Extracted text (via pymupdf_layout)
141592 characters
AGENCY: U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) Office Of Environmental Justice and External Civil Rights (OEJECR) TITLE: Environmental Justice Government-to-Government Program (EJG2G) ACTION: Request for Applications (RFA) FUNDING OPPORTUNITY NO.: EPA-R-OEJECR-OCS-23-02 TYPE: INITIAL ANNOUNCEMENT ASSISTANCE LISTING NO: 66.312 DATES: ANNOUNCEMENT DATE: January 10, 2023 CLOSING DATE: April 14, 2023 DEADLINE: Application packages must be submitted on or before April 14, 2023, at 11:59 PM (Eastern Time) through Grants.gov. Applications received after the closing date and time will not be considered for funding. Note - Prior to naming a contractor (including consultants) or subrecipient in your application as a “partner”, please carefully review Section IV.d, “Contracts and Subawards”, of EPA’s Announcement Clauses that are incorporated by reference in this announcement (See Section I.K). EPA expects recipients of funding to comply with competitive procurement contracting requirements as well as EPA’s rule on Participation by Disadvantaged Business Enterprises in EPA Programs in 40 CFR Part 33. The Agency does not accept justifications for sole source contracts for services or products available in the commercial marketplace based on a contractor’s role in preparing an application. CONTENTS BY SECTION I. Funding Opportunity Description II. Award Information III. Eligibility Information IV. Application and Submission Information V. Application Review Information VI. Award Administration Information VII. Agency Contacts VIII. Other Information and Appendices A – Tips on Preparing an EJ Grant Application B – Blank Logic Model Template C – Logic Model Guide – What each Category Means D – Example Completed Logic Model E – Blank Itemized Budget Sheet Template F – Example Completed Itemized Budget Sheet G – Quality Assurance Project Plan Questionnaire H – Guidance on Structuring Health Impact Assessment -1- I. FUNDING OPPORTUNITY DESCRIPTION (back to Contents by Section) A. EXECUTIVE ORDERS AND DEFINITIONS EPA is issuing this solicitation requesting applications for projects that support and/or create model state, tribal, local, and territorial government activities that lead to measurable environmental or public health results in communities disproportionately burdened by environmental harms and risks. These projects will help transform disadvantaged and underserved communities into healthy, thriving communities capable of addressing the environmental and public health challenges they have historically faced, as well as current and future challenges. This competition is being launched in order to meet the goals and objectives of two Executive Orders (EO 14008 and EO 13985) issued by the Biden Administration that demonstrate the EPA’s and Administration’s commitment to achieving environmental justice and embedding environmental justice into Agency programs. Executive Order 14008, Tackling the Climate Crisis at Home and Abroad, issued on January 27, 2021, affirmed the Administration’s commitment to advancing environmental justice by creating the Justice40 Initiative. The Justice40 Initiative1establishes a goal that 40% of the overall benefits of certain federal investments—including those in climate change; clean energy and energy efficiency; clean transit; affordable and sustainable housing; training and workforce development; the remediation and reduction of legacy pollution; and the development of critical clean water infrastructure—flow to disadvantaged communities.2 In addition, Section 219 of the Executive Order stressed that environmental and economic justice are key considerations to factor into governmental decision-making and that transforming disadvantaged communities—historically marginalized, underserved, and overburdened—into healthy, thriving communities, and undertaking robust actions to mitigate climate change while preparing for the impacts of climate change across rural, urban, and Tribal areas are governmental priorities. The Executive Order also called for making environmental justice part of Agency missions by developing programs, policies, and activities to address the disproportionately high and adverse human health, environmental, climate-related and other cumulative impacts on disadvantaged communities, as well as the accompanying economic challenges of such impacts. Complementing Executive Order 14008, is Executive Order 13985, Advancing Racial Equity And Support For Underserved Communities Through The Federal Government, issued on January 20, 2021, which stated that the federal government should pursue a comprehensive approach to advancing equity for all, including people of color and others who have been historically underserved, marginalized, and adversely affected by persistent poverty and inequality. “Environmental justice,” which is the common theme of these two Executive Orders, is defined by the EPA is the fair treatment and meaningful involvement of all people regardless of race, color, national origin, or income with respect to the development, implementation, and enforcement of environmental laws, regulations, and policies. Fair treatment means that no one group of people, including racial, ethnic, or socioeconomic groups, should bear a disproportionate share of the negative environmental consequences resulting from industrial, municipal, and commercial 1 Further information on J40 can be found in OMB’s interim implementation guidance for the Justice40 Initiative (M- 21-28). 2 EPA is currently in the process of defining the term “disadvantaged communities.” -2- operations or the execution of federal, state, local, and tribal environmental programs and policies. Meaningful involvement means that: • People have an opportunity to participate in decisions about activities that may affect their environment and/or health; • The public's contribution can influence the regulatory agency's decision; • Community concerns will be considered in the decision-making process; and • Decision makers will seek out and facilitate the involvement of those potentially affected. The underserved and disadvantaged communities for which these projects are focused on include, as defined by Executive Order 13985, “populations sharing a particular characteristic, as well as geographic communities, that have been systematically denied a full opportunity to participate in aspects of economic, social, and civic life…”. This includes communities such as Black, Latino, and Indigenous and Native American persons, Asian Americans and Pacific Islanders and other persons of color; children, the elderly, members of religious minorities; lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, and queer (LGBTQ+) persons; persons with disabilities; persons who live in rural areas; and persons otherwise adversely affected by persistent poverty or inequality. For purposes of this RFA, “underserved communities” also includes “environmentally overburdened communities” (that is, communities adversely and disproportionately affected by environmental, climate and human health harms and risks including remote, rural, and urban communities), and disadvantaged communities. Community-based Nonprofit Organizations (CBOs) For this RFA, the EJ Grants program defines a “community-based nonprofit organization” (CBO) as a public or private nonprofit organization that supports and/or represents a community and/or certain populations within a community through engagement, education, and other related services provided to individual community residents and community stakeholders. A “community” can be characterized by a particular geographic area and/or by the relationships among members with similar interests and can be characterized as part of a broader national or regional community where organizations can be focused on the needs of urban, rural, and/or tribal areas, farmworkers, displaced workers, children with high levels of lead, people with asthma, subsistence fishers, and other similar groups. B. BACKGROUND OF GOVERNMENT-TO-GOVERNMENT PROGRAM The mission of the EPA is to protect human health and the environment for all people with an emphasis on assisting those communities adversely and disproportionately affected by environmental, climate, and human health harms and risks. Under the Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2022, EPA received significant investments for environmental justice and in the health, equity, and resilience of these, and all communities, to address past, current, and future environmental health and justice challenges. Additionally, the 2022 Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) codified the Environmental and Climate Justice block grant program in section 138 of the Clean Air Act (CAA) and provided EPA with $2.8 billion in grant funding for the program to benefit disadvantaged communities. To maximize these significant investments, the Environmental Justice Government-to-Government (EJG2G) program (formally known as the State Environmental Justice Cooperative Agreement [SEJCA] program) provides funding to eligible entities to work collaboratively with underserved communities to understand, promote and integrate approaches to -3- provide meaningful and measurable improvements to public health and/or the environment in those communities. Program History - The EPA’s Office of Environmental Justice and External Civil Rights (OEJECR) first and original efforts to assist States in achieving environmental justice goals and objectives began with the States and Tribal Environmental Justice (STEJ) Grants Program pilot projects which were awarded and developed during fiscal years 1998-2001. These pilot projects were directed to assist States and tribal governments in the development of environmental justice considerations and approaches in their environmental programs. In 2009, the program was relaunched as assistance listing 66.312 (i.e., The State Environmental Justice Cooperative Agreement [SEJCA] Program) where five cooperative agreements were made to state governments. In 2020, this program was recompeted with expanded eligibility to states, tribal governments, local governments, and US territories which resulted in 31 total awards being made in 2020-21. Now, for this competition, OEJECR is rebranding this program with a new name that better reflects the multiple entities eligible for the funding as well as the purpose of the program. The newly named Environmental Justice Government-to-Government (EJG2G) program builds on progress made through the initial pilot grants and more recent cooperative agreements. The EJG2G program features expanded eligibility to applicants from all levels of governments: States, tribal governments, local governments, US Territories, and now also Freely Associated States (FAS). With this expanded program, OEJECR strives to support the integration of environmental justice goals at all levels of government as we collaborate with our governmental partners. C. PURPOSE OF THE GOVERNMENT-TO-GOVERNMENT PROGRAM AND PROJECTS SOUGHT The purpose of the EJG2G program is to support and/or create model state, tribal, local, and territorial government activities that lead to measurable environmental or public health results in communities disproportionately burdened by environmental harms and risks. These models should leverage or utilize existing resources or assets of state, tribal, local, and territorial agencies to develop key tools and processes that integrate environmental justice considerations into all levels of government and government programs. Projects Sought Under this Funding Opportunity: Projects submitted under this funding opportunity should support the EJG2G program goals detailed below: (1) achieve measurable and meaningful environmental and/or public health results in communities; (2) build broad and robust, results-oriented partnerships, particularly with community- based nonprofit organizations (CBOs) within disproportionately impacted areas; (3) pilot activities in specific communities that create models, which can be expanded or replicated in other geographic areas; and (4) strengthen the development and implementation of specific approaches to achieve environmental justice. To help ensure that they will achieve EJG2G program goals, projects should factor in: (1) state and local data; (2) state and local leadership; (3) state and local results; (4) relationships between delegated programs (i.e., federal environmental programs delegated to and carried out by states, tribes, local government, and US territories) and state, tribal, local, and territorial environmental justice policies, and (5) state, tribal, local, and territorial government targeting of -4- disproportionately burdened areas. Information about all EPA Environmental Justice assistance programs, including the EJG2G program, can be found at the website below: https://www.epa.gov/environmentaljustice/environmental-justice-grants-and-resources D. AUTHORITY The EJG2G program is designed to address multi-statute environmental and/or public health issues. In support of this, Congress provided EPA with both funding and expanded authority to further environmental justice through financial assistance programs in the Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2022 (Public Law 117-103), which provided funding for environmental justice implementation and training grants. Examples of grant applications involving implementation activities include: small-scale clean-ups, environmental treatments, pollution abatements, hazardous waste disposal and/or energy recovery projects. Additionally, under the IRA, Congress created the Environmental and Climate Justice Block grant program in Clean Air Act (CAA) Section 138 and appropriated $2.8 billion for grants for projects to benefit disadvantaged communities. Eligible projects with this funding fall into five broad categories and include: (A) community-led air and other pollution monitoring, prevention, and remediation, and investments in low- and zero-emission and resilient technologies and related infrastructure and workforce development that help reduce greenhouse gas emissions and other air pollutants; (B) mitigating climate and health risks from urban heat islands, extreme heat, wood heater emissions, and wildfire events; (C) climate resiliency and adaptation; (D) reducing indoor toxics and indoor air pollution; or (E) facilitating engagement of disadvantaged communities in State and Federal advisory groups, workshops, rulemakings, and other public processes. EPA interprets the term “community-led air and other pollution monitoring, prevention and remediation . . .” in CAA 138(b)(2)(A) to allow EPA to fund activities to address water pollution, drinking water contamination, pesticide contamination, toxic substance contamination, solid and hazardous waste contamination, and hazardous substance contamination as well as air pollution. Note that as provided in CAA 314 contractors and subcontractors for construction projects receiving financial assistance under CAA 138 must comply with the U.S. Department of Labor’s regulations (29 CFR Parts 1, 3, and 5) implementing Davis-Bacon Act prevailing wage requirements. EPA will use the definition of the term Construction in 40 CFR 33.103 to determine Davis Bacon Act applicability. Any infrastructure project as defined in M-22-11 must also comply with the domestic content preferences in the Build America, Buy America Act for iron and steel, manufactured products, and construction materials. Please note that infrastructure projects under $250,000 may be covered under EPA’s Small Project General Applicability waiver. The EPA also encourages project labor agreements (i.e., pre-hire collective bargaining agreements between unions and contractors that govern terms and conditions of employment for all workers on a construction project); the use of an appropriately trained workforce (i.e., through registered apprenticeships and other joint labor-management training programs that serve all workers, particularly those historically excluded); the use of an appropriately credentialed workforce (i.e., requirements for appropriate and relevant professional training, certification, and licensure); and neutrality with respect to union organizing. -5- E. SPECIAL CONSIDERATIONS For this competition, EPA will give special consideration to applications that address one or more of the following program priorities: • Projects addressing Climate Change, Disaster Resiliency, and/or Emergency Preparedness – The effects of climate change and extreme weather events tend to adversely impact the most vulnerable communities and populations disproportionately. Therefore, EPA may give special consideration to projects that address the needs of underserved and vulnerable communities that have been adversely impacted or are likely to be adversely impacted by natural disasters, including, but not limited to, hurricanes, tornadoes, wildfires, floods, earthquakes, and future pandemics. • Rural areas – EPA will give special consideration to high-ranking proposals to be performed in rural areas as defined by the program. Rural areas, for the purposes of this competition, are defined as one of the following: 1. Local areas with populations of 50,000 or less that have limited access to public or private resources commonly found in metropolitan areas 2. Community Network areas selected by the Rural Partners Network (See rural.gov for a complete list of communities) 3. Coal and Energy Communities (See energycommunities.gov for a complete list of communities) Applicants claiming rural status must provide sufficient detail (census data, population figures, descriptions of local resources, etc.) for EPA to validate the rural status of the underserved community. The goal of this special consideration is to encourage and increase project performance in rural areas in the EPA EJ Grants program. • Health Impact Assessment (HIA) – HIA is a “practice that aims to protect and promote health and to reduce inequities in health during a decision-making process.”3 One’s health is affected by genetics and the health care we receive, but also by the built, social, and natural environments in which we live and work. As such, there is growing recognition that a broad range of decisions can affect health, and health consequences, positive and negative, should be considered as part of decision-making. EPA may give special consideration to HIA projects that seek to determine the potential effects of a proposed environmental decision (e.g., policy, plan, program, project, action) on the health of underserved and vulnerable communities and the distribution of those effects within the communities. (See section I.G and VIII.H for guidance on developing HIAs.) The special considerations listed above will only be considered as an “other factor”, in addition to the scoring criteria in Section V, in making selection decisions. Additional other factors which may be considered during the selection process can be found in Section V of this funding announcement. The selection official may consider any (or all) of these “other factors” or none at all in making selection decisions. 3 Bhatia R, Farhang L, Heller J, Lee M, Orenstein M, Richardson M and Wernham A. Minimum Elements and Practice Standards for Health Impact Assessment, Version 3. September, 2014. https://www.tn.gov/content/dam/tn/health/documents/learningopportunities/HIA_Best_Practice_Standards_2014.pdf -6- NOTE: All eligible organizations are encouraged to apply. Under this competition, projects not located in rural areas and/or proposed by organizations conducting HIAs as identified in Section I are still eligible for award. F. ELIGIBLE PROJECT ACTIVITIES & PROJECT EXAMPLES Projects Sought Under this Funding Opportunity: 1. Eligible Project Categories – Consistent with section 138(b)(2) of the Clean Air Act, applications submitted in response to this funding opportunity should address one of the following four broad categories: • community-led air and other pollution monitoring, prevention, and remediation, and investments in low- and zero-emission and resilient technologies and related infrastructure and workforce development that help reduce greenhouse gas emissions and other air pollutants; • mitigating climate and health risks from urban heat islands, extreme heat, wood heater emissions, and wildfire events; • climate resiliency and adaptation; or • reducing indoor toxics and indoor air pollution 2. Eligible Project Activities – The following are more specific examples of the types of activities which may be considered for funding under this solicitation. It is provided for illustrative purposes only and is not all inclusive. • research that is incidental to the project design • public education • small-scale construction and demolition work (if needed for project) • small-scale clean-ups • installations of air or water filtration systems • major disposal training • energy recovery projects training • building refurbishments that reduce greenhouse gas emissions and other pollutants • mitigation of pollution • remediation of lead or asbestos • workforce development to support low and zero emission and resilient technologies that reduce greenhouse gas and other air pollutants. • Environmental Justice partnership building that engages disadvantaged communities in Local, State and Federal public processes, such as advisory groups, workshops, and rulemakings • community revitalization planning in support of climate resiliency and adaptation • monitoring of sources of pollution • efforts to improve equitable transportation and mobility including through efforts to address barriers of cost and safety related to walking, bicycling, and public transit in order to reduce air pollution • development of disaster preparedness plans • community revitalization planning addressing local pollution and greenspace • facilitating the engagement of disadvantaged communities in State advisory groups, workshops and rulemakings and other public processes • Smaller scale land purchases and/or acquisitions NOTE – only land purchases and/or -7- acquisitions which represent less than half of the requested project funds under an application are allowable. 3. Examples of EJG2G Projects See the list below for examples of EJG2G projects. This is not an exhaustive list: a. Cleanup of nonhazardous trash (e.g., scrap tires, construction debris) in underserved communities, especially where illegal dumping is an ongoing concern. b. Reduction of lead in underserved communities and vulnerable populations. Eligible activities include but are not limited to blood lead level (BLL) testing, surveillance, and linkages to service providers who can provide lead remediation services; Restoration, Repair and Paint (RRP) projects at schools and daycare facilities to remove lead-based paint; and paving lead-contaminated dirt in alleys and other public spaces. c. Development of Citizen Science Monitoring programs to address various environmental contamination issues including water quality. Programs should provide support for communities to not only participate but take ownership over the data collected and collaboratively develop solutions. d. Planning and development of heat island mitigation strategies in underserved communities. Eligible projects include but are not limited to installation of cool roofs and walls, green roofs, cool pavements, permeable pavers and other green infrastructure measures, and urban forestry initiatives, and extreme heat-related activities within local government departments (e.g., public health, climate, parks, emergency management). e. Efforts to improve equitable transportation and mobility that encourage mode shift from private vehicles to walking, biking, and public transportation in underserved communities in order to reduce air pollution. Eligible projects include but are not limited to expansion of bike share programs and bike storage facilities, subsidies to encourage the adoption of bicycles including low-speed electric bicycles. Incidental activities for planning and signage for road safety interventions particularly on roadways and intersections with a history of injury and death to pedestrians and bicyclists as part of a larger project to encourage reductions in vehicle miles traveled in automobiles (e.g., dedicated bicycle lanes or pedestrian trails) is also eligible for funding. f. Energy efficiency, electrification, and renewable energy programs in K-12 schools including preventative maintenance of HVAC systems, energy audits, energy system upgrades, installation of on-site renewables and/or green infrastructure indoor air quality monitoring and related employee training. g. Planning and development of environmental justice mapping tools or methodologies to determine potential impacts to underserved communities from multiple disproportionate environmental and/or public health issues. h. Development of emergency preparedness and disaster resiliency plans and programs for underserved communities and vulnerable populations to minimize the exposure to pollutants in the event of a natural disaster. Disasters disproportionately impact communities of color, low-income, rural, elderly, and youth populations. Applicants may -8- propose to develop plans or programs that specifically work to mitigate the disproportionate impacts of these disasters on their vulnerable populations. Disasters include but are not limited to hurricanes, tornadoes, coastal flooding, oil spills, wildfires, and earthquakes. Projects should address and/or prepare communities for the increases in pollution that can result from these and other disasters. i. Monitoring and/or prevention and/or remediation of air quality issues related to living close to transportation networks (e.g., railroads, railyards, ports, heavily trafficked roadways) in the local area, especially in areas where data may be limited. j. Monitoring, preventing or remediation of nonpoint or point source releases of waterborne pollutants in underserved communities. k. Establishment of collaborative and coordinated efforts, processes or procedures, and communication strategies between state agencies and local governments regarding ongoing environmental monitoring, prevention, or remediation projects at local levels to maximize use of local resources and reduce duplication of efforts. NOTE: For all of the above described activities, reasonable costs to encourage program participation (e.g. training, community meeting participation and/or childcare stipends,) may be allowable with prior EPA approval to the extent provided for in EPA’s Guidance on Participant Support Costs. G. HEALTH IMPACT ASSESSMENT PROJECT GUIDANCE 1. Health Impact Assessment Case Studies Two Health Impact Assessment (HIA) case studies are provided below to assist applicants in understanding how an HIA may be structured and implemented. NOTE: Applicants proposing to conduct HIAs through this opportunity will be expected to lead and coordinate the HIA along with their partners. Where availability allows, EPA staff may provide technical advice and guidance to an HIA project team. However, EPA staff will not lead the implementation and/or management of any HIA funded through this funding opportunity. a. Gerena School Renovation Project (Springfield, MA): Gerena Community School, located in Springfield, MA, is underwent renovations to improve the environmental conditions for its users. The facility functions as an elementary school and community center, serving students and residents of the North End Community. EPA collaborated with stakeholders, including departments within the City of Springfield and community-based groups, to perform an HIA. The purpose of this HIA was to provide valuable health-focused information to help the City of Springfield narrow down and prioritize those renovation actions that best addressed the existing environmental conditions and reduced the potential negative health impacts to students, faculty, staff, and community members who use the facility. The HIA also provided an avenue for the community and other stakeholders to be engaged in the decision-making process. Community stakeholders had raised concerns related to Gerena School, which included indoor air quality issues related to motor vehicle emissions, flooding, moisture, mold, and other indoor environment conditions. The HIA utilized on-site observations, reviewed evidence, and professional expertise to judge each of the proposed renovation options for potential impacts to respiratory health. Based on the predicted impacts to health, the HIA provided recommendations for renovation actions that -9- aim to maximize potential benefits to health and mitigate and/or avoid potential adverse impacts to health. The executive summary for this case study is available at https://www.epa.gov/healthresearch/gerena-school-health-impact-assessment-hia-final- report. b. Kingsbury Bay-Grassy Point Habitat Restoration Project (Duluth, MN): This project informed the MN Department of Natural Resources and the City of Duluth decisions on design and implementation of habitat restoration and park improvement projects at two sites along the St. Louis River in Duluth, Kingsbury Bay and Grassy Point. It evaluated the potential health impacts, specifically, seven pathways were identified and prioritized by stakeholders: water quality and habitat; equipment operation, traffic and transport; air quality; noise and light pollution’ crime and safety; recreation, aesthetics, and engagement with nature; and social/cultural aspects. The HIA concluded that the proposed projects will have positive and negative health impacts, and that the net impacts are expected to be positive. Impacts include improved water quality and aquatic habitat, reductions in crime from improved green spaces, increased opportunity for recreation, and access to cultural resources, among other things. The HIA also included recommendations to enhance the positive health impacts and reduce the negative health impacts, some of which were adopted by the decision makers. The HIA Project Team consisted of EPA staff, contractors, research fellows, and local professional stakeholders (e.g., individuals from academia; community organizations; local, county and state government agencies; and environmental organizations). Members of the HIA Project Team served on the HIA Leadership Team, HIA Research Team, or both. The HIA Project Team conducted the HIA with input and guidance from an HIA Advisory Committee, made up of technical experts and representatives from several stakeholder groups. The executive summary for this case study is available at https://www.epa.gov/system/files/documents/2021-09/kingsbury-bay-grassy- point-hia-summary-report.pdf. 2. Potentially Eligible EJG2G Types of Decisions Informed by Health Impact Assessments HIAs consider the full range of potential impacts of the proposed decision — both positive and negative — on health and those factors known to directly and indirectly affect human health (known as health determinants). HIAs provide recommendations for maximizing the potential positive health impacts and minimizing and/or avoiding the potential negative health impacts of the decision. In addition to promoting human health considerations, HIAs also encourage democracy, health equity, a comprehensive approach to individual and community health, and sustainability in decision-making. The types of decisions informed by HIAs listed below are not an exhaustive list and are provided for illustrative purposes to help applicants as they develop their applications. Types of decisions that are eligible for this RFA include but are not limited to the following: Local County - Land use policies and projects to promote - County bicycle and pedestrian master plans climate resiliency and adaptation - Placement and maintenance of community - Sitting of recreational centers and schools to Gardens to reduce Vehicle Miles Traveled to promote climate resiliency and adaptation obtain fresh fruit and vegetables. - Mass transit/transit-oriented design - Sub-area plans for revitalizing highways and - Neighborhood/sub-area planning studies surrounding neighborhoods to reduce air -10- - Affordable housing siting to promote climate pollutions resiliency and adaptation State - Encouraging the use of mass transit and traffic control features that reduce unnecessary idling of automobiles and trucks - Energy assistance programs - Comprehensive planning and growth policies to reduce vehicle miles traveled and other sources of air pollution For further guidance on structuring HIAs, please refer to Section VIII.H. “Guidance of Structuring Health Impact Assessment” of this funding announcement. NOTE: For proposed HIA activities, reasonable costs to encourage program participation (e.g. training, community meeting participation and/or childcare stipends,) may be allowable with prior EPA approval to the extent provided for in EPA’s Guidance on Participant Support Costs. H. INELIGIBLE ACTIVITIES The following are examples of ineligible activities under the awards to be made from this RFA4: • Lobbying as restricted in 2 CFR 200.450 and the terms and conditions of EJG2G assistance agreements. • Legal advice, services, or representation • Travel for federal employees • Projects or programs that are not eligible for funding under section 138(b)(2) of the Clean Air Act or the environmental justice implementation and training grant authority in EPA’s Fiscal Year 2022 Appropriation Act, Public Law 117-103 • Land purchases and/or acquisitions that represent more than half of the requested project funds I. EPA STRATEGIC PLAN LINKAGE & ANTICIPATED OUTPUTS, OUTCOMES & PERFORMANCE MEASURES This announcement supports key priorities of the Administration as detailed in Executive Order 13985 Advancing Racial Equity and Support for Underserved Communities Through the Federal Government, and Executive Order 14008 Tackling the Climate Crisis at Home and Abroad. Specifically, the projects selected under this RFA will support the federal government’s efforts to advance racial equity and environmental and energy justice, address health outcome disparities, and support underserved communities. In addition, pursuant to Section 6a of EPA Order 5700.7, “Environmental Results under EPA Assistance Agreements,” (see https://www.epa.gov/grants/epa-order-57007a1-epas-policy- environmental-results-under-epa-assistance-agreements). EPA must link proposed assistance agreements to the Agency’s Strategic Plan. EPA’s Strategic Plan 2022 - 2026 is available at https://www.epa.gov/planandbudget/strategicplan. 4 This is not an exhaustive list of ineligible activities. All activities receiving EPA and DOE funding are subject to requirements for cost allowability in applicable regulations including limitations on consultant fees in 2 CFR Part 1500. Additionally, only activities described in the EPA approved scope of work are eligible for funding. -11- The activities to be funded under this RFA support the FY 2022-2026 EPA Strategic Plan. Awards made under this RFA will support Goal 2 (Take Decisive Action to Advance Environmental Justice and Civil Rights), Objective 2.1, (Promote Environmental Justice and Civil Rights at the Federal, Tribal, State, and Local Levels) of the Strategic Plan which states that: “Building Community Capacity and Climate Resilience and Maximizing Benefits to Overburdened and Underserved Communities: EPA will increase support for community-led action by providing unprecedented investments and benefits directly to communities with environmental justice concerns and by integrating equity throughout Agency programs.” Applicants should explain in their application how their EJCPF proposal will further this goal and objective and they will be evaluated on this under the evaluation criteria in Section V.A. EPA Order 5700.7 also requires that grant applicants adequately describe environmental outputs and outcomes to be achieved under assistance agreements. Applicants must include specific statements describing the environmental results of the proposed project in terms of well-defined outputs and, to the maximum extent practicable, well-defined outcomes that will demonstrate how the project will contribute to the goals and objectives described above. 1. Output Measures The term “output” means an environmental activity, effort, and/or associated work product related to an environmental/public health goal and objective that will be produced or provided over a period of time or by a specified date. Outputs may be quantitative or qualitative but must be measurable during the assistance agreement funding period. Application narratives should address the specific output measures related to the proposed project. Examples of possible output measures for awards under this competition include, but are not limited, to: Creation of an environmental/public health program to achieve and sustain environmental/public health improvements (e.g., a community-wide asthma coalition) Number of community assessments performed, and tools developed to measure air and water quality issues The number of partnerships formed by the applicant at the local level. The number of samples collected and related to waterborne pollution from nonpoint or point sources and their significance. The number of homes/residents/communities reached or impacted by an environmental/public health monitoring and remediation program (e.g., number of homes that participate in a lead abatement program). 2. Outcome Measures The term “outcome” means the result, effect, or consequence that will occur from carrying out an environmental/public health program or activity that is related to an -12- environmental/public health programmatic goal or objective. Outcomes may be environmental, behavioral, health-related, or programmatic in nature, but must be quantitative. They may not necessarily be achievable within the assistance agreement funding period. Narratives should link the proposed output measures to potential long- term outcomes. Examples of possible outcome measures expected to result from awards under this competition include but are not limited to: The reduction of waterborne pollutants in local waterbodies and/or increase in fish populations leading to reduced contaminant levels in consumed fish. The ongoing communication to the underserved communities resulting in measurable risk reduction in a specific media and communities’ participation directly in that risk reduction. The resultant changes in State or local regulation directly related to risk assessments performed in the communities which results in State/regional risk reductions. Reduction in asthma-related hospital visits due to air pollution remediation activities and use of zero-emission technologies Increase in local job opportunities and worker skills to related to workforce development programs specializing in technologies that reduce greenhouse gas emissions Reduction in local temperatures in metropolitan areas due to urban heat island mitigation activities and planning, Increase in residents transitioning from private vehicles to public transit, walking, and bicycling. J. ADDITIONAL PROVISIONS FOR APPLICANTS INCORPORATED INTO THE ANNOUNCEMENT Additional provisions that apply to sections III, IV, V, and VI of this RFA and/or awards made under this RFA, can be found at EPA Announcement Clauses. These provisions are important for applying to this RFA and applicants must review them when preparing applications for this RFA. If you are unable to access these provisions electronically at the website above, please contact the EPA point of contact listed in this RFA (usually in Section VII) to obtain the provisions. II. AWARD INFORMATION (back to Contents by Section) A. FUNDING AVAILABILITY AND PROJECT PERIOD The total estimated funding expected for all awards under this solicitation is approximately $70,000,000, broken down as follows: -13- • $40,000,000 of Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) appropriations for local governments partnering with CBOs and federally recognized tribal governments partnering with CBOs • $30,000,000 of annual appropriations for OEJECR for states partnering with CBOs, U.S. Territories, Freely Associated States, Puerto Rico, state recognized tribal governments, and tribes in remote areas (federally recognized or state recognized) Between these two sources of funds, EPA anticipates awarding approximately seventy (70) cooperative agreements nationwide up to $1,000,000 per award. B. NUMBER AND TYPE OF ANTICIPATED AWARDS EPA anticipates making seventy (70) awards under this announcement, awarding up to $1,000,000 per award. The awards for selected projects will be in the form of cooperative agreements because the EJG2G program requires substantial involvement and interaction between the applicant and EPA. EPA will negotiate the precise terms and conditions of “substantial involvement” as part of the award process. Federal involvement may include: close monitoring of the recipient’s performance to verify the results proposed by the applicant; collaboration during the performance of the scope of work; in accordance with 2 CFR 200.325, as appropriate, review of proposed procurements; reviewing qualifications of key personnel; and/or review and comment on the content of printed or electronic publications or reports prepared although recipients will make the final decisions on the content of documents. EPA does not have the authority to select employees or contractors employed by the recipient. All subawards must be consistent with EPA’s Subaward Policy and EPA does not select subrecipients. In appropriate circumstances, EPA reserves the right to partially fund applications by funding discrete portions of the proposed projects. If EPA decides to partially fund an application, it will do so in a manner that does not prejudice any applicant or affect the basis upon which the application was evaluated and selected for award, thereby maintaining the integrity of the competition and selection process. EPA also reserves the right to make additional awards under this RFA, consistent with Agency policy and guidance, if additional funding becomes available after the original selections are made. Any additional selections for awards will be made no later than 6 months after the original selection decisions. C. SET ASIDES EPA plans to award funding under this competition under specific set-asides. There will be a separate ranking list developed under this competition for each of the set-asides detailed below: State –Approximately $20M of annual appropriations funds is set aside for awards to states (includes the District of Columbia) and instrumentalities of states (see section III.A) under the -14- authority of EPA’s Fiscal Year 2022 Act5. The dollar amount intended for these awards may be adjusted depending upon the quality of applications received and other relevant considerations. Tribal –Approximately $20M of CAA 138 IRA funds is set aside for awards to federally recognized tribal governments who partner with CBOs as required by CAA 138(b)(3)(A). The dollar amount intended for these awards may be adjusted depending upon the quality of applications received and other relevant considerations Local Government –Approximately $20M of CAA 138 IRA funds is set aside for awards to local governments who partner with CBOs as required by CAA 138(b)(3)(A). The dollar amount intended for these awards may be adjusted depending upon the quality of applications received and other relevant considerations. U.S. Territory, Freely Associated State, Puerto Rico, State Recognized Tribal Government, and Remote Tribal Government – Approximately $10M of annual appropriations funds is set aside for awards to U.S. Territories, Freely Associated States (FAS), Puerto Rico, state recognized tribal governments, and tribes in remote areas of the United States (federally recognized or state recognized). The dollar amount intended for these awards may be adjusted depending upon the quality of applications received and other relevant considerations. Tribes located in Remote Areas (federally recognized or state recognized) are a subset of the special consideration for rural areas (see Section I.E) and are defined as tribal governments located in rural areas with limited or no access to CBOs to partner with. Remote areas may also be characterized by limited access to public or private resources commonly found in metropolitan areas. NOTE - tribal governments that claim this remote status and limited access to community- based nonprofit partners must explain why they qualify for remote status. Tribes that qualify as remote will be placed in the U.S. Territory, Freely Associated States, Puerto Rico, state recognized tribal government, and remote tribal government track where approximately $10 million will be available. However, federally recognized tribal governments that are able to partner with at least one CBO will be placed in the Tribal track featuring $20 million of IRA funding. EPA encourages tribal governments that can partner with a CBO to do so to access the track with the larger funding amount. Note that tribes that apply in partnership with CBOs cannot also apply for funding as a remotely located tribal government. D. PROJECT PERIOD The estimated project period for awards resulting from this solicitation is three years, from December 2023 to November 2026. Applicants should plan for projects to start on December 1, 2023. NOTE: Due to the restrictions in CAA 138(b)(1), EPA cannot extend the performance periods for EJG2G assistance agreements beyond three years. III. ELIGIBILITY INFORMATION (back to Contents by Section) Note: Additional provisions that apply to this section can be found at EPA Announcement Clauses. 5 As indicated in CAA 138(b)(3) states and territories are not eligible entities for assistance agreements authorized by CAA 138(b). -15- A. ELIGIBLE ENTITIES BASED ON THE ASSISTANCE LISTING - In accordance with CFDA 66.312 (as it will be updated to be consistent with this announcement), an eligible applicant must be one of the following entities: (1) a partnership between* — a state (includes the District of Columbia) and a CBO. The term State encompasses instrumentalities of state government as provided in 2 CFR 200.1 with the exception of state institutions of higher education.6 (2) a partnership between* — a federally recognized tribal government and a CBO (3) a partnership between* — a local government (as defined by 2 CFR 200.1 - includes cities, towns, municipalities, and counties, public housing authorities and councils of government) and a CBO (4) Puerto Rico (5) U.S. Territories – includes territorial and local governmental entities in American Samoa, Guam, the Commonwealth of Northern Mariana Islands, and the U.S. Virgin Islands (6) Freely Associated States (FAS) – includes state and local governmental entities in the Federated States of Micronesia, the Republic of the Marshall Islands, and Palau (7) Tribal governments in remote areas (as defined in Section II.C of this RFA) (8) State recognized tribal governments * NOTE: The term CBO is defined in Section I.A of the RFA. In addition, the partnership must be documented with a signed Letter of Commitment from the CBO detailing the parameters of the partnership, as well as the role and responsibilities of the community-based organization. See further details about partnerships below. Requirements of a Threshold Eligibility Qualifying CBO Partnership – For the purposes of the Environmental and Climate Justice Block Grants programs authorized by section 138 of the Clean Air Act that are covered by this RFA, a “partnership” is a formal relationship between a state, federally recognized tribal government, or local government and a CBO that is memorialized in writing and is legally binding under applicable law. This requirement does not apply to state recognized tribes, FAS, U.S. territories, Puerto Rico, and remote tribal governments (federally recognized or state recognized). The qualifying partnership agreement must be signed by both parties and specify which member of the partnership will enter into the assistance agreement with EPA for the purposes of accountability for the proper expenditure of federal funds and receipt of the funds from EPA, performance of the assistance agreement, liability for claims for recovery of unallowable costs 6 Although under section 138(b)(3)(A) partnerships between institutions of higher education and CBOs are eligible entities, for policy reasons EPA is limiting eligibility for this RFA to partnerships between units of government and CBOs. Note that this limitation applies to institutions of higher education that are agencies and instrumentalities of state or tribal governments such as state universities and tribal colleges under this RFA. -16- incurred under the agreement and must specify roles in performing the proposed scope of work for the assistance agreement. For purposes of this RFA, the direct recipient of the EPA funds must be the state, local, or federally recognized tribal government partner and the CBO(s) partners must receive the funds from the direct recipient as subawards. Thus, a qualifying partnership must include a subaward agreement from the direct recipient of EPA funds to the partnering CBO(s). Additionally, Letters of Commitment from the partnering CBO(s) must indicate a subaward agreement is planned to establish the partnership. The qualifying partnership agreement must also at a minimum specify other roles and responsibilities of each partner, including how the priority environmental and public health issues of the disadvantaged communities being served by the partnership are identified and selected for projects and activities, as well as the role of community leaders in the decision-making processes and implementation of the proposed projects for funding. NOTE - Applicants are not required to include the qualifying partnership agreement as a part of their workplan but must include the necessary details as expressed above for the expected subaward(s) between the direct recipients of EPA funds and the partnering CBO(s). If a non- financial relationship exists between entities (e.g., in-kind support on the project), then a letter of commitment explaining the non-financial relationship is sufficient. Letters of Commitment – Applicants should include signed letters of commitment from the partnering CBOs (and entities from other stakeholder groups) that provide detailed information about the partnership agreement (e.g., roles and responsibilities), including information about the planned subaward (if applicable). Only partnerships that include a signed letter of commitment will be considered valid partnerships during the evaluation of your application. Please do not include generic letters of support. A generic letter of support will not count as a valid letter of commitment. EPA strongly encourages EJG2G projects to include at least three partners from three different stakeholder groups Nonprofit Organization Definition – For the purposes of the “nonprofit organization” requirement for qualifying as a CBO consistent with the definition of Nonprofit organization at 2 CFR 200.1, the term “nonprofit organization means any corporation, trust, association, cooperative, or other organization that is operated mainly for scientific, educational, service, charitable, or similar purpose in the public interest and is not organized primarily for profit; and uses net proceeds to maintain, improve, or expand the operation of the organization. Eligible nonprofit organizations may, but are not required to be, exempt from taxation under section 501 of the Internal Revenue Code. Workforce Investment Boards and organized Labor Unions that meet these criteria may be eligible community-based nonprofit organizations. Nonprofit organizations described in Section 501(c)(4) of the Internal Revenue Code that engage in lobbying activities as defined in Section 3 of the Lobbying Disclosure Act of 1995 are not eligible to apply. The following entities are INELIGIBLE to receive a direct award as described in Section A above, but we strongly encourage applicants to work with these entities as appropriate (e.g., through procurement contracts or subawards). (See competition requirements in Contracts and Subawards solicitation clause) to perform the project: A. Public and Nonprofit institutions of higher education, including state and tribal colleges and universities even if they are instrumentalities of state or tribal government. B. Hospitals and medical facilities even if they are instrumentalities of state, tribal or local governments. -17- C. Non-profit organizations even if they are CBOs.7 D. For-profit businesses E. Faith-based organizations and local houses of worships F. Civic and philanthropic organizations G. International Organizations8 H. Individuals B. COST-SHARING OR MATCHING FUNDS No cost-sharing or matching is required as a condition of eligibility under this competition. C. THRESHOLD ELIGIBILITY CRITERIA All applications must meet the eligibility requirements described in Sections III.A., B., and C. to be considered eligible for award. Applicants deemed ineligible for funding consideration as a result of the threshold eligibility review will be notified within 15 calendar days of the ineligibility determination. 1. Applications must substantially comply with the application submission instructions and requirements set forth in Section IV of this RFA or else they will be rejected. However, where a page limit is expressed in Section IV with respect to the application or parts thereof, pages in excess of the page limitation will not be reviewed. In addition to any page limitations, applicants are advised that readability is of paramount importance and should take precedence with respect to such things as font type and size. 2. Initial applications must be submitted through Grants.gov as stated in Section IV of this RFA (except in the limited circumstances where another mode of submission is specifically allowed for as explained in Section IV) on or before the application submission deadline published in Section IV of this RFA. Applicants are responsible for following the submission instructions in Section IV of this RFA to ensure that their application is properly and timely submitted. Please note that applicants experiencing technical issues with submitting through Grants.gov should follow the instructions provided in the Section IV.A grants.gov instructions, which includes both the requirement to contact Grants.gov and email a full application to EPA prior to the deadline. 3. Applications submitted outside of Grants.gov will be deemed ineligible without further consideration unless the applicant can clearly demonstrate that it was due to EPA mishandling or technical problems associated with Grants.gov or SAM.gov. An applicant’s failure to timely submit their application through Grants.gov because they did not timely or properly register in SAM.gov or Grants.gov will not be considered an acceptable reason to 7 As noted above, for this RFA the direct recipient must be a unit of government and CBOs who enter into partnership agreements with units of government are eligible subrecipients. 8 International organization means a public international organization in which the US participates pursuant to any treaty or under the authority of any Act of Congress authorizing such participation or making an appropriation for such participation, and which shall have been designated by the President through appropriate Executive order as being entitled to enjoy privileges, exemptions, and immunities conferred by the International Organizations Immunities Act. 22 U.S.C. § 288. -18- consider a submission outside of Grants.gov. Applicants should confirm receipt of their application with Omari Burrell, Burrell.Omari@epa.gov as soon as possible after submission —failure to do so may result in your application not being reviewed. DO NOT WAIT! Register in SAM.gov or Grants.gov as soon as possible. Finalizing these registrations could take a month or more. You do not want a late registration to prevent you from being able to properly submit your application through Grants.gov. 4. Please note that applications must be written in English only. Applications written in languages other than English will not be considered for award. 5. Ineligible Activities - If an application is submitted that includes any ineligible tasks or activities, including but not limited to those described in Section I.H, that portion of the application will be ineligible for funding and may, depending on the extent to which it affects the application, render the entire application ineligible for funding. Funds awarded under this RFA may not be used to support lobbying activities as provided in 2 CFR 200.450. Subawards made to 501(c)(4) nonprofit organizations that lobby are not allowed. Note: Land purchases and/or acquisitions that exceed half of the requested project funds are also not allowed. 6. Multiple Applications – Applicants may submit only one application under this solicitation. If an applicant submits more than one, then they will be contacted by EPA prior to the evaluation process to determine which one to withdraw. However, an applicant organization may be a partner on a single application or multiple applications. Additionally, applicants can only receive one award under this EJG2G announcement. NOTE: Different agencies, departments and/or divisions within a state, local, tribal, or territorial government may submit one application each. However, each applying agency, department, and/or division must have their own UEI number. EPA will seek clarity from applicants where it appears applications are duplicative and/or were submitted by the same governmental entity. Applications that are duplicative will be considered ineligible. IV. APPLICATION AND SUBMISSION INFORMATION (back to Contents by Section) Note: Additional provisions that apply to this section can be found at EPA Announcement Clauses. A. REQUIREMENT TO SUBMIT THROUGH GRANTS.GOV AND LIMITED EXCEPTION PROCEDURES 1. Requirement to Submit Through Grants.gov and Limited Exception Procedures Applicants must apply electronically through Grants.gov under this RFA based on the grants.gov instructions below. If your organization has no access to the internet or access is very limited, you may request an exception from applying through Grants.gov for the remainder of this calendar year by following the procedures outlined here. Please note that your request must be received at least 15 calendar days before the application due date to allow enough time to negotiate alternative submission methods. Issues with -19- submissions with respect to this RFA only are addressed in section 3, Technical Issues with Submission, below. 2. Submission Instructions a. SAM.gov (System for Award Management) Registration Instructions Organizations applying to this funding opportunity must have an active SAM.gov registration. If you have never done business with the Federal Government, you will need to register your organization in SAM.gov. If you do not have a SAM.gov account, then you will need to create an account using login.gov9 to complete your SAM.gov registration. SAM.gov registration is FREE. The process for entity registration includes obtaining a Unique Entity ID (UEI), a 12-character alphanumeric ID assigned an entity by SAM.gov, and requires assertions, representations and certifications, and other information about your organization. Please review the Entity Registration Checklist for details on this process. If you have done business with the Federal Government previously, you can check your entity status using your government issued UEI to determine if your registration is active. SAM.gov requires you renew your registration every 365 days to keep it active. Please note that SAM.gov registration is different than obtaining a UEI only. Obtaining an UEI only validates your organization’s legal business name and address. Please review the Frequently Asked Question on the difference for additional details. Organizations should ensure that their SAM.gov registration includes a current e- Business (EBiz) point of contact name and email address. The EBiz point of contact is critical for Grants.gov Registration and system functionality. Contact the Federal Service Desk for help with your SAM.gov account, to resolve technical issues or chat with a help desk agent: (866) 606-8220. The Federal Service desk hours of operation are Monday – Friday 8am – 8pm ET. b. Grants.gov Registration Instructions Once your SAM.gov account is active, you must register in Grants.gov. Grants.gov will electronically receive your organization information, such as e-Business (EBiz) point of contact email address and UEI. Organizations applying to this funding opportunity must have an active Grants.gov registration. Grants.gov registration is FREE. If you have never applied for a federal grant before, please review the Grants.gov Applicant Registration instructions. As part of the Grants.gov registration process, the EBiz point of contact is the only person that can affiliate and assign applicant roles to members of an organization. In addition, at least one person must be assigned as an Authorized Organization Representative (AOR). Only person(s) with the AOR role can submit applications in Grants.gov. Please review the Intro to Grants.gov-Understanding User Roles and Learning Workspace – User Roles and Workspace Actions for details on this important process. Please note that this process can take a month or more for new registrants. Applicants 9 Login.gov a secure sign in service used by the public to sign into Federal Agency systems including SAM.gov and Grants.gov. For help with login.gov accounts you should visit http://login.gov/help. -20- must ensure that all registration requirements are met in order to apply for this opportunity through Grants.gov and should ensure that all such requirements have been met well in advance of the application submission deadline. Contact Grants.gov for assistance at 1-800-518-4726 or support@grants.gov to resolve technical issues with Grants.gov. Applicants who are outside the U.S. at the time of submittal and are not able to access the toll-free number may reach a Grants.gov representative by calling 606-545-5035. The Grants.gov Support Center is available 24 hours a day 7 days a week, excluding federal holidays. c. Application Submission Process To begin the application process under this RFA, go to Grants.gov and click the red “Apply” button at the top of the view grant opportunity page associated with this opportunity. The electronic submission of your application to this RFA must be made by an official representative of your organization who is registered with Grants.gov and is authorized to sign applications for Federal financial assistance. If the submit button is grayed out, it may be because you do not have the appropriate role to submit in your organization. Contact your organization’s EBiz point of contact or contact Grants.gov for assistance at 1-800-518-4726 or support@grants.gov. Applicants need to ensure that the Authorized Organization Representative (AOR) who submits the application through Grants.gov and whose UEI is listed on the application is an AOR for the applicant listed on the application. Additionally, the UEI listed on the application must be registered to the applicant organization's SAM.gov account. If not, the application may be deemed ineligible. d. Application Submission Deadline Your organization's AOR must submit your complete application package electronically to EPA through Grants.gov no later than April 14, at 11:59 PM ET. Please allow for enough time to successfully submit your application and allow for unexpected errors that may require you to resubmit. Applications submitted through Grants.gov will be time and date stamped electronically. Please note that successful submission of your application through Grants.gov does not necessarily mean your application is eligible for award. Any application submitted after the application deadline time and date deadline will be deemed ineligible and not be considered. 3. Technical Issues with Submission If applicants experience technical issues during the submission of an application that they are unable to resolve, follow these procedures before the application deadline date: a. Contact the Grants.gov Support Center before the application deadline date. b. Document the Grants.gov ticket/case number. -21- c. Send an email with EPA-OEJECR-OCS-23-02 in the subject line to burrell.omari@epa.gov before the application deadline time and include the following information: 1. Grants.gov ticket/case number(s) 2. Description of the issue 3. The entire application package in PDF format Without this information, EPA may not be able to consider applications submitted outside of Grants.gov. Any application submitted after the application deadline will be deemed ineligible and not be considered. Please note that successful submission through Grants.gov or email does not necessarily mean your application is eligible for award. EPA will make decisions concerning acceptance of each application submitted outside of Grants.gov on a case-by-case basis. EPA will only consider accepting applications that were unable to submit through Grants.gov due to Grants.gov or relevant SAM.gov system issues or for unforeseen exigent circumstances, such as extreme weather interfering with internet access. Failure of an applicant to submit the application prior to the application submission deadline time and date because they did not properly or timely register in SAM.gov or Grants.gov is not an acceptable reason to justify acceptance of an application outside of Grants.gov. 4. Application Materials The following forms and documents are required under this announcement: Mandatory Documents: 1. Application for Federal Assistance (SF-424) 2. Budget Information for Non-Construction Programs (SF-424A) 3. EPA Form 4700-4 Pre-award Compliance Review Report (Please see these Useful Tips for completing this form) 4. EPA Key Contacts Form 5700-54 5. Project Narrative Attachment Form: Use this to submit your workplan, prepared as described in Section IV.B below. Please note the page limit that applies to the workplan identified below. 6. Use the Other Attachments Form for the following additional mandatory documents: • Itemized Budget Sheet (See below Section IV.B.1 and Appendices E & F) • Environmental Results/Logic Model (See below Section IV.B.1 and Appendices B, C, & D) • Letters of Commitment from Partners (See Section IV.B.1 below) • Resumes of the Project Manager (PM) and other key personnel (See Section IV.B.1 below) B. CONTENT AND FORM OF APPLICATION SUBMISSION The forms and documents required as part of the application submission are described in Section IV.A above. 1. APPLICATION WORKPLAN: The workplan is one of the most important parts of the application package. The workplan describes the project. workplans that are focused and succinct are stronger than ones that try to address too many issues. Applications will be -22- evaluated on the extent and quality of how well the project addresses program objectives and allowable activities under the criteria in Section V. The workplan, as described below, must not exceed eighteen (18) single-spaced typewritten pages (including the Project Summary Page) and be on letter size pages (8 1/2 X 11 inches). Any pages beyond 18 pages will not be reviewed by the Review Panel. It is recommended that applicants use a standard font (e.g., Times New Roman, Calibri, and Arial) and a 12-point font size with 1- inch margins. While these guidelines establish the acceptable type size requirements, applicants are advised that readability is of paramount importance and should take precedence in selection of an appropriate font for use in the application. Supporting materials, such as resumes and partnership letters, can be submitted as attachments and are not included in the 18-page limit. Project applications must be written in English. Workplans must address the information described above. The 18-page workplan must also contain the following components (items 1.0-6.0 below) and should be identified by the headings in the order listed below. Also ensure that the workplan addresses all the evaluation criteria in Section V and any necessary threshold eligibility criteria in Section III: 1.0 Program Objectives a. Project Summary Page – Recommended one-page summary document (this page does count as part of the 18-page workplan limit). Summary includes: • Applicant Information (Org Name, Main Point of Contact, address, contact info) • Environmental issues – e.g., Air, Land, Water related • Project Abstract -- Brief description (250 words or less) of the main objective, activities, and outputs/outcomes of the project, including the specific geographic areas of focus. • Project Type(s) -- such as research, tool development, training, small-scale construction, and monitoring • Underserved Communities and Vulnerable Populations addressed by project (include geographic and location info, such as zip code, city or county) • Special Considerations* – If applicable to your project, which special considerations do you believe your project qualifies for? (Climate Change/Disaster Resiliency, Health Impact Assessment, Rural Areas, or any Other Factor described below in Section V) • List of Project Partners – include partner name and stakeholder group. For example, Tribal Governments (tribe); State University (academic); CBO (see definition in Section I); House of worship (faith-based); Internet Technology contractor (business/industry); etc. • Will you need to develop a QAPP for your project? (See Appendix G) * If your project relates to one or more of the other factors in Section V (e.g., Health Impact Assessment, Rural Areas, or Disaster Resiliency) include additional details about how the project addresses those factors in this section. b. Disproportionate Environmental and Public Health Issues Impacting Underserved Communities - The applicant will be evaluated on the ability to clearly describe the local environmental justice issue(s), underserved communities, and vulnerable populations the project proposes to address and the communities that are impacted. Accordingly, please describe the following: -23- • Describe and characterize the underserved communities and vulnerable populations directly impacted by disproportionate environmental and/or public health issues and describe how those communities and populations are impacted by those issues • What are the environmental/public health issue(s) that the project seeks to address? Describe other recent efforts in the State, if any, that have sought to address those issues as well • What are the environmental/public health results the project seeks to achieve and how will the underserved communities and vulnerable populations benefit from those results? The application must include relevant information such as demographics, geographic location, and community history. We encourage the use of EPA’s EJSCREEN tool and/or local screening and mapping tools to further help characterize and describe your target communities. Instructions and resources on how to use EJSCREEN are included at the hyperlink above. For any questions you have about EJSCREEN, please contact Tai Lung at Lung.Tai@epa.gov or 202-566-1296. c. Organization’s Recent Efforts to Directly Support Underserved Communities - The applicant will be evaluated on the strength of its efforts over the last five years to provide direct support and build relationships with underserved communities and vulnerable populations involved with the proposed project. Please describe the following: • Recent Efforts (within five years) your organization has made to provide direct support and build relationships with the underserved communities and vulnerable populations identified in your application, including the duration of involvement and circumstances that led to your organization’s involvement. Examples may include, development of new housing assistance programs, community workshops and public meetings, environmental justice programming, and neighborhood planning • How your entity has worked directly with community residents and/or community- based organizations of underserved communities to address local environmental and public health issues within the last five years and what are some of the results of that work • How the residents were part of the decision-making process of past efforts. How those efforts increased capacity and resources for local underserved communities to address public health and/or environmental issues. And, how the applicant maintained an ongoing relationship with those communities and populations d. Project Linkages Please describe the following: • Briefly describe how the project supports EPA Strategic Plan Goal 2, Objective 2.1 (Promote Environmental Justice and Civil Rights at the Federal, Tribal, State, and Local Levels). https://www.epa.gov/planandbudget/strategicplan e. Partner and Collaborate - Provide a clear and concise description of how the proposed project promotes collaborations with partners from multiple stakeholder groups, such as CBOs, business, academia, government, etc., to develop and implement solutions that will address environmental and/or public health issues. We encourage applicants to seek diversity in partnerships in an effort to enhance the process of -24- achieving the project’s goals. Applicants are strongly encouraged to have at least THREE signed letters of commitment from partners representing at least THREE different stakeholder groups. Note: A partnership with a CBO is required for states, local governments, and federally recognized tribes. This counts as one stakeholder group. • Describe how the project will accomplish its goals through the use of appropriate and diverse partnerships from multiple stakeholder groups, such as grassroots community groups, business, academia, government, etc. • Identify and describe all partners involved, including those partnerships that may be under development. Include the following details about each of your partners. If you are not planning on collaborating with other stakeholders or having partners for project performance, you must describe how you can effectively perform the project without such collaboration or partnerships: - Planned roles of each partner listed in your Project Summary. Include which stakeholder group the partner represents and the project activities each partner will be responsible for - What resources each partner brings to the partnership - How the partner has a vested interest in working with this partnership [other than just getting income from a sub-award or contract] - How the applicant organization plans to maintain and sustain these relationships on into the future Note About Commitment Letters: Given the nature of this program and the requirements under CAA 138, partnerships and collaborations with other interested stakeholders in performance of the project will likely be necessary and, for certain entities, required (refer to Section III.A for eligible entity requirements) could adversely impact the applicant’s scoring under the relevant evaluation criteria in Section V and render the application less competitive than others that include partnerships and collaboration. Partnerships and collaboration with other interested stakeholders in performance of the project are integral to the success of this program. If an applicant is eligible without partners and does not demonstrate such partnerships or collaboration as described above, they must be able to convincingly demonstrate in their application how they can effectively perform the project without any partners or collaboration. All letters of commitment for required partnerships with CBOs as well as other types of collaborative partnerships must be submitted by the applicant with its application package by the submission deadline. The letters of commitment must be included as other attachments in the grants.gov application package (Section IV.A) and are not subject to the 18-page workplan limit. The letters must be submitted by the applicant with the other application documents by the submission deadline. The letters of commitment should include information about the role and activities each partner or stakeholder organization will perform as well as any resources the partner or stakeholder will provide. The letters of commitment must be signed by the partnering organizations. Do not include generic letters of support or recommendation. Regardless -25- of the source, generic letters of support will not be considered in evaluating applications. Partnerships and collaborations that are not supported by letters of commitment will not be included in the evaluation of the application. If no letters of commitment are included, then it will be assumed the applicant has no partners and they must demonstrate how they can effectively perform the project without partners or collaboration. For-profit organizations are not eligible for subawards under this grant program but may receive procurement contracts. Any contracts for services or products funded with EPA financial assistance must be awarded under the competitive procurement procedures of 2 CFR Part 200 and/or 2 CFR Part 1500, as applicable. The regulations at 2 CFR 1500.10 contain limitations on the extent to which EPA funds may be used to compensate individual consultants. Refer to the Best Practice Guide for Procuring Services, Supplies, and Equipment Under EPA Assistance Agreements for guidance on competitive procurement requirements and consultant compensation. Do not name a procurement contractor (including a consultant) as a “partner” or otherwise in your application unless the contractor has been selected in compliance with competitive procurement requirements. Note also that competitive procurement requirements apply to contracts entered into prior to or after selection for award even if you do not name a contractor as a partner. Additionally, potential contractors who assist with preparing requests for proposals, quotations of similar documents (including providing sample procurement documents) must be excluded from competing for the procurement as required by 2 CFR 200.319. Note: If you intend to fund a named or unnamed partner’s participation in the project your application must describe how the proposed financial transaction complies with applicable requirements in 2 CFR Part 200, EPA’s Subaward Policy, the Best Practice Guide for Procuring Services, Supplies, and Equipment Under EPA Assistance Agreements or EPA Guidance on Participant Support Costs. Note that naming a contractor (including a consultant) as a “partner” does not relieve the applicant from complying with competitive procurement requirements. EPA does not accept sole source contract justifications for professional services (including environmental consulting services and consulting services on preparing grant applications) that are available in the commercial marketplace. 2.0 Project Activities / Milestone Schedule / Detailed Budget Narrative Please describe the following: a. Project Activities - Clear description of steps the applicant will take to meet the program objectives. Descriptions of the detailed project activities or components and the anticipated products/results associated with each activity. b. Milestone Schedule - Clearly articulated milestone schedule, including timeframes and major milestones to complete significant project activities. It is recommended that you insert a table in your application narrative to help organize your milestone schedule. c. Itemized Budget Sheet / Budget Narrative - Submit as Attachment (use Other Attachment Form in Grants.gov). Do not include leveraged funds from other sources in your EPA budget request. See further budget details later in this section (Section IV). -26- 3.0 Environmental Results – Outputs, Outcomes, and Performance Measures (Logic Model) Please describe the following: a. Environmental Results (Logic Model) – Submit as Attachment (use Other Attachments Form in Grants.gov). See further instructions later in Section IV on this optional submission. b. Performance Measurement Plan – Applicants will be evaluated on the ability to formulate concrete, well-developed performance measures on a semi-annual and annual basis. Applicants should describe how they plan to track and monitor their project performance and progress throughout the project period. Applicants will be evaluated on the extent and quality to which the application demonstrates a sound plan for tracking progress towards achieving the expected outputs, outcomes, and associated timeframes for achieving those results. You will be evaluated on your approach for determining how and whether progress is made in achieving the expected project outcomes and outputs and how your project will achieve these results. c. Sustainability Plan and Environmental Justice Integration – Based on your project planning with underserved communities and other partners, describe how your organization plans to utilize the results and momentum of the proposed project to further integrate environmental justice principles in all operations of State and/or local government work. 4.0 Programmatic Capability In order to be evaluated under this criterion in Section V, applicants must provide information on their: a. Organizational Experience related to the proposed project and their plan for building relationships with underserved communities, community groups, and vulnerable populations to successfully perform the project b. Staff Experience / Qualifications of Project Manager (PM) - Provide information that clearly demonstrates that the proposed PM and other staff associated with the project are qualified to perform the project successfully. This will be determined through the description of the following: - Why the PM and associated staff are qualified to undertake the project - Illustrating the PM’s experience building relationships with community residents and community organizations in a professional capacity. Please include detailed descriptions of similar activities and programs that the PM has worked onto improve local communities c. Expenditure of Awarded Grant Funds - Applicants will be evaluated based on their approach, procedures, and controls for ensuring that awarded grant funds will be expended in a timely and efficient manner and applicants must describe this in the workplan. -27- 5.0 Past Performance Submit a list of federally and/or non-federally funded assistance agreements (assistance agreements include Federal grants and cooperative agreements but not Federal contracts) similar in size and scope to the proposed project that your organization performed within the last three years (no more than 5 agreements, and preferably EPA agreements) and describe (i) whether, and how, you were able to successfully complete and manage those agreements and (ii) your history of meeting the reporting requirements under those agreements including whether you adequately and timely reported on your progress towards achieving the expected outputs and outcomes of those agreements (and if not, explain why not) and whether you submitted acceptable final technical reports under the agreements. In evaluating applicants under these factors in Section V, EPA will consider the information provided by the applicant and may also consider relevant information from other sources, including information from EPA files and from current/prior grantors (e.g., to verify and/or supplement the information provided by the applicant). If you do not have any relevant or available past performance or past reporting information, please indicate this in the application and you will receive a neutral score for these factors (a neutral score is half of the total points available in a subset of possible points). If you do not provide any response for these items, you may receive a score of 0 for these factors. 6.0 Quality Assurance Project Plan (QAPP) Information (If applicable) Please describe the following: • Indicate whether you believe that your project will involve the use of existing environmental data or information or the collection of new data (use the checklist in Appendix F to assist you in making this determination). For more information about Quality Assurance Project Plans, please consult the following website https://www.epa.gov/sites/default/files/2015-06/documents/g5-final.pdf. You are not required to develop a QAPP at this point. You are only being asked to determine whether you will need a QAPP should your project be selected for funding. If required, then an approved QAPP must be in place prior to the initiation of project activities related to environmental data collection or use. 7.0 Other Attachments Forms a. Itemized Budget Sheet (Template available in Appendices E and F): Provide a detailed budget and estimated funding amount for each project component/activity. Identify the requested federal dollars. Keep in mind that EPA reserves the right to partially fund applications by funding discrete portions of the proposed projects. Clearly explain how EPA funds will be used. Applicants must itemize costs related to personnel, fringe benefits, contractual costs, travel, equipment, supplies, other direct costs, indirect costs, and total costs in their EPA budget request. All subaward funding should be located under the “other” category. This section provides an opportunity for narrative description of the budget or aspects of the budget such as “other” and contractual. Provide itemized costs with sufficient detail for EPA to determine the reasonableness and allowability of costs for each workplan -28- component/activity. Where necessary, your itemized budget sheet should include a budget narrative to make it clear how you determined/calculated the costs for each budget category. Please note that applicants that intend to use EPA funds for construction must include the estimated costs for construction contracts in the “Construction” line item and estimated costs for architectural and engineering services in the “Contractual” line item in the detailed budget sheet and the SF 424 A form. In accordance with 2 CFR 200.414(f), recipients that do not have a current negotiated indirect cost rate under 10% are eligible for a de minimis rate of 10% of modified total direct costs for all Federal awards. Please see EPA’s IDC Policy: https://www.epa.gov/sites/default/files/2021-04/documents/indirect-cost-policy-for- recipients-of-epa-assistance-agreements.pdf for full details. Note that as provided in 2 CFR 200.332 subrecipients who do not have current negotiated indirect cost rates may also use the 10% rate but that applicants may not force subrecipients to use the 10% rate rather than their negotiated rate. Total estimated costs in the itemized budget template should reflect federal funding only. Applicants are permitted to attach the itemized budget template as an “Other Attachment” to their application and it will not count against the 18-page workplan limit. Applicants will not be penalized if they choose not to use the budget template. b. Environmental Results / Logic Model Applicants will be evaluated on the quality of the expected project outputs and outcomes identified in the application for their project. The expected outputs and outcomes should be effective in achieving the Program Objectives listed in Section I, including developing strategies for addressing local environmental and public health issues, as well as building consensus and setting community priorities in the underserved community. Applicants are permitted to attach their completed logic models as an “Other Attachment” to their applications so the sheet will not count against the 18-page workplan limit. While not required, including a logic model as part of your application package is strongly encouraged. A logic model is a useful tool in developing output and outcome measures. It is a visual illustration that shows the relationship between your work and your desired results. Applicants may use the logic model template provided in the appendices or use/create one of their own likings. If you choose not to provide a logic model, you must still detail the outputs and outcomes of your project and address how you will measure performance. (Logic model template and example are available in Appendices B, C, & D). When developing outputs and outcomes for all projects, it is important to consider the following: - What are the measurable short term and longer term results the project will achieve? - How will my project measure progress in achieving the expected results (including outputs and outcomes) and how will the approach use resources effectively and efficiently? -29- - Are the projected outputs and outcomes specific and detailed? Did I include specific target measures where possible? Are my target measures reasonable and achievable within the project period and for the funding amount? c. Letters of Commitment from Partners (representing at least three stakeholder groups): Letters of commitment should include information about the role and activities each partner or stakeholder organization will perform as well as any resources the partner or stakeholder will provide. The letters of commitment must be signed by the partnering organizations. Do not include generic letters of support or recommendation. Regardless of the source, generic letters of support will not be considered in evaluating applications. The Letters of Commitment are not subject to the 18-page limit. Note: A partnership with a CBO is required for states, local governments, and federally recognized tribes. This counts as one stakeholder group. d. Resumes of the Project Manager (PM) and Other Key Personnel: Applicants must attach a resume or curricula vitae (CV) for the PM and other key personnel named on the Key Contacts List. These are not subject to the workplan page limit although individual resumes should not exceed 2 pages in length. 8.0 Intergovernmental Review Act Executive Order 12372, (For projects proposing construction and/or land use planning activities) NOTE - Intergovernmental Review of Federal Programs may be applicable to awards resulting from this announcement. EPA implemented the Executive Order in 40 CFR Part 29. EPA may require applicants selected for funding to provide a copy of their application to their State Point of Contact (SPOC) for review as provided at 40 CFR 29.7 and 40 CFR 29.8. The SPOC list can be found on the webpage below. • Office of Federal Financial Management Resources and Other Information EPA may require successful applicants from states that do not have a SPOC to provide a copy of their application for review to directly affected state, area-wide, regional and local government entities as provided at 40 CFR 29.7 and 40 CFR 29.8. These reviews are not required before submitting an application. Only applicants that EPA selects for funding under this announcement are subject to the Intergovernmental Review requirement. -30- C. PRE-APPLICATION ASSISTANCE CALLS, WEBINARS, & FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS Applicants are invited to participate in webinars with EPA to address questions about the EJG2G Program and this solicitation. Interested persons may access the pre-application assistance calls by dialing the conference call-in information listed in the table below when prompted. Additional conference call information, webinar links, and call recordings can be found at the following website: https://www.epa.gov/environmentaljustice/environmental- justice-government-government-program. Currently, as shown in the table below, there will be two webinars for this RFA. Webinar dates and times may be subject to change, so please refer to the web links in this section to have the most up-to-date information: Date Time Zoom Webinar Information (Eastern Time) January 26, 2:00pm - Zoom Webinar Format - Applicants may ask general 2022 3:30pm ET questions about this RFA. (EJG2G Live Visit the following link for log-in information: Webinar) https://www.epa.gov/environmentaljustice/environmental- justice-government-government-program February 7, 2:00pm – Zoom Webinar Format - Applicants may ask general 2023 3:30pm ET questions about this RFA. (EJG2G Live Visit the following link for log-in information: Webinar) https://www.epa.gov/environmentaljustice/environmental- justice-government-government-program In accordance with EPA's Assistance Agreement Competition Policy (EPA Order 5700.5A1), EPA staff will not meet with individual applicants to discuss draft applications, provide informal comments on draft applications, or provide advice to applicants on how to respond to ranking criteria. Applicants are responsible for the contents of their applications. However, consistent with the provisions in the announcement, EPA will respond to questions from individual applicants regarding threshold eligibility criteria, administrative issues related to the submission of the application, and requests for clarification about the announcement. In addition, if necessary, EPA may clarify threshold eligibility issues with applicants prior to making an eligibility determination. -31- V. APPLICATION REVIEW INFORMATION (back to Contents by Section) Note: Additional provisions that apply to this section can be found at EPA Announcement Clauses. A. MERIT EVALUATION CRITERIA Eligible applications that meet the threshold eligibility criteria described in Section III. will be reviewed and scored by a review panel(s) comprised of EPA staff and subject matter experts using the criterion below. The maximum total number of points is 100. Please note that certain criteria are worth more points than others. Applicants must ensure that their workplan and application materials address the evaluation criteria below. Applications will be scored based on how well they address the following ranking criteria: Points Criteria Category Evaluation Criteria 100 Program Objectives 38 1.0 Applications will be evaluated based on the extent and quality to which they address the following: a. Project Summary The one-page summary document includes: 2 Page • Applicant Information (Org Name, Main Point of Contact, address, contact info) • Environmental issues – e.g., Air, Land, Water related • Project Abstract -- Brief description (250 words or less) of the main objective, activities, and outputs/outcomes of the project, including the specific geographic areas of focus. • Project Type(s) – such as research, tool development, training, small-scale construction, and monitoring • Underserved Communities and Vulnerable Populations addressed by project (include geographic and location info, such as zip code, city, or county) • Special Considerations – If applicable to your project, which special considerations do you believe your project qualifies for? (Climate Change/Disaster Resiliency, Health Impact Assessment, Rural Areas, or any Other Factor described below in Section V) • List of Project Partners -- include partner name and stakeholder group. For example, Tribal Governments (tribe); State University (academic); CBOs; House of Worship (faith-based); Internet Technology contractor (business/industry); etc. • Will you need to develop a QAPP for your project? (See Appendix G) b. Disproportionate Applications will be evaluated on how clearly they describe 12 Environmental the local environmental justice issue(s), underserved -32- and Public Health communities, and vulnerable populations the project proposes Issues Impacting to address and the communities that are impacted. Applicants Underserved will be evaluated based on the extent and quality to which Communities they (maximum 4 points each): (1) Describe and characterize the underserved communities and vulnerable populations directly impacted by disproportionate environmental and/or public health issues and describe how those communities and populations are impacted by those issues (2) Describe the local environmental/public health issue(s) that the project seeks to address? Describe other recent efforts in the State, if any, that have sought to address those issues as well (3) Describe the local environmental/public health results the project seeks to achieve and how will the underserved communities and vulnerable populations benefit from those results? * The application must include relevant information such as demographics, geographic location, and community history. We encourage the use of EPA’s EJSCREEN tool and/or local screening and mapping tools to further help characterize and describe your target communities. Instructions and resources on how to use EJSCREEN are included at the hyperlink above. For any questions you have about EJSCREEN, please contact Tai Lung at Lung.Tai@epa.gov or 202-566-1296. c. Organization’s The application will be evaluated on the extent and quality to 12 Recent Efforts to which it demonstrates the strength of its efforts over the last Directly Support five years to provide direct support and build relationships Underserved with underserved communities and vulnerable populations Communities involved with the proposed project. Applications will be evaluated based the extent and quality to which it addresses the following (maximum 4 points each): (1) Recent Efforts (within the last five years) that the applicant’s organization has made to provide direct support and build relationships with the underserved communities and vulnerable populations identified in your application, including the duration of involvement and circumstances that led to your organization’s involvement. Examples may include, development of new housing assistance programs, community workshops and public meetings, environmental justice programming, and neighborhood planning. -33- (2) How the applicant organization has worked directly with community residents and/or CBOs of underserved communities to address local environmental and public health issues within the last five years and what are some of the results of that work. (3) How the residents were part of the decision-making process of past efforts. How those efforts increased capacity and resources for underserved communities to address public health and/or environmental issues. And, how the applicant maintained an ongoing relationship with those communities and populations. d. Project Linkages The application will be evaluated on the extent and quality to 2 which it: (1) Supports EPA Strategic Plan Goal 2 (Take Decisive Action to Advance Environmental Justice and Civil Rights), Objective 2.1 (Promote Environmental Justice and Civil Rights at the Federal, Tribal, State, and Local Levels) (2 points) Refer to link Below: https://www.epa.gov/planandbudget/strategicplan e. Partner and Under this criterion, applications will be evaluated on the 10 Collaborate following sub criteria: a. The quality and extent to which the applicant provides a clear and concise description of how the proposed project promotes collaborations with partners from multiple stakeholder groups, such as CBOs, industry, business, academia, government, etc., to develop and implement solutions that will address environmental and/or public health issues at the local level. Under this criterion, EPA will evaluate: - planned roles of each partner listed on the Project Summary Page - how each partner will contribute to the project, - what resources each partner brings to the project - how the partner has a vested interest in working with this partnership (other than just getting income from a sub-award or contract) - how the applicant organization plans to sustain these relationships on into the future (5 points) Eligible applicants who do not propose partnerships or collaboration with others will be evaluated based on how well they demonstrate that they can effectively -34- and efficiently perform the project without any collaborating partners. b. Letters of Commitment. Applications will be evaluated based on the quality of the letters of commitment submitted with the application. Applicants are strongly encouraged to submit at least three letters of commitment from three partners from three different stakeholder groups. The letters should explain the partners’ role in the project, what resources (funding, in-kind, technical assistance, etc.) they are bringing to the effort, and their interest in the project and community. Generic letters of support will not be evaluated. Submitting fewer than three letters of commitment from three different stakeholder groups may negatively impact an applicant’s score under this criterion. (5 points) NOTE: Only partnerships supported by a commitment letter will be evaluated using the above sub criteria. Partnerships with no commitment letters will not be evaluated. Partnerships and collaboration with other interested stakeholders in performance of the project are integral to the success of this program. If an applicant does not demonstrate such partnerships or collaboration as described in Section IV, applications will be evaluated on how well they demonstrate in their application that they can effectively perform the project without any partners or collaboration. Given the nature of this program, failure to demonstrate effective partnerships or collaboration with other stakeholders or having fewer partners/collaboration than recommended above, will likely adversely impact the applicant’s scoring under this criterion and render the application less competitive than others that include partnerships and collaboration. If an application has no commitment letters and does not demonstrate how the applicant can effectively perform the project without partners or collaboration, they may receive a zero for this criterion. 2.0 Project Activities/ Milestone Schedule/ Detailed Budget Narrative 28 Under this criterion, applications will be evaluated based on the extent and quality to which they demonstrate the following: a. Project activities Clearly identified steps that the applicant will take that will 12 reasonably progress towards achieving the program objectives and a clear description of the detailed project activities or components and the anticipated products/results associated with each activity as described in Section IV. b. Milestone schedule A clearly articulated and realistic milestone schedule, 4 -35- including timeframes and major milestones to complete significant project activities. It is recommended that you insert a table in your application narrative to help organize your milestone schedule c. Itemized Budget Reasonable and allowable costs for each component/activity. 12 Sheet / Budget Applicants must itemize costs into the following budget Narrative categories: personnel, fringe benefits, contractual costs, travel, equipment, supplies, other direct costs, indirect costs, and total costs. Describe itemized costs in sufficient detail for EPA to evaluate the reasonableness and allowability of costs for each workplan component/activity. (6 points) Total EPA funding awarded to partnering CBOs. Applications will be evaluated on the percentage of the total funds proposed to be awarded to the applicant that are to be subawarded to partnering CBOs. Applicants are strongly encouraged to budget a minimum of 20% of their proposed budget for partnering CBOs. For example, for a $1M award, a minimum of $200,000 would be budgeted for partnering CBOs. Subaward funds should be accounted for in the “Other Costs” budget category. (6 points) Applicants are permitted to submit the itemized budget sheet using the “Other Attachment” form so the sheet will not count against the 18-page workplan limit. 3.0 Environmental Results—Outcomes, Outputs and Performance Measures 18 (Logic Model) - Under this criterion, applications will be evaluated on the following elements: a. Environmental The extent and quality to which the expected project outputs 10 Results- and outcomes identified in the application are demonstrated to Outputs/Outcomes be effective in achieving the Program Objectives listed in Section I, including developing strategies for addressing local environmental and public health issues, educating and empowering the community about those issues, and developing approaches to building consensus and setting community priorities in the underserved community. b. Performance The extent and quality to which the application demonstrates 4 Measurement Plan a sound plan for tracking progress towards achieving the expected outputs, outcomes, and associated timeframes for achieving those results. c. Sustainability Plan The extent and quality to which the application demonstrates 4 and Environmental plans to utilize the results and momentum of the proposed Justice Integration project to further integrate environmental justice principles in -36- all operations of State and/or local government work. 4.0 Programmatic Capability 10 Under this criterion, applications will be evaluated based on the applicant’s ability to successfully complete and manage the proposed project, taking into account their: a. Organizational Organizational experience related to the proposed project, and 4 experience plan for building relationships with underserved communities, community groups, and vulnerable populations to successfully perform the project. b. Staff Experience / The applicant will be evaluated on the ability to clearly 4 Qualifications of demonstrate that the selected PM and other staff associated Project Manager with the project are qualified to successfully perform the (PM) project. This will be determined through evaluating the following: (1) How the PM and staff are qualified to undertake the project successfully; (2 points) (2) Illustrating the PM’s experience building relationships with community residents and community organizations in a professional capacity. Please include detailed descriptions of similar activities and programs that the PM has worked onto improve local communities (2 points) (3) c. Expenditure of Under this criterion, applicants will be evaluated based on 2 Awarded Grant their approach, procedures, and controls for ensuring that Funds awarded grant funds will be expended in a timely and efficient manner. 5.0 Past Performance 6 Under this criterion, applicants will be evaluated based on their ability to successfully complete and manage the proposed project taking into account their: (i) past performance in successfully completing and managing the assistance agreements identified in response to Section IV of the solicitation (3 points), (ii) history of meeting the reporting requirements under the assistance agreements identified in response to Section IV of the solicitation including whether the applicant submitted acceptable final technical reports under those agreements and the extent to which the applicant adequately and timely reported on their progress towards achieving the expected outputs and outcomes under those agreements and if such progress was not being made whether the applicant adequately reported why not (3 points). Note: In evaluating applicants under this criterion, the Agency will consider the information provided by the applicant and may also consider relevant information -37- from other sources including agency files and prior/current grantors (e.g., to verify and/or supplement the information supplied by the applicant). If you do not have any relevant or available past performance or past reporting information, please indicate this in the application and you will receive a neutral score for these subfactors (items i and ii above-a neutral score is half of the total points available in a subset of possible points). If you do not provide any response for these items, you may receive a score of 0 for these factors. B. REVIEW AND SELECTION PROCESS Applications will be reviewed and scored under the following process: 1. Threshold Eligibility Screening Process – All applications will be evaluated for eligibility using the threshold eligibility criteria described in Section III.C by EPA Office of Environmental Justice and External Civil Rights (OEJECR) staff. 2. Panel Review and Evaluation Process – EPA will convene a review panel(s) to review, score, and rank all eligible applications that pass the threshold eligibility review based on the merit evaluation criteria listed above in separate ranking lists for each of the set-aside categories described in Section II. The review panel(s) will include EPA staff and may include external subject matter experts. 3. Final Selection Process and Other Factors – The review panel will present final rankings and selection recommendations to the Selection Official, who will then make the final selections for award in each set-aside category. In addition to this information, the Selection Official may also consider any of the following “other factors” in making final selection decisions from among the high-ranking applications: • Projects addressing Climate Change, Disaster Resiliency, Health Impact Assessments, Rural Areas, and/or Emergency Preparedness. • Geographic Diversity – EPA may consider the mix of high-ranking projects located in urban and rural areas or different regions of the country when making final selections, as well as the geographical nature or impact of the project. • Programmatic Priorities – OEJECR, EPA National Programs, and Regional Offices develop annual goals and priorities that may focus on certain environmental and/or public health issues (e.g., lead contamination, safe drinking water, and risk management). These overarching goals and priorities may be a consideration when making final selections among high-ranking applications. • Availability of funds Accordingly, in making the final funding decisions, the Selection Official will consider the review panel rankings and recommendations, OEJECR staff input based on their call with the review panel(s) and may also consider the other factors identified above. The “other factors” may only be considered by the Selection Official when determining final selections after the scoring and ranking process is complete. -38- C. ANTICIPATED ANNOUNCEMENTS AND AWARD DATES Below is a tentative schedule of important dates for the EJG2G Program. Please note dates are tentative and subject to change: General Dates Activity January 10, 2023 EJG2G competition announced. Open competition period begins. January 26, 2023 Webinars and Pre-application Assistance Calls February 7, 2023 Open competition closes. Applications must be submitted through Grants.gov April 14, 2023 by 11:59 p.m. (ET), April 14, 2023. Applications received after this date will not be reviewed. EPA will review applications for Threshold Eligibility Criteria (Section III). Ineligible applicants will be notified via email with details regarding ineligibility. Notification to ineligible applicants will be sent via email to the April – May 2023 contact identified on the submitted SF-424 form providing brief explanations on the reason(s) for ineligibility. Ineligible applicants may request a debriefing within 15 days of receipt of the correspondence. (See debriefing and disputes clause in Section VI.l and m of the EPA Announcement Clauses referenced in Section I.J.) EPA review panel(s) review, score, and rank eligible applications. EPA will June – August 2023 make the final selections for awards. All applicants will be notified of the selection results by mail and/or email. Headquarters/Regional offices will request any additional application November 2023 documentation from selected applicants. Awards will be made by headquarters and/or regional grant offices as determined to be appropriate. December 2023 OEJECR will release a national announcement for the EJG2G awardees VI. AWARD ADMINISTRATION INFORMATION (back to Contents by Section) Note: Additional provisions that apply to this section can be found at EPA Announcement Clauses. A. AWARD NOTICES EPA anticipates notification of selected finalists will be made via telephone or electronic or postal mail by the end of November 2023. The notification will be sent to the original signer of the application, or the project contact listed in the application. This notification, which informs the applicant that its application has been selected and is being recommended for award, is not an authorization to begin work. The official notification of an award will be made by EPA’s Regional Grants Offices. Applicants are cautioned that only a grants officer is authorized to bind the Government to the expenditure of funds; selection does not guarantee an award will be made. For example, statutory authorization, funding, or other issues discovered during the award process may affect the ability of EPA to make an award to an applicant. The award notice, signed by an EPA grants officer, is the authorizing document and will be provided through electronic or postal mail. -39- B. ADMINISTRATIVE AND NATIONAL POLICY REQUIREMENTS This award is subject to the requirements of the Uniform Administrative Requirements, Cost Principles and Audit Requirements for Federal Awards; Title 2 CFR, Parts 200 and 1500. EPA also has programmatic regulations located in 40 CFR Chapter 1 Subchapter B. A listing and description of general EPA regulations applicable to the award of assistance agreements may be viewed at: https://www.epa.gov/grants/epa-policies-and-guidance-grants. C. REPORTING Progress Report. The Project Manager will be required to submit semi-annual progress reports for the duration of the agreement to update the EPA Regional Project Officer and will also be required to have quarterly meetings with the EPA Regional Project Officer. Final Report Requirement. The Project Manager must submit a Final Technical Report for EPA approval within 120 days after the end of the project period. A draft of this report should be submitted within sixty (60) days after the end of the project period. A Financial Status Report is also required and will be described in the award agreement. The EPA may collect, review, and disseminate those final reports that can serve as models for future projects. Many applicants may find it useful to document their progress using various media. This may include, but not limited to the use of videos, blogs, and other forms of social media. Post-Project Period Follow-up and Engagement For no less than one year after completion of the project, recipients agree to provide semi-annual updates to their designated EPA Project Officer on current community-based and environmental justice work the recipient is performing and how/if that work relates to their now completed EJG2G project. These semi-annual updates may include (but are not limited to) recent local media reports, additional grant funding received, new initiatives, and developing partnerships. The EPA EJ Grants program is invested in the long-term success of each EJ Grant recipient and their long- term impact on addressing the disproportionate environmental and public health impacts plaguing their communities. These post-project period updates allow the EJ Grants program to provide past recipients with additional guidance about applicable funding opportunities, potential collaborations, and technical assistance that may assist recipients in their future work*. The periodic updates also allow the program to track best practices that lead to greater project sustainability and long-term community revitalization for impacted community residents. Recipients are strongly encouraged to continue providing updates and engaging with their EPA Project Officer beyond the additional year after the end of the project. *NOTE – Compliance with this term & condition will not give the recipient priority during future EPA EJ grant competitions and is not a guarantee for future EPA grant funding. Justice40 Reporting The activities to be performed under the awards are expected to contribute to the President’s goal that 40% of the overall project benefits flow to disadvantaged communities (the Justice40 Initiative - See Section I.A). Recipients, therefore, will be expected to report on certain metrics to demonstrate to what extent the activities contribute to the 40% goal. The award will include appropriate terms and conditions to this effect. -40- Signage The activities to be performed under the awards are expected to publicize that they were funded by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency and the Inflation Reduction Act (e.g., via signs at the place(s) of performance. The award will include appropriate terms and conditions to this effect. EJ Grantee Training Workshops (Virtual and in-person options) During the three-year project period, all EJG2G recipients will be required to attend a number of EJ Grantee Networking and Training Workshops facilitated by EPA Headquarters or the nearest EPA regional office. These workshops may be hosted, coordinated, and/or facilitated by the Environmental Justice Thriving Communities Technical Assistance Centers (EJ TCTACs) awarded under assistance listing 66.309. The purpose of the training and networking workshops are to: 1) connect current EJ grant recipients with past recipients and community partners, 2) assist all community stakeholders with strategic planning for their communities, 3) facilitate grantees accessing additional resources and 4) provide general project management and federal grant guidance. Frequency of workshops attendance is subject to change and will be determined by EPA. EJ Grant Applicant Database The EJ grant program strives to support as many community- based organizations that apply to our EJ grant opportunities as possible, regardless of their ultimate success in receiving a grant, by 1) familiarizing applicants with federal grant application requirements, 2) sharing expectations and responsibilities of managing federal grants, 3) providing constructive feedback and recommendations on ways to strengthen unselected applications, 4) helping organizations build sustainability into projects so they continue to grow and develop after the project period is over, and 5) facilitating connections with other potential resources that can help organizations address community needs. To facilitate the achievement of these immediate goals, all applicants who apply to this opportunity will be added to our EJ Grant Applicant Database. The database helps the Environmental Justice program identify and work with additional underserved communities outside the context of our grant awards. Quality Assurance Project Plans (QAPP) Quality assurance is sometimes applicable to assistance projects (see 2 CFR 1500.12 and the EPA Environmental Information Quality Policy CIO 2105.2). Quality assurance requirements apply to the collection and/or use of environmental data and information. Environmental data are any measurements or information that describe environmental processes, location, or conditions; ecological or health effects and consequences; or the performance of environmental technology. Environmental data include information collected directly from measurements, produced from models, and compiled from other sources, such as databases or literature. Once the award is made, if a Quality Assurance Project Plan is required for the project, the applicant will have to draft a QAPP prior to beginning work on the project activities related to environmental data collection or information. You must reserve time and financial resources in the beginning of your project in order to prepare your QAPP and include the cost for developing your QAPP in your Detailed Budget. Selected applicants cannot begin data collection until EPA approves the QAPP. D. COMPETITION DISPUTE RESOLUTION Assistance agreement competition-related disputes will be resolved in accordance with the dispute resolution procedures published in 70 FR (Federal Register) 3629, 3630 (January 26, 2005) which can be found at Grant Competition Dispute Resolution Procedures. Please note that the FR notice references regulations at 40 CFR Parts 30 and 31 that have been superseded -41- by regulations in 2 CFR parts 200 and 1500. Notwithstanding this, the procedures for competition-related disputes remains unchanged from the procedures described at 70 FR 3629, 3630, as indicated in 2 CFR Part 1500, Subpart E. Copies of these procedures may be requested by contacting Omari Burrell at (214) 665-3162 or Burrell.Omari@epa.gov. VII. AGENCY CONTACTS (back to Contents by Section) Office of Environmental Justice Burrell.Omari@epa.gov, Burney.Jacob@epa.gov and External Civil Rights Region 1 Norcross.Jeffrey@epa.gov Region 2 Frazier.Tasha@epa.gov Region 3 Scott.Gail@epa.gov Region 4 Thomas-Burton.Tami@epa.gov Region 5 Triantafillou.Kathy@epa.gov Region 6 Acosta.Gerardo@epa.gov Region 7 Espinosa.Monica@epa.gov Region 8 Heffernan.Daniel@epa.gov Region 9 Capilla.Morgan@epa.gov Region 10 Chu.Rebecca@epa.gov VIII. OTHER INFORMATION AND APPENDICES (back to Contents by Section) A – Information on Preparing an EJ Grant Application B – Blank Logic Model Template C – Logic Model Guide – What Each Category Means D – Example Completed Logic Model E – Blank EJG2G Detailed Budget Template F – Sample EJG2G Detailed Budget G – Quality Assurance Project Plan Questionnaire H – Health Impact Assessment Guidance See appendices on following pages -42- APPENDIX A INFORMATION ON PREPARING AN ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE GRANT APPLICATION This information is intended to help you put together a competitive application for the Environmental Protection Agency's (EPA) Environmental Justice Grants Program. Please read the Application Guidance carefully -- this document is intended for informational purposes only. Target your audience carefully Identify a specific group or community to work with to develop a program that will give the highest return for your dollars invested. Build partnerships and alliances You are strongly encouraged to enlist project involvement from community groups with similar or related goals and secure their commitment of services and/or dollars. Be sure to document this by obtaining letter(s) of commitment for your application. Initiate the partnerships early in your planning since building alliances can take time and effort. Do some homework Allow time to develop and document your understanding of environmental justice issues within the community you work in or with. Find out what materials exist on the subject and the procedures you are planning to include in your workplan. Use this information to back up your project plans or to explain how your group activities are unique and/or creative. Develop a project evaluation technique Define as carefully and precisely as possible what you want to achieve with this project and how you will test its success. Ask yourself: “what do you expect to be different once the project is complete?” Outline a plan you will use to measure the success of your activities/project. Develop a timeline or project accomplishment schedule List the major tasks that you will complete to meet the goals of the project. Break these broad goals into smaller tasks and lay them out in a schedule over the twelve months of the grant period. Determine and identify in the application the total estimated cost for each task. You may estimate this cost by the number of personnel, materials, and other resources you will need to carry out the tasks. Stay within the format and follow application instructions including any page limits This makes it easier for the reviewer to read and therefore, understand your workplan. Please refer to the application requirements. Communicate the nature of your project accurately, precisely, and concisely. Describe exactly what you propose to do, how you are going to do it, when you are going to do it, who will benefit, and how you will know you are successful. Indicate not only what you propose but what expertise your group has for completing the project (include resumes). COMMON STRENGTHS • Project application developed solidly from within the community • Broad based community support for a project that has the potential to positively affect local people • Project identifies established community advisory board or community group who will guide, steer, or otherwise be involved with the project • Good partnership with local businesses, industry, community, environmental groups, and state and local agencies. Good coordination with a variety of community groups • Application does a good job of outlining a complex problem and approach to solving it -- does not overlook any major issues or key players • Clear identification and background description of population to be served • Application identifies specific outputs, target accomplishments, and estimated budgets for each goal, and target dates for completion • Proposed project builds on existing projects or programs • The scope of the project can be completed within a three-year project period • Application clearly describes how the project will achieve the program goals outlined in the application guidance • Application includes innovative ideas and creative thinking about how to motivate and involve youth in the communities where they live • Application includes honest discussion of challenges involved COMMON WEAKNESSES • Application did not include information specifically requested in the application guidance • Community members do not appear to be an integral part of the project planning process • Not specific enough about what EPA funds will be used for • Applicant is not an eligible organization • Program may be too ambitious for a three-year project period • Project funds conferences or dialogues to discuss EJ issues but does not fund activities that make direct changes in a community • Immediacy of need is not established • Methods of evaluating the success of the project unclear • Failure to mention other groups that applicant will work with or to secure letters of commitment • Application seeks support for developing general environmental program with little mention of environmental justice issues. The link between goals of EPA's environmental justice program and the project is not clearly stated • Discussion of overall mission and goals of the organization, but not enough detail on how the specific project and activities will help achieve the goals APPENDIX B Blank Logic Model Template (Optional—EPA will not penalize applicants for using a different format.) Resources/ Activities Outputs Audience Short-term Intermediate Long-term Inputs Outcomes Outcomes Outcomes (6-12 months) (12-24 months) (2+ years) *Your completed logic model may span multiple pages Appendix C Logic Model Guide – What each category means Resources Activities Outputs Audience Short-Term Intermediate Long-Term Outcomes Outcomes Outcomes What you What you What you Who you Change in: Change in: Change in: invest! do! produce or reach! deliver! (#) •Knowledge •Behaviors •Environment •Time •Plan •Customers •Skills •Practices •Social •Money •Meet •Workshops •Participants •Attitude •Procedures conditions •Partners •Educate •Events •Decision- •Awareness •Economic •Equipment •Create •Publications makers •Motivation conditions •Facilities •Clean up •Resident •Policies involvement Logical Flow (below): if then if then Appendix D Example Completed Logic Model Example Project - Creating Partnerships to Develop Inter-Agency Air Quality Guidance Resources/ Activities Outputs Audience Short-Term Intermediate Long-term Inputs Outcomes Outcomes Outcomes (6-12 months) (12-24 months) (2+ years) Staff time Identify 8 meetings with city, state, local Increase in # Increase in # of Development of potential partners on government of local residents who new air quality partners in city, quarterly basis to stakeholders participate in ordinances and In-kind county, state formulate air local partners committed to partner meetings policies enacted contributions government, quality guidance project and by local govt. public health community addressing Additional grants office, and 400 residents residents community’s Increase in # of universities to reached thru air issues various Decrease in draft and door-to-door local universities (target(s) = 4 stakeholders number of Volunteers implement air outreach govt. partners, participating in asthma-related quality 3 public efforts to address hospital visits Partnering guidance and 250 residents health issues concerning amongst Organizations arrange provide support officials, and air quality community meetings and input 2 universities) residents Create one report Conduct door and 4 brochures Increase in # knocking to on local air of residents solicit resident quality aware of air support and quality issues input 550 residents in community receive report (target(s)= Generate and info and 600 residents) disseminate brochures report and brochures on air quality data APPENDIX E EJG2G Budget Detail Template (Optional EPA will not penalize applicants who use a different format.) Description Total Personnel Fringe Benefits Travel Equipment Supplies Contractual Construction Indirect Costs Other $1,000,000 APPENDIX F EJG2G Detailed Budget Example For detailed information on preparing budgets for applications for EPA assistance agreements please refer to EPA’s Interim General Budget Development Guidance for Applicants and Recipients of EPA Financial Assistance. Description Total Personnel Project Manager @ $50,000 annual salary X 30% of time on project = $45,000 for three years Outreach worker @ $35,000 annual salary X 20% of time on project = $21,000 Community leader @ $20,000 annual salary X 15% = $9,000 Fringe Benefits Project Manager 15% of salary (includes medical, dental, life insurance) = $6,750 for three years Outreach worker 10% of salary (includes medical, dental, life insurance) = $2,100 Community leader 10% of salary (includes medical, dental, life insurance) = $900 Travel Local mileage for Project Manager for partner meetings: 25 miles @ $0.55/mi. X 48 meetings = $660.00 Local mileage for Outreach worker for community outreach efforts: 10 miles @ $0.55/mi. X 30 times X 36 months = $5,940 Travel to 3 regional seminars: Per diem - $30 per day X 3 days = $90; Airfare = $1,500 Equipment 3 Computer Servers @ $10,000 each for development of EJ (for purchases mapping and screening data tools at 3 locations = $30,000 greater than 2 Chemistry Analyzer Lab Equipment @ $22,000 $5,000 per unit) 3 Compound Lab Microscopes @ $5,000 each = $15,000 Supplies 30 reams of copy paper @ $4.00 for outreach materials = $120 Laptop computer for Outreach worker to work off-site on community $1,500 Miscellaneous supplies for staff on this project = $750 2 Air Monitors = $7,660.00 2 Filters (500 filter) = $4,000 Contractual Bookkeeper/Accountant $15/hr. @ 3 hrs./week @ 156 weeks = $7,020 Lab to conduct tests @$45*750 = $33,750 Data Processing Contract = $45,000 (provide details if possible) Construction NOTE - Construction related activities may include heavy machinery rental costs, demolition-related costs, and costs related to building structures Indirect Costs IDC Rate Agreement of 10% of Salaries and Wages ($75,000 X 10%) Other Participant Support Cost= $1500 for stipends to encourage participation in community meetings. Subaward to CBO for outreach activities and project recruitment = $200,000 (provide details about deliverables subgrantee is responsible for) $ APPENDIX G Office of Environmental Justice Quality Assurance Project Plan Requirement (QAPP) Check Yes or No for each of the items provided below as it applies to your specific project. If you answered YES to any of the items listed above, you are REQUIRED TO SUBMIT a Quality Assurance Project Plan in accordance with EPA Requirements and an approved QAPP must be in place prior to the initiation of activities. You will be contacted with information on how to prepare your QAPP. In the meantime, please visit the website https://www.epa.gov/quality which provides guidance on what must be submitted for grants/cooperative agreements. 1. Your project will involve the collection of groundwater, soil, sediment, surface water, air, biota or fauna samples for chemical or biological analysis. Yes No 2. Your project will use existing computer databases containing analytical data or personal information previously collected. Yes No 3. Your project will use existing historical research pertaining to this project or application. Yes No 4. Your project will implement deed searches for current property or site. Yes No 5. Your project will conduct medical records search for the population covered in the grant. Yes No 6. Your project will compile meteorological data to determine weather trends or air mixing trends. Yes No 7. Your project will use existing statistical studies or will conduct these studies as part of the project. Yes No 8. Your project will create a new database based on the information gathered. Yes No 9. Your project will use this information for litigation purposes. Yes No 10. Your project will use this information to make recommendations on environmental decisions. Yes No APPENDIX H Guidance on Structuring Health Impact Assessment Health Impact Assessment (HIA) is a decision-support tool being utilized by EPA to promote sustainable and healthy communities. The foundation of a healthy community is strongest when built upon a decision-making process that balances environmental, social, and economic factors to promote the health and well-being of its members. HIA is a tool designed to investigate how a proposed program, project, policy, or plan may impact health and well-being and inform decision-makers of these potential outcomes before the decision is made. HIAs: • determine the potential effects of a proposed decision on the health of a population and the distribution of those effects within the population; • consider input from stakeholders, including those impacted by the decision; • use different types of qualitative and quantitative evidence and analytical methods; • are flexible based on available time and resources; and • provide evidence and recommendations to decision-makers in a timely manner. HIAs typically involve six steps (North American HIA Practice Standards Working Group 2010; Bhatia 2011; National Research Council 2011; Human Impact Partners 2011, 2012; EPA, 2013). NOTE: It is strongly encouraged that selected applicants follow the steps below in conducting their HIA: 1. Screening – Determine whether an HIA is needed, and the value added. a. Define the decision and its alternatives; HIA is intended to inform a decision b. Assess the feasibility of conducting the HIA given the timeframe and available resources c. Determine willingness of partners to participate in the HIA and decision makers to receive recommendations from the HIA 2. Scoping – Identify which health effects to consider and set the HIA parameters. a. Determine who will conduct the HIA and plan for stakeholder involvement b. Examine stakeholder concerns and potential impacts of the decision on population health and the distribution of those effects across vulnerable groups. c. Determine methods and data sources for use in the assessment. 3. Assessment – Collect qualitative and quantitative information to create a profile of existing health conditions, and identify, evaluate, and prioritize the potential health impacts of the decision. a. Consider direction, magnitude, severity, likelihood, and distribution/equity of impacts. b. Describe data sources and methods, acknowledging assumptions, strengths, and limitations of the data and methods. c. Include documentation of stakeholder engagement. 4. Recommendations – Identify alternatives to the decision and/or strategies for promoting the positive health impacts and/or mitigating the adverse health impacts. a. Develop, and consider prioritizing, recommendations to mitigate adverse health impacts. b. Develop an implementation plan for the recommendations, including who is responsible, timeline for implementation, indicators for monitoring progress. 5. Reporting – Write a final report and communicate the results of the HIA to decisionmakers and other stakeholders for implementation/action. a. Develop a transparent and publicly accessible report to document the process, methods, findings, funding, and participants of the HIA. b. Communicate findings and recommendations to stakeholders and decision makers. 6. Monitoring and Evaluation – Evaluate the processes involved in the HIA, the impact of the HIA on the decision-making process, and the impacts of the decision on health. a. Perform a process evaluation to document and communicate how effective the HIA was in meeting its objectives and established practice standards. b. Perform an impact evaluation to document and communicate the impact of the HIA on the decision-making process. c. Perform an outcome evaluation to determine the accuracy of the health impacts predicted in the HIA when feasible. Minimum Elements and Practice Standards for Health Impact Assessment Identifies eight essential elements for conducting comprehensive HIA that distinguish it from other processes used to assess and inform decisions. In addition to the eight elements below, this resource explains detailed practice standards for implementing HIAs. Note: It is strongly encouraged that applicants follow these minimum elements and practice standards. 1. HIA is conducted to assess the potential health consequences of a proposed program, policy, project, or plan under consideration by decision-makers, and is conducted in advance of the decision in question. 2. HIA involves and engages stakeholders affected by the proposal, particularly vulnerable populations. 3. HIA systematically considers the full range of potential impacts of the proposal on health determinants, health status, and health equity. 4. HIA provides a profile of existing conditions for the populations affected by the proposal, including their health outcomes, health determinants, and vulnerable sub-groups within the population, relevant to the health issues examined in the HIA. 5. HIA characterizes the proposal’s impacts on health, health determinants, and health equity, while documenting data sources and analytic methods, quality of evidence used, methodological assumptions, and limitations. 6. HIA provides recommendations, as needed, on feasible and effective actions to promote the positive health impacts and mitigate the negative health impacts of the decision, identifying, where appropriate, alternatives or modifications to the proposal. 7. HIA produces a publicly accessible report that includes, at minimum, documentation of the HIA’s purpose, findings, and recommendations, and either documentation of the processes and methods involved, or reference to an external source of documentation for these processes and methods. The report should be shared with decision-makers and other stakeholders. 8. HIA proposes indicators, actions, and responsible parties, where indicated, for a plan to monitor the implementation of recommendations, as well as health effects and outcomes of the proposal. Types of HIA Figure 1. HIA Typology Descriptions Source: Harris-Roxas and Harris, 2011, as referenced in EPA, 2013. Additional Resources: § EPA Health Impact Assessments § A Review of Health Impact Assessments in the U.S.: Current State-of-the-Science, Best Practices, and Areas for Improvement (EPA, 2013) § EPA Health Impact Assessment Case Studies § Minimum Elements and Practice Standards for Health Impact Assessment, Version 3 (Bhatia et al., 2014) § HIAs and Other Resources to Advance Health-Informed Decisions (a searchable database of HIA projects; Pew Trusts, 2021) § Health Impact Assessment: Key Citations (International Association for Impact Assessment, updated 2021) § IAP2 Spectrum of Public Participation (International Association for Public Participation, 2018) § Online Course – Health Impact Assessment, step by step (National Collaborating Centre for Healthy Public Policy, 2019) § A Health Impact Assessment Toolkit: A Handbook to Conducting HIA, 3rd edition (Human Impact Partners 2011) § Health Impact Assessment: A Guide for Practice (Bhatia 2011) § HIA Summary Guides (Human Impact Partners 2012) § Rapid HIA Toolkit (Design for Health 2008) § Technical Guidance for Health Impact Assessment (HIA) in Alaska (Alaska Department of Health 2015) § Improving Health in the United States: The Role of Health Impact Assessment (National Research Council 2011)