Attachment A - Oct. 28, 2026 CSE Minutes.pdf

City of Phoenix — Community Services and Education Subcommittee (2026-11-17)

View PDF Meeting page

Extracted text (via pymupdf_layout) 10963 characters
ATTACHMENT A
Phoenix City Council
Community Services and Education (CSE) Subcommittee
Summary Minutes
Wednesday, October 28, 2026
City Council Chambers
200 W. Jefferson St.
Phoenix, Ariz.
Subcommittee Members Present Subcommittee Members Absent
Vice Mayor Kesha Hodge Washington, Chair
Councilwoman Anna Hernandez
Councilwoman Ann O’Brien
Councilwoman Debra Stark
CALL TO ORDER
Chairwoman Hodge Washington called the Community Services and Education
Subcommittee (CSE) to order at 10:31 a.m. with all members present.
MINUTES OF MEETINGS
1. Minutes of the Community Services and Education Subcommittee Meeting
Councilwoman Stark made a motion to approve the minutes of the September 23, 2026
Community Services and Education Subcommittee meeting. Councilwoman O’Brien
seconded the motion which passed unanimously, 4-0.
CONSENT ACTION (ITEMS 2-3)
Items 2-3 were for consent action. No presentations were planned, but staff was
available to answer questions.
2. 2027-28 Housing and Urban Development Consolidated Plan Annual Action
Plan Process Kick-Off – Neighborhood Services
Councilwoman Hernandez asked how much money will be allocated to the City of
Phoenix from the Housing and Urban Development (HUD) grants.
Neighborhood Services Department Director Spencer Self responded and said they do
not yet know how much will be allocated.
Councilwoman Hernandez asked what metrics will define successful community
engagement.
Mr. Self explained that staff has an extensive list of metrics that is reported to HUD for
each program funded by the grants.

Councilwoman Hernandez shared her excitement for the future of the program as well
as the community’s engagement.
3. Code Enforcement Policy Update
Councilwoman Hernandez thanked the Neighborhood Services Department for their
work regarding this issue and highlighted the importance of updated code enforcement.
Councilwoman O’Brien made a motion to approve Items 2-3. Councilwoman Stark
seconded the motion which passed unanimously, 4-0.
INFORMATION ONLY (ITEM 4)
4. Head Start Birth to Five Monthly Report - August
Information only. No Councilmember requested additional information.
INFORMATION AND DISCUSSION (ITEMS 5-7)
5. College Depot: Gateway to GRIT
Phoenix Public Library Director Erin MacFarlane and Strategic Programs Director Judy
Reno presented this item.
Ms. Reno introduced College Depot, Grit, ReEngage Phoenix, and Craft a Profession.
Ms. Reno provided data on College Depot's visits, assistance, and participants.
Ms. Reno shared a pie chart detailing the types of people utilizing College Depot.
Ms. Reno detailed the services offered through College Depot.
Ms. Reno introduced Phoenix Public Library’s new program, Gateway to GRIT, and
explained the program and its target demographic.
Ms. Reno detailed the goals of the Gateway to GRIT program.
Ms. Reno described the program's monthly offerings and its goal of growth.
Ms. Reno shared a testimony about the Gateway to GRIT program detailing how the
program helped the participant prepare for and attend Arizona State University.
Councilwoman Stark commended College Depot and Ms. Reno.
Councilwoman Hernandez asked if this program is available at all libraries or exclusively
at Burton Barr.
Ms. Reno answered that Burton Barr is where their staff is based, and that they rely on
outreach at other branches, high schools, and community organizations.

Councilwoman Hernandez asked how they execute their outreach.
Ms. MacFarlane explained that outreach is done through many channels and
highlighted that Ms. Reno and her team's relationship with Phoenix Union High School
District provides direct advertising through schools. She then shared their plan to
introduce an ambassador role to connect directly with those curious about the
programs. She included that there is a virtual option for those who may be far from
Burton Barr.
Councilwoman Hernandez commended the increase in scholarship opportunities and
inclusivity. She described the positive impact this will have on our youth and the City.
Councilwoman O'Brien praised staff’s outreach across the City and their data collection.
She then asked whether there is a way to measure how many program participants
obtained their degree.
Ms. Reno answered that staff can share that data.
Councilwoman O'Brien said she would like to see the graduation rate data to strengthen
the program's credibility. She then asked for a copy of the data-sharing agreement to
provide to other school districts and thanked staff for their work.
Chairwoman Hodge Washington thanked staff for their work on both programs and
emphasized the importance of education and access to resources for participants of all
ages. She expressed interest in post-enrollment data and asked how they can measure
success, as well as their plans for juniors in high school.
Ms. Reno explained that they collect a lot of data and want to use it to gauge interest
among juniors and eventually high school wide.
Chairwoman Hodge Washington expressed strong interest in preparing students as
early as possible and the benefits that follow. She congratulated staff on their success
in the programs.
6. Head Start Governing Board Orientation
Human Services Director Jacqueline Edwards, Human Services Assistant Director
Nichole Ayoola, and Human Services Deputy Director Michelle Kuamoo presented this
item.
Ms. Ayoola provided an overview of the Head Start program.
Ms. Ayoola shared how the program receives funding, as well as how many people are
enrolled and serve as service providers.
Ms. Ayoola shared a graphic detailing the program's leadership and governance and
explained their roles.

Ms. Kuamoo shared the program's three focus areas for Fiscal Year 2026-27.
Ms. Kuamoo detailed program eligibility and how to apply.
Ms. Kuamoo shared that the program has a required waitlist and explained how it
prioritizes those with greater needs.
Ms. Ayoola provided a closing overview of the presentation.
Chairwoman Hodge Washington thanked the presenters and highlighted the importance
of their roles as governing board members for the program.
Councilwoman Hernandez asked whether any federal updates have affected the policy
or leadership day-to-day.
Ms. Edwards responded that a new notice of proposed rulemaking was released and
that comments were submitted because of the drastic changes it would have. She
shared that those comments are now under review and that more information will be
provided in the new year. She added that nothing new has been added that will affect
the governance structure.
Councilwoman Hernandez asked whether participants' feedback is used to highlight its
significance.
Ms. Edwards responded that the Human Services Department receives feedback from
all its services, and that Head Start receives the highest marks.
Councilwoman Hernandez stated that this was no surprise and thanked the program
and its staff for their work.
7. Neighborhood Services Department Update on Infill Property Dispositions
Neighborhood Services Department Director Spencer Self and Deputy Director of
Neighborhood Services Matt Utyro presented this item.
Mr. Utyro shared two requests for proposals, one in South Mountain Village and another
in the Isaac Redevelopment Area.
Mr. Self shared that these proposals could create a total of 371 affordable housing
units.
Mr. Utyro shared and explained a visual timeline of the disposition.
Mr. Utyro shared details of the proposal for the South Mountain Village, which included
three packages, 17 vacant lots, and the creation of 113 housing units.

Mr. Utyro shared details of the proposal for the Isaac Redevelopment Area, which
included five packages, 38 vacant lots, and 258 housing units.
Mr. Self reminded the subcommittee that no action has been taken yet and that they are
still in a period of transparency. He shared that community members with questions can
reach out to their project managers.
Mr. Self thanked the leadership and staff of the Housing Department for their role in the
Housing Phoenix Plan and coordination on the dispositions.
Chairwoman Hodge Washington thanked staff for their work in putting vacant properties
to good use.
Councilwoman Hernandez asked for an explanation of what disposition means for
Phoenix.
Mr. Self acknowledged that City jargon may be hard to follow and that, for the City,
disposition means properties Phoenix has owned for various reasons will go through a
process to be converted to housing.
Councilwoman Hernandez asked whether updates will be provided on the sale of the
units, ensuring they are sold to their intended demographic.
Mr. Self responded that this is an absolute part of the proposal process, as well as the
model being used.
Councilwoman Hernandez thanked and congratulated District 4 and District 8.
Chairwoman Hodge Washington asked how the City ensures affordability within these
developments and what mechanisms are in place to ensure it.
Mr. Utyro answered that negotiations help them understand contractual responsibilities
and that they remain involved in all processes throughout the agreed contractual time
span.
Mr. Self added that there are many types of housing and that each has a different path
to follow.
Chairwoman Hodge Washington added that this ensures that those who need
affordable housing know the City will be involved long-term.
Chairwoman Hodge Washington asked if there is an opportunity to engage the
community on compatibility with the projects and their neighborhoods.
Mr. Utyro highlighted the importance of community involvement in community meetings
upon receiving approval from council for input on integration and features of these
buildings.

Chairwoman Hodge Washington shared that staff highlighted what she hoped they
would and that this exemplifies how the City is addressing resident concerns regarding
housing.
CALL TO THE PUBLIC
Aldo Gonzales shared that he is the engagement director for the Protectors of the Salt
River organization and that they clean the Salt River every Sunday, logging hundreds of
hours. He shared that they are seeking investment in native habitat restoration, shaded
green spaces along the river, Indigenous-led cultural signage with O'odham
translations, resident farming and coaching, and neighborhood cooling.
Sarah Warren introduced herself and shared that she volunteers with the Protectors of
the Salt River. She explained that in three years they have completed over 615
volunteer shifts across three acres, removed 740 bags of trash and invasive plants from
the river and nearby areas, supported local vendors, and are deeply invested in
protecting the water near the transformation site. She expressed that they are seeking
help from the City through education for their organization. She listed different possible
benefits from the City backing their projects.
FUTURE AGENDA ITEMS
None.
ADJOURNMENT
Chairwoman Hodge Washington adjourned the meeting at 11:29 a.m.
Respectfully submitted,
Caitlin Johnston
Management Fellow