Planning and Zoning Regular Meeting Minutes 10.21.2026
Extracted text (via pymupdf_layout)
23447 characters
Meeting Minutes Planning and Zoning Commission Regular Meeting October 21, 2026 I 5:30 p.m. ,::._CHANDLER Chandler City Council Chambers +j\,ar1zona 88 E. Chicago St., Chandler, AZ Community of Innovation Call to Order The meeting was called to order by Chair Koshiol at 6:00 p.m. Roll Call Commission Attendance Staff Attendance Chair Sherri Koshiol David de la Torre, Acting Planning Admin. Vice Chairman Tom Bilsten Lauren Schumann, Acting Planning Manager Commissioner Mike Quinn Alisa Petterson, Senior City Planner Commissioner Charlotte Golla Taylor Manemann, City Planner Commissioner Ryan Schwarzer Thomas Allen, Assistant City Attorney Commissioner Tracy Ducharme Danielle Smee, Clerk Commissioner Dan Gauthier Pledge of Allegiance The Pledge of Allegiance was led by Commissioner Gauthier. Scheduled and Unscheduled Public Appearances Members of the audience may address any item not on the agenda. State Statute prohibits the Board or Commission from discussing an item that is not on the agenda, but the Board or Commission does listen to your concerns and has staff follow up on any questions you raise. Consent Agenda and Discussion 1. September 16, 2026, Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting Minutes Move Planning and Zoning Commission approve Planning and Zoning Commission meeting minutes of the Study Session and Regular Meeting of September 16, 2026. 2. Rezoning and Preliminary Development Plan, The Station at Park Place Rezoning Move Planning and Zoning Commission recommend approval of Rezoning PLH26-0012 The Station at Park Place, amending the PAD zoning to allow multi-family residential as part of a mixed use development southeast corner of Price Road and Santan 202 Freeway, subject to the conditions as recommended by Planning staff. Preliminary Development Plan Move Planning and Zoning Commission recommend approval of Preliminary Development Plan PLH26-0012 The Station at Park Place for site layout and building architecture southeast corner of Price Road and Santan 202 Freeway, subject to the conditions as recommended by Planning staff. 3. Area Plan Amendment, Rezoning and Preliminary Development Plan, Hamstra Crossing Area Plan Move Planning and Zoning Commission recommend approval of PLH26-0027 Area Plan Amendment to Chandler Airpark Area Plan, from Innovation District to Commercial Office District located at the northwest corner of McQueen and Germann roads, as recommended by Planning staff. Rezoning Move Planning and Zoning Commission recommend approval of Rezoning PLH26-0022 Hamstra Crossing, rezoning from PAD for RV storage, fuel station and retail development, to PAD amended to remove specific architectural design requirements located at the northwest corner of McQueen and Germann roads, subject to the conditions as recommended by Planning staff. Preliminary Development Plan Move Planning and Zoning Commission recommend approval of Preliminary Development Plan PLH26-0022 Hamstra Crossing for site layout and building architecture located at the northwest corner of McQueen and Germann roads, subject to the conditions as recommended by Planning staff. 4. Rezoning, Social Tap Chandler Page 2 of 11 Move Planning and Zoning Commission recommend approval of PLH26-0023 Social Tap Chandler, amending an existing Planned Area Development (PAD) zoning to allow reduced setbacks for a patio cover, located at 135 W Ocotillo Road, generally located at the Southwest corner of Arizona Avenue and Ocotillo Road, subject to the conditions as recommended by Planning staff. 5. Preliminary Development Plan, Desert Palms- Burlington Signs Move Planning and Zoning Commission recommend approval of Preliminary Development Plan PLH26-0031 Desert Palms - Burlington Signs for a comprehensive sign plan for an existing shopping center located at the northeast corner of Alma School and Warner roads, subject to the conditions as recommended by Planning staff. 6. Notice of Cancellation of November, 4, 2026, Planning and Zoning Commission Hearing Notice of Cancellation of the November 4, 2026, Planning and Zoning Commission due to lack of items. CHAIR KOSHIOL inquired if any audience member wished to speak on any of the items on the Consent Agenda. CHAIR KOSHIOL asked ALISA PETTERSON, SENIOR PLANNER to read the revised stipulations for Item #3, Hamstra Crossing. ALISA PETTERSON read the updated stipulations for the record as follows: Rezoning: Move Planning and Zoning Commission recommend approval of rezoning PLH26-0022 Hamstra Crossing from PAD for RV storage, fuel storage and retail development, to PAD fuel station and regional commercial (C-3) zoning district uses, located at the northwest Queen Creek and Germann Roads, subject to the conditions as recommended by Planning Staff. Preliminary Development Plan: Uses permitted on the property shall be those permitted in the regional commercial (C-3) zoning district, in addition to RV storage, fuel station and retail development as provided in the Hamstra Crossing Development booklet. Stipulation #9: Free standing monument signs shall be prohibited from using any digital signs, excluding the digital fuel pricing cabinet, unless a sign code text amendment is approved at a later date by city council. COMMISSIONER QUINN motioned to approve the Consent Agenda items with the revised stipulations on Item 3, Hamstra Crossing, seconded by COMMISSIONER SCHWARZER. Consent Agenda approved unanimously (7-0). Page 3 of 11 Action Agenda and Discussion 7. Rezoning and Preliminary Development Plan, Vale Sereno Rezoning Move Planning and Zoning Commission recommend approval of Rezoning PLH26-0021 Vale Sereno, Rezoning from Agricultural District (AG-1) and Planned Area Development (PAD) for general and medical office to PAD for single-family residential, generally located at the southeast corner of Chandler Heights and Cooper Roads, subject to the conditions as recommended by Planning staff. Preliminary Development Plan Move Planning and Zoning Commission recommend approval of Preliminary Development Plan PLH26-0021 Vale Sereno for subdivision layout and housing product for a 53-lot single-family subdivision, generally located at the southeast corner of Chandler Heights and Cooper Roads, subject to the conditions as recommended by Planning staff. TAYLOR MANEMANN, CITY PLANNER presented PLH26-0021 Vale Sereno. MS. MANEMANN reviewed the current zoning and the history of the area. MS. MANEMANN noted there is a portion of this proposed development that is in Maricopa County and that this would involve an annexation. The property is located in the Southeast Chandler Area Plan. MS. MANEMANN reported there would be primary access to the development on Chandler Heights and secondary access residents and emergency access only, located off Via De Palmas. MS. MANEMANN reviewed the amenities in the community, including a ramada, dog park, tot lot and walking paths. MS. MANEMANN reviewed lot sizes, building heights, lot coverage, setbacks for the 53 single-family homes proposed totaling 4.38 dwelling units per acre. Lot 53 has a larger size setback on the side yard, as stipulated. MS. MANEMANN reviewed that this side yard for this specific lot is immediately adjacent to a backyard of a resident in McKinley Glenn. Other separation was also incorporated in this project from the current homes and the proposed homes. MS. MANEMANN reviewed the elevations of the proposed housing product, noting there is a single story, a partial two-story and a full two-story option provided. It was noted there are specific lots that can only be single story or the partial two-story. Neighborhood meetings were held July 28, 2026, with 17 community members in attendance. There have been 15 letters received and four phone calls with concerns and in opposition of the project, including two letters included in the addendum memos before the Commissioners as they were received after the agenda had been posted. Concerns included density, two-story building heights, setbacks and buffering, and traffic and access. The main concern with density was that Page 4 of 11 the lot size and density were not in character with the area. Per staff research, the average aggregate density within a half-mile radius of the site does not exceed the 2.5 dwelling units per acre from the Southeast Chandler Area Plan. There is reportedly a common occurrence of two story homes within a one-mile radius of the area. For setbacks and buffering, there were concerns with two-story homes backing up to the existing homes. MS. MANEMANN stated that the applicant did rework the site plan to address those setbacks to create buffering and restricted where two story structures can be located. The applicant submitted a traffic impact statement that was submitted to traffic engineering, which did not identify any issues or concerns with site circulation or traffic generation for this project. Staff finds the request to be in conformance with the General Plan and the Southeast Chandler Area Plan. Staff recommended approval with stipulations. MS. MANEMANN shared a modification to stipulation #10 to remove the prohibition of sport courts in the north side yard (Lot #53). Staff removed the language at the recommendation of the Assistant City Attorney as Planning Staff is not able to regulate sport courts since there is no permit required to be submitted for the city for single-family property owners to construct a sport court. CHAIR KOSHIOL asked if there were any questions for MS. MANEMANN. COMMISSIONER GAUTHIER inquired if this was the first application in which average aggregate density was used. DAVID DE LA TORRE, ACTING PLANNING ADMINISTRATOR reported here have been several applications within the Southeast Chandler Area Plan that have used this density and sited the community VIVIEN DO as an example. CHAIR KOSHIOL inquired if this was the same housing product that was constructed at Viviendo. MS. MAN EM MAN reported it to be a similar housing product, but different floor plans are used in this instance. CHAIR KOSHIOL asked about the neighborhood meeting held and asked if the changes requested by the residents were addressed. MS. MANEMANN shared that the changes were made to the floor plan restrictions and increasing those restrictions on the east side to have every other lot be restricted to the single story or hybrid and the restrictions for lot #53 for the side yard setbacks were also implemented from concerns at the neighborhood meetings. Page 5 of 11 VICE CHAIR BILSTEN shared he liked the lot restrictions that were set and asked if there was a regulation on those partial two-story homes and how much of the home is two story versus one story. MS. MANEMANN directed Commissioners to the stipulation in the Preliminary Development Plan and stated there not a set percentage of what portion is two-story on a partial two-story home. VICE CHAIR BILSTEN noted that there were some concerns about building heights based on emails from residents and that the Preliminary Development Plan could provide the residents with something to look toward if they had concerns about what lots would have which housing product. COMMISSIONER SCHWARZER asked about Lot 53 and the setbacks, asking if that was included within the lot and that it was not a landscape tract. MS. MANEMANN stated that was correct, there would be no dedicated landscape tract, the space would be a part of Lot 53. COMMISSIONER SCHWARZER followed up about Lot 53 being a larger lot and that maybe it should be looked at putting back some of that space back into the community for a buffer for the residents of McKinley Glen. MS. MANEMANN shared that that was provided as an option but that it would be an un-manned area that is not looked at consistently and could turn into a sort of "alley" which is why the current option was chosen by the applicant. JESSIE RAY, APPLICANT, reviewed the current zoning and proposed project. MS. RAY reiterated MS. MANEMANN'S presentation. MS. RAY reviewed maps of the area as well as the proposed elevations of the housing products and reviewed the lot restrictions that have been made for where two-story homes can be within the community. MS. RAY stated that this will provide housing for the area, and that they have created a mindful plan for a functional and sustainable community. COMMISSIONER SCHWARZER asked about clarification on Lot 53 and if it was restricted to a one story home option only as he was not sure MS. RAY'S presentation matched MS. MANEMANN'S. MS. MANEMANN stated her presentation included that as a one-story home option, the same as MS. RAYS. COMMISSIONER GAUTHIER asked to go back to a slide to review if there was a 15-foot landscape buffer on the homes to the North and west of Lot 53. MS. RAY stated that yes there was a landscape buffer there. Page 6 of 11 COMMISSIONER GAUTHIER asked about Lot 53 and staff being unable to stipulate the landscaping on that buffer space. MS. RAY clarified that it would be landscaping on a single-family lot, done in the future after the owners have moved in. She noted that the housing developer, K. Hovanian, would provide the landscaping on this lot in that area and that the homeowner would be responsible for ongoing upkeep. CHAIR KOSHIOL opened the floor to the public. STEVEN BACHMANN (12819 E Chandler Heights Road, Chandler) opposed the development, stating that he has been active in providing some content about the feelings of the neighbors in the area. MR. BACHMANN stated he was concerned with the density proposed, stating the density felt higher than anything else in the area. Additionally, MR. BACHMANN stated that this was too many two-story homes for the area and that it was out of character for this area of the Chandler. JEFF GEHLING (12839 E Chandler Heights Road, Chandler) stated he was the property owner directly north of the proposed area and that he would share about 500 feet of shared property. He stated his concerns were with the density and the lot size and concerns for his privacy with the two-story homes bordering his property. MR. GEHLING recognized the buffer that was created but that overall, the windows of the two-story houses would look directly into his yard. MR. GEHLING stated that he was asked to present his concerns to the home builder and he has yet to get a response from the representative about his concerns, nor did he get a response to his e mail. MR. GEHLING reported that there is a lot nearby that has a lot of dirt that was dropped on it and that it has caused issues with drainage and water that he would like to see addressed with this project. MR. GEHLING shared that in a square mile there were not many two-story homes and if there were they were on much larger lots than what is being proposed. KEN MCALLISTER (24206 124th Street, Chandler) was in opposition to Vale Sereno, stating that the project was too dense and was not consistent to the surrounding area. MR. MCALLISTER stated that he was originally told that the Via De Palmas gate would only be an egress at one neighborhood meeting and then was told that it was only emergency access at another, but that now it is emergency access and for residents to use. MR. MCALLISTER stated he did not want that in the proposal. MR. MCALLISTER also asked about who currently maintains Via De Palmas and that the city has not done any road improvements on Via De Palmas. MR. MCALLISTER stated that one of the neighborhood meetings he asked about the irrigation pipe for the county residents. He stated that somebody argued with him at the meeting and he was told by MR. BRENNAN RAY that it would be investigated further. MR. MCALLISTER stated he has yet to hear from MR. RAY. MR. MCALLISTER stated he was overall not opposed to developing in that area, but that wanted it to be right for the area. Page 7 of 11 MICHELLE WOOD (2141 E Nolan Place, Chandler) stated she owns the home that will back to Lot 53. She stated she was not opposed to the development of the area but that it is not compatible with the surrounding area, stating that two-story homes are not in the immediate area and if so, they sit on lots that double in size than the lots being proposed. MS. WOOD stated she would like to see more single-story homes and larger lots to preserve what makes that part of Chandler special. ERIC BOSHOVEN (12840 E VIA DE PALMAS) stated he has more footage that will back up to this project than others that have previously spoken. He stated he is happy with this project, though he does have concern for the egress/ingress as this has appeared to change over the neighborhood meetings. He believed it would be better if it was more limited access. He noted that the irrigation pipe has been discussed and he is aware of what would be happening on his property and how the existing box will be moved south to continue to feed those existing properties and irrigation will not be affected. MR. BOSH EVEN stated there are many two-story lots in the area so he felt that was an invalid argument that others were making. SUE PHILLAPOT (2200 E Cedar Place, Chandler) reported her home looks out to Via De Palmas. She reported her main concern to be the access point on Via De Palmas, stating that for Via De Palmas she would like it to be emergency access only as the road is not fully improved and she has concerns about it worsening traffic. MS. PHILLAPOT referenced that there are nearby similar size neighborhoods that only have one gate for residents. EILEEN BEVERAGE (24004 S Cooper Road, Chandler) agreed with the density concerns of previous speakers and stated there are concerns about the traffic that will come to that area. MS. BEVERAGE stated that the gate access changed between the 1st and 2nd Neighborhood meetings, which she found to be frustrating. DAVE SHAPIRO (12515 E Chandler Heights, Chandler) stated that he has known MR. RAY for a long time and feels that he may forget what the area is supposed to be like in South Chandler with a more rural feel. MR. SHAPIRO echoed his concerns with the density and wants that to be taken into consideration. COMMISSIONER SCHWARZER asked if the city and/or developers have looked at the ingress/egress as there seemed to be conflicting messages from what residents have said throughout the evening about the proposed secondary gate access. COMMISSIONER SCHWARZER asked about the traffic and stated maybe on entrance could be enough. MS. MANEMANN stated the statement from the traffic engineer regarding the traffic study provided by the applicant, that there could be a secondary access point for residents and emergency at that location. CHAIR KOSHIOL closed the floor to speakers and invited MS. RAY back to the floor for her rebuttal. Page 8 of 11 MS. RAY stated that she and MR. RAY did hear the concern of residents regarding density and that the proposed housing development would be meeting the density for the area plan. MS. RAY stated that none of the properties on the northeast directly touch the development and that it has a landscape tract and a roadway in between. MS. RAY stated there are 950-1000 homes in a one mile radius that are two-story in the surrounding area. MS. RAY stated that great care was taken for this area and it is consistent with the surrounding area. As far as the emergency access, MS. RAY stated that whether this is developed or not, people will come down that road if there is an error with mapping software, as pointed out by previously concerns from residents. VICE CHAIR BILSTEN asked if Via de Pal mas was a public road. MS. MANEMANN stated that her understanding was that Via De Palmas is a public road. LAUREN SCHUMANN, ACTING PLANNING MANAGER stated that this development would be required to improve their half of Via De Palmas to allow for two-way traffic from their property to Cooper Road. VICE CHAIR BILSTEN asked if Via De Palmas is a through street that can drivers can use as a shortcut to access other streets to the east. MS. MANEMANN stated that Via De Pal mas does not currently and would not cut further east with this project. She noted there is a turn around point at the end of Via De Pal mas. VICE CHAIR BILSTEN asked about responsiveness with the developer and stipulations as this was a concern from a speaker. He stated that it would be regulated by the city and wanted to assure the residents of that. MS. MANEMANN stated that was correct and that when the plot plans come into the city, they are reviewed with the stipulations to ensure the stipulations are being upheld. COMMISSIONER SCHWARZER asked MS. MANEMANN to speak about the Southeast Chandler Area Plan, stating that this project may not have things that fit that "agrarian call back," such as Spanish elevations for housing product. MS. MANEMANN shared that the density is the primary characteristic of this area plan and that there are other character areas with design regulations but that this site as a whole meets the area plan in that it regulates two-story on the arterial streets and that along Cooper Road there is a larger setback and the wall depths are varied. Additionally, height and levels of landscaping and attention to detail on architecture are also things that are considered in this area. Page 9 of 11 DAVID DE LA TORRE stated that the Southeast Chandler Area Plan was first created in 1999. There are now only infill parcels left that cannot do the big things, like bodies of water, that they previously did in older neighborhoods in the area and that solutions in development are being made, while still meeting the area plan requirements. COMMISSIONER GAUTHIER asked about the ingress/egress and the statement made from the traffic engineer. COMMISSIONER GAUTHIER asked if that was the traffic engineers' recommendation to have it ingress/egress. MS. MANEMANN stated that was correct that it would be recommended that they could have the gate ingress/egress and not emergency only. CHAIR KOSHIOL thanked staff and applicant for their presentations and for addressing residents' concerns. CHAIR KOSHIOL thanked and appreciated the residents for coming and speaking their concerns. CHAIR KOSHIOL stated that Chandler is transitioning from large green farms to a community where we all live and thrive together. CHAIR KOSHIOL shared she lives in an area nearby and has experienced a new development coming in adjacent to her area and that she understood the concerns residents may have. but shared she has seen a thriving community be created through these infill projects and that these developments allow people to join our community. CHAIR KOSHIOL stated she was in support of this project and asked if there were any other comments from the Commission. CHAIR KOSHIOL reminded Commissioners of the revised stipulation. COMMISSIONER QUINN motioned to approve the Action Agenda Item with the modification to Stipulation #10, seconded by Commissioner Golla. Item approved unanimously (7-0). Staff /Member Comments & Announcements MR. DE LA TORRE reported there would be a Planning and Zoning Commission Retreat during a regularly scheduled meeting to talk about hot topics. He reported an email will follow to save the date for December 2, 2026. Calendar The next regular meeting will be held on Wednesday, November 18, 2026, in the Chandler City Council Chambers, 88 E. Chicago Street. Adjourn The meeting was adjourned at 7:29 p.m. Page 10 of 11 David de la Torre, Secretary Sherri Koshiol, Chair Page 11 of 11