Extracted text (via pymupdf_layout)
6838 characters
Planning & Zoning Report Date: November 18, 2026 To: Planning and Zoning Board Through: Ken Cost, Assistant City Manager From: Angelica Guevara, Code Compliance Director Subject: Mesa Zoning Ordinance text amendments to Title 11, Chapters 79 and 87, regarding residential and non-residential civil violations and penalties (Citywide) Recommendation Staff recommends that the Planning and Zoning Board recommend that the City Council adopt the proposed amendments to Chapters 79 and 87 of Title 11 of the Mesa City Code to classify civil code violations as residential or non-residential and modify and add penalties, including increased fines for non-residential civil violations. Related proposed enforcement amendments to Chapter 6 of Title 8 may be discussed for context but are not subject to the Board’s recommendation. Purpose The proposed amendments would establish a separate civil fine category with higher, escalating penalties for non-residential violations. These changes would encourage timely compliance with the Nuisance and Zoning Codes and reduce the impacts of violations on residents, surrounding properties, and the public, including business visitors. Proposed amendments to Chapters 79 and 87 of Title 11 of the Mesa City Code pertaining to the classification of civil code violations as residential or non-residential and to modify and add new penalties. Although not subject to the recommendation of the Board, the discussion may also cover related, proposed amendments to the Public Nuisances, Property Maintenance, Neighborhood Preservation and Animal Regulations, Chapter 6 of Title 8 of the Mesa City Code pertaining to enforcement. Discussion The civil citation fines were last updated in 2019, and existing fines apply equally to properties regardless of use with escalating fines when violations persist. The proposal would create a separate category with higher penalties for non-residential civil violations. Non-residential uses can affect surrounding neighborhoods and expose customers and other visitors to code violations. Higher fines are intended to encourage business operators and property owners to correct violations promptly and maintain properties in compliance with City codes. The escalating ranges also provide a stronger incentive to address conditions that remain unresolved after a prior finding. | 1 Classification of Violations The amendments to Chapters 79 and 87 would establish the classification of residential and non- residential civil violations and the corresponding penalties. The proposed non-residential category includes non-residential zoned properties, multifamily developments including fourplexes, and businesses unlawfully operating in residential zoning districts that are determined to negatively affect neighborhood character. The ordinance text will establish the controlling definitions and applicability of these classifications. Existing and Proposed Non-Residential Civil Violation Fines Proposed non- Civil violation Existing Title 11 Existing Title 8 residential fines Titles 11 and 8 First finding $150–$1,500 $250–$1,500 $750–$1,500 Second finding $250–$2,500 $350–$2,500 $1,250–$2,000 Third finding $500–$2,500 $500–$2,500 $1,750–$2,500 Existing fines apply without separate residential and non-residential categories. Applicable reinspection, process server, and lien fees and charges are additional to the fines shown. After a citation is issued, the defendant may request a civil hearing. At the hearing, the Civil Hearing Officer considers testimony and circumstances and may reduce fees and fines as authorized by ordinance. Minimum or reduced fines are typically assessed when violations have been corrected by the hearing date. Related Title 8 Amendments Related amendments to Title 8, Chapter 6 would also revise nuisance and property maintenance enforcement as summarized below. These amendments provide context for the zoning proposal and are outside the Planning and Zoning Board’s requested recommendation, which is limited to Title 11. Section 8-6-2 would add residential and non-residential civil violation definitions based on the property’s land use. Residential violations would involve uses listed in Title 11, Section 11-86-2, Residential Use Classifications. Non-residential violations would involve other land uses. Section 8-6-9 would establish separate civil sanction ranges. Residential fines would be $250– $1,500 for a first finding, $350–$2,000 for a second finding, and $500–$2,500 for a third finding. Proposed non-residential fines are shown in the comparison above. Second and third findings would use a 36-month period calculated from the dates the violations were committed. Applicable Code Compliance fees and charges would also apply. The section would retain the Civil Hearing Officer’s authority to reduce or eliminate sanctions for good cause under unusual or extraordinary circumstances. Following abatement, the hearing officer could reduce sanctions or vacate a judgment through a compliance hearing. Each day a violation continues would remain a separate civil offense. | 2 Section 8-6-11 would clarify that prior residential or non-residential civil findings count toward habitual-offender enforcement. A subsequent violation within 36 months after three prior civil findings on separate dates could result in a Class 1 misdemeanor complaint. Upon conviction, the court could impose up to six months in jail, a fine up to $2,500 excluding penalty assessments, or both. The amendment would require a minimum fine of $750 per count and probation for up to 36 months. The court could reduce the fine to $500 per count if all violations are corrected and the site complies with the chapter within 90 days of sentencing. Citizen Participation The proposed Code Compliance fine changes were presented or discussed at the following public meetings: March 5, 2026 – The Audit, Finance, and Enterprise Committee reviewed the proposal to increase Code Compliance fines and fees, including higher civil fines for non-residential properties. March 26, 2026 – The City Council discussed the proposed fine increases during a Study Session presentation on redevelopment programs and initiatives. A Notice of Intent to Establish Fees for Code Compliance was posted on the City of Mesa website on May 14, 2026. June 1, 2026 – The City Council considered proposed fine and fee increases to the Code Compliance Department’s Schedule of Fees and Charges. September 17, 2026 – The City Council discussed the proposal fine increases during its Strategic Planning Session Code Compliance update. Implementation Staff recommends the ordinance approving the proposed text amendments become effective 30 days from the date of City Council approval. Exhibits Exhibit 1 – Proposed amendments to Title 11, Chapters 79 and 87 Ordinance. | 3