Extracted text (via pymupdf_layout)
78950 characters
Downtown El Mirage Revitalization Plan Detailed Implementation Strategy Introduction PURPOSE This implementation strategy translates the broad recommendations from the El Mirage Downtown Revitalization Plan into a structured action plan for the city and partner organizations. It is intended to: • sequence the work into manageable phases, • assign likely lead/support roles, • identify planning-level cost considerations, • align projects with likely funding sources, • focus early efforts where visible success can build momentum for later private investment. This detailed directive is grounded in the original plan’s stated vision for Downtown El Mirage as the city’s centerpiece and a community gathering place with a mix of housing, retail, services, public spaces, and recreation amenities. Implementation Strategy Framework IMPLEMENTATION PRINCIPLES This section outlines the core concepts from the foundational Revitalization Plan that were used to shape this more detailed implementation strategy. These principles help frame how the City and its partners should prioritize work, allocate resources, and evaluate opportunities while staying aligned with the revitalization direction established in the overarching plan. 1. Start with visible wins. When trying to attract 3. Balance public actions with market visitation to the downtown area and enhance support. Achieving implementation success private investment, emphasis on perception, will require coordinated efforts amongst city safety, cleanliness, and high-visibility public action, existing business support, and future improvements should be foundational. private reinvestment. 2. Concentrate investment 4. Use Downtown’s existing assets to attract geographically. Avoid trying to work foot traffic. Rather than starting from scratch, everywhere at once and group improvements Bill Gentry Park, existing civic facilities, and to create visible synergies. local community service efforts are assets that should be leveraged. EL MIRAGE DOWNTOWN REVITALIZATION PLAN DETAILED IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY | 2 RECOMMENDED GOVERNANCE STRUCTURE This section describes the organizational framework needed to carry out revitalization efforts effectively. Because implementation will require ongoing coordination across departments and external partners, a clear governance structure is essential to maintain accountability, continuity, and momentum. Downtown Implementation Team Core departments: • City Manager’s Office • Community Services • Development Services / Planning / Code Compliance • Economic Development • Public Works • Parks & Recreation • Police / Public Safety • Communications / Public Information External partners: • commercial property owners • downtown businesses • neighborhood representatives • arts/culture partners • school/community institutions • regional partners (e.g., MAG/ADOT where relevant) Recommended management tools • Create an interdepartmental implementation team. • Appoint a dedicated project manager. • Prepare an annual Downtown work program, this may include: o a quarterly implementation dashboard, o a grant pipeline tracker, o a parcel opportunity tracker, o a business contact database, o an annual update to Council. SUGGESTED IMPLEMENTATION GEOGRAPHY This subsection identifies the priority areas where early action is most likely to generate visible impact and support broader redevelopment goals. By concentrating effort in key nodes and corridors, the City can create stronger synergies and avoid spreading resources too thinly across the entire study area. To avoid dilution of effort, the City should organize work into three priority geographies: • Priority Area A: Civic Heart / Gathering Place o Bill Gentry Park/ Senior Center o El Mirage Road / Thunderbird Road intersection • Priority Area B: Thunderbird Corridor Infill o Vacant and underutilized parcels along Thunderbird Road o Existing plazas and small commercial nodes • Priority Area C: Grand Avenue Gateway o Grand Avenue / Thunderbird gateway area o Adjacent commercial frontage TIME HORIZONS This section presents the recommended implementation schedule by broad time period. It is intended to help organize work into realistic phases so that immediate actions, mid-term initiatives, and long-range capital projects can be sequenced in a manageable and strategic way. To move from foundational efforts to long-term catalytic redevelopment initiatives, the implementation program should be structured into three phases: Phase 1: Foundation Building (0-2 Years) Phase 3: Long-Term Redevelopment (5-10 Focus on organization, branding, Years) maintenance, business support, and low-cost Focus on transformative projects, visible improvements. redevelopment of strategic sites, parking improvements, and major private investment. Phase 2: Catalytic Investment (2-5 Years) Focus on public realm enhancements, Ongoing: Baseline Focus (Annual) redevelopment incentives, placemaking, and Maintenance, code compliance, business business recruitment. outreach, public events, program monitoring. EL MIRAGE DOWNTOWN REVITALIZATION PLAN DETAILED IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY | 4 COST METHODOLOGY These are planning-level rough-order-of-magnitude (ROM) ranges for strategy development only. They are not budget authorizations and should be refined through scoping, design, and procurement. Cost ROM Range Typical Use Band Low Under $30,000 Outreach, branding studies, bulletins, workshops, technical assistance Moderate $30,000-$100,000 Small pilots, events, consultant studies, business support programs Gateway signs, façade grant seed funding, small public realm High $100,000-$500,000 improvements $500,000- Major Parking lots, corridor improvements, streetscape, major site work $2,000,000+ Important cost note: land acquisition, utility relocation, major drainage work, and full roadway reconstruction can materially increase costs. Further, floodplain/drainage considerations and Luke AFB noise constraints may affect project feasibility and cost. Detailed Action Plan by Strategy This section forms the core of the implementation strategy by translating the El Mirage Downtown Revitalization Plan’s major concepts into actionable work programs. Each strategy includes an objective, recommended lead parties, timing, cost considerations, and specific actions intended to guide implementation over the next several years. Strategy 1: Clean, Safe, and Attractive Downtown OBJECTIVE Create confidence among residents, businesses, and investors through highly visible improvements and proactive maintenance. The project survey identified cleanliness, safety, aesthetics, and property maintenance as top concerns. Potential ROM Ref Action Lead / Support Timeline Funding / Cost Delivery Establish quarterly Code 0-3 City operating 1.1 Downtown clean/safe Low budget Compliance / months; assessment walks EL MIRAGE DOWNTOWN REVITALIZATION PLAN DETAILED IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY | 5 Potential ROM Ref Action Lead / Support Timeline Funding / Cost Delivery with checklist and Public Works / then issue tracking Police quarterly Utilize the City’s “Community Uplift” CDBG, City Public Works / relaunch and “Day of budget, sponsor Parks & 6-12 Service” program to Low- support, 1.2 Recreation / months; host a “Spruce Up Moderate APS/AARP style volunteers / recurring Downtown” community businesses cleanup/beautification grants event Create a “Downtown Pulse” bulletin for Communications businesses, owners, 0-6 / Economic City operating 1.3 and residents that months; Low Development / budget highlights clean and quarterly Police safe information updates Continue owner- Development Maricopa Co- occupied housing Services / Home Repair repair/property Housing 6-18 1.4 High Program; CDBG, improvement partners/ months HOME, CAP- assistance in adjacent Community style resources neighborhoods Services 6-18 Create a small Economic months for façade/storefront Local support, Development / design; 18- 1.5 improvement program High private owner Development 36 months for visible commercial match services implement properties ation Prioritize visible amenity/public City CIP, Public Works / infrastructure fixes in APS/AARP style Parks & 6-24 High- 1.6 Priority Area A (Bill community Recreation/ months Major Gentry park upgrades, grants, sponsor Planning landscape partnerships improvements) EL MIRAGE DOWNTOWN REVITALIZATION PLAN DETAILED IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY | 6 Potential ROM Ref Action Lead / Support Timeline Funding / Cost Delivery Shift to proactive code 0-3 Moderate Code City operating 1.7 compliance focus in months; annual Compliance budget priority areas ongoing operating Strategy 2: Define Identity, Brand, and Cultural Presence Objective Create a distinct Downtown El Mirage identity tied to local history, culture, and community pride, then express it consistently through branding, signage, art, and programming. Potential ROM Ref Action Lead / Support Timeline Funding / Cost Delivery Develop unified Downtown El Mirage / Communications City budget; Thunderbird corridor 0-12 2.1 / Economic Moderate Arizona arts- brand package (logo, months Development related support narrative, messaging, style guide) Design City CIP, 6-12 APS/AARP Prepare and install Development months; style 2.2 Downtown gateway Services / Public High install community signage at key entries Works 12-24 grants, months sponsorships Development AZ Launch public Services / Arts 6-18 Commission art/mural/utility box/bus partners / months Moderate- on the Arts, 2.3 shelter activation schools/ Public pilot; High Arizona program reflecting local Works/ Parks & ongoing Humanities, culture and history Recreation APS grants Economic Create a citizen-led arts 0-6 City operating 2.4 Development / Low or culture working group months budget Communications EL MIRAGE DOWNTOWN REVITALIZATION PLAN DETAILED IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY | 7 Potential ROM Ref Action Lead / Support Timeline Funding / Cost Delivery Parks & Build annual cultural Recreation/ programming calendar 6-18 sponsors, arts Communications Moderate 2.5 tied to Downtown months; grants, City / business group/ - High businesses and public recurring event budget Art Partners spaces (WVAC & WHAM) Integrate brand requirements into City Communications 6-12 marketing, event City operating 2.6 / Economic months; Low materials, and budget Development ongoing development/recruitment packets Pursue implementation partnerships with Local partner MOUs / First Arizona, LISC, CPLC, Economic 6-18 2.7 Low program arts groups, and regional Development months referrals business support entities named in the report Strategy 3: Build Healthy Neighborhoods and Stronger Connections Objective Improve social cohesion, neighborhood identity, non-vehicular connectivity between neighborhoods and downtown destinations while reinforcing Downtown as a community meeting place. Better walkability ranked among the highest community priorities. Potential ROM Ref Action Lead / Support Timeline Funding / Cost Delivery Identify and convene Planning / Parks 6-12 City operating 3.1 resident leaders in study & Recreation / Low months budget area neighborhoods Communications EL MIRAGE DOWNTOWN REVITALIZATION PLAN DETAILED IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY | 8 Potential ROM Ref Action Lead / Support Timeline Funding / Cost Delivery Support resident-led micro-projects (block parties, cleanup days, 6-18 Development Moderate AARP/APS- 3.2 small beautification, months; services annual style grants; shade/seating, planters, recurring “Community Uplift” events) Implement neighborhood Development 6-24 stabilization and housing services/ City operating 3.3 months; Moderate rehabilitation program Community budget ongoing efforts Services Prepare conceptual plan for walkable, north/south multimodal connector corridors to Thunderbird Public Works / City budget; 6-18 3.4 Road and larger city Planning/ Parks & Moderate transportation/ months planned trail system, Recreation CIP sources including candidate corridors like 119th Ave / El Frio St. Implement first segment pedestrian/bike/ Public Works/ CIP, grants, accessibility 18-36 High- 3.5 Parks & phased improvements in a months Major Recreation construction priority connector corridor Strategy 4: Strengthen Business Recruitment, Retention, and Expansion Objective Grow Downtown’s business base by supporting existing operators, improving recruitment readiness, and directing businesses to the right sites. EL MIRAGE DOWNTOWN REVITALIZATION PLAN DETAILED IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY | 9 Potential Ref Action Lead / Support Timeline ROM Cost Funding / Delivery Build and maintain accurate Economic 0-6 months; City operating 4.1 database of Low Development ongoing budget Downtown business and property owners Conduct systematic Start in 3 Low- business Economic months; City operating 4.2 Moderate retention visits Development quarterly/ budget annual and issue ongoing tracking Create recruitment packet with Economic market data, 4.3 Development / 0-6 months Moderate City budget amenities, Communications demographics, and Downtown vision Establish target business list aligned with survey responses: Economic 0-6 months; City operating 4.4 Low dining, coffee, Development annual refresh budget neighborhood- serving retail, recreation/culture uses Host biannual broker/property owner Economic 6-12 months; City operating 4.5 Low roundtables on Development biannual budget vacancies, leasing barriers, EL MIRAGE DOWNTOWN REVITALIZATION PLAN DETAILED IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY | 10 Potential Ref Action Lead / Support Timeline ROM Cost Funding / Delivery and site opportunities Improve City web presence for Communications Downtown 4.6 / Economic 6-12 months Moderate City budget business Development attraction and site marketing Market smaller contiguous parcels together Economic private broker to improve Development / Low- 4.7 6-24 months network; City development Planning / Moderate facilitation potential, brokers especially along Thunderbird Rd Pilot pop-up sponsorships, retail/vendor local kiosk/shared- Economic entrepreneurship 4.8 space activation Development / 12-24 months Moderate programs, Local in vacant property owners First AZ storefronts or resources underused sites Form a Downtown Economic City operating 4.9 business group or Development / 24-36 months Low budget merchant businesses association Launch Downtown News Communications Flash e- 6-12 months; City operating 4.10 / Economic Low newsletter for ongoing budget Development owners and businesses Formalize ribbon Communications Start within 6 City operating 4.11 cuttings, press / Economic months; Low budget releases, and Development ongoing EL MIRAGE DOWNTOWN REVITALIZATION PLAN DETAILED IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY | 11 Potential Ref Action Lead / Support Timeline ROM Cost Funding / Delivery recognition program for reinvestment Develop shared parking / on- Planning / Public City budget for street parking Works / study; later 4.12 strategy for 12-24 months Moderate Economic CIP/private cost smaller parcels Development share along Thunderbird Road Evaluate public parking opportunities 18-36 months Moderate for west of El Mirage study; 36-60 CIP, possible Planning / Public study; Major 4.13 Rd near Bill months development Works for Gentry Park and implementation agreements construction east of El Mirage if justified Rd near transit stops Strategy 5: Encourage Bold, Distinctive, and Flexible Placemaking Objective Create a Downtown experience that is memorable and unique by allowing flexible programming, tactical urbanism, arts/business collaboration, and signature public-space development. Potential Funding Ref Action Lead / Support Timeline ROM Cost / Delivery Adopt a flexible activation policy/ Planning / 5.1 process for Economic 0-6 months Low City operating temporary uses Development budget such as food trucks, pop-ups, EL MIRAGE DOWNTOWN REVITALIZATION PLAN DETAILED IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY | 12 Potential Funding Ref Action Lead / Support Timeline ROM Cost / Delivery art markets, and small events Identify 2-3 tactical urbanism Planning / Public 5.2 pilot sites in Works / Parks & 6-12 months Low City budget Priority Areas A Recreation and B Implement first tactical pilot: Parks & food truck court, Recreation / sponsorships, 5.3 temporary 12-24 months Moderate Economic grants, vendor fees seating/plaza, or Development weekend market concept Parks & Recreation/ Create “Art in El Communications Mirage” / business group/ 12-24 months; Moderate arts/humanities 5.4 event/program Economic recurring annual grants, sponsors linking artists and Development/ businesses Art partners (WHAM & WVAC) Prepare concept plan for a signature Planning / Parks gathering space Moderate - City budget; 5.5 & Recreation/ 12-24 months near Bill Gentry High philanthropy/grants Public Works Park / Thunderbird / El Mirage Rd node EL MIRAGE DOWNTOWN REVITALIZATION PLAN DETAILED IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY | 13 APPENDIX A: Neighborhood Stabilization Guide EL MIRAGE DOWNTOWN REVITALIZATION PLAN DETAILED IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY | 14 EL MIRAGE DOWNTOWN REVITALIZATION PLAN NEIGHBORHOOD STABALIZATION GUIDE | 1 Neighborhood Stabilization Guide Introduction The following recommendations are intended to strengthen and stabilize residential neighborhoods across the City of El Mirage. The principal aim of the recommendations is to make neighborhood revitalization efforts more visible, accessible, and responsive to residents and their needs. The recommendations identify a menu of action items organized under three categories that include phased improvements to the City’s Code Compliance webpage, operational updates for code compliance services, and considering established programs of partnership for increased community code involvement. Overall, Code Compliance’s objectives and goals are to encourage home and business owners through education, literature, enforcement, and assistance to gain voluntary compliance and always keep their properties clean and free. EL MIRAGE DOWNTOWN REVITALIZATION PLAN NEIGHBORHOOD STABALIZATION GUIDE | 2 CATEGORY 1 Code Compliance Webpage Modernization The El Mirage Code Compliance webpage is heavy on text and CATEGORY 1 RECOMMENDATION information. The webpage directs viewers to make complaints via a direct email, phone call, or in-person at El Mirage City FUNDING MECHANISM Hall. Only the email option has a link for online users. • Utilize existing IT and Development Other municipalities in the Phoenix area have code Services budgets for implementation of compliance webpages that are interactive and service- First Level Investments for Code oriented in design. These modern types of code compliance Compliance webpage modernization webpages provide residents with appealing graphical updates. layout/hierarchy, educational content for different violations • Use the City’s SmartGov platform as the (with visuals), and online submittal complaint platforms with operational back end of online reporting supporting tracking tools. tool for residents to avoid duplicate The following are levels of investments for updates to the Code licensing, hosting, data migration, Compliance webpage for improved resident use and visibility cybersecurity review, and staff training of the role of compliance. costs. Levels of Investment First Level • Code Compliance webpage reorganization that includes o a digital environment that supports both desktop and mobile devices o interactive features (i.e., “Report a Violation” button) o content organized by violation categories o violation example photos o text lists redesigned into card-based layout graphics o more prominent FAQs, and downloadable informational handouts. Second Level • Code Compliance webpage updates that include the implementations of o Online violation reporting and service requests functions o Photo uploads for reporting of compliance violations o Case-status tracking tool. Third Level • Code Compliance webpage updates that include o Communication of successes frequently by creating online dashboards to report performance metrics o Addition GIS mapping tool for tracking ongoing compliance cases. EL MIRAGE DOWNTOWN REVITALIZATION PLAN NEIGHBORHOOD STABALIZATION GUIDE | 3 Category 2 • Code Compliance Operations Update Code Compliance will always continue to provide effective CATEGORY 2 RECOMMENDATION enforcement of city code violations whether by complaint or FUNDING MECHANISM proactively, with the goal to obtain compliance and preserve communities within the city. • Leverage recent technological advances to develop cost-saving The following are levels of investments for updates to the Code efficiencies of current code Compliance operations for improved resident use and visibility of the compliance operations and role of compliance. processes, including automated and Levels of Investment digital notices. First Level • Use cost-savings to provide code compliance more focused on the • Code Compliance conducts daily routine inspections encouragement of community for code violations. compliance and engagement. • The city is broken up in 3 areas, and each area has an • Explore Community Development assigned Code Officer, who patrols their areas daily to Block Grant (CDBG) programs for investigate complaints and concerns with the eligible neighborhoods, if communities. applicable. Second Level • Attend community meetings and events to spread awareness. • Emphasize education and voluntary compliance first. • Promote success stories and before-and-after neighborhood improvements. • Collaborate with residents, HOAs, and businesses. EL MIRAGE DOWNTOWN REVITALIZATION PLAN NEIGHBORHOOD STABALIZATION GUIDE | 4 Category 3 Consider External Partnership Program for Compliance Assistance The City of El Mirage can setup a formal partnership similar to the Community Abatement & Revitalization Effort (C.A.R.E.) Program in the nearby City of Glendale. The C.A.R.E. Program is an initiative designed CATEGORY 3 to provide assistance to residents who may be physically and/or RECOMMENDATION FUNDING financially unable to correct minor property violations on their own. The MECHANISM local code compliance staff recognized that some residents, including seniors, veterans, single parents, and physically challenged • Explore intergovernmental individuals, do not have the resources or physical ability to complete agreement with Maricopa necessary property maintenance. County Adult Probation or similar group. Recognizing the need and using existing municipal resources, Glendale Code Compliance staff partnered with Maricopa County Adult • Repurpose recovered nuisance- Probation to provide supervised community service labor that directly abatement funds to replenish benefits Glendale neighborhoods. Through this partnership, municipal expenditures for probationers are able to complete required community service hours external partnership programs while assisting residents with minor property improvements and in this recommendation. cleanup efforts. Services provided through the C.A.R.E. Program • Consider the feasibility of local include: sponsorships and in-kind • Weed removal donations to implement such partnerships. • Moving small items prohibited from public view • Trimming shrubs and small trees • Spreading rock and underlayment • Painting walls The C.A.R.E Program started in 2024 and currently operates through internal funding and staff dedication without a dedicated departmental budget. EL MIRAGE DOWNTOWN REVITALIZATION PLAN NEIGHBORHOOD STABALIZATION GUIDE | 5 APPENDIX B: Façade Improvement Program EL MIRAGE DOWNTOWN REVITALIZATION PLAN DETAILED IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY | 15 El Mirage Commercial Business Facade Improvement Program Policy Framework & Implementation Guide This program is designed to address aging or outdated façades and inconsistent aesthetics that currently limit the economic and civic value of commercial business areas within El Mirage as displayed on Figure 1. To promote high-quality exterior improvements by reducing the financial burden on commercial property owners and businesses, the City seeks to encourage private investment, enhance safety and accessibility, and strengthen community pride throughout El Mirage. SECTION I: LEGAL AUTHORITY This program is adopted pursuant to: • Arizona Constitution, Article 9, Section 7 • A.R.S. § 9-240(B) – General powers of cities and towns • A.R.S. § 9-462 et seq. – Zoning and land use authority • A.R.S. § 9-500.05 – Economic development agreements • City of El Mirage Municipal Code (as applicable) • Federal requirements (if using CDBG/ARPA funds) The City Council finds that: 1. Commercial business revitalization serves a valid public purpose by minimizing blight, enhancing safety, increasing property values, strengthening the tax base, and promoting economic vitality. 2. In exchange for any public funds granted, the City will receive direct, bargained-for consideration in the form of defined, publicly visible façade improvements and the property owner’s enforceable covenant to maintain those improvements, the fair market value of which will equal or exceed the value of the assistance provided. Anticipated indirect benefits, such as increased tax revenue, higher property values, and general economic stimulus, support the City’s public-purpose determination but are not relied upon as consideration. 1 3. This program is structured to comply with the Arizona Gift Clause: the consideration the City receives — the completed façade improvements and the recorded maintenance covenant enforceable against the owner and its successors — is not grossly disproportionate to the reimbursement paid, which is limited to a matching share of documented, verified project costs. SECTION II: PROGRAM PURPOSE The Commercial Business Facade Improvement Program is established to: • Improve the visual appearance and safety of commercial corridors • Stimulate private investment • Enhance property values and sales tax generation • Reduce blight and code violations • Support small and locally owned businesses SECTION III: ELIGIBILITY REQUIREMENTS A. Eligible Applicants • Property owners or tenants of commercial buildings with an Urban Corridor (UC) zoning designation that are located within El Mirage as displayed on Figure 1. • Commercial tenants must have written property owner authorization to participate in the program. • Properties must be current on all taxes, utilities, and city fees. • Properties shall have no outstanding zoning or building code violations (or must resolve prior to reimbursement). B. Ineligible Applicants • Residential-only properties (i.e. duplex, single-family, or multi-family dwellings). • Properties with pending bankruptcy or foreclosure. • Applicants with unresolved litigation against the city. • New construction, where the structure is being increased by more than fifty percent (50%). El Mirage Commercial Business Facade Improvement Program 2 Figure 1: Façade Improvement Program Area SECTION IV: ELIGIBLE IMPROVEMENTS Only improvements to facades and streetscapes that are directly visible from a public right- of-way are eligible for funding. A. Eligible Façade Improvement Costs may include, but are not limited to: • Exterior paint and stucco repair • Façade redesign and architectural enhancements • Murals or other artwork (if they’re a permanent enhancement, visible from a public right-of-way and don’t function as a sign/commercial advertising) • Masonry repair • Doors and window replacement or repair (including security bar removal) El Mirage Commercial Business Facade Improvement Program 3 • Shade structure placement, replacement, or repair • ADA accessibility upgrades • Exterior lighting • Signage (compliant with City code) • Awnings and canopies • Landscaping and irrigation improvements • Exterior code compliance improvements that are part of a larger project which includes eligible improvements listed above. B. Ineligible Façade Improvement Costs specifically include: • Interior improvements • Inventory, equipment, or tools • Routine maintenance • Roof replacement (unless façade-related and visible) • Any “In-kind” labor (work performed by owner/tenant) • Work solely used for remediation of existing zoning or building code violations • New construction (standalone buildings) • Work began prior to grant approval SECTION V: FUNDING STRUCTURE A. Program Funding The annual Commercial Business Facade Improvement Program total funding allocation shall be determined by the City Council during the fiscal year budgeting and approval process. B. Grant Type This program is established as a reimbursement-based matching grant. Applicants selected for funding shall receive a Notice to Proceed and conditional grant award identifying the maximum reimbursement amount reserved for the approved project. Grant funds shall not El Mirage Commercial Business Facade Improvement Program 4 be disbursed until the approved work is completed, inspected, and all reimbursement requirements have been satisfied. Successful applicants must wait 2 years after a grant award before reapplying for additional grant awards. Applicants not approved during one funding cycle may reapply for future cycles, but are not automatically rolled over into the next cycle. C. Grant Award Amount • Will reimburse up to 50% of eligible project expenses • The maximum grant contribution per property from the city shall be determined annually at the time of City Council budget approval. OR The annual grant contribution shall be a maximum of $25,000 and minimum of $5,000 per property address. There is a total maximum cap of $50,000 awarded to any single property address over a 5-year period. D. Minimum Project Cost • Minimum total project cost: $10,000 E. Payment Method • Applicants shall not commence grant-funded work until receiving written authorization from the City in the form of a Notice to Proceed, or another written form of approval provided by the City. • Projects must be completed within one (1) year of the City’s official award notification unless otherwise approved. • Reimbursement shall occur only after: • Completion of approved work. • Submission of paid invoices and supporting documentation. • City inspection approval. • Verification that the completed improvements substantially conform to the approved application. • A project that alters approved plans without prior approval may be disqualified for payment. • Designs not completed as approved may be disqualified for payment. El Mirage Commercial Business Facade Improvement Program 5 SECTION VI: PROGRAM IMPLEMENTATION AND APPLICATION A. Required Documentation Application forms provided by the Development Services Department must be completed and signed with original signatures of all required parties. Electronic application submittals will also be accepted. All required supplemental application materials must be recent and valid at the time of application submission. Preliminary project estimates of the eligible costs and therefore the dollar amount of the grant requested is determined at the time of application. • All applicants must provide itemized cost estimates of labor and specific material quantities with the application. • Any application that includes estimates for labor must include a detailed quote for the services to be completed and the hours assigned. • No reimbursements for “In-Kind” labor will be awarded. The grant agreement contract must be signed by the applicant and submitted as part of the application package to be presented for review and approval. IRS Form W-9 (Request for Taxpayer Identification Number and Certification) and an active City Business License must be submitted at the same time as the Facade Improvement Program application. If applicable, the “Owner Consent Form” must also be submitted at the same time as the Facade Improvement Program application. Any required permits (i.e. building or electrical) must be reviewed and approved by the City of El Mirage prior to commencement of façade work. Applicants submit the following with their application packet: • Completed application form, including a detailed narrative. • IRS W-9 form and proof of an active City-issued business license. • Proof of property tax payment and code-compliance clearance. • Owner-tenant consent form (if tenant applies). • Recent color photographs of existing façades. El Mirage Commercial Business Facade Improvement Program 6 • Elevations, material samples, and color boards of proposed improvements • Detailed cost estimate from a licensed contractor. Any total project cost over $20,000 shall provide a minimum of two cost estimates. Any total project cost over $30,000 shall provide a minimum of three cost estimates. B. Grant Application Timeline • _______Program announcement/advertisement. • _______Applications due. • _______Panel review and applicant selection. • _______Program implementation. C. Grant Evaluation Criteria • All facade design proposals must meet applicable zoning requirements of the El Mirage Zoning Ordinance, and all applicable Building Codes; • The degree to which a project contributes to a cohesive and recognizable Downtown El Mirage identity shall be considered during scoring. Projects that incorporate preferred design elements identified by the City, including architectural detailing, desert-inspired design, public art, culturally significant themes, historically inspired features, pedestrian-oriented storefront enhancements, decorative lighting, enhanced landscaping, or district branding elements, shall receive favorable consideration during the evaluation process. • Priority consideration will be given to proposals that make visible and significant design contributions, and which contribute to the overall program’s purpose: o Improve the visual appearance and safety of commercial corridors o Stimulate private investment o Enhance property values and sales tax generation o Reduce blight and code violations o Support small and locally owned businesses • Structural design configuration, exterior finishes, and building material choices will all influence the decision-making process. Please include as many samples and support information as possible with your application. • When choosing an exterior paint scheme or color palette, light, neutral colors should be used on buildings. Deeper colors should be used for accenting. Bright colors, and unusual patterns and color schemes are discouraged. • Grant evaluation scoring shall be weighted as follows: El Mirage Commercial Business Facade Improvement Program 7 Criteria Weight Description Visual Impact & Public 30% Alignment with Downtown Revitalization Benefit Plan; before/after evaluation of submitted application material. Economic Benefit 25% Anticipated business viability enhancement. Placemaking 25% Use of unique design approach, material, or application. Feasibility & Readiness 20% Permits secured; realistic project timeline D. Project Approval and Notice to Proceed • El Mirage Development Services and Economic Development staff will be responsible for initial review of the application for completeness of all required elements. Complete applications will then be forwarded to the city identified Façade Program Committee for review and recommendation. By simple majority vote, the Committee may vote to approve the application and enter into the formal agreement process. • Approved applicants shall receive a Notice to Proceed identifying the approved scope of work and reserved grant amount. • Work initiated prior to issuance of a Notice to Proceed is ineligible for reimbursement unless previously authorized by the City. • Reimbursement shall occur upon project completion, submission of required documentation, and City inspection approval. E. Adequate Consideration Each participant must sign a Facade Improvement Agreement including: • Agreement to maintain the funded improvements for a minimum five (5) year period, in accordance with the approved scope of work and the maintenance standard specified in the Agreement. • During this period, the property owner is responsible for keeping approved improvements in their fully maintained, complete, and finished condition. If the facade is purposefully altered, changed, redesigned, reconfigured, damaged, destroyed, deteriorates, decays, or falls into obvious disrepair, the owner may be subject to the claw-back provision below. El Mirage Commercial Business Facade Improvement Program 8 • The Façade Improvement Agreement shall specify the approved scope of work, the standard and term of the maintenance obligation, and the reimbursement amount. The City shall record the executed Agreement with the Maricopa County Recorder as a development agreement under A.R.S. § 9-500.05 within ten (10) days of execution, so that its maintenance and recapture obligations run with the property and bind the owner and all successors in interest and assigns for the duration of the maintenance period. F. Claw-back Provision Property owners found in noncompliance with a grant award will be required to repay to the City (recapture) an amount equal to the following percentage of the total grant award, according to the following time frames after final reimbursement: • 0 – 24 months 100% claw-back • 25 – 36 months 75% claw-back • 37 – 48 months 50% claw-back • 49 – 60 months 25% claw-back Property owners who return their facade to a condition of compliance shall remain in the program with favorable standing and continue to be eligible for grant awards in the future. Properties, and property owners, who fail to gain or regain compliance must pay the recapture amount assessed within 14 days of notice and will no longer be eligible for future grant awards on any eligible project. Overdue recapture amounts will be placed as a lien on the property and subject to collection in the same manner as property taxes, to the extent authorized by law. G. Rejected Applications • Applicants not selected for funding shall receive written notice of the City’s determination. • Rejected applications may be revised and resubmitted during a future funding cycle. • Rejection of an application does not affect eligibility for future program participation. El Mirage Commercial Business Facade Improvement Program 9 APPENDIX C: Branding EL MIRAGE DOWNTOWN REVITALIZATION PLAN DETAILED IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY | 16 DOWNTOWN EL MIRAGE BRANDING + WAYFINDING Through analysis, engagement, and on-the-ground PROJECT FRAMING VISION observations, several key themes emerged that help + shape a downtown identity framework that is authentic, practical, and responsive to community values. Understanding Downtown El Mirage Before Designing Its Future '' -------- Downtown El Mirage has evolved organically CIVIC HEART INVESTMENT Identity development Historic townsite and CORRIDOR is not about creating over decades through neighborhood growth, community anchor Thunderbcrd R<>3d as the center'ed on Gfntry Park front&ge primary commercial and opportunity something new for agricultural roots, civic investment, and and civic institutions. for growth, its own sake. It is corridor development. about translating 9 1 tl M , 5 .....::::: ... : --=3== ,IL___ what already exists Rather than redefining downtown, this NEIGHBORIOOD REGIONAL into a coherent project seeks to clarify and strengthen FABRIC GATEWAY RMidcntial neighboffloods Grand Avenue / US 60 visual and the places, stories, and connections that that form the cultural and as the primary regional family-cente<N:1 of downtown. backbone navigational system. '' already shape community life. • WHERE WE'VE BEEN Over the past several months. the project team has been developing a coordinated branding and wayfinding foundation for Downtown El Mirage through community engagement, identity exploration, downtown analysis, and preliminary design development. The following work reflects the Work Completed to Date emerging alignment between placemaking. branding, connec·tivity, and revitalization opportunities. 0 G 8 cm, J C, G Cl - - PROJECT FRAMING > COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT > DOWNTOWN ANALYSIS > BRANDING + IDENTITY > WAYFINDING + > PRELIMINARY + VISIONING + OUTREACH + STRUCTURE DEVELOPMENT PLACEMAKING CONCEPTS DESIGN OPTIONS • Project goals • Spring Fair outreach • Corridor obsel'vations • logo concepts • Sign family dil'ection • Integrated identity systems • Downtown identity exploration • Survey engagement • Activity nodes • Color palettes • Gateway concepts • Visual direction refinement • Brand journey framework • Stakeholder convel'sations • Connectivity opportunities • Typogl'aphy systems • 0istrict continuity • Branding and wayfinding alignment • Community obsel'Vations • Gateway exploration • 0owntown ch.al'3cter themes • Pedestri.an experience ideas • Community review preparation Bui/cling a cohesive downtown identity through layered planning. engagen1ent, @ --------+ (S) ________ ...,. @ ---------► 0 -------+ ® branding, and wayfinding. LISTEN DISCOVER DEFINE DESIGN CONNECT - I:g· 11,, ,· APPENDIX D: Executive Summary of Marketing Campaign EL MIRAGE DOWNTOWN REVITALIZATION PLAN DETAILED IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY | 17 Downtown Survey City of El Mirage Marketing Campaigns The marketing campaign for the Downtown Survey generally ran from June 1 to August 31, 2026, and utilized a full complement of City communication and marketing tools. There were four separate messages/campaigns: o Take the Survey by clicking the link/scanning the QR code, and win a prize o Attend the pop-up Workshops at Family Dollar (citywide) o Invitation to attend Resident Advisory Group meetings (targeted) o Social media poll, non-statistical, on preferred amenities (Nextdoor only) Strategies and Platforms 1. Social media a. Reels (video) b. Posts (graphic/photos) c. Poll (Nextdoor only) d. Events within the platform (Facebook & Nextdoor) 2. Website (Homepage News & Announcements, Dev. Services Dept., Calendar) 3. Digital signs a. Outdoor Billboards at Gateway and Bill Gentry Park b. City Hall Lobby Screens 4. Mass Notification MyAlerts – City News and Updates 5. Print media a. Utility bill inserts b. Flyers (8.5 x 11) c. Posters 6. In-person outreach a. Spring Faire booth (April) b. Community pop-up workshop events (2) (Family Dollar) c. Resident Advisory Group meetings (Riverview School and Senior Center) City Marketing Campaigns for the Downtown Survey 1 Social Media Summary The social media campaign consisted of 84 posts on the City’s five channels, utilizing a combination of static posts and reels. Across Facebook, Instagram, Nextdoor, X, and YouTube, the Downtown Survey campaign delivered strong awareness for survey-type content, reaching 14,268 unique viewers/reach and generating 24,777 total views across platforms. The campaign successfully informed residents, stimulated conversation about community planning, and achieved broad multi-platform visibility, making it a high-performing example of municipal survey communication. On Facebook, survey posts reached 145% of our follower base (7,902 followers), demonstrating substantial visibility among non-followers and local residents. Instagram reached virtually 100% of its follower base (2,785), indicating complete saturation of the audience there. Even platforms with lower expected engagement for civic survey content—such as X (2,329 followers) and YouTube (151 subscribers)— still contributed meaningful supplemental exposure. With survey content being informational rather than entertaining, the campaign’s 122 reactions, 29 verified shares, and active public discussion (especially on Nextdoor’s 13,759-member community) reflect solid and appropriate engagement patterns. Compared with El Mirage’s population of 36,000 residents, the campaign reached an estimated 35–40% of the community, an exceptionally strong outcome for civic survey messaging. This level of visibility and engagement indicates that the outreach successfully informed residents, stimulated meaningful conversation, and ensured widespread awareness of the Downtown Survey across the city. Interpreted through the lens of survey outreach—which typically yields low reactions, low saves, modest follower growth, and limited viral spread—the metrics exceed expectations. City Marketing Campaigns for the Downtown Survey 2 Website Homepage News: Downtown Survey The Downtown Survey was promoted on several pages of the City’s website, including the homepage and Community areas, where it appeared under “News & Announcements” from June 1 to August 31, 2026. In addition, it was featured on the Development Services Downtown Revitalization page. Digital Billboards The Downtown Survey campaign was also featured on both of the City’s digital billboards near Gateway Park and Bill Gentry Park from June 12 to August 31, 2026. In addition, during that period, a promotional graphic was part of the rotation on City Hall monitor displays in the lobby and vestibule of Council Chambers. Digital Signs-Billboards Mass Notification The City sends periodic updates to utility customers, business license holders, and subscribers through its MyAlerts system (text/email/App). The Downtown Survey was highlighted three times during the June - August survey period. City Marketing Campaigns for the Downtown Survey 3 Print Print media was utilized in a variety of ways to promote the survey, utilizing QR codes and through the shortcut link www.ElMirageAZ.gov/Downtown. Due to the timing of deadlines for the quarterly newsletter, this campaign was not able to be featured in that magazine, but several other print methods were utilized. • Utility bill inserts (August) • Flyers (200) were placed at city and partner facilities and handed out in person by staff (see below). . • Posters (A-frame and easel) posters were placed at special events (2026 Spring Faire), at Customer Service, and on-site at the pop-up workshops (see below). Utility Bill Insert (August) City Marketing Campaigns for the Downtown Survey 4 Pop-up Workshops The City promoted the two in-person pop-up tables, or “workshops” conducted by Michael Baker Consulting on 6/19/2026 and 6/26/2026 from 9:30 a.m. to 11 a.m. at Family Dollar. • Posts and “Events” were created with the social media platforms Facebook & Nextdoor, inviting residents to these in-person workshops • Flyers (200) were hand-delivered to downtown businesses by staff members of Economic Development and Intergovernmental & Public Relations (IPR) on 6/19/2026. Copies were also provided to the consulting firm for further distribution. • The consulting firm provided survey materials, staff, and posterboards for the “pop-up workshop” event. City Marketing Campaigns for the Downtown Survey 5 Resident Advisory Group Two resident advisory group meetings were held on 7/30/2026. The City promoted the resident advisory group meetings through targeted invitations to neighborhoods identified by the Development Services Department and consultant teams. A letter was mailed via USPS to all residents in the downtown advisory group areas. In addition, the City’s mass notification system (text and email) was utilized to notify residents and subscribers in the specific neighborhoods of “Old Town” and “Arizona Brisas.” This invitation was supported by a Nextdoor event invitation. Nextdoor Poll The City conducted two polls on Nextdoor, asking, “What is the biggest improvement you would like to see in the El Mirage downtown area?” The first one ran for one week, ending July 9, 2026. The second ran for the month of August. The polls received 652 combined impressions and 19 responses. 1. Biking/walking infrastructure (37%) 2. Benches, planters, decorative lights (streetscaping) (21%) 3. Murals, sculptures, art wraps (public art) (21%) 4. Green Spaces (16%) 5. Welcome, directional signs (wayfinding) (5%) Comments included: • Better lighting on old el mirage streets • I didn’t know El Mirage had a downtown. • Me either • I am sorry. I am not trying to be dumb or mean but can you tell me where the downtown is? The map seems to indicate Grand Ave? I would be happy to complete the survey if I actually knew where it was. City Marketing Campaigns for the Downtown Survey 6 Glossary Each definition explains what the metric means on that specific platform and how to interpret it. Cross-Platform Social Media Metrics for the Downtown Survey Campaign and Definitions Facebook Metrics Facebook Impressions = 13,613 Definition: The total number of times your Facebook content (post, photo, video, etc.) appeared on any user’s screen. Details: Each time a post or Reel loads, it counts as one impression. If the same person sees your post multiple times, each view is counted separately. Facebook Interactions = 96 Definition: The total number of actions people took on your Facebook content. Details: This includes likes, comments, shares, link clicks, video views, reactions, and any other user activity that indicates engagement. Facebook Net Follows = 8 Definition: The number of new followers minus the number of unfollows over the reporting period. Details: A positive number means your Facebook audience grew. Facebook Reactions = 79 Definition: The emotional-response buttons users click on your post. Details: Includes Like, Love, Care, Haha, Wow, Sad, and Angry, showing how people feel about your content. Facebook Saves = 3 Definition: The number of times users saved or bookmarked your post to return to later. Details: Saves signal high content value because users consider the information worth revisiting. Facebook Shares = 29 Definition: The number of times Facebook users re-shared your post to their own feed or timeline. Details: Shares extend your content to new audiences outside your existing followers. Facebook Viewers = 11,474 Definition: The number of unique people who viewed your video or visited your content. Details: Each person is counted once, no matter how many times they watched. Facebook Views = 17,463 Definition: The number of times your video or content was played. Details: If one individual watches your video three times, that counts as one viewer and three views. City Marketing Campaigns for the Downtown Survey 7 Instagram Metrics Instagram Impressions / Reach = 2,794 Definition: The number of unique Instagram accounts that saw your Reel or post. Details: Reach counts unique viewers; impressions count total load views. Reach is your best indicator of how widely your content spread. Instagram Views = 3,991 Definition: The number of times your Instagram Reels or videos were watched. Details: Each watch counts as one view, including repeat plays from the same user. Instagram Likes (Reactions) = 51 Definition: The number of users who tapped “Like” on your Instagram content. Details: A simple way users show positive acknowledgment of your post. Instagram Shares = 16 Definition: The number of times users shared your Reel or post via direct messages or to their Instagram Story. Details: Shares greatly increase your visibility because they move your content into private and semi-private spaces. Instagram Saves = 6 Definition: The number of times users stored your post in their Saved collection. Details: Saves are a strong indicator of value and user intent to revisit the information later. Instagram Follows = (varies by post) Definition: The number of new followers gained from Instagram posts. Details: Follows reflect audience growth and indicate content resonance with new users. X / Twitter Metrics X Views = 2,762 Definition: The number of times your posts were displayed on screens. Details: A “view” occurs when a post becomes visible in someone’s timeline, even if they don’t interact with it. X Likes = 3 Definition: The number of users who tapped “Like” on your Tweet. Details: Likes signal positive reception but are often lower for government or survey-based content. X Replies = 1 Definition: The number of public responses written directly under your Tweet. Details: Replies reflect conversation and user willingness to engage. X Reposts = 0 Definition: The number of times users re-shared your Tweet to their own feed. Details: Reposts greatly extend reach but are uncommon for survey content. City Marketing Campaigns for the Downtown Survey 8 X Bookmarks = 1 Definition: The number of users who saved your Tweet privately. Details: Bookmarks indicate the user may revisit or share the content later. Nextdoor Metrics – Survey (does not include the poll) Nextdoor Impressions = 547 Definition: The total number of times your Nextdoor post appeared in residents’ feeds. Details: Each time your post loads for a member, it counts as an impression. Nextdoor Thanks = 0 Definition: The closest equivalent to a “Like” on Nextdoor. Details: “Thanks” acknowledges positive sentiment but is often low for survey content. Nextdoor Replies = 35 (across posts) Definition: The number of public comments posted under your survey outreach. Details: Replies reflect meaningful conversation and resident interest, often more valuable than reactions. Nextdoor Attachments / Link Clicks Definition: The number of attachments (photos, maps, videos) included in posts and any link interactions. Details: These items help clarify content and increase engagement with informational posts like surveys. Nextdoor Audience Size = 13,759 members Definition: Total users who can potentially see your posts. Details: Not every member receives the same post because visibility depends on neighborhood scope and algorithm behavior. YouTube Metrics YouTube Views = 14 Definition: The number of times your video was watched on YouTube. Details: Views include repeat plays and are counted after a few seconds of active watch time. YouTube Watch Time (Seconds Viewed) Definition: How long viewers spent watching your video. Details: Higher watch time indicates deeper engagement with informational content. YouTube Subscribers = 151 Definition: The number of people following your YouTube channel. Details: A subscriber is more likely to see future videos and receive notifications. YouTube Likes / Comments (if any) Definition: Standard engagement indicators similar to other platforms. Details: These reflect viewer sentiment and interaction with your video content. City Marketing Campaigns for the Downtown Survey 9 APPENDIX E: Survey Results EL MIRAGE DOWNTOWN REVITALIZATION PLAN DETAILED IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY | 18 November 2026 El Mirage Downtown Revitalization Community Input Survey Analysis Executive Summary T h e E l M i ra g e D ow n t ow n One of the most consistent findings Revitalization Community survey was a widespread lack of awareness received 208 responses collected of a defined downtown district, between March 20th and August with many long-term residents 31st, representing residents from unaware the city had a downtown across multiple neighborhoods at all. Among those who recognize and offering a broad cross-section it, the area was most commonly of community perspectives. This referred to as “Old El Mirage” or “Old survey captured feedback across Town El Mirage,” with Bill Gentry several key topic areas, including Park, the library, fire station, and existing conditions, community former city hall serving as primary identity, desired improvements, and anchors, underscoring the need for long-term vision for the area. stronger district identity, improved wayfinding, and a more cohesive The survey results reflect a visual presence. community that is proud of El Mirage’s history and strong sense Residents described the downtown’s of community but feels like its character as “hardworking,” downtown lacks a clear identity. “evolving,” and “friendly,” balanced Residents generally view the area against candid acknowledgments as the civic and historic heart of of unrealized potential. Demand was the city, centered around parks, strong for more local businesses, public facilities, local businesses, restaurants, improved streetscaping, and community events. Common shade, lighting, public art, and priorities for the future include community gathering spaces. beautification, redevelopment, Most meaningfully, respondents additional restaurants and local expressed a clear desire for businesses, improved walkability, revitalization that honors El Mirage’s and stronger branding to create Hispanic heritage, working-class a more vibrant and recognizable roots, and historic character, destination. supporting existing residents and businesses rather than displacing them. Survey Analysis: The following summary outlines the most prominent themes and findings per question, identified across 208 responses throughout the survey period. 2 1. When you talk about the “Downtown El Mirage area”, what name do you usually use to refer to it? Responses to this question offer a glimpse into how residents relate to and understand the downtown area. The most frequently used terms were “Old El Mirage,” and “Old Town El Mirage,” reflecting a connection between the community and the area’s historic roots. General references such as “Downtown El Mirage,” and simply “Downtown” were also widely used, suggesting Key Themes Identified: that while residents do recognize the area, there is not yet • “Old El Mirage” and “Old Town a universally shared name or identity for the district. El Mirage” as the most common identifiers Another finding from this question was the number of residents who expressed surprise at the existence of a • Widespread lack of awareness of a defined downtown area. Several respondents noted they defined downtown district had lived in El Mirage for many years without recognizing a • Landmark and location-based distinct downtown district, which speaks to an opportunity orientation in lieu of a distinct for greater awareness and visibility. In the absence of a identity strong district identity, many residents naturally gravitated toward familiar landmarks and locations to describe the • A range of perceptions reflecting area, including Gentry Park, the library, former city hall, the both frustrations and community fire station, and Grand Avenue. pride • Inconsistent terminology reflecting Responses also captured a range of perceptions about an opportunity to establish a clearer the area’s current character. A notable portion of residents identity shared candid and at times critical feedback reflecting frustrations with its present conditions. At the same time, several residents spoke warmly of the district, highlighting the meaningful connection some community members feel toward the area. 3 2. Please describe the boundaries of this area in your own words. (You may also use the following map to reference specific street names as needed.) While no single boundary definition emerged as universal, several consistent reference points appeared across a meaningful share of responses. The most commonly referenced boundaries centered around El Mirage Road and Thunderbird Road as the Key Themes Identified: core of the downtown area, with Grand Avenue (US 60) • El Mirage Road and Thunderbird frequently cited as the northern edge. Many respondents Road as the most commonly also referenced the Agua Fria River as an eastern boundary, identified core Cactus Road as a southern limit, and 127th Avenue as a western edge. This general framework emerged as the • Grand Avenue, Cactus Road, the most shared understanding of the district’s extents, though Agua Fria River, and 127th Avenue definitions varied considerably across responses. As was as the most frequently referenced the case with the previous question, civic landmarks and outer boundaries community facilities, including Bill Gentry Park, the library, • Civic landmarks and community former city hall, the fire station, and El Mirage Elementary facilities as primary spatial anchors School, played a significant role in how residents described and oriented area. • Inconsistent boundary definitions reflecting a lack of clearly defined A number of responses reflected uncertainty or unfamiliarity district edges with the area’s boundaries, with some residents describing • Continued uncertainty and the downtown area in broad or informal terms, referencing unfamiliarity with the downtown nearby destinations such as Walmart, Food City, or the area among a portion of residents post office rather than specific streets. Perceptions of the area’s character were also woven into many descriptions, • A mix of community pride and ranging from warm reflections on the district’s small-town candid concerns about current feel and community facilities, to candid assessments conditions noting concerns about infrastructure, upkeep, and safety. 4 3. If Downtown El Mirage was a person, how would you describe their personality? (For example: friendly, hardworking, evolving, proud, quiet, energetic, etc…) Responses to this question offer an insight into how residents perceive the character of Downtown El Mirage. While a wide variety of descriptors were shared, several personality traits emerged with notable frequency. “Hardworking” and “evolving” were by far the most Key Themes Identified: commonly used descriptors, appearing across a significant • “Hardworking” and “evolving” as the share of responses. Together, these traits suggest that most frequently used descriptors residents recognize both the working-class roots of the community and a sense of forward momentum. “Friendly,” • “Friendly,” “quiet,” and “proud” “quiet,” and “proud” were also frequently cited, reflecting reflecting a modest but community- a district that feels modest and unassuming, but with a connected identity genuine sense of community identity and belonging. • A notable thread of critical perceptions reflecting feelings of A portion of responses leaned toward more critical neglect and unrealized potential characterizations. These descriptors reflect a candid recognition that the area’s potential has not yet been fully • Optimism and hope for the area’s realized. Balanced against this, however, were a number future of more hopeful descriptors, suggesting an undercurrent of optimism about the district’s future. Several responses • Strong cultural identity tied to Hispanic heritage, working-class also reflected the area’s strong cultural identity, with roots, and close-knit community references to its Hispanic heritage, immigrant roots, blue- character collar character, and close-knit neighborhoods. 5 4. What do you think Downtown El Mirage is “best at” or “does especially well” right now? Responses to this question revealed a mix of appreciation for certain aspects of the downtown area alongside acknowledgement of its limitations. While a notable share of respondents indicated they couldn’t identify a particular strength, several consistent themes emerged among those who did. Key Themes Identified: Community events and gatherings stood out as the most • Community events and seasonal frequently cited strength, with many residents pointing to festivals as the most widely seasonal celebrations, holiday festivals, food trucks, and recognized strength park events, particularly at Bill Gentry Park, as meaningful opportunities for the community to come together. The • Civic and community facilities as concentration of civic and community facilities was also a valued and accessible resource widely recognized, with the library, fire station, former cluster city hall, the senior center, and nearby parks frequently • Small-town character and Hispanic noted as valuable assets that make the area a practical cultural identity as appreciated and accessible hub for everyday needs. For residents qualities living nearby, the walkability of these resources was an added benefit. • Local small businesses recognized as emerging assets The district’s small-town character and cultural identity, • A significant portion of residents particularly its Hispanic heritage, local small businesses, unable to identify a current strength, and close-knit neighborhood feel, were also cited as reflecting an opportunity for growth qualities worth preserving. At the same time, a meaningful portion of respondents struggled to identify a specific strength, with some stating outright that the area does nothing especially well at this time, reinforcing the broader opportunity for the district to establish a clearer and more compelling identity. 6 5. If you had a magic wand and could change one thing about Downtown El Mirage, what would it be? The most common desire expressed was for more local businesses, residents, and dining options. Residents repeatedly cited the need for sit-down restaurants, coffee shops, boutiques, and locally- owned establishments, with many referencing successful examples in neighboring communities, such as downtown Tolleson, old town Glendale, and downtown Peoria, as Key Themes Identified: inspiration for the type of walkable environment they hope • More local businesses, restaurants, to see in El Mirage. and dining options as the most frequently expressed desire Visual improvements and streetscape enhancements were equally prominent, with residents calling for • Visual and streetscape better landscaping, shade trees, public art, murals, improvements including updated building facades, improved lighting, and cleaner landscaping, shade, lighting, murals, storefronts. The condition of buildings along Thunderbird and updated facades Road was specifically noted by multiple respondents • A stronger and more defined sense as an area needing attention. A stronger sense of place of place and district identity and identity, including gateway signage, wayfinding, and design consistency, was also a frequently expressed • Addressing homelessness and desire. Addressing homelessness, improving safety, improving perceptions of safety and enhancing cleanliness along both commercial and • Improved cleanliness and property residential corridors were additional recurring priorities, upkeep along commercial and with several residents identifying these as meaningful residential corridors barriers to enjoying the downtown area. • More community gathering spaces, Several respondents also called for more community amenities, and family-friendly gathering spaces, including shaded plazas, splash pads, destinations expanded park facilities, and improved parking near event venues, alongside a revival of larger community festivals reminiscent of past celebrations. 7 6. When you think of Downtown El Mirage, what places or areas come to mind? Bill Gentry Park was by far the most frequently referenced location, reinforcing its role as the most recognizable and meaningful public space in the downtown area. The library and fire station, El Mirage Elementary School, the senior center, the post office, and former city hall were also among the most commonly cited landmarks, collectively forming the backbone of how Key Themes Identified: residents mentally map the downtown area. • Bill Gentry Park as the most widely recognized landmark On the commercial side, Walmart and Food City were frequently mentioned alongside smaller local • Civic and community facilities as establishments such as Pratt’s Pets, Family Dollar, Rally’s, the primary mental anchors for the carnicerias, and food trucks. Small businesses were noted downtown area as emerging spots, while several residents expressed • A mix of local commercial frustration with the concentration of liquor stores, smoke references ranging from valued shops, and cannabis dispensaries in the area. Vacant small businesses to less-desired lots, run-down storefronts, and aging buildings were also uses prominently referenced, reflecting the area’s current physical condition, through a number of respondents • Vacant lots and aging storefronts as spoke warmly of the area’s cultural character, including notable physical characteristics street vendors, local churches, and the community garden, • Cultural assets including food as meaningful elements of the downtown experience. trucks, carnicerias, local vendors, and churches • Continued uncertainty among some residents about what constitutes the downtown area 8 7. Are there places in Downtown El Mirage that are hard to find or confusing to navigate? If so, what are they? Responses to this question were notably mixed, with a significant portion of respondents indicating that the downtown area is generally easy to navigate given its small size and straightforward layout. However, a number of respondents did identify specific challenges, and several consistent themes emerged among those who did. Key Themes Identified: • Lack of clear signage and The most frequently cited challenge was the lack of clear wayfinding as the most commonly signage and wayfinding. Multiple respondents noted that cited navigational challenge public facilities such as the library, community center, City Hall, and parking areas are not well-marked from main • Absence of gateway markers roads, making them difficult to identify, particularly for defining the downtown district’s first-time visitors or newer residents. The absence of clear entry points gateway markers indicating where the downtown district • Traffic and intersection concerns, begins was also noted as a source of confusion. Parking particularly at Grand Avenue and access, particularly around former city hall and during Thunderbird Road events at Bill Gentry Park, was similarly mentioned, with entrances not always being obvious from the main road. • Parking access and visibility as areas of confusion Traffic and intersection issues were another recurring • Individual businesses and facilities concern, with several residents specifically highlighting the difficult to identify from main roads entry onto Grand Avenue and the left-turn configuration at Grand Avenue and Thunderbird Road as a challenge • A notable share of respondents during busy periods. A smaller number of respondents finding the area easy to navigate noted that individual businesses along the main corridors due to its small scale can be difficult to spot due to limited signage or placement • Continued unfamiliarity with the set back from the road. downtown area among some residents Notably, several respondents used this question to reiterate their unfamiliarity with the downtown area altogether, reinforcing the broader finding that the district lacks a clear and recognizable identity for a portion of the community. 9 8. How would you like to see Downtown El Mirage evolve in the future? The desire for more local businesses, restaurants, and dining options was the most common theme, echoing sentiments expressed throughout the survey. Residents repeatedly called for sit-down restaurants, coffee shops, boutiques, and locally-owned establishments that would give people a reason to spend time in the area. Many referenced neighboring Key Themes Identified: communities as inspiration, with a strong undercurrent • More local businesses, restaurants, across responses being the desire for a downtown that and dining options, as the most feels like a true destination rather than a pass-through frequently expressed vision corridor. • Improved walkability, streetscaping, Improved walkability, streetscaping, and visual appeal lighting, and visual appeal were equally prominent, with residents calling for shaded • Preservation of cultural identity sidewalks, more trees, better lighting, murals, public art, and historic character throughout updated facades, and landscaping that reflects the city’s revitalization southwestern character. Several respondents emphasized the importance of preserving the area’s cultural identity • More community events, gathering and historic character through this process, expressing a spaces, and family-friendly desire for revitalization that enhances rather than erases amenities what makes El Mirage unique. More community events, • Addressing homelessness, safety, gathering spaces, and family-friendly amenities were also and cleanliness as foundational widely requested, alongside continued calls for addressing priorities homelessness, improving safety, and cleaning up the area as foundational priorities. • A desire for Downtown El Mirage to become a true destination rather A smaller group also emphasized the importance of than a pass-through corridor supporting existing residents and small businesses • Support for existing residents and throughout the revitalization process, expressing concern small businesses throughout the that growth and investment should benefit the community growth process already there rather than displacing longtime residents. 10 9. Is there anything else you’d like the project team to understand. The most consistent message was a desire for the project team to honor the area’s history, heritage, and existing community. Many residents expressed pride in El Mirage’s roots as a working-class, migrant, and Hispanic community, emphasizing that revitalization should reflect and celebrate that identity rather than replace it. Several respondents expressed concern that Key Themes Identified: improvements could be designed for newcomers or • A strong desire to honor the area’s outside interests rather than for the families that have history, heritage, and existing called El Mirage home for generations. community identity A closely related theme was a sense that Downtown El • A longstanding sense that Mirage has long been overlooked, with multiple residents Downtown El Mirage has been noting that the area has been neglected while newer overlooked and underinvested developments and neighboring communities received • Cautious optimism that the planning investment and attention. This sentiment was paired with process represents a genuine cautious optimism with many expressing hope that the commitment to change planning process represents a commitment to change, and that visible improvements would go a long way toward • Concern that revitalization rebuilding community trust. Authenticity and affordability remain authentic, affordable, and were also recurring concerns, with residents cautioning community-centered against developments that could displace longtime • Reiteration of practical priorities residents or result in a downtown that feels disconnected including safety, lighting, from El Mirage’s true character. homelessness, and more businesses Practical priorities, including better lighting, improved safety, addressing homelessness, and attracting more • A call for continued and meaningful businesses, were reiterated throughout, reinforcing community involvement throughout themes that appeared consistently across the survey. the planning process Many respondents also stressed the importance of • Expressions of gratitude, ongoing and meaningful community involvement in the community pride, and hope for the planning process. area’s future 11 10. How do you primarily interact with El Mirage? Responses to this question confirm that the survey reached a predominately resident audience, with the vast majority of respondents identifying as people who live in El Mirage. Beyond residents, the next most commonly represented groups were regular visitors and business owners, followed by a smaller number of respondents who identified working in El Mirage or Key Themes Identified: representing a community organization or institution. A small number selected “Other,” suggesting interactions • Residents as the overwhelming with the city that may not fit neatly into the provided majority of survey respondents categories. • Regular visitors and business The strong resident representation across the response owners are the next most set reinforces the relevance and authenticity of the represented groups community input gathered, and suggests that the findings of this survey are based in the lived experiences of those • Workers and community who interact with Downtown El Mirage on a regular basis. organization representatives 2.4% 1.9% contributing additional perspectives 3.8/% 5.8% 7.2% Live Visit regularly Own a business Work Other Represent a community organization 78.8% 12 11. What neighborhood/subdivision do you live in? Responses to this question reflect a broad geographic distribution of survey participants across El Mirage, with representation from a wide range of neighborhoods and subdivisions throughout the city. Sundial, encompassing several units including Sundial 1, 2, 3, and 4, was the most frequently referenced neighborhood, Key Themes Identified: appearing across a significant share of responses. • Sundial as the most frequently Rancho El Mirage was the second most commonly cited represented neighborhood subdivision, followed by Parque Verde, Arizona Brisas, Buenavida, Cactus Park, and Thompson Ranch, each • Rancho El Mirage, Parque Verde, appearing multiple times. A number of respondents Arizona Brisas, Buenavida, and identified themselves as living in or near the historic core, Cactus Park as other commonly referencing areas such as Old El Mirage, Primrose, Pueblo referenced subdivisions El Mirage, and Dysart Ranchettes. Several respondents • Representation from both historic also provided street intersections or general location core neighborhoods and newer descriptions rather than subdivision names, suggesting outer subdivisions either uncertainty about their subdivision’s official name or a preference for orienting by familiar landmarks. • Some respondents identifying by street location rather than subdivision name • Broad geographic distribution suggesting community-wide engagement with the survey 13 12. Please select your age. The 25-64 age group represented the overwhelming majority of respondents, accounting for a significant share of the total response set. This broad working-age bracket encompasses a wide range of life stages and perspectives, suggesting that the survey captured input from the core of El Mirage’s resident population. Key Themes Identified: • The 25-64 age group is the The 65 and over age group represented the second most dominant respondent demographic common age group, appearing across a notable portion of responses. This level of participation from younger • Meaningful participation from the residents is an encouraging sign of engagement from 18-24 age group reflecting youth a demographic that is sometimes underrepresented engagement in community planning processes. Residents 65 and • Representation from residents over were also meaningfully represented, reflecting the 65 and over reflecting older adult presence and engagement of El Mirage’s older population. perspectives A very small number of residents identified as under 18, indicating some participation from younger community • A small but present voice from members as well. respondents under 18 81.3% • Broad age distribution supporting the overall relevance of survey findings 7.7% 10.1% 1.0% Under 18 18-24 25-64 65 and over 14