Extracted text (via pymupdf_layout)
27584 characters
OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK COUNCIL MINUTES November 2, 2026 The City Council of the City of Mesa met in the Council Chambers at City Hall, 20 East Main Street, on November 2, 2026, at 5:45 p.m. COUNCIL PRESENT COUNCIL ABSENT OFFICERS PRESENT Mark Freeman None Scott Butler Scott Somers Holly Moseley Rich Adams Jim Smith Jennifer Duff Alicia Goforth Francisco Heredia Dorean Taylor Mayor’s welcome. Mayor Freeman conducted a roll call. Mayor Freeman recognized the members of the Mayor’s Youth Committee in attendance. Invocation by Reverend Dr. Derrick Elliott from Desert Heritage Church. Pledge of Allegiance was led by members of the Mayor’s Youth Committee. Awards, recognitions, and announcements. Mayor Freeman declared November as Alzheimer’s Awareness month to raise awareness on the importance of early detection, research and caregiver support. Councilmember Heredia stated that he is proud to sponsor this proclamation and wants Mesa residents living with Alzheimer’s and their families caring for them to know that their community supports them. He mentioned Alzheimer’s Awareness month is an opportunity to gain strength, encourage people to seek support and recognize the caregivers who give so much of themselves. He invited Kathy Norris-Wilheim, an Alzheimer’s advocate and ambassador, to the podium to share her personal story with Alzheimer’s. 1. Take action on all consent agenda items. All items listed on the agenda with an asterisk (*) are on the consent agenda which means they will be considered by the City Council as a group, without any separate discussion of these items, unless a Councilmember or citizen requests the item be removed from the consent agenda to be considered separately. If a citizen wants an item removed from the consent agenda, a request must be made prior to the scheduled start time of the meeting. Regular Council Meeting November 2, 2026 Page 2 It was moved by Councilmember Duff, seconded by Vice Mayor Somers, that the consent agenda items be approved. Upon tabulation of votes, it showed: AYES – Freeman–Somers–Adams–Duff–Goforth–Heredia–Taylor NAYS – None Carried unanimously. *2. Approval of minutes of previous meetings as written. Minutes from the Study Sessions held on September 14, and October 26, 2026; the Strategic Planning Session held on September 17, 2026; and the Regular Council meeting held on October 26, 2026. 3. Take action on the following liquor license applications: *3-a. Valley Liquors A convenience store is requesting a new Series 10 Beer and Wine Store License for Valley Liquors LLC, 1160 East University Drive - Sandeep Singh Sodhi, agent. There is no existing license at this location. (District 1) *3-b. Jin BBQ A restaurant that serves lunch and dinner is requesting a new Series 12 Restaurant License for Half LBS F&B LLC, 111 South Dobson Road, Suite 104 - Minjae Oh, agent. The existing Series 12 Restaurant License held by IMLEE LLC will revert to the State. (District 3) *3-c. Walmart #3089 A retailer is requesting an ownership and location transfer of a Series 9 Liquor Store License for Walmart Inc., 6306 South Mountain Road - John Dean Curtis II, agent. There is no existing license at this location. (District 6) *3-d. Walmart Fuel Station #3089 A fuel station with a convenience store is requesting a new Series 10 Beer and Wine Store License for Walmart Inc., 11143 East Destination Auto Drive - John Dean Curtis II, agent. There is no existing license at this location. (District 6) 4. Take action on the following resolutions: *4-a. Approving and authorizing the City Manager to enter into a Development Agreement with The Grove at Lehi Community Association related to the maintenance of landscaping on property adjacent to the development known as The Grove at Lehi, a residential development located north of McDowell Road and east of the 202 Red Mountain Freeway in Mesa, Arizona. (District 1) – Resolution No. 12588 *4-b. Approving and authorizing the City Manager to enter into an Intergovernmental Agreement with the Town of Queen Creek (Town) and Maricopa County (County) to Regular Council Meeting November 2, 2026 Page 3 establish the transfer of jurisdiction over right-of-way associated with improvements to the Sossaman Road and Germann Road intersection and the Union Pacific Railroad at- grade crossing. The Town will be solely responsible for all acquisition-related expenses, at no cost or financial obligation to the City or County. (District 6) – Resolution No. 12589 *4-c. Approving and authorizing the City Manager to enter into an Intergovernmental Agreement (IGA) with the Flood Control District of Maricopa County (FCDMC) for construction, construction management, operation, and maintenance of the Pecos Road Basins and Storm Drain Improvements Project. The IGA will authorize a cost share of expenditures not to exceed a total of $22,000,000. The City’s responsibility will be fifty percent (50%), up to $11,000,000, and FCDMC will be responsible for the remaining fifty percent (50%), up to $11,000,000. This project is funded by Local Streets Sales Tax. (District 6) – Resolution No. 12582 5. Introduction of the following ordinance and setting November 16, 2026 as the date of the public hearing on this ordinance: *5-a. ZON25-00943 "Waffle Flower Warehouse Rezone," 2.4± acres located at the northwest corner of East Thomas Road and North 54th Street. Rezone from Single Residence-90 (RS-90) to Light Industrial (LI), Site Plan Review, and Special Use Permit. This request will allow for an approximately 18,000± square foot Industrial development. William Erwin, Erwin Architecture and Development, applicant; Zee Properties, LLC, owner. (District 5) – Ordinance No. 6037 Staff Recommendation: Approval with conditions P&Z Board Recommendation: Approval with conditions (Vote: 7-0) 6. Discuss, receive public comment, and take action on the following ordinance: *6-a. ZON25-00895 "Terrible's Commercial Development," 1.3± acres located approximately 190± feet south of the southwest corner of South Crismon Road and East Hampton Avenue. Rezone from Planned Employment Park with a Planned Area Development Overlay (PEP-PAD) to Limited Commercial (LC), Site Plan Review, and Special Use Permit. This request will allow for an approximately 4,689± square foot Convenience Market with Accessory Service Station. KFH CRISMON & HAMPTON LLC, owner; Tim Rasnake, Archicon Architecture & Interiors LLC, applicant. (District 5) – Ordinance No. 6035 Staff Recommendation: Approval with conditions P&Z Board Recommendation: Approval with conditions (Vote: 7-0) 7. Discuss, receive public comment, and take action on the following resolution and ordinance pertaining to historic preservation: *7-a. See: Items not on the Consent Agenda. *7-b. See: Items not on the Consent Agenda. Items not on the Consent Agenda Regular Council Meeting November 2, 2026 Page 4 7-a. A resolution adopting the Mesa Historic Preservation Design Guidelines that amend and replace the “Historic Homes of Mesa: An Architectural and Preservation Guide”. The amendments include, but are not limited to, Certificates of Appropriateness, Historic Districts and Landmarks, Historic Building Types and Architectural Styles, Guidelines for Preservation, Restoration, and Rehabilitation, and Guidelines for Additions and New Construction. (Citywide) – Resolution No. 12590 Staff Recommendation: Adoption P&Z Board Recommendation: Adoption with conditions (Vote: 7-0) HPB Board Recommendation: Adoption with conditions (Vote: 6-0) Assistant Planning Director Rachel Phillips introduced Historic Preservation Officer Matthew Kriegl and displayed a PowerPoint presentation. (See Attachment 1) Ms. Phillips discussed the history and purpose of the text amendment adjustments and explained the intention to simplify and clarify historic preservation regulations by consolidating procedures into Chapter 74 of the Zoning Ordinance. (See Pages 2 through 4 of Attachment 1) Mr. Kriegl reviewed the streamline of the Certificate of Appropriateness (COA) process to better align with other city processes. He highlighted the amendments to strengthen property maintenance and clarify the demolition procedures, noting that the requirements extend the demolition review moratorium on projects from six months to one year. He identified the amendments that strengthen protections for historically-designated signs, and the framework for reviewing archeological resources procedures for compliance. He shared new historic preservation definitions added to Chapter 87 that clarify previously undefined terms. (See Pages 5 through 9 of Attachment 1) Mr. Kriegl described the extensive community outreach that began in 2023, including the Historic Preservation Board and Planning and Zoning (P&Z) Board meetings, public open houses, and stakeholder engagement. (See Page 10 of Attachment 1) Mr. Kriegl presented a summary of the recommendations from the P&Z Board and Historic Preservation Board, which supported the proposed text amendments. (See Page 11 of Attachment 1) In response to a question from Mayor Freeman, Mr. Kriegl replied that properties must be at least 50 years old to qualify for historic consideration. Responding to a question posed by Mayor Freeman, Ms. Phillips explained that designating an individual property or group of properties as a historic district follows the same process as a rezoning and is relatively straightforward . Mayor Freeman thanked staff for the presentation. 7-b. Amendments to Mesa City Code Title 11, Chapters 23, 44, 66, 74, and 87 pertaining to historic preservation. The amendments include, but are not limited to, repealing in its entirety Chapter 23: Historic and Landmark Overlay Districts and replacing it with a new “Chapter 23: Historic Preservation Overlay”; repealing in its entirety Chapter 44: Historic Signs and replacing it with a new “Chapter 44: Historic Signs”; repealing in its entirety Chapter 74: Historic District and Historic Landmark Procedures and replacing it with a new “Chapter 74: Historic Preservation Procedures”; adding review procedures for Regular Council Meeting November 2, 2026 Page 5 archaeological resources; adding definitions; and modifying the authority and duties of the Historic Preservation Board. (Citywide) – Ordinance No. 6036 Staff Recommendation: Adoption P&Z Board Recommendation: Adoption (Vote: 7-0) HPB Board Recommendation: Adoption (Vote: 6-0) Assistant Planning Director Rachel Phillips introduced Historic Preservation Officer Matthew Kriegl and displayed a PowerPoint presentation. (See Attachment 2) Ms. Phillips explained that the City's historic preservation guidelines were approximately 25 years old, over 200 pages, and require updating to ensure support for Mesa’s Certified Local Government (CLG) program. She provided an overview of the updated design guidelines regarding the Historic Preservation program. She noted the seven chapters and five appendices will be updated to help property owners understand preservation requirements and historic features. (See Pages 2 and 3 of Attachment 2) Mr. Kriegl reviewed the amendments to the seven chapters and five appendices of the updated guidelines, explaining that the new document is designed to be more user-friendly than the previous 200-page version. (See Pages 4 through 11 of Attachment 2) Mr. Kriegl summarized the public engagement process for design guidelines, which began in 2023 and included stakeholder meetings, board meetings, and public open houses. (See Page 12 of Attachment 2) Mr. Kriegl presented the recommendations from the Historic Preservation Board and the P&Z Board. (See Page 13 of Attachment 2) Responding to a question from Councilmember Adams, Ms. Phillips replied that the two-year gap resulted from staff turnover, and the need to review and re-engage various organizations during staff transitions. Councilmember Duff expressed support for the updated guidelines, noting that the graphics and clearly organized information make preservation requirements easier for homeowners to understand. She encouraged preservation of Mesa's mid-century homes and recognized the importance of historic districts in maintaining the City's character and history. In response to multiple questions from Councilmember Taylor, Mr. Kriegl explained that the COM has an opt-in program for homeowners to pursue, but the City does not seek particular houses or neighborhoods. Mr. Kriegl stated that the program provides two voluntary options under the Historic Preservation Overlay: an individual property can be designated as a historic landmark based on its historical significance, or multiple properties can participate in establishing a historic district. Councilmember Duff commented that a historic district generally requires at least 50% of the homes to retain their original historic character and homeowners whose properties retain their historic features may also pursue individual designation through the State Historic Preservation Office, even if their neighborhood does not qualify as a historic district. She noted that state historic registration may provide property tax advantages and encourage future owners to preserve the property. Regular Council Meeting November 2, 2026 Page 6 Mayor Freeman thanked staff for the presentation. Mayor Freeman stated that pending no objection from the Council, agenda Items 7-a and 7-b will be voted on in one motion. It was moved by Councilmember Duff, seconded by Vice Mayor Somers, that Resolution No. 12590 and Ordinance No. 6036 be adopted. Upon tabulation of votes, it showed: AYES – Freeman–Somers–Adams–Duff–Goforth–Heredia–Taylor NAYS – None Carried unanimously. 8. Items from citizens present. Jerrica Trimble, a Mesa resident, shared her concerns with Flock cameras, including the safety of the Flock poles installed, violation of the Fourth Amendment, and the potential of lawsuits against the City. She suggested Council request an investigation and asked for transparency on audit data. Chris Hamlet, a Mesa resident, expressed his disapproval of the Drag Queen Christmas Show at the Mesa Arts Center. 9. Adjournment. Without objection, the Regular Council Meeting adjourned at 6:29 p.m. ________________________________ MARK FREEMAN, MAYOR ATTEST: ___________________________________ HOLLY MOSELEY, CITY CLERK I hereby certify that the foregoing minutes are a true and correct copy of the minutes of the Regular Council Meeting of the City Council of Mesa, Arizona, held on the 2nd day of November 2026. I further certify that the meeting was duly called and held and that a quorum was present. ________________________________________ HOLLY MOSELEY, CITY CLERK lr (Attachment – 2) Regular November Attachment Page 1 of Council 12 2, 1 2026 meeting Text Historic Mesa City Matthew Rachel Amendments Preservation Study Kriegl, Phillips, Council Session Meg Historic : Eaton, Assistant October City Preservation Planning 26, Archeologist 2026 Officer Director Regular November Attachment Page 2 of Council 12 2, 1 2026 meeting 01 use The regulations organization streamline Simplify REORGANIZE Background and amendments of the are and 02 intended review requirements, terminology, Clarify CLARIFY to Purpose processes make and the regulations procedures provisions among consistency Improve 03 Historic HP CONSISTENCY easier and to Text understand, laws state with Align 04 Amendments Preservation and COMPLIANCE administer, applicable regulations federal and 2 Regular November Attachment Page 3 of Council 12 2, 1 2026 meeting Procedures Historic CHAPTER Historic CHAPTER Historic CHAPTER comprehensive Bring the Reorganize Districts 74 Signs 44 and 23 City’s and Landmark chapter key Historic Historic Overlay Landmark Districts Preservation regulations and Historic procedures Text together PROCEDURES PRESERVATION HISTORIC CHAPTER in one Amendments Preservation 74 3 Regular November Attachment Page 4 of Council 12 2, 1 2026 meeting New standards, Revise not yet Improve review Clarify Preservation Consolidate Chapter Consolidate eligibility designated the standards designation 74 provides and including criteria Supplemental Overlay Historic a age, to procedures, District clearer Clarify significance, align Inventory and framework with List application Historic for and nationally for designation integrity Landmark Historic recognized resources requirements, and Text Overlays historic determined public into administration Preservation notice, a single Amendments preservation eligible and but Historic 4 Regular November Attachment Page 5 of Council 12 2, 1 2026 meeting Historic Allow Ordinance Properties, Base Coordinate Clarify activities Identify Streamline emergency the review application that work Preservation Mesa on COA are that review Certificate repairs Secretary review exempt requires and to be Historic of with requirements from a coordination of reviewed Preservation Interior's building and review COA and with Standards permit review ordinary other Appropriateness concurrently Design for issuance timelines City Historic with Guidelines, the maintenance processes (COA) Text building and Treatment and Review Amendments Preservation permits Zoning of repair Historic 5 Regular November Attachment Page 6 of Council 12 2, 1 2026 meeting disrepair from prevent designated owners the Clarify DUTY 01 falling the of requirement and TO into a resource resources historically strengthen Strengthen state that MAINTAIN of 02 Maintenance Overlays Historic approved resources process Clarify DEMOLITION and within for the and Preservation historic demolition proposed REVIEW Historic Demolition Text alternatives year demolition delay Preservation Following ONE-YEAR 03 while the a Procedures Amendments Preservation are preservation permit issuance Board Historic DELAY explored one of a denial, 6 Regular November Attachment Page 7 of Council 12 2, 1 2026 meeting • • • • Create Establish application Require Update Establish a Strengthen requirements a modification, dedicated a eligibility are process restoration and procedures Historically Protections not met for and criteria, revocation for future Designated for for maintenance application designation, Signs revocation and section Historically plan restoration, Historic when as review Text part designation of the procedures maintenance, Designated Amendments Preservation designation Signs 7 Regular November Attachment Page 8 of Council 12 2, 1 2026 meeting The Before Require Add a Establish determine City qualified consultation federal dedicated excavation laws all whether Archaeologist professionals, with governing development framework Archaeological the on for protected may as City City-owned cultural to reviewing cultural conduct applicable Archaeologist, or comply Resource an resources. with archeological materials archaeological SHPO, controlled applicable Historic may THPOs, property, resources Compliance Text be and local, present assessment other require state, Amendments Preservation to and Procedures 8 Regular November Attachment Page 9 of Council 12 2, 1 2026 meeting Add a Define State Historically Historic Historic Historic Historic Certificate new category of of Previously Disrepair Resource Preservation Landmark District of Historic Designated Sign Overlay Appropriateness Undefined Preservation-related Terms Historic definitions Text to Chapter Amendments Preservation 87 9 Regular November Attachment Council 2, 1 2026 meeting Page 10 of 12 2026 2023 Outreach Discussion HPB MAY Discussion HPB AUG Multiple 5 1 & rounds Discussion HPB JUL Public of 7 House AUG Open 24 Engagement Board Public JUL informed House Open 21 review, Discussion HPB SEP 5 the public P&Z JUL Session Study 22 updated outreach, Discussion HPB OCT Hearing HPB SEP 3 Historic Guidelines 1 and Text P&Z stakeholder Hearing P&Z SEP Session NOV 9 Study 1 Amendments Preservation consultation • • • • KEY Mesa GRIC SRPMIC Arizona Foundation Preservation THPO THPO SHPO STAKEHOLDERS 10 Regular November Attachment Page 11 Council of 2, 12 1 2026 meeting Staff Board Ordinance • • 01 recommends for HISTORIC adoption recommendation Unanimous September PRESERVATION 1, that Recommendations 2026 the BOARD City Council adopt • • 02 the Historic for ZONING PLANNING Unanimous September proposed Text adoption recommendation 9, BOARD AND Historic 2026 Amendments Preservation Preservation 11 Regular Council meeting November 2, 2026 Attachment 1 Page 12 of 12 Questions & Historic Text Discussion Preservation Amendments 12 Regular November Attachment Page 1 of Council 14 2, 2 2026 meeting Historic Mesa Design City Matthew Rachel Guidelines Preservation Kriegl, Phillips, Council Meg Historic Eaton, Assistant November City Preservation Planning 2, Archeologist 2026 Officer Director Regular November Attachment Page 2 of Council 14 2, 2 2026 meeting updated Guidelines The UPDATE 25 Why in current YEARS The 2001 were Design 01 SINCE Update last update the fundamental modernizes types resources range of addresses program Mesa’s EVOLVED PROGRAM Guidelines? role Mesa’s and historic a broader now preservation HAS of project historic preservation TO preservation property applicants practical accessibility, organization, Improves USE CLEARER Historic guidance owners and guidance and & review. while for usability, EASIER Design retaining Preservation the program Local of Mesa’s guidance preservation Updates PROGRAM SUPPORTS Guidelines Government Certified in support CLG 2 Regular November Attachment Page 3 of Council 14 2, 2 2026 meeting APPENDICES 5 CHAPTERS 7 Updated Designed context, Program SUPPORTING 01 Mesa’s Preservation PRIMARY and historic Guidelines designers, as a cultural Information, context planning, GUIDANCE staff, practical heritage review RESOURCES project at a and the resource standards, review, Glance Historic for character rehabilitation, Preservation property defining Historic owners, additions, Board. features, new Design applicants, districts construction, Preservation and Guidelines landmark signage, and 3 Regular November Attachment Page 4 of Council 14 2, 2 2026 meeting current regulations Explains structures, locally Provides used Explains Guidelines Establishes Chapter Building that designated 01 when 1: and the and practical the Code should signs and purpose Introduction Guidelines historic direction how be the and used homes, for role supplement Guidelines of alongside buildings, improvements the the City should Design Historic sites, to be Design Preservation Guidelines 4 Regular November Attachment Page 5 of Council 14 2, 2 2026 meeting decisions Identifies National Property Explains Describes exempt Explains Brings Chapter in Rehabilitation the the 01 from when the 2: Mesa as Register, Register, application review a COA the Secretary and relationship COA process Certificates of COA Historic and is foundation the between review required together of for Interior’s review Preservation and in the one preservation Mesa procedures when Appropriateness Standards Overlay, work location Historic Historic is for Design Preservation Guidelines 5 Regular November Attachment Page 6 of Council 14 2, 2 2026 meeting solution. without Provides defining paint, Addresses of historic Emphasizes historic Primary Chapter 01 01 3: prescribing practical features. landscaping, windows, materials repair buildings. guidance a single and doors, rather for work Preservation, recommendations other whenever than on design character- roofs, feasible. existing porches, replacement Restoration & Historic Rehabilitation Design Guidelines Preservation 6 Regular November Attachment Page 7 of Council 14 2, 2 2026 meeting preserves subordinate Encourages materials, Addresses original Emphasizes Guidance Chapter to and 01 structure for 4: character-defining the contemporary design placement, compatibility additions Additions historic size, to building design scale, while historic features and that massing, preserving buildings remains the Historic Design Guidelines Preservation 7 Regular November Attachment Page 8 of Council 14 2, 2 2026 meeting mechanical accessory Also materials, Considers replication Emphasizes historic Guidance Chapter addresses and 01 districts for 5: dwelling scale, new New equipment, units, accessory overall massing, compatibility and design construction Construction solar fencing, buildings, setbacks, rather systems walls, than within Historic Design Preservation Guidelines 8 Regular November Attachment Page 9 of Council 14 2, 2 2026 meeting and new Provides landmarks character Supports signage Provides signs Guidance Chapter signage a of on 01 for 6: consistent commercial business historic recommendations preserving Historic framework visibility buildings and Signage districts while for for and appropriate rehabilitating evaluating individual contributing to new historic Historic historic the Design Guidelines Preservation 9 Regular November Attachment Page 10 Council of 2, 14 2 2026 meeting architecture building Includes periods Organizes development and Recognizes character historic Provides Chapter types, a visual Mesa’s Piipaash 01 buildings, updated 7: styles, and connections Mesa’s Mesa’s and architectural development post-World history neighborhoods, context for Historic common into War II through from & residential reference major suburban agricultural longstanding and understanding explaining historical architectural Mesa’s Architectural Historic growth O’odham Context Design Guidelines Preservation 10 E D C B A Regular November Attachment Page 11 Council of 2, 14 2 2026 meeting Appendices Neighborhood Context CULTURAL characteristics, Context HISTORIC 01 Identifies CHARACTER Standards CERTIFICATE 01 Preservation HISTORIC on for and for Program significant HERITAGE defining Mesa’s DISTRICTS explains DEFINING Certificate OF tools, PRESERVATION archaeological & features, designated & common of APPROPRIATNESS districts, HERITAGE and historic HISTORIC FEATURES Appropriateness landmarks, PROGRAM and cultural photographs districts LANDMARKS character-defining and REVIEW and the resources, NEIGHBORHOODS and features demolition Heritage OVERVIEW Historic landmarks, STANDARDS including including found on review Neighborhood Design a their historic description Recognition Preservation of significance, properties Guidelines the Program Heritage architectural 11 Regular November Attachment Council 2, 2 2026 meeting Page 12 of 14 2026 2023 Outreach Discussion HPB MAY Discussion HPB AUG Multiple 5 1 & rounds Discussion HPB JUL Public of 7 House AUG Open 24 Engagement Board Public JUL informed House Open 21 review, Discussion HPB SEP 5 the public P&Z JUL Session Study 22 updated outreach, Discussion HPB OCT Hearing HPB SEP 3 Historic Guidelines 1 and P&Z Design stakeholder Hearing P&Z SEP Session NOV 9 Study 1 Preservation consultation • • • • KEY Guidelines Mesa GRIC SRPMIC Arizona Foundation Preservation THPO THPO SHPO STAKEHOLDERS 12 Regular November Attachment Page 13 Council of 2, 14 2 2026 meeting Staff Board Ordinance • • 01 recommends for HISTORIC adoption recommendation Unanimous September PRESERVATION 1, that Recommendations 2026 the BOARD City Council adopt • • 02 the Historic for ZONING PLANNING Unanimous September proposed adoption recommendation Design 9, BOARD AND Historic 2026 Preservation Guidelines Preservation 13 Regular Council meeting November 2, 2026 Attachment 2 Page 14 of 14 Questions & Historic Discussion Design Preservation Guidelines 14