Extracted text (via pymupdf_layout)
23960 characters
PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD STUDY SESSION MINUTES October 28, 2026 The Planning and Zoning Board of the City of Mesa met in the Study Session room at City Hall, 20 East Main Street, on October 28, 2026, at 3:00 p.m. BOARD PRESENT BOARD ABSENT STAFF PRESENT Troy Peterson, Chairperson Jayson Carpenter, Boardmember Evan Balmer Jeff Pitcher, Vice Chairperson Misty Klann, Boardmember Kirstin Dvorchak Chase Hales, Boardmember Danika Heying Genessee Montes, Boardmember* Mary Kopaskie-Brown Scott Thomas, Boardmember Cassidy Welch Justin Trexler, Boardmember* Alexis Kay Wagner, Boardmember (*Participated in the meeting through the use of video conference equipment) Chairperson Peterson conducted a roll call. 1. Call meeting to order. 2. Review and discuss items listed on the Public Hearing agenda for October 24, 2026. Staff Planner, Chloe Durfee Daniel reviewed agenda Item 3-a, ZON26-00129. "Ellsworth I Energy Center," 21.8± acres located approximately 2,450± feet west of the southwest corner of South Ellsworth Road and East Starfire Avenue. Rezone from Light Industrial with a Planned Area Development Overlay (LI-PAD) to Light Industrial (LI) and Site Plan Review. This request will allow for a Battery Energy Storage System Facility. (District 6) on the Planning and Zoning Board Public Hearing agenda and displayed a PowerPoint presentation. (See Attachment 1) Ms. Durfee Daniel noted that the site is designated as a Regional Employment Center Placetype with an Evolve growth strategy under the General Plan, where warehousing and storage serve as supporting land uses. Primary access is provided via East Starfire Avenue to the north, with secondary access extending from the east parcel toward the south side of the site. Proposed perimeter landscaping includes Palo Brea, Desert Museum Palo Verde, Texas Olive, and Yellow Bells. (See Pages 3 through 8 of Attachment 1) The site will be enclosed by a 14-foot-tall perimeter screening wall featuring varying CMU textures and colors, exceeding the 11-foot maximum battery equipment height to ensure full visual screening across grade variations. The interior substation will be screened by a secondary wall featuring fixed louvers with 75 percent opacity. (See Pages 9 through 11 of Attachment 1) Planning and Zoning Board Study Session October 28, 2026 Page 2 In accordance with Mesa Zoning Ordinance requirements for BESS facilities, notification was sent to property owners within a half-mile radius for two mandatory neighborhood meetings. April 21, 2026, meeting: Neighbors raised questions regarding safety, land use, and necessity, which were addressed by the applicant. May 4, 2026, meeting: Neighbors expressed concerns regarding noise nuisances and potential utility cost increases. Public hearing notices were sent to property owners, HOAs, and registered neighborhoods within 1,000 feet. Staff received one comment in support of the project. Updated exhibits were distributed to the Board prior to the meeting to address missing items in Legistar. Staff recommends approval with conditions. (See Page 12 of Attachment 1) In response to an inquiry from Boardmember Hales regarding alignment with the Mesa Gateway Strategic Development Plan (which designates the area for a mixed-use community), Ms. Durfee Daniel explained that the parcel sits on the boundary between the Mixed-Use Community and Logistics and Commerce districts. Staff confirmed the industrial use aligns with surrounding industrial developments supporting the airport corridor. In response to questions from Chairperson Peterson, Ms. Durfee Daniel verified that the battery units are 11 feet tall. The 14-foot wall height includes two feet of required clearance above equipment and one foot of architectural wall articulation to ensure full visual screening across site elevation changes. Chairperson Peterson raised concerns regarding Stipulation 12C, which requires a registered professional engineer or architect to document compliance with noise level reduction standards under Section 11-19-5 for properties within Airport Overlay District 3 (AOA-3). Chairperson Peterson noted that acoustical engineering is not a registered category under the Arizona Board of Technical Registration, suggesting the stipulation be updated to reference acoustical consultants to avoid regulatory conflicts. Assistant Planning Director, Evan Balmer, and Kirstin Dvorchak, Assistant City Attorney, explained that the condition text is drawn verbatim from the zoning ordinance for AOA-3 properties. Staff confirmed that in practice, certified acoustic consultant reports submitted with permit packages satisfy the requirement and noted that code text amendments are currently being prepared to refine the language. Staff Planner, Chloe Durfee Daniel, reviewed agenda Item 3-b, ZON26-00131. "Ellsworth II Energy Center," 20.3± acres located approximately 1,200± feet west of the northwest corner of South Ellsworth Road and East Starfire Avenue. Rezone from Light Industrial with a Planned Area Development Overlay (LI-PAD) to Light Industrial (LI) and Site Plan Review. This request will allow for a Battery Energy Storage System Facility. (District 6) on the Planning and Zoning Board Public Hearing agenda and displayed a PowerPoint presentation. (See Attachment 2) Ms. Durfee Daniel presented case ZON26-00131 that is designated as a Regional Employment Center Placetype with an Evolve growth strategy under the General Plan, where warehousing and storage serve as supporting land uses. Site access will be provided via East Starfire Avenue to the south, with secondary access extending through parcels to the north. The existing site conditions look north toward the proposed site, adjacent drainage area, and the existing SRP substation directly to the west. (See Pages 3 through 5 of Attachment 2) Proposed perimeter and streetscape landscaping meets all code requirements and includes Mulga, Desert Palo Verde, Texas Olive, and Gold Lantana. The site will utilize the same 14-foot perimeter screening wall design as Ellsworth Two's companion site (Ellsworth One), featuring varying CMU textures and colors to screen the maximum 11-foot battery equipment height. (See Pages 6 through 10 of Attachment 2) Planning and Zoning Board Study Session October 28, 2026 Page 3 Neighborhood meetings were held on April 21, 2026, and May 4, 2026, with property owners notified within a half-mile radius. Public hearing notices were sent to property owners, HOAs, and registered neighborhoods within 1,000 feet. Staff received one comment in support of the project. Staff recommends approval with conditions. (See Pages 11 through 12 of Attachment 2) Assistant Planning Director, Evan Balmer, presented reviewed agenda Item 3-c, ZON25- 00660. “Gateway Crossing,” 37± acres located at the southwest corner of East Williams Field Road and the East 24 Gateway Freeway. Council Use Permit (CUP), Special Use Permit (SUP), and Site Plan Review. This request will allow for an approximately 360,895± square foot Group Commercial Center. (District 6) on the Planning and Zoning Board Public Hearing agenda and displayed a PowerPoint presentation. (See Attachment 3) Mr. Balmer presented Case ZON25-00660, "Gateway Crossing," on behalf of Senior Planner Kellie Rorex. The 36.7± acre vacant site is located at the southwest corner of East Williams Field Road and State Route 24 in Council District 6, directly north of the Arizona Athletic Grounds. The applicant is requesting a Site Plan Review, two Council Use Permits (CUP), and two Special Use Permits (SUP) for a large group commercial center. (See Pages 3 through 4 of Attachment 3) Mr. Blamer explained that the CUP covers the majority of the 36.7± acre parcel for an approximately 355,000-square-foot group commercial development. Two pads fronting Williams Field Road are designated for future development and will return for individual Development Plan Review. The first CUP is required for a Large Commercial Development within the Light Industrial (LI) zoning district, per Section 11-7 of the Mesa Zoning Ordinance. The second CUP is required for two proposed hotels (a Home2 Suites and a Residence Inn) located within Airport Overflight Area 2 (AOA-2). The first Special Use Permit is to allow the two proposed hotels to exceed the maximum height allowance within the LI zoning district. The second Special Use Permit will allow a service station, which is situated behind the future pad sites. (See Pages 5 through 6 of Attachment 3) Mr. Balmer noted that the site is designated as a Regional Center Placetype with an Evolve growth strategy under the General Plan, where entertainment, recreation, eating, and drinking serve as principal land uses. Although eating and drinking uses with drive-thrus generally require a CUP, this site has an existing CUP waiver for drive-thrus, and general retail is a permitted use in the LI district. Mr. Balmer displayed site photos looking south from Williams Field Road toward the property, as well as site plans, inline retail shop elevations (Shops A and B), anchor tenant elevations, and renderings. Staff noted that the Design Review Board recently reviewed the hotel elevations favorably, with staff currently working through minor landscape comments. (See Pages 7 through 22 of Attachment 3) Public notices were sent to property owners, HOAs, and registered neighborhoods within a 1,000-foot radius of the site. A neighborhood meeting was conducted in June with seven residents in attendance, all of whom expressed strong support for the project. Staff finds that the request satisfies all applicable criteria for Site Plan Review, Council Use Permits, and Special Use Permits, and recommends approval subject to conditions. (See Pages 23 through 24 of Attachment 3) Boardmember Hales inquired why the applicant pursued multiple CUPs and SUPs under the existing LI zoning rather than rezoning the property to a commercial district that inherently permits these uses and asked whether maintaining LI zoning leaves the door open for undesirable heavy industrial uses. Mr. Balmer explained that the CUP requirement for hotels Planning and Zoning Board Study Session October 28, 2026 Page 4 within AOA-2 applies regardless of the underlying zoning district. Additionally, staff sent the height SUP request to Mesa Gateway Airport officials, who reviewed and cleared the proposal. Maintaining the LI designation is consistent with the broader surrounding industrial corridor (similar to the adjacent Arizona Athletic Grounds). Mr. Balmer clarified that the approval conditions tie the entitlements directly to the presented site plan. Any future attempt to deviate from the commercial scope toward intense industrial or auto-repair uses would trigger the Development Plan Review modification criteria, requiring a legislative modification and public approval process before City Council. Staff Planner, Tulili Tuiteleleapaga-Howard, reviewed agenda Item 3-d, ZON26-00217. "Val Vista Oil," 0.45± acres located approximately 250± feet north of the northeast corner of South Val Vista Drive and East Southern Avenue. Major Site Plan Modification. This request will allow for an approximately 2,200± square foot Minor Automobile Repair facility. (District 2) on the Planning and Zoning Board Public Hearing agenda and displayed a PowerPoint presentation. (See Attachment 4) Staff Planner, Tulili Tuiteleleapaga-Howard, presented Zoning Case ZON26-00217, "Val Vista Oil," located on a 0.45-acre site approximately 250 feet north of the northeast corner of East Southern Avenue and South Val Vista Drive within an existing commercial center. The applicant is requesting a Major Site Plan Modification to allow an approximate 3,356-square-foot minor automobile repair facility (a Take 5 Oil Change facility featuring a 2,200-square-foot main floor building footprint and an 1,156-square-foot pit area). (See Pages 3 through 4 of Attachment 4) Ms. Tuiteleleapaga-Howard noted that the site is designated as an Urban Center Placetype with an Evolve growth strategy under the General Plan, where convenience centers serve as a principal land use. The site plan provides six required parking spaces plus one ADA space. The proposed landscape plan includes existing and new foundation trees and shrubs around the building perimeter, as well as a large perimeter landscape yard and retention basin along Val Vista Drive. Ms. Tuiteleleapaga-Howard displayed site photos looking east from Val Vista Drive and west from within the commercial center, along with updated building elevations. The Design Review Board reviewed the elevations during their October 13 work session, providing comments regarding facade paneling and materials. Ms. Tuiteleleapaga-Howard also shared renderings illustrating customer entry access and parking views looking west from within the site. (See Pages 5 through 15 of Attachment 4) Public hearing notices were sent to property owners within 500 feet, as well as HOAs and registered neighborhoods. Staff received one email expressing opposition to the project, which was included in the Board's packet. Staff recommends approval with conditions. (See Pages 16 through 17 Attachment 4) Boardmember Wagner inquired whether the construction of the oil change facility would reduce available parking for surrounding businesses in the commercial center to a level that creates a deficit. Ms. Tuiteleleapaga-Howard explained that the overall commercial center was originally approved with an excess of approximately 213 parking spaces. While the proposed oil change facility eliminates 24 existing parking spaces, the commercial center will still maintain a surplus of approximately 189 spaces. Staff Planner, Kwasi Abebrese, reviewed agenda Item 3-e, ZON26-00614. "Stonelake- Pecos Crossing," 35± acres located at the northeast corner of East Pecos Road and South Sossaman Road. Rezone from Employment Opportunity (EO) to Light Industrial with a Planned Area Development Overlay (LI-PAD). This request will allow for modifications to an existing Planning and Zoning Board Study Session October 28, 2026 Page 5 Industrial development. (District 6) on the Planning and Zoning Board Public Hearing agenda and displayed a PowerPoint presentation. (See Attachment 5) Mr. Abebrese presented Case ZON26-00614, "Stone Lake Pecos Crossing." The applicant is requesting a rezone from Employment Opportunity (EO) to Light Industrial with a Planned Area Development overlay (LI-PAD) on an approximately 35-acre site located at the northeast corner of East Pecos Road and South Sossaman Road. In June 2023, the Planning Director approved a site plan for four speculative industrial buildings ranging in size from 81,059 to 243,634 square feet. Two of the four buildings (Buildings C and D) have been constructed. Because outdoor storage is not a permitted use under the Pecos Road Employment Opportunity Zone (PREOZ), the applicant is requesting LI-PAD zoning to allow accessory outdoor storage within screened truck courts and service/loading areas. The proposed LI-PAD zoning aligns with the General Plan's Regional Employment Center Placetype, where indoor/outdoor warehousing and storage serve as supporting land uses. (See Pages 3 through 5 of Attachment 5) Access to the site is provided via two main drive aisles along Pecos Road to the south and a connecting drive aisle to Sossaman Road to the west. Outdoor storage yards are proposed south of Building A, between Buildings C and D, and on the east side of Building B. The approved landscape plan features foundation planting around the buildings, interior parking lot landscaping, and perimeter/streetscape buffers along Sossaman Road, Pecos Road, and the north and east boundaries. Approved plant species include: Mulga Acacia, Texas Ebony, Red Push Pistache, Ghost Gum, and Thornless Mesquite. Shrubs: Yellow Bird of Paradise, Little John Dwarf Bottlebrush, and Dwarf Oleander. (See Pages 6 through 10 of Attachment 5) The requested PAD overlay includes two specific development standard deviations from the base Light Industrial (LI) district: An increase in maximum permitted building height from 40 feet to 50 feet to accommodate the existing and proposed structures and to locate accessory outdoor storage areas within the screened truck courts and loading areas, outside the rear one- half of the lot. All manufacturing and processing activities will remain entirely within enclosed buildings. Mr. Abebrese displayed building elevations (southeast elevation of Building D) and proposed screen wall details (an 8-foot-high wall composed of board-formed concrete with perforated metal panel gates). (See Pages 11 through 13 of Attachment 5) Public hearing notices were mailed to property owners within 1,000 feet, HOAs within a half- mile, and registered neighborhoods within one mile. A neighborhood meeting was conducted on September 21, 2026, with zero residents in attendance. No public comments have been received by staff or the applicant. Staff finds the request complies with the 2050 Mesa General Plan and Zoning Ordinance Chapter 22 and recommends approval with conditions. (See Pages 14 through 16 of Attachment 5) Chairperson Peterson inquired about the timing and logistics of wall construction, referencing the site wall plan in the Board packet and noting that Buildings C and D are existing while Buildings A and B are planned for future construction. Mr. Abebrese explained that Buildings C and D currently have a portion of the 8-foot masonry wall constructed between them. To convert truck courts into outdoor storage yards, the applicant must install gates between Buildings C and D and construct an 8-foot screen wall with gates on the east side of Building B to screen storage from adjacent public parking areas. These modifications will be reviewed administratively via an Administrative Development Plan Modification. Mr. Balmer clarified that standard truck court screening differs from outdoor storage screening requirements. Under the conditions of approval, any active outdoor storage area must be fully enclosed by an 8-foot screen wall matching the architectural colors and materials of the primary Planning and Zoning Board Study Session October 28, 2026 Page 6 buildings. If an outdoor storage footprint expands within a truck court in the future, the screening wall must be extended accordingly while maintaining required fire lanes. Staff Planner, Chloe Durfee Daniel, reviewed agenda Item 4-a, GPA26-00248. "View 202 - Minor GPA," 21.6± acres located at the southwest corner of South Ellsworth Road and East Starfire Avenue. Minor General Plan Amendment to change the Placetype from Urban Residential with an Evolve Growth Strategy to Local Employment Center with an Evolve Growth Strategy. (District 6) on the Planning and Zoning Board Public Hearing agenda and displayed a PowerPoint presentation. (See Attachment 6) Ms. Durfee Daniel presented Case GPA26-00248 (accompanied by concurrent rezoning case ZON26-00126) for a Minor General Plan Amendment. The subject site is a 21.6± acre vacant parcel located at the southwest corner of South Ellsworth Road and East Starfire Avenue (north of Ray Road, on the west side of Ellsworth Road, situated directly east of the Ellsworth One site and southeast of the Ellsworth Two site). (See Pages 3 through 4 of Attachment 6) The applicant is requesting a Minor General Plan Amendment to change the Placetype designation from Urban Residential to Local Employment Center, while maintaining the existing Evolve growth strategy across both place types. The concurrent rezoning request seeks to rezone the property from Multiple Residence 4 with a Planned Area Development overlay (RM- 4-PAD) and Limited Commercial with a PAD overlay (LC-PAD) to Light Industrial with a PAD overlay (LI-PAD) and Limited Commercial with a PAD overlay (LC-PAD), maintaining the underlying existing PAD. Staff noted that the site is currently vacant and displayed a site photo looking northwest toward the property. (See Pages 5 through 9 of Attachment 6) Public notifications were sent to property owners, HOAs, and registered neighborhoods within a 1,000-foot radius. A neighborhood meeting was conducted on May 12, 2026, during which one attendee inquired about electrical infrastructure in the surrounding area. Staff have received no additional public comments. Staff finds that the request satisfies the General Plan Amendment approval criteria and recommends approval with conditions. (See Pages 10 through 11 of Attachment 6) Staff Planner, Chloe Durfee Daniel, reviewed agenda Item 4-b, ZON26-00126. "View 202 - Multifamily Rezone," 21.6± acres located at the southwest corner of South Ellsworth Road and East Starfire Avenue. Rezone 17.1± acres from Multiple Residence-4 with a Planned Area Development Overlay (RM-4-PAD) and Limited Commercial with a Planned Area Development Overlay (LC-PAD) to Light Industrial with a Planned Area Development Overlay (LI-PAD), Rezone 4.5± acres from RM-4-PAD and LC-PAD to Limited Commercial with a Planned Area Development Overlay (LC-PAD), and a Council Use Permit. This request will allow for the future development of industrial and commercial uses. (District 6) on the Planning and Zoning Board Public Hearing agenda and displayed a PowerPoint presentation. (See Attachment 7) Ms. Durfee Daniel presented Case ZON26-00126, "View 202 Multifamily Rezone," concurrent with the previously discussed General Plan Amendment Case, GPA26-00248. The 21.6± acre site is located at the southwest corner of South Ellsworth Road and East Starfire Avenue (north of Ray Road and west of Ellsworth Road, situated east of Ellsworth One and southwest of Ellsworth Two). The applicant is requesting to rezone 17.1 acres from Multiple Residence 4 with a Planned Area Development overlay (RM-4-PAD) and Limited Commercial with a PAD overlay (LC-PAD) to Light Industrial with a PAD overlay (LI-PAD) and to rezone 4.5 acres from RM-4- PAD and LC-PAD to LC-PAD. The applicant is also requesting a Council Use Permit (CUP) to allow a large commercial development within the Light Industrial (LI) zoning district. The Planning and Zoning Board Study Session October 28, 2026 Page 7 underlying PAD overlays will be maintained across the entire site. (See Pages 3 through 10 of Attachment 7) Ms. Durfee Daniel noted that the site is currently vacant and displayed a photo looking northwest toward the property. She highlighted that the project complies with both the general Council Use Permit criteria and the specific CUP requirements for large commercial developments within industrial zones. (See Page 10 of Attachment 7) Public notifications were sent to property owners, HOAs, and registered neighborhoods within a 1,000-foot radius. At the May 12, 2026, neighborhood meeting, attendees raised questions regarding area electrical infrastructure. Ms. Durfee Daniel has received no additional comments to date. Staff finds that the request satisfies all applicable rezoning and Council Use Permit approval criteria and recommends approval with conditions. (See Pages 11 through 12 of Attachment 7) 3. Planning Director’s Update. Balanced Housing Update. 4. Adjourned. It was moved by Vice Chairperson Pitcher, seconded by Boardmember Wagner, that the Study Session be adjourned. Upon tabulation of votes, it showed: AYES –Peterson, Pitcher, Hales, Montes, Thomas, Trexler, Wagner NAYS – None ABSENT–Carpenter, Klann Without objection, the Planning and Zoning Board Study Session adjourned at 3:58 p.m. I hereby certify that the foregoing minutes are a true and correct copy of the minutes of the Planning and Zoning Board Study Session meeting of the City of Mesa, Arizona, held on the 28th day of October 2026. I further certify that the meeting was duly called and held and that a quorum was present. __________________________________________ TROY PETERSON, CHAIRPERSON DH (Attachments - 7)