BOS AGENDA 3-29-23 - REVISED.PDF

Maricopa County — Formal (2023-03-29)

View PDF Item 67 Meeting page

Extracted text (via pymupdf_layout) 8794 characters
Board of Supervisors' Agenda
2019/2020: TX2021-000019 (W-EH ECC OWNER VI LLC) Represented by Mooney, Wright,
Moore & Wilhoit, PLLC;
2021: TX2021-000569 (KW PHX LLC) Represented by Mooney, Wright, Moore & Wilhoit,
PLLC;
2023: ST2022-000005 (LARGO 258 LLC) Represented by David Hay, President of Hayland
Property Tax Consulting, Inc.; ST2022-000012 (Orfan Annie LLC) Represented by John
Barker, Agent for the Owner; TX2022-000350 (C.R. Gilbert, L.L.C.) Represented by
Mooney, Wright, Moore & Wilhoit, PLLC; TX2022-000395 (Empire West Title Agency LLC,
et al) Represented by Mooney, Wright, Moore & Wilhoit, PLLC; ST2022-000021 (Mark &
Luz Losavio) Represented by Mark & Luz Losavio.

2019/2020

*** C O V E R S H E E T ***
_____________________________________________________________
TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION
Date: 03/13/2023
Maricopa County 1 Parcel
301 West Jefferson
Phoenix, AZ 85003
County Atty: MUTHIG KLAUS PETER
Prepared by: Chappell / Procaccini
Tax Case: TX2021-000019
Parcel #: See Attached Tax Year: 2019
Plaintiff: W-EH ECC OWNER VI LLC et al
LAND IMPS FCV RATIO
CURRENT 3,409,800 15,783,342 19,193,142 See Parcel
RECOMMENDED: N/C 13,059,830 16,469,630 TASRs

Date: 03/13/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1
Tax Year: 2019 Plaintiff: W-EH ECC OWNER VI LLC et al Appraiser: CHAPPELL NED
Tax Case: TX2021-000019 Attorney: MUTHIG KLAUS PETER
Number of
Parcels: 1
Current: Recommended:
Parcel PUC Land Impr FCV LPV Class PUC Land Impr FCV LPV Class Rule
30153094 1512 3,409,800 15,783,342 19,193,142 14,778,719 1.12 @18.0% 2815 N/C 13,059,830 16,469,630 N/C B5
3,409,800 15,783,342 19,193,142 14,778,719 3,409,800 13,059,830 16,469,630

*** C O V E R S H E E T ***
_____________________________________________________________
TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION
Date: 03/13/2023
Maricopa County 1 Parcel
301 West Jefferson
Phoenix, AZ 85003
County Atty: MUTHIG KLAUS PETER
Prepared by: Chappell / Procaccini
Tax Case: TX2021-000019
Parcel #: See Attached Tax Year: 2020
Plaintiff: W-EH ECC OWNER VI LLC et al
LAND IMPS FCV RATIO
CURRENT 3,920,500 18,717,708 22,638,208 See Parcel
RECOMMENDED: N/C 14,466,410 18,386,910 TASRs

Date: 03/13/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1
Tax Year: 2020 Plaintiff: W-EH ECC OWNER VI LLC et al Appraiser: CHAPPELL NED
Tax Case: TX2021-000019 Attorney: MUTHIG KLAUS PETER
Number of
Parcels: 1
Current: Recommended:
Parcel PUC Land Impr FCV LPV Class PUC Land Impr FCV LPV Class Rule
30153094 1512 3,920,500 18,717,708 22,638,208 15,517,656 1.12 @18.0% 2815 N/C 14,466,410 18,386,910 N/C A2
3,920,500 18,717,708 22,638,208 15,517,656 3,920,500 14,466,410 18,386,910

2021

*** C O V E R S H E E T ***
_____________________________________________________________
TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION
Date: 03/10/2023
Maricopa County 5 parcels
301 West Jefferson
Phoenix, AZ 85003
County Atty: MUTHIG, KLAUS PETER
Prepared by: Hoover/Procaccini
Tax Case: TX2021-000569
*Parcel #s: See Attached Tax Year: 2021
Plaintiffs: KW PHX LLC ET AL
2021 TOTAL PENALTY $587,501.26
NEW TOTAL PENALTY $293,750.63
*NO CHANGES TO ANY PARCEL VALUES OR CLASSIFICATIONS

Date: 03/10/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1
Tax Year: 2021 Plaintiff: KW PHX LLC ET AL Appr HOOVER, TOM
Tax Case: TX2021-000569 Attorney: MUTHIG, KLAUS PETER
*Number of Parcels: 5
*NO CHANGES TO ANY PARCEL VALUES OR CLASSIFICATIONS

2023

*** C O V E R S H E E T ***
_____________________________________________________________
TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION
Date: íóïìóîí 03/02/2023
Maricopa County 9 Parcels
301 West Jefferson
Phoenix, AZ 85003
County Atty: JOE BRANCO/ROSA AGUILAR
Prepared by: VANA SYAWISH
Tax Case: ST2022-000005
Parcel #: See Attached Tax Year: 2023
Plaintiff: LARGO 258 LLC
LAND IMPS FCV RATIO
CURRENT 1,906,500 0 1,906,500 See Parcel
RECOMMENDED: 680,081 0 680,081 TASRs

Date: 03/14/2023 Rev'd. Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1
Tax Year: 2023 Plaintiff: LARGO 258 LLC Appraiser: VANA SYAWISH
Tax Case: ST2022-000005 Attorney: JOE BRANCO/ROSA AGUILAR
Number of Parcels: 9
Current: Recommended:
Parcel PUC Land Impr FCV LPV Class PUC Land Impr FCV LPV Class Rule
40239003D 0022 172,500 0 172,500 5,956 2.R @15.0% 0022 $ 67,394 0 $ 67,394 N/C A1
40239001A 0022 76,900 0 76,900 1,580 2.R @15.0% 0022 $ 18,139 0 $ 18,139 N/C A1
40239004C 0022 126,100 0 126,100 4,133 2.R @15.0% 0022 $ 46,076 0 $ 46,076 N/C A1
40239003E 0031 198,400 0 198,400 18,597 2.R @15.0% 0022 $ 59,381 0 $ 59,381 N/C A1
40239003C 0022 260,700 0 260,700 9,846 2.R @15.0% 0022 $ 111,106 0 $ 111,106 N/C A1
40239002A 0022 60,700 0 60,700 4,255 2.R @15.0% 0022 $ 13,618 0 $ 13,618 N/C A1
40239004A 0022 424,200 0 424,200 46,975 2.R @15.0% 0022 $ 149,127 0 $ 149,127 N/C A1
40239004B 0022 565,100 0 565,100 65,516 2.R @15.0% 0022 $ 211,118 0 $ 211,118 N/C A1
40239003F 0022 21,900 0 21,900 1,298 2.R @15.0% 0022 $ 4,122 0 $ 4,122 N/C A1
1,906,500 0 1,906,500 158,156 $ 680,081 0 $ 680,081

*** C O V E R S H E E T ***
_____________________________________________________________
TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION
Date: 02/28/2023
Maricopa County 1 Parcel
301 West Jefferson
Phoenix, AZ 85003
County Atty: JOSEPH BRANCO
Prepared by: NED CHAPPELL
Tax Case: ST2022-000012
Parcel #: See Attached Tax Year: 2023
Plaintiff: ORFAN ANNIE LLC
LAND IMPS FCV RATIO
CURRENT 72,000 0 72,000 See Parcel
RECOMMENDED: 5,760 0 5,760 TASRs

Date: 02/28/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1
Tax Year: 2023 Plaintiff: ORFAN ANNIE LLC Appraiser: NED CHAPPELL
Tax Case: ST2022-000012 Attorney: JOSEPH BRANCO
Number of Parcels: 1
Current: Recommended:
Parcel PUC Land Impr FCV LPV Class PUC Land Impr FCV LPV Class Rule
12173031B 0011 72,000 0 72,000 33,840 2.R @15.0% 8805 5,760 0 5,760 N/C A1
72,000 0 72,000 33,840 5,760 0 5,760

*** C O V E R S H E E T ***
_____________________________________________________________
TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION
Date: 03/07/2023
Maricopa County 2 Parcels
301 West Jefferson St.
Phoenix, AZ 85003
County Atty: MUTHIG KLAUS PETER
Prepared by: Syawish/Chappell/Procaccini
Tax Case: TX2022-000350
Parcel #s: See Attached Tax Year: 2023
Plaintiff: CR GILBERT LLC
LAND IMPS FCV RATIO
CURRENT 6,792,700 0 6,792,700 See Parcel
RECOMMENDED: 35,262 N/C 35,262 TASRs

Date: 03/07/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1
Tax Year: 2023 Plaintiff: CR GILBERT LLC Appraiser: SYAWISH VANA/CHAPPELL NED
Tax Case: TX2022-000350 Attorney: MUTHIG KLAUS PETER
Number of
Parcels: 2
Current: Recommended:
Parcel PUC Land Impr FCV LPV Class PUC Land Impr FCV LPV Class Rule
30407001U 0014 1,845,500 0 1,845,500 689,593 2.R @15.0% 4110 10,553 N/C 10,553 N/C A1
30407035B 0022 4,947,200 0 4,947,200 2,747,687 2.R @15.0% 4110 24,709 N/C 24,709 N/C A1
6,792,700 0 6,792,700 3,437,280 35,262 0 35,262

*** C O V E R S H E E T ***
_____________________________________________________________
TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION
Date: 03/07/2023
Maricopa County 3 Parcels
301 West Jefferson
Phoenix, AZ 85003
County Atty: SIMON JONATHAN
Prepared by: Syawish/Chappell/Procaccini
Tax Case: TX2022-000395
Parcel #s: See Attached Tax Year: 2023
Plaintiff: EMPIRE WEST TITLE AGENCY LLC… et al
LAND IMPS FCV RATIO
CURRENT 7,945,400 7,500 7,952,900 See Parcel
RECOMMENDED: 1,080,478 N/C 1,087,978 TASRs

Date: 03/07/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1
Tax Year: 2023 Plaintiff: EMPIRE WEST TITLE AGENCY LLC… et al Appraiser: SYAWISH / CHAPPELL
Tax Case: TX2022-000395 Attorney: SIMON JONATHAN
Number of
Parcels: 3
Current: Recommended:
Parcel PUC Land Impr FCV LPV Class PUC Land Impr FCV LPV Class Rule
50070003F 0014 631,900 0 631,900 296,993 2.R @15.0% 4111 47,995 N/C 47,995 N/C B1
50064001K 0012 3,241,500 0 3,241,500 1,523,505 2.R @15.0% 4110 97,752 N/C 97,752 N/C B1
50063006B 4111 4,072,000 7,500 4,079,500 1,917,365 2.R @15.0% 4117 934,731 N/C 942,231 N/C B2
7,945,400 7,500 7,952,900 3,737,863 1,080,478 7,500 1,087,978

*** C O V E R S H E E T ***
_____________________________________________________________
TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION
Date: 03/14/2023
Maricopa County 2 Parcels
301 West Jefferson
Phoenix, AZ 85003
County Atty: BRANCO / AGUILAR
Prepared by: Syawish / Chappell / Procaccini
Tax Case: ST2022-000021
Parcel #s: See Attached Tax Year: 2023
Plaintiff: LOSAVIO MARK / LUZ
LAND IMPS FCV RATIO
CURRENT 1,212,300 0 1,212,300 See Parcel
RECOMMENDED: 524,055 0 524,055 TASRs

Date: 03/14/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1
Tax Year: 2023 Plaintiff: LOSAVIO MARK / LUZ Appraiser: SYAWISH / CHAPPELL
Tax Case: ST2022-000021 Attorney: BRANCO / AGUILAR
Number of
Parcels: 2
Current: Recommended:
Parcel PUC Land Impr FCV LPV Class PUC Land Impr FCV LPV Class Rule
21731047B 0012 533,000 0 533,000 277,301 2.R @15.0% N/C 201,600 N/C 201,600 N/C A1
21731047A 0012 679,300 0 679,300 354,944 2.R @15.0% N/C 322,455 N/C 322,455 N/C A1
1,212,300 0 1,212,300 632,245 524,055 0 524,055