Extracted text (via pymupdf_layout)
49889 characters
3-29-17.txt Board of Supervisors' Agenda March 29, 2017 2014: TX2013-000159; 2015: Tx2014-000187; TX2014-000214; TX2014-000243; TX2014-000609; TX2014-000619; 2015/2016: TX2015-000355; 2016: TX2015-000344; TX2015-000937; 2016/2017: ST2016-000061; ST2016-000068; TX2016-000127; TX2016-000141; 2016/2017/2018: ST2016-000035; 2017: ST2016-000037; ST2016-000042; ST2016-000050; ST2016-000051; ST2016-000203; Tx2016-000136; TX2016-000890; TX2016-000964; TX2016-000965; TX2016-001203; TX2016-001302; TX2016-001312; TX2017-000215; Page 1 SP2706: *** COVER SHEET *** TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Date: 03/15/2017 Maricopa County 27 Parcels 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 Cty Atty: PAT I ERS ON Prepared by: CHAPPELIN / LYLES Employee #: 7824 / 3683 Tax Case: TX2013-000159 Parcel #: see attached Tax Year: 2014 Mintiffi TARGET CORPORATION ETAL LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 54,079,699 180,112,229 234,191,928 see parcel RECOMMENDED: 54,295,200 131,743,900 186,039,100 TASR's Personal Property: See attached Reason: CODE 19 - Per Judgment TX2013-000159 Current Tax: N/A The Maricopa County Assessor's Office does not provide estimates of recommended Recommended taxes or tax refunds. Tax: N/A Total Refund: N/A Half Refund: N/A 217-13-034C 216-51-090G 208-12-9390 206-09-028 201-08-167 200-53-026 176-09-489 156-35-004J 148-06-551B 142-55-488 140-43-001J 134-26-323N 126-08-137G 122-94-008 102-39-006K -14-010 101 Parcel Current: Number Tax Tax Date: Case: Year 1430 1430 1410 1430 1410 1430 1430 1444 1410 1430 1410 1410 1430 1410 1153 1410 PUC of 2014 15-MAR-17 Parcels TX2013-000159 27 5,128,600 4,472,000 2,426,500 2,206,200 2,198,500 2,298,400 1,915,200 2,283,600 828,600 1,307,300 907,800 1,884,726 2,938,800 1,148,300 652,800 1,362,100 Land 3,336,400 6,344,764 8,788,500 5,689,500 9,119,300 5,828,500 6,430,400 9,481,400 6,661,690 6,671,000 3,831,300 5,331,200 5,298,300 6,399,280 6,251,300 6,757,900 lmpr Reason: Attorney: Plaintiff: 8,465,000 10,816,764 11,215,000 7,895,700 11,317,800 8,126,900 8,345,600 11,765,000 7,490,290 7,978,300 4,739,100 7,215,926 8,237,100 7,547,580 6,904,100 8,120,000 FCV CODE TARGET TAX PATTERSON 19 - APPEAL Per CORPORATION 7,090,419 10,708,596 9,923,514 7,450,757 10,228,910 7,913,194 7,539,384 11,765,000 7,039,978 7,338,546 4,453,034 7,215,926 7,256,035 7,360,986 5,386,582 7,502,000 LPV Judgment 1.8 1.8 1.8 1.8 1.8 1.8 1.8 1.8 1.8 1.8 1.8 1.8 1.8 1.8 1.12 1.8 ETAL SETTLEMENT @19% @ @19% @19% @19% @ @ @ @ @ @19% @19% @19% @ @ @19% Class 19% 19% 19% 19% 19% 19% 19% 19% TX2013-000159 N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C PUC Recommended: RECOMMENDATION N/C N/C 2,416,500 N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C 1,897,000 N/C N/C N/C N/C Land Basis: Specialist: Appraiser: 1,541,400 3,578,000 6,413,500 3,993,800 6,716,500 4,471,600 4,559,800 6,981,400 5,071,400 4,972,700 N/C 3,958,000 3,546,200 4,791,700 4,782,200 5,037,900 lmpr LYLEs CHAPPELL 6,670,000 8,050,000 8,830,000 6,200,000 8,915,000 6,770,000 6,475,000 9,265,000 5,900,000 6,280,000 N/C 5,855,000 6,485,000 5,940,000 5,435,000 6,400,000 FCV NORMAN Page: N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C Class of 1 SP27070 2 A2 B2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 B7 A2 A2 A2 A2 Rule Totals: 501-17-933 500-91-874 500-03-446B 304-55-044 304-29-964A 304-25-909 303-85-686 301-65-900 301-58-884B 219-25-683 218-56-451 Parcel Current: Number Tax Tax Date: Case: Year 1153 1480 1153 1153 1410 1420 1153 1410 1410 1430 1430 PUC of 2014 15-MAR-17 Parcels TX2013-000159 27 54,079,699 1,668,000 783,100 963,000 2,725,100 1,580,800 1,153,400 1,379,600 3,203,100 3,013,473 1,270,500 2,380,200 Land 180,112,229 6,116,657 10,391,500 6,069,424 9,124,760 10,045,100 5,971,700 6,351,400 6,563,850 6,009,404 6,751,500 4,496,200 lmpr Reason: Attorney: Plaintiff: 234,191,928 7,784,657 11,174,600 7,032,424 11,849,860 11,625,900 7,125,100 7,731,000 9,766,950 9,022,877 8,022,000 6,876,400 FCV CODE TARGET TAX PATTERSON 19 - APPEAL Per CORPORATION 215,557,073 7,316,095 9,890,359 6,108,290 10,367,625 10,309,878 6,777,408 7,731,000 8,766,988 8,111,809 7,271,194 6,733,566 LPV Judgment 1.12 1.8 1 12 1.8 1.8 1.8 1.12 1.8 1.8 1.8 1.8 ETAL SETTLEMENT @19% @ 19% @ 19% @ 19% @ 19% @19% @19% @19% @ 19% @ 19% @19% Class TX2013-000159 N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C PUC Recommended: RECOMMENDATION 54,295,200 N/C N/C N/C N/C 1,580,500 N/C N/C N/C 3,227,000 N/C N/C Land Basis: Specialist: Appraiser: 131,743,900 4,462,000 8,016,900 4,577,000 6,604,900 7,574,500 4,616,600 4,920,400 4,486,900 4,153,000 5,049,500 3,034,800 lmpr LYLES CHAPPELL 186,039,100 6,130,000 8,800,000 5,540,000 9,330,000 9,155,000 5,770,000 6,300,000 7,690,000 7,380,000 6,320,000 5,415,000 FCV NORMAN Page: N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C Class 2 of 2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 B7 A2 A2 Rule SP2706: ***COVER SHEET*** TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Date: 03/13/2017 Maricopa County 4 Parcels 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 Cty Atty: PATTERSON Prepared by: CHAPPEL1\ / LYLES Employee #: 7824 / 3683 Tax Case: TX20 14-00 0 1 8 7 Parcel #: see attached Tax Year: 2015 Plantiff: HOME DEPOT U S A INC / SCOTTSDALE FIES LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 16,743,250 15,468,800 32,212,050 see parcel RECOMMENDED: 13,727,718 7,022,282 20,750,000 TASR' s Personal Property: See attached Reason: CODE 19 - Per Judgment TX2014-000187 Current Tax: N/A The Maricopa County Assessor's Office does not provide estimates of recommended Recommended taxes or tax refunds. Tax: N/A Total Refund: N/A Half Refund: N/A Totals: 217-36-980 215-52-036C 215-32-490 215-32-115E Parcel Current: Number Tax Tax Date: Case: Year 1430 1153 1153 8802 PUC of 2015 13-MAR-17 Parcels TX2014-000187 4 16,743,250 6,227,400 6,762,800 3,712,200 40,850 Land 15,468,800 5,428,200 5,177,400 4,758,100 105,100 lmpr Reason: Attorney: Plaintiff: 32,212,050 11,655,600 11,940,200 8,470,300 145,950 FCV CODE HOME TAX PATTERSON 19 - DEPOT APPEAL Per U S A 31,889,625 11,655,600 11,694,060 8,394,015 145,950 LPV Judgment INC / 1.8 1.12 1.12 1.12 SETTLEMENT @ @ @ @ Class SCOTTSDALE 18.5%1 18.5 1 18.5 1 18.5 1 TX2014-000187 N/C N/C N/C N/C PUC FIESTA Recommended: RE1 RECOMMENDATION 13,727,718 5,021,474 4,953,194 N/C N/C Land Basis: Specialist: Appraiser: 7,022,282 2,478,526 2,046,806 2,391,850 N/C IMpr LYLEs CHAPPELL 20,750,000 7,500,000 7,000,000 6,104,050 N/C FCV NORMAN Page: N/C N/C N/C N/C Class of 1 SP27070 1 A2 A2 A2 A2 Rule SP2706: *** COVER SHEET *** TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Date: 03/16/2017 Maricopa County 31 Parcels 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 Cty Atty: PATTERSON Prepared by: CHAPPEL1N / LYLES Employee #: 7824 / 3683 Tax Case: TX2 0 1 4 — 0 02 1 4 Parcel #: see attached Tax Year: 2015 Planta: TARGET CORPORATION LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 56,334,426 188,976,500 245,310,926 parcel see RECOlVEVIENDED: 53,949,226 115,048,774 168,998,000 TASR s Personal Property: See attached Reason: CODE 19 - Per Judgment TX2014-000214 Current Tax: N/A The Maricopa County Assessor's Office does not provide estimates of recommended Recommended taxes or tax refunds. Tax: N/A Total Refund: N/A Half Refund: N/A 201-08-167 200-53-029E 200-53-026 176-09-489 156-35-004J 148-06-554B 148-06-553B 148-06-5510 142-55-488 140-43-001J 134-26-323N 134-26-323L 126-08-137G 122-94-008 102-39-006K 101-14-010 Parcel Current: Number Tax Tax Date: Case: Year 1410 1430 1430 1430 1444 1074 1074 1410 1430 1410 1410 1416 1430 1410 1153 1410 PUC of 2015 16-MAR-17 Parcels TX2014-000214 31 2,198,500 121,700 2,298,400 1,723,700 1,706,700 592,700 66,800 828,600 1,438,000 907,800 1,884,726 173,500 3,499,800 1,205,700 718,100 1,294,000 Land 9,826,500 348,100 5,789,800 7,151,200 6,820,400 6,982,900 6,728,000 4,830,200 5,867,000 4,348,200 6,822,300 6,326,900 7,778,000 IMpr 0 0 0 Reason: Attorney: Plaintiff: 12,025,000 469,800 8,088,200 8,874,900 8,527,100 592,700 66,800 7,811,500 8,166,000 5,738,000 7,751,726 173,500 7,848,000 8,028,000 7,045,000 9,072,000 FCV CODE TARGET TAX PATTERSON 19 - APPEAL Per CORPORATION 10,740,356 469,8001.8 8,088,200 7,916,3531.8 8,527,100 557,382 62,441 7,391,977 7,705,473 4,675,686 7,580,251 173,500 7,618,837 7,729,035 5,655,911 7,877,100 LPV Judgment 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 1.12 1.8 1.8 1.8 1.8 @ 1.8 1.8 @ 1.8 1.8 @ 1.12 1.8 Class SETTLEMENT @18.5% 18.5% @18.5% 18.5% @18.5% @18.5 @18.5% @18.5% @18.5% 18.5% @18.5% 18.5% @18.5% 18.5% @18.5 @18.5% TX2014-000214 N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C PUC Recommended: RECOMMENDATION N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C Land Basis: Specialist: Appraiser: 5,821,500 N/C 3,321,800 4,106,300 6,633,300 N/C N/C 3,811,900 4,217,000 N/C 3,211,774 N/C 2,340,200 4,144,300 4,181,900 4,461,000 Impr LYLES CHAPPELL 8,020,000 5,620,200 5,830,000 8,340,000 4,640,500 5,655,000 5,096,500 5,840,000 5,350,000 4,900,000 5,755,000 FCV NORMAN N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C Page: N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C Class 1 of SP27070 2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 Al Al A2 A2 A2 B7 Al A2 A2 A2 A2 Rule Totals: 501-17-933 500-91-874 500-03-446B 304-55-044 304-29-964A 304-25-909 303-85-686 301-65-900 301-58-8846 219-25-683 218-56-451 217-13-034C 216-51-090G 208-12-9390 206-09-028 Parcel Current: Number Tax Case: Tax Date: Year 1410 1480 1410 1410 1410 1420 1153 1410 1410 1430 1430 1430 1430 1410 1430 PUC of Parcels 2015 16-MAR-17 TX2014-000214 31 56,334,426 1,284,700 861,400 1,059,300 3,068,200 1,675,600 1,222,600 1,448,600 3,363,300 3,185,000 1,270,500 2,523,100 5,385,100 4,695,600 2,426,500 2,206,200 Land 188,976,500 7,701,300 10,582,600 7,181,700 8,937,800 10,358,400 6,813,400 8,335,500 6,883,700 6,186,000 7,234,500 5,132,900 3,720,900 4,978,400 9,601,500 5,708,400 lmpr Reason: Attorney: Plaintiff: 245,310,926 8,986,000 11,444,000 8,241,000 12,006,000 12,034,000 8,036,000 9,784,100 10,247,000 9,371,000 8,505,000 7,656,000 9,106,000 9,674,000 12,028,000 7,914,600 FCV CODE PATTERSON TARGET TAX 19 - APPEAL Per CORPORATION 224,387,459 8,356,9801.8 10,384,877 7,664,130 11,165,5801.8 10,825,3721.8 7,116,278 8,117,550 9,205,337 8,715,030 7,634,7541.8 7,070,244 7,444,940 9,674,000 10,419,6901.8 7,823,295 LPV Judgment SETTLEMENT @ 1.8 1.8 @ @ 1.8 1.12 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ Class 18.5% @18.5% 18.5% 18.5% @18.5% @18.5% 18.5 18.5% @18.5% 18.5% @18.5% 18.5% 18.5% @18.5% 18.5% TX2014-000214 N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C PUC Recommended: RECOMMENDATION 53,949,226 N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C 3,000,000 4,695,500 N/C N/C Land Basis: Specialist: Appraiser: 115,048,774 4,235,300 7,058,600 3,940,700 5,331,800 6,564,400 3,977,400 4,251,400 3,536,700 3,455,000 4,429,500 2,376,900 3,000,000 2,544,500 5,523,500 3,393,800 Impr LYLES CHAPPELL 168,998,000 5,520,000 7,920,000 5,000,000 8,400,000 8,240,000 5,200,000 5,700,000 6,900,000 6,640,000 5,700,000 4,900,000 6,000,000 7,240,000 7,950,000 5,600,000 FCV NORMAN Page: N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C Class 2 of 2 B9 A2 B9 B9 A2 A2 A2 A2 B2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 Rule SP2706: COVER SHEET *** TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Date: 03/13/2017 Maricopa County 4 Parcels 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 Cty Atty: PATTERSON Prepared by: CHAPPEL1N / LYLES Employee #: 7824 / 3683 Tax Case: TX2014-000243 Parcel #: see attached Tax Year: 2015 Plantiff: HD DEVELOPMENT OF MARYLAND INC LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 9,994,400 16,176,900 26,171,300 parcel see RECOMMENDED: 9,992,400 7,917,600 17,910,000 TASR s Personal Property: See attached Reason: CODE 19 - Per Judgment TX2014-000243 Current Tax: N/A The Maricopa County Assessor's Office does not provide estimates of recommended Recommended taxes or tax refunds. Tax: N/A Total Refund: N/A Half Refund: N/A Totals: 303-31-212A 301-84-197 301-84-192 218-56-437 Parcel Current: Number Tax Tax Date: Case: Year 1410 1074 1480 1153 PUC of 2015 13-MAR-17 Parcels TX2014-000243 4 9,994,400 1,872,700 365,500 3,916,000 3,840,200 Land 16,176,900 7,475,800 4,890,100 3,811,000 lmpr 0 Reason: Attorney: Plaintiff: 26,171,300 9,348,500 365,500 8,806,100 7,651,200 FCV CODE HD TAX PATTERSON 19 - DEVELOPMENT APPEAL Per 25,286,538 9,348,500 365,500 8,189,6731.8 7,382,865 LPV Judgment OF 1.12 1.12 @ 1.12 MARYLAND SETTLEMENT @ @ @ Class 18.5 1 18.5 1 18.5%1 18.51 TX2014-000243 INC N/C N/C N/C N/C PUC Recommended: RECOMMENDATION 9,992,400 N/C 363,500 N/C N/C Land Basis: Specialist: Appraiser: 7,917,600 3,877,300 N/C 1,880,500 2,159,800 lmpr LYLES CHAPPELL 17,910,000 5,750,000 363,500 5,796,500 6,000,000 FCV NORMAN Page: N/C N/C N/C N/C Class 1 of SP27070 1 A2 Al B9 A2 Rule SP27060 TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 Cty Atty: LEIBSOHN Prepared by: BARR / LYLES Date: 03/20/2017 Employee #: 7550 / 3683 Tax Case: TX2014-000609 Parcel #: 121-70-099J Year: 2015 Plantiff PRESIDENT PARTNERS LIMITED PARTNERSHIP LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 1,742,000 6,968,000 8,710,000 10.00 % RECOMMENDED: 740,000 2,960,000 3,700,000 N/C Recommended LPV calculation used: Personal Prop: N/A Basis: Reason: CODE 19 - Per Judgment TX2014 -000609 Current Tax: N/A The Maricopa County Assessor's Office does not provide estimates of recommended Recommended taxes or tax refunds. Tax: N/A Total Refund: N/A Half Refund: N/A LEGAL CLASSIFICATION : LAND 100 % CLASS 4.2 @ 10.00 % 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % PUC IMPS 100 % CLASS 4.2 0374 0 % CLASS 0 % CLASS SP27060 TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 Cty Arty: LEIBSOHN Prepared by: BARR / LYLES Date: 03/17/2017 Employee #• 7550 / 3683 Tax Case: TX2014-000619 Parcel #: 135-56-010L Year: 2015 Plantiff ALGARVE LP / MIDTOWN MESA LP LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 850,100 3,400,700 4,250,800 10.00 % RECOMMENDED: 439,969 1,760,031 2,200,000 N/C (Y0 Recommended LPV calculation used: Personal Prop: N/A Basis: Reason: CODE 19 - Per Judgment TX2014-000619 Current Tax: N/A The Maricopa County Assessor's Office does not provide estimates of recommended Recommended taxes or tax refunds. Tax: N/A Total Refund: N/A Half Refund: N/A LEGAL CLASSIFICATION : LAND 100 % CLASS 4.2 @ 10.00 % 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % PUC IMPS 100 % CLASS 4.2 @ 10.00 % 0366 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % 0 % CLASS g 0.00 % 2015 / 2016 SP27060 TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 Cty Atty: LEIBSOHN Prepared by: BARR / LYLES Date: 03/07/2017 Employee #: 7550 / 3683 Tax Case: TX2015-000355 Parcel #: 215-32-003U Year: 2015 Plantiff: UIRC-GSA PHOENIX AZ LLC LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 1,029,800 2,566,100 3,595,900 18.50 % RECOMMENDED: 801,869 1,998,131 2,800,000 N/C % Recommended LPV calculation used: Personal Prop: N/A Basis: Reason: CODE 19 - Per Judgment TX2015-000355 Current Tax: N/A The Maricopa County Assessor's Office does not provide estimates of recommended Recommended taxes or tax refunds. Tax: N/A Total Refund: N/A Half Refund: N/A LEGAL CLASSIFICATION : LAND 100 % CLASS 1.12 @ 18.50 % 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % PUC IMPS 100 % CLASS 1.12 @ 18.50 % 1511 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % SP27060 TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 Cty. Atty: LEIBSOHN Prepared by: BARR / LYLES Date: 03/07/2017 Employee #: 7550 / 3683 Tax Case: TX2015-000355 Parcel #: 215-32-003U Year: 2016 Plantiff UIRC—GSA PHOENIX AZ LLC LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 1,252,200 2,670,200 3,922,400 18.00 % RECOMMENDED: 893,881 1,906,119 2,800,000 N/C % Recommended LPV calculation used: Personal Prop: N/A Basis: Reason: CODE 19 - Per Judgment TX2015-000355 Current Tax: N/A The Maricopa County Assessor's Office does not provide estimates of recommended Recommended taxes or tax refunds. Tax: N/A Total Refund: N/A Half Refund: N/A LEGAL CLASSIFICATION : LAND 100 % CLASS 1.12 @ 18.00 % 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % PUC IMPS 100 % CLASS 1.12 @ 18.00 % 1511 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % SP2706: *** COVER SHEET *** TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Date: 03/16/2017 Maricopa County 31 Parcels 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 Cty Atty: PATTERSON Prepared by: CHAPPELI\ / LYLES Employee #: 7824 / 3683 Tax Case: TX2015— 000344 Parcel #: see attached Tax Year: 2016 Plaintiff: TARGET CORPORATION LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 61,796,800 213,697,900 275,494,700 parcel see RECOMMENDED: N/C 144,266,256 206,063,056 TASR s Personal Property: See attached Reason: CODE 19 - Per Judgment TX2015-000344 Current Tax: N/A The Maricopa County Assessor's Office does not provide estimates of recommended Recommended taxes or tax refunds. Tax: N/A Total Refund: N/A Half Refund: N/A 201-08-167 200-53-029E 200-53-026 176-09-489 156-35-004J 148-06-554B 148-06-553B 148-06-551B 142-55-488 140-43-001J 134-26-323N 134-26-323L 126-08-137G 122-94-008 102-39-006K 101-14-010 Parcel Current: Number Tax Tax Date: Case: Year 1410 1430 1430 1430 1444 1074 1074 1410 1430 1410 1410 1416 1430 1410 1153 1410 PUG of 2016 16-MAR-17 Parcels TX2015-000344 31 2,753,300 127,500 2,408,200 2,531,600 1,812,500 516,000 58,100 721,300 1,508,700 970,700 2,195,800 318,700 4,902,500 3,226,700 738,700 1,309,400 Land 12,696,600 371,400 5,071,200 7,249,600 10,304,300 9,115,800 6,726,200 4,295,600 8,040,500 5,645,600 7,997,400 7,086,500 8,327,800 IMpr 0 0 0 Reason: Attorney: Plaintiff: 15,449,900 498,900 7,479,400 9,781,200 12,116,800 516,000 58,100 9,837,100 8,234,900 5,266,300 10,236,300 318,700 10,548,100 11,224,100 7,825,200 9,637,200 FCV CODE TARGET TAX PATTERSON 19 - APPEAL Per CORPORATION 11,277,374 493,290 7,479,400 8,312,171 8,953,455 516,000 58,100 7,761,576 8,090,747 4,909,470 7,959,264 182,175 7,999,779 8,115,487 5,938,707 8,270,955 LPV Judgment SETTLEMENT 1.8 1.8 1.8 1.8 1.8 1.12 1.8 1.8 1.8 1.8 1.8 1.8 1.8 1.8 1.12 1.8 @18% @ @ @18% @18% @16% @ @18% @ @18% @ @ @ @ @ @18% Class 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% TX2015-000344 N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C PUC Recommended: RECOMMENDATION N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C Land Basis: Specialist: Appraiser: 7,125,017 4,595,422 4,647,093 7,588,628 5,242,219 5,454,860 3,974,617 2,286,944 3,360,922 5,287,285 5,777,838 Impr N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C LYLES CHAPPELL 9,878,317 7,003,622 7,178,693 9,401,128 5,963,519 6,963,560 6,170,417 7,189,444 6,587,622 6,025,985 7,087,238 FCV NORMAN N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C Page: N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C Class 1 of sP27070 2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 Al Al A2 A2 A2 A3 Al A2 A2 A2 A2 Rule Totals: 501-17-933 500-91-874 500-03-4468 304-55-044 304-29-964A 304-25-909 303-85-686 301-65-900 301-58-884B 219-25-683 218-56-451 217-13-034C 216-51-090G 208-12-939D 206-09-028 Parcel Current: Number Tax Tax Date: Case: Year 1410 1480 1410 1410 1410 1420 1153 1410 1410 1430 1430 1430 1430 1410 1430 PUC of 2016 16-MAR-17 Parcels TX2015-000344 31 61,796,800 970,600 929,300 1,188,000 3,266,000 1,673,300 1,263,300 1,633,600 3,821,600 2,900,300 1,834,800 2,423,000 5,898,100 2,804,500 2,274,700 2,816,000 Land 213,697,900 7,196,100 12,048,400 6,493,600 11,924,700 11,788,700 5,312,200 9,599,600 8,262,000 7,844,000 6,805,200 4,867,700 5,100,900 7,006,100 10,457,300 6,062,900 lmpr Reason: Attorney: Plaintiff: 275,494,700 8,166,700 12,977,700 7,681,600 15,190,700 13,462,000 6,575,500 11,233,200 12,083,600 10,744,300 8,640,000 7,290,700 10,999,000 9,810,600 12,732,000 8,878,900 FCV CODE TARGET TAX PATTERSON 19 - APPEAL Per CORPORATION 232,166,299 8,166,700 10,904,121 7,681,600 11,723,859 11,366,641 6,575,500 8,523,428 9,665,604 9,150,782 8,016,492 7,290,700 7,817,187 9,810,600 10,940,675 8,214,460 LPV Judgment 1.8 1.8 @ 1.8 1.8 1.8 1.8 1.12 1.8 1.8 1.8 @ 1.8 1.8 1.8 1.8 1.8 Class SETTLEMENT @18% 18% @ 18% @ 18% @ 18% @ 18% @18% @18% @18% 18% @18% @18% @18% @18% @18% TX2015-000344 N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C PUC Recommended: RECOMMENDATION 61,796,800 N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C Land Basis: Specialist: Appraiser: 144,266,256 5,823,946 8,824,031 4,949,988 7,076,706 8,473,931 5,133,259 6,226,400 4,703,116 5,276,208 5,166,902 3,578,808 1,490,258 5,945,500 7,513,892 4,075,466 lmpr LYLES CHAPPELL 206,063,056 6,794,546 9,753,331 6,137,988 10,342,706 10,147,231 6,396,559 7,860,000 8,524,716 8,176,508 7,001,702 6,001,808 7,388,358 8,750,000 9,788,592 6,891,466 FCV NORMAN Page: N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C Class 2 of 2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 Rule SP27060 TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 CtyAtty.. LEIBSOHN Prepared by: BARR / LYLES Date: 03/20/2017 Employee #• 7550 / 3683 Tax Case: TX2015-000937 Parcel #• 121-70-099J Year: 2016 Plantiffi PRESIDENT PARTNERS LIMITED PARTNERSHIP LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 1,613,360 7,504,000 9,117,360 10.00 % RECOMMENDED: 690,123 3,209,877 3,900,000 N/C % Recommended LPV calculation used: Personal Prop: N/A Basis: Reason: CODE 19 - Per Judgment TX2015-000937 Current Tax: N/A The Maricopa County Assessor's Office does not provide estimates of recommended Recommended taxes or tax refunds. Tax: N/A Total Refund: N/A Half Refund: N/A LEGAL CLASSIFICATION : LAND 100 % CLASS 4.2 @ 10.00 ')/0 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 °A PUC IMPS 100 % CLASS 4.2 0374 0 °A CLASS 0 % CLASS SP2706: *** COVER SHEET *** TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Date: 03/16/2017 Maricopa County 2 Parcels 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 Cty Atty: LEIB S OHN Prepared by: BARR / LYLES Employee #: 7550 / 3683 Tax Case: ST201 6-000061 Parcel #: see attached Tax Year: 2016 Planta: J & D CONCEPTS LLC LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 802,700 0 802,700 parcel see RECOMMENDED: 350,000 N/C 350,000 TASR's Personal Property: See attached Reason: CODE 19 - Per Judgment ST2016-000061 Current Tax: N/A The Maricopa County Assessor's Office does not provide estimates of recommended Recommended taxes or tax refunds. Tax: N/A Total Refund: N/A Half Refund: N/A Totals: 206-04-027C 206-04-027A Parcel Current: Number Tax Tax Date: Case: Year 0022 0022 PUC of ST2016 2016 16-MAR-17 Parcels 2 -000061 802,700 326,900 475,800 Land 0 0 o Impr Reason: Attorney: Plaintiff: 802,700 326,900 475,800 FCV CODE LEIBSOHN J & D TAX 19 - CONCEPTS APPEAL Per LLC 791,280 317,730 473,550 LPV Judgment SETTLEMENT 2.R 2.R @15% @ Class ST2016 15% I N/C I N/C PUC -000061 Recommended: RECOMMENDATION 350,000 142,538 207,462 Land Basis: Specialist: Appraiser: 0 N/C N/C Impr LYLES BARR MARY 350,000 142,538 207,462 FCV Page: N/C N/C Class 1 of SP27070 1 Al Al Rule SP2706: ***COVER SHEET*** TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Date: 03/16/2017 Maricopa County 2 Parcels 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 Cty Atty: LEIBSOHN Prepared by: BARR / LYLES Employee #: 7550 / 3683 Tax Case: ST2016-000061 Parcel #: see attached Tax Year: 2 017 Plantiff: J & D CONCEPTS LLC LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 728,000 0 728,000 parcel see RECOMMENDED: 350,000 N/C 350,000 TASR's Personal Property: See attached Reason: CODE 19 - Per Judgment ST2016-000061 Current Tax: N/A The Maricopa County Assessor's Office does not provide estimates of recommended Recommended taxes or tax refunds. Tax: N/A Total Refund: N/A Half Refund: N/A Totals: 206-04-027C 206-04-027A Parcel Current: Number Tax Tax Date: Case: Year 0022 0022 PUC of 2017 16-MAR-17 Parcels ST2016-000061 2 728,000 291,400 436,600 Land 0 0 0 lmpr Reason: Attorney: Plaintiff: J & TAX 728,000 291,400 436,600 FCV CODE LEIBSOHN D 19 - CONCEPTS APPEAL Per LLC 728,000 291,400 436,600 LPV Judgment SETTLEMENT 2.R @ 2.R @ Class 15% 15% ST2016-000061 I I N/C N/C PUC Recommended: RECOMMENDATION 350,000 140,096 209,904 Land Basis: Specialist: Appraiser: 0 N/C N/C lmpr LYLES BARR MARY 350,000 140,096 209,904 FCV Page: N/C N/C Class 1 of SP27070 1 Al Al Rule SP27060 TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 Cty Atty: LEIBSOHN Prepared by: BARR / LYLES Date: 03/10/2017 Employee #: 7550 / 3683 Tax Case: ST2016-000068 Parcel #: 139-08-459B Year: 2016 Plantiff: BTNJ PROPERTY MANAGEMENT LLC LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 246,000 231,300 477,300 18.00 % RECOMMENDED: 141,735 133,265 275,000 N/C Recommended LPV calculation used: Personal Prop: N/A Basis: Reason: CODE 19 - Per Judgment ST2016-000068 Current Tax: N/A The Maricopa County Assessor's Office does not provide estimates of recommended Recommended taxes or tax refunds. Tax: N/A Total Refund: N/A Half Refund: N/A LEGAL CLASSIFICATION : LAND 100 % CLASS 1.12 @ 18.00 % 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % PUC IMPS 100 % CLASS 1.12 @ 18.00 % 1760 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % 0 % CLASS g 0.00 % SP27060 TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 Cty Atty: LEIBSOI-IN Prepared by: BARR / LYLES Date: 03/10/2017 Employee #: 7550 / 3683 Tax Case: ST2016-000068 Parcel #: 139-08-459B Year: 201 7 Plantiff BTNLT PROPERTY MANAGEMENT LLC LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 289,600 253,000 542,600 18.00 % RECOMMENDED: 141,735 133,265 275,000 N/C °A) Recommended LPV calculation used.. Personal Prop: N/A Basis: Reason: CODE 19 - Per Judgment ST2016-000068 Current Tax: N/A The Maricopa County Assessor's Office does not provide estimates of recommended Recommended taxes or tax refunds. Tax: N/A Total Refund: N/A Half Refund: N/A LEGAL CLASSIFICATION : LAND 100 % CLASS 1.12 @ 18.00 % 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 °/,, PUC IMPS 100 % CLASS 1.12 @ 18.00 % 1760 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % SP27060 TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 Cty Atty: PALMER Prepared by: BARR / LYLES Date; 03/17/2017 Employee #: 7550 / 3683 Tax Case: TX2016-000127 Parcel #: 215-07-238 Year: 2016 Plantiff TORINO HOLDINGS LLC LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 9,682,000 0 9,682,000 15.00 % RECOMMENDED: 6,750,000 N/C 6,750,000 N/C % Recommended LPV calculation used: Personal Prop: N/A Basis: Reason; CODE 19 - Per Judgment TX2016-000127 Current Tax; N/A The Maricopa County Assessor's Office does not provide estimates of recommended Recommended taxes or tax refunds. Tax: N/A Total Refund; N/A Half Refund: N/A LEGAL CLASSIFICATION : LAND 100 % CLASS 2.R @ 15.00 % 0 °A) CLASS @ 0.00 % 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % PUC IMPS 0 % CLASS 0021 0 % CLASS 0 % CLASS • SP27060 TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 Cty Atty: PALMER Prepared by: BARR / LYLES Date: 03/17/2017 Employee #: 7550 / 3683 Tax Case: TX2016-000127 Parcel #: 215-07-238 Year: 2017 Plantiff: TORINO HOLDINGS LLC LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 17,491,500 0 17,491,500 15.00 % RECOMMENDED: 6,750,000 N/C 6,750,000 N/C % Recommended LPV calculation used: Personal Prop: N/A Basis: Reason: CODE 19 - Per Judgment TX2016-000127 Current Tax: N/A The Maricopa County Assessor's Office does not provide estimates of recommended Recommended taxes or tax refunds. Tax: N/A Total Refund: N/A Half Refund: N/A LEGAL CLASSIFICATION : LAND 100 % CLASS 2.R @ 15.00 % 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % PUC IMPS 0 % CLASS 0.00 % 0021 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % SP2706! *** COVER SHEET *** TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Date: 03/09/2017 Maricopa County 9 Parcels 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 Cty Atty: LEIBSOHN Prepared by: ANDZIEWI / LYLES Employee #: 7635 / 3683 Tax Case: TX2016-000141 Parcel #: see attached Tax Year: 2 016 Plantiff: AZCF1 LLC LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 2,798,100 0 2,798,100 see parcel RECOMMENDED: 1,600,000 N/C 1,600,000 TASR's Personal Property: See attached Reason: CODE 19 - Per Judgment TX2016-000141 Current Tax: N/A The Maricopa County Assessor's Office does not provide estimates of recommended Recommended taxes or tax refunds. Tax: N/A Total Refund: N/A Half Refund: N/A Totals: 115-37-175 115-37-174 115-37-173 115-37-172 115-37-171 115-37-170 115-37-169 115-37-168 115-37-167A Parcel Current: Number Tax Tax Date: Case: Year 0031 0031 0031 0031 0031 0031 0031 0031 0031 PUC of TX2016 2016 09-MAR-17 Parcels 9 -000141 2,798,100 84,600 73,400 115,900 480,500 626,200 497,800 395,400 413,600 110,700 Land 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Impr Reason: Attorney: Plaintiff: TAX 2,798,100 84,600 73,400 115,900 480,500 626,200 497,800 395,400 413,600 110,700 FCV CODE LEIBSOHN AZCF1 19 - LLC APPEAL Per 2,745,645 83,055 72,030 113,820 471,450 614,460 488,460 387,975 405,825 108,570 LPV Judgment SETTLEMENT 2.R 2.R 2.R 2.R 2.R 2.R 2.R 2.R 2.R @ @ @ @15% @ @ @15% @15% @ Class TX2016 15% 15% 15% 15% 15% 15% 3077 3077 3077 3077 3077 3077 3077 3077 3077 PUC -000141 Recommended: RECOMMENDATION 1,600,000 36,000 30,000 52,000 284,000 390,000 296,000 225,000 238,000 49,000 Land Basis: Specialist: Appraiser: 0 N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C Impr LYLES ANDZIEWICZ 1,600,000 36,000 30,000 52,000 284,000 390,000 296,000 225,000 238,000 49,000 FCV KEITH Page: N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C Class 1 of sp27070 1 Al Al Al Al Al Al Al Al Al Rule SP2706: *** COVER SHEET *** TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Date: 03/09/2017 Maricopa County 9 Parcels 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 Cty Atty: LEIBSOHN Prepared by: ANDZIEWI / LYLES Employee #: 7635 / 3683 Tax Case: TX2 0 1 6-0 0 0 1 4 1 Parcel #: see attached Tax Year: 2017 Plantiff: AZCF1 LLC LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 2,993,900 0 2,993,900 see parcel RECOMMENDED: 1,600,000 N/C 1,600,000 TASR's Personal Property: See attached Reason: CODE 19 - Per Judgment TX2016-000141 Current Tax: N/A The Maricopa County Assessor's Office does not provide estimates of recommended Recommended taxes or tax refunds. Tax: N/A Total Refund: N/A Half Refund: N/A Totals: 115-37-175 115-37-174 115-37-173 115-37-172 115-37-171 115-37-170 115-37-169 115-37-168 115-37-167A Parcel Current: Number Tax Tax Date: Case: Year 0031 0031 0031 0031 0031 0031 0031 0031 0031 PUC of 2017 09-MAR-17 Parcels TX2016-000141 9 2,993,900 90,600 78,600 124,100 514,100 670,000 532,600 423,000 442,500 118,400 Land 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Impr Reason: Attorney: Plaintiff: TAX 2,993,900 90,600 78,600 124,100 514,100 670,000 532,600 423,000 442,500 118,400 FCV CODE LEIBSOHN AZCF1 19 LLC APPEAL - Per 2,882,929 87,208 75,632 119,511 495,023 645,183 512,883 407,374 426,116 113,999 LPV Judgment SETTLEMENT 2.R 2.R 2.R 2.R 2.R 2.R 2.R 2.R 2.R @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ Class 15% 15% 15% 15% 15% 15% 15% 15% 15% TX2016-000141 3077 3077 3077 3077 3077 3077 3077 3077 3077 PUC Recommended: RECOMMENDATION 1,600,000 36,000 30,000 52,000 284,000 390,000 296,000 225,000 238,000 49,000 Land Basis: Specialist: Appraiser: 0 N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C lmpr LYLES ANDZIEWICZ 1,600,000 36,000 30,000 52,000 284,000 390,000 296,000 225,000 238,000 49,000 FCV KEITH Page: N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C Class 1 of SP27070 1 Al Al Al Al Al Al Al Al Al Rule SP2706: COVER SHEET *** TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Date: 03/14/2017 Maricopa County 3 Parcels 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 Cty Atty: LEIBSOHN Prepared by: BARR / LYLES Employee #: 7550 / 3683 Tax Case: ST201 6 —000035 Parcel #: see attached Tax Year: 2016 plantun SDKR HOLDINGS LLC / CROCKETT RANDALL LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 184,800 851,000 1,035,800 parcel see RECOMMENDED: 80,286 369,714 450,000 TASR s Personal Property: See attached Reason: CODE 19 - Per Judgment ST2016-000035 Current Tax: N/A The Maricopa County Assessor's Office does not provide estimates of recommended Recommended taxes or tax refunds. Tax: N/A Total Refund: N/A Half Refund: N/A Totals: 301-42-022 301-42-021 301-42-001D Parcel Current: Number Tax Tax Date: Case: Year 2640 2590 2650 PUC of 2016 14-MAR-17 Parcels ST2016-000035 3 184,800 48,100 67,200 69,500 Land 851,000 43,400 807,600 0 Impr Reason: Attorney: Plaintiff: 1,035,800 91,500 874,800 69,500 FCV CODE LEIBSOHN SDKR TAX 19 - HOLDINGS APPEAL Per LLC 917,205 91,500 756,205 69,500 LPV Judgment / 1.12 1.12 M @ CROCKETT SETTLEMENT @ @ 16.5% Class 18% I 18%I I PUC ST2016-000035 RANDALL N/C N/C N/C Recommended: RECOMMENDATION 80,286 20,897 29,195 30,194 Land Basis: Specialist: Appraiser: 369,714 18,855 350,859 N/C Impr LYLES BARR MARY 450,000 39,752 380,054 30,194 FCV Page: N/C N/C N/C Class 1 of SP27070 1 A2 A2 Al Rule SP2706: *** COVER SHEET ***. TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Date: 03/14/2017 Maricopa County 3 Parcels 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 Cty Atty: LEIBSOHN Prepared by: BARR / LYLES Employee #: 7550 / 3683 Tax Case: ST201 6-000035 Parcel #: see attached Tax Year: 2017 Planta: SDKR HOLDINGS LLC / CROCKETT RANDALL LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 184,300 924,100 1,108,400 see parcel RECOMMENDED: 80,286 369,714 450,000 TASR s Personal Property: See attached Reason: CODE 19 - Per Judgment ST2016-000035 Current Tax: N/A The Maricopa County Assessor's Office does not provide estimates of recommended Recommended taxes or tax refunds. Tax: N/A Total Refund: N/A Half Refund: N/A Totals: 301-42-022 301-42-021 301-42-001D Parcel Current: Number Tax Tax Date: Case: Year 2640 2590 2650 PUC of 2017 14-MAR-17 Parcels ST2016-000035 3 184,300 45,600 63,700 75,000 Land 924,100 47,600 876,500 0 Impr Reason: Attorney: Plaintiff: SDKR TAX 1,108,400 93,200 940,200 75,000 FCV CODE LEIBSOHN 19 HOLDINGS APPEAL - Per LLC / 960,190 93,200 794,015 72,975 LPV Judgment SETTLEMENT 1.12 1.12 M @ CROCKETT @18% @ 16.5% Class I 18%1 I PUC ST2016-000035 RANDALL N/C N/C N/C Recommended: RECOMMENDATION 80,286 20,897 29,195 30,194 Land Basis: Specialist: Appraiser: 369,714 18,855 350,859 N/C Impr LYLES BARR MARY 450,000 39,752 380,054 30,194 FCV Page: N/C N/C N/C Class 1 of SP27070 1 A2 A2 Al Rule SP2706: *** COVER SHEET *** TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Date: 03/14/2017 Maricopa County 3 Parcels 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 Cty Atty: LEIBSOHN Prepared by: BARR / LYLES Employee #: 7550 / 3683 Tax Case: ST2016-000035 Parcel #: see attached Tax Year: 2018 SDKR HOLDINGS LLC / CROCKETT RANDALL LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 199,000 800,500 999,500 see parcel RECOMMENDED: 80,286 369,714 450,000 TASR' s Personal Property: See attached Reason: CODE 19 - Per Judgment ST2016-000035 Current Tax: N/A The Maricopa County Assessor's Office does not provide estimates of recommended Recommended taxes or tax refunds. Tax: N/A Total Refund: N/A Half Refund: N/A Totals: 301-42-022 301-42-021 301-42-001D Parcel Current: Number Tax Tax Date: Case: Year 2640 2590 2650 PUC of 2018 14-MAR-17 Parcels ST2016-000035 3 199,000 49,200 68,800 81,000 Land 800,500 32,500 768,000 0 Impr Reason: Attorney: Plaintiff: 999,500 81,700 836,800 81,000 FCV CODE LEIBSOHN SDKR TAX 19 - HOLDINGS APPEAL Per LLC 992,040 81,700 833,716 76,624 LPV Judgment / 1.12 1.12 M CROCKETT SETTLEMENT @ @18%! @16.5% Class 18%I I ST2016-000035 N/C N/C N/C PUC RANDALL Recommended: RECOMMENDATION 80,286 20,897 29,195 30,194 Land Basis: Specialist: Appraiser: 369,714 18,855 350,859 N/C Impr LYLES BARR MARY 450,000 39,752 380,054 30,194 FCV Page: N/C N/C N/C Class 1 of SP27070 1 A2 A2 Al Rule SP2706: *** COVER SHEET *** TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Date: 03/10/2017 Maricopa County 2 Parcels 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 Cty Atty: LElBSOHN Prepared by: BARR / LYLES Employee #: 7550 / 3683 Tax Case: ST2016-000037 Parcel #: see attached Tax Year: 2 0 1 7 Plantiffi PANAGIOTAKOPOULOS ALEXANDER LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 154,300 617,200 771,500 parcel see RECOMMENDED: 108,000 432,000 540,000 TASR's Personal Property: See attached Reason: CODE 19 - Per Judgment ST2016-000037 Current Tax: N/A The Maricopa County Assessor's Office does not provide estimates of recommended Recommended taxes or tax refunds. Tax: N/A Total Refund: N/A Half Refund: N/A Totals: 160-34-006B 160-34-006A Parcel Current: Number Tax Tax Date: Case: Year 0151 0197 PUC of 2017 10-MAR-17 Parcels ST2016-000037 2 154,300 107,962 46,338 Land 617,200 617,200 0 lmpr Reason: Attorney: Plaintiff: TAX 771,500 725,162 46,338 FCV CODE LEIBSOHN 19 - PANAGIOTAKOPOULOS APPEAL Per 154,300 107,962 46,338 LPV Judgment SETTLEMENT 4.2 2.R ALEXANDER @ @ Class 10% I 15% I ST2016-000037 N/C N/C PUC Recommended: RECOMMENDATION 108,000 75,566 32,434 Land Basis: Specialist: Appraiser: 432,000 432,000 N/C Impr LYLEs BARR MARY 540,000 507,566 32,434 FCV Page: 3. @10% N/C Class 1 of SP27070 1 B7 B7 Rule SP27060 TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 Cry Arty: LEIBSOHN Prepared by: BARR / LYLES Date: 03/10/2017 Employee #: 7550 / 3683 Tax Case: ST2016-000042 Parcel #: 106-22-014B Year: 2017 Plantiffi LONGMEADOW PROPERTIES LLP LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 253,700 184,000 437,700 18.00 % RECOMMENDED: 165,192 119,808 285,000 N/C % Recommended LPV calculation used: Personal Prop: N/A Basis: Reason: CODE 19 - Per Judgment ST2016-000042 Current Tax: N/A The Maricopa County Assessor's Office does not provide estimates of recommended Recommended taxes or tax refunds. Tax: N/A Total Refund: N/A Half Refund: N/A LEGAL CLASSIFICATION : LAND 100 % CLASS 1.12 @ 18.00 % 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % PUC IMPS 100 % CLASS 1.12 @ 18.00 % 1040 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % 0 % CLASS g 0.00 % SP27060 TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 Cty Atty: LEIBSOHN Prepared by: BARR / LYLES Date: 03/17/2017 Employee #: 7550 / 3683 Tax Case: ST2016-000050 Parcel #: 304 -28 - 798 Year: 2017 Plantiffi EM-50 UAV SLBCO LLC LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 339,100 1,511,400 1,850,500 18.00 % RECOMMENDED: 164,923 735,077 900,000 N/C % Recommended LPV calculation used: Personal Prop: N/A Basis: Reason: CODE 19 - Per Judgment ST2016-000050 Current Tax: N/A The Maricopa County Assessor's' Office does not provide estimates of recommended Recommended taxes or tax refunds. Tax: N/A Total Refund: N/A Half Refund: N/A LEGAL CLASSIFICATION : LAND 100 °A) CLASS 1.12 @ 18.00 % 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % PUC IMPS 100 % CLASS 1.12 @ 18.00 % 1140 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 (3/0 0 °A) CLASS g 0.00 % SP27060 TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 Cty Arty: LEIBSOHN Prepared by: BARR / LYLES Date: 03/13/2017 Employee #: 7550 / 3683 Tax Case: ST2016-000051 Parcel #: 145-07-003G Year: 2017 Plantiff MISSOURI PLAZA LLC LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 153,800 464,700 618,500 15.38 % RECOMMENDED: 99,466 300,534 400,000 N/C % Recommended LPV calculation used.. Personal Prop: N/A Basis: Reason: CODE 19 - Per Judgment ST2016-000051 Current Tax: N/A The Maricopa County Assessor's Office does not provide estimates of recommended Recommended taxes or tax refunds. Tax.. N/A Total Refund: N/A Half Refund: N/A LEGAL CLASSIFICATION : LAND 89 % CLASS 1.12 @ 18.00 % 11 °A) CLASS 4.3 @ 10.00 °A 0 °A) CLASS @ 0.00 % PUC CHANGE TO: IMPS 60 % CLASS 1.12 @ 18.00 % 0013 40 % CLASS 4.3 @ 10.00 % 0 °A CLASS @ 0.00 % SP27060 TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 Cty Atty: LE1BSOHN Prepared by: BARR / LYLES Date: 03/13/2017 Employee #: 7550 / 3683 Tax Case: ST2016-000203 Parcel #: 300-05-090 Year: 2017 Plantiff NEESE DONALD STEVEN LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 105,800 423,300 529,100 10.00 % RECOMMENDED: 93,982 376,018 470,000 N/C % Recommended LPV calculation used: Personal Prop: N/A Basis: Reason: CODE 19 - Per Judgment ST2016-000203 Current Tax: N/A The Maricopa County Assessor's Office does not provide estimates of recommended Recommended taxes or tax refunds. Tax: N/A Total Refund: N/A Half Refund: N/A LEGAL CLASSIFICATION : LAND 100 % CLASS 3 @ 10.00 % 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % PUC IMPS 100 % CLASS 3 g 10.00 % 0141 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % 0 % CLASS g 0.00 % SP27060 TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 Cty Atty: LEIBSOHN Prepared by: BARR / LYLES Date: 02/28/2017 Employee #: 7550 / 3683 Tax Case: TX2016-000136 Parcel #: 132-61-082D Year: 2017 Plantiffi GRACE COMMUNITY CHURCH OF THE VALLEY LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 780,000 3,120,000 3,900,000 11.60 % RECOMMENDED: 400,000 1,600,000 2,000,000 N/C % Recommended LPV calculation used: Personal Prop: N/A Basis: Reason: CODE 19 - Per Judgment TX2016-000136 Current Tax: N/A The Maricopa County Assessor's Office does not provide estimates of recommended Recommended taxes or tax refunds. Tax: N/A Total Refund: N/A Half Refund: N/A LEGAL CLASSIFICATION : LAND 80 % CLASS 4.1 @ 10.00 % 20 % CLASS 1.12 @ 18.00 % 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % PUC IMPS 80 % CLASS 4.1 g 10.00 % 0364 20 % CLASS 1.12 @ 18.00 % 0 % CLASS g 0.00 % SP2706: *** COVER SHEET *** TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Date: 03/14/2017 Maricopa County 8 Parcels 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 Cty Atty: PATTERSON Prepared by: CHAPPEL1N / LYLES Employee #: 7824 / 3683 Tax Case: TX2 016 —000890 Parcel #: see attached Tax Year: 2017 Plantiff: TARGET CORPORATION LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 19,748,400 67,276,200 87,024,600 see parcel RECOMMENDED: N/C 48,454,107 68,202,507 TASR's Personal Property: See attached Reason: CODE 19 - Per Judgment TX2016-000890 Current Tax: N/A The Maricopa County Assessor's Office does not provide estimates of recommended Recommended taxes or tax refunds. Tax: N/A Total Refund: N/A Half Refund: N/A Totals: 501-17-933A 500-03-44613 304-55-044 304-25-909 303-85-686 301-58-8848 219-25-683 201-08-167 Parcel Current: Number Tax Tax Date: Case: Year 1410 1410 1410 1420 1153 1410 1430 1410 PUC of 2017 14-MAR-17 Parcels TX2016-000890 8 19,748,400 1,093,000 1,322,400 3,102,700 1,414,900 1,845,900 3,635,900 2,054,900 5,278,700 Land 67,276,200 6,987,200 6,386,200 11,611,100 5,225,200 10,649,600 7,433,500 6,603,300 12,380,100 Impr Reason: Attorney: Plaintiff: 87,024,600 8,080,200 7,708,600 14,713,800 6,640,100 12,495,500 11,069,400 8,658,200 17,658,800 FCV CODE TARGET TAX 19 PATTERSON APPEAL - Per CORPORATION 72,020,194 6,544,962 7,708,600 12,310,052 6,640,100 8,949,599 9,608,321 8,417,317 11,841,243 LPV Judgment 1.8 1.8 @ 1.8 1.8 @ 1.12 1.8 @ 1.6@ 1.8 @ Class SETTLEMENT @18% 18% @18% 18% @18% 18% 18% 18% TX2016-000890 N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C PUC Recommended: RECOMMENDATION 19,748,400 N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C Land Basis: Specialist: Appraiser: 48,454,107 6,041,273 5,122,487 7,757,141 5,301,486 6,904,100 4,949,433 5,296,887 7,081,300 Impr LYLES CHAPPELL 68,202,507 7,134,273 6,444,887 10,859,841 6,716,386 8,750,000 8,585,333 7,351,787 12,360,000 FCV NORMAN Page: N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C Class of 1 SP27070 1 A3 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 Rule SP2706: *** COVER SHEET *** TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Date: 03/14/2017 Maricopa County 13 Parcels 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 Cty Atty: PATTERSON Prepared by: CHAPPELIN / LYLES Employee #: 7824 / 3683 Tax Case: TX201 6-000964 Parcel #: see attached Tax Year: 2017 plantiin TARGET CORPORATION LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 24,960,000 66,296,000 91,256,000 parcel see RECOMIVIENDED: N/C 44,761,680 69,721,680 TASR's Personal Property: See attached Reason: CODE 19 - Per Judgment TX2016-000964 Current Tax: N/A The Maricopa County Assessor's Office does not provide estimates of recommended Recommended taxes or tax refunds. Tax: N/A Total Refund: N/A Half Refund: N/A Totals: 500-91-874 301-65-900 218-56-451 206-09-028 200-53-029E 200-53-026 148-06-5546 148-06-553B 148-06-551B 142-55-488 134-26-323N 134-26-323L 122-94-008 Parcel Current: Number Tax Tax Date: Case: Year 1480 1410 1430 1430 1430 1430 1074 1074 1410 1430 1410 1416 1410 PUC of 2017 14-MAR-17 Parcels TX2016-000964 13 24,960,000 1,072,000 4,318,400 2,713,800 3,541,100 180,800 3,414,900 615,700 69,400 860,600 2,341,700 2,149,100 197,700 3,484,800 Land 66,296,000 11,632,600 8,036,400 4,682,300 5,780,700 354,200 4,879,300 8,789,700 6,530,500 7,826,300 7,784,000 Impr 0 0 0 Reason: Attorney: Plaintiff: 91,256,000 12,704,600 12,354,800 7,396,100 9,321,800 535,000 8,294,200 615,700 69,400 9,650,300 8,872,200 9,975,400 197,700 11,268,800 FCV CODE TARGET TAX PATTERSON 19 - APPEAL Per CORPORATION 80,308,335 11,449,327 10,148,884 7,396,100 8,625,183 517,955 7,853,370 541,800 61,005 8,149,655 8,495,284 8,357,227 191,284 8,521,261 LPV Judgment SETTLEMENT 1.8 1.8 1.8 1.8 1.8 1.8 1.12 1.8 1.8 1.8 1.8 1.8 1.8 Class @ @ @18% @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ 18% @18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% @18% 18% 18% 18% TX2016-000964 N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C PUC Recommended: RECOMMENDATION 24,960,000 N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C Land Basis: Specialist: Appraiser: 44,761,680 9,168,997 4,632,552 3,588,098 3,694,939 3,927,748 5,318,800 4,970,038 4,466,772 4,639,536 Irnpr N/C N/C N/C N/C LYLES CHAPPELL 69,721,680 10,240,997 8,950,952 6,301,898 7,236,039 7,342,648 6,179,400 7,311,738 6,615,872 8,124,336 FCV NORMAN N/C N/C N/C N/C Page: N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C Class 1 of S27070 1 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 Al Al A2 A2 A2 Al A2 Rule SP2706: *** COVER SHEET*** TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Date: 03/15/2017 Maricopa County 10 Parcels 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 Cty Atty: PATTERSON Prepared by: CHAPPELI\ / LYLES Employee #: 7824 / 3683 Tax Case: TX2 016 — 000965 Parcel #: see attached Tax Year: 2017 Plantiff: TARGET CORPORATION LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 33,733,000 75,225,900 108,958,900 parcel see RECOMMENDED: 25,107,476 57,998,868 83,106,344 TASR s Personal Property: See attached Reason: CODE 19 - Per Judgment TX2016-000965 Current Tax: N/A The Maricopa County Assessor's Office does not provide estimates of recommended Recommended taxes or tax refunds. Tax: N/A Total Refund: N/A Half Refund: N/A Totals: 304-29-964A 217-13-034C 216-51-090G 208-12-939D 176-09-489 156-35-004J 140-43-001J 126-08-137G 102-39-006K 101-14-010 Parcel Current: Number Tax Tax Date: Case: Year 1410 1430 1430 1410 1430 1444 1410 1430 1153 1410 PUC of TX2016 2017 15-MAR-17 Parcels 10 -000965 33,733,000 1,589,600 8,604,500 3,377,200 2,922,800 3,611,000 2,184,000 1,168,500 7,306,000 1,581,100 1,388,300 Land 75,225,900 11,349,600 4,912,800 6,800,600 10,091,000 6,859,500 9,943,900 4,189,800 5,384,800 7,679,900 8,014,000 IMpr Reason: Attorney: Plaintiff: 108,958,900 12,939,200 13,517,300 10,177,800 13,013,800 10,470,500 12,127,900 5,358,300 12,690,800 9,261,000 9,402,300 FCV CODE TARGET TAX PATTERSON 19 - APPEAL Per CORPORATION 88,412,293 11,934,973 8,208,046 10,177,800 11,487,709 8,727,780 9,401,128 5,154,944 8,399,768 6,235,642 8,684,503 LPV Judgment SETTLEMENT 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 1.8 @ 1.8 @ 1.8 1.12 1.8 Class 18% 18% 18% 18% @18% 18% 18% @18% @18% @18% TX2016-000965 N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C PUC Recommended: RECOMMENDATION 25,107,476 N/C 2,844,976 N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C 4,440,000 N/C N/C Land Basis: Specialist: Appraiser: 57,998,868 9,064,992 N/C 5,622,800 7,355,222 3,926,627 7,687,184 N/C 4,440,000 4,746,184 6,053,259 Impr LYLES CHAPPELL 83,106,344 10,654,592 7,757,776 9,000,000 10,278,022 7,537,627 9,871,184 N/C 8,880,000 6,327,284 7,441,559 FCV NORMAN Page: N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C Class of 1 SP27070 1 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 A2 Rule SP27060 TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 Cty. Atty: PALMER Prepared by: CHAPPELA / LYLES Date: 03/14/2017 Employee #: 7824 / 3683 Tax Case: TX2016-001203 Parcel #: 144-44-328 Year: 2017 Plantiff. VHS ACQUISITION CORPORATION LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 968,200 26,531,800 27,500,000 18.00 % RECOMMENDED: 1,020,000 14,080,000 15,100,000 N/C Recommended LPV calculation used: Personal Prop: N/A Basis: Reason: CODE 19 - Per Judgment TX2016-001203 Current Tax: N/A The Maricopa County Assessor's Office does not provide estimates of recommended Recommended taxes or tax refunds. Tax: N/A Total Refund: N/A Half Refund: N/A LEGAL CLASSIFICATION : LAND 100 % CLASS 1.12 @ 18.00 % 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % PUC IMPS 100 % CLASS 1.12 @ 18.00 % 2110 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % SP27060 TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 Cty Atty: LEIBSOHN Prepared by: BARR / LYLES Date: 03/20/2017 Employee & 7550 / 3683 Tax Case: TX2016-001302 Parcel ft: 121-70-099J Year: 2017 Plantiff PRESIDENT PARTNERS LIMITED PARTNERSHIP LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 2,174,200 10,157,600 12,331,800 10.00 % RECOMMENDED: 722,864 3,377,136 4,100,000 N/C % Recommended LPV calculation used: Personal Prop: N/A Basis: Reason: CODE 19 - Per Judgment TX2016-001302 Current Tax: N/A The Maricopa County Assessor's Office does not provide estimates of recommended Recommended taxes or tax refunds. Tax: N/A Total Refund: N/A Half Refund: N/A LEGAL CLASSIFICATION : LAND 100 % CLASS 4.2 @ 10.00 % 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % PUC IMPS 100 °A CLASS 4.2 @ 10.00 % 0374 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % 0 `)/0 CLASS g 0.00 % SP27060 TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 Cty Atty: LEIBSOHN Prepared by: BARR / LYLES Date: 03/09/2017 Employee #: 7550 / 3683 Tax Case: TX2016-001312 Parcel #: 173-44-231 Year: 2017 Plantift GUINA INTERESTS LLC LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 532,000 2,128,000 2,660,000 10.00 % RECOMMENDED: 252,520 1,010,080 1,262,600 N/C (Y0 Recommended LPV calculation used: Personal Prop: N/A Basis: Reason: CODE 19 - Per Judgment TX2016-001312 Current Tax: N/A The Maricopa County Assessor's Office does not provide estimates of recommended Recommended taxes or tax refunds. Tax: N/A Total Refund: N/A Half Refund. N/A LEGAL CLASSIFICATION : LAND 100 % CLASS 4.1 @ 10.00 0/0 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % 0 % CLASS @ 0.00 % PUC IMPS 100 4)/0 CLASS 4.1 0181 0 % CLASS 0 % CLASS Rule A3 SP27070 1 of 1 Class N/C Page: FCV N/C 6,500,000 LISA BOWEY LYLES lmpr N/C 5,181,300 Appraiser: Specialist: Basis: Land N/C 1,318,700 RECOMMENDATION Recommended: -000215 I PUC N/C TX2017 Class 18% @ SETTLEMENT LPV 12 1 Judgment 5,265,000 5,265,000 LLC Per APPEAL HOLDINGS - 19 T3T PATTERSON CODE FCV 6,500,000 6,500,000 TAX Plaintiff: Attorney: Reason: Impr 5,181,300 5,181,300 Land 1,318,700 1,318,700 -000215 1 2017 TX2017 Parcels PUC 3747 09-MAR-17 of Year Case: Date: Tax Tax Number Current: Parcel 102-56-025 Totals: