Extracted text (via pymupdf_layout)
116005 characters
WHEN RECORDED RETURN TO:
City of Mesa
Attn: Real Estate Services
20 E. Main Street
Mesa, Arizona 85201
===============================================================
DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT
===============================================================
by and among
CITY OF MESA, ARIZONA,
an Arizona municipal corporation;
MARTENS ELLIOT LAND LLC,
an Arizona limited liability company;
and
MARTENS ELLIOT RETAIL PADS LLC,
an Arizona limited liability company
===============================================================
________________, 2026
===============================================================
{00624621.1}
This Development Agreement (this “Agreement”) is made to be effective as of the ____ day of
_______________, 2026 (the “Effective Date”), by and among:
CITY OF MESA, ARIZONA, an Arizona municipal corporation (the “City”);
MARTENS ELLIOT LAND LLC, an Arizona limited liability company (“Elliot Land
Owner”); and
MARTENS ELLIOT RETAIL PADS LLC, an Arizona limited liability company (“Elliot
Retail Owner”).
Each of the City, Elliot Land Owner and Elliot Retail Owner may be referred to in this
Agreement as a “Party,” and collectively as the “Parties.” Elliot Land Owner and Elliot Retail
Owner may be referred to collectively in this Agreement as “Developer”, or individually as a
“Co-Developer”)
RECITALS
A. Elliot Land Owner owns unimproved real property consisting of approximately
17.54 +/- gross acres of land, at the northwest corner of S. Hawes Road and E. Elliott Road
between the future S. 82nd Street and S. Hawes that is located in the corporate boundary of the
City and which is legally described in Exhibit A-1 (the “Elliot Land Property”).
B. Elliot Retail Owner (which is an Affiliate of Elliot Land Owner) owns
unimproved real property adjacent to the Elliot Land Property consisting of approximately
1.71+/- gross acres of land, also located at the northwest corner of S. Hawes Road and E. Elliott
Road between the future S. 82nd Street and S. Hawes Road that is located in the corporate
boundary of the City and which is legally described in Exhibit A-2 (the “Elliot Retail
Property”). The Elliot Land Property and the Elliot Retail Property are collectively referred to
herein as the “Property” which is shown in the final plat attached as Exhibit A-3.
C. Developer proposes to develop the Property as “The Craftsman,” a vertical
mixed-use development built on a unified neighborhood concept consisting of 65% +/- of the site
area allocated for multi-family use and 35% +/- of the site area allocated for mixed and dedicated
retail and commercial use (collectively, the “Project”), all as generally depicted on the approved
site plan attached to this Agreement as Exhibit B. Supporting the Project will be a base of new
public infrastructure, including new roadway improvements on future S. 82nd Street and S.
Hawes Road that Developer is responsible to construct.
D. The Property is zoned as Mixed-Use with a Planned Area Development Overlay
(MX-PAD). The land uses for the Project described above that are contemplated by this
Agreement are consistent with the City’s zoning and land use ordinances (as amended from time
to time, collectively, “Zoning”), the City’s General Plan (as amended from time to time,
“General Plan”) and this Agreement.
E. The City Council now finds and determines that development of the Project will
result in planning, infrastructure, economic and other public benefits to the City and its residents
by, among other things: (a) providing for the construction of public improvements and
{00624621.1} 1
infrastructure in and around the Project; (b) providing for a planned and orderly development of
the Project consistent with and advancing the goals of the City’s General Plan and the Zoning;
(c) increasing transaction privilege tax revenues collected by the City arising from or relating to
both the public and private improvements to be constructed on the Project, and the operations on
and business conducted from the Project; (d) creating new jobs and otherwise supplementing the
economic welfare of residents of the City; and (e) enhancing the quality of life for the City’s
residents by providing more opportunities for residential housing, shopping, and dining.
F. The City, as a part of its City of Mesa Project No. CP0982 (Elliot Road: Eastern
Maricopa Floodway to Ellsworth) capital improvement project (“CIP Project”) is constructing
public infrastructure along Elliot Road, including the portion of Elliot Road with frontage
immediately adjacent to the Property as shown in Exhibit C (such portion of the Elliot Road
improvements on the frontage of the Property that represent the half-street improvements are
hereafter referred to “Elliot Road Improvements”). If the Elliot Road Improvements were not
included in the CIP Project, Developer would be responsible under the City Code for
constructing such improvements. In lieu of Developer expending its own funds for the
construction of the Elliot Road Improvements, Developer will pay the City the amount of money
representing one-half of the City’s CIP Project costs for the construction of the Elliot Road
Improvements (“Developer Public Improvement Contribution”, see also Section 3.2.1). The
Developer Public Improvement Contribution may be reimbursed to Developer in accordance
with A.R.S. § 42-6010 as costs for public infrastructure accepted and controlled by the City if
certain conditions precedent are met by Developer as described herein.
G. Developer and the City desire to enter into this Agreement related to the
development of the Property to provide a program for reimbursement of the Developer Public
Improvement Contribution, solely from a portion of the transaction privilege taxes generated
from the Project. This Agreement constitutes a “Development Agreement” within the meaning
of A.R.S. § 9-500.05, and a “Retail Development Tax Incentive Agreement” within the meaning
of A.R.S. § 9-500.11, that will be recorded in the Official Records against the interests of
Developer in the Project to give notice to all persons of its existence and of the intent that the
burdens and benefits contained in this Agreement be binding on, and inure to the benefit of
Developer and the City and their respective successors in interest and assigns.
H. In accordance with A.R.S. § 9-500.11(D)(2), Developer represents to the City
that, in the absence of the tax reimbursement incentive offered to Developer under this
Agreement, Developer would not locate the Project in Mesa, Arizona, in the same time, place or
manner.
I. As required by A.R.S. § 9-500.11(K), the City Council adopted a Notice of Intent
to enter into this Agreement on October 26, 2026, a copy of which is on file with the City
Clerk’s Office as Resolution No. 12584.
J. As required by A.R.S. § 9-500.11(D), the City Council now finds that: (i) the
sales tax incentive contemplated by this Agreement is anticipated to raise more revenue than the
amount of the incentive during the duration of this Agreement, which was verified by an
independent Third Party not financed or selected by the Developer; and (ii) in the absence of the
{00624621.1} 2
tax incentive offered to Developer, neither the Project nor a similar development would locate in
Mesa, Arizona, in the same time, place or manner as contemplated by the Project.
AGREEMENT
1. Index of Defined Terms. In this Agreement, capitalized words and phrases are
to be construed as they are defined in the Index of Defined Terms following the signature pages
(and which Index is fully incorporated into this Agreement for all purposes), unless a different
meaning is expressly and unambiguously required from their context. In addition, unless
otherwise expressly limited (that is, as being references to A.R.S., U.S.C. or to the City Code),
references to sections, exhibits and schedules mean Sections of, and Exhibits and Schedules to,
this Agreement.
2. Scope and Regulation of the Project.
2.1 Hawes Crossing DA. The Property is subject to a development agreement
dated April 29, 2020, recorded in the Official Records of Maricopa County as Recording No.
2020-00381318 (“Hawes Crossing DA”). This Agreement is separate from and subordinate to
the Hawes Crossing DA and does not amend or modify its terms and conditions. In the event of a
conflict between this Agreement and the Hawes Crossing DA, the Hawes Crossing DA controls.
2.2 Compliance with Applicable Laws. Developer agrees that the design,
construction and development of the Project, including the Developer’s Public Improvements,
will comply with the terms of the Hawes Crossing DA, this Agreement, and Applicable Laws.
All Applicable Laws and terms of the Hawes Crossing DA in effect at the time of development
of any portion of the Property will apply to the development of the Project. Developer shall pay
all applicable application, permit, inspection, capacity and other fees related to or required in
connection with the development and construction of the Project (each, a “Fee,” and collectively,
“Fees”) at the City’s standard rates, and prior to the issuance of any permit or the scheduling of
any inspection.
2.3 City Review and Approval of Plans. Developer must design, develop, and
construct the Project in accordance with plans submitted by Developer and approved by City,
including the approved site plan and design requirements for the Project, as well as the
requirements of Design Review Board Case No. DRB23-00342, all as amended from time to
time with City approval. The development and construction of the Project are subject to the
City’s normal and customary planning, engineering, and building plan submittal, review,
approval, and inspection processes and Fees. The City will use reasonable efforts to facilitate its
regulatory processes, including use permits, design review, building permits, and inspection
processes, within the time normally associated with the City’s regulatory processes then in
effect.
3. Public Improvements.
3.1 Developer’s Public Improvements. In connection with its development of
the Project, Developer must plan, design, construct and dedicate to the City the public
infrastructure required for the Project by the City Code, including the roadway improvements
required for S. 82nd Street and S. Hawes Road including, curb gutter, sidewalk, pavement,
{00624621.1} 3
streetlights (on S. Hawes only), and ITS quad ducts, traffic signals, storm drain, and water and
sewer where required (such public improvements being referred to hereafter as the “Project
Public Improvements”), except for the Elliot Road Improvements which are the responsibility of
the City to construct subject to Section 3.2. For water and sewer lines that are part of the Project
Public Improvements, Developer has the right, in accordance with the City’s standard policies,
procedures, and conditions to utilize a “Utility Buy-in Program, Private Line Agreement” as set
forth in City Code Section 9-6-5(C)(3)(e)(ii). No portion of the Project Public Improvements or
any public infrastructure or other improvements existing or to be constructed on or within the
Project is eligible or intended for Reimbursement under the terms of this Agreement except for
the Developer Public Improvement Contribution provided by Developer to City for the Elliot
Road Improvements.
3.1.1 Dedication, Acceptance, and Maintenance. When the Project
Public Improvements are Completed in accordance with the requirements of this Agreement and
Applicable Laws, Developer must dedicate to the City, and the City will accept and control, the
Project Public Improvements; however, the City’s acceptance of the Project Public
Improvements will be conditioned upon such reasonable and customary conditions as the City
may impose, including a two (2) year (from the date the Project Public Improvement, any
component thereof, or the work of any specific trade or contractor regarding the Project Public
Improvement, as applicable, is Completed) warranty of workmanship, materials, and equipment
(see Section 3.1.2 for more information). Upon acceptance of the Project Public Improvements
by the City: (a) the Project Public Improvements will become public facilities and property of the
City; and (b) all subsequent maintenance, replacement, or repairs of the Project Public
Improvements will be the responsibility of the City to complete except for landscaping, which
will remain the responsibility of Developer to maintain, replace, and repair in accordance with
the City Code, but the City does not waive any rights at law or in equity it may have related to
maintenance, replacement, or repair.
3.1.2 Risk of Loss. Developer assumes the risk of any and all loss,
damage, or claim to any portion of the Project Public Improvements unless and until title to the
Project Public Improvements is accepted by and transferred to the City. At the time title to the
Project Public Improvements is accepted by and transferred to the City by dedication deed, plat
recordation, or otherwise, Developer will, to the extent allowed by law, assign to the City any
unexpired warranties relating to the design, construction, or composition of such Public
Improvements. Acceptance of any Project Public Improvements by the City will be conditioned
on the City’s receipt of a two (2) year warranty of workmanship, materials, and equipment;
provided, however, any such warranty may be provided by Developer’s contractors or
subcontractors directly to the City and are not required from Developer, and will extend from the
date any Public Improvement, any component thereof, or the work of any specific trade or
contractor regarding the Public Improvement, as applicable, is Completed.
3.2 Elliot Road Improvements.
3.2.1 Amount of Developer Public Improvement Contribution. The
amount of the Developer Public Improvement Contribution is $775,142.00, which the Parties
agree represents one half of the City’s CIP Project costs for the construction of the Elliot Road
Improvements.
{00624621.1} 4
3.2.2 Construction by City; Developer Public Improvement Costs. The
City will design, bid, and construct the Elliot Road Improvements in compliance with Applicable
Laws, including Title 34 of A.R.S. and the City’s procurement and public bidding procedures.
Developer will reimburse the City for a portion of the costs of the Elliot Road Improvements by
paying the City the Developer Public Improvement Contribution by the deadline set forth below.
The Elliot Road Improvements will be constructed according to the schedule established for the
CIP Project, which the City may modify from time to time in its sole and absolute discretion. As
of the Effective Date, the letter of acceptance for completion of the entire CIP Project anticipates
project completion to be July 2028. This date is an estimate and does not establish a binding
completion deadline. The City will work in good faith with its contractor to determine whether
the CIP Project can be phased to allow the Elliot Road Improvements to be completed earlier in
the CIP Project schedule. The City does not guarantee that such phasing will occur or that the
Elliot Road Improvements will be completed by any particular time in the CIP Project schedule.
The Elliot Road Improvements will be public facilities owned and controlled by the City, and
Developer’s payment of the Developer Public Improvement Contribution or any portion thereof
will not confer any ownership interest or other rights in the Elliot Road Improvements. For
clarity, the Parties acknowledge that, because the City is constructing the Elliot Road
Improvements through the CIP Project, those improvements are not Infrastructure Improvements
that Developer is required to construct as a condition of Frame Inspections under the Hawes
Crossing DA (as those terms are defined therein).
4. Private Improvements.
4.1 General. In order for Developer to be eligible for Reimbursement of its
Developer Public Improvement Contribution, Developer must meet the Reimbursement
Conditions set forth in Section 5, including the completion of the Private Improvements in
Section 4.2 and the Restaurant Occupancy Minimum in Section 4.3. Further, although the
Private Improvements are described in this Agreement as distinct components of the Project,
Developer agrees and acknowledges that the Private Improvements include all ancillary and
appurtenant improvements required by the City Code in connection with the development and
construction of the Private Improvements, such as drives and roadways, walkways, private utility
infrastructure, lighting and landscaping.
4.2 Private Improvements. Developer must construct the following non-public
improvements within the Project (the “Private Improvements”) to be eligible for
Reimbursement of its Developer Public Improvement Contribution retail: commercial space on
the Property that contains a minimum of 39,000 rentable square feet under roof (“Commercial
Area”), that includes a minimum of 10,000 rentable square feet of Qualifying Restaurant.
4.3 Restaurant Occupancy Minimum; Qualifying Restaurant. 10,000 rentable
square feet under roof of the Commercial Area must be occupied by one or more Qualifying
Restaurants that receive their final certificate of occupancy and are open to the public
(“Restaurant Occupancy Minimum”). To be a “Qualifying Restaurant” counted towards the
Restaurant Occupancy Minimum, a restaurant must meet all the criteria in this Section 4.3
below.
(a) The location must be a modern, upscale restaurant, defined as a
{00624621.1} 5
chef-driven, Full-Service Restaurant offering a distinctive, non-standardized dining concept,
contemporary interior design, premium ingredients, and a curated menu and beverage program.
A “Full-Service Restaurant” is defined as a restaurant where patrons are seated and served food
and beverages by wait staff for on-premises consumption, and specifically excludes drive-thrus,
fast-food, and quick-service restaurants, except that a Full-Service Restaurant may include an
accessory counter where customers order, pay for, and pick up food or beverages without table
service so long as the counter is located within and operated as part of the Full-Service
Restaurant and may not constitute a separate restaurant use.
(b) The restaurant operates under a brand with fewer than 100
locations in the United States as of the date a lease is executed for the location at the Property.
(c) The restaurant does not operate another location in Mesa under the
same brand name within a 10-Mile Radius of the Property as of the date the lease is executed for
the location at the Property. “10-Mile Radius” means the geographic area located within 10
miles of the Property, measured in a straight line from the nearest boundary of the Property to the
nearest boundary of the applicable parcel or lot being evaluated.
(d) Qualifying Restaurant specifically excludes family-dining and
conventional casual-dining establishments characterized by standardized national menus, value-
oriented pricing, or a primary focus on high-volume service.
(e) Qualifying Restaurant specifically includes a modern, upscale
restaurant concept that incorporates an accessory gourmet market, specialty food and beverage
counter, beverage shop, or other curated retail component, and such retail square footage of the
restaurant location will be counted towards the Restaurant Occupancy Minimum.
4.4 Restaurant Minimum Occupancy Five-Year Requirement. The Restaurant
Occupancy Minimum must be met for a period of five (5) years beginning from the
Reimbursement Commencement Date (the “Restaurant Occupancy Term”), and Developer
must consistently and without interruption maintain the Restaurant Occupancy Minimum during
the full Restaurant Occupancy Term.
5. Reimbursement of Developer Public Improvement Contribution. Based on
the findings of the City Council, including those described in Recital E and Recital J, and in
consideration of (a) Developer’s constructing or causing to be constructed the Project Public
Improvements, and then conveying the Completed Project Public Improvements to the City, (b)
Developer’s timely satisfying all of the Reimbursement Conditions, (c) Developer not having an
uncured Event of Default, and (d) Developer’s satisfying all other conditions of this Agreement,
the City will reimburse Developer for the Developer Public Improvement Contribution from the
Eligible Sales Tax collected by the City derived from activities and operations on the Property
(“Reimbursement”), up to the value of the Developer Public Improvement Contribution.
5.1 Reimbursement Conditions.
5.1.1 Conditions Precedent for Reimbursement. The Reimbursement
will be paid to Developer for the Developer Public Improvement Contribution as permitted under
{00624621.1} 6
Applicable Laws, including A.R.S. § 9-500.11 and A.R.S. § 42-6010, for Developer’s
contribution towards the Elliot Road Improvements constructed by the City. As conditions
precedent to Developer’s receipt of any portion of the Reimbursement, Developer must have
satisfied all the below on or before the dates listed, subject only to Permitted Extensions and
Enforced Delay (each, a “Reimbursement Condition,” and collectively, the “Reimbursement
Conditions”):
(a) Building Permits. Developer obtains all the required
building permits from the City for the construction of the Project, including the Project Public
Improvements and the Private Improvements, no later than six (6) months after the Effective
Date.
(b) Project Public Improvements. Developer must Complete
Construction and convey ownership to the City of the Project Public Improvements no later than
nine (9) months after the Effective Date, with each such conveyance including an assignment to
the City of all applicable suppliers’ and contractors’ warranties and otherwise in compliance with
this Agreement. The conveyance of the ownership of the Project Public Improvements will be
evidenced by a letter of acceptance issued by the City.
(c) Private Improvements. Developer must Complete
Construction of the Private Improvements no later than thirty (30) months after the Effective
Date.
(d) Restaurant Occupancy Minimum. Developer must satisfy
the Restaurant Occupancy Minimum, with each Qualifying Restaurant counted toward that
minimum having received its final certificate of occupancy and being open to the public, no later
than thirty-six (36) months after the Effective Date.
(e) Payment of the Developer Public Improvement
Contribution. Developer must pay the Developer Public Improvement Contribution to City
within nine (9) months after the Effective Date. Payment is not deemed made until the funds
have cleared the City’s financial system.
5.1.2 Permitted Extensions. The City Manager, in the City Manager’s
sole discretion and for good cause, may grant up to three (3) extensions of not more than four (4)
months each with respect to the dates set forth in Section 5.1.1 (“Permitted Extensions”). Each
Permitted Extension must be in writing and may apply to one or more dates in Section 5.1.1, but
no more than three (3) Permitted Extensions may be granted in total, regardless of the number of
dates covered. A Permitted Extension extends only the dates expressly identified in the written
approval and does not extend any other deadline for Developer to satisfy a Reimbursement
Condition or for Developer to perform any other obligation under this Agreement.
5.1.3 Confirmation of Satisfaction of Reimbursement Conditions.
Developer will send Notice to the City of its claim of satisfaction of each of the Reimbursement
Conditions, and City will (reasonably promptly after the City’s receipt of such Notice from
Developer) provide Developer with the City’s return Notice either (a) confirming satisfaction of
the applicable Reimbursement Condition or, (b) if the City does not agree that the
{00624621.1} 7
Reimbursement Condition has been satisfied, describing in reasonable detail any matter
regarding the Reimbursement Condition that Developer must timely resolve in order for the City
to issue its confirmation of Developer’s satisfaction of the Reimbursement Condition.
Satisfaction of each Reimbursement Condition will be dated as of the date the City provides
confirmation to Developer of the satisfaction of the applicable Reimbursement Condition (each,
a “Satisfaction Date”), but no Satisfaction Date with respect to one Reimbursement Condition
will extend the date of required satisfaction of any other Reimbursement Condition included in
Section 5.1.1. The Satisfaction Date upon which the last of the Reimbursement Conditions has
been timely satisfied is the “Reimbursement Commencement Date.”
5.1.4 Failure to Meet Reimbursement Conditions; Required
Conveyance. For the purposes of this Agreement, the failure of Developer to meet any of the
Reimbursement Conditions by the required date is “Noncompliance,” and not an Event of
Default except that the failure of Developer to pay the Developer Public Improvement
Contribution in accordance with Section 5.1.1(e) is not an event of Noncompliance, but is an
Event of Default. Noncompliance will result in: (i) Developer not receiving any portion of the
Reimbursement, or any other financial or tax related incentive that may be granted under this
Agreement related to the development of the Project; (ii) the City’s immediately transferring the
Eligible Sales Tax allocated in the Reimbursement Account into the City’s general fund; (iii) the
City having no further obligations to Developer that arise under this Agreement; and (iv)
Developer remaining fully obligated to the City under this Agreement, including the obligation
to Indemnify and construct and convey the Project Public Improvements.
(a) Since Noncompliance is not an Event of Default, there is
no Grace Period or Notice-and-Cure available to Developer with respect to Developer’s failure
to timely meet the Reimbursement Conditions.
(b) Even if Developer fails to meet all of the Reimbursement
Conditions and is therefore not eligible to receive Reimbursement for Developer Public
Improvement Contribution, Developer must Complete the Project Public Improvements and
convey them to the City in accordance with this Agreement; and the failure of Developer to
comply with any of the requirements of this Subsection is an Event of Default.
5.1.5 Failure to Sustain Qualifying Use and Occupancy. To
continue to receive Reimbursements during the Reimbursement Period, Developer must
continuously and without interruption sustain the Restaurant Occupancy Minimum for the full
Restaurant Occupancy Term. During the Restaurant Occupancy Term, the City reserves the right
to request from Developer documentation showing that Developer is meeting the Restaurant
Occupancy Minimum which Developer must provide certifying Developer’s compliance with the
Restaurant Occupancy Minimum requirements of this Agreement (or describing any failure to
comply). If Developer satisfied all Reimbursement Conditions and begins to receive
Reimbursements but later fails to sustain the Restaurant Occupancy Minimum for the full
Restaurant Occupancy Term, the City shall suspend Reimbursement payments to Developer
(“Suspension”) and promptly send Notice of the Suspension to Developer; and the Suspension
will continue until Developer certifies that the Restaurant Occupancy Minimum has been
restored. During any period of Suspension: (a) all Eligible Sales Tax received by the City that
would otherwise be deposited in the Reimbursement Account, will be retained by the City and
{00624621.1} 8
not be deposited in the Reimbursement Account; (b) Developer, upon restoration of the
Restaurant Occupancy Minimum, will not be entitled to receive any portion of such Eligible
Sales Tax collected by the City during the period of Suspension (and which will be held free of
all claims by Developer); and (c) such Eligible Sales Tax will instead go into the City’s general
fund for unrestricted use by the City. A Suspension will extend the Restaurant Occupancy Term
for the period of the Suspension, but will not extend the Reimbursement Period. Subject to
Enforced Delay, the failure of Developer to restore the Restaurant Occupancy Minimum to the
City’s reasonable satisfaction within twelve (12) months following the date of the City’s Notice
of the Suspension is an Event of Default.
5.2 Reimbursement Payments. Upon satisfaction of the Reimbursement
Conditions, Developer will be eligible to receive payments of the Reimbursement from Eligible
Sales Tax as provided in this Section 5.2.
5.2.1 Reimbursement Cap. The City will pay to Developer, but only
from monies allocated to and held in the Reimbursement Account, the Reimbursement in an
amount not to exceed the Developer Public Improvement Contribution paid by Developer to City
(the “Reimbursement Cap”) subject to the payment limitations herein, including Section 5.2.2.
5.2.2 Reimbursement Period. If Developer has satisfied all
Reimbursement Conditions, and there is no uncured Event of Default on the part of Developer,
the City will make payments of the Reimbursement to Developer until the earliest of (a) payment
in full of the Reimbursement Cap, (b) ten (10) years from the Reimbursement Commencement
Date (“Reimbursement Period”), or (c) the earlier termination of the Agreement. For purposes
of clarity, upon expiration of the Reimbursement Period or earlier termination of this Agreement,
Developer will not be entitled to any additional payments of the Reimbursement, even if
Developer has not received the full amount of the Reimbursement up to the Reimbursement Cap.
5.2.3 Sites Generating Eligible Sales Tax. For the purposes of
determining Eligible Sales Tax, the real property generating Eligible Sales Tax consists only of
the Property (the “Eligible Tax Base”).
5.2.4 Eligible Sales Tax. The City collects transaction privilege tax on
the gross receipts of taxable activities (“TPT”) based on the authority provided under Applicable
Laws, including Title 5, Chapter 10 of the City Code (“Mesa Tax Code”). The City’s TPT rate
as of the Effective Date is two percent (2.0%). The City’s two percent (2.0%) TPT rate is divided
as follows: one and two-tenths percent (1.20%) is non-dedicated, unrestricted or unassigned to a
specific purpose (“Non-Dedicated”) and the remaining eight-tenths of a percent (.80%) is
dedicated to local streets, public safety and quality of life. Within the Mesa Tax Code, there is
also an additional five percent (5.0%) tax on transient lodging under Section 5-10-447 for certain
business activities (“TLT”). The City agrees to provide the Reimbursement in accordance with
this Agreement on “Eligible Sales Tax,” which consists only of the following portions of the
City’s General TPT and Construction TPT revenue (specifically excluding any TLT revenue)
received by the City from taxable activities on the Eligible Tax Base from and after the Effective
Date that will be held in the Reimbursement Account:
{00624621.1} 9
(a) General TPT. The City agrees to allocate to the
Reimbursement Account fifty percent (50%) of the General TPT . “General TPT” means the
Non-Dedicated portion of the TPT collected by the City after the Effective Date attributable to
taxable activities at the Project under the Mesa Tax Code but excluding the Construction TPT
identified below and the TLT. General TPT consists only of the Non-Dedicated portions of the
tax rate; therefore, zero percent (0%) of dedicated tax funds will be allocated to the
Reimbursement Account.
(b) Construction TPT. The City agrees to allocate to the
Reimbursement Account thirty-five percent (35%) of Construction TPT. “Construction TPT”
means the Non-Dedicated portion of the TPT collected by the City after the Effective Date
attributable to taxable activities at the Project under Section 5-10-415 of the Mesa Tax Code
[“Construction Contracting; Construction Contractors”]. Construction TPT consists only of the
Non-Dedicated portions of the tax rate; therefore, zero percent (0%) of the dedicated tax funds
will be allocated to the Reimbursement Account.
(c) Subsequent Increases in TPT Rates. As noted above, as of
the Effective Date, the City’s TPT rate is two percent (2.0%), of which one and two-tenths
percent (1.2.0%) is Non-Dedicated. In the event the City Council, in accordance with Applicable
Laws, increases the TPT rate or modifies the taxable activities in the Mesa Tax Code to increase
the amount of TPT received by the City, those increases will not increase the amount of Eligible
Sales Tax that is allocated to the Reimbursement Account from the General TPT and
Construction TPT rates in effect as of the Effective Date as described in Section 5.2.4.
5.3 Modifications to Mesa Tax Code or Applicable Laws. This Agreement in
no way binds the City Council or any taxing authority to prevent future modifications to
Applicable Laws related to taxation, including the Mesa Tax Code. If prior to or during the
Reimbursement Period, the Arizona Legislature eliminates or reduces the City’s ability to collect
any of the Eligible Sales Tax, then the City will pay the Reimbursement from the collected
Eligible Sales Tax that the City received prior to the elimination of the tax or, in the case of a
reduction, the collected reduced amount, and the City will not be obligated to pay the
Reimbursement from any other sources of City revenue.
5.4 Accounting.
5.4.1 Bookkeeping. The portions of Eligible Sales Tax that are collected
and available for payment of the Reimbursement will be held in an account separate from the
City’s general fund, which account may (in the City’s sole election) take the form of a separate
or segregated accounting or journal entry (the “Reimbursement Account”). The City is not
required to deposit the Eligible Sales Tax in a separate account at a bank or other financial
institution, but any interest that may accrue on any account in which the Eligible Sales Tax is
held will be the property of the City and will not increase the Reimbursement Cap or accrue for
the benefit of Developer.
5.4.2 Reimbursement Conditions. Developer agrees, acknowledges and
confirms that they will have no rights in the Eligible Sales Tax as accumulated in the
Reimbursement Account, and no payment of any portion of Eligible Sales Tax will be made to
{00624621.1} 10
Developer, unless and until Developer meets all the Reimbursement Conditions; and all of
Developer’s rights to receive payments of the Reimbursement are subject to Developer’s
compliance with all of the terms and conditions of this Agreement. If the Reimbursement
Conditions are not met and sustained in accordance with the requirements of this Agreement,
Developer agrees that all funds in, and interest accrued on, the Reimbursement Account will be
retained by the City free and clear of any claims by Developer (including claims of forfeiture).
5.5 Reimbursement Payments. The City will make Reimbursement payments
to Developer from Eligible Sales Tax held in the Reimbursement Account as follows:
5.5.1 Quarterly Payments.
(a) General. Within thirty (30) days after the first Business
Day of the first full calendar quarter following the Reimbursement Commencement Date, and
within thirty (30) days after the first Business Day of each subsequent calendar quarter the earlier
of: (i) payment in full of the Reimbursement to Developer up to the Reimbursement Cap; or (ii)
expiration of the Reimbursement Period (but subject to the qualifications, conditions and
limitations of this Agreement), the City will pay to Developer the Eligible Sales Tax then held by
the City in the Reimbursement Account, in an amount not to exceed the unpaid balance of the
Reimbursement Cap, and otherwise subject to the terms of this Agreement (“Quarterly
Payments”). Each Quarterly Payment must not exceed the remaining unpaid amount of the
Reimbursement Cap and is subject to the qualifications, conditions, and limitations of this
Agreement.
(b) Confidentiality Exception. Notwithstanding the foregoing,
to protect the confidentiality of taxpayer information, Quarterly Payments will not commence
after the Reimbursement Conditions are met until at least three (3) different Third-Party
taxpayers operating on the Property have each paid Eligible Sales Tax for each month of the
same six (6) consecutive calendar months. Once this condition is satisfied, Quarterly Payments
will commence within thirty (30) days after the first Business Day of the next calendar quarter,
but no earlier than otherwise provided in this Section. After Quarterly Payments commence, the
City will suspend Quarterly Payments if fewer than three (3) different taxpayers operating within
the Project have paid Eligible Sales Tax for any subsequent calendar month unless Developer
obtains a consent to release tax information from each taxpayer. If suspended, Quarterly
Payments will resume within thirty (30) days after the first Business Day of the calendar quarter
following the date on which at least three (3) different taxpayers operating within the Project
have again each paid Eligible Sales Tax for each month of the same six (6) consecutive calendar
months. During any suspension, Eligible Sales Tax will continue to accumulate in the
Reimbursement Account and, upon resumption, will be included in Quarterly Payments, subject
to the qualifications, conditions, and limitations of this Agreement. A suspension does not extend
the Reimbursement Period.
5.5.2 Limited Obligation. The City’s obligation to pay the
Reimbursement is limited to only Eligible Sales Tax received by the City and reported as having
been generated from activities and operations on or at the Property. Under no circumstances
shall any obligation of the City under this Agreement represent or constitute a general obligation
{00624621.1} 11
of or pledge of the full faith and credit of the City, the State of Arizona, or of any political
subdivision thereof.
5.5.3 Issuance of Payment: Elliot Land Owner. Elliot Land Owner and
Elliot Retail Owner agree that the City will make all Quarterly Payments of the Reimbursement
solely to Elliot Land Owner on behalf of both entities as “Developer”. Each Quarterly Payment
made to Elliot Land Owner will be deemed received by Developer and will fully discharge
City’s payment obligation to the extent of that payment. The allocation and distribution of those
payments between Elliot Land Owner and Elliot Retail Owner are solely their responsibility.
Elliot Retail Owner, as the entity not receiving payment directly from the City, waives all claims
against the City arising from City’s payment to the Elliot Land Owner or the Elliot Land
Owner’s failure to allocate or distribute those funds.
5.5.4 Bank Account Information. Prior to the issuance of any
Reimbursement payment, Elliot Land Owner must provide the City’s Tax Audit & Collections
Administrator (or designee) with its federal tax identification and bank account information for
the issuance of payments. It is the responsibility solely of the Developer to ensure that the bank
account information provided, including any routing or electronic fund transfer information, is
up to date and correct throughout the Term of this Agreement.
5.6 Determination of Amount of Eligible Sales Tax Received by the City.
The City, in its sole and absolute discretion and in accordance with its normal processes and
procedures related to tax calculations, will determine the amount of the Eligible Sales Tax for
each month (or partial month if applicable) in which Developer is eligible for the
Reimbursement.
5.7 Computation and Report of Sales Tax Revenues; Confidentiality. In
conjunction with each quarterly payment of any portion of the Reimbursement, the City will
deliver to Developer a report of the Eligible Sales Tax collected by the City (“Reimbursement
Report”). Any Reimbursement Report will be subject to Applicable Laws that may prohibit or
limit the dissemination or use of tax information, including confidentiality requirements of the
Arizona Department of Revenue; as such, any Reimbursement Report will not identify the
amount collected from any individual taxpayer and shall present all information in aggregated
form only in a manner that satisfies the Arizona Department of Revenue’s then-current
confidentiality requirements unless Developer receives a consent to release tax information by
the applicable taxpayer. If necessary to meet confidentiality requirements, the City’s obligation
to issue confidential information in a Reimbursement Report is conditioned upon the completion
of a consent to release tax information by the applicable taxpayer(s), that Developer is required
to obtain. Without prior written consent from the applicable taxpayer, under no circumstances
will City provide Developer with confidential taxpayer information.
5.8 Tax Licensing; Multiple Business Locations. The Arizona Department of
Revenue requires each business with multiple locations in the State to have a separate location
code to separately report the transaction privilege tax for each location. Developer (and its
successors) will ensure that Developer’s contractors and subcontractors for construction of the
Project, as well as its tenants or any other occupants of the Property, are properly licensed with
the Arizona Department of Revenue and (if applicable) have a unique location code used for the
{00624621.1} 12
purposes of reporting transaction privilege taxes. Except as may be required by any Applicable
Laws and in accordance with the City’s normal processes and procedures, the City is not
responsible for ensuring that any tax licenses related to the Project are issued and valid, or that
transaction privilege taxes are reported in a manner that ensures payment of the Reimbursement
to Developer. Failure of a taxpayer to properly attribute transaction privilege tax to its location at
the Property will neither modify nor extend the terms of the Reimbursement. The City is not
obligated to reimburse any tax amounts collected or received by the City from a taxpayer that
fails to properly attribute transaction privilege tax to its location at the Property.
5.9 Requests for Refund or Amended Return. Should Developer (or any other
Project-related taxpayer or taxpayer operating at the Property) amend its tax returns or request a
refund for taxes paid that impacts the Reimbursement, to the extent that such taxpayer is entitled
to a refund, at the City’s sole and reasonable discretion, either the City will decrease the amount
of the next Quarterly Payment to the Developer in an amount equal to the refund or the
Developer will return to the City within 90 days of demand of the portion of the Reimbursement
that was paid in error (that is, refunded to the taxpayer) as a result of the amended tax return
filings.
5.10 City’s Prepayment Right. Prepayment by the City of the Reimbursement
up to the Reimbursement Cap, in whole or in part, is permitted at any time, and from time to
time, without penalty and without payment of unaccrued interest. The City may, but is not
obligated to, authorize a prepayment through any means available to the City.
6. Indemnity; Insurance.
6.1 Developer’s Indemnity. Developer and its successors and assigns will
indemnify, defend, pay and hold harmless (collectively, “Indemnify”) the City and its City
Council members, officers, officials, agents and employees (collectively, including the City, the
“City Indemnified Parties”) for, from and against any and all claims, demands, fines, penalties,
costs, expenses, damages, losses, obligations, judgments, liabilities, and suits, including
administrative fines and penalties, property damage, personal injury and wrongful death (and
including attorneys’ fees, experts’ fees and court costs associated) which may be imposed upon,
incurred by or asserted against the City Indemnified Parties (each, a “Claim,” or collectively,
“Claims”) which arise from or relate in any way, whether in whole or in part, to any of the
following:
(a) any act or omission by Developer, or its employees, contractors,
subcontractors, agents or representatives, undertaken in fulfillment of Developer’s obligations
under this Agreement;
(b) Developer’s construction of any improvements constituting the
Project, the Project Public Improvements, or any other work done on or about the Property by (1)
Developer or (2) Developer’s employees, contractors, subcontractors, agents or representatives;
(c) any act or omission in the design or construction of the Project
Public Improvements;
{00624621.1} 13
(d) any breach or violation by Developer of Applicable Laws
(including Hazardous Materials Laws), or breach or violation of any representation or warranty
of Developer;
(e) from adjacent landowners to the Property that their real property
and real property interests were devalued as a result of City’s agreements, acts and undertakings
set forth in this Agreement or the development of the Project; or
(f) any loss of or reduction in the City’s State Shared Revenue arising
in connection with a claim brought or maintained under A.R.S. § 41-194.01 or A.R.S. § 42-6010
resulting from this Agreement.
6.2 Joint and Several Obligations. The obligations of Elliot Land Owner and
Elliot Retail Owner, including when Elliot Land Owner and Elliot Retail Owner are referred to in
this Agreement as Developer or Co-Developer, and their successors and assigns, to Indemnify
are joint and several and extend to and encompass all costs incurred by the City Indemnified
Parties in defending against the Claims (both at the trial and any appellate level), including
attorney, witness and expert fees, and any other mediation, arbitration and litigation-related
expenses, whether or not such Claims are settled or resolved by judicial order. The provisions of
Section 6.1, however, will not apply to Claims to the extent such Claims are solely and directly
caused by the gross negligence or willful misconduct of the City Indemnified Parties. The
obligations of Developer and their successors and assigns under Section 6.1 will survive the
expiration or termination of this Agreement.
7. Insurance. During the applicable period of time set forth in Exhibit D,
Developer will obtain and provide the City with proof of payment of premiums and certificates
of insurance showing that Developer is carrying, or causing its contractor(s) to carry, policies of
insurance in amounts and coverages set forth in Exhibit D. Such policies of insurance will be
placed with financially sound and reputable insurers, require the insurer to give at least thirty
(30) days advance written Notice of cancellation to the City, and will name the City Indemnified
Parties as additional insureds on such policies.
8. City’s Representations and Warranties. The City represents and warrants to
Developer that as of the Effective Date:
8.1 All consents and approvals necessary to the execution, delivery and
performance of this Agreement were obtained, and no further action needs to be taken in
connection with such execution, delivery, and performance.
8.2 The City will execute and acknowledge when appropriate all documents
and instruments and take all actions necessary to implement, evidence, and enforce this
Agreement.
8.3 The City knows of no litigation, proceeding, initiative, referendum,
investigation or threat of any of the same contesting the powers of the City or its officials with
respect to this Agreement that has not been disclosed in writing to Developer.
{00624621.1} 14
8.4 This Agreement (and each undertaking of the City contained in this
Agreement), constitutes a valid, binding and enforceable obligation of the City, enforceable
according to its terms, except to the extent limited by Applicable Laws, including bankruptcy,
insolvency and other Applicable Laws of general application, whether considered at law or in
equity.
8.5 The execution, delivery and performance of this Agreement by the City is
not prohibited by, and does not conflict with, any other agreements, instruments or judgments or
decrees to which the City is a party or is otherwise subject.
8.6 The City was assisted by counsel of its own choosing in connection with
the preparation and execution of this Agreement.
9. Co-Developer’s Representations and Warranties. Each Co-Developer
represents and warrants to the City that as of the Effective Date:
9.1 It is a duly formed and legally valid existing entity under the laws of the
State of Arizona.
9.2 All consents and approvals necessary to the execution, delivery, and
performance of this Agreement were obtained, and no further action needs to be taken in
connection with such execution, delivery and performance.
9.3 Co-Developer knows of no litigation, proceeding or investigation pending
or threatened against or affecting the Co-Developer contesting the validity or enforceability of
this Agreement or Developer’s performance under this Agreement.
9.4 Co-Developer will execute and acknowledge when appropriate all
documents and instruments and take all actions necessary to implement, evidence, and enforce
this Agreement.
9.5 This Agreement (and each undertaking of Developer contained in this
Agreement) constitutes a valid, binding and enforceable agreement of Co-Developer, enforceable
according to its terms, except to the extent limited by Applicable Laws including bankruptcy,
insolvency and other Applicable Laws of general application, whether considered at law or in
equity.
9.6 The execution, delivery and performance of this Agreement by Co-
Developer is not prohibited by, and does not conflict with, any other agreements, instruments,
judgments, or decrees to which Co-Developer is a party or to which Co-Developer is otherwise
subject.
9.7 Co-Developer has not paid or given, and will not pay or give, any Third
Party any money or other consideration for obtaining this Agreement other than normal costs of
conducting business and costs of professional services such as the services of architects,
engineers and attorneys.
{00624621.1} 15
9.8 Co-Developer was assisted by, or had the opportunity to be assisted by,
counsel of its own choosing in connection with the preparation and execution of this Agreement.
9.9 To Co-Developer’s knowledge, there exist no known violations of
Hazardous Materials Laws respecting the Property.
10. Event of Default; Remedies. “Event of Default” means as set forth in Section
10.1 (as to Developer) and Section 10.2 (as to the City).
10.1 Events of Default by Developer. Event of Default by Developer under
this Agreement means any of the following:
(a) Any representation or warranty made in this Agreement by
Developer was materially inaccurate when made or proves to be materially inaccurate during the
Term;
(b) Developer fails to pay to the City the Developer Public
Improvement Contribution by the required deadline in Section 5.1.1(e);
(c) Developer transfers or attempts to transfer or assign this
Agreement in violation of the terms in this Agreement; or
(d) Developer fails to observe or perform any other covenant,
obligation or agreement required of it under this Agreement, expressly including the required
performance of Developer to Indemnify.
10.2 Events of Default by the City. Event of Default by the City under this
Agreement means any of the following:
(a) Any representation or warranty made in this Agreement by the
City was materially inaccurate when made or proves to be materially inaccurate during the term
of the Agreement;
(b) Subject to the provisions in this Agreement, including satisfaction
of the Reimbursement Conditions by Developer, the City fails to make Reimbursement payments
to Developer as provided in this Agreement; or
(c) The City fails to observe or perform any other covenant, obligation
or agreement required of it under this Agreement.
10.3 Grace Periods; Notice and Cure. Upon the occurrence of an Event of
Default by a Party, the nonperforming Party shall, upon written Notice from a performing Party,
proceed immediately to cure or remedy such Event of Default within thirty (30) days (“Grace
Period”) after the nonperforming Party’s receipt of such Notice (“Notice-and-Cure”); provided,
however, if the Event of Default cannot reasonably be cured within the Grace Period, the
nonperforming Party shall not be in Default so long as it commences the cure within the Grace
Period and thereafter continuously and diligently pursues the cure to completion, but in no event
shall the cure period extend beyond ninety (90) days after receipt of the Notice unless otherwise
{00624621.1} 16
agreed to in writing by the nonperforming Party and the Party that provided the Notice. A copy
of the Notice will be provided by the Party claiming the Event of Default to all Parties so that all
Parties are aware of the claim.
10.4 Remedies on Default. Whenever any Event of Default by a Party occurs
and is not cured within the Grace Period, a non-defaulting Party may take any or one or more of
the following actions specifically allowed for the non-defaulting Party:
10.4.1 Remedies of the City for Developer’s Default. The City’s
remedies for a Default by Developer described in Section 10.1 consist of the following:
(a) With respect to an Event of Default described in Section
10.1 that has not been timely cured within the Grace Period, the City may suspend any of its
obligations to Developer under this Agreement.
(b) With respect to an Event of Default described in Section
10.1 that has not been timely cured within the Grace Period, the City may immediately (and
without further act or Notice required) terminate its obligations to pay the Reimbursement (and
all other obligations of the City to Developer), and the City may then transfer all undisbursed
funds in the Reimbursement Account into the City’s general fund, in which event Developer will
have no further rights to the Reimbursement but will remain obligated to the City with respect to
all other obligations of Developer, including the duty to Indemnify.
(c) With respect to an Event of Default described in Section
10.1 that has not been timely cured within the Grace Period, the City additionally may (1) seek
special action or other similar relief (whether characterized as mandamus, injunction, specific
performance or otherwise), requiring Developer to comply with the terms of this Agreement, and
(2) recover from Developer its actual damages arising from such Default.
(d) The remedies provided in this Section 10.4.1 do not limit
the City’s further right to recover its actual damages related to Developer’s duty to Indemnify
under the provisions of this Agreement.
(e) The remedies provided in this Section 10.4.1 do not limit
the City’s right, in its capacity as a municipality, to enforce Applicable Laws.
(f) The failure of Developer to satisfy the Reimbursement
Conditions is an event of Noncompliance and is not a Default of Developer, as (1) such failure
terminates Developer’s right to Reimbursement, but (2) Developer’s other obligations arising
under this Agreement, including the duty to Indemnify, continue despite the failure or
termination of Developer’s right to receive Reimbursement.
10.4.2 Remedies of Developer. Developer’s exclusive remedy for a
Default by the City will consist of and be limited to bringing a special action to compel the
City’s required performance (including payment) under this Agreement, and recovering its actual
damages. Each Co-Developer waives any right to seek consequential, punitive, multiple,
exemplary or any other damages from the City for a Default.
{00624621.1} 17
11. Alternative Dispute Resolution.
11.1 Impasse. It is the intent of the Parties for Developer to proceed rapidly
with the implementation of this Agreement and the development of the Project. Accordingly, the
Parties agree that if at any time Developer believes an impasse has been reached with City staff
on any issue affecting the Project which is not an Event of Default (an “Impasse”), Developer
will have the right to immediately appeal to a designated City representative for an expedited
decision. If the Developer and City representative cannot resolve the Impasse within ninety (90)
days, the Developer has the right to meet with the City Manager (or Assistant City Manager) and
pursue mediation pursuant to the provisions of Section 11.2 below.
11.2 Mediation. If a dispute arises between or among the Parties which is not
an event of Default by a Party and which the Parties cannot reasonably resolve between (or
among) themselves, the Parties agree that there will be a ninety (90) day moratorium on litigation
during which time the Parties agree to attempt to settle the dispute by non-binding mediation
before commencement of litigation. The mediator will be agreed upon by the Parties and all
administrative fees will be divided evenly between or among the Parties to the mediation.
12. Defense of Agreement.
12.1 Indemnity. In addition to all other obligations of Elliot Land Owner and
Elliot Retail Owner to Indemnify City and the City Indemnified Parties as set forth in Section 6,
Elliot Land Owner and Elliot Retail Owner will jointly and severally Indemnify the City and the
City Indemnified Parties and defend the validity and enforceability of this Agreement, at their
sole cost and expense, in the event of (a) any challenge to the validity and enforceability of this
Agreement or (b) any proceeding or litigation arising from its terms that names the City, Elliot
Land Owner, or Elliot Retail Owner (or any combination of the Parties) as a party or which
challenges the authority of the Parties to enter into or perform any of their obligations in this
Agreement. Elliot Land Owner and Elliot Retail Owner will cooperate with the City and will
otherwise meet their obligation to Indemnify the City and the City Indemnified Parties as set
forth in this Agreement in connection with any other action or legal challenge in which the City
is a party and the benefits of this Agreement to the City are challenged. The severability
provisions of Section 14.5 will apply in the event of any successful challenge to this Agreement.
12.2 Fees and Costs.
12.2.1 Between or Among the Parties. In the event of litigation arising in
connection with a Default by any Party and commencement of a subsequent legal action by a
Party in the appropriate forum, the prevailing Party in any such dispute will be entitled to
reimbursement of its reasonable attorneys’ fees and court costs, including its reasonable costs of
expert witnesses, transportation, lodging and meal costs of out-of-town parties and witnesses,
costs of transcript preparation, and other reasonable and necessary direct and incidental costs of
such dispute.
12.2.2 Third-Party Claim Naming Developer. Developer at their sole cost
and expense, and by counsel of its own choosing, and subject to its reasonable business
judgment, will defend the validity and enforceability of this Agreement in the event of any
{00624621.1} 18
proceeding or litigation commenced or maintained by a Third Party arising from its terms that
names either Co-Developer as a party or which challenges the authority of either Co-Developer
to enter into or perform any of its obligations hereunder or the enforceability of any term or
condition of this Agreement. If the City is not named as a party in such proceeding or litigation,
the City will cooperate with Developer (at no cost or expense to the City) in connection with any
action in which Developer is a party and the benefits of this Agreement to the City are
challenged.
12.2.3 Third-Party Claim Naming City. The City may elect to defend, by
counsel of its own choosing, the validity and enforceability of this Agreement in the event of any
proceeding or litigation commenced or maintained by a Third Party arising from its terms that
names the City as a party to such proceeding or litigation and which challenges: (a) the authority
of the City to enter into this Agreement or perform any of its obligations under this Agreement,
(b) the enforceability of any term or condition of this Agreement, or (c) the compliance of this
Agreement with any Applicable Laws (including a claim or determination arising under A.R.S. §
41-194.01 or A.R.S. § 42-6010); provided, however, that Developer, within thirty (30) days of
written demand from the City, must reimburse the City all of the City’s actual, out-of-pocket
attorneys’ fees and costs incurred under this Section 12.2.2. The City may settle any such
proceeding or litigation on such terms and conditions as the City may elect in its sole and
absolute discretion, but at no additional expense or liability to Developer (beyond the
reimbursement of the attorneys’ fees and costs) without Developer’s approval; however, the term
“expense or liability to Developer” does not include the loss of any benefit anticipated by
Developer to be obtained by Developer under this Agreement, including the Reimbursement.
The language of this Section 12.2.2 does not suspend or modify Developer’s obligations to
Indemnify the City set forth in this Agreement.
13. Preservation of State Shared Revenue. Notwithstanding any other provision of
or limitation in this Agreement to the contrary, if the City’s State Shared Revenue is withheld or
is subject to being withheld under either A.R.S. § 41-194.01 or A.R.S. § 42-6010 related to this
Agreement, these provisions will apply, as applicable:
13.1 A.R.S. § 41-194.01. Notwithstanding any other provision of or limitation
in this Agreement to the contrary, if in accordance with A.R.S. § 41-194.01 the Attorney General
determines that this Agreement, or any portion thereof, violates any provision of state law or the
Constitution of Arizona, then the City and Developer, in good faith, will attempt to modify this
Agreement so as to resolve the violation with the Attorney General within thirty (30) days of
notice from the Attorney General in accordance with and under the provisions of A.R.S. §41-
194.01(B)(1). If, by the twenty-ninth (29th) day after the date of the notice from the Attorney
General, the Parties, after good faith efforts, are not successful in modifying this Agreement to
the satisfaction of the Attorney General, this entire Agreement will automatically terminate at
midnight on the thirtieth (30th) day after the date of receiving such notice from the Attorney
General, and upon such termination the Parties will have no further obligations under this
Agreement. Additionally, if, under A.R.S. § 41-194.01(B)(2), the Attorney General determines
that this Agreement may violate a provision of State law or the Constitution of Arizona under
A.R.S. § 41-194.01(B)(2), and the Arizona Supreme Court requires the posting of a bond under
A.R.S. § 41-194.01(B)(2), the City will be entitled to terminate this Agreement, except if
Developer posts such bond; and provided further, that if the Arizona Supreme Court, determines
{00624621.1} 19
that this Agreement violates any provision of State law or the Constitution of Arizona, the City
may terminate this Agreement and the Parties will have no further rights or obligations under this
Agreement except for obligations to Indemnify that survive the expiration or earlier termination
of this Agreement.
13.2 A.R.S. § 42-6010. If a court of competent jurisdiction determines that this
Agreement or the Reimbursement is a violation of A.R.S. § 42-6010 that would result in a
withholding by the Arizona Department of Revenue of the City’s State Shared Revenue as a
penalty under A.R.S. § 42-6010(B), this Agreement will automatically terminate at midnight on
the earlier of (a) the day after the City’s receipt of notice of the court’s final unappealable ruling
that the City is subject to withholding (or a prior appealable court ruling that the City is subject
to withholding and Developer fails to timely provide a bond or other assurance of payment in the
amount necessary to stay the penalty during the appeal), or (b) such other ruling the Parties
agree, in their sole and reasonable discretion, shall bind them, and upon such termination the
Parties will have no further rights or obligations under this Agreement. Additionally, if the
Attorney General or any State agency determines that this Agreement may violate A.R.S. § 42-
6010, the City will be entitled to terminate this Agreement and the Parties will have no further
right or obligations under this Agreement (except for obligations to Indemnify that survive the
expiration or earlier termination of this Agreement).
14. General Provisions.
14.1 Term. The term of this Agreement (“Term”) means the period of time
commencing on the Effective Date and ending on the earlier of: (a) fifteen (15) years from the
Effective Date; (b) if Noncompliance occurs, the date on which Developer has both (i) paid the
City the Developer Public Improvement Contribution as required herein, and (ii) caused
Completion of Construction of the Project Public Improvements and conveyed the improvements
to the City, with the construction and conveyance meeting the requirements herein; (c) the end of
the Reimbursement Period; or (d) any earlier termination of this Agreement as allowed in this
Agreement.
14.2 Governing Law; Choice of Forum. This Agreement is made under, and
will be construed in accordance with and governed by, the internal, substantive laws of the State
of Arizona (without reference to conflict of law principles). The Parties confer exclusive
jurisdiction, to the fullest extent possible, upon the Superior Court of the State of Arizona in and
for the County of Maricopa (“Superior Court”), for the purpose of coordinating and centralizing
any required judicial administration of this Agreement. Accordingly, any action brought to
interpret, enforce or construe any provision of this Agreement must be commenced and
maintained in the Superior Court (or, as may be appropriate, in the Justice Courts of Maricopa
County, Arizona, or in the United States District Court for the District of Arizona, if, but only if,
the Superior Court lacks or declines jurisdiction over such action). As this is a material and
specifically bargained-for term of this Agreement, the Parties irrevocably consent to the
exclusive jurisdiction and venue in such courts for such purposes and agree not to seek (and do
not have the right to seek) transfer or removal of any action commenced in accordance with the
terms of this Section.
{00624621.1} 20
14.3 E-Verify. To the extent applicable under A.R.S. § 41-4401 and A.R.S. §
23-214, Developer represents and warrants that it will comply with all federal immigration laws
and regulations that relate to its employees and their compliance with the E-Verify requirements
of A.R.S. § 23-214(A), and Developer will contractually require its contractors and
subcontractors to comply with same. Breach of the warranty in this Section will be an Event of
Default of this Agreement and may result in the termination of the Agreement by the City. The
City retains the legal right to randomly inspect the papers and records of any employee of a Co-
Developer who works under this Agreement to ensure compliance with the above-mentioned
laws.
14.4 Assignment and Transfer; Sale of Pad Sites.
14.4.1 Restrictions on Assignment and Transfer. The City has entered
into this Agreement solely because of the stated experience of Developer’s members and
principals in the development of mixed-use projects similar to the contemplated Project,
including the attraction of Qualifying Restaurant tenants and operators, as well as Developer’s
experience in owning and operating properties of a comparable caliber. Accordingly, this
Agreement (and the corresponding rights of Developer) may not be assigned, transferred or
conveyed, either in whole or in part, by Developer without first receiving the written consent of
the City, which may be granted, withheld, conditioned and delayed by the City in its sole,
absolute and unfettered discretion. Any attempted assignment, either in whole or in part, without
such consent will be void, and not voidable. The provisions of this Agreement are binding upon
and will inure to the benefit and burden of the Parties, and their heirs, successors, executors,
administrators, and assigns.
14.4.2 Sale of Pad Sites. The Property owned by Developer is divided
into pad sites (individually a “Pad Site”, and collectively the “Pad Sites”). This Agreement is a
retail development tax incentive agreement in accordance with A.R.S. § 9-500.11 intended to
provide Reimbursement of the Developer Public Improvement Contribution in accordance with
the terms of this Agreement. To that end, for any Pad Site purchased by a Third Party from
either Co-Developer: (i) this Agreement will not impose any obligations upon a Third Party
purchaser of a Pad Site and all obligations, including the development of the Project Public
Improvements, will remain with and be personal to the Developer; and (ii) any Third Party
purchaser of a Pad Site will not be entitled to any of the benefits of this Agreement, as all
benefits will remain with and be personal to the Developer, as applicable, including the right of
Developer to receive the Reimbursement. Accordingly, any Third Party purchaser of a Pad Site
will not be (a) considered the “Developer” for the purpose of this Agreement, or (b) a successor
in interest or assignee of Developer; and, although this Agreement will continue to run with the
land (including any Third-Party owned Pad Site), the obligations and benefits in this Agreement
relating to Developer will remain personal to the Developer, as applicable, and will be retained
by the Developer unless and until the City consents to an assignment in accordance with Section
14.4.1.
14.4.3 Rights of Lenders.
14.4.3.1 The City is aware that Developer may obtain financing
or refinancing for the development of the real property, in whole or in part, from time to time, by
{00624621.1} 21
one or more Third Parties (individually a “Lender”, and collectively the “Lenders”). In the
event of an Event of Default by Developer, the City shall provide Notice of such Event of
Default, at the same time Notice is provided to Developer, to not more than two (2) of such
Lenders as previously designated by Developer to receive such Notice (the “Designated
Lenders”) whose names and addresses must be provided by Notice to the City in accordance
with Section 14.7. The City shall give Developer copies of any such Notice provided to such
Designated Lenders and, unless Developer notifies the City that the Designated Lenders names
or addresses are incorrect (and provides the City with the correct information) within three (3)
Business Days after Developer receives its copies of such Notice from the City, the City will be
deemed to have given such Notice to the Designated Lenders even if their names or addresses are
incorrect. Developer may provide notices to other Lenders.
14.4.3.2 Upon request by a Lender, the City may, in its sole
discretion, enter into a non-disturbance (or similar) agreement with such Lender, consistent with
the provisions of this Section. Under no circumstance will the City agree to subordinate any of
its rights in this Agreement, nor will the City agree to any change of the terms and conditions of
this Agreement in a non-disturbance or similar agreement with a Lender, although the City in its
sole election may agree to a reasonable (not to exceed 90 days) extension of a Lender’s right to
cure an Event of Default by Developer or to assume Developer’s position with respect to this
Agreement. If a Lender is permitted, under the terms of any non-disturbance (or similar)
agreement with the City to cure the Event of Default or to assume Developer’s or a Co-
Developer’s position with respect to this Agreement, the City agrees to recognize such rights of
the Lender and otherwise permit the Lender to assume all of the rights and obligations of
Developer or Co-Developer (as applicable) under this Agreement.
14.4.3.3 The City shall, upon reasonable written request by
Developer, provide to any Lender an estoppel certificate or other similar document confirming
that this Agreement is in full force and effect and that no Event of Default by Developer exists
(or, if appropriate, specifying the nature and duration of any existing Event of Default). The
terms of any estoppel certificate shall not amend, modify, supplement, or expand this
Agreement, create new obligations, waive any rights, or constitute a separate agreement with or
in favor of the Lender.
14.5 Severability. The Parties each believe that the execution, delivery, and
performance of this Agreement is in compliance with all Applicable Laws. However, in the
unlikely event that any provision of this Agreement is declared void or unenforceable (or is
construed as requiring the City to do any act in violation of any Applicable Laws), such
provision will be deemed severed from this Agreement and this Agreement will otherwise
remain in full force and effect; provided that this Agreement will retroactively be deemed
reformed to the extent reasonably possible in such a manner so that the reformed agreement (and
any related agreements effective as of the same date) provide essentially the same rights and
benefits (economic and otherwise) to the Parties as if such severance and reformation were not
required. The Parties further agree, in such circumstances, to do all acts and to execute all
amendments, instruments and consents reasonably necessary (subject to the City Council’s
legislative discretion) to accomplish and to give effect to the purposes of this Agreement, as
reformed.
{00624621.1} 22
14.6 Construction. The terms and provisions of this Agreement represent the
results of negotiations among the Parties, each of which was (or had the opportunity to be)
represented by counsel of its own choosing, and none of which acted under any duress or
compulsion, whether legal, economic or otherwise. Consequently, the terms and provisions of
this Agreement will be interpreted and construed in accordance with their usual and customary
meanings, and the Parties each waive the application of any rule of law which would otherwise
be applicable in connection with the interpretation and construction of this Agreement that
ambiguous or conflicting terms or provisions contained in this Agreement will be interpreted or
construed against the Party who prepared or whose attorney prepared the executed Agreement or
any earlier draft of the same. Words used in the present tense include the future tense, words in
the plural number include the singular number (although “Developer” is expressly intended
throughout this Agreement to be a defined term that means and includes the Elliot Land Owner
and the Elliot Retail Owner, jointly and severally), and words in the singular number include the
plural number. The terms “shall” or “must” mean a duty or obligation. The use of the term
“including” is not a limitation, and refers to “including, but not limited to” and “including, by
way of example and not limitation.” The citation to any statute, ordinances, rules, regulations,
standards, permit requirements, and other requirements and official policies are as they presently
exist or may be amended or hereafter enacted from time to time.
14.7 Notices.
14.7.1 Addresses. Except as otherwise required by law, any notice
required or permitted under this Agreement (each, a “Notice”) must be in writing and given by
one of the following methods, with the delivery charges prepaid by the Party delivering the
Notice, at the respective addresses set forth below, or at such other address as a Party may
designate by a Notice given in accordance with the terms of this Section: (a) personal delivery;
or (b) any nationally recognized express or overnight delivery service (for example, Federal
Express or UPS), delivery charges prepaid, for next Business Day delivery.
If to the City: City of Mesa
20 East Main Street, Suite 750
Mesa, Arizona 85211
Attn: City Manager
With a required copy to: Mesa City Attorney’s Office
20 East Main Street, Suite 850
Mesa, Arizona 85211
Attn: City Attorney
If to Elliot Land Owner, 6710 N. Scottsdale Road, Suite 140
Elliot Retail Owner, Scottsdale, Arizona 85253
or to Developer: Attn: David Martens
With a required copy to: 6710 N. Scottsdale Road, Suite 140
Scottsdale, Arizona 85253
Attn: John Parnell
{00624621.1} 23
14.7.2 Effective Date of Notices. Any Notice personally delivered or
delivered by a nationally recognized express or overnight delivery service will be deemed
effective upon its receipt or refusal to accept receipt by the addressee. Notices transmitted
digitally, electronically, by facsimile or by United States Postal Service may be offered as a
courtesy, but do not constitute “Notice” for the purposes of Section 14.7.
14.7.3 Payments. Unless otherwise agreed to by the Parties, payments
will be made and delivered by wire transfer unless otherwise agreed to by the Parties.
14.7.4 Single Notice to Developer. Although there are two entities
constituting Developer, in the event that any Notice is required to be given to an entity
constituting Developer, only one Notice is required to be given and will be provided to the
address for the “Developer” listed in Section 14.7.1 and receipt of such Notice will satisfy the
requirements for Notice herein by all entities constituting Developer.
14.8 Enforced Delay in Performance for Causes Beyond Control of Party.
Whether stated or not, all periods of time in this Agreement are subject to this Section14.8.
Neither the City nor Developer, as the case may be, will be considered in Default of its
obligations under this Agreement in the event of enforced delay (an “Enforced Delay”) directly
due to causes beyond its control and without its fault, negligence or failure to comply with
Applicable Laws, including acts of God (for example, a significant weather or geological event),
a Public Health Event, civil or military disturbance, labor or material shortage (excluding those
caused by lack of funds), legal challenges to this Agreement by a Third Party filed in a court of
competent jurisdiction, initiative or referendum, confiscation or seizure by any government or
public authority, or acts of terrorism. In no event will an Enforced Delay include any delay
resulting from general economic or market conditions, unavailability for any reason of particular
tenants or purchasers of portions of the Project, nor from the unavailability for any reason of a
particular contractor, subcontractor, vendor, investor or lender desired by Developer in
connection with the Project, it being agreed that Developer will bear all risks of delay which are
not an Enforced Delay. In the event of the occurrence of any such Enforced Delay, the time or
times for performance of the obligations of the Party claiming delay will be extended for the
period of the Enforced Delay; provided that the Party seeking the benefit of the provisions of this
Section must, within thirty (30) days after such Party knows (or reasonably should have known)
of any such Enforced Delay, first notify the other Parties of the specific delay in writing and
claim the right to an extension for the period of the Enforced Delay; provided, however, that
either Party’s failure to notify the others of an event constituting an Enforced Delay will not
alter, detract from or negate its character as an Enforced Delay if such event of Enforced Delay
were not known or reasonably discoverable by such Party.
14.9 Time of Essence. Time is of the essence of this Agreement and each of its
provisions.
14.10 Section Headings. The Section and subsection headings contained in this
Agreement are for convenience in reference only and are not intended to define or limit the scope
of any provision of this Agreement.
{00624621.1} 24
14.11 Waiver. The Parties agree that neither the failure nor the delay of any
Party to exercise any right, remedy, power or privilege under this Agreement will operate as a
waiver, nor will any single or partial exercise of any right, remedy, power or privilege preclude
any other or further exercise of the same or of any other right, remedy, power or privilege, nor
will any waiver of any right, remedy, power or privilege with respect to any occurrence be
construed as a waiver of such right, remedy, power or privilege with respect to any other
occurrence. No waiver is effective unless it is in writing and is signed by the Party asserted to
have granted such waiver.
14.12 Third-Party Beneficiaries. There are no Third-Party beneficiaries to this
Agreement, except for permitted successors and assigns of a Party, and except that the City
Indemnified Parties are Third-Party beneficiaries of such indemnification provisions. Further,
and for the avoidance of doubt, no Third-Party Pad Site owner, retailer, restaurant or other tenant
within the Project (despite being located at the Project) has any rights under this Agreement
14.13 Regarding Developer. Although Elliot Land Owner and Elliot Retail
Owner are separate entities constituting Developer, their rights, responsibilities and obligations
arising under this Agreement as Developer are joint and several. The City may look to either Co-
Developer for performance (including the duty to Indemnify) required by Developer, and neither
Co-Developer has any right and remedy as to the City that is separate or divisible from those
rights and remedies of the other Co-Developer.
14.14 Exhibits. The Parties agree that all references to this Agreement include
all Exhibits referred to and attached to this Agreement, such Exhibits being incorporated into and
made integral parts of this Agreement for all purposes.
14.15 Entire Agreement. Except as expressly provided in this Agreement, this
Agreement constitutes the entire agreement between and among the Parties with respect to its
subject matter and supersedes any prior agreement, understanding, negotiation or representation
regarding the subject matter covered by this Agreement.
14.16 Further Assurances. Each Party agrees to perform such other and further
acts and to execute and deliver such additional agreements, documents, affidavits, certifications,
acknowledgments and instruments as the other Party may reasonably require (subject to
negotiation and agreement of the terms by the Parties) to consummate, evidence, confirm or
carry out the matters contemplated by this Agreement, or to confirm the status of (a) this
Agreement as being in full force and effect and (b) the performance of the obligations required of
the Parties at any time during the Term.
14.17 Computation of Time. If the last day of any time period stated in this
Agreement or the date on which any obligation to be performed under this Agreement falls on a
day that is not a Business Day, then the duration of such time period or the date of performance,
as applicable, will be extended so that it ends on the next succeeding Business Day. The time for
performance of any obligation or the taking of any action under this Agreement will expire at
5:00 p.m. (Phoenix, Arizona, time) on the last day of the applicable time period. Any period
expressed in months ends on the same numerical day of the applicable month as the starting date
or, if that month has no corresponding day, on the last day of that month. Any period expressed
{00624621.1} 25
in years ends on the same month and numerical day in the applicable year as the starting date or,
if that month has no corresponding day, on the last day of that month.
14.18 Consents and Approvals. Wherever this Agreement requires or permits
the consent or approval of a Party to any act, document, use or other matter, such consent or
approval will be given or denied by such Party in its reasonable discretion unless this Agreement
expressly provides otherwise, and except that any decision related to this Agreement that must be
made by the City Council will be at the City Council’s sole, absolute and unfettered legislative
discretion.
14.19 Covenants Running with Land; Inurement. Subject to Section 14.4, the
covenants, conditions, terms and provisions of this Agreement run with the land and are binding
upon, and inure to the benefit of the Parties and their respective permitted successors and assigns
with respect to Property. Wherever the term “Party” or the name of any particular Party is used
in this Agreement, such term includes any such Party’s permitted successors and assigns. Any
reference in this Agreement to an Affiliate or to the permitted successors and assigns of
Developer, means and includes the Affiliate or the successors and permitted assigns of both or
either Co-Developer, as applicable, with respect to the obligations assumed by or applicable to
such person under this Agreement.
14.20 Recordation. Within ten (10) days after this Agreement is executed by the
Parties, the City will record this Agreement in the Official Records.
14.21 Amendment. Except as otherwise expressly provided for or permitted in
this Agreement, no change or addition is to be made to this Agreement except by written
amendment executed and acknowledged by authorized representatives of the City, Elliot Land
Owner and Elliot Retail Owner. Certain amendments may be determined by the City to be
“material” (rather than administrative, ministerial or discretionary) that require the approval of
the City Council, which may be granted or withheld in the City Council’s sole, absolute and
unfettered legislative discretion. Within ten (10) days after the full execution of any amendment
to this Agreement, such amendment shall be recorded in the Official Records. Upon amendment
of this Agreement, references to the “Agreement” will mean this Agreement, as amended. The
effective date of any duly processed amendment will either be (1) the date described in the
amendment as the effective date of such amendment, or (2) if no date is specified in the
amendment as its effective date, the date on which the last representative for the Parties executes
the amendment. If, after the effective date of any amendment, the Parties find it necessary to
refer to this Agreement in its original, unamended form existing as of the Effective Date, they
will refer to it as the “Original Development Agreement” or a similar term. When the Parties
mean to refer to any specific amendment to the Agreement, which amendment is unmodified by
any subsequent amendments, the Parties will refer to it by the number of the amendment as well
as its effective date.
14.22 Good Faith of Parties. Except where any matter is expressly stated in this
Agreement to be in the sole or absolute discretion of a Party, in the performance of this
Agreement or in considering any requested extension of time, the Parties agree that each will act
in good faith, will not act unreasonably, arbitrarily, or capriciously, and will not unreasonably
withhold, delay, or condition any requested approval, acknowledgment or consent. Any decision
{00624621.1} 26
related to this Agreement that must be made by the City Council will be at the City Council’s
sole, absolute and unfettered legislative discretion.
14.23 Survival. The provisions related to a requirement to Indemnify, the
waiver of claims in Section 14.29, and any terms expressly stating they survive the expiration or
earlier termination of this Agreement, will survive the execution and delivery of this Agreement,
the closing of any transaction contemplated by this Agreement, the full payment of the
Reimbursement, the expiration of the Term, and the rescission, cancellation, expiration, or
termination of this Agreement, unless modified or relinquished by the City in its sole and
reasonable discretion.
14.24 Nonliability of Officials, Employees, Members, Partners, Etc. No City
Councilmember, official, representative, agent, consultant, attorney or employee of the City will
be personally liable to either Co-Developer, or to any successor in interest to a Co-Developer, in
the event of any uncured City Default or for any amount which may become due to a Co-
Developer or their successors, or with respect to any obligation of the City under the terms of
this Agreement. Notwithstanding anything contained in this Agreement to the contrary, the
liability of each Co-Developer under this Agreement will not extend to or be enforceable against:
(a) the individual assets of any of the individuals or entities who are shareholders, members,
managers constituent partners, officers or directors of the general partners or members of any
Co-Developer; (b) the shareholders, members or managers or constituent partners of either Co-
Developer; or (c) officers of either Co-Developer.
14.25 Conflict of Interest. In accordance with A.R.S. § 38-503 and A.R.S. § 38-
511, no member, official or employee of the City is permitted to have any personal interest,
direct or indirect, in this Agreement, nor will any such member, official or employee participate
in any decision relating to this Agreement which affects his or her personal interest or the interest
of any corporation, partnership or association in which he or she is, directly or indirectly,
interested. This Agreement is subject to cancellation in accordance with the terms of A.R.S. §
38-511.
14.26 No Boycott of Israel. Developer certifies in accordance with A.R.S. § 35-
393.01 that they are not currently engaged in, and for the Term of this Agreement will not
engage in, a boycott of Israel.
14.27 Forced Ethnic Uyghur Labor Prohibition. As this Agreement relates to
Developer’s construction of public improvements, in accordance with the requirements of A.R.S.
§ 35-394 and to the extent applicable, Developer certifies that it does not currently, and agrees
for the Term of the Agreement that it will not, use: (a) the forced labor of ethnic Uyghurs in the
People’s Republic of China; (b) any goods or services produced by the forced labor of ethnic
Uyghurs in the People’s Republic of China; or (c) any contractors, subcontractors, or suppliers
that use the forced labor or any goods or services produced by the forced labor of ethnic Uyghurs
in the People’s Republic of China. If, after providing the certification described in this Section,
Developer becomes aware that it is not in compliance with the certification, it shall notify the
City within five (5) Business Days of becoming aware of the noncompliance. Developer
acknowledges that it must remedy the noncompliance and provide written certification of that
within one hundred eighty (180) days after notifying the City of its noncompliance. If Developer
{00624621.1} 27
fails to remedy the noncompliance and provide the written certification within one hundred
eighty (180) days, the Agreement will terminate automatically.
14.28 City Council Action. The Parties acknowledge that, notwithstanding any
language of this Agreement or any subsequent additional document, no act, requirement,
payment or other agreed-upon action to be done or performed by the City which would, under
any Applicable Laws require formal action, approval, or concurrence by the City Council, will
be required to be done or performed by the City unless and until said formal City Council action
is taken and is no longer subject to referendum. This Agreement does not bind the City Council
or remove its independent authority to make determinations related to action of the City Council
in any way.
14.29 Waiver of Claims Under A.R.S. § 12-1134 et seq. Each Co-Developer
now fully and unconditionally waives and releases the City for, from and against any and all
claims arising directly or indirectly under A.R.S. § 12-1134, et seq., including any right to
compensation for reduction to the fair market value of all or any part of Property as a result of
City’s approval of this Agreement, any and all restrictions and requirements imposed on a Co-
Developer by this Agreement, the City’s approval of Developer’s plans and specifications for the
Project, the issuance of any permits, and all related Zoning, land use, building and development
matters arising from, relating to, or reasonably inferable from this Agreement. This is a material
and specifically bargained-for term of this Agreement, without which the City would not have
entered into this Agreement. The terms of the waiver in this Section 14.29 (a) run with Property
and all land that is the subject of this Agreement, (b) are binding upon the Parties, their permitted
successors and assigns, and all subsequent landowners, assignees, lessees and other successors,
and (c) survive the expiration or earlier termination of this Agreement.
14.30 Consent. Wherever the City’s consent is required to be given in this
Agreement, such consent will be the consent of the City Manager (or designee), without the
requirement of the prior approval of the City Council unless required by Applicable Laws, City
policy, or determination of the City Manager. Any consent required by or from the City Council
will be in the sole, absolute and unfettered legislative discretion of the City Council.
15. Execution and Delivery. The Parties have executed and delivered this Agreement
to be effective as of the Effective Date.
[THREE (3) SIGNATURE PAGES FOLLOW]
{00624621.1} 28
FIRST SIGNATURE PAGE TO DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT
CITY:
CITY OF MESA,
an Arizona municipal corporation
By: ____________________________
Scott Butler, City Manager
Date: ________________
ATTEST:
By: ____________________________
City Clerk
STATE OF ARIZONA )
) ss
COUNTY OF MARICOPA )
On _____________________, 2026, before me, ______________, a Notary Public in and
for said State, personally appeared Scott Butler, the City Manager of the City of Mesa, an
Arizona municipal corporation, personally known to me (or proved to me on the basis of
satisfactory evidence) to be the person whose name is subscribed to the within instrument and
acknowledged to me that he executed the same in his/her authorized capacity, and that by his
signature on the instrument the person, or the entity upon behalf of which the person acted,
executed the instrument.
WITNESS my hand and official seal.
Signature ______________________________
[SEAL]
{00624621.1} 29
SECOND SIGNATURE PAGE TO DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT
ELLIOT LAND OWNER:
MARTENS ELLIOT LAND LLC,
an Arizona limited liability company
By: ________________________________
Printed name: ________________________
Title: _______________________________
Date: ________________
STATE OF ARIZONA )
) ss
COUNTY OF MARICOPA )
On _____________________, 2026, before me, ______________, a Notary Public in and
for said State, personally appeared ______________________, the ______________________
of Martens Elliot Land LLC, an Arizona limited liability company, personally known to me (or
proved to me on the basis of satisfactory evidence) to be the person whose name is subscribed to
the within instrument and acknowledged to me that he/she executed the same in his/her
authorized capacity, and that by his/her signature on the instrument the person, or the entity upon
behalf of which the person acted, executed the instrument.
WITNESS my hand and official seal.
Signature ______________________________
[SEAL]
{00624621.1} 30
THIRD SIGNATURE PAGE TO DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT
ELLIOT RETAIL OWNER:
MARTENS ELLIOT RETAIL PADS LLC, an Arizona
limited liability company
By: ______________________________
Printed Name: ________________________
Its: ______________________________
Date: ________________
STATE OF ______________ )
) ss
COUNTY OF ____________ )
On _____________________, 2026, before me, ______________, a Notary Public in and
for said State, personally appeared _________________, the __________________________ of
Martens Elliot Retail LLC, an Arizona limited liability company, personally known to me (or
proved to me on the basis of satisfactory evidence) to be the person whose name is subscribed to
the within instrument and acknowledged to me that he/she executed the same in his/her
authorized capacity, and that by his/her signature on the instrument the person, or the entity upon
behalf of which the person acted, executed the instrument.
WITNESS my hand and official seal.
Signature ______________________________
[SEAL]
{00624621.1} 31
INDEX OF DEFINED TERMS
DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT
“10-Mile Radius” is defined in Section 4.3(c).
“Affiliate”, as applied to any Person, means any Person directly or indirectly Controlling,
Controlled by, or under common Control with, that Person or a blood relative or spouse of such
Person, if such Person is a natural person. For the purposes of this definition, (1) “Control”
(including with correlative meaning, the terms “Controlling,” “Controlled by” and “under
common Control”), as applied to any Person, means the possession, directly or indirectly, of the
power to direct or cause the direction of the management and policies of that Person, whether
through the ownership of voting securities, by contract or otherwise, and (2) “Person” means
and includes natural persons, corporations, limited partnerships, general partnerships, joint stock
companies, joint ventures, associations, limited liability companies, limited liability partnerships,
limited liability limited partnerships, trusts, land trusts, business trusts or other organizations,
whether or not legal entities.
“Agreement” means this Agreement, as amended and restated or supplemented in writing from
time to time and includes the Recitals and attached Exhibits which are incorporated by reference
and form a part of this Agreement.
“Applicable Laws” means, collectively, the federal, State, county and local laws (statutory and
common law), ordinances, rules, regulations, standards, permit requirements, and other
requirements and official policies of the City, as they presently exist or may be amended or
hereafter enacted from time to time, which apply to the development of Legacy Park, including
the City Code, the General Plan, Zoning, City Building Regulations (Title 4, Mesa City Code),
City Subdivision Regulations, and all related approvals or requirements by City Council or City
boards. Applicable Laws expressly include all Hazardous Materials Laws.
“A.R.S.” means Arizona Revised Statutes as now or later enacted or amended.
“Business Day” is Monday through Thursday excluding any legal holidays in which the City’s
offices are closed.
“CIP Project” is defined in Recital F.
“City” is defined in the first grammatical paragraph of this Agreement.
“City Code” means the Code of the City of Mesa, Arizona, as amended from time to time.
“City Council” means the City Council for the City of Mesa, Arizona.
“City Indemnified Parties” is defined in Section 6.1.
“City Manager” means the City Manager of Mesa, Arizona (or designee).
{00624621.1}
“Claim” and “Claims” are defined in Section 6.1.
“Co-Developer” is defined in the first grammatical paragraph of this Agreement, and includes
each of Elliot Land Owner’s and Elliot Retail Owner’s permitted successors and assigns,
respectively.
“Commercial Area” is defined in Section 4.2.
“Commencement of Construction,” “Commenced Construction,” “Commenced” or
“Commencement” means both (1) the obtaining of a building, excavation, grading or similar
permit by Developer for the construction of any portion of the Project, and (2) the actual
commencement of physical construction operations on the Property in a manner necessary to
achieve Completion of Construction of the Project.
“Completion of Construction,” “Completed Construction,” “Completed” or “Completion”
means the date on which both of the following have occurred: (1) the temporary or, if a
temporary is not issued, final certificate of occupancy for the applicable location and portion of
the Project is issued by the City; and (2) with regard to the Project Public Improvements, prior to
the issuance of a certificate of occupancy, all work in public rights of way must be completed,
and acceptance and approval obtained for warranty and requirements, in accordance with the
policies, standards, and specifications contained in Applicable Law. A temporary certificate of
occupancy may be issued by the City in accordance with City Code Section 4-1-6.
“Construction TPT” is defined in Section 5.2.4(b).
“County” means Maricopa County, Arizona.
“Default” means an Event of Default that has not been timely cured after Notice.
“Designated Lenders” is defined in Section 14.4.3.1.
“Developer” is defined in the first grammatical paragraph of this Agreement, and includes all of
Elliot Land Owner’s and Elliot Retail Owner’s permitted successors and assigns.
“Developer Public Improvement Contribution” is defined in Recital F.
“Effective Date” is defined in the first grammatical paragraph of this Agreement.
“Eligible Sales Tax” is defined in Section 5.2.4.
“Eligible Tax Base” is defined in Section 5.2.3.
“Elliot Land Owner” is defined in the first grammatical paragraph of this Agreement, and
includes all of Elliot Land Owner’s permitted successors and assigns.
“Elliot Land Property” is defined in Recital A and is legally described in Exhibit A-1.
“Elliot Retail Owner” is defined in the first grammatical paragraph of this Agreement, and
includes all of Elliot Retail Owner’s permitted successors and assigns.
{00624621.1}
“Elliot Retail Property” is defined in Recital B and is legally described in Exhibit A-2.
“Elliot Road Improvements” is defined in Recital F.
“Enforced Delay” is defined in Section 14.8.
“Event of Default” means as defined in Section 10 and is more specifically one or more of the
events described in Section 10.1, or Section 10.2.
“Fee” and “Fees” are defined in Section 2.2.
“Full-Service Restaurant” is defined in Section 4.3(a).
“General Plan” is defined in Recital D.
“General TPT” is defined in Section 5.2.4(a).
“Grace Period” is defined in Section 10.3.
“Hawes Crossing DA” is defined in Section 2.1.
“Hazardous Materials” means any substance: (1) that now or in the future is regulated or
governed by, requires investigation or remediation under, or is defined as a hazardous or toxic
waste, hazardous or toxic substance, pollutant or contaminant under any Hazardous Materials
Laws; (2) that is toxic, explosive, corrosive, flammable, radioactive, carcinogenic, dangerous or
otherwise hazardous, including gasoline, diesel fuel, petroleum hydrocarbons, any other
petroleum or petrochemical products or by-products, polychlorinated biphenyls, asbestos, lead,
radon, and urea formaldehyde foam insulation; or (3) that consists of or includes medical and
biohazard wastes regulated by federal, State, County or local laws or authorities, and includes
(but is not limited to) any solid waste which is generated in the diagnosis, treatment or
immunization of a human being or animal or in any research relating to that diagnosis, treatment
or immunization, or in the production or testing of biologicals.
“Hazardous Materials Laws” means any and all federal, State, County, municipal or other
governmental laws, statutes, ordinances, rules, decrees, orders, regulations, administrative
rulings and court decisions (including the so-called “common law”), or any amendment to any of
the foregoing, relating to Hazardous Materials and environmental conditions on, under or about
any of the real property (improved or unimproved) comprising or included in Legacy Park and
Gateway Crossing, including (solely by way of illustration and not of limitation) the
Comprehensive Environmental Response Compensation and Liability Act, 42 U.S.C. § 9601 et
seq., as amended; the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act, 42 U.S.C. § 6901 et seq., as
amended; the Toxic Substances Control Act, 15 U.S.C. §2601 et seq., as amended; the Safe
Drinking Water Act, 42 U.S.C. §§ 300f et seq., as amended; the Clean Air Act, 42 U.S.C. § 7401
et seq., as amended; the Arizona Hazardous Waste Management Act, A.RS. § 49-921 et seq., as
amended; the Arizona Environmental Quality Act, A.R.S. § 49-101 et seq., as amended; and any
other laws, rules, regulations, acts, and decisions that deal with the regulation of Hazardous
Materials or protection of the environment, including the ambient air, ground water, surface
{00624621.1}
water and land use, including sub-strata land, whether presently existing or enacted from and
after the Effective Date.
“Impasse” is defined in Section 11.1.
“Indemnify” is defined in Section 6.1.
“Lender” and “Lenders” are defined in Section 14.4.3.1.
“Mesa Tax Code” means title 5, chapter 10 of the City Code.
“Multi-Family Residential” is defined in Section 4.2.2.
“Noncompliance” is defined in Section 5.1.4.
“Notice” is defined in Section 14.7.1.
“Notice-and-Cure” is defined in Section 10.3.
“Official Records” means the Office of the Recorder of Maricopa County, Arizona.
“Pad Site” and “Pad Sites” are defined in Section 14.4.2.
“Party” and “Parties” are defined in the first grammatical paragraph of this Agreement.
“Permitted Extensions” is defined in Section 5.1.2.
“Private Improvements” is defined in Section 4.2.
“Project” is defined in Recital C.
“Project Public Improvement” is defined in Section 3.1.
“Property” is defined in Recital B.
“Public Health Event” means any one or more of the following, but only if declared by an
applicable governmental authority: epidemics; pandemics; plagues; viral, bacterial or infectious
disease outbreaks; public health crises; national health or medical emergencies; governmental
restrictions on the provision of goods or services or on citizens’ liberties, including travel,
movement, gathering or other activities, in each case arising in connection with any of the
foregoing, and including governmentally mandated closure, quarantine, “stay-at-home”, “shelter-
in-place” or similar orders or restrictions; or workforce shortages and disruptions of materials or
supply chains resulting from any of the foregoing.
“Project Public Improvements” means as defined in Section 3.1 and are such public
improvements and infrastructure that Developer constructs or causes to be constructed for the
Project that are directly related to the construction, development, or operation of the Project in
accordance with the requirements of this Agreement.
{00624621.1}
“Qualifying Restaurant” is defined in Section 4.3.
“Quarterly Payments” is defined in Section 5.5.1.1(a).
“Reimbursement” is defined in Section 5.
“Reimbursement Account” is defined in Section 5.4.1.
“Reimbursement Cap” is defined in Section 5.2.1.
“Reimbursement Commencement Date” is defined in Section 5.1.3.
“Reimbursement Condition” and “Reimbursement Conditions” is defined in Section 5.1.1.
“Reimbursement Period” is defined in Section 5.2.2.
“Reimbursement Report” is defined in Section 5.7.
“Restaurant Occupancy Minimum” is defined in Section 4.3.
“Restaurant Occupancy Term” is defined in Section 4.4.
“Satisfaction Date” is defined in Section 5.1.3.
“State” means the State of Arizona.
“State Shared Revenue” means the tax revenue subject to redistribution as described in A.R.S.
§ 41-194.01(B)(1)(a).
“Superior Court” is defined in Section 14.2.
“Suspension” is defined in Section 5.1.1.
“Term” is defined in Section 13.1.
“Third Party” or “Third-Party” means or refers to any Person other than a Party, or an
Affiliate of any Party.
“Title 34” means Title 34 (“Public Buildings and Improvements”) of Arizona Revised Statutes.
“TLT” is defined in Section 5.2.4.
“TPT” is defined in Section 5.2.4.
“U.S.C.” means the United States Code.
“Zoning” is defined in Recital D.
{00624621.1}
LIST OF EXHIBITS
DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT
Exhibit A-1: Legal Description of the Elliot Land Property
Exhibit A-2: Legal Description of the Elliot Retail Property
Exhibit A-3: Final Plat for “The Craftsman”
Exhibit B: Project Approved Site Plan
Exhibit C: Elliot Road Improvements
Exhibit D: City of Mesa Insurance Requirements
{00624621.1}
EXHIBIT A-1
DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT
LEGAL DESCRIPTION OF THE ELLIOT LAND PROPERTY
Lots 3 through 6, Lot 8, Lots 10 through 12, and Tracts, A, B, C and D of THE CRAFTSMAN,
according to the plat of record in the office of the County Recorder of Maricopa County,
Arizona, recorded in Book 1887 of Maps, page 44.
{00624621.1}
EXHIBIT A-2
DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT
LEGAL DESCRIPTION OF THE ELLIOT RETAIL PROPERTY
Lots 1 through 2, Lot 7, and Lot 9 of THE CRAFTSMAN, according to the plat of record in the
office of the County Recorder of Maricopa County, Arizona, recorded in Book 1887 of Maps,
page 44.
{00624621.1}
EXHIBIT A-3
DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT
FINAL PLAT FOR “THE CRAFTSMAN”
(SEE ATTACHED)
{00624621.1}
{00624621.1}
{00624621.1}
{00624621.1}
{00624621.1}
{00624621.1}
EXHIBIT B
DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT
PROJECT APPROVED SITE PLAN
(SEE ATTACHED)
{00624621.1}
{00624621.1}
EXHIBIT C
DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT
ELLIOT ROAD IMPROVEMENTS
(SEE ATTACHED)
{00624621.1}
{00624621.1}
EXHIBIT D
DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT
CITY OF MESA INSURANCE REQUIREMENTS
Developer, at their sole cost and expense, will maintain insurance coverage as follows:
A. Property. During the period of any construction involving the Project Public
Improvements and for a period of not less than three (3) years following Completion of
Construction, and with respect to any construction activities relating to the same, builder’s risk
insurance on an all-risk, replacement cost basis for the Project Public Improvements.
B. Liability. During the Term of the Agreement, insurance covering the Developer
and (endorsing as an additional insured) City against liability imposed by law or assumed in any
written contract, and/or arising from personal injury, bodily injury or property damage, with a
limit of liability of $3,000,000.00 per occurrence with a $3,000,000.00 products/completed
operations limit and a $10,000,000.00 general aggregate limit. Such policy must be primary and
written to provide blanket contractual liability, broad form property damage, premises liability
and products and completed operations.
C. Contractor. During the period of any construction involving the Project Public
Improvements and for a period of not less than three (3) years following Completion of
Construction, and with respect to any construction activities relating to the same, each of the
general or other contractors with which the Developer contracts for any such construction will be
required to carry liability insurance of the type and providing the minimum limits set forth
below:
(1) Workman’s Compensation insurance and Employer’s Liability with limits
of $1,000,000.00 per accident, $1,000,000.00 per disease and $1,000,000.00 policy limit disease.
(2) Commercial general liability insurance on a $3,000,000.00 per occurrence
basis providing coverage for (and endorsing the City as additional insured for):
Products and Completed Operations
Blanket Contractual Liability
Personal Injury Liability
Broad Form Property Damage
X.C.U.
(3) Business automobile liability including all owned, non-owned and hired
autos with a limit of liability of not less than $1,000,000.00 combined single limit for personal
injury, including bodily injury or death, and property damage.
D. Architect. In connection with any construction involving the Project Public
Improvements, and with respect to any construction activities relating to the same, the
Developer’s architect will be required to provide architect’s or engineer’s professional liability
{00624621.1}
insurance with a limit of $1,000,000.00 per occurrence. This policy, or other policies, will cover
claims for a period of not less than three (3) years after the Completion of Construction involving
Property and the Project Public Improvements.
E. Engineer. During the period of any construction involving the Public
Improvements, and with respect to any construction activities relating to the same, the
Developers’ soils engineer or environmental contractor will be required to provide engineer’s
professional liability insurance with a limit of $1,000,000.00 per occurrence. This policy, or
other policies, will cover claims for a period of not less than three (3) years after the Completion
of Construction involving Legacy Park and the Public Improvements.
F. Primary Coverage. Developer’s insurance coverage will be primary insurance
with respect to City, its officers, officials, agents, and employees. Any insurance or self-
insurance maintained by City, its officers, officials, agents, and employees will be in excess of
the coverage provided by Developers and will not contribute to it.
G. Indemnities. Coverage provided by Developer will not be limited to the liability
assumed under the indemnification provisions of the Agreement or exclude contractual liability.
H. Waiver of Subrogation. All policies will contain a waiver of subrogation in favor
of the City, its officers, officials, agents, and employees.
I. Notice of Cancellation. Each insurance policy will include provisions to the
effect that it may not be suspended, voided, cancelled, or reduced in coverage except after thirty
(30) days’ prior written Notice has been given to City. Such Notice must be provided directly to
City in accordance with the provisions of Section 14.7.1 of the Agreement.
J. Acceptability of Insurers. Insurance is to be placed with insurers duly licensed of
approved unlicensed companies in the State of Arizona and with an “A.M. Best” rating of not
less than A- VII. City in no way warrants that the above-required minimum insurer rating is
sufficient to protect Developers from potential insurer insolvency.
K. Endorsements and Verification of Coverage. Developer will furnish City with
endorsements naming the City, its officers, officials, agents, and employees as additional
insureds. The endorsements will be original certificates of insurance on ACCORD forms
approved by City. The certificates for each insurance policy are to be signed by a person
authorized by that insurer to bind coverage on its behalf. Any policy endorsements that restrict
or limit coverage will be clearly noted on the certificate of insurance.
(1) All certificates are to be received and approved by City before the
Commencement of Construction of the Public Improvements. Each insurance policy must be in
effect at or prior to the Commencement of Construction (after obtaining required permits actual
Commencement of physical construction) and must remain in effect for the duration set forth in
this Exhibit or, if no date is specified, the term of the Agreement. Failure to maintain the
insurance policies as required by this Agreement or to provide timely evidence of renewal will
be considered a material breach of the Agreement.
{00624621.1}
(2) All certificates required by this Agreement will be sent directly to City of
Mesa, Attn: Risk Manager, 20 E. Main Street, P.O. Box 1466, Mesa, Arizona 85211-1466. City
reserves the right to require complete, certified copies of all insurance policies and endorsements
required by this Exhibit at any time.
L. Approval. Any modification or variation from the insurance requirements in this
Exhibit must have prior approval from the City Manager (or designee), whose decision will be
final. Such action will not require formal contract amendment but may be made by
administrative action.
M. Miscellaneous. References to “Developer” in this Exhibit will mean and include
Elliot Land Owner, Elliot Retail Owner and Developers’ general contractor(s). References to the
“Agreement” will mean the Development Agreement of which this Exhibit is a part. Capitalized
terms not otherwise defined in this Exhibit will have the meanings set forth in the Agreement.
City in no way warrants that the minimum limits contained in this Exhibit are sufficient to
protect Developer from liabilities that might arise, and Developer may purchase such additional
insurance as Developer determines necessary. As Elliot Land Owner and Elliot Retail Owner are
jointly and severally liable under the Agreement, each must maintain insurance meeting the
coverage requirements and limits set forth in this Exhibit.
{00624621.1}