Extracted text (via pymupdf_layout)
23392 characters
Parks Advisory May Attachment 12, and 2026 Board Recreation 1 Meeting Page 1 of 16 Parks, Parks Brandon Recreation Erno, Water May PRCF 13, Use and Deputy 2026 and Community Director Standards Facilities Parks Advisory May Attachment 12, and 2026 Board Recreation 1 Meeting • • • • • • • • standards: Overview Page 2 of 16 Purpose Water Water Landscape Water Water Landscape System Mesa’s of Efficiency Shortage Efficiency Management Overview Water current Water Projects Construction Practices Usage Sources water Management Practices Standards consumption and 2 Parks Advisory May 12, and 2026 Board Recreation Meeting Attachment Page 3 of 16 1 Mesa’s Water Sources • • • • • • • Treated City Salt Surface Effluent Groundwater Central Well River Sites Arizona Water exchange Wastewater Project ~5% for (SRP) Project CAP ~40% (CAP) water. ~55% 3 3 • • • • Parks Advisory May 12, and 2026 Board Recreation Meeting and and basins, PRCF • • Parks Attachment Page 4 of 16 1 System connection wells Irrigation Turf Irrigated locations stadiums parks, Xeriscape = to (lake sources: maintained = 732.4 acreage Maintenance Overview canals) systems pools, 161.9 acres is potable, sports locations acres 894.3 maintains and direct flood, fields, include 220 4 4 Parks Advisory and Board Recreation Meeting May Attachment 12, 2026 1 Page 5 of 16 Landscape Water Usage • • Annual • • • • • • Fiscal expended: Eastmark Hohokam Red • • Flood • • Potable: gallons Highest-demand Year Riverview/Sloan Mountain $291,651 535,625,979 and $4,212,393.59 1,130,221,620 Great Stadium Well: 2025 used Park Park Park Parks: Gallons Usage: and Gallons 5 dollars 5 Parks Advisory and Board Recreation Meeting • • • • May Attachment 12, 2026 1 Water • Page 6 of 16 usage (workdays Irrigation Repairs inspected Irrigation Waterfluence Exceptions monitoring only) programs made weekly systems Management are water within are large are one budgeting repairs reviewed day physically Practices and daily 6 6 Parks and Recreation Advisory Board Meeting May 12, 2026 Attachment 1 Water Page 7 of 16 Management – Waterfluence 7 7 Parks Advisory May 12, and 2026 Board Recreation Meeting Attachment Page 8 of 16 1 Water Efficiency Practices • • • • Smart smart Global • • Leak • • detected Alarm Master sensed Automated Run Microclimate devices access detection evapotranspiration times Irrigation by notification valves through the and shutdown adjusted weather system when flow monitoring rates based Controllers: PC’s sensors when monitoring and problems rain is are 8 8 • • • • • Parks Advisory May • 12, and 2026 Board Recreation Meeting more Low and Limit to Smart not Attachment Page 9 of 16 1 reduction Irrigation (stormwater Maximize be watering Irrigation Landscape Impact xeriscape grass installed exceed non-playable natural to irrigation window a system Renovation: harvesting) Development installation playable 6-to-8-hour design Construction turf landscape controllers 20% use or are should Standards 9 9 • • • Parks Advisory May 12, and 2026 Board Recreation Meeting • • • • Water • Stage Attachment Page 10 of 16 1 Water life Impacts: winter 5% May Observed locations Reduced Reduced Citywide water use Enacted 1 – health 2022 grass use by Water Shortage and impacts at water reduction City over-seeding vitality to certain feature reduction, Council Watch: plant with hours goals: in Management 10 10 Parks and Recreation Advisory Board Meeting 200000.000 400000.000 600000.000 800000.000 1000000.000 May Attachment 1200000.000 12, 2026 1 0.000 Page 11 of 16 Current July 2022-June Annual 2023 -18% Total Usage 5-Year Water Parks Average (2017-2022) July Landscape Use 2023-June 2024 -14% Water Trend Total Usage Meter Water Budget Usage July Summary Total 2024-June Water - By 2025 8% Usage Fiscal Usage Year % Over-Under July 2025-February 3% 2026 Usage 11 -20% -15% -10% -5% 0% 5% 10% 11 Parks and Recreation Advisory Board Meeting 20000.000 40000.000 60000.000 80000.000 100000.000 120000.000 140000.000 160000.000 180000.000 May Attachment 200000.000 12, 2026 1 0.000 Page 12 of 16 Monthly July 0% August Water 17% September Use 5-Year -2% Average October Parks Trend (2017-2022) 24% Landscape – November 41% FY Water Water Budget December 2024 -35% Meter to July January Usage 2024-June 30% - FY 2025 2025 February 2024 Usage 75% to 2025 % March 64% Over-Under April 29% May -1% June 12 -6% -60% -40% -20% 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% 12 • • • Parks Advisory May Attachment 12, and 2026 Board Recreation 1 Meeting Base • • • • • • Water Stage Page 13 of 16 Water Contractual Sports Landscape Prioritize features Deactivate potable Mandatory Citywide 10% Use 2 - Budget (Sloan/Hohokam) Fields (trees/shrubs) water Water Shortage material Watering: irrigation use Reduction requirements decorative measures: Alert Reduction(s) 7am–7pm no reduction, Management water Goals: 13 13 • Parks Advisory • and Board Recreation Meeting • • • • • • May Attachment Page 12, 14 2026 of 16 1 Base • • Goal $1M Target Irrigation • • Goal Amount Four Water Upcoming To of To of Budget remove Replace received two remove summer Replace Locations: program: program: dedicated Conservation 20% aged locations: 20% demand aged Los Projects of beginning Renovation: of to irrigation of Basin irrigation all Alamos Reduction(s) four non-playable FY25/26 418 non-playable Park Projects systems & systems 719 properties: turf that turf that (current), – allow allow $5.25M Mtn 2024 for for View Bond: watering watering Park, windows windows Chaparral to to Park, not not exceed exceed Holmes 6 to 6 to Park 8 8 hours hours (basin) in 14 peak 14 • Parks Advisory May 12, and 2026 Board Recreation Meeting • • • Attachment Page 15 of 16 1 Recent at 54 Turf Carriage replaced) valve, irrigation Completed parks Non-Playable Renovation replacement and Riverview/Sloan Water Reduction and & Lane flow Turf Park (31 controller, upgrades: basins Non-Playable sensor Park Efficiency Reduction Irrigation controllers master smart Projects 15 15 Parks and Recreation Advisory Board Meeting May 12, 2026 Attachment 1 Page 16 of 16 16 Parks and Recreation Advisory Board Meeting May 13, 2026 Attachment 2 Page 1 of 46 MAY 2026 Parks Advisory DIVISION and UPDATES Board Recreation Parks and Recreation Advisory Board Meeting May 13, 2026 Attachment 2 Page 2 of 46 Recreation Parks Advisory and Board Recreation Meeting May Attachment 13, 2026 2 Page 3 of 46 Desert Wiggles Camp Continue & Fiesta Adaptive Challenge Giggles Applications @ Buddyverse Indoor Providing Games Stapley Curling, | Preschool ≈ | Jr. programs Innovative May 130 High Inclusion – Paddleboarding 27-31 Accepted karaoke, Offerings Sign Program | up 111 foam to | 80% cannon volunteer! full Parks Advisory and Board Recreation Jr. 3 Meeting May Attachment 13, 2026 2 Goodbye 115+ Page 4 of 46 National Successful Lifeguards new 35 6,000 Aquatics | Records Fremont private summer lifeguards 264 swim | ready broken May pool hired to 22 lessons registration: | go at rentals | 82% +40 Skyline Pools | 3,000 on 120 $600,000 return the by Opening rec inclusion teams in rate waitlist! 15-year-old Day | | 552 revenue May requests so para-athlete, 23 | people far! 325 on Pachanga pool Josie waitlists | passes Dolan May sold 30 Parks Advisory and Board Recreation Meeting May Attachment 13, 2026 2 Fall Page 5 of 46 Youth Adult Tennis WAC March | 2026 First Sports Spring Sports AIA | May Sports Field Field Athletics Spring 1,200 20-23 Requests Rentals Pickleball Council 147 | Allocations | Break athletes, AIA 209 | Olympic Leagues May Meeting rentals coaches, | 16-19 Camp 120+ Attendees | families, @ 28 60 | participants fans Hohokam participants @ 6 | MTPC Stadium leagues Parks Advisory and Board Recreation Meeting May Attachment 13, 2026 2 Page 6 of 46 MRS 2026 Revenue Emails Calls Summer Front Dollars MRS Registrations | | | 1,167 1,080 Discounts $641,350 | Registration| Desk Expended| 11,842 April Awarded $33,130 6-April | 387 16 Parks Advisory and Board Recreation Meeting May Attachment 13, 2026 2 Page 7 of 46 First Red Red Jefferson Summer Day of Rockwall Brand Fitness Mountain Mountain Spring Camps| Recreation Summer New Center Center 3 Coaching Carnival sites Camp Construction Members| | | | | 37 March-April Coordinator 484 82% May 26 Starting 204 sessions | | Visitors filled Centers 93% | Soon! Nicholas 1,300+ satisfaction Harkins enrollments rate Parks Advisory and Board Recreation Meeting May 13, 2026 Attachment Page 8 of 46 2 FNF Teen Full Half & Day Day Youth M.O.R.E. Leadership Camp| Johnson Falcon Bush Camps @ | | | 58% 65% 100% Summer Training full (Sports 1,800+ full full | Programs 99 camp) Camps so Lehi Silver enrollments far! | | 17% 60% Valley full full | 100% full Emerson | 26% full Parks Advisory and Board Recreation Meeting May 13, 2026 Attachment Page 9 of 46 2 Thank Front Fun Inclusion Adaptive M.O.R.E. ‘N’ You Desk | | | Fitness Celebrate to | Our Interactive Music Garden | Information Wall Mini Volunteers!! & Sprinkles Golf Booth Booth Drum Mesa Circle Parks Advisory and Board Recreation Meeting May Attachment 13, 2026 2 Page 10 of 46 COMMERCIAL Dobson Mesa Special Mesa The Mesa Post Ranch Cemetery Events Amphitheatre Convention Golf Office Course Center OPERATIONS Parks Advisory and Board Recreation 96% *as FY26 FY25 FY24 FY23 CC/AMP Meeting May Attachment 13, 2026 2 Cost of Page 11 of 46 4/28/26; $ $ $ $ July-April Recovery 4,434,380* 5,042,393 5,000,398 6,082,414 REVENUES Convention November October October September September September September July 25 June 13 April 10 February January 23 16 14 31 *5 13 25 20 18-19 12 additional Center potential Tucker Zhu Midland Squeeze Zeds Chris Ella Human UPCOMING SatchVai Levity INZO AMPHITHEATRE Movements Dead Mai – – | shows Wetmore & Tomlin League Band 5,500 2940 in Sept/Oct Adam & CONCERTS* – tickets CONCERTS Ant Soft 1.820 tickets Cell sold sold Amphitheatre tickets sold Total Other Events Community Weddings Private Meetings Consumer Banquets | Events Parties The Shows The (Jan-May) POST Post 77 0 24 9 7 26 0 11 Parks Advisory and Board Recreation Meeting May Attachment 13, 2026 2 Page 12 of 46 Convention • • • • The • • • Neon Post Convention Jan-April– Center Council Events: Vanessa Projects: Moon highlights Public-Private Center Hosted | Strategic CactusCon, Gonzalez C-Cure 50 Dance Party Planning Partnership door highlights events MasterTech, nominated and RFP upgrades, Amphitheatre Session, as is 116,982 FIFA Reptile GM of being Rigging the guests World Expo, explored Cup year calculations | Mayor's by Kick HSMAI still The Off, State Under of being the Post the City finalized, – 9,200 4/18/26: 4/11/26: 3/22/25: 3/13/26: Event 3/7/26: 3/1/26: 2/28/26: 11k 2/14/26: 2/13/26: Space 2/13/26: Mesa 1/19/26: Park 1/17/26: Parks Advisory and Board Recreation 4/24-4/25/26: 3/31-4/4/26: 3/25-3/28/26: Space registered – 3,500 Meeting May 13, 2026 attendees Celebrate Mask ALT DMA North Eastmark Mesa Mesa DMA MLK Copper Attachment Page 13 of 46 2 Breakthrough Mesa Mesa Alive Fest – Baseball Dakota Sunset participants Day each Breakaway Mesa Temple – Mesa Holi Marathon Marathon Parade State evening T1D Temple Pioneer Arts Block Picnic Festival – Expo Market and and Beer Winter/Spring Festival Walk – Easter Easter Park Center Party – Red – 10,080 – – spectators Festival Festival – Pageant – Mtn. Great runners, Sloan MacDonald in – Events Riverview Riverview Pageant MacDonald Park Park Park Riverview Park Park over Event Downtown SPECIAL EVENTS 7/4/26: 7/4/26: 6/6/26: Happy AZ Skate Birthday Celebration Party at USA of Plaza Upcoming – Freedom Park Eastmark – Summer Mesa Great Park Convention Events Center Parks Advisory and Board Recreation Meeting May Attachment 13, 2026 2 Page 14 of 46 • • • • • rides Live • • Literacy 14 9,000 24 City Saturday, checked visitors, Read literacy 3,000 entertainment, partners Lane attendees April out issued Runner crafts educational Departments, 11, 108 67 family books new Bookmobile distributing 14 10am-2pm toys/games, Food activities, library 3,000 Trucks at served cards, 1,500 free Pioneer carnival 1,172 books, Park Sponsor Recap Parks Advisory and Board Recreation Meeting May Attachment 13, 2026 2 Page 15 of 46 • • • • • • • Region Mesa event Social on Community Dobson 1 Aerification spring/summer Preemergent Crumbling pipes Replacement Jan-March Community during Media for Championship. WM of on-course the work total Ranch influencers, various crab applied rounds College Phoenix grass to bridge on-course and – Engagement Golf areas golf Men's Women's Open. Good course restroom preventative 25,888, Course Golf Local Good, completed to repaired up & finished Golf hosted to help 10% as captured families a help maintenance Outreach and free with minimize runners-up. 6th kids range were straight compaction attended conducted Parks Advisory and Board Recreation Meeting May Attachment 13, 2026 2 Page 16 of 46 • Main • • • • • Worker, New • • Fiscal Discussions Beautified decorations Performed Customer Graves Revenue: Year continue Country Gonzalo not Cemetery sold: to Meza Service in a 235 $1,436,320 Date Mesa on Club clean 2026 expansion entrance retired Specialist permanent ups (6.4% (1.2% with March was vase on decrease (July-March) phasing 6 January decrease new recently from Cemetery 15 granite hired; and FYTD from and April FYTD Tenured 15 2025) shrubs to 2025) Cemetery remove all Parks and Recreation Advisory Board Meeting May 13, 2026 Attachment 2 Page 17 of 46 Parks and Recreation Advisory Board Meeting May 13, 2026 Attachment 2 Page 18 of 46 The • Courts Main at Eastmark • • • • • • • • • • • • Project Start Construction $10.75 Estimated Radio Ninja Play 2 2 4 Completion – Ramadas Restrooms Exercise Sand Tennis Winter M Control Warrior equipment and and Basketball Components – Schedule Construction Equipment 2 8 Winter 2025 (RC) Course areas Concrete Courts Car Pickleball 2026 Costs for Course ages Volleyball Courts 2-5 & Courts 5-12 Parks and Recreation Advisory Board Meeting May 13, 2026 Attachment 2 Page 19 of 46 Parks and Recreation Advisory Board Meeting May 13, 2026 Attachment 2 Page 20 of 46 Parks Advisory and Board Recreation • • • • • • • • • Project Meeting May Attachment 13, 2026 2 Estimated Construction Phase BMX Trail Parking Page 21 of 46 Tentative Tentative $7,500,000 Pedestrian Ramadas Restrooms One bike system lot Components Start: Construction Costs bridge trails Completion: Winter over Winter 2025 Schedule wash 2026 to Signal connect • Main Butte Park Phase II Parks and Recreation Advisory Board Meeting May 13, 2026 Attachment 2 Page 22 of 46 • Main Parks and Recreation Advisory Board Meeting May 13, 2026 Attachment 2 Page 23 of 46 • Main Parks Advisory and Board Recreation Meeting May 13, 2026 Attachment Page 24of 46 2 • • • • • • Project Start: Estimated Construction Minor Replace Replaster Aquatic Mesa Completion: $1,064,226 November Construction Costs Cool Outdoor Main Components April Deck High 2026 2025 Repairs Shower Pool & Complex Schedule Lazy Assemblies River Parks and Recreation Some Advisory Board Meeting Construction May 13, 2026 Attachment 2 locations Page 25 of 46 will will be Update be staggered completed image by by site Winter with the 2026 bulk with of all six construction locations of all being sites completed occurring by Spring concurrently. 2027. 2024 Park Bond Renovations Parks and Recreation Advisory Board Meeting May 13, 2026 Attachment 2 Page 26 of 46 Parks and Recreation Advisory Board Meeting May 13, 2026 Attachment 2 Page 27 of 46 Parks and Recreation Advisory Board Meeting May 13, 2026 Attachment 2 Page 28 of 46 Parks and Recreation Advisory Board Meeting May 13, 2026 Attachment 2 Page 29 of 46 Parks and Recreation Advisory Board Meeting May 13, 2026 Attachment 2 Page 30 of 46 Parks and Recreation Advisory Board Meeting May 13, 2026 Attachment 2 Page 31 of 46 Parks Advisory and Board Recreation Meeting May Attachment 13, 2026 2 • • • Mesa • • Fremont • • • • Whitman • Page • Aripine 32 of 46 In Christopher In In Countryside Construction Design J. Construction Tennis & Construction Design Aquatic Construction: Design Construction Finalizing Park Construction Finalizing Park Brady Pickleball Dog Park Playground Playground Development Dog Development Complex Spring Development Construction Construction Completion: Completion: Completion: Completion: Completion: Park Center Demo 2027 Winter Addition Summer Court Summer (Bond Spring Contract Renovation Spring Contract Improvement 2026 2026 Lighting 2026 2018) 2027 2027 Updates Additional Project • • Water • • Shepherd • • • Red • • • Eastmark • • • Northeast In In In In Project In Updates Construction: Design Conservation Construction: Design Aquatic Working Construction: Design Mountain Working Construction: Design Aquatic Construction: Design Mesa through Aquatic through Initiation Fall Development @ Fall Development Complex Fall Development Fall Development Complex TBD Development Regional 2026 Los 2029 CMAR 2028 Complex CMAR 2027 Form to (Bond Alamos to Boiler to (Bond to (Bond submitted – Trails Summer Park Spring Install Contractor Spring Contractor Spring Feasibility 2024) 2030 2030 2024) 2029 2024) to 2027 selection selection the Study process process Engineering Complete Department Parks and Recreation Advisory Board Meeting May 13, 2026 Attachment 2 Page 33 of 46 • Main Parks Advisory and Board Recreation Meeting May Attachment 13, 2026 2 • • • Mesa • • Fremont • • • • Whitman • Page • Aripine 34 of 46 In Christopher In In Countryside Construction Design J. Construction Tennis & Construction Design Aquatic Construction: Design Construction Finalizing Park Construction Finalizing Park Brady Pickleball Dog Park Playground Playground Development Dog Development Complex Spring Development Construction Construction Completion: Completion: Completion: Completion: Completion: Park Center Demo 2027 Winter Addition Summer Court Summer (Bond Spring Contract Renovation Spring Contract Improvement 2026 2026 Lighting 2026 2018) 2027 2027 Updates Additional Project • • Water • • Shepherd • • • Red • • • Eastmark • • • Northeast In In In In Project In Updates Construction: Design Conservation Construction: Design Aquatic Working Construction: Design Mountain Working Construction: Design Aquatic Construction: Design Mesa through Aquatic through Initiation Fall Development @ Fall Development Complex Fall Development Fall Development Complex TBD Development Regional 2026 Los 2029 CMAR 2028 Complex CMAR 2027 Form to (Bond Alamos to Boiler to (Bond to (Bond submitted – Trails Summer Park Spring Install Contractor Spring Contractor Spring Feasibility 2024) 2030 2030 2024) 2029 2024) to 2027 selection selection the Study process process Engineering Complete Department Parks and Recreation Advisory Board Meeting May 13, 2026 Attachment 2 Page 35 of 46 Aquatic Eastmark Complex Aquatic Red Mountain Complex Parks and Recreation Advisory Board Meeting May 13, 2026 Attachment 2 Page 36 of 46 • Main Parks and Recreation Advisory Board Meeting May 13, 2026 Attachment 2 Page 37 of 46 • Main Parks Advisory and Board Recreation Meeting May Attachment 13, 2026 2 • • • Mesa • • Fremont • • • • Whitman • Page • Aripine 38 of 46 In Christopher In In Countryside Construction Design J. Construction Tennis & Construction Design Aquatic Construction: Design Construction Finalizing Park Construction Finalizing Park Brady Pickleball Dog Park Playground Playground Development Dog Development Complex Spring Development Construction Construction Completion: Completion: Completion: Completion: Completion: Park Center Demo 2027 Winter Addition Summer Court Summer (Bond Spring Contract Renovation Spring Contract Improvement 2026 2026 Lighting 2026 2018) 2027 2027 Updates Additional Project • • Water • • Shepherd • • • Red • • • Eastmark • • • Northeast In In In In Project In Updates Construction: Design Conservation Construction: Design Aquatic Working Construction: Design Mountain Working Construction: Design Aquatic Construction: Design Mesa through Aquatic through Initiation Fall Development @ Fall Development Complex Fall Development Fall Development Complex TBD Development Regional 2026 Los 2029 CMAR 2028 Complex CMAR 2027 Form to (Bond Alamos to Boiler to (Bond to (Bond submitted – Trails Summer Park Spring Install Contractor Spring Contractor Spring Feasibility 2024) 2030 2030 2024) 2029 2024) to 2027 selection selection the Study process process Engineering Complete Department Parks and Recreation Advisory Board Meeting May 13, 2026 Attachment 2 Page 39 of 46 • Main Parks and Recreation Advisory Board Meeting May 13, 2026 Attachment 2 Page 40 of 46 • Main Parks and Recreation Advisory Board Meeting May 13, 2026 Attachment 2 Page 41 of 46 • Main Parks Advisory and Board Recreation Meeting May Attachment 13, 2026 2 • • • Mesa • • Fremont • • • • Whitman • Page • Aripine 42 of 46 In Christopher In In Countryside Construction Design J. Construction Tennis & Construction Design Aquatic Construction: Design Construction Finalizing Park Construction Finalizing Park Brady Pickleball Dog Park Playground Playground Development Dog Development Complex Spring Development Construction Construction Completion: Completion: Completion: Completion: Completion: Park Center Demo 2027 Winter Addition Summer Court Summer (Bond Spring Contract Renovation Spring Contract Improvement 2026 2026 Lighting 2026 2018) 2027 2027 Updates Additional Project • • Water • • Shepherd • • • Red • • • Eastmark • • • Northeast In In In In Project In Updates Construction: Design Conservation Construction: Design Aquatic Working Construction: Design Mountain Working Construction: Design Aquatic Construction: Design Mesa through Aquatic through Initiation Fall Development @ Fall Development Complex Fall Development Fall Development Complex TBD Development Regional 2026 Los 2029 CMAR 2028 Complex CMAR 2027 Form to (Bond Alamos to Boiler to (Bond to (Bond submitted – Trails Summer Park Spring Install Contractor Spring Contractor Spring Feasibility 2024) 2030 2030 2024) 2029 2024) to 2027 selection selection the Study process process Engineering Complete Department Parks and Recreation Advisory Board Meeting May 13, 2026 Attachment 2 Page 43 of 46 AQUATICS, Parks CONTRACTS, Maintenance PARKS, RIVERVIEW, & SPORTS FIELDS Parks Advisory and Board Recreation Meeting May Attachment 13, 2026 2 Page 44 of 46 Water Work Field Note: Amount: Work Vandalism: Inspections: Parks Use: Orders: Preps: Statistics Overall, Orders: the 563,165 $17,016; 371; 4,948; 2,683; 6,782; total KGals; 56% 13% 5% 3% 3% drop in 3% Increase Increase Increase Decrease Decrease Maintenance usage above since 5-year Stage 1 is average -21%. Parks Advisory Meeting and Board Recreation May Attachment Page 13, 45 2026 of 46 2 Planted Pools Installed Replaced 162 Completed system Replaced Rancho Replaced Parks 224 31 fixtures 89 Del Highlights trees Halogen lighting failing Mar, concrete at valves irrigation or various at clocks upgrade Silvergate, courts at at damaged & at Maintenance locations Brimhall, Red light Valencia Hermosa Carson, Riverview/Sloan Mountain poles Parks Vista, & Park, across Shepherd the Escobedo, converting park Parks and Recreation Advisory Board Meeting May 13, 2026 Attachment 2 Page 46 of 46