Extracted text (via pymupdf_layout)
11258 characters
Police Department 12401 W. Cinnabar Ave., El Mirage 85335 623-500-3000 ; Fax 623-500-3019 TDD 623-933-3258; www.elmirageaz.gov TO: J. Crystal Dyches, City Manager FROM Michael Ashley, M.Ed., Deputy Director of Police Administration DATE October 21, 2026 SUBJECT Vehicle Towing Service RFP EM26-PDVTS01 This memorandum summarizes the key events and the basis for the El Mirage Police Department’s (EMPD) recommendation and Chief Marzocca’s response to your request. It reflects my recollection and the procurement records reviewed to date and is not a step-by-step account of every action or communication. I have taken the lead in preparing this response. EMPD is responsible for the scope of work, scope changes, evaluation, and recommendation. Finance administers the procurement procedures, and its input should help confirm the procedural record and vendor communications. 1. Procurement background and timeline: Why the procurement was initiated, the original scope of services, how the solicitation was conducted, and the key milestones. On July 13, 2026, I asked Ms. Ojeda by email when the tow contract would be up for bid. She replied on July 14 that it would expire on October 31, 2026. That date was incorrect; I confirmed with Legal that the correct expiration date was November 6, 2026. I requested Finance’s guidance so EMPD could complete the solicitation and identify the most competitive bid that met the department's needs and the statutory requirements under ARS 28-3511 et seq. The procurement was initiated to secure adequate towing coverage before the existing contract expires. RFP EM26-PDVTS01 sought emergency and nonemergency towing, removal, recovery, and storage, with one primary contractor and two alternates. It provided for a three-year term and up to two additional one-year extensions. The City established the rates and guaranteed no tow volume. Finance administered the solicitation through OpenGov. On July 16, 2026, Ms. Ojeda sent Mr. Robert Weddigen and me a copy of the previous RFP for our review and to use as the starting point for the scope of work. On July 30, 2026, I designated Lt. Chavez as EMPD’s project point of contact and assigned him to develop the scope of work for the new RFP. Lt. Chavez has nearly 40 years of law enforcement experience, including extensive experience with towing issues as a former member of the Department of Public Safety. Ms. Ojeda initially identified October 13, 2026, as the proposal deadline. I requested an earlier deadline because of the approaching contract expiration and the need to avoid service lapses. Her August 19, 2026, revised schedule moved the deadline to September 21, 2026. Lt. Chavez worked with Ms. Ojeda and submitted the scope of work. The records reviewed show an August 24, 2026, portal posting. Questions were due September 14, 2026, and proposals closed September 21, 2026. In total, six proposals were received and evaluated. Lt. Chavez and I were out of the country during part of the September review period, so I asked Lt. Takashige and Supervisor Randy Stewart to serve as evaluators. The October 6, 2026, tabulation established the final ranking. Assistant Chief Mason approved the Department’s recommendation on behalf of the Chief of Police, who was unavailable. Ms. Ojeda supplied the primary agreement and conditional intent notices for all three recommended vendors. She supplied the two alternate agreements. The award remained subject to Council approval. 2. Scope changes: What changed during the process, why those changes were necessary, and how they were communicated to participating vendors. We used the prior RFP as our starting point and held internal discussions with stakeholders to gather input on response standards, equipment, storage, reporting, insurance, and oversight. The 15-mile storage radius, evaluation weights, fixed rates, and primary/two-alternate framework were already in the supplied 2021 materials. On October 14, Lt. Chavez requested the removal of the inherited contractor's $150 administrative-fee clause on September 14, 2026, and Procurement posted the deletion that morning. The correction reflected EMPD’s collection process: the owner pays the applicable administrative charge to the City for qualifying impounds. The draft agreements later reintroduced a contractor obligation. EMPD’s October 14, 2026, redlines proposed deleting it again. Lt. Chavez also incorporated language consistent with Title 13, Chapter 3 of the Arizona Administrative Code, specifically articulating tow truck definitions and requirements, into the Scope of Work. Throughout the process, EMPD provided Ms. Ojeda with proposed responses concerning pricing, an obsolete invoice reference, insurance, and other scope questions. She was Procurement’s primary contact for vendor questions, with operational input from Lt. Chavez, Lt. Takashige, and me. Finance’s amendment and Q&A records should document what participating vendors received and when. The final agreements should state one consistent service standard and dispatch arrangement once agreed upon. 3. Evaluation process: How proposals were reviewed, the evaluation criteria, who participated, and how the Department reached its conclusions. Lt. Chavez authored the SOW; however, he did not evaluate the applicants. The evaluation committee consisted of Lt. Ian Takashige and Administrative Services Supervisor Randy Stewart. Each completed an independent evaluation using the published criteria: proximity and method of approach (35 points); qualifications and experience (30 points); references from similar projects (20 points); and conformance to the RFP and ability to provide services (15 points). The final scores were the average of their totals: E- Z 89, Western 86, Professional 81, the current contract provider 74.5, Prestigious 68.5, and Sun City 68. The current contract provider ranked fourth; the tabulation does not show a formal disqualification. Assistant Chief Mason’s approval of the recommendation for the Chief was separate from scoring. 2 4. Vendor considerations: Any relevant issues raised by participating vendors, including Jimmy, and how those matters were addressed. Vendors raised questions about pricing, the administrative fee, invoice requirements, and insurance. On September 16, 2026, Priority Towing requested a one-week extension. Because of the tight service- transition timeline, I discussed the request with Lt. Takashige and participated in the decision to decline it. Your October 21, 2026, email relayed the current contract provider’s concerns about using towing companies located outside El Mirage, including response times, towing and storage costs, and residents’ travel to retrieve vehicles. I am not aware of any adopted Council directive that requires only local towing companies to be included in this competitive procurement. During the evaluation process, EMPD recognized and gave great consideration to the current contract provider’s years of service, community contributions, and many contributions to the city and EMPD. The published evaluation criteria are listed in Section 3; community donations were not a separate scoring criterion. The RFP establishes response-time and availability requirements for light-, medium-, and heavy-duty service, requires a storage facility within a 15-mile radius of the police station, and gives preference to facilities in the closest proximity. Proximity and method of approach together account for 35 of the 100 evaluation points. The RFP also requires weekday vehicle-release staffing from 8:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m. and establishes common towing, storage, and service prices for awarded providers. These requirements address the response time, cost, and vehicle-retrieval concerns. Lt. Takashige identified deficiencies in the current contract provider’s equipment list, qualifications narrative, and reference descriptions. According to the current contract provider’s submitted proposal, there was no expressed commitment to the required response times, and their fleet did not include heavy towing capabilities. The current contract provider passed the required questionnaire. Its proposal was scored and ranked fourth. A debrief through Procurement would help explain the documented scoring and how the proposal compared under the published criteria. 3 5. Staff recommendation: Which vendor or vendors the Department intends to recommend, the rationale for that recommendation, and the anticipated next steps for Council consideration. EMPD recommends E-Z Towing & Recovery LLC as primary, Western Towing of Phoenix, Inc. as first alternate, and Professional Towing & Recovery, LLC as second alternate, subject to completion of the operational review and finalization of the agreements. The order follows the October 6, 2026, scores and the approved Department recommendation. Western’s evaluation identifies substantial equipment capacity and relevant agency experience. Professional’s evaluation identifies fleet and experience strengths and a staged-truck response plan; that plan’s staffing and sustainability still require verification. PD intends to dispatch the primary first and use the alternates in rank order only when the higher-ranked provider is unable or unavailable, under separate agreements with common rates and service requirements. The documented justification for recommending E-Z is its broader equipment capability, more detailed qualifications, and stronger police-agency references. E-Z averaged 89 points, compared with 74.5 for the current contract provider, under the published criteria. Current contract Evaluation criterion Maximum E-Z provider Proximity and method of approach 35 30 27.5 Qualifications and experience 30 28 22.5 References 20 18.5 14.5 Overall conformance and ability to perform 15 12.5 10 Total 100 89 74.5 Source: October 6, 2026, evaluation tabulation, pages 5–7. Lt. Takashige’s written comments provide the specific reasons: Equipment: E-Z listed more than 15 trucks covering light, medium, and heavy towing. The current contract provider listed two trucks, both marked medium duty, with no light- or heavy-duty equipment identified. Qualifications: E-Z provided detailed company history, personnel information, and background-check procedures. The current contract provider’s proposal provided less detail about the company, licensing history, and structured qualifications. References: E-Z listed current towing relationships with Surprise, Avondale, and Goodyear police departments. The current contract provider’s references provided limited descriptions of the towing services performed, and some lacked dates. Both evaluators scored E-Z above the current contract provider. The recommendation reflects the comparative evaluation of proposals under the published criteria. The City set common prices for all awarded providers; response times and proximity remain service requirements. EMPD will lead the preparation of the Council item, coordinating with Finance on procurement and fiscal records, and with Legal on the final agreements. November 17, 2026, is the anticipated date for Council review. No final award has been made; the recommendation and agreements remain subject to Council consideration. 4