Ordinance O26-11-06 Exhibit B

City of El Mirage — Regular Meeting (2026-11-17)

View PDF Meeting page

Extracted text (via pymupdf_layout) 15604 characters
EXHIBIT B.1
City of Flagstaff v. Mangum (1990) — Arizona Supreme Court Case
The 1990 Arizona Supreme Court decision in City of Flagstaff v. Mangum
established that, absent local law, local initiative petitions must be filed at
least four months before the next general municipal election, and that the
required signature threshold is 15% of the total votes cast for mayor in the
preceding election, not the number of eligible voters www.azleague.org
Case background
The case involved two special actions:
 City of Flagstaff & City Clerk Linda Butler (petitioners) vs. Judge Richard
K. Mangum and Citizens for Responsible Spending (respondents).
 Citizens for Responsible Spending (petitioners) vs. Judge Mangum, City
of Flagstaff, and City Clerk Butler (respondents) Justia Law.
The dispute arose over a local initiative petition seeking to place a proposed 2%
hotel, motel, campground, bar, and restaurant tax on the ballot. The trial court
found the petition timely but insufficient in valid signatures. Because normal
appeals would delay the election, the Arizona Supreme Court accepted jurisdiction
under Ariz. Const. art. 6, § 5(4) and Rule 1, Ariz. R.P.Sp.Act. Justia Law.
Issues presented
Filing deadline for local initiative petitions without controlling local law.
1. Whether untimely petitions could be valid for a later election.
2. Signature requirement: 15% of votes cast for mayor (actual votes) vs.
15% of eligible voters.
3. Proper method for calculating valid signatures under A.R.S. § 19‑121 et
seq.
Court’s holdings www.azleague.org
1. Filing deadline: In the absence of controlling local law, a local initiative
petition must be filed no later than four months before the next general
municipal election. Petitions filed after that date are void for inclusion on
any ballot.

2. Untimely petitions: Such petitions are not valid for later elections unless
refiled within the statutory deadline for that election.
3. Signature threshold: The required number of signatures is 15% of the
total votes actually cast for all candidates for mayor in the last
preceding general municipal election, not 15% of all eligible voters.
4. Calculation method: The correct procedural method for counting valid
signatures is set forth in the Arizona statutes (A.R.S. § 19‑121 et seq.).
Significance
The decision clarified statewide rules for local initiative petitions in Arizona,
resolving disputes over timing and signature calculations and is considered a key
precedent for municipal initiative law in the state www.azleague.org.
Citation: City of Flagstaff v. Mangum, 164 Ariz. 395, 793 P.2d 548 (Ariz. 1990)
Justia Law

EXHIBIT B.2
City of Flagstaff v. Mangum (Ariz. 1990)
Court: Arizona Supreme Court
Citations: 164 Ariz. 395, 793 P.2d 548
Docket Number: CV-89-0420-SA
Date Decided: July 5, 1990
164 Ariz. 395 (1990)
793 P.2d 548
CITY OF FLAGSTAFF, a municipal corporation, and Linda Butler, in her capacity as
City Clerk of the City of Flagstaff, Petitioners, v. Hon. Richard K. MANGUM, Judge of
the Superior Court of the State of Arizona, In and For the County of Coconino; and
Jacque Sullivan and K. Joseph Nackard, as taxpayers and electors on behalf of
Citizens for Responsible Spending, a campaign committee, real parties in interest,
Respondents. Jacque SULLIVAN and K. Joseph Nackard, taxpaying electors of the
City of Flagstaff, for themselves and on behalf of the Citizens for Responsible
Spending, a campaign committee, Petitioners, v. Hon. Richard K. MANGUM, Judge
of the Superior Court of the State of Arizona, In and For the County of Coconino;
City of Flagstaff, a municipal corporation and political subdivision of the State of
Arizona; and Linda Butler, City Clerk for the City of Flagstaff, acting in her official
capacity, the real parties in interest, Respondents.
No. CV-89-0420-SA.
Supreme Court of Arizona, En Banc.
May 31, 1990.
As Modified on Grant of Reconsideration July 5, 1990.
JURISDICTION
These two special actions present questions concerning the timeliness of the filing
of local initiative petitions and the method of calculating the number of valid
signatures on such petitions. The trial court found the petitions to be timely filed,
but lacking sufficient valid signatures to require placement on the ballot. Relief by
appeal is inadequate because normal appellate procedure would result in delay
beyond the scheduled election. See King v. Superior Court, 138 Ariz. 147, 149-50,
673 P.2d 787, 789-90 (1983). The questions presented involve issues of law with
statewide significance. See Summerfield v. Superior Court, 144 Ariz. 467, 469, 698
P.2d 712, 714 (1985). Therefore, we accepted jurisdiction of the special actions
pursuant to Ariz. Const. art. 6, § 5(4), and Rule 1, Ariz. R.P.Sp.Act., 17B A.R.S. We

permitted the League of Arizona Cities and Towns to file an amicus curiae brief
because the issues in this case are recurring and have been the subject of
controversy in cities and towns throughout Arizona. See Rule 7(f), Ariz.R.P.Sp.Act.,
17B A.R.S. and Rule 16, Ariz.R.Civ.App.P., 17A A.R.S.
ISSUES PRESENTED
1. In the absence of controlling local law, what is the filing deadline for local
initiative petitions?
2. If local initiative petitions are untimely filed as to the targeted election, are they
nevertheless valid for a later election?
3. In the absence of controlling local law, does the Arizona Constitution require
signatures on initiative petitions of fifteen percent of those who voted for mayor at
the last election or fifteen percent of those eligible to vote?
4. What is the proper procedural method for calculating the number of valid
signatures on initiative petitions under A.R.S. § 19-121 et seq.?
FACTS
In November 1987, the Flagstaff City Council enacted an ordinance levying a two
percent tax on the gross revenues of hotels, motels, campgrounds, bars and
restaurants. On August 7, 1989, Jacque Sullivan, on behalf of the Citizens for
Responsible Spending (Citizens), obtained an initiative petition seeking to eliminate
what has become known as the "bed, board and booze tax."
On November 21, 1989, Citizens tendered the petition to the city clerk for filing and
for presentation to the city council pursuant to A.R.S. § 19-143. The city clerk
refused to accept and file the petition, stating that the petition was not timely as an
initiative petition because it was not filed four months prior to the March 6, 1990
election, as required by Ariz. Const. art. 4, pt. 1, § 1(4). The clerk also rejected the
petition as a referendum petition because it was not filed within thirty days after
passage of the challenged ordinance as required by A.R.S. § 19-142.
Citizens then filed a special action in superior court, seeking an order compelling
the clerk to accept the petition and present it to the council, and to place the
initiative measure on the March 6, 1990 ballot. Citizens also sought a ruling that
the required fifteen percent of qualified electors be determined by applying the
percentage to the number of votes cast in the last mayoral election, rather than to
the number of persons qualified to vote.
The trial court held that the petition was timely because, in the absence of a
controlling City Charter provision, A.R.S. § 19-143(A) mandated a ninety-day filing
deadline. The trial court also held that under Ariz. Const. art. 4, pt. 1, § 1 the
required number of signatures was fifteen percent of all persons qualified to vote,
not just fifteen percent of those who voted at the last mayoral election.[1]

*398 The City filed a special action with this court seeking review of the timeliness
issue. Citizens also filed a special action in this court seeking review of the issue of
the required number of signatures. For reasons previously stated, we accepted
jurisdiction of both special actions and consolidated them.
The powers of initiative and referendum as to local matters are reserved to the
qualified electors of cities, towns and counties. Ariz. Const. art. 4, pt. 1, § 1(8).
These municipalities "may prescribe the manner of exercising said powers within
the restrictions of general laws."
The procedure with respect to municipal legislation shall be as nearly as practicable
the same as the procedure relating to initiative and referendum provided for the
state at large.
III. Definition of Qualified Electors
In light of our conclusion that the petitions were untimely filed and are now null and
void, the two remaining issues presented are moot for this particular case. On
occasion, however, we consider issues that are moot if significant questions of
public importance are presented and are likely to recur. See Fraternal Order of
Police v. Phoenix Employee Relations Bd., 133 Ariz. 126, 127, 650 P.2d 428, 429
(1982); see also Camerena v. Department of Public Welfare, 106 Ariz. 30, 31, 470
P.2d 111, 112 (1970). Local elections and the rules governing them are of
considerable public interest and justify departure from the usual mootness rule.
Further, the remaining issues concerning the definition of qualified electors and the
proper method of calculation of valid signatures recur and are the subject of
differing interpretations. The issues were thoroughly briefed and presented in an
adversarial fashion by the parties and by amicus, giving this court the benefit of the
opposing arguments and considerations. For these reasons, we exercise our
discretion to determine the merits of the two remaining issues notwithstanding the
fact that those issues are moot in this particular case.
The trial court ruled that, for local initiative purposes, "qualified electors" under
Ariz. Const. art. 4, pt. 1 means the entire number of persons eligible to vote at the
last city election, rather than those who actually voted. As noted previously, the
Arizona Constitution reserves the initiative power to "qualified electors" of cities,
towns and counties. Ariz. Const. art. 4, pt. 1, § 1(8). Fifteen percent of the
"qualified electors" within the municipality may propose local initiative measures.
Id. "Until provided by general law, said cities and towns may prescribe the basis on
which said percentages shall be computed." Id.
Based on Adams v. Bolin, 74 Ariz. 269, 247 P.2d 617 (1952), the City argues that
the constitutional requirement of fifteen percent must be applied to all electors
eligible to vote. Adams involved a legislatively proposed referendum which, if
approved by the voters, would have repealed an initiative measure. The
constitution provides that the "power of the legislature, to repeal ... shall not
extend to initiative ... measures approved by a majority vote of the qualified

electors." Ariz. Const. art. 4, pt. 1, § 1(6). In Adams, the court rejected the
argument that "approved by a majority vote of the qualified electors" meant
"approved by a majority of the qualified electors voting thereon" because "it is all
too clear that the constitution makers knew the difference" between the two. 74
Ariz. at 273-74, 247 P.2d at 620.
The City's reliance on Adams is misplaced. For purposes of this case involving local
initiatives, the constitution provides that "qualified electors" may be defined by
municipalities until defined by general law. See Ariz. Const. art. 4, pt. 1, § 1(8).
Accordingly, we first examine the general laws of the state to determine if the
legislature has defined "qualified electors" for local initiative purposes.
For local referendum purposes, A.R.S. § 19-142(A) expressly defines "qualified
*401 electors" as those voting in the preceding mayoral election. However, no
general law defines "qualified electors" for local initiative petition purposes. With
this void in the general law, we turn first to the City Charter. See generally 186-011
Op. Att'y Gen. 2 (1986) (where legislature fails to make provisions in general laws,
cities free to choose basis to compute percentage of qualified electors for initiative
petitions). However, as we have previously noted in connection with our discussion
of filing deadlines, art. 10, § 1 of the Flagstaff City Charter refers us back to the
state constitution and general state laws.
Turning back to state law, A.R.S. § 19-141(C) again provides a "gap-filler" in the
absence of controlling local law and mandates that local initiative procedures be as
consistent as possible with state initiative procedures. Therefore, we turn to the
provisions relating to statewide initiative petitions.
Ariz. Const. art. 4, pt. 1, § 1(7) provides:
The whole number of votes cast for all candidates for Governor at the general
election last preceding the filing of any initiative ... petitions on a state ... measure
shall be the basis on which the number of qualified electors required to sign such
petitions shall be computed.
Accordingly, we conclude that, in the absence of controlling local law to the
contrary, the number of qualified electors required to sign a local initiative petition
is fifteen percent of the entire vote cast for all candidates for mayor at the last
preceding general municipal election.[3]
CONCLUSION AND DISPOSITION
In the absence of controlling local provisions, local initiative petitions must be filed
not less than four months preceding the next local general election. Petitions
untimely filed pursuant to this constitutional deadline are null and void for inclusion
on any ballot. The petitions in this case were untimely filed.
In the absence of controlling local provisions, the number of votes actually cast for
mayor at the preceding election, rather than the number of voters eligible to vote,

is the basis for computing the number of signatures required for a local initiative
petition. The correct procedural method for calculating valid signatures on an
initiative petition under A.R.S. § 19-121.04 is as set forth herein.
Local law is controlling only if it is consistent with the Arizona Constitution, state
law, and Arizona Supreme Court precedent. A city cannot create a signature
threshold that unreasonably burdens initiative and referendum rights simply by
adopting an ordinance.

EXHIBIT B.3
ARS §19-143. Initiative petition in cities; action of council; amendment of charter
A. The whole number of votes cast at the city or town election at which a mayor or
councilman was chosen last preceding the submission of the application for an
initiative petition is the basis for computing the number of qualified electors of the
city or town required to sign the petition unless the city or town by charter or
ordinance provides an alternative basis for computing the number of necessary
signatures.
B. If an ordinance, charter or amendment to the charter of a city or town is
proposed by initiative petition, it shall be filed with the city or town clerk, who shall
submit it to the voters of the city or town at the next ensuing election. The council
may enact the ordinance or amendment and refer it to the people or it may enact
the ordinance or amendment without referring it to the people, and in that case it is
subject to referendum petition as other ordinances. The mayor shall not have
power to veto either of such measures.
C. Amendments to a city or town charter may be proposed and submitted to the
people by the council, with or without an initiative petition, but they shall be filed
with the clerk for submission not less than sixty days before the election at which
they are to be voted upon, and no amendment of a charter shall be effective until it
is approved by a majority of the votes cast thereon by the people of the city or
town to which it applies. The council may by ordinance order special elections to
vote on municipal measures.