900 133,200 FCV CODE PATTERSON 19 AIRPORT APPEAL - Per AG Judgment OWNER 1.8 1.8 1.8 1.8 1.8 1.8 1.8 1.8 1.8 1.8 L 8 L8 1.8 1.8 L8 1.8 Class LLC / SETTLEMENT @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ 668 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% TX2016-001299 NORTH N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C RIC LLC Recommended: RECOMMENDATION 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 Land Basis: Specialist: Appraiser: 21,923 45,718 50,263 42,938 48,445 59,407 51,172 55,771 48,445 43,900 51,172 49,354 102,398 44,809 59,407 58,498 lmpr LYLES DEVINE PETER 34,649 58,444 62,989 55,664 61,171 72,133 63,898 68,497 61,171 56,626 63,898 62,080 115,124 57,535 72,133 71,224 FCV Page: N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C Class 5 of 7 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 Rule 125-25-285 125-25-284 125-25-283 125-25-282 125-25-281 125-25-280 125-25-279 125-25-278 125-25-277 125-25-276 125-25-275 125-25-274 125-25-273 125-25-272 125-25-271 125-25-270 Parcel Current: Number Tax Tax Date: Case: Year: of 10-APR-18 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 PUC Parcels: 2016 TX2016-001299 98 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 23,800 Land 123,100 205,200 82,100 87,200 92,300 336,900 92,300 87,200 87,200 87,200 88,900 99,200 104,300 104,300 102,600 116,300 lunar Reason: Attorney: Plaintiff: TAX 146,900 229,000 105,900 111,000 116,100 360,700 116,100 111,000 111,000 111,000 112,700 123,000 128,100 128,100 126,400 140,100 FCV CODE PATTERSON 19 - 44AIRPORTAG APPEAL Per Judgment OWNERLLC/668 1.8 1.8 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8© 1.8 1.8 @ 1.8@ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8@ 1.8@ 1.8 @ 1.8@ 1.8 1.8 @ Class SETTLEMENT @ 18% @ 18% 1 8% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% @18% 18% TX2016-001299 NORTH N/C N/C N/C N/C NIC N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C PUC Recommended: LLC RECOMMENDATION 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 12,726 Land Basis: Specialist: Appraiser: 65,824 109,724 43,900 46,627 49,354 180,146 49,354 46,627 46,627 46,627 47,536 53,044 55,771 55,771 54,862 62,188 Impr LYLES DEVINE PETER 78,550 122,450 56,626 59,353 62,080 192,872 62,080 59,353 59,353 59,353 60,262 65,770 68,497 68,497 67,588 74,914 FCV Page: N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C Class 6 of 7 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 Rule Totals: 125-25-287 125-25-286 Parcel Current: Number Tax Tax Date: Case: Year: of 10-APR-18 1414 1414 PUC Parcels: 2016 TX2016-001299 98 2,332,400 23,800 23,800 Land 16,369,100 71,800 123,100 Impr Reason: Attorney: Plaintiff: 18,701,500 95,600 146,900 CODE 44 TAX FCV PATTERSON 19 AIRPORT APPEAL - Per AG Judgment OWNER 1.8 1.8 Class LLC / SETTLEMENT @ @ 668 18% I 18% I TX2016-001299 NORTH N/C N/C PUC Recommended: LLC RECOMMENDATION 1,247,148 12,726 12,726 Land Basis: Specialist: Appraiser: 8,752,852 38,393 65,824 Impr LYLES DEVINE PETER 10,000,000 51,119 78,550 FCV Page: N/C N/C Class 7 of 7 A2 A2 Rule SP2706: *** COVER SHEET *** TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Date: 04/10/2018 Maricopa County 98 Parcels 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 Cty Atty: PATTERSON Prepared by: DEVINE / LYLES Employee #: 7813 / 3683 Tax Case: TX2016-001299 Parcel #: see attached Tax Year: 2017 Plantiff: 44 AIRPORT AG OWNER LLC / 668 NORTH LL LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 2,518,600 13,693,300 16,211,900 parcel see RECOMMENDED: 1,553,594 8,446,406 10,000,000 TASR' s Personal Property: See attached Reason: CODE 19 - Per Judgment TX2016-001299 The Maricopa County Assessor's Office Current Tax: N/A does not provide estimates of recommended Recommended taxes or tax refunds. Tax: N/A Total Refund: N/A Half Refund: N/A 125-25-205 125-25-204 125-25-203 125-25-202 125-25-201 125-25-200 125-25-198 125-25-193 125-25-192 125-25-191 125-25-190 125-25-189 125-25-188 125-25-187 125-25-186 125-25-185 Parcel Current: Number Tax Tax Date: Case: Year: of 10-APR-18 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 PUC Parcels: TX2016 2017 98 -001299 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 Land ' 47,200 590,900 362,300 63,600 309,300 2,351,900 121,700 40,100 163,200 229,100 57,200 64,400 163,200 296,400 80,200 330,800 IMpr Reason: Attorney: Plaintiff: 72,900 616,600 388,000 89,300 335,000 2,377,600 147,400 65,800 188,900 254,800 82,900 90,100 188,900 322,100 105,900 356,500 FCV CODE PATTERSON 44 TAX 19 AIRPORT APPEAL - Per AG Judgment OWNER 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8© 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8@ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ Class LLC / 668 SETTLEMENT 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% TX2016-001299 N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C PUC NORTH Recommended: LLC RECOMMENDATION 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 Land Basis: Specialist: Appraiser: 29,114 364,485 223,478 39,230 190,786 1,450,674 75,068 24,735 100,667 141,316 35,283 39,724 100,667 182,829 49,470 204,048 IMpr LYLES DEVINE PETER 44,967 380,338 239,331 55,083 206,639 1,466,527 90,921 40,588 116,520 157,169 51,136 55,577 116,520 198,682 65,323 219,901 FCV Page: N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C Class 1 of SP27070 7 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 Rule 125-25-221 125-25-220 125-25-219 125-25-218 125-25-217 125-25-216 125-25-215 125-25-214 125-25-213 125-25-212 125-25-211 125-25-210 125-25-209 125-25-208 125-25-207 125-25-206 Parcel Current: Number Tax Tax Date: Case: Year: 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 PUC of 2017 10-APR-18 Parcels: TX2016-001299 98 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 Land 38,600 118,800 197,600 108,800 87,300 176,100 322,200 121,700 273,500 80,200 80,200 259,200 160,400 88,800 88,800 48,600 lmpr Reason: Attorney: Plaintiff: 64,300 144,500 223,300 134,500 113,000 201,800 347,900 147,400 299,200 105,900 105,900 284,900 186,100 114,500 114,500 74,300 FCV CODE PATTERSON 44 TAX 19 AIRPORT APPEAL - Per AG Judgment OWNER 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8@ 1.8@ 1.8@ 1.8@ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ L8@ 1.8@ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ Class TX2016 LLC / 668 SETTLEMENT 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C PUC -001299 NORTH Recommended: LLC RECOMMENDATION 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 Land Basis: Specialist: Appraiser: 23,810 73,280 121,886 67,111 53,849 108,624 198,743 75,068 168,703 49,470 49,470 159,883 98,940 54,775 54,775 29,978 !Mgr LYLES DEVINE PETER 39,663 89,133 137,739 82,964 69,702 124,477 214,596 90,921 184,556 65,323 65,323 175,736 114,793 70,628 70,628 45,831 FCV Page: N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C Class 2 of 7 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 Rule 125-25-237 125-25-236 125-25-235 125-25-234 125-25-233 125-25-232 125-25-231 125-25-230 125-25-229 125-25-228 125-25-227 125-25-226 125-25-225 125-25-224 125-25-223 125-25-222 Parcel Current: Number Tax Tax Date: Case: Year: of 10-APR-18 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 PUC Parcels: 2017 TX2016-001299 98 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 Land 111,700 87,300 91,600 91,600 110,200 87,300 95,900 94,500 73,000 73,000 73,000 126,000 141,700 126,000 73,000 67,300 lmpr Reason: Attorney: Plaintiff: 137,400 113,000 117,300 117,300 135,900 113,000 121,600 120,200 98,700 98,700 98,700 151,700 167,400 151,700 98,700 93,000 FCV CODE PATTERSON 44 TAX 19 - AIRPORT APPEAL Per AG Judgment OWNER 1.8 1.8 L8 1.8 1.8 1.8 1.8@ 1.8 1.8 1.8© 1.8 1.8© 1.8 1.8 1.8 1.8@ Class LLC / SETTLEMENT @ @ @ @18% @ @ @18% @ @ @ @ @ 668 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% TX2016-001299 NORTH N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C PUC Recommended: LLC RECOMMENDATION 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 Land Basis: Specialist: Appraiser: 68,900 53,849 56,502 56,502 67,975 53,849 59,154 58,291 45,029 45,029 45,029 77,721 87,405 77,721 45,029 41,513 Impr LYLES DEVINE PETER 84,753 69,702 72,355 72,355 83,828 69,702 75,007 74,144 60,882 60,882 60,882 93,574 103,258 93,574 60,882 57,366 FCV Page: N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C Class 3 of 7 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 Rule 125-25-253 125-25-252 125-25-251 125-25-250 125-25-249 125-25-248 125-25-247 125-25-246 125-25-245 125-25-244 125-25-243 125-25-242 125-25-241 125-25-240 125-25-239 125-25-238 Parcel Current: Number Tax Tax Date: Case: Year: of 10-APR-18 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 PUC Parcels: 2017 TX2016-001299 98 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 Land 100,200 87,300 93,000 81,600 80,200 73,000 73,000 181,800 167,500 181,800 73,000 73,000 73,000 83,000 83,000 87,300 Impr Reason: Attorney: Plaintiff: 125,900 113,000 118,700 107,300 105,900 98,700 98,700 207,500 193,200 207,500 98,700 98,700 98,700 108,700 108,700 113,000 FCV CODE PATTERSON 44 TAX 19 AIRPORT APPEAL - Per AG Judgment OWNER 1.8@ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8@ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8@ 1.8© 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8@ Class LLC / SETTLEMENT 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% TX2016-001299 668 N/C I N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C PUC NORTH Recommended: LLC RECOMMENDATION 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 Land Basis: Specialist: Appraiser: 61,806 53,849 57,365 50,333 49,470 45,029 45,029 112,140 103,319 112,140 45,029 45,029 45,029 51,197 51,197 53,849 IMpr LYLES DEVINE PETER 77,659 69,702 73,218 66,186 65,323 60,882 60,882 127,993 119,172 127,993 60,882 60,882 60,882 67,050 67,050 69,702 FCV Page: N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C Class 4 of 7 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 Rule 125-25-269 125-25-268 125-25-267 125-25-266 125-25-265 125-25-264 125-25-263 125-25-262 125-25-261 125-25-260 125-25-259 125-25-258 125-25-257 125-25-256 125-25-255 125-25-254 Parcel Current: Number Tax Tax Date: Case: Year: of 10-APR-18 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 141i 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 PUC Parcels: 2017 TX2016-001299 98 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 Land 34,300 71,600 78,700 67,300 75,900 93,000 80,200 87,300 75,900 68,700 80,200 77,300 160,400 70,100 93,000 91,600 Impr Reason: Attorney: Plaintiff: 60,000 97,300 104,400 93,000 101,600 118,700 105,900 113,000 101,600 94,400 105,900 103,000 186,100 95,800 118,700 117,300 FCV CODE 44 TAX PATTERSON AIRPORT 19 - APPEAL Per AG Judgment OWNER 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8@ 1.8 @ 1.8@ 1.8 @ 1.8@ 1.8 @ 1.8@ 1.8@ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8@ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ Class LLC / 668 SETTLEMENT 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% TX2016-001299 N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C PLIC NORTH Recommended: LLC RECOMMENDATION 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 Land Basis: Specialist: Appraiser: 21,157 44,165 48,545 41,513 46,817 57,365 49,470 53,849 46,817 42,376 49,470 47,681 98,940 43,240 57,365 56,502 Impr LYLES DEVINE PETER 37,010 60,018 64,398 57,366 62,670 73,218 65,323 69,702 62,670 58,229 65,323 63,534 114,793 59,093 73,218 72,355 FCV Page: N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C Class 5 of 7 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 Rule 125-25-285 125-25-284 125-25-283 125-25-282 125-25-281 125-25-280 125-25-279 125-25-278 125-25-277 125-25-276 125-25-275 125-25-274 125-25-273 125-25-272 125-25-271 125-25-270 Parcel Current: Number Tax Tax Date: Case: Year: of 10-APR-18 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 PUC Parcels: TX2016 2017 98 -001299 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 25,700 Land 103,100 171,800 68,700 73,000 77,300 282,100 77,300 73,000 73,000 73,000 74,400 83,000 87,300 87,300 85,900 97,300 Impr Reason: Attorney: Plaintiff: 128,800 197,500 94,400 98,700 103,000 307,800 103,000 98,700 98,700 98,700 100,100 108,700 113,000 113,000 111,600 123,000 FCV CODE 44 TAX 19 PATTERSON AIRPORT - APPEAL Per AG Judgment OWNER 1.8 @ 1.8© 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8© 1.8© 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8@ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ L8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8@ 1.8@ Class LLC / SETTLEMENT 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% TX2016-001299 668 N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C PUC NORTH Recommended: LLC RECOMMENDATION 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 15,853 Land Specialist: Appraiser: 63,595 105,972 42,376 45,029 47,681 174,008 47,681 45,029 45,029 45,029 45,892 51,197 53,849 53,849 52,986 60,018 lmpr DEVINE LYLES PETER 79,448 121,825 58,229 60,882 63,534 189,861 63,534 60,882 60,882 60,882 61,745 67,050 69,702 69,702 68,839 75,871 FCV Page: N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C Class 6 of 7 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 Rule Totals: 125-25-287 125-25-286 Parcel Current: Number Tax Tax Date: Case: Year: 1414 1414 PUC of 2017 10-APR-18 Parcels: TX2016-001299 98 2,518,600 25,700 25,700 Land 13,693,300 60,100 103,100 Impr Reason: Attorney: Plaintiff: 16,211,900 85,800 128,800 CODE 44 TAX FCV PATTERSoN 19 AIRPORT APPEAL - Per AG Judgment OWNER 1.8 1.8 Class LLC / SETTLEMENT @ @ 668 18% I 18% I TX2016-001299 NORTH N/C N/C PUC LLC Recommended: RECOMMENDATION 1,553,594 15,853 15,853 Land Basis: Specialist: Appraiser: 8,446,406 37,072 63,595 Impr LYLES DEVINE PETER 10,000,000 52,925 79,448 FCV Page: N/C N/C Class 7 of 7 A2 A2 Rule SP27060 TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 Cty Atty: LEIBSOHN Prepared by: DEVINE / LYLES Date: 04/10/2018 Employee #: 7813 / 3683 Tax Case: ST2017-000159 Parcel #: 141-54-034H Year: 2017 Plantiffi BABONA LLC LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 681,500 794,500 1,476,000 18.00 % RECOMMENDED: 369,377 430,623 800,000 N/C % Personal Prop: N/A Basis: Reason: CODE 19 - Per Judgment ST2017-000159 Current Tax: N/A The Maricopa County Assessor's Office does not provide estimates of recommended Recommended taxes or tax refunds. Tax: N/A Total Refund: N/A Half Refund: N/A LEGAL CLASSIFICATION : 100 °A) CLASS 1.12 @ 18.00 °A LAND 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % PUC IMPS 100 % CLASS 1.12 @ 18.00 `)/0 2010 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % 0 % CLASS g 0.00 % SP2706: *** COVER SHEET *** TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Date: 04/16/2018 Maricopa County 10 Parcels 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 Cty Atty: COMUS Prepared by: DEPAULO / LYLES Employee #: 7818 / 3683 Tax Case: TX2016 - 000884 Parcel #: see attached Tax Year: 2017 Plant.if'E SUN MP INVESTMENT PROPERTIES LLC LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 16,560,000 0 16,560,000 parcel see RECOMMENDED: 3,000,000 N/C 3,000,000 TASR's Personal Property: See attached Reason: CODE 19 - Per Judgment TX2016-000884 The Maricopa County Assessor's Office Current Tax: N/A does not provide estimates of recommended Recommended taxes or tax refunds. Tax: N/A Total Refund: N/A Half Refund: N/A Parcel Current: Tax Tax Date: Totals: 500-07-030 500-07-027E 500-07-022P 500-07-011B 500-07-010D 500-07-009F 500-07-0083 500-07-007H 500-07-007G 500-07-001 Number Case: Year: of 16-APR-18 0024 0024 0014 0022 0022 0022 0022 0022 0022 0022 PUC 2017 Parcels: TX2016-000884 10 Parcel 16,560,000 141,400 400,100 94,100 4,046,200 3,178,300 3,777,500 1,911,700 983,000 1,602,700 425,000 Land 500-07-027E: O O O O O O O O • O lmpr Plaintiff: AG Reason: Attorney: Status 16,560,000 141,400 400,100 94,100 4,046,200 3,178,300 3,777,500 1,911,700 983,000 1,602,700 425,000 CODE COMUS SUN TAX FCV MP Granted 19 - APPEAL Per INVESTMENT w/ Judgment Use 2.R 2R@ 2.R 2.R 2.R 2.R 2.R 2.R 2R@ 2.R Class PROPERTIES SETTLEMENT Code @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ 15% 15% 15% 15% 15% 15% 15% 15% 15% 15% TX2016-000884 LLC N/C 1 4110 N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C PUC change. Recommended: RECOMMENDATION 42-16002 3,000,000 26,065 21,165 17,346 745,857 585,872 696,325 352,393 181,201 295,434 78,342 Land (roll) Basis: Specialist: Appraiser: not 0 N/C N/C N/C N/C NIC N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C 1Mpr LYLES applicable DEPAULO DEBRA on 3,000,000 26,065 21,165 17,346 745,857 585,872 696,325 352,393 181,201 295,434 78,342 FCV (said) parcel. Page: N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C Class 1 of SP27070 1 Al Al Al Al Al Al Al Al Al Al Rule SP27060 TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 Cty Atty: LEIBSOHN Prepared by: CHAPPELA / LYLES Date: 04/12/2018 Employee #: 7824 / 3683 Tax Case: TX2016-001028 Parcel #: 138-44-039 Year: 2017 Plantiffi MHA WEST LLC LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 815,500 2,519,600 3,335,100 10.00 % RECOMMENDED: 391,233 1,208,767 1,600,000 N/C % Recommended LPV calculation used: Rule B3 Personal Prop: N/A Basis: Reason: CODE 19 - Per Judgment TX2016-001028 Current Tax: N/A The Maricopa County Assessor's Office does not provide estimates of recommended Recommended taxes or tax refunds. Tax: N/A Total Refund: N/A Half Refund: N/A LEGAL CLASSIFICATION : LAND 100 % CLASS 4.2 @ 10.00 % 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % PUC IMPS 100 % CLASS 4.2 @ 10.00 % 0364 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % 2017/2018 SP27060 TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 Cty Atty: LEIBSOHN Prepared by: DEVINE / LYLES Date: 04/04/2018 Employee #: 7813 / 3683 Tax Case: TX2017-000077 Parcel #: 301-67-966 Year: 2017 Plantift FAE RAY & RURAL LLC LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 1,073,300 3,031,800 4,105,100 18.00 % RECOMMENDED: 666,711 1,883,289 2,550,000 N/C % Personal Prop: N/A Basis: Reason: CODE 19 - Per Judgment TX2017-000077 Current Tax: N/A The Maricopa County Assessor's Office does not provide estimates of recommended Recommended taxes or tax refunds. Tax: N/A Total Refund: N/A Half Refund: N/A LEGAL CLASSIFICATION : LAND 100 % CLASS 1.8 @ 18.00 % 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % PUC IMPS 100 % CLASS 1.8 @ 18.00 % 1410 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 `)/0 0 % CLASS g 0.00 % SP27060 TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 Cty Atty: LEIBSOHN Prepared by: DEVINE / LYLES Date: 04/04/2018 Employee #: 7813 / 3683 Tax Case: TX2017-000077 Parcel lit: 301-67-966 Year: 2018 Plantiffi FAE RAY & RURAL LLC LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 1,159,100 2,902,200 4,061,300 18.00 % RECOMMENDED: 799,123 2,000,877 2,800,000 N/C % Personal Prop: N/A Basis: Reason: CODE 19 - Per Judgment TX2017-000077 Current Tax: N/A The Maricopa County Assessor's Office does not provide estimates of recommended Recommended taxes or tax refunds. Tax: N/A Total Refund: N/A Half Refund: N/A LEGAL CLASSIFICATION : LAND 100 % CLASS 1.8 @ 18.00 % 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % PUC IMPS 100 `)/0 CLASS 1.8 @ 18.00 `)/0 1410 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % SP27060 TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 Cly Atty: LEIB S OHN Prepared by: DEVINE / LYLES Date: 04/17/2018 Employee #: 7813 / 3683 Tax Case: ST2017-000007 Parcel #: 121 -39- 002K Year: 2018 Plantiff EWING IRRIGATION PRODUCTS INC LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 710,600 0 710,600 15.00 % RECOMMENDED: 40,400 N/C 40,400 N/C Personal Prop: N/A Basis: Reason: CODE 19 - Per Judgment ST2017-000007 Current Tax: N/A The Maricopa County Assessor's Office does not provide estimates of recommended Recommended taxes or tax refunds. Tax: N/A Total Refund: N/A Half Refund: N/A LEGAL CLASSIFICATION : 100 % CLASS 2.R g 15.00 % LAND 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % PUC IMPS 0 % CLASS 0032 0 % CLASS 0 % CLASS SP27060 TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 Cly Atty: LEIBSOHN Prepared by: DEVINE / LYLES Date: 04/17/2018 Employee #• 7813 / 3683 Tax Case: ST2017-000097 Parcel #: 218-07-015H Year: 2018 Plantiff: ROBACK ANTHONY / TRACEA LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 529,700 0 529,700 15.00 % RECOMMENDED: 79,500 N/C 79,500 N/C (Y0 Personal Prop: N/A Basis: Reason: CODE 19 - Per Judgment ST2017-000097 Current Tax: N/A The Maricopa County Assessor's Office does not provide estimates of recommended Recommended taxes or tax refunds. Tax: N/A Total Refund: N/A Half Refund: N/A LEGAL CLASSIFICATION : LAND 100 % CLASS 2.R @ 15.00 % 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 `)/0 PUC CHANGE TO: IMPS 0 % CLASS g 0.00 % 8806 0 % CLASS g 0.00 % 0 % CLASS g 0.00 % SP2706: *** COVER SHEET *** TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Date: 04/06/2018 Maricopa County 7 Parcels 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 Cty Atty: LEIBSOHN Prepared by: DEVINE / LYLES Employee #: 7813 / 3683 Tax Case: ST2017-000172 Parcel #: see attached Tax Year: 2018 Plantiff: LARGO 258 LLC LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 1,729,800 0 1,729,800 see parcel RECOMMENDED: 90,400 N/C 90,400 TASR I s Personal Property: See attached Reason: CODE 19 - Per Judgment ST2017-000172 The Maricopa County Assessor's Office Current Tax: N/A does not provide estimates of recommended Recommended taxes or tax refunds. Tax: N/A Total Refund: N/A Half Refund: N/A Totals: 402-39-004C 402-39-004B 402-39-003E 402-39-003D 402-39-003C 402-39-002A 402-39-001A Parcel Current: Number Tax Tax Date: Case: Year: of 06-APR-18 0022 0022 0031 0022 0022 0022 0022 PUC Parcels: 2018 ST2017-000172 7 1,729,800 169,400 590,900 233,400 234,000 352,900 65,400 83,800 Land 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 lmpr Reason: Attorney: Plaintiff: 1,729,800 169,400 590,900 233,400 234,000 352,900 65,400 83,800 FCV CODE LEIBSOHN LARGO TAX 19 - 258 APPEAL Per LLC 977,981 100,751 335,429 113,408 126,736 188,304 37,181 76,172 LPV Judgment 2.R 2.R 2.R 2.R 2.R 2.R @ 2.R Class SETTLEMENT @ @ @ @ @ @ 15% 15% 15% 15% 15% 15% 15% ST2017-000172 N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C PUC Recommended: RECOMMENDATION 90,400 3,400 53,900 15,300 4,900 8,100 3,500 1,300 Land Basis: Specialist: Appraiser: 0 N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C lmpr LYLES DEVINE PETER 90,400 3,400 53,900 15,300 4,900 8,100 3,500 1,300 FCV SP2706: ***COVER SHEET*** TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Date: 04/06/2018 Maricopa County 2 Parcels 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 Cty Atty: LEIBSOHN Prepared by: DEVINE / LYLES Employee #: 7813 / 3683 Tax Case: ST2017-000173 Parcel #: see attached Tax Year: 2018 Plantiff: LARGO 258 LLC LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 467,500 0 467,500 see parcel RECOMMENDED: 89,600 N/C 89,600 TASR's Personal Property: See attached Reason: CODE 19 - Per Judgment ST2017-000173 Current Tax: N/A The Maricopa County Assessor's Office does not provide estimates of recommended Recommended taxes or tax refunds. Tax: N/A Total Refund: N/A Half Refund: N/A Totals: 402-39-004A 402-39-003F Parcel Current: Number Tax Tax Date: Case: Year: 0022 0022 PUC of ST2017 2018 06-APR-18 Parcels: 2 -000173 467,500 444,200 23,300 Land 0 0 0 Impr Reason: Attorney: Plaintiff: 467,500 444,200 23,300 FCV CODE LEIBSOHN LARGO TAX 19 - 258 APPEAL Per LLC 268,529 254,802 13,727 LPV Judgment 2.R 2.R Class SETTLEMENT @ @ 15% I I 15% ST2017-000173 N/C N/C PUC Recommended: RECOMMENDATION 89,600 87,100 2,500 Land Basis: Specialist: Appraiser: 0 N/C N/C Impr LYLES DEVINE PETER 89,600 87,100 2,500 FCV SP2706: *** COVER SHEET *** TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Date: 04/10/2018 Maricopa County 3 Parcels 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 Cty Atty: LEIBSOHN Prepared by: DEVINE / LYLES Employee #: 7813 / 3683 Tax Case: ST2017-000278 Parcel #: see attached Tax Year: 2018 Plantiff: PARADISE ENCLAVE LLC LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 123,600 0 123,600 see parcel RECOMMENDED: 1,500 N/C 1,500 TASR' s Personal Property: See attached Reason: CODE 19 - Per Judgment ST2017-000278 Current Tax: N/A The Maricopa County Assessor's Office does not provide estimates of recommended Recommended taxes or tax refunds. Tax: N/A Total Refund: N/A Half Refund: N/A Totals: 200-53-846 200-53-845 200-53-844 Parcel Current: Number Tax Tax Date: Case: Year: of 10-APR-18 0011 0011 0011 PUC Parcels: ST2017 2018 3 -000278 123,600 48,700 18,600 56,300 Land 0 0 0 o lmor Reason: Attorney: Plaintiff: TAX 123,600 48,700 18,600 56,300 FCV CODE LEIBSOHN PARADISE 19 - APPEAL Per ENCLAVE 19,569 7,900 2,066 9,603 LPV Judgment LLC 2.R 2.R 2.R Class SETTLEMENT @ @ @ 15% 15% 15% ST2017-000278 10262 10262 10262 PUC Recommended: RECOMMENDATION 1,500 SOO SOO 500 Land Basis: Specialist: Appraiser: o N/C N/C N/C Impr LYLES DEVINE PETER 1,500 SOO 500 500 FCV Page: N/C N/C N/C Class 1 of SP27070 1 Al Al Al Rule SP27060 TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION AG Classification Granted - Maricopa County NO ROLL to 2019. 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 Cty Atty: LEIBSOHN Prepared by: HARBORT / LYLES Date: 04/05/2018 Employee #: 7701 / 3683 Tax Case: TX2017-000472 Parcel #: 303-55-018C Year: 2018 Plant iff' MSH CHANDLER LLC LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 5,090,600 0 5,090,600 15.00 % RECOMMENDED: 40,632 N/C 40,632 N/C % Personal Prop: N/A Basis: Reason: CODE 19 - Per Judgment TX2017-000472 Current Tax: N/A The Maricopa County Assessor's Office does not provide estimates of recommended Recommended taxes or tax refunds. Tax: N/A Total Refund: N/A Half Refund: N/A LEGAL CLASSIFICATION : LAND 100 % CLASS 2.R @ 15.00 % 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % PUC CHANGE TO: IMPS 0 % CLASS 4110 0 % CLASS 0 % CLASS SP2706: *** COVER SHEET *** TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Date: 04/17/2018 Maricopa County 10 Parcels 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 Cty Atty: COWS Prepared by: / LYLES Employee #: / 3683 Tax Case: TX2017-000514 Parcel #: see attached Tax Year: 201 8 Plantn SUN MP INVESTMENT PROPERTIES LLC LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 18,191,200 0 18,191,200 see parcel RECOMMENDED: 322,993 N/C 322,993 TASR' s Personal Property: See attached Reason: CODE 19 - Per Judgment TX2017-000514 Current Tax: N/A The Maricopa County Assessor's Office does not provide estimates of recommended Recommended taxes or tax refunds. Tax: N/A Total Refund: N/A Half Refund: N/A Totals: 500-07-030 500-07-027E 500-07-022P 500-07-011B 500-07-0100 500-07-009F 500-07-008J 500-07-007H 500-07-007G 500-07-001 Parcel Current: Number Tax Tax Date: Case: Year: of 17-APR-18 0024 0024 0014 0022 0022 0022 0022 0022 0022 0022 PUC Parcels: 2018 TX2017-000514 10 18,191,200 138,500 766,200 110,000 4,167,600 3,273,700 3,890,800 1,969,000 1,786,800 1,650,800 437,800 Land 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 lmpr Reason: Attorney: Plaintiff: 18,191,200 138,500 766,200 110,000 4,167,600 3,273,700 3,890,800 1,969,000 1,786,800 1,650,800 437,800 CODE COMUS SUN TAX FCV MP 19 - APPEAL Per INVESTMENT Judgment 2R@ 2.R 2R@ 2R@ 2.R 2R© 2.R 2R@ 2R@ 2.R Class PROPERTIES SETTLEMENT 42-16002 @ @ @ @ 15% 15% 15% 15% 15% 15% 15% 15% 15% 15% TX2017-000514 LLC not 4110 4110 4110 4110 4110 4110 4110 4110 4110 4110 PUC Recommended: applicable. RECOMMENDATION 322,993 2,425 23,247 5,576 102,014 47,290 61,115 23,992 17,574 35,049 4,711 Land Basis: Specialist: Appraiser: 0 N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C Impr LYLES 322,993 2,425 23,247 5,576 102,014 47,290 61,115 23,992 17,574 35,049 4,711 FCV Page: N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C Class 1 of SP27070 B9 B9 B9 B9 B9 B9 89 B9 B9 1 @ Al @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ Rule 62 62 62 62 62 62 62 62 62 SP2706: *** COVER SHEET *** TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Date: 04/10/2018 Maricopa County 98 Parcels 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 Cty Atty: PATTERSON Prepared by: DEVINE / LYLES Employee #: 7813 / 3683 Tax Case: TX2017-000551 Parcel #: see attached Tax Year: 2018 Planta: 668 NORTH LLC LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 2,714,600 15,650,400 18,365,000 see parcel RECOMMENDED: 1,552,026 8,947,974 10,500,000 TASR' s Personal Property: See attached Reason: CODE 19 - Per Judgment TX2017-000551 The Maricopa County Assessor's Office Current Tax: N/A does not provide estimates of recommended Recommended taxes or tax refunds. Tax: N/A Total Refund: N/A Half Refund: N/A 125-25-205 125-25-204 125-25-203 125-25-202 125-25-201 125-25-200 125-25-198 125-25-193 125-25-192 125-25-191 125-25-190 125-25-189 125-25-188 125-25-187 125-25-186 125-25-185 Parcel Current: Number Tax Tax Date: Case: Year: 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 PUC of 2018 10-APR-18 Parcels: TX2017-000551 98 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 Land 53,500 691,400 410,900 71,500 350,800 2,767,400 138,000 45,400 185,100 259,800 64,900 73,000 185,100 336,200 90,900 375,100 Impr Reason: Attorney: Plaintiff: 81,200 719,100 438,600 99,200 378,500 2,795,100 165,700 73,100 212,800 287,500 92,600 100,700 212,800 363,900 118,600 402,800 FCV CODE PATTERSON 668 TAX 19 - NORTH APPEAL Per LLC Judgment 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8@ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8© 1.8© 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8© 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ L8@ 1.8@ Class SETTLEMENT 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 1 8% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% TX2017-000551 N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C PUC Recommended: RECOMMENDATION 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 Land Basis: Specialist: Appraiser: 30,588 395,301 234,928 40,879 200,566 1,582,249 78,900 25,957 105,829 148,538 37,106 41,737 105,829 192,219 51,971 214,460 lmpr LYLES DEVINE PETER 46,425 411,138 250,765 56,716 216,403 1,598,086 94,737 41,794 121,666 164,375 52,943 57,574 121,666 208,056 67,808 230,297 FCV Page: N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C Class 1 of SP27070 7 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 Rule 125-25-221 125-25-220 125-25-219 125-25-218 125-25-217 125-25-216 125-25-215 125-25-214 125-25-213 125-25-212 125-25-211 125-25-210 125-25-209 125-25-208 125-25-207 125 -25 Parcel Current: Number Tax Tax Date: -206 Case: Year: of 10-APR-18 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 PUC Parcels: 2018 TX2017-000551 98 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 Land 43,800 134,800 224,100 123,400 99,000 199,700 365,400 138,000 310,200 90,900 90,900 293,900 181,900 100,700 100,700 55,200 lmpr Reason: Attorney: Plaintiff: 71,500 162,500 251,800 151,100 126,700 227,400 393,100 165,700 337,900 118,600 118,600 321,600 209,600 128,400 128,400 82,900 FCV CODE PATTERSON 668 TAX 19 NORTH APPEAL - Per LLC Judgment 1.8 @ 1.8@ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8© 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8© 1.8 @ 1.8 @ L8 @ L8@ Class SETTLEMENT 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% TX2017-000551 N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C PUC Recommended: RECOMMENDATION 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 Land Basis: Specialist: Appraiser: 25,042 77,071 128,127 70,553 56,602 114,176 208,914 78,900 177,354 51,971 51,971 168,034 103,999 57,574 57,574 31,560 lmpr LYLES DEVINE PETER 40,879 92,908 143,964 86,390 72,439 130,013 224,751 94,737 193,191 67,808 67,808 183,871 119,836 73,411 73,411 47,397 FCV Page: N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C Class 2 of 7 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 Rule 125-25-237 125-25-236 125-25-235 125-25-234 125-25-233 125-25-232 125-25-231 125-25-230 125-25-229 125-25-228 125-25-227 125-25-226 125-25-225 125-25-224 125-25-223 125-25-222 Parcel Current: Number Tax Tax Date: Case: Year: of 10-APR-18 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 PUC Parcels: 2018 TX2017-000551 98 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 Land 126,600 99,000 103,900 103,900 125,000 99,000 108,800 107,200 82,800 82,800 82,800 142,900 160,700 142,900 82,800 76,300 lmpr Reason: Attorney: Plaintiff: 154,300 126,700 131,600 131,600 152,700 126,700 136,500 134,900 110,500 110,500 110,500 170,600 188,400 170,600 110,500 104,000 FCV CODE PATTERSON 668 TAX 19 NORTH APPEAL - Per LLC Judgment L8 1.8 L8 1.8 L8 L8 L8 1.8 1.8 L8 L8 L8 1.8 1.8 1.8 L8 Class SETTLEMENT @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% TX2017-000551 N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C PUC Recommended: RECOMMENDATION 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 Land Basis: Specialist: Appraiser: 72,382 56,602 59,404 59,404 71,467 56,602 62,205 61,290 47,340 47,340 47,340 81,702 91,879 81,702 47,340 43,624 Impr LYLES DEVINE PETER 88,219 72,439 75,241 75,241 87,304 72,439 78,042 77,127 63,177 63,177 63,177 97,539 107,716 97,539 63,177 59,461 FCV Page: N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C Class 3 of 7 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 Rule 125-25-253 125-25-252 125-25-251 125-25-250 125-25-249 125-25-248 125-25-247 125-25-246 125-25-245 125-25-244 125-25-243 125-25-242 125-25-241 125-25-240 125-25-239 125-25-238 Parcel Current: Number Tax Tax Date: Case: Year: of 10-APR-18 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 PUC Parcels: 2018 TX2017-000551 98 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 Land 113,600 99,000 105,500 92,500 90,900 82,800 82,800 206,200 190,000 206,200 82,800 82,800 82,800 94,200 94,200 99,000 Impr Reason: Attorney: Plaintiff: 141,300 126,700 133,200 120,200 118,600 110,500 110,500 233,900 217,700 233,900 110,500 110,500 110,500 121,900 121,900 126,700 FCV CODE PATTERSON 668 TAX 19 - NORTH APPEAL Per LLC Judgment 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8@ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 1.8 @ 1.8@ 1.8 @ 1.8@ 1.8@ 1.8 @ 1.8@ Class SETTLEMENT 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% @18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% TX2017-000551 N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C 14/C PUC Recommended: RECOMMENDATION 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 Land Basis: Specialist: Appraiser: 64,950 56,602 60,319 52,886 51,971 47,340 47,340 117,893 108,631 117,893 47,340 47,340 47,340 53,858 53,858 56,602 lmpr LYLES DEVINE PETER 80,787 72,439 76,156 68,723 67,808 63,177 63,177 133,730 124,468 133,730 63,177 63,177 63,177 69,695 69,695 72,439 FCV Page: N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C Class 4 of 7 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 Rule 125-25-269 125-25-268 125-25-267 125-25-266 125-25-265 125-25-264 125-25-263 125-25-262 125-25-261 125-25-260 125-25-259 125-25-258 125-25-257 125-25-256 125-25-255 125-25-254 Parcel Current: Number Tax Tax Date: Case: Year: of 10-APR-18 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 PUC Parcels: 2018 TX2017-000551 98 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 Land 38,900 81,200 89,300 76,300 86,000 105,500 90,900 99,000 86,000 77,900 90,900 87,700 181,900 79,500 105,500 103,900 lmpr Reason: Attorney: Plaintiff: 66,600 108,900 117,000 104,000 113,700 133,200 118,600 126,700 113,700 105,600 118,600 115,400 209,600 107,200 133,200 131,600 FCV CODE PATTERSON 668 TAX 19 NORTH APPEAL - Per LLC Judgment 1.8© 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8© 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8@ Class SETTLEMENT 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% TX2017-000551 N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C PUC Recommended: RECOMMENDATION 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 Land Basis: Specialist: Appraiser: 22,241 46,425 51,056 43,624 49,170 60,319 51,971 56,602 49,170 44,539 51,971 50,142 103,999 45,453 60,319 59,404 lmpr DEVINE LYLES PETER 38,078 62,262 66,893 59,461 65,007 76,156 67,808 72,439 65,007 60,376 67,808 65,979 119,836 61,290 76,156 75,241 FCV Page: N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C Class 5 of 7 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 Rule 125-25-285 125-25-284 125-25-283 125-25-282 125-25-281 125-25-280 125-25-279 125-25-278 125-25-277 125-25-276 125-25-275 125-25-274 125-25-273 125-25-272 125-25-271 125 -25 Parcel Current: Number Tax Tax Date: -270 Case: Year: 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 1414 PUC of 2018 10-APR-18 Parcels: TX2017-000551 98 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 27,700 Land 116,900 194,900 77,900 82,800 87,700 319,900 87,700 82,800 82,800 82,800 84,400 94,200 99,000 99,000 97,400 110,400 Impr Reason: Attorney: Plaintiff: 144,600 222,600 105,600 110,500 115,400 347,600 115,400 110,500 110,500 110,500 112,100 121,900 126,700 126,700 125,100 138,100 FCV CODE 668 TAX 19 PATTERSON NORTH - APPEAL Per LLC Judgment 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ L8 @ 1.8@ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8@ L8 @ L8@ Class SETTLEMENT 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% TX2017-000551 N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C PUC Recommended: RECOMMENDATION 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 15,837 Land Basis: Specialist: Appraiser: 66,836 111,432 44,539 47,340 50,142 182,900 50,142 47,340 47,340 47,340 48,255 53,858 56,602 56,602 55,687 63,120 lmpr LYLES DEVINE PETER 82,673 127,269 60,376 63,177 65,979 198,737 65,979 63,177 63,177 63,177 64,092 69,695 72,439 72,439 71,524 78,957 FCV Page: N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C Class 6 of 7 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 Rule Totals: 125-25-287 125-25-286 Parcel Current: Number Tax Tax Date: Case: Year: 1414 1414 PLIC of 2018 10-APR-18 Parcels: TX2017 98 -000551 2,714,600 27,700 27,700 Land 15,650,400 68,200 116,900 Impr Reason: Attorney: Plaintiff: 18,365,000 95,900 144,600 FCV CODE PATTERSON 668 TAX 19 - NORTH APPEAL Per LLC Judgment 1.8 @ 1.8 @ Class SETTLEMENT 18% 18% TX2017-000551 N/C N/C PUC Recommended: RECOMMENDATION 1,552,026 15,837 15,837 Land Basis: Specialist: Appraiser: 8,947,974 38,993 66,836 Impr LYLES DEVINE PETER 10,500,000 54,830 82,673 FCV Page: N/C Class 7 of 7 A2 A2 Rule