Scores

City of El Mirage — Regular Meeting (2026-11-17)

View PDF Meeting page

Extracted text (via pymupdf_layout) 3218 characters
Aggregate Scores Summary
Vendor Timothy Mason Randy Stewart Ian Takashige Total Score
(Max Score 100)
Coco's Roadside Service … - 95 54 74.5
E-Z Towing & Recovery LLC - 100 78 89
Prestigious Towing & Reco… - 75 62 68.5
Professional Towing & Rec… - 85 77 81
Sun City Towing Inc - 80 56 68
WESTERN TOWING - 90 82 86
Vendor Scores by Evaluation Criteria
Vendor Proximity & Method of Qualification & Experie References from Simila Conformance to the Re Total Score
Points Based Points Based Points Based Points Based (Max Score 100)
35 Points (35%) 30 Points (30%) 20 Points (20%) 15 Points (15%)
Coco's Roadside Ser… 27.5 22.5 14.5 10 74.5
Sun City Towing Inc 17.5 24.5 15.5 10.5 68
Prestigious Towing & … 21 23.5 13 11 68.5
Professional Towing … 24 27 18.5 11.5 81
WESTERN TOWING 29 27.5 18 11.5 86
E-Z Towing & Recove… 30 28 18.5 12.5 89

Individual Response Scores
 Coco's Roadside Service and Towing
Evaluation Item Timothy Mason Randy Stewart Ian Takashige
Proximity & Method of Approach - 35 20
Points Based
35 Points (35%)
Qualification & Experience - 30 15
Points Based
30 Points (30%)
References from Similar Projects - 20 9
Points Based
20 Points (20%)
Conformance to the Request for Pro - 10 10
Points Based
15 Points (15%)
Total (Max Score 100) - 95 54
 E-Z Towing & Recovery LLC
Evaluation Item Timothy Mason Randy Stewart Ian Takashige
Proximity & Method of Approach - 35 25
Points Based
35 Points (35%)
Qualification & Experience - 30 26

Points Based
30 Points (30%)
References from Similar Projects - 20 17
Points Based
20 Points (20%)
Conformance to the Request for Pro - 15 10
Points Based
15 Points (15%)
Total (Max Score 100) - 100 78
 Prestigious Towing & Recovery, LLC
Evaluation Item Timothy Mason Randy Stewart Ian Takashige
Proximity & Method of Approach - 20 22
Points Based
35 Points (35%)
Qualification & Experience - 30 17
Points Based
30 Points (30%)
References from Similar Projects - 15 11
Points Based
20 Points (20%)
Conformance to the Request for Pro - 10 12
Points Based
15 Points (15%)
Total (Max Score 100) - 75 62

 Professional Towing & Recovery, LLC
Evaluation Item Timothy Mason Randy Stewart Ian Takashige
Proximity & Method of Approach - 25 23
Points Based
35 Points (35%)
Qualification & Experience - 30 24
Points Based
30 Points (30%)
References from Similar Projects - 20 17
Points Based
20 Points (20%)
Conformance to the Request for Pro - 10 13
Points Based
15 Points (15%)
Total (Max Score 100) - 85 77
 Sun City Towing Inc
Evaluation Item Timothy Mason Randy Stewart Ian Takashige
Proximity & Method of Approach - 20 15
Points Based
35 Points (35%)
Qualification & Experience - 30 19
Points Based
30 Points (30%)
References from Similar Projects - 20 11

Points Based
20 Points (20%)
Conformance to the Request for Pro - 10 11
Points Based
15 Points (15%)
Total (Max Score 100) - 80 56
 WESTERN TOWING
Evaluation Item Timothy Mason Randy Stewart Ian Takashige
Proximity & Method of Approach - 30 28
Points Based
35 Points (35%)
Qualification & Experience - 30 25
Points Based
30 Points (30%)
References from Similar Projects - 20 16
Points Based
20 Points (20%)
Conformance to the Request for Pro - 10 13
Points Based
15 Points (15%)
Total (Max Score 100) - 90 82