EM26-AS01 Evaluation Tabulation

City of El Mirage — Regular Meeting (2026-11-17)

View PDF Meeting page

Extracted text (via pymupdf_layout) 4565 characters
City of El Mirage
Finance
Robert Weddigen, Finance Director
10000 N El Mirage Rd, El Mirage, AZ 85335
EVALUATION TABULATION
RFP No. EM26-ASS01
Arterial Street Sweeping Services
RESPONSE DEADLINE: October 13, 2026 at 8:00 am
Report Generated: Monday, October 26, 2026
SELECTED VENDOR
VENDOR RECOMMENDED BY THE EVALUATION PROCESS
Vendor Location
C&S Sweeping Services, Inc. Phoenix, AZ
VENDOR QUESTIONNAIRE PASS/FAIL
Question Title C&S Sweeping Services, Inc. MGM Sweeping, LLC Offsite Sweeping LLC SCA of AZ, LLC
Have you read and agreed to Pass Pass Pass Pass
all of the terms and conditions
in the RFP
Subcontractor's List Pass Pass Pass Pass
Please Provide your Pass Pass Pass Pass
Certificates of Insurance.
Please Provide all Arizona Pass Pass Pass Pass
License(s)
Please provide any additional Pass Pass Pass Pass
information you would like for
the City to consider.
Proposal Pass Pass Pass

EVALUATION TABULATION
RFP No. EM26-ASS01
Arterial Street Sweeping Services
PHASE 1
EVALUATORS
Name Title Agreement Accepted On
Alec Eigenberger Program Oct 8, 2026 12:40 PM
Manager/Division Manger
II
Marcus Jonson Operations Supervisor Oct 14, 2026 3:01 PM
Richard MIranda Maintenance Supervisor Oct 13, 2026 1:14 PM
EVALUATION CRITERIA
Criteria Scoring Method Weight (Points)
Method of Approach Points Based 40 (40% of Total)
Description:
Criteria Scoring Method Weight (Points)
Similar Projects Completed Points Based 30 (30% of Total)
Description:
Criteria Scoring Method Weight (Points)
Price/Cost Points Based 30 (30% of Total)
Description:
EVALUATION TABULATION
Request For Proposal - Arterial Street Sweeping Services
Page 2

EVALUATION TABULATION
RFP No. EM26-ASS01
Arterial Street Sweeping Services
AGGREGATE SCORES SUMMARY
Vendor Alec Eigenberger Marcus Jonson Richard MIranda Total Score
(Max Score 100)
C&S Sweeping Services, Inc. 95 96 88 93
MGM Sweeping, LLC 90 92 88 90
SCA of AZ, LLC 85 89 86 86.67
Offsite Sweeping LLC 70 85 83 79.33
A&A Professional Sweeping 0 0 0 0
Excluded
VENDOR SCORES BY EVALUATION CRITERIA
Vendor Method of Approach Similar Projects Completed Price/Cost Total Score
Points Based Points Based Points Based (Max Score 100)
40 Points (40%) 30 Points (30%) 30 Points (30%)
C&S Sweeping Services, Inc. 37.7 29 26.3 93
MGM Sweeping, LLC 37.7 28 24.3 90
SCA of AZ, LLC 32.3 26.3 28 86.67
Offsite Sweeping LLC 32 27 20.3 79.33
A&A Professional Sweeping 0 0 0 0
Excluded
INDIVIDUAL PROPOSAL SCORES
C&S Sweeping Services, Inc.
Scores by Evaluator and Criteria
EVALUATION TABULATION
Request For Proposal - Arterial Street Sweeping Services
Page 3

EVALUATION TABULATION
RFP No. EM26-ASS01
Arterial Street Sweeping Services
Evaluation Item Alec Eigenberger Marcus Jonson Richard MIranda
Method of Approach (40 pts) 40 38 35
Similar Projects Completed (30 pts) 30 29 28
Price/Cost (30 pts) 25 29 25
Total Score (Max 100) 95 96 88
Comments
Similar Projects Completed (30 pts):
Alec Eigenberger: Excellent referrals from several municipalities as well as ADOT, MCDOT.
MGM Sweeping, LLC
Scores by Evaluator and Criteria
Evaluation Item Alec Eigenberger Marcus Jonson Richard MIranda
Method of Approach (40 pts) 40 35 38
Similar Projects Completed (30 pts) 30 28 26
Price/Cost (30 pts) 20 29 24
Total Score (Max 100) 90 92 88
Comments
Similar Projects Completed (30 pts):
Alec Eigenberger: Has previously provided as-needed services for the city of El Mirage.
Offsite Sweeping LLC
Scores by Evaluator and Criteria
EVALUATION TABULATION
Request For Proposal - Arterial Street Sweeping Services
Page 4

EVALUATION TABULATION
RFP No. EM26-ASS01
Arterial Street Sweeping Services
Evaluation Item Alec Eigenberger Marcus Jonson Richard MIranda
Method of Approach (40 pts) 30 33 33
Similar Projects Completed (30 pts) 30 25 26
Price/Cost (30 pts) 10 27 24
Total Score (Max 100) 70 85 83
SCA of AZ, LLC
Scores by Evaluator and Criteria
Evaluation Item Alec Eigenberger Marcus Jonson Richard MIranda
Method of Approach (40 pts) 30 34 33
Similar Projects Completed (30 pts) 25 27 27
Price/Cost (30 pts) 30 28 26
Total Score (Max 100) 85 89 86
A&A Professional Sweeping
(Excluded)
Scores by Evaluator and Criteria
Evaluation Item Alec Eigenberger Marcus Jonson Richard MIranda
Method of Approach (40 pts) 0 0 0
Similar Projects Completed (30 pts) 0 0 0
Price/Cost (30 pts) 0 0 0
Total Score (Max 100) 0 0 0
EVALUATION TABULATION
Request For Proposal - Arterial Street Sweeping Services
Page 5

EVALUATION TABULATION
RFP No. EM26-ASS01
Arterial Street Sweeping Services
EVALUATION TABULATION
Request For Proposal - Arterial Street Sweeping Services
Page 6