Attachment C - VPC Summary - Z-129-26-4.pdf
Extracted text (via pymupdf_layout)
15068 characters
ATTACHMENT C Village Planning Committee Meeting Summary Z-129-26-4 Date of VPC Meeting October 5, 2026 Request From C-1 TOD-1, C-1 SP TOD-1 and C-3 TOD-1 Request To WC Code T6:22 MT Proposal Surgical Center Location Southeast corner of 2nd Avenue and Indianola Avenue VPC Recommendation Approval, per the staff recommendation VPC Vote 9-0 VPC DISCUSSION: No members of the public registered to speak on this item. STAFF PRESENTATION: John Roanhorse, staff, provided an introduction and overview of the rezoning request, describing the location, general plan designation, existing and proposed zoning districts, and the surrounding uses. Mr. Roanhorse discussed the objectives of the WU (Walkable Urban Code) as supportive of mixed-use development opportunities including various retail and commercial uses, office space, and medical offices that support nearby institutions, including Saint Joseph's Hospital. Mr. Roanhorse stated that the city evaluates rezoning proposals based on their consistency with the WU Code and the broader context of the surrounding area including the TOD (Transit Oriented Development) planning document as part of the review. Mr. Roanhorse discussed the Reinvent Phoenix and Transit Oriented Development planning documents to illustrate the anticipated intensity of development, potential land uses, and building forms envisioned for the proposed site. Mr. Roanhorse stated that location near Indian School Road and Central Avenue is designated for development as regional and major activity areas. Mr. Roanhorse displayed maps, the proposed site plan and conceptual information to show the details of the proposed development. Mr. Roanhorse presented the project details noting the proposed surgical center development and the adjacent residential character, parking, traffic flow and redevelopment options and pedestrian routes. Mr. Roanhorse discussed the review process, the report analysis, findings, and stipulations. Committee Member Robert Warnicke asked about the building height and applicability of the WU Code as it applies to this proposal. Committee Member Warnicke asked why there are stipulations that include provisions related to future development City of Phoenix • Planning & Development Department 200 West Washington Street, 3rd Floor • Phoenix, Arizona 85003-1611 • (602) 262-6882 Encanto Village Planning Committee Meeting Summary Z-129-26-4 Page 2 of 5 incentives and building heights of up to 250 feet. Committee Member Warnicke stated that the development and requirements for the WU Code in the area may change in the future, resulting in restrictions based on the zoning request. Committee Member Warnicke stated that it appears the city is granting an entitlement for future development with limited restrictions for the current building and the site. Committee Member Warnicke stated that the situation promotes land banking along Central Avenue, which prompts economically inequity. Mr. Roanhorse responded that the current site has various overlay zoning categories including a Special Permit for the athletic club and this zoning request will remove the Special Permit and allow a broader range of uses within the WU Code. Committee Member Warnicke stated the WU Code will allow the applicant to have the use they want so why were there imposed incentive tied to future developments and opportunities. Mr. Roanhorse responded that development in this area will be under the WU Code and many of the developments along Central Avenue have been designed and development with the WU Code. Committee Warnicke stated requiring stipulations to a future development can have adverse impacts and the focus of rezoning should only consider that current adaptive reuse request. Committee Member Rick Mahrle asked what could be built on the site if there was no zoning change. Mr. Roanhorse responded that development and use of the site are restricted by the existing Special Permit. APPLICANT PRESENTATION: Benjamin Tate, with Withey Morris Baugh, PLC. representing American Development Partners on behalf of the Phoenix Surgical Institute, introduced the project and provided background on the property and its existing development. Mr. Tate stated that the site is located at the southeast corner of Second Avenue and Indianola Avenue is adjacent to Kent Tower building. Mr. Tate discussed the existing building, with a lower level and one above-ground level which was previously occupied by the Sports Club at City Square, which closed in 2021. Mr. Tate described the property's existing zoning as a combination of several zoning designations and that the current zoning configuration was unusual and that one objective of the request was to consolidate and update the zoning designations and noted that the city has been moving away from zoning districts in favor of the WU Code which is consistent with the city's long-term planning objectives for the Central Avenue corridor and the applicable transit-oriented development policies. Mr. Tate stated that the surrounding properties and their zoning designations, including the adjacent Kent Tower, a hotel, and nearby surface parking areas, and that the surrounding properties all have different zoning designations, which contributes to the complexity of the site's configuration. Mr. Tate stated there was a historical context for the development, explaining that the property was part of the Roszenweig Center, which was developed in connection with a corporate headquarters and was designed and developed around commercial office space and hotel uses. Mr. Tate stated that a Special Permit was approved in 1984 to allow the building to operate as an athletic club and this restricted the property to that specific use rather than allowing the full range of uses. Mr. Tate said the athletic club had permanently closed in 2021, and the existing City of Phoenix • Planning & Development Department 200 West Washington Street, 3rd Floor • Phoenix, Arizona 85003-1611 • (602) 262-6882 Encanto Village Planning Committee Meeting Summary Z-129-26-4 Page 3 of 5 building could not be used for a different purpose without a zoning change and that the adjacent hotel had changed ownership several times and the office tower had undergone changes in use and management. Mr. Tate stated Hilton assumed hotel management in 2003, after which the athletic club operated independently as Sports Club at City Square until its closure in 2021. Mr. Tate stated that the applicant was requesting to rezone the property to the WU Code designation noting the reasons for the request, emphasizing that the existing Special Permit limited the building to athletic club use and that rezoning was necessary to allow the property to accommodate the proposed use with limited changes to the exterior of the building. Mr. Tate stated that the proposal presented significant physical constraints for redevelopment, noting that the existing building was attached to other buildings on three sides and any vertical redevelopment would be difficult without coordinating with neighboring property owners. Mr. Tate stated that these constraints were the primary reason the applicant selected an adaptive reuse approach rather than proposing to demolish and replace the existing building and convert the structure into an ambulatory surgery center. Mr. Tate stated that the project would largely retain the existing building structure, with limited exterior improvements and there would be updates and minor adjustments to the building footprint, and improvements to exterior finishes and materials which would enhance the property while allowing the existing building to accommodate the proposed medical use. Mr. Tate stated the proposal would include a new generator and transformer on the west side of the building, which was necessary for reliable backup power and electrical infrastructure. Mr. Tate added that the additional infrastructure would be essential for an ambulatory surgery center, where medical equipment and other critical systems must remain operational during power outages or other disruptions. Mr. Tate stated that the applicant did not want the new equipment to detract from the property's appearance and to address this concern, the applicant proposed participating in the City of Phoenix Office of Arts and Culture mural program. Mr. Tate stated there will be artwork that would be incorporated into the new exterior enclosure and other mechanical areas in the building's overall design. Mr. Tate displayed and discussed the building's interior layout noting that the facility would accommodate the ambulatory surgery center and associated medical functions and specializations. Mr. Tate stated the floor plan would be developed for medical use on the ground floor, and the basement would be used for storage. Mr. Tate then displayed and discussed the building elevations, noting that only the north and west elevations were exposed because the building is attached to the adjacent Kent Tower and other structures. Mr. Tate stated that the applicant submitted a TIA (Traffic Impact Analysis) noting that the proposal was expected to generate a relatively limited amount of additional automobile traffic. Mr. Tate stated that most of the project's traffic would be associated with patient appointments and procedures and that the facility's operating rooms and procedure rooms would serve scheduled patients, resulting in predictable arrival and departure patterns. City of Phoenix • Planning & Development Department 200 West Washington Street, 3rd Floor • Phoenix, Arizona 85003-1611 • (602) 262-6882 Encanto Village Planning Committee Meeting Summary Z-129-26-4 Page 4 of 5 Mr. Tate stated that the property had sufficient parking capacity relative to the proposed use and noted that the existing parking arrangements provided access to approximately 552 parking spaces, while the project was expected to require parking for approximately 100 employees and noted that the parking allocation originated from an earlier agreement or arrangement associated with the property. QUESTIONS FROM THE COMMITTEE: Committee Member Robert Warnicke asked if the proposal included activated frontages, as required under the WU Code. Mr. Tate responded that the proposal did not include activated frontages and explained that the proposal involved the adaptive reuse of the existing building, which would remain largely unchanged. Mr. Tate stated that under the requirements redevelopment involving more than 2,000 square feet of the building would trigger requirements to bring the property into conformance with the WU Code. Mr. Tate stated that the site's physical constraints made it difficult to modify the existing building to provide the required activated frontage and the applicant's options were to proceed with the proposed rezoning and retain the existing building under the applicable nonconforming provisions or pursue a site-specific zoning approach that would need to remain consistent with the city's planning objectives. Committee Member Eric Tedhams asked if the proposed surgery center would provide emergency surgical services or perform procedures scheduled in advance. Mr. Tate responded that the facility would include three operating and two procedure rooms for pain management and gastrointestinal procedures and these services would be provided through scheduled procedures rather than emergency room services. Committee Member G.G. George commented that when she first moved to Phoenix in 1966, she had stayed at the Del Webb Townhouse (which is now the Kent Tower) for approximately one month while looking for a place to live and asked when the existing building was constructed. Mr. Tate responded that the original building was believed to have been constructed in 1962. Committee Member Procaccini asked if the proposed transformer and emergency generator would be fully enclosed by solid walls or otherwise screened from view and if there were potential noise impacts, noting the nearby hotel and residential uses. Mr. Tate responded that the transformer would be enclosed in a heavy steel structure and the applicant will incorporate screening and design features into the exterior improvements to reduce the visual impact of the equipment. Mr. Tate stated that the emergency generator would operate during routine testing and when needed during a power outage and would be tested periodically to ensure it remained operational and would otherwise run only when backup power was required. Committee Member Brent Kleinman stated he was supportive of the proposal and was prepared to make a motion to approve the case based on the staff report and its City of Phoenix • Planning & Development Department 200 West Washington Street, 3rd Floor • Phoenix, Arizona 85003-1611 • (602) 262-6882 Encanto Village Planning Committee Meeting Summary Z-129-26-4 Page 5 of 5 stipulations. Vice Chair Jorge Picos stated that it was too early to make a motion and asked whether there were any additional questions from the committee or the public. Committee Member Steve Procaccini asked about the parking arrangements, including the location of the parking areas and the applicant's rights to use the available spaces. Mr. Tate responded that the property had access to several surface parking areas associated with the larger development and noted parking areas to the northeast and southwest of the subject property and referenced approximately 80 spaces in one area and 72 spaces in another. Mr. Tate noted that the precise allocation of parking rights among the various buildings and ownership entities was complex and that the existing agreements and arrangements established parking access for the properties within the larger development. Committee Member Tedhams asked about the status of the development that Mr. Tate was involved with adjacent to the Carnation Neighborhood and asked about the parking arrangements previously discussed noting the concerns raised by the neighborhood regarding the condition of the site and the project's construction schedule. Mr. Tate explained that the rising construction costs, particularly for steel and concrete, had affected project feasibility and that the owner had been contacted earlier but that the effect of recent interest rate increases on the project's schedule remained uncertain. PUBLIC COMMENTS: None. APPLICANT RESPONSE: Mr. Tate thanked the committee and members of the public and stated there were no additional comments. MOTION Committee Member Brent Kleinman made a motion to recommend approval of Z-129- 26-4 per the staff recommendation. Committee Member G.G. George seconded the motion. VOTE 9-0; motion to recommend approval of Z-129-26-4 per the staff recommendation passes with Committee Members George, Gilmore, Jameison, Kleinman, Mahrle, Procaccini, Tedhams, Warnicke, and Picos in favor. STAFF COMMENTS REGARDING VPC RECOMMENDATIONS: None. City of Phoenix • Planning & Development Department 200 West Washington Street, 3rd Floor • Phoenix, Arizona 85003-1611 • (602) 262-6882