Proposed amendments to Title 11, Chapters 79 and 87 Ordinance
City of Mesa — Planning and Zoning Board - Public Hearing (2026-11-18)
Extracted text (via pymupdf_layout)
22277 characters
ORDINANCE NO. _________ AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF MESA, ARIZONA, REGARDING CLASSIFICATION OF CIVIL VIOLATIONS OF THE MESA CITY CODE, AMENDING MESA CITY CODE TITLE 8 (HEALTH, SANITATION AND ENVIRONMENT), CHAPTER 6 (PUBLIC NUISANCES, PROPERTY MAINTENANCE, NEIGHBORHOOD PRESERVATION AND ANIMAL REGULATIONS), ARTICLE III (ENFORCEMENT) AND TITLE 11 (ZONING ORDINANCE), CHAPTER 79 (ENFORCEMENT) AND CHAPTER 87 (DEFINITIONS) TO CLASSIFY CIVIL VIOLATIONS AS EITHER RESIDENTIAL OR NON-RESIDENTIAL, ADOPT RELEVANT DEFINITIONS, AND TO MODIFY AND ADD NEW PENALTIES. Whereas, pursuant to A.R.S. § 9-240, cities and towns are authorized to adopt ordinances necessary for the good government and order of the municipality, to define, abate, and remove nuisances, to compel the cleaning of property and adjacent areas, to adopt regulations necessary for the prevention and suppression of disease, and to enforce observance of municipal ordinances through penalties and other lawful means. Whereas, pursuant to A.R.S. § 9-499 et seq., the City is authorized to require, by ordinance, the removal and abatement of rubbish, trash, weeds, filth, debris, dilapidated buildings, and other hazardous or unsanitary conditions affecting property and contiguous sidewalks, streets, and alleys, and to provide procedures for notice, appeal, abatement, cost recovery, and related enforcement remedies. Whereas, pursuant to A.R.S. § 9-499.04, the City is further authorized to provide for animal control officers and to enforce local ordinances relating to animal control as part of its broader responsibility to protect the public health, safety, and welfare. Whereas, pursuant to A.R.S. § 9-462.01, the City is authorized to regulate zoning, including things such as the use of buildings, structures and land, signs and billboard, the size and use of lots and yards, and off-street parking and loading, among other things, to protect and promote the public health, safety, peace, comfort, convenience, prosperity and general welfare. Whereas, pursuant to A.R.S. § 9-500.21, the City is authorized to classify ordinance violations as civil offenses and to establish procedures for civil enforcement, including issuance of citations, notice to alleged violators, hearings before a hearing officer, imposition of civil penalties, entry of abatement orders pursuant to A.R.S. § 9-499, and judicial review. Whereas, Mesa City Code Title 8, Chapter 6 establishes standards intended to protect and preserve the community’s health, sanitation, environment, safety, appearance, livability, and quality of life through regulations governing public nuisances, property maintenance, neighborhood preservation, and animal regulations. Mesa City Code Section 8-6-9 currently establishes civil penalties for violations enforced under Title 8, Chapter 6, of the Mesa City Code but the existing penalty structure does not distinguish between violations related to residential property and violations related to non-residential property. 1 Whereas, Mesa City Code Title 11 establishes the City’s Zoning Ordinance, with the purpose of implementing the City’s General Plan and to protect and promote the public health, safety, peace, comfort, convenience, prosperity and general welfare. Section 11-79-4 of the Mesa City Code establishes civil penalties for violations enforced under Title 11, Chapter 79, of the Mesa City Code. Like the violations in Title 8, the Zoning Ordinance’s existing penalty structure does not distinguish between violations related to residential property and violations related to non-residential property. Whereas, violations related to non-residential property may involve larger sites, more intensive uses, greater volumes of stored or discarded materials, more frequent activity, higher levels of public exposure, and broader impacts on traffic circulation, drainage, sanitation, safety, neighborhood appearance, and the economic vitality of surrounding areas. Whereas, members of the general public are more likely to enter or use non-residential properties that they do not own, possess, or control. Because the public may be unable to identify, avoid, or correct unsafe or unlawful conditions on those properties, City code enforcement is necessary to help protect the health, safety, and welfare of the public on non-residential property. Whereas, non-residential properties often occupy substantial street frontage along arterial and other highly traveled streets and corridors and, by reason of their size, visibility, frequency of use, and relationship to commercial, employment, industrial, and public activity, may have broader impacts on traffic circulation, drainage, sanitation, safety, neighborhood appearance, economic vitality, and the public image of the City, surrounding neighborhoods, nearby property owners, and businesses. Whereas, when non-residential properties are not maintained in compliance with City codes or become blighted, deteriorated, unsafe, or visually neglected, the resulting impacts may be more visible and more widely experienced by residents, visitors, customers, employees, adjoining property owners, and the traveling public than similar conditions occurring on smaller or less frequently used properties. Whereas, owners, operators, and persons responsible for non-residential properties generally have greater operational responsibility and capacity to monitor, manage, and timely correct conditions on property used for commercial, employment, industrial, and other non- residential purposes. Whereas, residential and non-residential properties often differ in scale, intensity of use, operational characteristics, frequency of activity, and potential impacts on adjacent properties, public rights-of-way, and surrounding areas, and those differences may warrant different civil penalty classifications for purposes of effective enforcement. Whereas, distinguishing civil violations as either residential or non-residential will provide clearer standards for administration and enforcement and will better align the civil penalty structure with the differing characteristics and impacts of those properties. Whereas, retaining the existing civil sanctions as the penalties applicable to residential violations will preserve continuity in the City’s current enforcement framework while allowing 2 the City to address non-residential violations through a separate and more proportionate penalty schedule. Whereas, the City Council desires to amend Mesa City Code Title 8, Chapter 6, Section 8- 6-9 and Mesa City Code Title 11, Chapters 79 and 87 to classify civil violations as either residential or non-residential, to designate the existing civil sanctions as applicable to residential violations, to establish additional civil violations and sanctions applicable to non-residential violations, and to provide appropriate definitions. Whereas, the City Council desires to amend Title 8, Chapter 6, Section 8-6-11 and Mesa City Code Title 11, Chapter 79 to reflect the new classification types of residential and non- residential and to establish new habitual offender penalties related to non-residential violations. Whereas, for the reasons stated herein, the City Council finds it is appropriate and in the best interests of the City to amend Mesa City Code Title 8, Chapter 6, and Title 11, Chapters 79 and 87, as stated, to promote good government and order of the City and to strengthen the City’s ability to obtain compliance, abate nuisance and property maintenance conditions, protect neighborhoods and the environment, and preserve the public health, safety, and general welfare. BE IT ORDAINED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF MESA: Section 1: Mesa City Code Title 8, Chapter 6, Section 8-6-9: – Civil Penalties, is amended as follows: 8-6-9:– CIVIL PENALTIES (A) Any responsible party who is found responsible SANCTIONS for a civil violation of this Chapter, whether by admission, default, or after a hearing, shall pay a civil sanction BE AS FOLLOWS: 1. RESIDENTIAL VIOLATIONS. (A) FIRST VIOLATION. ANY RESPONSIBLE PARTY WHO IS FOUND RESPONSIBLE for a civil RESIDENTIAL vViolation of this Chapter, whether by admission, default, or after a hearing, shall pay a civil sanction of not less than $250 Nor more than $1,500. (B) SECOND VIOLATION. A second finding of responsibility FOR A RESIDENTIAL VIOLATION within 36 months of the commission of a prior RESIDENTIAL vViolation of this Chapter shall result in an enhanced civil sanction of not less than $350 Nor more than $2,5000. (C) THIRD VIOLATION. A third finding of responsibility FOR A RESIDENTIAL VIOLATION within 36 months of the commission of a prior RESIDENTIAL vViolation of this Chapter shall result in an enhanced civil sanction of not less than $500 Nor more than $2,500. 3 (D) RESPONSIBILITY FOR ALL FEES AND CHARGES. In addition to the civil sanction, the responsible party shall pay the applicable fees and charges set forth in the City’s Development Services (Code Compliance) Schedule of Fees and Charges and may be ordered to pay any other applicable fees and charges. 2. NON-RESIDENTIAL VIOLATIONS. (A) FIRST VIOLATION. ANY RESPONSIBLE PARTY WHO IS FOUND RESPONSIBLE FOR A NON-RESIDENTIAL VIOLATION OF THIS CHAPTER, WHETHER BY ADMISSION, DEFAULT, OR AFTER A HEARING, SHALL PAY A CIVIL SANCTION OF NOT LESS THAN $750 NOR MORE THAN $1,500. (B) SECOND VIOLATION. A SECOND FINDING OF RESPONSIBILITY FOR A NON-RESIDENTIAL VIOLATION WITHIN 36 MONTHS OF THE COMMISSION OF A PRIOR NON- RESIDENTIAL VIOLATION OF THIS CHAPTER SHALL RESULT IN AN ENHANCED CIVIL SANCTION OF NOT LESS THAN $1,250 NOR MORE THAN $2,000. (C) THIRD VIOLATION. A THIRD FINDING OF RESPONSIBILITY FOR A NON-RESIDENTIAL VIOLATION WITHIN 36 MONTHS OF THE COMMISSION OF A PRIOR NON- RESIDENTIAL VIOLATION OF THIS CHAPTER SHALL RESULT IN AN ENHANCED CIVIL SANCTION OF NOT LESS THAN $1,750 NOR MORE THAN $2,500. (D) RESPONSIBILITY FOR ALL FEES AND CHARGES. IN ADDITION TO THE CIVIL SANCTION, THE RESPONSIBLE PARTY SHALL PAY THE APPLICABLE FEES AND CHARGES SET FORTH IN THE CITY’S CODE COMPLIANCE SCHEDULE OF FEES AND CHARGES AND MAY BE ORDERED TO PAY ANY OTHER APPLICABLE FEES AND CHARGES. (B) Under unusual or extraordinary circumstances, and for good cause, the Civil Hearing Officer shall have the discretion to reduce or eliminate any portion of the civil sanctions specified in this Section, and/or to make any other judgments or orders deemed by the Civil Hearing Officer to be in the best interests of the City of Mesa, which will result in the furtherance of these regulations and effectuate the abatement or cessation of any violation of this Chapter. (C) After entering a judgment of responsible and setting a civil sanction and fees as specified in Section 8-6-9(A), the Civil Hearing Officer may order a compliance hearing and set a date for such hearing. Upon presentation of evidence and/or testimony by the City Inspector at the compliance hearing that the violation(s) specified in the complaint has been abated, the Civil Hearing Officer may reduce all or a portion of the civil sanction commensurate with the cost borne by the 4 defendant to achieve compliance, or the Civil Hearing Officer may vacate the previous judgment and dismiss the citation(s). If, a minimum of 7 calendar days before a scheduled compliance hearing, the Civil Hearing Officer receives both of the following items, then the Civil Hearing Officer may issue written orders commensurate with the authority given in this Section, to reduce civil sanctions and/or vacate the related judgment without holding the scheduled compliance hearing: 1. A written and notarized confirmation from the City Inspector that the violation has been successfully abated; and 2. A written and notarized statement from the defendant describing the actions taken and the itemized costs borne to abate the violation. If either item has not been received by the designated Clerk of the Civil Hearing Office seven (7) calendar days before, then the compliance hearing shall take place as previously scheduled. (D) The 36-month provision of paragraph (A) of this Section shall be calculated by the dates the violations were committed. The responsible party shall receive the enhanced sanction upon a finding of responsibility for any violation of this Chapter that was committed within 36 months of the commission of another violation for which the responsible party was convicted or was otherwise found responsible, irrespective of the order in which the violations occurred or whether the prior violation was civil or criminal. (E) Each day in which a violation of this Chapter continues or the failure to perform any act or duty required by this Chapter or by the Civil Hearing Officer continues shall constitute a separate civil offense. Section 2: Mesa City Code Title 8, Chapter 6, Section 8-6-11: – Habitual Offender, is amended as follows: 8-6-11:– HABITUAL OFFENDER (A) A person who commits a violation of this Chapter WITHIN A 36-MONTH PERIOD after previously having been found responsible for committing 3 civil violations of ANY TYPE (RESIDENTIAL OR NON-RESIDENTIAL) UNDER this Chapter on 3 separate dates and within a 36 month period, whether by admission, by payment of the fine, by default, or by judgment after hearing, shall be guilty of a class 1 criminal misdemeanor. The Mesa City Prosecutor is authorized to file a class 1 criminal misdemeanor complaint in the Mesa City Court (Court) against habitual offenders. For purposes of calculating the 36-month period under this paragraph, the dates of the commission of the offenses are the determining factor. (B) Upon conviction of a violation of this Section, the Court may impose a sentence authorized by the laws of the State of Arizona for a class 1 misdemeanor, including 5 incarceration not to exceed 6 months in jail or a fine not to exceed $2,500, exclusive of penalty assessments prescribed by law, or both. The Court shall order a person who has been convicted of a violation of this Section to pay a fine of not less than $7500 for each count upon which a conviction has been obtained and be placed on probation for up to 36 months. The Court may reduce such fines to $2500 for each count upon which a conviction has been obtained provided all violations have been abated and the site is in compliance with all Sections of this Chapter within 90 days of sentencing. (C) Every action or proceeding under this Section shall be commenced and prosecuted in accordance with the laws of the State of Arizona relating to criminal misdemeanors and the Arizona Rules of Criminal Procedure. Section 3: Mesa City Code Title 8, Chapter 6, Section 8-6-2 – Definitions, is hereby amended only to add the definitions of “Non-Residential Violation,” and “Residential Violation,” which shall be inserted, in alphabetical order, into the list of existing definitions. All other definitions in Section 8-6-2 remain unchanged. 8-6-2:– DEFINITIONS … NON-RESIDENTIAL VIOLATION: A CIVIL VIOLATION OF THIS CHAPTER RELATED TO ANY PROPERTY, LOT, OR PARCEL USED FOR A LAND USE TYPE, EXCLUDING ANY LAND USE TYPE LISTED UNDER MESA CITY CODE TITLE 11, CHAPTER 86, SECTION 11-86-2: - RESIDENTIAL USE CLASSIFICATIONS. … RESIDENTIAL VIOLATION: A CIVIL VIOLATION OF THIS CHAPTER RELATED TO ANY PROPERTY, LOT, OR PARCEL USED FOR ANY LAND USE TYPE LISTED UNDER MESA CITY CODE TITLE 11, CHAPTER 86, SECTION 11-86-2: - RESIDENTIAL USE CLASSIFICATIONS. … Section 4: Mesa City Code Title 11, Chapter 79, Section 11-79-4: – Civil Penalties, is amended as follows: 11-79-4: CIVIL PENALTIES A. Any owner, occupant or responsible party who is found responsible for a civil violation of this Ordinance, SANCTIONS FOR A CIVIL VIOLATION OF THIS CHAPTER whether by admission, default, or after a hearing, SHALL BE AS FOLLOWS: 1. RESIDENTIAL VIOLATIONS. 6 A. FIRST VIOLATION. ANY OWNER, OCCUPANT OR RESPONSIBLE PARTY WHO IS FOUND RESPONSIBLE FOR A RESIDENTIAL VIOLATION OF THIS CHAPTER shall pay a civil sanction of not less than $1250 Nor more than $1,500, per citation. B. SECOND VIOLATION. A second finding of responsibility within 24 months of the commission of a prior RESIDENTIAL violation of this Chapter shall result in a civil sanction of not less than $2350 Nor more than $2,5000. C. THIRD VIOLATION. A third finding of responsibility within 36 months of the commission of a prior RESIDENTIAL violation of this Chapter shall result in a civil sanction of not less than $500 Nor more than $2,500. D. RESPONSIBILITY FOR ALL FEES AND CHARGES. In addition to the civil sanction, the responsible party shall pay the applicable fees and charges set forth in the City’s Code Compliance Schedule of Fees and Charges, and may be ordered to pay any other applicable fees and charges. 2. NON-RESIDENTIAL VIOLATIONS. A. FIRST VIOLATION. ANY OWNER, OCCUPANT OR RESPONSIBLE PARTY WHO IS FOUND RESPONSIBLE FOR A NON-RESIDENTIAL VIOLATION OF THIS CHAPTER SHALL PAY A CIVIL SANCTION OF NOT LESS THAN $750 NOR MORE THAN $1,500, PER CITATION. B. SECOND VIOLATION. A SECOND FINDING OF RESPONSIBILITY WITHIN 24 MONTHS OF THE COMMISSION OF A PRIOR NON-RESIDENTIAL VIOLATION OF THIS CHAPTER SHALL RESULT IN A CIVIL SANCTION OF NOT LESS THAN $1,250 NOR MORE THAN $2,000. C. THIRD VIOLATION. A THIRD FINDING OF RESPONSIBILITY WITHIN 36 MONTHS OF THE COMMISSION OF A PRIOR NON-RESIDENTIAL VIOLATION OF THIS CHAPTER SHALL RESULT IN A CIVIL SANCTION OF NOT LESS THAN $1,750 NOR MORE THAN $2,500. D. RESPONSIBILITY FOR ALL FEES AND CHARGES. IN ADDITION TO THE CIVIL SANCTION, THE RESPONSIBLE PARTY SHALL PAY THE APPLICABLE 7 FEES AND CHARGES SET FORTH IN THE CITY’S CODE COMPLIANCE SCHEDULE OF FEES AND CHARGES, AND MAY BE ORDERED TO PAY ANY OTHER APPLICABLE FEES AND CHARGES. B. The 36-month provision of subsection (A) of this Section shall be calculated by the dates the violations were committed. The owner, occupant, or responsible party shall receive the enhanced sanction upon a finding of responsibility for any violation of this Chapter that was committed within 36 months of the commission of another violation for which the owner or responsible party was convicted or was otherwise found responsible, irrespective of the order in which the violations occurred or whether the prior violation was civil or criminal. C. Each day in which a violation of this Ordinance continues, or the failure to perform any act or duty required by this Ordinance or by the Civil Hearing Officer continues, shall constitute a separate civil offense. Section 5: Mesa City Code Title 11, Chapter 79, Section 11-79-5: – Habitual Offender, is amended as follows: A. A person who commits a violation of this Ordinance WITHIN A 36-MONTH PERIOD after previously having been found responsible for committing THREE (3) or more civil violations of ANY TYPE (RESIDENTIAL OR NON- RESIDENTIAL) UNDER this Ordinance within a 24 month period — whether by admission, by payment of the fine, by default, or by judgment after hearing — shall be guilty of a class ONE (1) criminal misdemeanor. The Mesa City Prosecutor is authorized to file a criminal class ONE (1) complaint in the Mesa City Court against habitual offenders. For purposes of calculating the 2436-month period under this paragraph, the dates of the commission of the offenses are the determining factor. B. Upon conviction of a violation of this Subsection, the Court may impose a sentence or incarceration not to exceed SIX (6) months in jail; or a fine not to exceed $2,500, exclusive of penalty assessments prescribed by law; or both. The Court shall order a person who has been convicted of a violation of this Section to pay a fine of not less than $50750 for each count upon which a conviction has been obtained. A judge shall not grant probation to or suspend any part or all of the imposition or execution of a sentence required by this Subsection except on the condition that the person pay the mandatory minimum fines as provided in this Subsection. C. Every action or proceeding under this Section shall be commenced and prosecuted in accordance with the laws of the State of Arizona relating to criminal misdemeanors and the Arizona Rules of Criminal Procedure. Section 6: Mesa City Code Title 11, Chapter 87 – Definitions, is hereby amended only to add the definitions of “Non-Residential Violation,” and “Residential Violation,” which shall be inserted, in alphabetical order, into the list of existing definitions. All other definitions in Title 11, Chapter 87 remain unchanged. 8 CHAPTER 87– DEFINITIONS … NON-RESIDENTIAL VIOLATION: A CIVIL VIOLATION OF THIS TITLE RELATED TO ANY PROPERTY, LOT, OR PARCEL USED FOR A LAND USE TYPE, EXCLUDING ANY LAND USE TYPE LISTED UNDER MESA CITY CODE TITLE 11, CHAPTER 86, SECTION 11-86-2: - RESIDENTIAL USE CLASSIFICATIONS. … RESIDENTIAL VIOLATION: A CIVIL VIOLATION OF THIS TITLE RELATED TO ANY PROPERTY, LOT, OR PARCEL USED FOR ANY LAND USE TYPE LISTED UNDER MESA CITY CODE TITLE 11, CHAPTER 86, SECTION 11-86- 2: - RESIDENTIAL USE CLASSIFICATIONS. … Section 7: Recitals. The recitals above are fully incorporated in this ordinance by reference, and each recital represents a finding of fact and determination made by the City Council. Section 8: Amended Language. In Sections 1 through 6 of this ordinance, language added to the Mesa City Code is shown in BOLD ALL CAPS and language deleted from the Mesa City Code is shown in strikethrough. Section 9: Preservation of Rights and Duties. This ordinance does not affect suits pending, rights and duties that matured or were existing, or penalties that were incurred or proceedings that were initiated prior to the effective date of this ordinance. Section 10: Effective Date. The effective date of this ordinance is ___________ __, 2026. Section 11: Severability. If any term, provision, section, subsection, sentence, clause, phrase, or portion of this ordinance is for any reason held to be invalid, unenforceable, or unconstitutional by the decision of a court of competent jurisdiction, the remaining portions of this ordinance will remain in effect. Passed and adopted by the City Council of the City of Mesa on _____________, 2026. ______________________________ Mark Freeman, Mayor Attest: 9 _____________________________ Holly Moseley, City Clerk 10