Extracted text (via pymupdf_layout)
20287 characters
ECONOMIC AND REVENUE IMPACTS OF THE CRAFTSMAN CITY OF MESA, AZ OCTOBER 2026 11209 N. Tatum Boulevard, Suite 225 * Phoenix, AZ 85028 * 602-765-2400 tel * 602-765-2407 fax TABLE OF CONTENTS 1.0 INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................................ 1 1.1 PROJECT DESCRIPTION ............................................................................................ 1 1.2 DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT TERMS ....................................................................... 2 2.0 IMPACT SUMMARY ....................................................................................................... 3 3.0 ECONOMIC IMPACT ANALYSIS ...................................................................................... 4 3.1 CONSTRUCTION IMPACTS ..................................................................................... 4 3.2 OPERATIONS IMPACTS .......................................................................................... 4 4.0 TAX REVENUE IMPACTS ................................................................................................. 6 4.1 GROSS CITY TAX REVENUES ................................................................................... 6 4.2 RETAIL SALES TAX INCENTIVE ................................................................................ 7 4.3 SUMMARY ............................................................................................................. 8 ii 1.0 INTRODUCTION The City of Mesa retained Applied Economics to perform an economic and revenue impact analysis of The Craftsman, a proposed mixed-use development that will be part of Hawes Crossing. The Project will be located on a 19.25 +/-acre site at the northwest corner of Hawes Road and Elliott Road, between Hawes Road and the 82nd Street alignment. The Craftsman will provide a unified neighborhood concept with a mix of residential and nonresidential uses. This analysis focuses on the commercial development only. The Project would require roadway improvements on the adjacent portion of Elliott Road. The City will enter into a development agreement with Martens Elliot Land, LLC and Martens Elliott Retail PADS, LLC. The development agreement details how non-dedicated sales tax revenues (those sales tax revenues that are unrestricted and not dedicated to a specific purpose) will be used to reimburse a portion of the cost of developer’s contribution towards eligible public infrastructure improvements required for this development. Restricted sales tax revenues (those sales taxes dedicated to a specific purpose), although collected by the City, will not be eligible for reimbursement. This analysis includes estimates of the economic impacts of construction and operations of the tenant businesses, as well as the projected gross and net tax revenues to the City of Mesa over ten years. The objective of this analysis is to quantify the value that this Project could create, and to understand the value of infrastructure reimbursements compared to the future tax revenue stream generated by the Project. 1.1 Project Description The development agreement requires at least 39,000 square feet of commercial improvements, of which 10,000 square feet would be full-service restaurants, to qualify for the reimbursement. The remaining 29,000 square feet would include a mix of retail, office, quick-service restaurants, and services. This Project is part of a larger development, and 65% of the site will be apartments based on the conditions of a previous development agreement. Some of the commercial space will be on the first floor of the apartment buildings, and some will be freestanding. Based on the site plan for the Project, this analysis includes 39,971 square feet with 15,238 square feet of office space, 9,495 square feet of retail and services, 5,238 square feet of drive-thru limited-service restaurants, and 10,000 square feet of full-service restaurants. The development timeline is intentionally conservative to align with the maximum timeline in the development agreement. Total estimated hard and soft construction costs are $121.2 million, including $95.5 million in hard construction costs and $25.7 million in soft costs. Commercial hard costs, estimated at $33.4 million or 35% of total hard costs, form the basis for construction sales tax. The Craftsman could create an estimated 170 new jobs on-site, assuming an average occupancy rate of 90% to 100% (Figure 1). Estimated sales per square foot are $350 for the retail space, $750 for the full-service restaurants, and $700 for quick-service restaurants. The analysis assumes 10% of the non-restaurant space, or 2,900 square feet, would be service businesses that do not generate sales tax. There would be additional taxable sales associated with leases on the commercial space based on a lease rate of $45 per square foot. 1 FIGURE 1 DEVELOPMENT ASSUMPTIONS Rentable Estimated Taxable Square Feet Jobs Occupancy Sales PSF Lease Rate Retail/Services 9,495 19 90% $350 $45.00 Office 15,238 55 90% $0 $45.00 Full-Service Restaurants 10,000 66 100% $750 $45.00 Quick-Service Restaurants 5,238 30 90% $700 $45.00 Total 39,971 170 na na $45.00 1.2 Development Agreement Terms The development agreement states that the developer must obtain all necessary permits within six months of the effective date of the agreement, complete construction and dedicate the Project Public Improvements identified below within nine months of the effective date, complete construction of private improvements within 30 months, and the qualifying restaurant space must be open to the public within 36 months of the effective date of the agreement. There are specific requirements for the qualifying restaurants. They must be upscale full-service restaurants with fewer than 100 locations in the United States, and no other locations within a ten-mile radius of the property. The qualifying restaurant space must be fully occupied for five full years from the reimbursement commencement date (the date in which the conditions precedent for reimbursement are all met). The development is unique in that the City will construct the public improvements along Elliott Road, and the developer would pay a Developer Public Improvement Contribution of $775,142 (half of the total cost) within nine months of the effective date of the agreement as part of the reimbursement conditions. Once the developer completes all the requirements outlined in the development agreement, they would qualify for a rebate of developer’s contribution to the Elliot Road infrastructure from a portion of the eligible construction and general sales tax up to a Reimbursement Cap of $775,142. In addition to the Developer Public Improvement Contribution, the developer will construct Project Public Improvements on Hawes Road and 82nd Street that are not eligible for reimbursement. The developer would be eligible for a reimbursement of 35% of the non-dedicated portion of construction sales tax on the commercial development. In addition, the reimbursement would include 50% of the non-dedicated sales tax on general taxable activities within the Project. The reimbursement period would extend for up to ten years from the reimbursement commencement date, or until the Reimbursement Cap is paid in full. 2 2.0 IMPACT SUMMARY The construction of this commercial development could create a variety of economic and fiscal impacts to the City. These impacts are based on the proposed types of commercial uses. The Project could generate $3.2 million in City sales taxes during construction and in the first ten years of operations based on the assumptions used in this analysis. The development would require off-site public improvements on the portion of Elliot Road adjacent to the site constructed by the City that the developer will contribute costs towards, including two lanes of roadway with utilities, signals, and streetlights. The developer could be reimbursed for up to $775,142 of its contribution to the public improvement costs for Elliot Road from construction and retail sales taxes generated by the Project from the beginning of construction through the first ten years of operations. The economic impacts of the tenant business operations in The Craftsman could total $362.1 million over ten years. The retail, service, and restaurant space in the development could directly support an estimated 170 jobs at build-out with a direct wage impact of $8.0 million per year. The commercial tenants could also support 74 estimated indirect and induced jobs and $5.1 million in annual payroll at other local businesses in Mesa and throughout the county. These indirect and induced jobs are the result of local supplier purchases made by the tenants in the development, as well as local spending by employees. The construction activity associated with this development could also create economic impacts. In this analysis, construction starts in 2027 and must be complete by June 2029, based on the terms of the development agreement. The commercial construction expenditures of $33.4 million could support 150 estimated direct jobs at the site and 117 indirect and induced jobs at other local businesses. Construction activity could create a total economic impact of $59.6 million during the construction period. The Craftsman commercial development could generate new revenues for the City from sales taxes on construction, retail/restaurant sales, and leases. The Project could also create a significant number of new jobs, generating indirect and induced economic impacts at businesses in Mesa and throughout the county. 3 3.0 ECONOMIC IMPACT ANALYSIS The projected economic impacts from the commercial portion of The Craftsman include both one-time construction impacts and operations impacts. This analysis quantifies the impacts in terms of direct, indirect, and induced jobs, labor income, and output generated by the development. Economic impacts measure the effects of economic stimuli or expenditures in the local economy. Direct impacts include the jobs, labor income or payroll, and output generated by the development. Indirect impacts quantify the increase in jobs, labor income, and output at businesses in Mesa that sell goods and services to businesses in The Craftsman. Induced impacts quantify the increase in jobs, labor income, and output supported by increased consumer demand from employees. The economic impacts are for information only and are not considered in the incentive analysis. 3.1 Construction Impacts Estimated hard construction costs for the commercial development are $33.4 million. Construction is expected to start in 2027 and be completed by June 2029, based on the maximum timeline in the development agreement. The multiplier effects of this construction spending could result in a total increase in economic output in Mesa of $59.6 million (Figure 2). The estimated 150 direct jobs and 117 indirect and induced jobs supported by this construction activity could generate $22.4 million in total labor income during the construction period. FIGURE 2 CONSTRUCTION IMPACTS Direct Impacts Total Impacts Construction Labor Labor Expenditures Jobs Income Output Jobs Income 2027 $13,370,000 61 $5,593,589 $23,855,747 107 $8,964,055 2028 $13,370,000 60 $5,593,589 $23,855,747 107 $8,964,055 2029 $6,685,000 30 $2,796,795 $11,927,873 53 $4,482,027 Total $33,425,000 150 $13,983,973 $59,639,367 267 $22,410,137 Note: Construction costs include public improvements, and developer hard costs for multifamily, integrated commercial and stand-alone commercial. 3.2 Operations Impacts Once construction is completed, the tenant businesses in the development could create economic impacts through their operations, as well as through supplier purchases and employee spending. Direct impacts include jobs, labor income, and output at commercial tenants within the Project. These businesses could make local supplier purchases, generating indirect impacts, 4 and their employees could make consumer purchases, generating induced impacts, that are captured in the total impact estimates. The retail, restaurant, and service businesses in the commercial development could directly support 170 estimated jobs and $8.0 million in direct annual labor income (Figure 3). The multiplier effect of this increase in jobs and labor income could result in total economic output of $362.1 million over ten years, 244 direct and indirect jobs, and $131.6 million in labor income. FIGURE 3 ANNUAL ECONOMIC IMPACTS Direct Impacts Total Impacts Year Output Jobs Labor Income Output Jobs Labor Income 2029 $5,006,592 170 $2,006,804 $9,051,685 207 $3,290,288 2030 $20,026,368 170 $8,027,217 $36,206,738 244 $13,161,150 2031 $20,026,368 170 $8,027,217 $36,206,738 244 $13,161,150 2032 $20,026,368 170 $8,027,217 $36,206,738 244 $13,161,150 2033 $20,026,368 170 $8,027,217 $36,206,738 244 $13,161,150 2034 $20,026,368 170 $8,027,217 $36,206,738 244 $13,161,150 2035 $20,026,368 170 $8,027,217 $36,206,738 244 $13,161,150 2036 $20,026,368 170 $8,027,217 $36,206,738 244 $13,161,150 2037 $20,026,368 170 $8,027,217 $36,206,738 244 $13,161,150 2038 $20,026,368 170 $8,027,217 $36,206,738 244 $13,161,150 2037* $15,019,776 170 $6,020,413 $27,155,054 244 $9,870,863 Total $200,263,675 170 $80,272,174 $362,067,380 244 $131,611,501 Note: 2037 represents a partial year based on the term of the development agreeement. The differences between direct and total economic impacts are called multiplier effects and include the secondary impacts of vendor expenditures and employee spending. Multiplier effects are a way of representing the larger economic effects on the local economy. The multiplier effects quantify how an increase in output (loosely defined as the cost of labor, plus the cost of supplies, plus profits) translates into an increase in jobs and labor income. In essence, the multiplier effect represents the recycling of local spending. This recycling process creates new business opportunities. The multipliers used in this analysis are from IMPLAN, a nationally recognized vendor of economic impact software, and are specific to the economy of Mesa. The new economic activity generated directly and indirectly by the Project could support a total local population of about 170 people. The supported population includes families of direct employees, as well as families of indirect and induced workers. This supported population estimate assumes that 50 percent of the employees would work and live in Mesa, based on data from the Maricopa County Rideshare Survey. 5 4.0 TAX REVENUE IMPACTS The Craftsman could generate new local tax revenues, primarily from taxable retail sales and leases. The Project could generate $3.2 million in estimated gross sales tax revenues to the City of Mesa from 2027 to mid-year 2037. This includes construction only in 2027 and 2028, and the first businesses opening mid-year 2029. The reimbursement term extends for ten years, or mid- year 2037. 4.1 Gross City Tax Revenues There are three primary sources of sales taxes: construction, retail sales, and commercial leases. The Project could generate one-time City sales taxes from new construction estimated at $0.4 million in 2027 through 2029, including dedicated and non-dedicated taxes (Figure 4). Estimated non-dedicated and dedicated sales tax revenues from leases and taxable retail and restaurant sales total $2.8 million over ten years. Taxable sales and leases include 2% annual inflation. Construction and on-going sales taxes combined could total $3.2 million over ten years. FIGURE 4 GROSS CITY TAX REVENUE IMPACTS Construction Sales Tax Retail Sales Tax Non- Dedicated Dedicated @ Funds @ Non-Dedicated Dedicated Funds Gross City 1.2% 0.8% @ 1.2% @ 0.8% Sales Tax 2027 $104,286 $69,524 $0 $0 $173,810 2028 $104,286 $69,524 $0 $0 $173,810 2029 $52,143 $34,762 $56,373 $37,582 $180,861 2030 $0 $0 $192,609 $128,406 $321,015 2031 $0 $0 $197,424 $131,616 $329,040 2032 $0 $0 $202,360 $134,907 $337,266 2033 $0 $0 $207,419 $138,279 $345,698 2034 $0 $0 $212,604 $141,736 $354,341 2035 $0 $0 $217,919 $145,280 $363,199 2036 $0 $0 $223,367 $148,912 $372,279 2037 (Partial Yr) $0 $0 $171,714 $114,476 $286,190 Total $260,715 $173,810 $1,681,790 $1,121,194 $3,237,509 Note: Taxables sales include 2% annual inflation. 6 4.2 Retail Sales Tax Incentive The City would construct roadway improvements along Elliott Road at an estimated cost of $1,550,285. The developer would contribute $775,142 to the City by July 2027. If the developer meets the conditions outlined in the development agreement, they could be reimbursed for this contribution. The development agreement includes provisions for a sales tax reimbursement equal to 35 percent of non-dedicated construction sales tax (1.2 percent) for the Project. The reimbursement also includes 50 percent of non-dedicated sales taxes (1.2 percent) generated by the commercial development. The maximum reimbursement would be equal to $775,142 over a period of up to ten years. The reimbursement period for construction sales tax begins when the Project public improvements and private improvements are complete, and the qualifying restaurant space is fully occupied and open to the public. This analysis assumes that both the retail and qualifying restaurant space would be open by October 2029. A.R.S. 9-500.11 (D) requires that any proposed tax incentive is anticipated to raise more revenues than the amount of the incentive within the duration of the agreement. We have reviewed the development agreement and prepared an analysis of projected taxable activities and the future sales tax revenue stream to the City during the reimbursement period. Based on our review, we believe that the Project would generate a significantly greater amount of sales tax revenues than the total amount of the reimbursement. The amount of tax revenues generated will likely be sufficient to reach the estimated maximum reimbursement of $775,142 within ten years from completion of construction (Figure 5). FIGURE 5 UNRESTRICTED CITY SALES TAX AND PROJECTED REIMBURSEMENT SCHEDULE City of Mesa Gross Non-Dedicated Sales Tax Reimbursement Construction Retail Sales Total Schedule 2027 $104,286 $0 $104,286 $0 2028 $104,286 $0 $104,286 $0 2029 $52,143 $56,373 $108,516 $119,437 2030 $0 $192,609 $192,609 $96,305 2031 $0 $197,424 $197,424 $98,712 2032 $0 $202,360 $202,360 $101,180 2033 $0 $207,419 $207,419 $103,709 2034 $0 $212,604 $212,604 $106,302 2035 $0 $217,919 $217,919 $108,960 2036 $0 $223,367 $223,367 $40,537 2037 (Partial Yr) $0 $171,714 $171,714 $0 Total $260,715 $1,681,790 $1,942,505 $775,142 Note: Taxables sales include 2% annual inflation. 7 The $775,142 maximum reimbursement covers half the cost of specific public infrastructure improvements as outlined in the development agreement. The developer must pay the Developer Public Improvement Contribution prior to any sales tax reimbursement. A.R.S. 42-6010 requires that sales tax incentives offered to retail businesses are only for reimbursement for public infrastructure dedicated to, and accepted and controlled upon completion, by a state or local government entity. All public improvements described above would meet these requirements, and the cost of such improvements forms the basis for the reimbursement amount per the development agreement. 4.3 Summary The proposed commercial development described in this analysis could create economic impacts and new tax revenues for the City of Mesa. The economic benefits include the impacts of construction as well as on-going operations. The development could create jobs and payroll at tenant businesses within the Project, and support additional economic activity at other local businesses in Mesa. The Craftsman is projected to generate $3.2 million in City sales tax revenues during construction and over the first ten years of operations. The development agreement allows for reimbursement of up to $775,142 in public improvement costs, with the City retaining $2.4 million in dedicated and non-dedicated sales tax revenues. Thus, the Project will raise significantly more revenues within the term of the development agreement than the amount of the reimbursement. 8