Extracted text (via pymupdf_layout)
5987 characters
3. Discuss and make a recommendation to the City Council on the following amendments: 3-a* ZON25-00895. "Terrible's Commercial Development," 1.3± acres located approximately 190± feet south of the southwest corner of South Crismon Road and East Hampton Avenue. Rezone from Planned Employment Park with a Planned Area Development Overlay (PEP-PAD) to Limited Commercial (LC), Site Plan Review and Special Use Permit. This request will allow for an approximately 4,689± square foot Convenience Market with Accessory Service Station. (District 5). Staff Planner: Chloe Durfee Daniel Recommendation: Approval with Conditions 3-b See: Items not on the Consent Agenda 4. Items not on the Consent Agenda 3-b ZON21-00066. "Greenfield Multifamily," 1.9± acres located approximately 2,025± feet north of the northwest corner of East Brown Road and North Greenfield Road. Rezone from Single Residence-35 (RS-35) to Multiple Residence-3 with a Planned Area Development Overlay (RM-3-PAD) and Site Plan Review. This request will allow for a 30- unit multiple residence development. (District 2). Staff Planner: Jennifer Merrill Recommendation: Approval with Conditions The following citizens spoke and addressed the Board in opposition to case number ZON21-00066: • Wendy Wise, Mesa resident • Daren Jensen, Mesa resident • Janet Cotie, Mesa resident • Chase Wennersten, Mesa resident • Loralee Langilde, Mesa resident • Rich Vales, Mesa resident • Lenore Dai, Mesa resident • Ginger Blum, Mesa resident • Jason Oaks, Mesa resident • Mark Hunksaker, Mesa resident The above-listed speakers offered a series of comments in opposition to the case number ZON21-00066 including but not limited to the following: • Concern regarding the high density and three-story scale of the proposed 30-unit development, stating it is out of character with the surrounding lower-density, single-family neighborhood on half-acre to one-acre lots. • Privacy and security concerns for homes directly west across the canal, noting that second-story windows and elevated site grading will allow direct sightlines into neighboring backyards and windows despite the removal of rear balconies. • Potential traffic congestion on Greenfield Road, added vehicle noise, and overflow parking spilling into adjacent neighborhood streets due to insufficient guest parking or high tenant vehicle counts. • Safety risks associated with the property's proximity to Falcon Field Airport and local aircraft movements. • Reduced property setbacks and increased site utilization attempt to fit too many units onto less than two acres, requesting instead a lower-density single-story commercial or residential buffer use. Andy Funk and Michael Miller, representatives of the applicant, along with Jacob Cluff, project architect, presented updates on the proposed 30-unit multiple residence development. Mr. Funk explained that two neighborhood outreach meetings were held— one at a resident's home and another at the Red Mountain Public Library—to directly address neighbor concerns regarding privacy, height, and noise. They detailed several site modifications implemented since the previous meeting, including replacing the western view fence along the canal with a full-height CMU block privacy wall, removing second-story rear balconies to eliminate potential view corridors into neighboring yards, increasing building setbacks, and adding structural gaps between buildings to incorporate additional tree landscaping. They further noted that the team fully adopted Design Review Board recommendations by shifting to a traditional architectural style, adjusting color palettes, and modifying rooflines without increasing upper-level living space. Mr. Miller highlighted spatial context, noting that distance from proposed structures to neighboring residences across the canal ranges between 136 and 345 feet. Addressing traffic and site circulation, he stated that all access is directed onto Greenfield Road, supported by an 80-foot entry driveway to allow adequate vehicle queuing, along with two- car attached garages and 15 guest parking spaces. In response to board inquiry regarding three-story structures along Greenfield Road, Mr. Funk explained that right-of-way constraints made a compressed footprint necessary, adding that these buildings will serve as an effective acoustic buffer against arterial traffic noise. Mr. Cluff confirmed that site grading complies with FEMA regulations and stormwater will be managed via underground retention and dry wells. Boardmember Hales expressed support for three-bedroom, two-car garage rental units to address broader housing shortages, noting that residential uses generate less traffic than single-story commercial options and that the canal provides over 100 feet of separation from neighboring homes. Boardmember Wagner noted that the applicant made good-faith privacy adjustments by reorienting balconies inward toward the pool, observing that arterial corridors are the appropriate location for higher-density residential developments. Boardmember Trexler and Vice Chairperson Pitcher voiced concerns regarding the excessive number of requested base zoning modifications under the PAD overlay, as well as the overall site density along the canal. Boardmember Montez acknowledged the applicant's four-year history of design adjustments and noted the challenge of developing a long-vacant infill parcel. Chairperson Peterson expressed opposition to the introduction of three-story structures in an area lacking similar height precedent and a contradiction between the applicant's statements on strong landscaping buffers and their requested PAD modifications reducing required trees and landscape yards. o-story neighborhood context. It was moved by Boardmember Carpenter, seconded by Boardmember Montes, that case ZON21-00066 be recommended for approval. Upon tabulation of votes, it showed: AYES – Carpenter, Hales, Montes, Wagner NAYS – Peterson, Trexler, Pitcher ABSENT– Klann