Attachment A - October 21, 2026 TIP Minutes
City of Phoenix — Transportation, Infrastructure, and Planning Subcommittee (2026-11-18)
Extracted text (via pymupdf_layout)
12314 characters
Attachment A Phoenix City Council Transportation, Infrastructure, and Planning Subcommittee Summary Minutes October 21, 2026 City Council Chambers 200 W. Jefferson St. Phoenix, Arizona. Subcommittee Members Present Subcommittee Members Absent Councilwoman Debra Stark, Chair Councilman Jim Waring Councilman Kevin Robinson Vice Mayor Kesha Hodge Washington CALL TO ORDER Chairwoman Stark called the Transportation, Infrastructure, and Planning (TIP) Subcommittee to order at 10:01 a.m. with Councilman Jim Waring and Councilman Kevin Robinson present. Vice Mayor Kesha Hodge Washington participated virtually. CALL TO THE PUBLIC None. MINUTES OF MEETINGS 1. Minutes of the Transportation, Infrastructure, and Planning Subcommittee Meeting Councilwoman Stark made a motion to approve the minutes of the May 20, 2026, Transportation, Infrastructure, and Planning Subcommittee meeting. Councilman Robinson seconded the motion which passed unanimously, 4-0. CONSENT ACTION (ITEMS 2-4) Items 2-4 were for consent action. No presentations were planned, but staff was available to answer questions. Chairwoman Stark made a motion to approve Items 2-4. Councilman Robinson seconded the motion which passed unanimously, 4-0. 2. Request to Issue Solicitation- Bus Rapid Transit 3. Amend City Code- Local Speed Limits 4. Taxi Services Contract Award at PHX Chairwoman Stark praised the Bus Rapid Transit (BRT) system that she experienced in Madison, Wisconsin, and she expressed that it will complement the light rail well. INFORMATION AND DISCUSSION (ITEM 5) 5. Parks and Recreation Department Master Plan UpdateDeputy City Manager Cynthia Aguilar introduced the item. Parks and Recreation Director Martin Whitfield, Special Projects Administrator Felicita Mendoza, and PROS Consulting representative Mike Spetz presented an update on the Parks and Recreation Department’s 10-year Master Plan. The plan will guide investments in parks, recreation facilities, pools, amenities, water conservation, and operations. Mr. Spetz shared the results of community engagement and assessments of the park system. He stated that 78 percent of residents used the park system, 70 percent rated park conditions as good or excellent and 86 percent rated programs and events as good or excellent. Mr. Spetz noted that residents prioritized safe, clean, shaded and functional parks. Residents also identified maintenance, shared-use paths and restrooms as priorities. Mr. Spetz emphasized that maintenance, recreation programs, and urban park rangers contributed to park safety. He stated that approximately three out of four park visits involved self-directed activities such as walking, using playgrounds, and picnicking. Mr. Spetz reviewed access to parks, recreation centers, community centers and pools. He also discussed community interest in pickleball courts, dog parks, and splash pads. Mr. Spetz stated that future investments should protect and renew existing parks, add amenities based on community needs, and consider the long-term costs of operating and maintaining new facilities. Director Whitfield stated that staff anticipated completing the draft Master Plan during the winter, presenting it to the Parks and Recreation Board after the beginning of the year, and returning to the subcommittee with the final plan. Tim Sierakowski asked why golf courses and mountain preserves were not included in the Master Plan. He also requested that hiking trails and trail maintenance be considered as part of the plan. Chairwoman Stark asked how the department ensured equity in the maintenance of older parks compared to newer parks. Director Martin Whitfield stated that maintenance teams serviced all 189 City parks and did not distinguish between older and newer parks. Chairwoman Stark noted the popularity of cricket practice pitches in her district and asked how the Master Plan addressed emerging recreational trends. Mr. Spetz stated that staff reviewed participation data over different periods to identify recreation trends. He recommended continued community engagement and periodic review of the data to prevent investments from becoming outdated. Councilman Waring discussed the use of the cricket pitch at Sandpiper Park and expressed support for the project. He noted that the improvement provided a dedicated area for cricket and preserved other areas for baseball and softball. He expressed appreciation for staff monitoring emerging trends, as supporters may not always be vocal or advocate for these additions. He acknowledged that new constructions often depend on community input, prioritization, and available funds. Councilman Waring asked about the cost of constructing and converting courts for pickleball. Director Whitfield stated that two pickleball courts could fit in one tennis court. He explained that costs varied depending on the condition of the existing court and whether resurfacing, concrete replacement, lighting, drinking fountains or new construction were needed. He noted that these costs may range from $25,000 to $1 million. Councilman Waring encouraged staff to provide information about the cost of amenities when asking residents to identify park priorities. Councilman Waring asked whether new splash pads would recapture water. He encouraged staff to consider water conservation when developing aquatic amenities. Councilman Waring asked how frequently park equipment and grounds were inspected. Director Whitfield stated that maintenance teams inspected playgrounds, irrigation systems, restrooms, turf and other park amenities daily. Councilman Waring asked how frequently park parking lots were inspected and how repairs were funded. Director Whitfield stated that maintenance teams inspected parking lots daily and repairs were funded through the department’s budget. He noted that the department had a five-year capital item for parking lot repairs. Councilman Waring asked what percentage of playground equipment was shaded and acknowledged the substantial cost of shading infrastructure Director Whitfield responded that he did not have a percentage. He stated that the department installed shade when replacing playgrounds and other equipment. He acknowledged the continued partnership with Director David Hondula and the Office of Heat Response and Mitigation for supporting these initiatives. Councilman Waring asked about the cost of constructing new park restrooms. Director Whitfield stated that many park restrooms were old and noted that a new restroom could cost approximately $1.8 million. Councilman Waring noted that costs have increased over time and recommended that future community engagement materials include the relative costs of proposed amenities. Councilman Waring asked when signs announcing future parks were installed. Director Whitfield stated that the department did not have a formal protocol. He suggested that signs be installed when a project reached the design phase. Councilman Waring asked how long it generally takes to develop a new park. Director Whitfield explained that community engagement generally takes six to twelve months, design takes approximately twelve months, and construction could take another twelve months. He stated that development of a new park could take up to three years. Councilman Waring asked whether the department’s capital and operating budgets were separate. Director Whitfield affirmed and stated that maintenance was funded through the operating budget. He noted that maintenance represented approximately 60 percent of the department’s operating budget. He stated that the department also has a 5-year $422 million Capital Improvement Program budget. Councilman Waring asked whether Phoenix Parks and Preserves Initiative funds could be used for park safety. Director Whitfield confirmed that the funds were used for certain staffing costs. Councilman Waring stated that a priority is to attract and maintain park users through creating a safe and welcoming environment. He requested an update on contracted security and urban park rangers. Director Whitfield stated that beginning in February 2023, contracted security patrolled 12 parks between 8:00 p.m. and 10:00 a.m., seven days a week. He noted that contracted security coordinated with urban park rangers, the Police Department and the Fire Department. Director Whitfield stated that the department has 44 urban park rangers who serve the Parks system 24 hours a day, seven days a week. He stated that this was the most urban park rangers in Parks history. He noted that the rangers visit approximately 175 of the City’s 189 parks each month. Councilman Waring expressed appreciation for the department’s coordination with the District 2 office on park improvements. He emphasized the value of parks for children, families, and neighborhoods. Director Whitfield thanked Councilman Waring for the kind words. Councilman Waring asked whether the department operated the City’s golf courses. Director Whitfield stated that the City owns the golf courses. He explained that Grand Canyon University operates Maryvale Golf Course, Arizona State University operates Papago Golf Course, and the department operates the remaining courses. Councilman Waring asked why golf courses were not included in the Master Plan. Director Whitfield stated that the department decided in 2023 to focus the current Master Plan on urban parks. He noted that separate master plans for preserves and other amenities were anticipated. Councilman Waring asked whether golf course maintenance was contracted. Director Whitfield affirmed that the maintenance of City golf courses was contracted. Councilman Waring stated that trails may have different needs than other Parks initiatives outlined in the plan. He asked whether the department planned to seek feedback from trail users. Director Whitfield stated that the department planned to gather feedback but had not established a timeframe. He noted that there are individual master plans for some preserves, and the preserves would be updated in the future. Vice Mayor Hodge Washington thanked staff for developing the Master Plan and engaging residents. She asked how the plan would prioritize maintenance, safety, shade, walking paths, restrooms, and other amenities. Mr. Spetz stated that safety was identified as the primary barrier to park use. He explained that community priorities would guide recommendations for operations, maintenance, and capital investments. Vice Mayor Hodge Washington asked whether residents would participate in determining the safety needs of individual parks. Mr. Spetz stated that safety concerns varied among parks and districts. He emphasized that a strategic plan should include community engagement at the individual park level. Vice Mayor Hodge Washington encouraged staff to consider flexible, multi-use facilities when responding to recreation trends, so facilities were not limited to one sport. Vice Mayor Hodge Washington asked how the Master Plan would measure self-directed park use. Mr. Spetz stated that the current community engagement results could serve as a baseline. He recommended periodically measuring changes in park use, safety concerns, and access. Vice Mayor Hodge Washington asked whether the Master Plan would incorporate the Shade Phoenix Plan, Monarch Pledge, Phoenix Bird Plan, and other City efforts. Mr. Spetz confirmed that the Master Plan would coordinate with existing City plans and planning efforts. Vice Mayor Hodge Washington asked whether the Laveen Area Conveyance Channel was included in the Master Plan. Director Whitfield clarified that the Conveyance Channel was considered a linear urban park and was included. Chairwoman Stark thanked staff for the presentation. CALL TO THE PUBLIC Mr. Sierakowski stated that the Master Plan was not encompassing of all Parks initiatives. Additionally, he recommended allowing legal documents involving police officers and firefighters to be served through the City Clerk’s Office. FUTURE AGENDA ITEMS Deputy City Manager Aguilar noted that a revised agenda would be distributed, featuring a T2050 update and other items. Councilman Waring requested an update on Phoenix golf courses. ADJOURNMENT Chairwoman Stark adjourned the meeting at 11:12 a.m. Respectfully submitted, Alex Saldana Management Fellow