Extracted text (via pymupdf_layout)
13819 characters
City Council Report Date: November 16, 2026 To: Mayor and Council Through: Scott Butler, City Manager From: Jaye O’Donnell, Economic Development Director Nick Juszczak, Sr. Project Manager Subject: A resolution making findings required by A.R.S. § 9-500.11 (Version 2) for the City to enter into a “retail development tax incentive agreement” and approving and authorizing the City Manager to enter into a development agreement that is a “retail development tax incentive agreement” under A.R.S. § 9-500.11 (Version 2), related to the development of certain improvements for a project known as “The Craftsman” on approximately 19.25 +/- acres generally located at the northwest corner of South Hawes Road and East Elliot Road. (District 6) Purpose and Recommendation The purpose of this report is to discuss and consider making findings related to a “retail development tax incentive agreement” under A.R.S. § 9-500.11 (version 2) and the approval of such an agreement as a development agreement with Martens Elliot Land LLC and Martens Elliot Retail Pads LLC (collectively, “Developer”) for a project known as “The Craftsman” (“Development Agreement”). The proposed retail development tax incentive agreement would support the upscale, chef-driven restaurant concept and the commercial portion of the project. Staff recommends the City Council approve the Resolution. Background The Craftsman is an approximately 19.25 +/- acre mixed-use development project located at the northwest corner of S. Hawes Road and Elliot Road, with a mix of commercial and residential uses (“Project”). The Project would include approximately 39,971 rentable square feet of commercial development with a minimum of 10,000 square feet of modern, upscale restaurant(s). Development of the Project requires significant investment in public infrastructure, including improvements to Hawes Road, 82nd Street, and Elliot Road. Without these improvements, the Project site would not be suitable for the proposed commercial development. 1 The proposed Development Agreement would establish the development and performance requirements for the Project including requiring the Developer to make a payment to the City in the amount of $775,142 for public improvements to Elliot Road (“Developer Public Improvement Contribution”), as the Project’s Elliot Road frontage will be completed by the City as a part of the approved Elliot Road Capital Improvement Project which began construction in October 2026; all other public improvements required for the Project are the responsibility of the Developer to construct. Provided the Developer meets the Conditions Precedent (defined below), they are eligible to be reimbursed the Developer Public Improvement Contribution as a reimbursement for eligible public infrastructure costs from transaction privilege tax revenues generated by the Project. Additionally, the Project sits within Hawes Crossing which has an extensive development agreement that was approved by the City Council in 2020 (“Hawes Crossing Development Agreement”). The proposed retail tax incentive Development Agreement does not amend in any way the Hawes Crossing Development Agreement. All terms and conditions within the Hawes Crossing Development Agreement are still in effect, including those related to development requirements. For example, in compliance with the Hawes Crossing Development Agreement, the site, zoned MX, must have 35% commercial development and 65% residential development. The Developer has worked with the Planning Department to confirm compliance on this requirement. Discussion The Project presents a significant economic benefit to the City, including job creation and increased sales (transaction privilege) tax revenue generated by construction and new commercial activity. The subject site requires a substantial investment in public infrastructure to support development, including street improvements, streetlights, water, sewer, storm drain and retention. These improvements are essential to the Project as presented to attract the type of high-quality development that will generate long-term economic value for the City. In recognition of these economic factors, the Developer and City staff are proposing to enter into the Development Agreement for the reimbursement to Developer of its Developer Public Improvement Contribution, with a maximum reimbursement of $775,142. Under the Development Agreement, the Developer would pay the Developer Public Improvement Contribution to the City which represents half of the Elliot Road Capital Improvement Project costs for the Elliot Road frontage along the Project. The Developer may be reimbursed for this payment if they meet the stipulations of the Development Agreement. The purpose of the Development Agreement is to guide the future development of the Project as a high-quality project with certain economic incentives that will help bring new tax revenue to the City. The Development Agreement includes the below major terms and conditions. 2 Public Improvements Typically the Developer is responsible for construction of the public improvements along their development’s frontage; however, in this instance, the City has a Capital Improvement Project underway that includes the Project site’s Elliot Road frontage. Therefore, in coordination with the Engineering Department, a decision was made to include the Project’s frontage in the Elliot Road Capital Improvement Project and remove the frontage from the Developer’s offsite requirements. This allows for the City to complete the infrastructure without having more than one construction project going on in the same portion of the City’s right-of-way, ensuring consistency and efficient development of the right-of-way. To help compensate the City for its construction of the Elliot Road frontage, Developer agreed to pay half the cost of the Elliot Road frontage improvements in the form of the Developer Public Improvement Contribution. As the contribution is towards the payment of public infrastructure that will be owned and controlled by the City, through the Development Agreement, the City is offering to reimburse the Developer for the Developer Public Improvement Contribution through a construction contracting and sales tax rebate of up to $775,142 (the amount of the Developer Public Improvement Contribution) that would come from taxes generated by the Project. Economic Incentive (Construction and Sales Tax Rebate) The City is proposing a performance-based tax rebate agreement with the Developer to support The Craftsman development. The rebate comes from two sources of non-dedicated (non-general fund) transaction privilege (sales) tax (“TPT”) collected by the City from the Project. With 35% of the site planned for commercial development, the City has proposed to make 35% of the TPT generated from construction of the Project eligible for reimbursement. On the retail side, the City has proposed to make 50% of the non-dedicated general TPT from taxable activities at the Project (other than construction) eligible for reimbursement. To qualify for any rebate, the Developer must meet key milestones (“Conditions Precedent”) following the effective date of the Development Agreement (“Effective Date”), including: A. Having a minimum of 10,000 square feet of modern, upscale restaurant(s) open to the public within 36 months of the Effective Date. A modern, upscale restaurant is defined in the Development Agreement as a chef-driven, full-service restaurant offering a distinctive, non-standardized dining concept, contemporary interior design, premium ingredients, and a curated menu and beverage program, and specifically excludes drive-thrus, fast- food, and quick-service restaurants. The restaurant(s) must also operate under a brand with fewer than 100 locations in the United States and not operate another location in Mesa under the same brand name within a 10-mile radius of the property. Qualifying restaurant(s) specifically exclude family-dining and conventional casual-dining establishments characterized by standardized national menus, value-oriented pricing, or a primary focus on high-volume service. B. Obtaining all necessary permits within 6 months of the Effective Date. 3 C. Completing and having the City accept the respective public improvements along S. Hawes Road and 82nd Street within 9 months of the Effective Date. D. Completing construction of the Project’s private improvements within 30 months of the Effective Date. Upon completion of the Conditions Precedent, the Developer may receive as a reimbursement from eligible TPT up to 100% of the Developer Public Improvement Contribution. The period for payment of the reimbursement is 10 years following the completion of the Conditions Precedent; however, Developer is eligible to receive towards the reimbursement the applicable construction and general TPT collected by the City following the Effective Date but prior to the completion of the Conditions Precedent. If the Developer fails to meet any required milestones of the Conditions Precedent, Developer will be ineligible to receive any portion of the reimbursement for the Developer Public Improvement Contribution. The Development Agreement supports the significant upfront investment required for the public infrastructure necessary to attract a high-quality restaurant(s) that will bring long-term economic benefits to the City. Required Findings: A.R.S. § 9-500.11 (version 2) A.R.S. § 9-500.11 (Version 2), entitled “Expenditures for economic development; requirements; definitions” (“A.R.S. § 9-500.11”), allows the governing body of a city or town to appropriate and spend public monies for and in connection with economic development activities. The Development Agreement, if entered into by the City, meets the definition of a “retail development tax incentive agreement” in A.R.S. § 9 500.11(M)(6). A.R.S. § 9-500.11(D) and (E) require the City Council, by at least a two-thirds vote and prior to entering into the Development Agreement, to find that: (i) “the proposed tax incentive is anticipated to raise more revenue than the amount of the incentive within the duration of the agreement”; and (ii) “[t]hat in the absence of a tax incentive, the retail business facility or similar retail business facility would not locate in the city or town in the same time, place or manner.” Pursuant to A.R.S. § 9-500.11(H), a report prepared by an independent third party was provided to the City Council along with this Council Report verifying that the proposed tax incentive in the Development Agreement is anticipated to raise more revenue than the amount of the incentive within the duration of the agreement. Specifically, the report projects that the Project is anticipated to generate $3,200,000 in gross City tax revenue during construction and over the first ten years of operation, showing that the projected revenue to the City is significantly greater than the reimbursement of the $775,142 Developer Public Improvement Contribution; the City would retain an estimated $2,400,000 in tax revenue over the designated time period. Also of note, the independent third-party analysis projects that the Project could create an estimated 170 new jobs on site. 4 Further, Developer’s representative provided information confirming that without the proposed incentive (reimbursement) in the Development Agreement, the Project would not be able to locate in Mesa at the same time, place, or manner—primarily due to the commercial project economics not allowing for capital partners to support the commercial portion of the development, resulting in the Project not being able to move forward as presented. Additionally, with the incentive provided by the Development Agreement, the Developer can target a more local, unique retail operator that the City residents are asking for. Overall, (a) the findings of the economic impact analysis conducted by Applied Economics confirm that the amount of tax revenues raised by the proposed development will be more than the sales tax reimbursement incentive to the Developer; and (b) Developer confirmed that the development of the Project would not have occurred in the same time, place or manner without the tax incentive. Alternatives The following alternatives are presented for consideration: APPROVAL OF THE DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT Approval of the Resolution would approve the findings required by A.R.S. § 9-500.11 and approve the Development Agreement. NO ACTION OR NOT APPROVING OF THE DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT If the City Council chooses not to approve the Resolution, the required findings that are a prerequisite to entering into the Development Agreement will not be made and the City will not be able to enter into a retail development tax incentive agreement with Developer as proposed. Staff recommends the City Council approve the Resolution. Fiscal Impact The proposed retail tax reimbursement will not exceed $775,142 and is intended to cover the Developer Public Improvement Contribution for the Elliot Road improvements that will be developed, owned, and controlled by the City. As previously noted, the independent third-party analysis required by A.R.S. § 9-500.11 and conducted by Applied Economics indicates the Project is projected to generate $3,200,000 in City tax revenue during construction and the first ten years of operations, of which the Developer will be eligible to receive a maximum reimbursement of $775,142 if all the Conditions Precedent are completed; however, the actual amount received by the Developer will depend upon the eligible tax collected by the City. Coordinated With 5 The Office of Economic Development worked closely with the City Attorney's Office, Development Services, Engineering, and Transportation on this project. 6