Extracted text (via pymupdf_layout)
31365 characters
Planning and Zoning Report Date November 18, 2026 Case No. ZON26-00379 Project Name Culdesac Mesa (FKA Site 17) Request Rezone from Downtown Core (DC) to Infill Development-2 (ID-2) to allow for the development of a mixed-use community. Project Location Located approximately 230+ feet west and 150+ feet south of the southwest corner of East University Drive and North Mesa Drive Parcel No(s) Multiple Project Area 24.3± acres Council District District 4 Existing Zoning Downtown Core (DC) Proposed Zoning Infill Development-2 (ID-2) General Plan Downtown Placetype with an Designation Evolve Growth Strategy Applicant Duke DiEugenio, Culdesac Inc. Owner City of Mesa Staff Planner Jennifer Merrill, Senior Planner Recommendation Staff finds that the Proposed Project is consistent with the Mesa 2050 General Plan, the purposes and intents of the Infill Development-2 (ID-2) District from Mesa Zoning Ordinance (MZO) Section 11-12-1, and the applicability requirements for the ID District from MZO Section 11-12-2, and the proposed Infill Incentive Plan (IIP) meets the requirements of MZO Section 11-12-6. Staff recommends approval with conditions. Project Overview Request: The applicant is requesting approval of a rezoning for 24.3± acres from Downtown Core (DC) to the Infill Development-2 (ID-2) District, and approval of the associated Infill Incentive Plan (IIP), to allow for the development of a mixed-used community (Proposed Project). Site Context General Plan: The Placetype for the project site is Downtown; the Growth Strategy for the project site is Evolve. The Infill Development-2 (ID-2) District is an appropriate Zoning District for the Downtown Placetype per the Mesa 2050 General Plan. Principal Land Uses in the Downtown Placetype include Multi-Family Residential, Public/Semi-Public, Retail, Personal Services, Eating and Drinking Establishments, Entertainment and Recreation, and Business Office; Supporting Land Uses include Single- Family Residential and Medical Facilities. The Proposed Project includes three phases of development that allow for all of the principal and supporting land uses listed above. The first phase, located closest to the Glenwood Wilbur Historic District, allows for attached and detached Single-Family Residential, Multi-Family Residential, and other land uses generally at a smaller-scale. Subsequent phases allow for attached Single-Family Residential, Multi-Family Residential, and the other land uses listed above. [2] The Proposed Project is consistent with the Downtown Placetype and furthers the implementation of, and is not contrary to, the Vision, Guiding Principles, Strategies, and applicable elements of the Mesa 2050 General Plan. Supporting General Plan Strategies: o N1. Promote complete communities in both existing and new neighborhoods. o N4. Use neighborhood planning to engage local communities and define neighborhood specific character, values, and policies. o N5. Improve street and open space network connectivity within neighborhoods and to local serving amenities. o HAC2. Support and encourage a variety of artwork in public places, such as parks, public buildings, and plazas. o H1. Create more opportunities for housing options. o H4. Encourage the development of high-density housing in close proximity to transit and major activity centers. o CM4. Promote transit-supportive development along existing and future high- capacity transit routes. o LU1. Promote a balance of land uses to enhance the quality of life for current and future generations. o LU2. Create opportunities for placemaking in neighborhoods that reinforce their unique character and sense of place. o LU3. Encourage infill and redevelopment to meet the community's strategic needs. o LU4. Create design and development standards that improve the City’s visual quality, urban form, and function to enhance the quality of life for current and future generations. o LU5. Encourage the development of vibrant activity centers in downtown and throughout the City. o ED3. Sustain a business climate that fosters entrepreneurs and small businesses. Sub-Area Plan: The project site is located in the Central Main Street Area Plan within the Employment district. Per the Plan, the project site represents an excellent opportunity to develop an urban employment district that includes a mixture of uses including higher education planned in a coordinated manner with an urban form that includes buildings close to, and addressing the streets and parking behind or to the side of buildings, preferably structured. The Proposed Project includes three phases of development; the first two phases will contain residential and mixed-use projects with an urban form, and the third phase is anticipated to involve Arizona State University and include student housing, college classroom and academic office space. [3] The Proposed Project is consistent with the Employment district and furthers the implementation of, and is not contrary to, the vision and goals of the Central Main Street Area Plan. Zoning: The applicant is requesting to rezone the site to the Infill Development-2 (ID-2) District. The rezoning request will adopt an Infill Incentive Plan (IIP) which establishes the permitted and conditional uses, development standards, and certain project specific administrative processes for the subject site. Surrounding Zoning & Use Activity: The proposed mixed-use neighborhood is compatible with surrounding land uses, which include the Single and Multiple Residential, Hotel and Conference Center, Offices, Place of Worship, and other commercial uses. Northwest (Across North Northeast University Dr.) (Across University Dr.) Convenience Market and DR-3 DR-3, DB-1 Service Station (Circle K) Escobedo Apartments Place of Worship, Apartments, (Across University & Mesa Medical Office Building, Drives) Retail/Restaurants DR-3 Place of Worship West Project Site East (Across Pasadena) DC (Across Mesa Dr.) DC Vacant DB-1, DR-2 Hotel and Conference Center, Jiffy Lube, Offices, Multi- Offices Family Residential, Single Residence (Across Pomeroy) Apartments Southwest South Southeast (Across Pasadena and E. (Across E. 2nd St.) (Across Pomeroy) 2nd St.) DR-2 DC DC, DR-2 Multiple and Single Multiple Residential Residential (Across Mesa Dr.) Offices, Multiple and Single K-12 Charter School Residential Site History: June 14, 1883: The original square mile of the City of Mesa was established, including the project site (Ordinance No. 1). September 8, 1987: City Council approved a request for a Special Use Permit for 0.4± acres, located at the southwest corner of Mesa Drive and University Drive (adjacent to the project site), to allow the construction of an automobile service station and [4] convenience market (Case No. SUP86-010). September 8, 1987: The City Council approved new Town Center zoning districts, development regulations and design standards for 836.8+ acres including the project site (Case No. Z87-040; Ordinance No. 2254). Limited Commercial/General Multiple Residential (TCB-1), General Multiple Residential (TCR-3) and Restricted Multiple Residential (TCR-2) were established for the project site. The Downtown Core (DC) District was later established for the overall area. Project/Request Details Infill Development-2 (ID-2) District Designation: The applicant is requesting to rezone the property from DC to ID-2 for a mixed-use neighborhood development. Per MZO Section 11-12-1, the purpose of the ID Districts is to promote and facilitate the development and redevelopment of by-passed, underutilized, or abandoned properties. This district provides for the establishment of specific land uses, development standards, alternative fees and streamlined review processes as incentives to stimulate re-investment and development of these properties in a manner that will contribute to the creation of a high-quality context for employment opportunities and improve the overall economic viability of that area of the city. The Proposed Project achieves the purpose and intent of MZO Section 11-12-1, by encouraging redevelopment and investment of a by-passed group of properties through an Infill Incentive Plan (IIP) that utilizes sustainable development practices including promoting a mix of uses in close proximity of each other, which enables more pedestrian activity, on properties where public infrastructure is in place. The Proposed Project will result in a cohesive mixed-use neighborhood with housing, employment, services, common open space and recreational uses accessible by walking, bicycling, and other transportation modes. Summary of the ID District The DC District is governed by the adopted IIP. The IIP is summarized by chapter below. Chapter 1 – IIP Introduction The proposed Culdesac Mesa project is comprised of multiple parcels totaling 24.3+ acres located southwest of the intersection of North Mesa Drive and East University Drive. The site has been vacant for three decades and meets the defining criteria of a by-passed parcel as explained in detail below in the Evaluation Criteria section. It also meets four of the six ID District applicability requirements, including having a relatively low level of development or investment activity, and a high occurrence of crime and nuisance activity. The site may contain cultural resources which merit additional investigation, which will occur in accordance with the MZO and with Arizona State statutes and regulations. The vision and goals for the development include expanding access to homeownership in a well- connected mixed-use community, with high-quality and environmentally resilient design, shared spaces designed to foster daily interaction and connection, multiple modes of transportation, and [5] support for new and local retail businesses. Chapter 2 – Zone Standards The proposed Culdesac Mesa project includes three Zones. The Neighborhood Zone is located adjacent to the single residential neighborhood to the south and is intended to provide residential and small-scale commercial uses. Buildings are a maximum of three stories in height. The Village Zone comprises the majority of the project area, including along Mesa and University Drives, and is intended to create a medium- to high-intensity, mixed-use neighborhood including residential, retail, restaurants, live-work spaces and other local businesses with a connected network of streets and public spaces. Buildings are four to 12 stories in height. The Campus Zone is located along the western boundary adjacent to the parking area for the Delta Hotel and City-owned parcels. The intent of the Campus Zone is to create a high-intensity, pedestrian-oriented district that supports the long-term expansion of higher-education and associated uses including residential, academic, commercial, and institutional. The tallest buildings are accommodated in the Campus Zone, designed to incorporate active ground floor uses and walkable urban settings with integrated open spaces. Chapter 3 – Land Use Regulations A permitted land use table lists a broad range of recreation, civic, education, cultural, residential, commercial, office, hospitality, and transportation uses. The Neighborhood Zone allows for detached single-unit residential uses, whereas the Village and Campus Zones do not. Uses permitted in all three Zones include community services; multi-unit residences and attached single-unit residences; medical/dental clinics and offices; places of worship; day care facilities; libraries, museums and live/work units less than 2,500 square feet; and eating and drinking establishments under 5,000 square feet. The Village and Campus Zones allow for more intense uses that are not permitted in the Neighborhood Zone including hospitals; public safety facilities; theaters, cinemas and performing arts; post-secondary institutions; lodging for 50 or more keys; libraries, museums, live/work units, and offices over 2,500 square feet; and studios, eating and drinking establishments, and general retail over 5,000 square feet. Several uses are allowed prior to construction, as indicated by the cross symbol at the foot of the table and as explained in Chapter 7 of the IIP. Chapter 4 – Development Standards The IIP establishes development standards for uses where the proposed standards differ from those established in the MZO. These include architectural, screening, trash and refuse collection, landscaping, lighting, parking, and signage. Some key differences between the Development Standards in the MZO and those in the proposed IIP include: Fences. Opaque yard fences need to include at least two framed views, where an area of at least one square foot of transparent materials or void shall be located at a height of at least two and no more than six feet within the fence; this will provide more safety, as well [6] as visual connections between outdoor spaces. The MZO does not require framed views for opaque yard fences. Paving. Variations in paving materials, patterns, textures, and colors shall be used to define pedestrian areas, gathering spaces, plazas, crossings, seating areas, and other activity zones, and alternative paving materials including stabilized decomposed granite, porous or permeable pavers, and precast pavers are permitted. The MZO does not require variations in paving materials between outdoor pedestrian activity areas. Retention Basins. Retention basins can incorporate alternative designs and systems (from the MZO) approved by the City Engineer or designee. Landscaping Species. All on-site landscape materials are required to be native or desert adapted species as included in the Arizona Department of Water Resources Active Management Plan Low Water Use Plant List for Phoenix, unless approved by the Planning Director. The MZO does not limit material species to those on that plant list. Tree Size. A minimum tree size of seven-gallon (vs. 15-gallon required by the MZO), should allow for faster establishment, lower maintenance needs, and better long-term survival compared with larger trees. Required Parking. Required parking spaces are to be provided per the Development Phasing Map and will total at least 800 off-street parking spaces for the entire Culdesac Mesa project area. Minimum off-street parking space requirements are as follows per phase: o Phase I: 140 spaces o Phase II: 250 spaces o Phase III: 425 spaces Flexible Parking Spaces. Constructed parking spaces may be used as parking for any use in the IIP project area or may be converted for use as outdoor seating, private courtyard or porch space, pocket parks, outdoor sales, public plaza space, bike or bike share parking, carshare parking, or other uses as approved by the Planning Director or designee. The MZO does not allow required parking spaces to be converted to non- parking uses. Chapter 5 – Thoroughfare Standards The Thoroughfare Standards chapter provides six proposed thoroughfare assemblies, or dimensioned street/path cross-sections, with the goal of providing a compact, walkable, and connected neighborhood. A Conceptual Circulation Plan guides the placement of the thoroughfare assemblies, but final locations will be determined during Development Plan Review. The six thoroughfare assemblies are: Suburban Streets. Regulations apply to improvements located between the back of curb and property line; adjacent to Mesa Drive and University Drive. Mixed Use Streets. Primary neighborhood spines with minimum 37-foot right-of-way [7] (ROW); minimum nine-foot lane width and up to one lane per direction, plus bicycle lanes with buffers. Local Streets. (located along the edges of the Site with minimum 33-foot ROW; minimum nine-foot lane width and up to one lane per direction, plus bicycle lanes with buffers); Shared Streets. Function as both circulation routes and public gathering spaces for markets, special events and everyday activities, with a minimum 20-foot ROW; minimum nine-foot lane width and up to one lane per direction, plus bicycle lanes with buffers. Shared Lanes. Narrow vehicular access with a minimum nine-foot ROW; nine-foot-wide single-direction lanes, or 12-foot-wide bi-directional lane, serving vehicles, bicyclists and pedestrians. Pathways. Pedestrian- and bicycle-only corridors with a minimum three-foot ROW. Alternative Thoroughfare Standards are permitted through an additional review process. Chapter 6 – Open Space Standards The proposed Culdesac Mesa project provides for a network of open spaces designed for private and for public/civic use. Ten percent of the net acreage of the project Site will be provided as open space, and each request for Development Plan Review will be required to provide a minimum of seven percent open space. The Open Space Standards chapter provides requirements for those private and civic open spaces. Private open spaces include private decks, balconies, patios or yards, directly accessible to the unit(s) served. Six Civic Open Space types are outlined in the Chapter, but they may be combined or expanded upon with approval by the Planning Director or designee. Chapter 7 – Review and Development Procedures Chapter 7 establishes the IIP as Culdesac Mesa’s primary zoning regulations. Where permitted by law, the Plan governs over conflicting Mesa Zoning Ordinance provisions; matters not addressed remain subject to the Zoning Ordinance. Development Plan Review All Development Plans require a Pre-Submittal Conference followed by administrative Development Plan Review, consistent with the City’s established review procedures, timelines and notification requirements. Each request for Development Plan Review will include a Phase Compliance Tracking Table identifying the existing and proposed amounts of residential units, commercial floor area, and open space, relative to the amount required for the applicable Phase, and cumulatively for the entire Culdesac Mesa project site, as stated in the Development Agreement (DA). Neighborhood Programming and Interim Uses Chapter 7 establishes provisions for Neighborhood Programming and Interim Uses intended to support the phased development and ongoing activation of Culdesac Mesa. [8] These provisions provide opportunity for community gathering, social interaction, cultural expression, recreation, placemaking, and activities that support local businesses and contribute to a vibrant, pedestrian-oriented neighborhood. Neighborhood Programming provides a framework for reoccurring activities, events, and temporary installation within designated civic spaces, streets, paseos, and other areas identified for programming within an approved Development Plan. Such activities may include community markets, outdoor performances, art exhibitions, recreational activities, cultural events, neighborhood gatherings, and similar uses that contribute to the social and economic vitality of the development. Neighborhood Programming Plans identify the proposed programming areas, anticipated activities, frequency and duration of events, and operational considerations necessary to ensure compatibility with surrounding uses and the safe and functional operation of the development. Interim Uses Plans provide opportunities to temporarily activate vacant or undeveloped portions of the Culdesac Mesa project site prior to approval and implementation of a permanent Development Plan. Interim uses may include temporary commercial activities, outdoor gathering areas, recreational amenities, community events, pop-up retail, food and beverage activities, art installations, and other uses that contribute to site activation and neighborhood identity. Interim Use Plans may also authorize temporary structures, infrastructure, utilities, and site improvements necessary to accommodate these activities. Such plans identify the proposed uses, site layout, anticipated duration, access and circulation, and other operational considerations, recognizing that these improvements are temporary and may be modified or removed as permanent development proceeds. Neighborhood Programming Plans and Interim Use Plans are subject to administrative review and approval by City Planning Staff in Planning in coordination with Licensing, Fire, Police, and other departments as needed. Review will consider public safety, emergency access, pedestrian and vehicular circulation, accessibility, noise, lighting, hours of operation, and other potential impacts associated with the proposed activities. IIP Amendments. Minor amendments to the IIP can be reviewed administratively and approved by the Planning Director or designee, and major amendments to the IIP can be reviewed and approved through the Planning and Zoning Board. Chapter 8 – Definitions Chapter 16 establishes project-specific definitions for civic, recreation, school and cultural institutions, residential, commercial, transportation and specialized terms used throughout the Plan. The Definitions replace all definitions listed in the Mesa Zoning Ordinance. These definitions ensure clear, consistent, and predictable administration of the adopted zoning standards. Evaluation Criteria [9] Evaluation Criteria Per MZO Section 11-12-6 1. Conform to applicable policies, land use map designations, and land use definitions of the Mesa General Plan; The Proposed Project meets the applicable policies, land use map designations and land use definitions of the Mesa General Plan by providing permitted principal land uses such as Multi-Family Residential, Public/Semi-Public, Retail, Personal Services, Eating and Drinking Establishments, Entertainment and Recreation, and Business Office, and supporting land uses such as Single-Family Residential and Medical Facilities, all in conformance with the Downtown Placetype of the Mesa General Plan. 2. Conform to the purposes and intents of the ID District as listed in Section 11-12-1; The Culdesac Mesa project meets the purposes and intents of the ID District by providing land uses, development standards, and streamlined review processes for this 24+ acre area of by-passed properties, as well as Neighborhood Programming and Interim Uses that can support new and local businesses and improve the overall economic viability of the area. The IIP encourages the use of innovative approaches to development including green stormwater infrastructure, solar energy, and alternative modes of transportation. The project will contain a mix of uses in close proximity to each other, which will be connected with a circulation pattern that shortens walking distances, improves access, supports a pedestrian-oriented environment, and integrates into the surrounding area including Downtown Mesa, Pioneer Park, and the Glenwood Wilbur Historic District. 3. Address the concerns outlined in the statement of need in support of the ID district; The 24.3+ acre project site meets the definition of “by-passed parcel” without regard to lot size and meets four (minimum of three are required) of the six eligibility criteria for the ID District. The site has been vacant for 30 years, and there have been more than 3,800 reports of trash removal, homeless encampments, and/or drug paraphernalia collection since 2023, with an increase in incidents in recent years. Compared with other areas in the City, this site has seen no development or investment activity. The Culdesac Mesa project includes rapid activation of the site, with Interim Uses beginning soon after the rezoning is approved, to bring people to the site for social events, recreational activities, and opportunities for placemaking, even before construction begins. After Development Plans are approved, the Neighborhood Programming will continue those events and activities, and additional residents will populate the area, bringing more eyes on the streets, more riders for the light rail, and more customers to local businesses. 4. Provide a land use, or a combination of land uses that are arranged and designed in such a manner as to be well integrated with other land uses, the immediate surrounding area, the planned thoroughfare system, and other public facilities such as water and sewer systems, parks, schools, transit routes and utilities; The Proposed Project provides a combination of land uses that are arranged and designed to be integrated with other land uses and the immediate surrounding area. Phase I proposes residential townhomes along the southern boundary of the project site adjacent to the existing Glenwood Wilbur Historic District neighborhood. The proposed land uses will be well integrated with the existing and planned thoroughfare system, and with other public facilities, parks, transit routes and utilities. [10] 5. Adequately, reasonably and conveniently integrate into existing and planned streets, transit systems, and public services, utilities, and public facilities; The City of Mesa Transportation Department, Water Resources Department, Engineering Department, Business Services (Licensing) Department, and Development Services Department have reviewed the IIP. The Departments have found that the Proposed Project adequately, reasonably and conveniently integrates into existing and planned streets, transit systems, public services, utilities and public facilities and will not result in a reduction in service levels to adjacent properties. 6. Promote development that is appropriate to and well-integrated with its environmental setting, including existing vegetation, soils, geology, topography, and drainage patterns. The City of Mesa Development Services Department has reviewed the Proposed Project and determined that the development is appropriate to and well-integrated with the existing environmental setting, including existing vegetation, soils, geology, topography, and drainage patterns. 7. Justify any deviations from Standard Development Requirements based upon the overall quality of the plan provided, the need to address specific concerns outlined in the Statement of Need, and the need to address other conditions that may affect the viability of reasonably developing the property in a manner consistent with stated objectives of the Mesa General Plan; Per Chapter 4 of the IIP, the proposed Development Standards will offer more safety and visibility for fenced yards, different standards for hardscape materials to provide high- quality civic spaces, alternative retention basin design, landscape requirements that will reduce water use and allow for lower maintenance needs, and parking requirements that will reduce the amount of asphalt in the Site. These deviations are consistent with the stated objectives of the Mesa General Plan, including Strategy LU5: Encourage the development of vibrant activity centers in downtown and throughout the City, 8. Provide superior design and environmental sustainability in comparison with development reviewed under other base zoning district regulations. The Proposed Project provides superior design pursuant to MZO Section 11-31-32 by providing cohesive, high-quality and context-sensitive architecture, landscaping and signage; encouraging climate-responsive design with shade elements and durable landscape materials; and providing safe, comfortable public spaces with integrated open space defined by landscape and hardscape design, and pedestrian amenities. 9. Be compatible with, and not detrimental to, adjacent properties or the surrounding neighborhood(s). The Proposed Project is compatible with, and not detrimental to, adjacent properties or the surrounding neighborhood. The Site is bound by public streets including University Drive, Mesa Drive, Pomeroy, E. 2nd Street, and Pasadena. Across University Drive to the north and Mesa Drive to the east are existing places of worship, multi-family residential, convenience service uses and a charter school. Across E. 2nd St. to the south are multi- and single-residential uses including the Glenwood Wilbur Historic District neighborhood. [11] Across Pasadena to the west are offices, residential uses and a hotel and conference center. The Proposed Project provides much needed residential units Downtown, with single-residential located closest to the existing single-residential neighborhood. It also provides retail, restaurant, office, education, and opportunities for small businesses in live- work units and in Neighborhood Programming and Interim Uses. The Proposed Project will support the immediate vicinity, including the ASU campus, and bring more people to the Downtown businesses and commercial areas located across University and Mesa Drives. Impact Analyses School Impact: Mesa Public Schools was notified of the Proposed Project and determined that the District currently has capacity to serve the students generated from this development. The ability exists in their neighborhood schools, including Eisenhower Elementary, Kino Middle School, and Westwood High School. Citizen Participation: The applicant conducted a Citizen Participation process, notifying surrounding property owners, HOAs, and registered neighbors, creating a Culdesac Mesa website in English and Spanish, providing six public engagement events including a neighborhood meeting at The Post, and meeting with various stakeholders (33). Neighborhood Meeting: A neighborhood meeting was held on June 25, 2026, with 47 sign-ins. A spreadsheet of citizen concerns, with responses from Culdesac, is provided in the Citizen Participation Report. Many comments included requests for affordable housing, a grocery store, and open/civic spaces that are accessible to the surrounding neighborhoods. Some indicated concerns about providing one parking space per dwelling unit; and some requested information in Spanish (provided). The applicant explained that the IIP is written to allow for many different housing types accommodating a wide range of households and budgets, and it also is flexible regarding how people park, so it can adapt to future needs. The applicant also hopes to bring a corner store or grocery store. Culdesac Mesa’s public gathering spaces will be open to neighbors and visitors in addition to the Culdesac residents. Required Notification: Property owners within 1,000 feet, HOAs within ½ mile, and registered neighborhoods within one mile of the subject site were notified of the public hearing. Staff has not received any public input on the Proposed Project. Conditions of Approval Staff recommends approval of the rezoning request and the Infill Incentive Plan, subject to the [12] following conditions: 1. Compliance with the Infill Incentive Plan (IIP) and any future amendments thereto. 2. Compliance with all City development codes and regulations except as identified within the IIP. 3. Compliance with the Subdivision Regulations. 4. Dedicate the right-of-way and easements required under the Mesa City Code at the time of application for a building permit, at the time of recordation of the subdivision plat, or at the time of the City's request for dedication, whichever comes first. 5. Compliance with all requirements of development agreement DA26-02416. Exhibits Exhibit 1 – Vicinity Map Exhibit 2 – Project Narrative Exhibit 3 – Infill Incentive Plan Exhibit 4 – Citizen Participation Plan Exhibit 5 – Citizen Participation Report Exhibit 6 – Power Point Presentation [13]