Council Report

City of Mesa — City Council (2026-11-16)

View PDF Meeting page

Extracted text (via pymupdf_layout) 5233 characters
City Council Report
Date: November 16, 2026
To: City Council
Through: Scott J. Butler – City Manager
Teri Overbey-Brown – Human Resources Director
From: Nitra Hawkins – Safety Administrator
SUBJECT: FY 26/27 Excess Workers’ Compensation Insurance and Self-Insurance
Surety Bond Purchase
PURPOSE AND RECOMMENDATION
Staff requests City Council approval to purchase excess workers' compensation
insurance (policy period beginning December 1, 2026) and a workers' compensation self-
insurance surety bond (term beginning January 1, 2027). The surety bond is required for
the City to maintain its self-insurance authority with the Industrial Commission of Arizona,
and the excess insurance protects the City from catastrophic claim costs.
This year’s recommended excess insurance and surety bond purchases are:
• Excess Workers’ Compensation Insurance:
Premium Amount: Not to exceed $775,000.
• Self-Insurance Surety Bond:
Bond Rate: $12.00 per every $1,000 of the required security amount.
DISCUSSION – EXCESS WORKERS’ COMPENSATION INSURANCE
As a self-insured employer authorized under A.R.S. §§ 23-961(A)(2) and 23-962, the City
of Mesa purchases excess workers' compensation insurance, which must meet the
requirements of Arizona Administrative Code R20-5-1526. This coverage protects the
City from severe financial loss when an employee suffers a catastrophic work-related
injury or illness.
The City currently pays each compensable claim up to its self-insured retention (SIR):
$1.25 million per accident/injury/illness, or $2 million per statutory presumptive illness.

The excess insurance carrier reimburses the City for claim costs above the SIR amounts.
The excess premium has more than doubled over ten years, from $320,375 in FY 16/17
to $646,799 in FY 25/26. Increases have been driven by excess market hardening, rising
medical and indemnity costs, payroll growth, and presumptive-illness exposure.
The below table highlights the City’s excess insurance premium history.
Coverage Self-Insured Self-Insured Retention Premium Change from
period Retention (SIR) (SIR) (Presumptive prior year
Illness)
FY 16/17 $1,000,000 — $320,375 —
FY 17/18 $1,000,000 — $321,218 +0.3%
FY 18/19 $1,000,000 — $311,609 -3.0%
FY 19/20 $1,000,000 — $311,609 0.0%
FY 20/21 $1,250,000 $2,000,000 $388,981 +24.8%
FY 21/22 $1,250,000 $2,000,000 $439,650 +13.0%
FY 22/23 $1,250,000 $2,000,000 $528,017 +20.1%
FY 23/24 $1,250,000 $2,000,000 $543,644 +3.0%
FY 24/25 $1,250,000 $2,000,000 $624,633 +14.9%
FY 25/26 $1,250,000 $2,000,000 $646,799 +3.5%
RENEWAL OPTION
After reviewing current market conditions and the City's loss experience, the City's
insurance broker, Arthur J. Gallagher & Co., recommends keeping the current SIR of
$1.25 million per accident/injury/illness and $2 million per statutory presumptive illness.
The renewal premium will not exceed $775,000, an increase of up to $128,201 (19.8%)
over FY 25/26.
Recommendation:
Approve the purchase of the excess workers’ compensation insurance policy for the
policy period beginning December 1, 2026, at a premium not to exceed $775,000, with
an SIR of $1.25 million per accident/injury/illness and $2 million per statutory presumptive
illness.
WORKERS’ COMPENSATION SELF – INSURANCE SURETY BOND
To maintain its self-insurance authority, the City must post security with the Industrial
Commission of Arizona (ICA) under A.R.S. § 23-961(A)(2). Arizona Administrative Code
R20-5-1520 sets the amount at 125% of the City’s total estimated future medical and
2

indemnity liability, as calculated on the Workers’ Compensation Liability Form, unless the
ICA requires a different amount. The City meets this requirement with a surety bond,
which guarantees payment of the City’s current and future workers’ compensation
obligations.
The City’s insurance broker, Arthur J. Gallagher & Co., has secured a bond rate of $12.00
per $1,000 of the required security amount.
Recommendation:
Approve the purchase of the workers’ compensation self-insurance surety bond at a rate
of $12.00 per $1,000 of the required security amount.
The bond premium for the term beginning January 1, 2027 will be based on the total
estimated liability for open compensable workers’ compensation claims, as calculated on
the Workers’ Compensation Liability Form to be filed with the Industrial Commission of
Arizona on December 1, 2026. For comparison, the City’s bond for the term beginning
January 1, 2026, was based on $26,459,248 in estimated liability and cost $145,526, a
rate of $5.50 per $1,000. At the new $12.00 rate, the same amount would cost
approximately $317,511.
FISCAL IMPACT OF INSURANCE/BOND PURCHASED
If City Council approves staff’s recommendations, the excess workers’ compensation
insurance and self-insurance surety bond will be purchased through the Workers’
Compensation Trust Fund. The estimated total fiscal impact for FY 26/27 is
approximately $1.09 million, as follows:
1) Excess Workers' Compensation Insurance
• Premium Amount: Not to exceed $775,000.
2) Self-Insurance Surety Bond
• Premium Rate: $12.00 per $1,000 of the required security amount.
• Final amount based on the Workers’ Compensation Liability Form to be filed
with the Industrial Commission of Arizona on December 1, 2026.
3