1006.2026.TCRS.MEETING.MINUTES

Town of Fountain Hills — Town Council (2026-11-17)

View PDF Meeting page

Extracted text (via pymupdf_layout) 153213 characters
TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
MINUTES OF THE REGULAR SESSION
OF THE FOUNTAIN HILLS TOWN COUNCIL
October 6, 2026
A Regular Session of the Fountain Hills Town Council was convened at 5:30 p.m.
Members Present: Mayor Gerry M. Friedel: Vice Mayor Gayle Earle;
Councilmember Rick Watts; Councilmember Peggy McMahon; Councilmember
Brenda J. Kalivianakis; Councilmember Hannah Larrabee; Councilmember Allen
Skillicorn
Staff Present: Town Manager Rachael Goodwin; Town Attorney Timothy La
Sota; Deputy Town Clerk Angela Padgett-Espiritu

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
Post-Production File
Town of Fountain Hills
Town Council Meeting Minutes
October 6, 2026
Transcription Provided By:
eScribers, LLC
* * * * *
Transcription is provided in order to facilitate communication accessibility and may not
be a totally verbatim record of the proceedings.
* * * * *
Page 1 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
FRIEDEL: I'd like to call this meeting to order. Would you please rise for the Pledge of
Allegiance?
ALL: I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic
for which it stands. One nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
FRIEDEL: And if you choose to remain standing, the invocation tonight will be by Pastor
Clayton Wilfer from JOY Church of Fountain Hills.
Pastor.
WILFER: Gracious God and Heavenly Father, we thank you for your great love for us.
We thank you that your mercies are made new for us each and every day. I lift up this
town council to you, the leaders of this community. I pray that you would pour out your
wisdom, give them insight, give them compassion, grace, and even love as they go about
the decisions of the town. Give them wisdom for doing what is right for the whole
community. Guide them, bless them. And I pray this in Jesus name. Amen.
FRIEDEL: Thank you.
Town clerk, can we take a roll call, please?
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Yes, Mayor.
Mayor Friedel.
FRIEDEL: Present.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Vice Mayor Earle.
EARLE: Present.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember Kalivianakis.
KALIVIANAKIS: Here.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember Watts.
WATTS: Here.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember Larrabee.
LARRABEE: Here.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember McMahon.
MCMAHON: Here.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember Skillicorn.
Page 2 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
SKILLICORN: Here.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: We have a quorum.
FRIEDEL: Thank you. And before we move on to the town manager, I have one
announcement I'm going to make tonight. I'm going to give a little extra time for
agenda items 9a and 9b. So instead of three minutes for -- for speakers, we're going to
go to four minutes for each speaker. It's a big topic for the town. So we're going to
allow a little bit of extra time for that.
And now we'll move on to the town manager. Rachael?
GOODWIN: Thank you, Mayor.
This is our first meeting of the month, but it's been a little while since our last one. So I
have a number of items to kind of share with the community, just sort of save the dates.
But I have a lot of -- I have a long list and not a lot of voice, so bear with me.
All right. So first, we recently launched our new short-term rental public portal. It's on
the town's website. This is where residents can now review permitted short-term rental
properties and access the emergency contact information associated with those
properties. The portal can be found under our -– our finance and licensing area, but
really, this provides residents with a convenient direct resource when questions or
concerns arise regarding a short-term rental property. I know there will be more
discussion about STRs later tonight, and I'm sure John can share more details or Paul.
Tomorrow residents will notice a fresh look along the Avenue of the Fountains as the
existing banners are replaced with new banners highlighting art, dining and shopping in
our downtown area. We are also beginning our annual overseeding of Fountain Park
and along the Avenue of the Fountains. Irrigation will be running more frequently over
the next few weeks while the new grass becomes established, which may make some of
our walking areas wet or less convenient than usual. During this period residents are
encouraged to take advantage of the walking paths and amenities at some of our other
town parks. We appreciate everyone's patience while we get these areas ready for the
fall and winter seasons.
All right. This Saturday, UWS will be hosting a community open house at the community
Page 3 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
center from 9 to 11:30 a.m. A postcard with details about the transition and upcoming
meetings has been mailed to all residents. As a reminder, UWS will be our new trash
haul service provider. Additional information will be available about the meeting on the
town's website, or if you have -- or are looking for more information about this
transition. Residents who are unable to attend this Saturday will have another
opportunity on October 21st. These meetings are a chance to learn more about the
upcoming Solid Waste transition, ask questions and speak directly with the UWS team.
Also, this weekend movie in the park returns at Four Peaks Park from 7 to 9, where we'll
be featuring Toy Story 5. It's a free, family friendly opportunity to enjoy an evening
outside in one of our parks.
Looking ahead, Thursday, October 15th is the Fountain Hills High School homecoming
parade along Park View Avenue. We encourage residents to come out and support our
students and enjoy this great community tradition. Also on October 15th, following the
parade is the return of our Thursday concert series at the Centennial Pavilion from 6 to
7:30. The concert is free and open to the public, and we will have Bachelor Pad BBQ and
Snowbird ice cream on site with treats available.
And finally, next Saturday is Make a Difference Day. It's from 8 to noon, and it provides
another great opportunity for residents to get involved and give back to our community.
It is not too late to sign up, so if you're still thinking about it, if you're on the fence, visit
our website to learn more and you can register by Monday, October 12th.
So there's a lot happening over the next couple of weeks. And we encourage residents
to take a look at our website or follow our social media channels for more details and
updates. Thank you, Mayor.
FRIEDEL: Thank you. As you can see, we have a lot going on in the town of Fountain
Hills.
We're going to move on now to proclamations, and I'm going to start it out tonight with
Community Planning Month. Whereas change affects all communities and planning
helps guide this change. And whereas planning allows residents and officials to shape
the future of their community, whereas October is National Community Planning Month
Page 4 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
recognizing the work of planners and volunteers. Now, therefore, I, Gerry Friedel,
mayor of Fountain Hills, proclaim October is Community Planning Month and I
encourage all residents to acknowledge the contributions of our community planners.
And I think John Wesley is here. I'm going to bring this down, John, and present this to
you and your staff.
WESLEY: Thank you, Mayor, for this proclamation about Community Planning Month. I
want to accept it on behalf of our Planning and Zoning Commission and all the citizen
planners here in town that work with us to help make Fountain Hills the great town that
it is. As we look forward to the future and look for the changes that are coming, and
work to preserve those things that are great and good about the community and help us
be a resilient and vibrant community. I appreciate the opportunity to recognize
planning and the role it plays, and thank the council for your ongoing support for the
work that we do.
FRIEDEL: And I'll add that there's so much work behind the scenes that this Department
handles and planning and zoning the commissioners. So we really appreciate all the
efforts that everybody puts in for our town and our community. So thank you again.
And next up, we have a proclamation that will be done by our Vice Mayor, Gayle Earl.
This is for Arbor Day. Gayle.
EARLE: Yeah. Thank you, Mayor. Arbor Day. Whereas Arbor Day was established in
1872 by J. Sterling Morton to encourage the planting and appreciation of trees and is
now recognized throughout the nation and the world. And whereas trees provide
essential environmental benefits. And whereas trees are a renewable resource that
provides many products. And whereas trees enhance our community by increasing
property values, beautifying our surroundings, and providing opportunity for joy and
spiritual renewal. And now, therefore, Gerry M. Friedel, mayor of the town of Fountain
Hills, Arizona, does hereby proclaim October 17, 2026, as Arbor Day in the town of
Fountain Hills.
In witness thereof, he has his hand and caused to be affixed -- no sorry. He has set his
hand and caused to be affixed the seal of the town of Fountain Hills, Arizona, this 6th
Page 5 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
day of October 2026. I think we have Kevin here.
SNIPES: Hopefully well anchored. I'd just like to say thank you to the town and the
council for their support. We've done a lot over the last few years to help protect our
trees and make sure that our vendors do the same. We have a lot of trees in the town
that have substantial value, not only monetarily, but to the quality of life that we all live.
And so thank you for this. We really appreciate it. It takes a lot of staff and our vendors
to -- to take care of the trees and make sure that they're in the shape where they can
handle our monsoons. So thank you very much.
EARLE: And I want to thank you for all the new trees I see planted around town.
SNIPES: Thank you.
FRIEDEL: The next proclamation will be October as Breast Cancer Awareness Month,
and that will be done by Councilwoman Peggy McMahon. Peggy.
MCMAHON: Thank you very much. Breast Cancer Awareness Month is October, and
whereas Breast Cancer Awareness Month is observed each October to promote breast
cancer awareness, education, research and the importance of early detection. And
whereas breast cancer is the most common form of cancer among women, affecting
approximately one in eight women in the United States while also impacting men.
Whereas millions of breast cancer survivors are living in the United States,
demonstrating the importance of early detection, regular screenings and timely
treatment in improving outcomes.
Whereas, Breast Cancer Awareness Month provides an opportunity to remember those
lost to breast cancer, support those currently affected, celebrate survivors and
recognize the dedication of health care providers and researchers. Whereas, the town
of Fountain Hills recognizes October 2026 as Breast Cancer Awareness Month and
encourages residents to promote education, early detection, compassionate care, and
continued research toward controlling and ultimately curing breast cancer.
And fortunate tonight, we have Dr. Stephanie Lindauer and Dr. Sommer Gunia here to
accept the proclamation from Honor Health.
So do you want to join me, Gerry?
Page 6 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
LINDAUER: Thank you so much. Just wanted to say a quick thank you to the town. And
thank you for the councilmembers for recognizing this month. Breast cancer is so
important. We know early detection saves lives. So anything we can do to promote
awareness, promote education is great. And again I'm Dr. Stephanie Lindauer, medical
oncologist with Honor Health Cancer Care. This is one of my colleagues, Dr. Sommer
Gunia, who's a breast surgeon.
FRIEDEL: Thank you.
EARLE: Thank you very much.
FRIEDEL: And we have another proclamation. This is October as Domestic Violence
Awareness Month. And this will be read by Brenda. Go ahead.
KALIVIANAKIS: Thank you, Mr. Mayor. And I'd also just like to thank you for your
appointing me to the Domestic Violence Council for MAG, your old job. It's been much
appreciated.
Domestic Violence Awareness Month. Whereas home and family should provide
warmth, love, tranquility, and security. And whereas for many Americans, these
blessings have tragically been impacted by violence and fear. Whereas women, men,
children and the elderly are all -- can all be victims of domestic violence. And whereas
domestic violence contributes significantly to homelessness, particularly among women
and children, and can result in lasting physical and emotional harm. Whereas, law
enforcement, shelters, hotlines, health care workers, clergy, volunteers, concerned
citizens work to support victims and to end domestic violence. Whereas, it is important
to recognize their compassion and dedication while increasing public awareness and
understanding of this serious issue.
Now, therefore, I, Mayor Gerry Friedel, mayor of Town in Fountain Hills, do hereby
proclaim October as Domestic Violence Awareness Month in Fountain Hills and
encourage all citizens to become informed about domestic violence and support efforts
to end it. And tonight, we have Kathy Dale (sic) from a turn -– a New Leaf to accept the
proclamation. Kathy.
Hello? And Kathy has 30 years of service.
Page 7 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
DI NOLFI: Yes. Thank you all very much. Kathy Di Nolfi, Chief Program Officer at A New
Leaf. I hope you've heard of us. We've been around a while. I've been around 30 years
there at A New Leaf.
Thank you, Mayor and Council, for this proclamation. Thank you for recognizing
domestic violence awareness as a public health concern, as an issue that affects all of us
all the time, not just in our family, our neighbors, each other, our friends. So thank you
all for allowing me to be here and accept this proclamation.
FRIEDEL: And I think I'll add that we are going to have the town hall lit up in purple and
the fountain as well on Wednesdays for domestic violence. Are we going to do a night
for breast cancer awareness as well?
GOODWIN: Yeah, we can certainly do that.
FRIEDEL: We can do that as well as -- so we'll recognize that further that way. Okay.
Thank you.
And we'll move on now to presentation. Rachael.
GOODWIN: Mayor, I think we can all pause for just a moment to recognize a big
milestone in our community, which was the completion of the eastbound third lane of
Shea Boulevard between Palisades and Fountain Hills Boulevard. I'm pleased to
recognize that major improvement because it represents an important investment in
our community. It improves safety, mobility, and the overall experience for our
residents, our visitors, our businesses, and anyone who travels through Fountain Hills.
I appreciate the hard work and the partnership that went into bringing this project to
completion. In particular, I want to, even though I know it will make him
uncomfortable, I'd like to thank Director Weldy for his time and efforts in making this
project a priority. It was a priority internally. It was a priority for our community. So I
really thank you for what you've done to make it come -- see it through.
So at this time, I would like to turn it over to Public Works Director Justin Weldy to share
a few more details about the project, along with a brief video highlighting the
improvements. This is a great step forward for Fountain Hills, and I look forward to
seeing the benefits for many years to come. Director.
Page 8 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
WELDY: Mayor and Council, Town manager, thank you for the kind words and the
recognition. You've obviously seen and heard me stand here before and say this. I am
the spokesperson for the people that actually get out there and do all of those. And on
behalf of them, thank you for this recognition. I rarely make notes, but I did make a few
little notes here that I'll go over while the video plays. This is a video that we made of
the project after completion.
[VIDEO]
WELDY: Shea Boulevard has long been Fountain Hills lifeline to the greater Phoenix
area, connecting our residents, business and visitors in the region. Before
incorporation, Shea served as a county maintained two lane rural connector. For those
of you that may or may not have lived in this area prior to incorporation or travel
through here, you would note it would be something very similar to what you would
encounter on Fountain Hills Boulevard. If there was a rainstorm and you came across
one of the numerous washes that crossed it, you would simply have to wait it out or
turn around and go back.
Following incorporation in December of 1989, the town began assuming responsibility
for this vital corridor, a transition that culminated in Maricopa County's formal roadway
transfer in 1993. The transition marked more than a change in maintenance
responsibilities, it gave Fountain Hills greater control over its transportation future and
laid the groundwork for decades of investment and regional partnership. Today's
improvements continue that legacy.
We -- with support from the Maricopa Association of Governments and our project
partners, we are improving a corridor essential to our community's mobility, safety and
economic vitality. Thank you to the staff, the regional partners, Mayor and council, the
construction team and all of our residents for their patience. For those of you that -- if
you have not had an opportunity, please take a drive down this little section. Let us
know what you think of it. Those are the few words I'm going to say. We have the
executive director for MAG here, Audra Koester Thomas is going to say a few words.
And again, I thank you for the opportunity and the kind words.
Page 9 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
KOESTER THOMAS: Well, Mayor and council, it's a distinct honor and pleasure to be
with you here this evening, to join in this celebration of the completion of the Shea
Boulevard project. As you know, MAG is the regional planning agency for
transportation, environmental and human services work throughout our region, which is
over 10,000 square miles and over five million people strong.
I'm joined this evening by my partner, Ryan Barber, who is our senior analyst at MAG,
who has worked closely with your staff on a very important component of this project,
reimbursement of funding. We are pleased to be your partners in delivery of this
project. It's an important regional project, in addition to serving the community of
Fountain Hills.
The Shea Boulevard project was an original proposition 400 project, and so with the
completion, you are delivering on promises made to the voters back in 2004 to deliver
this regionally significant project. Of course, our partnership doesn't end here. We
have a lot more work ahead as we look towards our commitments with voters in the
proposition 479 delivery. We look forward to working with the town in the years ahead
on projects including the reconstruction of Palisades Boulevard. And as I was
mentioning to the mayor this evening. Phase two of the Shea Boulevard widening here
in the years ahead.
It's our distinct pleasure to serve this community. Just in the past few years, over $6
million has been delivered to Fountain Hills through MAG funding. While a significant
portion of that certainly is in reflection of the Shea Boulevard project. Funding has also
gone to identify and fill sidewalk gaps throughout the city's -- or the town's core.
A few years ago, we provided funding to help the town pave a portion of Fountain Hills
Boulevard, as well as to fund a Safe Routes to School project connecting our community.
We appreciate invitations like these when we get to celebrate a project's completion.
So on behalf of the 32 other towns, cities, counties and native nations that comprise the
MAG community, congratulations on delivering this regionally significant project and for
including Ryan and I in your celebration tonight. Thank you.
FRIEDEL: Thank you, again.
Page 10 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
We'll move on now to our consent agenda. Do I have a motion and a second?
KALIVIANAKIS: Motion to approve consent agenda.
LARRABEE: Second.
FRIEDEL: We have a motion and a second.
Can I get a roll call, please, Town Clerk?
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember Larrabee?
LARRABEE: Aye.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember McMahon?
MCMAHON: Aye.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember Watts?
WATTS: Aye.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember Skillicorn?
SKILLICORN: Yes.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember Kalivianakis?
KALIVIANAKIS: Aye.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Vice Mayor Earle?
EARLE: Aye.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Mayor Friedel?
FRIEDEL: Aye.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Motion passes unanimously.
FRIEDEL: Thank you.
We'll move on to our regular agenda item 9a. Consideration regarding ordinance 26-13
repealing Town Code Articles. Rachael.
GOODWIN: Thank you, Mayor. I will speak for -- I'm going to speak for a lot of people
and say, this is a big item. This has been an item that has been long discussed with this
council, as well as previous councils, as well as a number of community groups. Our
P&Z, it has been a big lift for staff. So it has been a long time coming in terms of this
conversation and these updates. I will let John walk us through this, but I will mention I
believe our consultant is also on the line. They can see us. We cannot see them, but we
Page 11 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
can certainly -- we -- they can hear us as well. So we can have questions or discussion
with them as well. Is that right, John?
WESLEY: Yes, that is right. Vanessa and Scott, I believe both are on the line. So most of
your questions, I'm sure, want to be directed to them, but I'll give the presentation to
start with.
GOODWIN: Sounds great. Thank you.
WESLEY: Okay. So Mayor and Council, I'll walk through this. Again, my purpose is to
give you an overview of what is in the ordinance, and then see what questions you may
have as we move forward with this important step, meeting the needs of the town.
So again, some background. Town Manager touched on this a little bit, but the council
directed P&Z to work on updates to all of our wireless ordinance provisions. Both of
these for the small cell that we're talking about this evening and what's in Chapter 17 of
the zoning ordinance for the macro towers. And so we've been working on both since
March of '25. We were fortunate to be able to hire the McCollough Law Firm, to step in
and help us with this, because it's a very technical topic area, a little bit beyond the --
the expertise that we had in house and staff to work on.
This draft ordinance that you're -– or this ordinance that you're looking at this evening
was on a P&Z work session back in the end of July. So they took a look at it then,
provided some comments on it, and the public was able to see it at that point. So
they've been able to have that time to become familiar with it and be prepared to make
comments.
Overall goals we've had in this process, preserving local authority to the fullest extent
while still following the federal and state laws, preserving the town character and
implementing a comprehensive approach to the application and review processes, and
providing transparency and accountability for decisions that are made. Again, some of
the background and the legal framework for doing this, federal law does preserve some
authority to local jurisdictions with regard to cell towers, it's somewhat limited, but the
benefit of having an expert such as McCollough Law Firm step in is they know where
those places are, where we can step in and -- and provide more local control. And so
Page 12 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
that's what they've done for us. But they've been careful to follow those federal
guidelines. So we don't pre-empt any particular carriers or discriminate among
providers or base anything on RF radiation that we can't.
So there's zone law mandates approval of certain types of small cell wireless facilities in
the right of way. So we've preserved that. But again, it does provide some flexibility,
so -- where that's possible. The ordinance provides for it.
So in review of the ordinances that we have, the way the ordinances have been set up is
Chapter 17 of the zoning ordinance is handled. All wireless towers and antennas except
for small cell in the right of way. That's always been a little bit of a confusion or concern
about why those things are in different places like that. But moving forward, as we
looked at this and worked with consultant, it was determined that it really be best to
have all the small cell together in an ordinance. And so that's what we did.
Chapter 16 of the Town Code deals with streets and highway -- or streets and sidewalks.
And so once we started bringing small cell wireless facilities that were on private
property, not in the streets anymore, it made sense to move all that to a new chapter of
the Town Code. So all the way along, it's been a little bit confusing. At this point, we've
been talking about changes to Chapter 16 of Town Code. Well, now we're talking about
Chapter 19. So hopefully we don't get lost in that little -- little change.
But so Chapter 19 is what we're talking about, a new Chapter 19 that will address both
the small cell wireless facilities as well as the utility service antennas. Quickly on utility
service antennas. Those are the antennas that SRP or EPCOR uses to communicate
within their system. We have some around town and we're working with them to -- the
most part, turn those into saguaro cactus. But there are no changes being made to that
other than moving into 19-2, just changing the section. So we're not going to talk about
that anymore this evening, again, because there's no changes there.
So you've had attached to your packet a copy of the ordinance itself. But with that we
also provided just a breakdown of chapter -- or Section 19-1 that shows in different font
colors the changes that have been made to the ordinance based on the P&Z
recommendation because when P&Z did make the recommendation last month, they
Page 13 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
did have a few things they wanted to see changed. So we wanted to make that clear
what those changes were compared to what the P&Z looked at. And so in case you
were wondering, when you see the different font colors in that purple was things
responding to citizens. The red was the things that we identified as a consultant staff,
and the green were more specifically the items that P&Z said.
So with that, let's step into the ordinance itself. Section 19-1-1 is the purpose provision.
And this provides overall framework for the ordinance and the things that we're trying
to accomplish through this. Describes our desire and intent to balance both the needs
of the industry to provide good and effective telecommunication services within the
town, while meeting the needs of the town and preserving our character. And so, you
know, that's what we're over -- after there.
The section has been substantially increased in terms of providing some of those ideas
and details, than the current ordinance gives us more things that we can -- can hang our
hats on as we need to, to show the purpose and intent. Compared to what was -- I
looked at P&Z and based on the recommendations, we have added a provision in this
with regard to the Sonoran Desert tortoise, but then also recognized compared to
Chapter 17 of the zoning ordinance, there is an extensive section on applicability that
wasn't in Chapter 19 or in this Section 19-1 purpose. So we moved that over
comparable to here. So we'd have that clear direction for future users of the code
about what it applies to.
Section 19-1-2 is definitions. There are more than 80 new definitions provided
compared to what we have currently in our code. Very extensive work in both this
chapter and in 17 to clearly define the different terms and important topics covered by
this technical area compared to what P&Z looked at and reviewed, and based on their
direction, we've added a definition for childcare facility.
Moving on to Section 19-1-3, general requirements. So this section of the code again
lists all the basic requirements that you need to know in order to site and plan for a
wireless facility. This section includes some things that are a little bit different from the
current code, one of which is a 500-foot separation from all residency zoned parcels.
Page 14 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
That was in the P&Z review. Based on their review and comments there, we've added a
couple of provisions. We extended that to also require the separation for child and
daycare facilities. And to state that if it's a guy facility, a tower that has guy wires that
will measure the distance from the outermost guy wire point, not from the base of the
tower.
So the section also covers information and requirements for co-location, restricted site
locations, and the preferential site locations that we are looking first to site these in
industrial or commercial areas if possible, and then moving out with other types of
locations if those don't work.
And then there was an item brought up at the P&Z commission. And based on that, so
added a provision about separating a tower a minimum distance from the primary
doorways into establishments.
KALIVIANAKIS: Can we ask questions as we go along or --
FRIEDEL: Let's take questions at the end when he's -- when he's done.
KALIVIANAKIS: Okay.
FRIEDEL: Please.
WESLEY: Okay. Going on with the general requirements. There are some basic
requirements in this section. One of the things is that if an applicant can see at the
beginning that they're going to have a challenge meeting some of the requirements,
particularly the location requirements, they can ask for an exception and make that part
of their application. So we can process that with the overall review. It addresses
accessory equipment, so anytime you have a tower, you've got some ground
equipment, transformers and other things. And so commission asked that we put in a
little bit more provision for battery safety with regard to those which has been done. It
prohibits obscuring visibility along the street and the section. Also, one of the concerns
from the P&Z Commission was that those antennas can be placed fairly low and close to
pedestrians. So they ask for a minimum height above a walking area. So that was
added at their recommendation.
Section 19-1-4, design standards, sets forth a basic design requirements to help achieve
Page 15 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
as much compatibility with the surrounding location. In the design and building of the
facility. They must comply with all federal and state requirements as part of the section.
The general design standards include things dealing with engineering and reducing
visual impact and providing for screening.
Set specific standards for those that are in the right of way, as well as specific standards
for those that are on private property. One of the items that was added was if it is a
data only facility. Otherwise, it's not doing voice, that those are required to go
underground if at all possible. So that was added per P&Z commission direction.
Moving on to the next Section 19-1-5, application submission requirements. So this tells
the applicants the things they need to prepare and submit with their application. So this
shows you a list of those types of information that are required to be provided to us, so
that we can review and ensure it's going to meet the requirements of the code. And
then in addition, there's some specific requirements based on whether it's in the town
right of way or on private property.
19-1-6 has the review procedures and timelines. So it provides review requirements for
all small wireless facilities applications within the right of way or on private property.
Also, this section allows us to hire and use an outside consultant to review the
applications. This is something that we are moving forward with and planning for now.
We've had an RFQ out to solicit those consultants, so we'll be -- have those in place
when these are approved. Because this is a very technical document, excuse me, with
very technical standards. And we'll benefit well by having the consultant. The
applicants will pay the cost of that consultant review.
And so it also makes clear that the towers are subject to all other town ordinances and
requirements. They can request a waiver of the time frames and then set those time
frames for completeness review. It allows for onsite inspection.
We can require a values impact report. Requires the town to conduct an environmental
review if we think it's necessary. That's something that was added based on discussion
at the P&Z Commission was a provision for biological resource survey. And then also
provides for historic impact review and again, standards for small cells in the right of
Page 16 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
way, and tells us how the town shall notify the applicant of decisions.
Section is coordinated with the Terms and Conditions document. So I'll step out of the
ordinance for just a minute. And this touches a little bit on your next item. But back in
2018, when the State passed its laws basically requiring towns to allow small cell
wireless in the town right of way, the town adopted those types of ordinance provisions,
but in addition to that, adopted a number of additional documents to help us
implement the ordinance. One of those is a set of terms and conditions for small cell in
the right of way.
And so we've looked through that ordinance as we have updated this. And one of the
things in the terms and conditions is that there's a three-step process that we go
through in reviewing a small cell starts with a pre-application and then a preliminary
plan review and then the construction documents. And so it's at that preliminary plan
review stage that items that would need to come forward to council for review, that's
when that would happen.
Section 19-1-7, permit conditions. So this tells us things we can do attach with the
permit and take care of during that permit process. And so there's a list of things here
that we can do to ensure that it is built and -- and implemented the way that the plan is
called for and approved. Insurance is one of the new items that's in here. And then a
required rating notice or required minimum rating of the insurance provider was added
based on input received at the P&Z Commission.
Safety standards is the next item of the ordinance that sets some basic standards of
safety and then requires -- allows the town to shut down a facility if the standards aren't
met.
Section 19-1-9, operational requirements. So after the tower is -- is complete, up and
operational. This sets forth some standards that the town can follow to ensure it
continues to operate safely and within the established RF emissions limits. So most of
this was in the current code, but we did add a few things. And one of which that came
from discussion of P&Z was a notice of noncompliance and a cure period for that if that
should happen.
Page 17 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
And then finally Section 19-1-10, exceptions. Mentioned this earlier, the provisions in
the ordinance are fairly strict. As mentioned before, it requires minimum separation
from residential at -- at 500 feet and other things. So it could become challenging to
actually implement or find a location for a tower. But this exception provision provides
the applicant the opportunity to come before council and demonstrate that that they've
met everything in the code, but to avoid any conflicts with the State or federal law that
they need an exception.
And then finally appeals. If an application is denied administratively, it provides for a
review of that through an appeal process.
Rates and fees. There are somewhat set through -- through the State, but we will --
based on having a consultant that's going to look at these, we'll need to do some
updates to those. And so we'll be updating the fee schedule to be consistent with the
ordinance requirements and the -- the process within the code.
So again P&Z Commission looked at this at a work session. It's not within their purview
to actually make a recommendation since it's not in the zoning ordinance. But they did
provide that level of review and some comment for you. Based on that, we did receive
comments and we've made the changes consistent with those comments. And so staff
is here tonight recommending approval of the ordinance as presented.
So glad to take questions. And again Vanessa and Scott are on the phone to help with
those.
FRIEDEL: I'll remind the councilmembers, hit the left button so you get in the queue if
you want to -- if you have questions. Please.
WATTS: Thank you, John, for the recap. I think I'm going to go a little off script first and
foremost, and go above and beyond and say thank you for the tenacity of staying
engaged with the consultants. It was refreshing to see the puts and the takes. You
would push one direction. The consultants would push back and say, why or why not
what we could do. And that was -- took a lot of stamina to go through all of that. So
from a personal level, thank you for sticking with it for so many years because it's been a
long, hard process.
Page 18 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
WESLEY: Thank you.
WATTS: On another note, as far as the appeal process goes, I'm a little concerned about
the Board of Adjustment being the person -- the entity that is going to do the appeals,
and that would be -- my recommendation would be that we have -- and I've got three
items that apply to the appeal, so I'd like to read those. And then I'd like to get
feedback from the consultants Vanessa and Scott.
So the appeal in the reconsideration process should remain strictly within the purview
of the town council without involving the Board of Adjustments or other external entity.
The Town Council, with the support of staff, is most familiar with the local issues. Town
Council should review and reconsider any appeal with the guidance of a qualified third-
party firm/expert. The firm must be a nationally recognized for their expertise in state,
federal and local laws and regulations. I think that goes to your point of doing an RFQ
for those that would be appropriate to do, review -- pardon me, reviews or even the
appeal process.
And then secondly, I want to make sure that in the definitions we have a definition
describing the qualifications of the firm. You know, what are we looking for? Have they
got the experience, the depth of expertise, did they get the bandwidth to have? Most
firms that have -- and I'll use an engineering or an architectural firm, for instance. They
have a depth that looks at planning and zoning. They look at mechanical, electrical,
plumbing. So they have to have the ability to look at the entirety of the application and
the whole project.
And then finally, again, back to the review and the appeals. I think we have to have
whomever we have do the review of the application initially on staff, have some training
done by and through that consultant so that we can assure that who does the reviews,
knows what they're looking for in its totality and just not accepting things.
And then I've got a couple of more after that. So maybe we can get those three adjust --
addressed right now.
WESLEY: Okay. Thank you, Mayor, Councilmember. I'll take a little bit of a stab at that,
and then we can see if Scott or Vanessa have a comment.
Page 19 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
I believe we -- we use the Board of Adjustment because it's coming from a staff decision.
And that's a little bit more typical. But I don't know if there's a reason why the appeals
couldn't come to the town council, if that's your preference there to be -- be that
involved in those -- those technical decisions like that.
As far as the definition of the consultant, I'm sure that's something we could work on.
Certainly not anything that we had thought about before trying to define that type of
term. But again, let's see what the consultant has to say about that particular idea. And
my thought is that with regard to this, once we have the consultant, the minute an
application hits our desk, we're forwarding it. Staff's really not doing much at all with it
other than acknowledging that we have -- have it, because we do see the consultant we
hire is really being the one to -- to understand it and be able to know if it's a complete
application and work with the applicant to meet all the requirements.
WATTS: So we are relying on a third-party to do the review, in addition to making sure
that when we first get the application, it's pretty much check the box not for content.
WESLEY: Right.
WATTS: The third-party would be doing a review –
WESLEY: That completes this review.
WATTS: -- of content.
WESLEY: Yes.
WATTS: Okay. Good. That would satisfy my position on that, anyway. I don't know if
the consultants have any additional comment about the Board of Adjustment versus
Town Council. I think Town council and staff, Board of Adjustments really isn't going to
have the background. But if council was -- I mean, we've been so intimately involved
with this for so many years, and I think new council going forward would be privy to that
same information by being supported by a third-party again.
FRIEDEL: Vanessa or Scott, do you have any comments?
MCCOLLOUGH: Well, I can make a quick comment. In many places, including in
Arizona, the council has the option of itself being the Board of Adjustment, either in
general or for a specific purpose. You have chosen to have a separate Board of
Page 20 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
Adjustment for most purposes. But you could provide either by amendment or change
to this ordinance or in the other organizational part of your general ordinances that for
appeals of wireless matters, you would sit as the Board of Adjustment. However, I really
do just think the easiest way to do it is to provide that an appeal goes to the council
itself. That's quite common. It happens throughout the country, and that would be the
simplest and cleanest fix.
WATTS: That would work. Thank you.
I've got an easy one. This is a softball. Can we add -- to childcare, can we add elder care
to make sure that there's a clarity there. And I know when I read it, I see that it implies
things along the lines of childcare or -- but I'd be comfortable with elder care of some
sort, adult care centers, that type of thing.
WESLEY: Mayor, Councilmember, I'll start a response. And I know Vanessa looked into
the childcare and the legalities of that and the process for doing that to see how it could
be handled. Elder care is in my first reaction is a little bit maybe harder to define. I
don't even know if we have any in Fountain Hills is I guess it's different than assisted
living. It's a place that -- where an elderly person would go during the day to receive
some care, socialization, whatever, while their normal caregiver is -- is not at home.
WATTS: We have assisted living covered though?
WESLEY: Yeah. So assisted living, that's a residential home that's already covered by
the residential.
WATTS: If we've got that that's an oversight on my part. Then I want to make sure that
we were protecting the elderly who require some level of assisted living as well.
WESLEY: So yeah, so all residential, whether it's zoned or a use is covered.
WATTS: Okay. Well, that was easy enough. The noise issue. The noise is not in this
scenario, it's not electrical noise, it's not EMF noise. It's acoustical noise. And the
mechanical equipment that goes into some of these installations has levels that are
specified by the manufacturer, either enclosed or not. So acoustical enclosures would
dampen it if it was wide open and it had different -- different levels. I think it's
important for the residents to know that we're protecting the noise levels in the area by
Page 21 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
identifying decibel levels that are acceptable, a range. And off the top of my head, I
don't know what those are, but if I said there were 50 to a hundred and they submitted
75 and it was supported by the manufacturer specifications. And we have a point of
reference when there was a complaint.
So I'm looking for something more specific than just noise because we've had this issue
before, the subjectivity of noise, the MCSO's, I'll call it refusal, to get decibel meters
when we have the party houses and vacation rentals and that type of stuff, it becomes
challenging. But the owners would be on the contractor or the service provider if it
didn't meet the specifications of what the manufacturer said in the submitted data. So
we wouldn't incur the cost. The contractor service provider would be responsible for
proving that what is installed is consistent with what they put in their application. So I'd
like to see some bumpers around decibel levels and how they are validated through the
application process.
I think page 26, item 16, we have 500 feet versus 300 feet. I think there's a consistency.
WESLEY: Do you have a section number or a packet page number to find which one
you're talking about?
WATTS: Page 26.
WESLEY: Okay. That's not going to be page -- since I have the packet pulled up here,
that's not going to be a page number that I have.
WATTS: I did. It's -- I don't know if it's 19-1-5. That's -- last time I had section numbers.
And now I've got page numbers and –
UNIDENTIFIED SPEAKER: Yeah. John, you went right there.
WATTS: Okay.
UNIDENTIFIED SPEAKER: 16 on that paper.
SHINMOTO: I can speak.
WESLEY: Oh, yes, okay.
UNIDENTIFIED SPEAKER: 300 feet posted.
WESLEY: Okay. There we go.
SHINMOTO: I believe –
Page 22 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
WESLEY: So –
SHINMOTO: -- the 300 feet –
WESLEY: So Vanessa, I'm not sure if it's on your end or our end, but we can barely hear
you. So this -- this is the notice requirement, which is our standard notice requirements
for all zoning --
WATTS: Right.
WESLEY: -- is 300 feet.
WATTS: I knew it was for zoning. I knew that was what we've got as a standard. But
everywhere else throughout this we've got distances between of 500 feet. Should we
be consistent with 500 feet or -- I'm looking for some input to support the 300 feet.
WESLEY: Again, it's because that's our standard notification requirement for any zoning
action. That's why we use that number. It could be 500 feet if you want it to be.
WATTS: I'd like to see it be 500 feet if I can get Vanessa to agree with that.
SHINMOTO: I don't see any reason why it wouldn't be -- why we couldn't do 500 feet if
we wanted to make it -- providing notice.
WATTS: That sounds like a yes.
SHINMOTO: I'm trying to kind of -- so yeah, I think it would be fine on the notice.
WATTS: Okay. And page -- here we go, page 29. So let's try three pages down where it
says, "500 versus 1,000". I'm going to go the other way on this one. We've got 1,000
feet.
WESLEY: Have I gone past it yet? Yeah, okay, right there.
WATTS: There it is, right there. Identify all residential properties located in at least
1,000 feet. And again, it's a consistency thing. We've got 500 feet everywhere else. I'm
not so sure why we have 1,000 feet on this particular item.
WESLEY: So again Vanessa can step in in a moment.
SHINMOTO: Yeah –
WESLEY: But when we're talking –
SHINMOTO: I'll go ahead and –
WESLEY: Okay.
Page 23 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
SHINMOTO: Can you hear me? So that item is the -- that is the property values impact
report. And I think 1,000 feet is more reflective of, you know, the entire area because it
casts a wider net over the properties and it gives more, you know, the -- the realtor
appraiser who's going to appraise the impact of the facility -- of the proposed facility,
that it will give them a wider range of properties to look at.
So I personally would keep the 1,000 feet just -- just for that reason, because it -- it
really extends the range of how much this facility could potentially affect all the
properties within the area. And I do think that residents would, you know, want to be
included in that analysis to see how -- you know, how much will this proposed facility
affect their -- you know, their property values. So I don't -- I don't -- I think that that's
fine.
I mean, the reason why there is an inconsistency is between the 500 feet and the 1,000
feet really has to do with the effect of prohibition in the sense that it's kind of -- you
know, of course, we would really prefer all of the facilities to be, well, at least 1,600
feet, but it may become difficult to justify it in light of, you know, the federal -- both the
federal and the Arizona present pre – pre-emptions, but the federal pre-emption as an
effective prohibition. And so the 500 feet was really, I think, the furthest that we could
push the wireless facilities to stay away from residential properties and school and
daycare facilities without coming -- coming as close to the effective prohibition. But on
the other hand, 1,000 feet is -- it's not really an effective prohibition. It's just basically
asking the applicant to, you know, do a wider analysis of the area and see how much it's
going to affect the -- you know, the entire area, not just the homes that are within the
500 feet. So I mean, I would argue that we should keep those separate.
WATTS: Okay. No I understand. Makes more sense now that you've explained it. So
thank you for that. And I think that does it for me. So thank you, John.
EARLE: Thank you, Mayor. I want to come back and support what Councilman Watts
said about the appeals going back to the council in lieu of Board of Adjustments and
then listening to the other things you said, I support your other recommendations as
well. Thank you.
Page 24 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
FRIEDEL: Brenda.
KALIVIANAKIS: Thank you very much. I've written something out and I'd like to take a
moment to go through it because I have some serious concerns about this ordinance.
FRIEDEL: Can I --
KALIVIANAKIS: We hired this law firm --
FRIEDEL: Can I stop you for just a second? This is for questions right --
KALIVIANAKIS: Okay.
FRIEDEL: -- now. General discussion will follow after comment cards, if that's okay.
KALIVIANAKIS: So when are we going to talk about it so that I can make my --
FRIEDEL: Soon. Yeah. So we have questions first. Then we ask for comment cards and
then we have council discussion. And you can -- you can do it then. Okay.
Councilman.
SKILLICORN: Mr. Mayor, I -- I think you probably answered what my thought was, is if
we're done with the technical questions, I was wanting to hear from the residents and
then further our own discussion.
FRIEDEL: We're almost there. I think Councilman -- Councilwoman Kalivianakis has a
question.
KALIVIANAKIS: Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Yeah, I do have a few questions. I know when
we had a previous legal advice on Chapter 16, it was said to the council quite explicitly
that that was forbidden territory that was covered by federal and state law. Has that
changed between the previous legal advice we had and currently?
WESLEY: Mayor, councilmember, no, it hasn't changed, but we do have consultants that
we've brought on board who has a greater familiarity with -- for the details of the law
and the court cases and so forth that could help us find where there was some flexibility
so that we can take as much advantage of the local control as we could.
KALIVIANAKIS: It says right in there that we're trying to expand the horizons of an
ordinance to go just as far as federal law will let us go. See, I think that's been the
impetus. I do have any concerns that this has gone too far and that we've taken too
many liberties with state and federal law as far as fees, distances. I've got 25 things
Page 25 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
written out that could possibly go askew. Do you have any concerns about that, Mr.
Wesley?
WESLEY: Mayor, Councilmember, this certainly has pushed it a lot further than -- than
when I was working on it by myself, felt comfortable with, given my limited
understanding of the law and the technicalities involved. But I've felt very comfortable
working with the McCollough Law Firm and their breadth of knowledge and
understanding of the allowances within the ordinances and within the statutes that they
have kept us within bounds, it can be defensible.
KALIVIANAKIS: So you're relying on their expertise?
WESLEY: Yes.
KALIVIANAKIS: Thank you. When this document came to your department, was it
reviewed by our town attorney?
WESLEY: Yes.
KALIVIANAKIS: It was. Would that be Jen?
WESLEY: Yes.
KALIVIANAKIS: Okay. Because when I received a copy of this, I had questions and
problems with a great deal of it. And a lot of it was grammatical errors, blank dates,
numbering errors, addressing wrong legal citations. Are you telling me that it went --
made it to the law firm through our legal department, through you with all these errors?
Is this draft ready to be approved? Because I found more errors in my research that are
there still to this day right now. And I was trying to stop you along the way because I
have specific questions to answer. It would be very difficult for me to go back to ask you
the numerous questions I have. This seems to be something that we should have a
workshop on so we can ask the correct questions. We can't be here till 3 in the
morning, or maybe we can, but I do have a problem with -- with all the -- the errors that
have brought it here.
Do you have any concerns about that John?
WESLEY: Mayor, Councilmember, at this point, we've been through it. Again, finding
some number of errors in a document this extensive isn't uncommon. And most of
Page 26 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
those are -- are what would be considered scrivener's errors that can be easily corrected
after the fact if -- if, you know, they're found typos and so forth. So no again, I think we
continue to get some feedback and review. And I'm comfortable that we've got an
ordinance that's ready for approval.
KALIVIANAKIS: Do you think the changing ARS reference from 9-951 to -- 9-951 to 9-591
or changing 47 U.S. Code reference from 6409(b)(2) to 1445. Do you think those are just
superficial errors, or are they consequential errors that are literally creating the -- citing
the wrong code? Are those inconsequential in your opinion?
WESLEY: So they were important to correct though, so it was -- is the site -- the correct
site. But again, after the fact it would have been easy corrections to make if they would
have gotten adopted with those because it would be clear what the correction should
be.
KALIVIANAKIS: But it would be like turning in a legal brief with all these citations and
then asking to correct them later. I'm just wondering if this document, as it's been
presented to us, is ready for our vote. It seems to me, and again, I'm just asking you a
question. Do you think that maybe we should take a little more time before this council
votes on this, so we can ferret out the concerns that I'm sure myself and some of the
other councilmembers have? This has been going on for four years, and I don't know
why we're rushing it. Do you have an opinion on that?
WESLEY: Mayor, Councilmember, I think I'll come back to --
EARLE: A point of order. Is that -- I feel like you're interrogating John.
KALIVIANAKIS: I'm asking him questions.
EARLE: Well, it sounds like you're interrogating him.
KALIVIANAKIS: Whatever. Let's go back to the -- the 500 foot for childcare and daycare.
Where did we arrive at 500 feet at? Was that a number that was given to us by an
expert?
WESLEY: Mayor, Councilmember, we'd established 500 feet for separation from
residential uses as an appropriate standard to ensure that residential homes are -- are
not impacted. And so it just seemed to the Planning Zoning Commission that the same
Page 27 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
standard should be applied to another place where young children are located to
prevent any harm that might happen there.
KALIVIANAKIS: It's funny you mention that the young children, because when AT&T sent
us a letter two years ago saying that they had a problem with what we're attempt –
we're going to attempt to do, I've got a copy of the letter right here. They specifically
referred to our emissions and health effects. Now, we cannot regulate our emissions
for health effects. So when we put it -- codify that we have concerns about childcare,
daycare and possibly elder care, what other concerns would we have other than the
health effects of young brains being exposed to these towers?
WESLEY: So again as I mentioned earlier, our consultants really had all the technical
details. Those are probably better questions for Vanessa to address because --
KALIVIANAKIS: Okay. Fair --
WESLEY: -- they --
KALIVIANAKIS: Fair enough. Vanessa could -- could you -- you -- yourself said that you
thought we were pushing it on the 500 feet, which I agreed with. I think we pushed it
way too far. Is the 500 foot rule to protect young children's brains and elder care and
daycare? Why are we -- why are we doing that? Why are we trying to restrict
placement of these based on what I think is -- at least I'm trying to figure out why -- why
we're doing it for that reason.
SHINMOTO: So that does come close to the restrictions. However, we think that they
can be defensible in terms of there's other provisions in the ordinance that address
radio frequency compliance in terms of keeping -- making sure that they're at least
within the FCC limits. And even though those -- that's for the town to make sure that
those are in compliance. And so these are just additional safeguards in terms of the --
of -- of making sure that there isn't exposure.
Now, that -- that does run a little bit close. But I -- when I reviewed it with Attorney
McCullough, we thought that we could see how this would be pushed forward -- pushed
to the limit of, you know, the radio frequency impacts, but that's what I would direct it,
because even within those limits, those could be justified as there might be other
Page 28 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
criteria that we could -- we could look at to see if there's an adverse impact on those
properties.
MCCOLLOUGH: If I can follow up? This is Scott –
SHINMOTO: Yeah.
MCCOLLOUGH: -- McCollough. The case law indicates, and if you look throughout the
country, you will see separation and setback requirements in ordinances in many, many
locations. They're quite common. And they have been allowed by the courts when they
have a purpose other than to directly regulate on the basis of environmental effects. So
there are rational reasons to have separations and setbacks. One of them is property
value impacts.
We had a case not too long ago where there was a -- a childcare facility very close to a
proposed tower. And the evidence was that everybody that was going to that school
was going to leave. It would put the -- the -- the school out of business. And it would
have obviously reduced the -- the value of that enterprise. So that's an allowable
reason.
Now, could it be justified solely on health effects, no. But there are other bases upon
which to have separation and setback requirements for sensitive locations, whether
they be residences or other businesses that have certain special qualities, like schools,
like elder care. Now, the courts haven't just uniformly rejected those.
One thing I do want to point out as well is that yes, it is true. We've come pretty close
to the line in many of these provisions. We've taken you as far as can be justified.
Because we consider that was the intent and desire of council, that you want to retain
all of the authority that you are allowed to have. You don't want to give up any
authority.
One of the things that was important to put in this ordinance was that if any wireless
company thinks that any of these provisions go so far as to in its situation constitute an
effective prohibition, it can tell you that. And there is a process for it to obtain a waiver.
So if they think any of these would be a problem in their particular case, they can tell
you about it. They can present facts to justify that argument and you can rule on it.
Page 29 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
And if you are convinced by their presentation, then you can give them their waiver.
That's -- that -- that safe harbor is pretty likely to solve almost any of the effective
prohibition issues that occur.
KALIVIANAKIS: And thank you for that explanation. And I appreciate your candor. You
know, I was hoping that we would have more of a conservative document that wouldn't
be -- something would -- that have to be litigated. And I know, when Vanessa said you
know, we pushed this as far as we can go. I – I don't want to have to litigate this
through the courts. I don't think that's wise. The FCC's position, which I looked up was
that they argued that under its Build America agenda, that local authorities are tending
to slow roll approvals, exact exorbitant fees.
FRIEDEL: Brenda, do you have a --
KALIVIANAKIS: Yes.
FRIEDEL: -- do you have a specific question?
KALIVIANAKIS: Yeah, that's what I'm doing right now to -- to the council.
FRIEDEL: It sounds like more of a --
KALIVIANAKIS: So role approve -- and is -- is this -- could this document be construed as
slow rolling and adding a lot of superfluous information into it? I'll give you one more
example. Section 19-1-5c includes extensive submission requirements including fire
plans, electrical acoustic studies, advance notice neighbors, many -- many of the things
that are kind of picayune. I -- do you think all these burdens are going to be upheld in
litigation because I'm not sure they will.
SHINMOTO: Well, what I would like to say is that this is really more of a responsible
permitting, because the reality of it is that, yes, the FCC has its agenda to Build America
and to accelerate wireless and broadband deployments. And you know, we do
recognize the importance of accelerating those. I mean, we do want to be a
technologically advanced society. We don't want to deny the technology. And we do
want to allow for technological innovation.
But you know, as it stands now, there's really it's very unbalanced and it doesn't
consider community interests and it doesn't consider the interests of ordinary citizens
Page 30 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
and homeowners and people who are, you know, going to bear the cost of these
deployments. And right now it's very one sided. And it's not to say that, you know, I
don't believe that our ordinance effectively prohibits any deployments. It's just asking
the applicants to be responsible and to say, well, if it does this, for instance, this small
cell, which can be 50 foot, does it really need to be in front of someone's front yard? I
mean, maybe not. Maybe it does, but maybe it doesn't. But at least make them prove
that they have to -- that that's where they have to put it. Because why should an
ordinary resident bear that? And that kind of cost, especially when it comes at an
impact to their home, which is typically the source of wealth for most Americans, is their
home.
And so like what's happening right now is with these FCC build outs is that they're
basically asking ordinary people to foot the bill while the telecoms profit. And yes,
maybe there are some sacrifices that need to be made in terms of getting all of us to,
you know, the broadband and the wireless communication and connectivity that we
need. But you know, what we're asking is -- is for more responsibility and for more
transparency in the process.
And so I really personally feel very strongly that this is a great ordinance that allows the
town to do this, and it was our understanding that the town did want to go, you know,
as far as it could go to protect the citizens and also to protect its character and its dark
sky status. So that's what I would say, you know -- you know, as a push for the
ordinance.
Of course, you know, we are happy to work with the town council. And if there are, you
know, things that we need to walk back that you're not comfortable with, where we're
happy to do that as well. So I just want to put that out there.
KALIVIANAKIS: And thank you for that. And all I'd like to say is I wish we would have a
chance to have that discussion. So the ones that do exceed what I would view local
authority, we could pull back on before we take a vote on this, because when we take a
vote on it, it's going to be codified. It's too late. We'll have to go back to amend an
ordinance. I would rather get it right the first time.
Page 31 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
The last thing -- and I have many other questions, but the last one to you, Vanessa, is
again, if the Build America agenda is passed in Washington, will that nullify this
ordinance?
SHINMOTO: It will have some impact on the ordinance, and we are working to not have
that passed.
KALIVIANAKIS: Okay. Thank you.
SHINMOTO: Or at least to have it more passed in a more responsible way to really
carve-out some of -- and not degrade so much local authority, because at this point
it's -- in the direction that it's headed, it's basically, you know, the federal -- the FCC has
kind of become a national zoning board. And that just doesn't really seem like a tenable
outcome in terms of how different localities are. And you know, with unique
characteristics, a lot of the authority should remain local.
KALIVIANAKIS: Yeah. And I appreciate that. I do think they're looking for uniformity
and nationally, and not to have to sub -- have every telecommunications company
subject themselves to local ordinances like the ones we're anticipating passing tonight.
So again, thank you for your thoughtful answers.
LARRABEE: Objection. Leading the witness.
John, I just have a couple questions. When was this issue first brought to your desk? I
know it was a long time ago, but do you remember?
WESLEY: Mayor, Councilmember, 2020
LARRABEE: 2020.
WESLEY: I think.
LARRABEE: Okay. Since 2020, approximately -- you don't have to have an exact
number. It's okay if you haven't done a count, but approximately how many meetings
have we had regarding 5G?
WESLEY: No idea. A lot.
LARRABEE: A lot, yeah. And during this meeting right now, we're -- we're not even in
the discussion part, but my notes say that we have three potential amendments still on
the table. There were five that were presented for feedback by Councilman Watts. Do I
Page 32 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
have those notes correct?
WESLEY: I believe that's correct from what I can recall. But I'm sure the councilmember
can --
LARRABEE: Oh, thank you, Councilmember, I appreciate that.
Okay. I think that covers my questions. We can keep pushing.
WATTS: When we build a single-family home, multi-family home, don't we ask for
virtually the same thing? There are some additional things that we ask for here, but we
ask for planning and zoning and setbacks and right of ways, and we ask for structural,
mechanical, electrical engineering. We ask for occupancy. We ask for all of the things
that we have included in here. So this isn't something that's new. We've been doing
this from a permitting standpoint for an awful long time, and what we've done is fine
tune it to be applicable for -- for small wireless facilities. The statement doesn't need an
answer, John. Thank you.
FRIEDEL: Okay. I think we'll move on for comment cards. Do we have any comment
cards, Town Clerk?
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Yes, Mayor. The Town received three online comment cards with
the position of against. And then we have four here requesting to speak.
So we'll begin with Claire Suckman followed by Crystal Cavanaugh.
SUKMAN: Thank you. Tonight you're deciding whether Fountain Hills should bear
three -- actually four serious risks. The first is the value of your homes. Is the mic on?
Okay. I'm starting again. Tonight, you're deciding where Fountain Hills residents should
bear three serious risks. The first is the value of your homes. For many families, their
home is their retirement plan. They spend decades building its value. A wireless
facilities near your home, even 500 feet near your home, can threaten that value
through a decision that we never asked for. Imagine if you chose to sell, fewer buyers,
fewer offers, and being forced to accept less for your home. Even if you never sell, your
investment will suffer, and so will your neighbors. If a facility is seen by your neighbor,
the value of their house decreases.
Research by Bond and Wang found that proximity to wireless facilities can reduce
Page 33 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
residential property values by approximately 20 percent. How many years would it take
you to save that again? If the Planning and Zoning Commission recognized that a four
percent loss can cause serious hardship, why would our town allow facilities even 500
feet near our homes?
The second issue is a 500-foot setback. The proposed ordinance says small wireless
facilities must be three to five feet from our homes. Then it opens the door to an
exception, the public right of way. The right of way is the land along your street, right in
front of your house. That exception could put a small wireless facility just 20 feet -- 20
feet from your door. 20 feet. That's your front door, your driveway, the bedroom
window where your child sleeps, where your child plays, where the radiation from this
facility is emitting into your child's body. That's not a setback. That's a loophole.
Remove the exception. 500 feet must mean 500 feet from every home, with no
exceptions.
There's also an issue of a fire. If a fire occurs on your property that the tech company
puts on who is responsible, you are responsible. The town will not be responsible. Your
insurance will not pay. The tech company might pay part of it. It will be your
responsibility. And if that fire goes on to another property, you'll be responsible for
your property and their property.
The fourth (sic) issue is the human reality. You can't ignore it. When I moved here, I
became extremely ill with electromagnetic hypersensitivity. For six months I lived in the
dark with every breaker on the house -- in the house off. I didn't know if I was going to
survive. I didn't know if my marriage was going to survive. This is not only my story.
Other people in Fountain Hills are ill, concerned. If wireless close to my home or close
to theirs, we may be forced to leave. And where are we supposed to go when wireless
infrastructure has reached even remote communities?
I commend Rick, I commend John. I -- I commend the lawyers who are putting this
together. You have a good ordinance, an ordinance that protects people in Fountain
Hills. What we're asking tonight is clear, remove the right of way exception. Do not
have it. 500-foot setback for every home and 1,000 is correct. Not even 500. Because if
Page 34 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
it's 500 close to your home, your home will be devalued by 20 percent. So this is not
about the health only. It's about the value. It's about the fire. It's about your property.
It's about your financial loss that you will have.
FRIEDEL: Next speaker, please.
CAVANAUGH: Crystal Cavanaugh, Fountain Hills resident. I'm not sure how many here
or at home have actually read the entire packet on this agenda item, but even if you've
just read a portion of it, you will realize precisely why our town and this council brought
in the outside law firm who had the expertise to assist in writing and overseeing this
particular ordinance.
As has been stated for years now, it is a complex issue. The residents in town needed a
well-written ordinance that protects us as a community while still allowing this
technology. And after reading this packet, I wholeheartedly support it, although I
understand others may have some additional suggestions tonight. I too have a
recommendation. Councilman Watts addressed it, but I'll continue with my thoughts
for the record.
Under appeals section 19-1-11, on page 43, it reads in part, "Any person adversely
affected by a decision of the Town Manager or development services in granting or
denial of a permit pursuant to this section may appeal that decision to the Board of
Adjustment." As far as I'm aware, our current Board of Adjustment does not include a
qualified consultant or an expert in this field, and future councils may be in that same
boat. It seems like this would be a vital component during this process.
Under section 19-1-6, review procedures and timelines. An independent consultant is
referenced in part B when it states, "The Town is authorized to retain an independent,
qualified consultant to review any application for a permit for a small wireless facility to
review the technical aspects of the application, including, but not limited to the
following", and then it lists the matters.
The majority of this town council saw the importance of expertise throughout this
process and the careful writing of this ordinance. So I think it is logical that a qualified
professional should be included as part of the appeals portion of this ordinance also.
Page 35 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
Thank you.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Next up we have Larry Meyers. I mean -- I'm sorry. Next up we
have Lori Troller. Sorry, Larry, followed by Larry Myers.
FRIEDEL: We have an IT issue up here. Is Mike in the back? Can he -- can you come
forward while Lori is speaking?
TROLLER: Can you tell I'm thrilled. Good evening Council, Scott and Vanessa. Lori
Troller, resident. Thrilled we're at this point and I have a few issues for consideration.
Starting on Chapter 19-1-3, General Requirements. On page 16, we define the setback
from a debris zone, but we don't define debris zone. So if we could include that in the
definitions.
Also in page 17, we talk about preferred locations. We list everything, but we -- the
schools fall out of that list. I don't know why -- why we lost the -- the schools on that list
and -- oh, that was -- that was something else. Also on 19-3 (sic), page 17, we talk about
the 2,510-foot setbacks. I would like to change the word "main entrance" to "public
entrance."
Page 18, we talk about the height of antennas. We have a minimum height of 8.5 feet.
Can we change that to 12 feet?
Then in Section 19-1-4, design standards page 20, we talk about all sorts of data that can
be communicated on the towers. Can we just call that Title 1?
Then in Section 19-1-5, the application submission request on page 21. We do not have
a balloon test. And considering our definition say that our small wireless can be 50 feet
in height, I think that warrants a conditional test based on height.
Page 25, we talk about acoustic analysts and we do not define what too loud is. So
that's arbitrary. So I -- I would like to get that in concrete. Somebody evaluating that
could have a hearing loss come up and doesn't sound loud to them. I'd love to get a
concrete number on there.
The -- on page 26, we also talk about measuring the emissions from a new tower. It says
get right under the mount point, as close to the antenna as you can. Antennas don't
emit straight down. They emit in a cone. I just want to make sure that we're not taking
Page 36 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
a reading where it says zero. I think the point is not to start at the far end of the
emission. I think they're trying to say start near the pole, but it reads a little funny. I
would just make sure that we're not taking a reading where there is no reading.
Then in Section 19-1-5, the application submission re -- oh, we talked about this. This is
the distances for the facility notification and for the property impact report. I'm going
to leave those alone. And then we already did discuss about the Board of Appeals -- or
Board of Adjustments for appeals.
I do want to mention for Claire's sake, there is a call out in the ordinance for ADA
considerations that is there. That was not mentioned. That's -- she needs to be aware
of that. And boy, do I want to give my sincere thanks to John. I can cry literally. John
Scott and Vanessa it's a fantastic product. Thanks.
FRIEDEL: Next speaker please.
MEYERS: Council, expert consultants, Mayor. So I'll answer Hannah's question. It was
five years ago because I was 70 and now I'm 75. So I'm deeply offended that anyone
would think that this could go on any longer, especially since we were so wise as a town
to hire such esteemed experts. And why you would not want to protect every resident.
This was started to protect every resident in this town. Not a couple, not me, every
resident. So why you would want to not? Well, you would short change yourself in any
manner whatsoever. I can't fathom that. And so I fully support you passing this. Make
the amendments.
The ones that I had, I think Councilman Watts, who I would also like to thank for five
years' worth of plotting through really, really hard technical documents, of which I don't
know that there's that many people, especially the loudest voices probably didn't. And
getting to this point, the Planning and Zoning Commission meetings and workshops you
know, I know who was in them because I was at every single one and some of the voices
who seemed to have the most to say about this not being passed tonight were not in
attendance. I repeat, not.
And so I just had one other thing that I didn't know whether Councilman Watts actually
said in 19-1-10 exceptions. It says reviewing authority. Did we ask for that to be in the
Page 37 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
definitions, what the reviewing authority was? Because if we didn't, then I would like to
have that there.
And then I concur with the Board of Adjustment has no business even being in the
general vicinity of this complex topic. The reviewing authority should be the final say for
remedies and for also exceptions. So I think Councilman Watts covered that.
And with that, I really hope that as I'm 75 today, I would implore you to give me a
birthday present end this nightmare and move on to other town business. And I
appreciate your time. Thank you.
FRIEDEL: Are there any other speakers?
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: No, there's not, Mayor.
FRIEDEL: Okay. And now we'll open it up for council discussion. And as long as I have
the microphone, I have a couple things I want to say. For me, it was the nail on the head
was preserving town character. I don't know. I think planning and zoning had a dozen,
dozen-and-a-half meetings over the last five years. I was at every one of them except
for one. I was at the workshop. Questions were asked. Information was exchanged.
We've had plenty of opportunity over the last five years to digest this and come up with
solutions and recommendations and hiring this firm and Rick as the liaison for our town
council for this. I can't say enough about what a great job you guys have done.
I have been out talking to residents. 98 percent of the residents that I've talked with
don't want another structure in the middle of their front yard, in front of their front
door. It's just that simple. This is not a Partizan political thing. This is a community
ordinance. That's how I look at this. And the lady that mentioned the 20 percent hit,
she's -- she's spot on. I've talked to a couple of real estate agents who also agree with
that.
And again, if you went to those meetings, you learned a lot, you learned about not in
front of a primary doorway, not obstructing street visibility, impact, insurance
requirements. I had no idea. That's why I went to those meetings. I sat in the back. I
didn't say a word, but I sat there and I listened. And I learned about what we need to
do. And then local control. So it's a good ordinance. I'm in favor of it. And I'll turn the
Page 38 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
mic over to whoever's next in line here.
Councilman Skillicorn.
SKILLICORN: Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Because I want to protect the values of our
property owners, because I want to protect our dark sky status and because I want to
protect the charm of our town, Mr. Mayor, I'd like to ask if Councilman Watts would like
to make a motion with the amendments he was talking about, like including the Board
of Appeal and -- Board of -- instead of having the Board of Appeal having the town
council, the 300-foot, the 500-foot. If you want to make that motion, I will happily
second it.
WATTS: It's too lengthy to read again, but I'm going to give the notes to John so he can
integrate them in too. So I would -- I would like to move for -- to move forward with the
approval for the ordinance.
MCMAHON: Aren't we still talking about it?
WATTS: We are. We are. And with the caveat that I'll give John the -- my notes on the
appeal, the expert, the review, we answered senior, the noise component identifying
decibel levels and manufacturer specifications, the 300 versus 500. That's a consistency
thing. We talked about that. That was reviewed. And the clarification on the 1,000
feet, all those are on my notes. And so rather than re-read them, I'll give them to you to
incorporate. And that would be my motion to move forward.
SKILLICORN: I will second the motion with the amendments included.
WESLEY: Mayor, if I may. So Mayor, Councilmember, so Ms. Troller had a number of
items on her list. Many of them were the same, but a few were a little bit different, I
believe. So were any of those items to be included or not?
WATTS: Frankly, I thought the majority of the items that were include -- that were
mentioned were already included.
WESLEY: Most of them are.
WATTS: They were already addressed, and there was one or two that I don't think we
can address. We kind of belabored them. The range of impact on housing is 4 to 20
percent. So there's a lot of things that we've already addressed in – in -- before we got
Page 39 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
to this point. So I think –
WESLEY: Just want to make sure that was clear.
WATTS: -- I think you'll agree with Mayor.
WESLEY: Okay.
FRIEDEL: Hannah.
LARRABEE: Thank you, Mayor. I just had a short spiel for the few who are -- who are
newer to the issue, might be wondering why we're doing this. What is the big concern?
Why does it have to be so complicated? While we are absolutely a pro technology
community, there's something to be said for ensuring that there remains a balance
between private and public interests. An example of that, I think I've done this spiel in
one of the last meetings that we've had about 5G, but I have the dates this time, so.
In the 1880s when Thomas Edison was wanting to roll out electricity to the nation,
really, the original direct current system required a local -- would have required a local
power plant in every neighborhood. Let me repeat that, not every town, every
neighborhood would have needed a power plant in order for that to work. It wasn't
until 16 years later that that was no longer the up-to-date technology, made the DC
moot. If we had built those out all over the country, we would be stuck with a bunch of
dead power plants that then had to be cleared out and that land was forever graded.
What we're talking about today is something similar with small cell wireless. It is the
most up to date technology for now. Have you noticed how much your phone has
changed in the last 15 years? How much your computer has changed in the last 15
years? If we were to allow these to just build wherever they wanted in the name of
progress, we might end up looking really silly with a bunch of antennas in people's
yards. So that is the reason that I have been so hawkish on this issue. Why this has
been a conversation for five years. I want to be pro-technology, but -- and pro, you
know, technological process, but also wise about our town's resources and about
protecting our public. So thank you.
KALIVIANAKIS: Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Yeah, at this point, I know it did come up during
the call -- the law firm that -- the Scott McCollough Law Firm that was chosen. I just
Page 40 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
want the people of Fountain Hills to know that this law firm is an advocacy law firm who
is involved with the Children's Health Defense Fund. They are anti-federal activancers
(phonetic) – activancers vaccinators. They have been in the 5G industry asserting that
exposure to this technology is debilitating, causes damage to DNA, reproductive
orgasms, blah blah, blah. This isn't just a neutral law firm that has come here to write a
responsible ordinance. It's -- they're an advocate and they're pushing this to the very
limit. And I am quite sure that we are going to run afoul of the law.
The agreement also provides that McCollough Law Firm will be acting on behalf of more
than one party in the same manner, and describes the venture with Fountain Hill as a
joint endeavor. I'd love to ask him about that. So it seems like we are being involved in
a broader strategy to push back against this kind of technology, and I think the people of
Fountain Hill should know this is a little bit of a lab experiment.
I would -- if I could ask them, could they respond unequivocally that every deadline,
every fee, every approval requirement, every renewal provision, every termination
provision and relocation provisions in this document would be consistent with A.R.S. 9-
591 through 9-599 and applicable federal law. If so I would like for them to identify the
statutory authority for the provisions that give this town broader discretion than those
prohibits -- those prohibited under statute and federal law. I know that's a difficult
question. It's one we can't answer tonight, but those are the questions that need to be
answered before we go forward, that they can verify that we have the authority to do
what we're doing here tonight, because, in my opinion, we don't.
FRIEDEL: Peggy.
MCMAHON: Thank you very much. It has been a long time coming, and there's a lot of
reasons for that and not alone just the complexity of this matter and how complicated it
is. But I still have serious concerns with this ordinance, not just what was said tonight,
but just in general. Like Brenda said, when we hired this law firm, there was -- we
discussed it and we had significant concerns about potential conflicts of interest, the
scope of the engagement, the attorney's position regarding 5G health and
telecommunications and other provisions. To me, they weren't adequately addressed.
Page 41 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
But here we are. We now have a over 40-some to 50-page ordinance before us that
raises a lot of questions that people have been asking and addressing.
But I have a question, and I don't mean to put Mr. La Sota on the -- on -- on the hot seat,
but have you completely reviewed this legal document because you are now our current
town attorney? And I want to know if I can go to you and talk to you about this
document that you'll have -- you'll -- that you'll be able to have answers for me.
LA SOTA: Mr. Mayor -- Mr. Mayor and Councilwoman McMahon, I have reviewed the
document. I am comfortable speaking with you about it. But obviously, we've retained
people who deal specifically in this matter, so I'm happy to talk to you any time.
MCMAHON: Okay.
LA SOTA: And -- but certainly I think you should utilize the consultants as well.
MCMAHON: The consultant is not my attorney. You're the town attorney, and I rely on
you for advice. Historically, what has happened when we see such a complex
document -- legal document come through, we get an email from the town attorney
letting -- you know, and we usually have an E-session. Go through it, you know, letting
us know pros and cons, et cetera. He addresses questions and then it comes before
council. I feel like that has been completely missed, and I don't feel comfortable moving
forward with it. And that's not an insult to you. It's just what we have done in the past
with something of this complexity.
And I've reviewed this ordinance and I've identified over 25 or so problems with it. And
I'm not a telecommunications attorney. These are questions that raise conflict of
interest laws, et cetera, conflicts with federal and with state laws. And I'm concerned
with that. They haven't been answered, which is precisely a point because I think given
the complexity of this and yes, we have a consultant, however, I think we may want to
consider hiring an independent land use attorney to review this as well.
I'm also concerned about provisions that appear to be overly burdensome for the
telecommunications providers because -- and we do -- certainly we have an obligation
to protect our town and its residents, but we also have to make sure that regulations
remain within the limits established by federal and state laws, because, after all, the
Page 42 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
federal government does regulate the telecommunications and we don't want to
effectively prevent or have a requirement that effectively prevents or is -- unreasonably
restricts any telecommunications provider from doing something that federal law
protects it from doing. I mean, we do have a letter from AT&T. They have threatened a
lawsuit. I would hate to have to be stuck for years in litigation over this.
Also there's just a lot of legal consequences with this in adopting it tonight. And there is
also a timing issue we need to consider. The FCC is moving forward with changes in its
rules concerning state and local requirements affecting deployment of high speed wire
infrastructures under Section 253 of the Communications Act. And if those federal
changes are expected -- they are expected very soon. And so I believe it would be
prudent on our part to understand these first before finalizing such a comprehensive
and complex ordinance. Yes, I've heard about time. I've been involved with it as well. I
understand and recognize our community's needs, but my concern is there were so
many things brought up tonight about this that are unclear, and they're significant that
they need to be addressed. And I still have a ton of questions that we don't even have
time for tonight.
So I really wish that we would consider tabling this item, you know, addressing the
amendments, addressing the concerns, maybe get another expertise in before we pass
such a monumental document that is -- affects all of us and that we know the FCC
governs and is going to rule on very, very shortly.
And yes, I heard the consultant say they're going to fight this and they don't want it, but
that doesn't mean that that's going to happen. I have a feeling it is going to happen,
and I don't want to have to come back here again and spend five more years trying to
amend an ordinance that we could wait a little bit and have it be complete and better --
more applicable to our town. Thank you.
EARLE: Thank you, Mayor. I want to thank Rick for all the work he did on this, and I
appreciate the motion he made in the -- with the amendments to it. I do just want to
clarify for the first person who came up and spoke, she's not here anymore, but I do
believe that there is not an exception for the right of way in front of someone's home.
Page 43 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
It would be the 500 feet; is that correct? So she said she wanted us to do an exception
for the right of way in front of someone's home, but that's already been addressed. So
I'm saying that for her. Thank you.
LARRABEE: Mayor, I apologize. I know that we have a motion on the table already, but
if it's all right, I'd like to ask a question to our consultant real quick.
Mr. McCollough, I apologize. We didn't really give you a chance to introduce yourself,
so I wanted to ask, how many telecom cases have you been involved in in your career?
MCCOLLOUGH: I lost count in 1990, at which point I'd done more than 1,500
rulemakings in contested cases. I've been litigating almost exclusively in this field since
then. I think I'm probably up to about 10,000 cases now. And --
LARRABEE: Fantastic.
MCCOLLOUGH: -- I have also represented local jurisdictions in many matters, whether
they be a local -- I mean, electric or gas or water utilities. I recognize that you're
wearing a different hat when you're doing that. I've worked for the industry and against
the industry. So I've got a fairly broad and wide experience in this -- in this field.
LARRABEE: Thank you. And this specific role that you're taking for us, how many
municipalities or I don't even know states even have you assisted in similar ordinances?
MCCOLLOUGH: I'm going to have to let Vanessa answer that question. I think she's got
the exact count rather than I.
LARRABEE: Okay.
SHINMOTO: Yeah. We have assisted at least -- Scott says at least 12 over -- over his
career and within the past, you know, six months we've assisted two or now three, in
fact. So -- and throughout the country.
LARRABEE: Thank you.
SHINMOTO: And one other -- one other ordinance is -- is a municipality as well.
LARRABEE: Thank you, Vanessa.
And back to Mr. McCollough. I know you've been on both sides of the telecom industry
for a long time. Do you have an estimate of how many -- how many cases or ordinances
that you've assisted in, how much of that experience recently has been specific to small
Page 44 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
smell -- mall cell wireless?
MCCOLLOUGH: Most of the applications these days are for what meets or is claimed to
be a small wireless facility under the FCC rules. There are very few macros -- macro
towers 50 feet or more being proposed. They still come – come, but for the most part
it's small cells is where the game is being played right now. I would estimate 85 to 90
percent of the applications we touch involve small cells.
LARRABEE: Okay. Thank you very much.
FRIEDEL: I have a question for our town attorney. Mr. La Sota, would it be a fair
statement to say that lawyers can have different views on all kinds of other topics and
still be an expert with small cell ordinances?
LA SOTA: Certainly, Mayor. And the thing about attorneys is they obviously have ethical
obligations to this council. So I mean, they -- they are your attorney. I'm your attorney,
but so -- so are they. Just as when you hire someone. I know we heard about a case
that was won today, I think by -- by Justin Pierce. And -- and he was your attorney too.
So they -- all of them have ethical obligations to act as -- as directed by you. And -- and I
think they're taken very seriously.
FRIEDEL: Thank you. Penny.
MCMAHON: Thank you very much. I wasn't insulting anybody or making a question
about whether or not you're being ethical. That wasn't my question. And thank you to
the consultant. I appreciate the years of your expertise. However, it doesn't erase or fix
the fact that we have questions. There is questionable conflicts of law in the
documents, questionable errors, questionable cut and paste with other jurisdictions,
paragraphs, et cetera. So while your expertise on it, we still have questions about
making this particular document fit in our unique town of Fountain Hills and have it be
the right document for it. So thank you very much.
LARRABEE: Thank you, Mayor. I just wanted to ask if we could take a few minutes to
give my fellow councilwomen the opportunity to ask her questions.
FRIEDEL: Okay. So I believe we have a motion and a -- we have a motion and a second;
is that correct?
Page 45 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
EARLE: Yes.
FRIEDEL: Can we get a roll call vote, please?
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Sure. Councilmember Skillicorn?
SKILLICORN: Yes.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember Larrabee?
LARRABEE: Aye.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember McMahon?
MCMAHON: Nay.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember Kalivianakis?
KALIVIANAKIS: Nay.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember Watts?
WATTS: Aye.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Vice Mayor Earle?
EARLE: Aye.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Mayor Friedel?
FRIEDEL: Aye.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Motion passes five to two.
FRIEDEL: Thank you. We'll now move on to our regular agenda item 9b. Rachael.
GOODWIN: Thank you, Mayor. I'm going to pass this on to John Wesley again. This is a
companion item to this one we just finished. So John.
WESLEY: Sure. Yes. Mayor and council, as I mentioned earlier in the previous
discussion, as part of adopting the small wireless ordinance back in 2018, it was
accompanied by a number of other documents to help implement that ordinance at the
time, the wireless facility lease agreement, the right of way design standards and
guidelines, as well as the standard terms and conditions documents.
As part of this process Vanessa and her team have looked through those documents for
any updates that might be needed. We didn't identify any initially, but as we continue
to look at how the ordinance is being implemented, the -- is a provision in that
document that need to be updated whether we make any other changes or not. And
Page 46 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
that is provision in section 6.9 that requires submission of hard copies and a certain
number of hard copies of a document. We don't do hard copies anymore. We do all
electronic. And so this is simply updating that terms and conditions document to reflect
that change in how we handle applications today, that they're all electronic. And so
staff recommends approval of this resolution to make that change to the terms and
conditions.
UNIDENTIFIED SPEAKER: Oh, sorry.
FRIEDEL: Penny.
MCMAHON: So this is solely to change the application process to match updated
website and make it electronic.
WESLEY: (Indiscernible) .
MCMAHON: That's all this is?
WESLEY: Right.
MCMAHON: Thank you so much.
FRIEDEL: Vice Mayor.
EARLE: I would like to make a motion to approve as written.
LARRABEE: Second.
FRIEDEL: Before we get that far, are there any comment cards, Town Clerk?
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Yes, Mayor. The Town received two online comments with the
position of against and one request to speak from Larry Meyers, which he has declined
now.
FRIEDEL: Okay. Thank you. So we have a motion and a second. Oh, hold on. Go
ahead.
WATTS: John, I assume that some of the -- the things that we discussed as far as the
change to the ordinance, the inclusion of the -- the elimination of the Board of
Adjustments, Town Council, those sorts of things that are on my list, I'm going to give
you, will also be incorporated into the definition, such as the noise and a couple of other
things here. So is that a fair assumption?
WESLEY: Yes, Mayor, Councilmember, we'll look at what all those would be and what
Page 47 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
makes for a complete, accurate ordinance.
WATTS: Perfect. Thanks.
FRIEDEL: Okay. We have a motion and a second. Can we get a roll call, please?
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember McMahon?
MCMAHON: Aye.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember Watts?
WATTS: Aye.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember Skillicorn?
SKILLICORN: Yes.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember Kalivianakis?
KALIVIANAKIS: Aye.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember Larrabee?
LARRABEE: Aye.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Vice Mayor Earle?
EARLE: Aye.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Mayor Friedel?
FRIEDEL: Aye.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Motion passes seven to zero.
FRIEDEL: Thank you.
Agenda item 9c is regarding possible sale of town owned parcels at various locations.
Rachael.
GOODWIN: Thank you, Mayor. We're going to shift topics but not presenters. This is
another John item. It's kind of a John night tonight. But yes, as mentioned back in
December of last year, this council asked us to look into the potential of parcel sales
based on, you know, potential town usage versus the, you know, ability to liquidate
them. John has brought one back previously. He took a broader look at it and is
bringing several back for consideration this evening. John.
WESLEY: So yes, Mayor. Thank you, Town Manager. So as was stated back in
December of '25, we received some direction to begin looking at this topic of various
Page 48 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
town parcels that weren't really needed by the town and could possibly be sold. We
brought you one specific example back in March, and you directed staff to move
forward with that particular parcel. And we're in that process. It's a little bit of a slow
process, but we are at the point of getting the property surveyed and the plat created so
that those could move forward for sale.
You, at that time, directed us to look at other properties. And in doing so I've identified
five others for discussion this evening to get direction on, to see if you'd like us to move
forward with any of these. So with that, go through them one at a time here and see
what direction you have.
So one is here on North Del Cambre. It's a small area adjacent to a couple of lots. We
acquired this property back in '97. It's above the floodplain. No town department has
identified any particular use for this property. Right now, it's just something for us to
maintain to some degree. It could easily be subdivided into two lots that would be of
similar size to the ones adjacent to it. I mean, I don't know if you want to do any
discussion as we go, or wait till the end on each of these to get the direction, but we can
do it either way.
FRIEDEL: I think we'll let you get through with your presentation.
WESLEY: Okay. Then the -- the next one is here off of Greystone and Sycamore. There's
an area again that's above the actual floodplain of the lots there. The town acquired it
in '97. The -- I've taken liberties to draw a shape on this map of what a lot might be, if
we move forward with this and get some actual survey work done. The shape may
change a little bit, but the shape of that size is comparable in size to the other lots in the
neighborhood and fits the zoning requirements. But it's -- because the zoning only one
lot really is all that would fit in this particular area.
On Sunburst along the south side there, we've got this area we acquired in 1995. The
town manager noted with this one, there is some consideration at one point in the past
with the property owner in the area of donating some -- if I have the – correct -- correct
me if I'm wrong, potentially donating some of that vacant land to the southwest, to the
town, and then maybe some of that becomes a park. So maybe there would be a need
Page 49 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
for some of this land for access. But other than that, and that's a lot of ifs and maybes,
there's no current actual planned town use for these lots, and is of a size that it could be
subdivided into four lots of similar size to those adjacent to it along that south side of
Sunburst.
Moving to the other side of that wash there along Palomino, we have one lot of similar
size to the other ones adjacent to it. Again no identified town use. It's a pretty steep,
which is probably one of the reasons maybe it wasn't kept for a lot to begin with, but
you can see the similar topography on the adjacent lots and they built. So again, there
may be some opportunity there. Somebody might be interested in that lot.
And then over on Aspen -- Upper Aspen there's a track there along that wash that is
above the floodplain. Reviewed that carefully with a town engineer. And there's an
area there that could easily be subdivided into three lots of similar size to the ones
adjacent to it across the street.
And those are the lots that we've identified at this point. So again, we're seeking council
direction on any or all of these and move them forward in a process.
SKILLICORN: Thank you, Mr. Mayor. My preference would be to leave this as open
space, so I'm not so excited about developing them.
WATTS: So from your perspective, John, there's no future value in keeping these lots?
There's no use that you can perceive?
WESLEY: Mayor, Council, that's correct. As we've looked at it from the town staff,
there's no uses. It is open space for the neighborhoods, but developing for any specific
use, active use, park use, no, there's no particular need. There's just some properties
that we're maintaining.
WATTS: Is there any way to when and if they're sold to have a condition that they have
to retain their existing zoning?
WESLEY: I would turn to the town attorney a little bit, but I would think that could be a
stipulation of sale in the deed that here's your zoning and it can't be changed.
WATTS: I think it's worth considering.
LA SOTA: Mr. Mayor and Councilmember Watts, I think that it could be included. It's a
Page 50 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
contract for sale and I think conditions. I think there's maybe a question about how long
you would -- you would want that for, but that's a -- I would say, a council choice. And if
that's what you want to do, it -- it could impact what you get for it. But that's up to the
council.
WATTS: I think there's a case to be made. And if you go back to Log Lane, for instance,
and Log Lane wanted to subdivide that lot to 17 lots or so, I would hate to see
something like that occur when the residents in the area have a certain expectation. So
I'd -- I'd ask that in consideration at least.
FRIEDEL: Hannah.
LARRABEE: Okay. Thank you. First of all, thank you, John. I know that I was part of the
difficulty on this of asking you to go through one by one, and I really appreciate your
diligence in that. My fellow councilmember actually brought up my -- my main concern,
which was making sure that these lots would keep the zoning of the surrounding area.
So it sounds like there is interest in that. That would be my direction on the topic, but
otherwise that pretty much covers what I was going to say. So thank you.
KALIVIANAKIS: Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Yeah. I think this is a good idea as there are lots
that are useless. If somebody could turn them into productive lots of Fountain Hills, I
think it's a great idea. Maintaining the zoning, a solid idea. You know, if we can
manage. We did put another one on, I don't think it's been sold yet, but you know, if we
can sell some of these vacant lots, to fix roads, buy lake liners, or buy a new fire truck,
it's a good idea. So thanks, John.
FRIEDEL: Vice Mayor.
EARLE: Thank you, Mayor. I just I have three questions. First one is, why these lots?
And maybe because you asked him to look into the lots for sale. My second would be
the estimate of their value. And the third is what would the money be used for?
WESLEY: So Mayor, Vice Mayor, I can answer, I think the first one of those, the others --
EARLE: Okay.
WESLEY: -- are beyond me. So after giving -- getting the direction from the council back
in March to continue looking, I did go through the map rather carefully looking for all
Page 51 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
the town owned parcels and the ones that showed some potential and working with the
Town Engineer, the Public Works Director identified those that were in the floodplain,
so not possible. There were a few that had some deed restrictions that made them not
possible, but was able to identify these five at this point that showed the potential for
being able to be sold. There may still be a few more if we take another look at it, but
this is most of the ones that I could identify.
EARLE: As far as their estimated value, does anybody –
WESLEY: We have not --
EARLE: -- have any idea?
WESLEY: -- done that yet. That would be a next step after -- if the council gives us
direction to move forward and have the appraisals done.
EARLE: Because I just -- and then when we sell them, the money goes to wherever --
goes in the pot.
GOODWIN: Um-hum.
EARLE: So I -- I kind of have a feeling along with Councilman Skillicorn, I like open space
too. So I'm just trying to see, is it value for people in our town to have some open
space, or is it for us to sell and fill all the space?
FRIEDEL: Let me add that. So if you go back to the one where you said there was a park
down in the back side, that was the one off of Sunburst?
WESLEY: Yes.
FRIEDEL: Would there still be access if we sold all four of those or would we need to
take one of those and have access to the back side for a potential park?
WESLEY: So Mayor, so here's the tract along the south side of Sunburst that has --
FRIEDEL: Yeah.
WESLEY: -- potential for four lots. Then there's also a lot over here --
FRIEDEL: Oh, okay.
WESLEY: -- on the next slide.
FRIEDEL: Is that ours?
WESLEY: This is ours too. This is again --
Page 52 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
FRIEDEL: Okay.
WESLEY: -- one on the next slide.
FRIEDEL: So we would have access to -- if we wanted the parks.
WESLEY: So you could --
FRIEDEL: There's some more open space for you. But my point for all this was, we've
got a lot of road work to do. We've got a lot of expenses coming up. Fire truck, other
budgetary busters that are sitting out there that, you know, this -- these lots are in some
really nice areas, and I can't imagine they wouldn't be worth a pretty penny in this town.
And it would really give our -- our budget some relief to be able to move on these and
explore the possibility. I think if we give direction, find out what we're talking about in
the way of value, then we -- we have an idea. But we can get a lot of road work done
with these lots and pay for other essential needs that benefit the whole town. We're
sitting on these properties for 55 years. And somebody said, well, maybe you want to
save them for a rainy day. I think it's raining out right now, when you look at our roads.
We need a lot of road work done in this town. So that's just my thoughts. So I would be
for giving direction to proceed with the process on this.
KALIVIANAKIS: Yeah. I don't need -- know if we need a motion, but if we do, I'll move to
proceed staff to go ahead with the sale.
FRIEDEL: Councilmen?
WATTS: Who said second already?
FRIEDEL: Peggy.
WATTS: Peggy? She beat me to the mic. Didn't use your button, huh?
FRIEDEL: Okay. We have a motion and a second. Can we get a roll call vote, please?
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Sure, Mayor. And I just want to let you know on this item, the
town did not receive any comment cards or request to speak.
Okay. Councilmember McMahon?
MCMAHON: Aye.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember Kalivianakis?
KALIVIANAKIS: Aye.
Page 53 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember Larrabee?
LARRABEE: Aye.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember Watts?
WATTS: Aye.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember Skillicorn?
SKILLICORN: I like the idea of some zoning restrictions, but I would still be a no.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Vice Mayor Earle?
EARLE: I didn't get a chance to ask the question. Are you -- when you say moved to
approve this motion? This here says just one or more of the properties. So are we just
approving the sale of one or more of the properties?
FRIEDEL: More.
WATTS: I think this is the --
EARLE: Because we are researching.
WATTS: Probably more.
EARLE: Well, I'm just asking what was the -- if we're -- are you -- which -- what was the
motion?
FRIEDEL: Yeah.
EARLE: Just one or two?
FRIEDEL: For this, yes.
EARLE: One or two. Okay. Yes.
UNIDENTIFIED SPEAKER: (Indiscernible).
WATTS: No, it's all.
UNIDENTIFIED SPEAKER: All of them, all of the time.
FRIEDEL: To explore, all of them
EARLE: It's just an exploration then?
FRIEDEL: No, I mean --
EARLE: What -- you just said explore.
FRIEDEL: To go through the process.
EARLE: I guess my vote doesn't matter either way, does it?
Page 54 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
SKILLICORN: There's direction to go ahead, so.
EARLE: Pardon me?
SKILLICORN: There's direction to go ahead.
EARLE: Okay. So direction to go ahead, I guess.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Mayor Friedel?
FRIEDEL: Aye.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Motion passes six to one.
FRIEDEL: Thank you.
Agenda item 9d regarding ordinance 26-14, amending the town cone -- code for short-
term rentals. Rachael.
GOODWIN: Thank you, Mayor. Our short-term rental ordinance has been in effect for a
number of years. It's based off of the statewide adoptions that were done in 2022.
We've now had a chance to sort of operate under our town ordinance. Find -- we have
now sort of identified some of the loopholes, some of the areas where we can tighten it
up, and also areas where we've had some stumbling blocks. So John's going to present
some changes that we'd like to make to this ordinance.
WESLEY: Thank you, Town Manager, Mayor. So yes, as stated, we've been
implementing this ordinance now for a number of years. We've identified some
challenges with it and opportunities for improvement. And so staff's been working for
about a year reviewing ordinances from other jurisdictions, the state statutes, and really
what it says, what the allowances and requirements really are there to propose
amendments with the goals of addressing the problems and particularly approving the
suspension processes. I'll talk about a little bit later.
So just stepping through the sections of the ordinance quickly and some of the changes
that are in there. So there were a few definitions that were added and a few deleted.
Again, to better address some of the topics and challenges that we've had. Some
changes in state statutes, such as the accessory dwelling units, are now specifically
mentioned in state statutes, and when they can be used and not. We have people
trying to do various types of activities that weren't clearly discussed in the code, so the
Page 55 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
banquet space, event centers, those were put in there to make sure those were clear.
We have issues sometimes with -- the problem was not created by the person who
rented the space, but a guest. And so to find a guest and then later put in some
regulations for that. So -- so those types of items, probably the most important one on
this list really is the last one, the verified violation. So we'll talk about a little bit more
later. As we have tried to implement the ordinance and doing suspensions with existing
homes. And we didn't really clearly understand at the time what a verified violation
was. And as it turns out, that's defined in state statute as a ruling by a court on either a
criminal or a civil matter, and that creates that verified violation. So we added those
definitions.
Then moving on to the permit section and penalties. There's a little bit of ambiguity in
there. And so we have situations that are unclear, sometimes, when a person is
applying for a short-term rental permit, are they really the owner? Were they really
authorized by the owner? Do we have multiple designees applying for permits at the
same property and so forth? So try to clear that up and make it clear that each unit
requires its own permit that the permits are issued only to the owner, even if the
designee applies for it on behalf of the owner, the permit will go to the owner. And
there's only one permit issued to an address. And then we also clarified information
regarding the role of a designee that if there is a designee, that they are responsible
right along with the property owner for implementing the permit and monitoring the
conditions of the house.
We removed an item that we'll talk about again, a little bit more in attestation of
notification that's in the current ordinance that requires that as part of registering a
home that you certify or test that you have mailed a notice to all the property owners
that are adjacent. And that's been a problem from the beginning verifying that that has
really happened.
And then evidence of registration with the county. We had in there as an application
requirement. State statute doesn't really allow for that, so we took it out of the
application, but it's still in the code just moved to a different location. And then other
Page 56 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
requirements that were not in the state statute were -- were removed.
We did add some additional provisions to allow staff use of application information for
enforcement purposes, clarifying the owner's designee role in the process, including
when it comes to code compliance. The permit revocation allowing to immediately
revoke if we find that they lied in the application, they didn't meet the requirements.
We don't have to wait and go through another process. And then how to handle a
reapplication after denial or suspension. Those items weren't in the current code. So
again, gives direction on how to handle those items.
In section 864, emergency point of contact requirements. We cleaned up some of the
language there for better consistency. And there was a provision dealing with violations
that didn't really fit, and so we moved it to its proper place in the code.
In 865, we again worked to address some of the problems we've had with some of the
homes in town. We've had the parties and activities that really weren't what we had in
mind would want to see in our neighborhoods. And so we again, we cleaned up some of
that language by defining some terms and clarifying what was meant.
And so here we get to the one on the neighborhood notification again, as mentioned.
The code now requires the applicant to attest that they have sent a notice to the
abutting property owners. They tell us they've done it. Then we get property owners
calling us saying, I never got a notice. How do I know they're there? And part of the
reason for that notice is so that the not only does the neighbor know that it is going to
be a short-term rental, but that gives them the name of the contact person and how to
contact them with a phone number and email. And so it is a problem for the neighbors
when they don't have that.
So because of those problems and state statute gives us another option, and that is to
work with our provider to have a website where you can just go look at a map. And so
that is up and running now, as -- as the town manager mentioned earlier. Here's the
website. And if you go on the site, if you click on any of these dots, you'll get a box
that'll pop up. It'll tell you who the owner is, who the designee is, and what the phone
number and email address is. So if it's 2:00 in the morning, you realize they're having a
Page 57 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
party next door and you want to know who to call. You can go to the website and find
out. You don't have to go through MCSO or anybody else or try to find that letter you
got six months ago, you know, what did it say, is it up to date? They can go right to the
website.
And 866 to 8610, again, there were a few minor modifications. We had to correct the
numbers because we took out a section. So you see that being a little bit different. But
a couple of minor changes here in terms of the proof of ownership. The online
marketplaces allow you the option to get your insurance that way. So if they provide
proof they've done it that way, that's more clear in the ordinance. And we updated the
list of the prohibited activities.
So the big change again was in the permit suspensions. You may be aware a year or so
ago, we had a home in town that was really having a lot of challenges with some
activities that weren't appropriate for the neighborhood. And so we issued them some
citations and-- and then worked to suspend their registration. In doing so we found out
that our code really didn't provide the tools that we needed to go through that process.
So that was really one of the things that caused us to move forward with this. And so
again, we looked at other cities and towns, how they're handling it, as well as what state
statutes allow us to do and -- and develop this new section, it's B and C in 611 to handle
the permit suspension process.
Again, it needs to be clear that we get to this step only after there are verified
violations. And verified violations mean they have been -- they've received the citations
from town staff and we've worked with them. And it's gotten to the point where
they've gone before a judge and a judge has found them guilty or responsible for
whatever it was. So been through all those processes first. And then at that point, in
most cases, it takes three of those before we get to the suspension. But there are some
things that involve a felony that can go after one. So they've been through all that and
then we can get to the suspension. And so it requires notification to the property owner
and the designee to set the hearing and allows them some input on when that hearing
would be. And then the rest of the ordinance describes in detail that hearing process
Page 58 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
and who has responsibilities, how long they can take and those types of things. And
ultimately, the hearing officer, after hearing all the -- the information, can decide a
suspension is appropriate and issue a suspension for 3 to 12 months. 12 months is the
maximum that's allowed through state statute.
And then through the rest of the ordinance, 612 through 616, there are just some minor
changes for some clarity and consistency of language, but no really substantive changes.
So with that Council, any questions you have for me with regard to this?
WATTS: John, do we have a third-party that does this administration after hours? I
know during the day -- daylight hours, our code enforcement can.
WESLEY: MCSO.
WATTS: MCSO does it –
WESLEY: Yes.
WATTS: -- afterwards? And when they do a process -- a server -- serve -- like a process
server, when they leave a violation, nobody's home. Is there some sort of an affidavit
that they fill out that says I've served them?
WESLEY: So Mayor, Councilmember, if -- Lt. Vance may need to come support me on
this, and we'll see. But typically what will happen is they will go and they will witness
the activity if necessary. They will shut an activity down and they will take a report and
they provide that to code enforcement. And code enforcement will be the one that
actually follows up with any citations and on through any court processes.
WATTS: It just seems like historically there's been a lot of loopholes either not
answering the door, much like a traffic violation. And I'd like to see if we can't close
those. So if we've got them covered already, then fine. I just -- I didn't know if we use
third-party and MCSO is a good third-party, so –
WESLEY: Yes.
WATTS: -- thanks.
GOODWIN: Mayor, thank you. I just wanted to take a pause and recognize John and his
efforts in this, because whether you recognize it or not, this has actually been a heavy
lift for the staff because it's not just John, but it's our code enforcement, it's MCSO, it's
Page 59 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
our finance department and our business licensing. It was a -- a lot of moving parts to
get to this and to really identify where the problems were, how they could be fixed.
And it was a lot of -- it was a lot of rabbit holes that we had to go down to get here
today. So I just wanted to thank the staff and everybody that was part of getting this
proposed and before our council tonight.
WESLEY: Yeah, just jump in – in on that. Thank you, Town management, Paul and
Michael from finance. Michael, in particular, he's good at finding those details and
looking them through and helped us work out a lot of those.
FRIEDEL: Vice Mayor.
EARLE: Thank you, Mayor. I'd like to move to approve the ordinance 26-14, amending
Town Code Article 8-6.
UNIDENTIFIED SPEAKER: I'll second.
FRIEDEL: Are there any comment cards, Town Clerk?
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: There are not. Oh, I'm sorry, there are two. Oops. First up is
Crystal Cavanaugh, followed by Larry Meyers.
CAVANAUGH: I'll be very brief. Crystal Cavanaugh, Fountain Hills resident. I just want
to state that I do appreciate the attempts to clarify these and make amendments to our
short-term rental ordinance to meet the neighborhood needs. I love the insurance
requirement, though. I mean, it's a no brainer. Of course, it's a business within a
neighborhood and you should have insurance. Just as when we had dialog about
transitional residences, group homes, it's logical. That is also a business within a
neighborhood, and it too needs insurance. And I'm very glad that you guys passed that.
Thanks.
FRIEDEL: Next speaker please.
MEYERS: Larry Myers, once again, Council, Mayor and Town Attorney. So I became
aware of one of our nuisance creators with regard to the insurance provision on the
community and transitional housing because we require insurance for those businesses,
just -- apparently just like we require insurance for this business that takes place. And
so I just want to call attention to that item that took four years and had the insurance
Page 60 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
provision previously stripped out by a council before you all, with the exception of two
took the dais. So thanks for putting the insurance provision back into that one. Thanks
for having the insurance provision in this one, because residents who are near these
places, they probably would really like to have the insurance. So thanks a lot, I
appreciate it.
FRIEDEL: Okay. We have a motion and a second. Can we get a roll call, please?
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember Larrabee?
LARRABEE: Aye.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember McMahon?
MCMAHON: Aye.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember Skillicorn?
SKILLICORN: Yes.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember Kalivianakis?
KALIVIANAKIS: Aye.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember Watts?
WATTS: Aye.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Vice Mayor Earle?
EARLE: Aye.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Mayor Friedel?
FRIEDEL: Aye.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Motion passes seven to zero.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Thank you.
And the next -- the next item, John, again. It looks like handbills. Rachael.
GOODWIN: Correct. Back in September, we brought forward some proposed changes
for our handbill ordinance. This is the result of that direction. John.
WESLEY: Hey, Mayor and Council, yes. Back September 1st, we had a discussion. You
gave us some direction and town attorney and I sat down and made some amendments
to the code based on what we understood the direction to be. First one was to get rid
of distinction between commercial and noncommercial handbills, all treated the same.
Page 61 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
And the second was to allow all handbills then on occupied properties, if secured and
not visible from the street.
As we looked at that, we recognized a couple other little things we ought to include. So
one is a reference -- the code currently references just U.S. Postal Service. We've got
other delivery services and so forth today that weren't maybe present at the time this
was done before. And we also recognize there are times that code enforcement staff is
posting property or Public Works is posting property for street projects or whatever. So
we want to make sure there wasn't any confusion that those were allowed.
So here is the -- the ordinance then as we are proposing it. The portion about the
handbills being secured was already in the code. So we added a provision that the
handbills are placed out of view from the adjacent public street or sidewalk. So they
can't just throw a bag of rocks on the driveway or whatever with the -- with it in there.
They've got to get it up under the mat or someplace where you can't see it from the
door.
And then again expanded to the Postal Service, to other common carriers and added the
provision about posting property for government purposes. So that is the amendment
that we hope is in concert with what the direction was from the council. And like a
recommendation for approval.
LARRABEE: Sorry.
FRIEDEL: Go ahead.
LARRABEE: I just wanted to make a motion to approve. Thank you so much, John, for
your work on this.
MCMAHON: Second.
EARLE: Second, third.
FRIEDEL: Do we have any -- do we have any comment cards?
WATTS: You got to be quick.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: No, we do not. But I have a question. Who made the second?
WATTS: We did.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: We? Can we just –
Page 62 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
MCMAHON: Unified.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: One?
WATTS: Vice Mayor.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Okay. Thank you so much.
WATTS: The flag goes to the Vice Mayor.
KALIVIANAKIS: Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Yeah, thanks for your presentation. Thanks for
upgrading that. I am -- I'm going to vote no on this. I'm going to repeat what I said last
time when it came before the council. I think that all our seasonal visitors, some people
call them snowbirds, would not appreciate people coming on their property and leaving
a bunch of fliers on there. And that will accumulate over time. And they will be
identified as a place that could be robbed because the people aren't there. Criminals
are sophisticated. They -- they target empty homes, homes, and we are facilitating that.
I think this is a really bad idea. I think that the people should be home and accept the
material or it should not be placed at the house.
And what I said last time is, you know, this is an item that I think all politicians should be
recused from and we shouldn't be voting on this because politicians running for office
all want to put promotional materials on these people's houses. And so we all have an
interest in this, maybe not fiduciary, but an interest in getting re-elected. And so I
would be a no on this.
LARRABEE: I had a question. If -- if the entire council recuses themselves, how do we
pass something? Thank you.
FRIEDEL: Okay. We have a motion and a second. Can we get a roll call, please?
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember Skillicorn?
SKILLICORN: Yes.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember Larrabee?
LARRABEE: Aye.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember McMahon?
MCMAHON: Aye.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember Kalivianakis?
Page 63 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
KALIVIANAKIS: Nay.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember Watts?
WATTS: Aye.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Vice Mayor Earle?
EARLE: Aye.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Mayor Friedel?
FRIEDEL: Aye.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Motion passes, six to one.
FRIEDEL: Thank you.
Moving on to 9f. This is our -- our agenda item dealing with license plate readers. And I
think we turn this over to Allen.
SKILLICORN: Sure. Thank you so much, Mr. Mayor. I did ask to put this on the agenda
because I wanted to balance the privacy rights of Fountain Hills residents and people
who visit Fountain Hills, but also take in consideration law enforcement and making sure
they have appropriate tools. And I had an opportunity to work with Jen Wright on this.
She put together an initial ordinance. We went and sent that ordinance over to Senator
Hoffman and a privacy expert, Eric Fowler, and made a few strategic changes to it. And
basically, I think this works out a balance that protects the privacy of people, but it also
gives law enforcement, which we love, and we respect, the tools that they need to do
their jobs.
And Mr. Mayor, I'd like to thank you for your transparency on this and willingness to
work on this. It is -- it is good to put this forward. And -- and additionally, I know we,
you know, met the public posting requirements. Actually, we were ahead. You know,
we had publicly posted for more time than what the state calls for. But even a couple
weeks ago, I made sure that not only privacy activists, but the people of Fountain Hills
had access to the ordinance so they can read it themselves. And they actually had that
for a couple of weeks before it was even, you know, posted on our website. So yeah,
that's -- that's kind of the details of it. I'm more than willing to entertain questions or --
and go over the details.
Page 64 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
FRIEDEL: Councilwoman?
MCMAHON: Thank you very much. I take exception to this being on the agenda
tonight. If you think about it, council acts as a body. It makes policy and acts on behalf
of the town through action taken by a majority vote as required. After proper notice,
discussion and consideration during a council meeting, a majority of councilmembers
present are required to direct the town attorney to take an action, including making
policy, including drafting ordinances, initiating litigation or performing other legal
administrative work, and that direction must occur after proper notice and full public
discussion of the matter before council takes action.
Three councilmembers, acting individually, cannot direct the town attorney to take such
legal action, and that is precisely why executive sessions and properly notice meetings
are available when council actions are required. Accordingly, the last meeting, three
council people directed the town attorney to draft this ordinance and that direction, it
was improper and therefore the ordinance should not have been drafted or presented
for council's consideration tonight.
And there's also a separate misuse of the process that taints this item. Council is
required to discuss properly notice matters, particularly ordinances, as a body, before
taking action or directing the town attorney to perform legal work. And in this instance,
even the mayor informed the council that this process has been misused and that
procedural defect, it cannot be undone simply after the fact and by placing this on the
agenda. And due to the improper way this item came before council, I don't think
council should discuss it or consider it tonight.
And in addition, there's a further problem. The matter that is noticed was noticed about
automated license plate readers only. The proposed ordinance, however, goes beyond
automated license plate readers and includes privately owned recording devices located
on private property, among other provisions. These additional subjects were not
properly noticed for council regardless of Mr. Skilli -- Councilmember Skillicorn handing
out this proposed ordinance that was misdrafted in my opinion. The discussion or
action on matters beyond what was properly noticed in the agenda violates open
Page 65 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
meeting laws, and I don't want to take that chance of that happening.
For all these reasons, the improper direction to the town attorney, the misuse of the
legislation and council process, failure to properly notice the full scope of the proposed
ordinance and the fact that there is absolutely no direction for council to act, and the
notice and agenda item, I believe council cannot discuss or consider this item. I think it
needs to be removed from the agenda and -- and taken up, possibly at a later time.
There is no direction. It's just like it was an afterthought and added, and there's
absolutely -- you're not asking council to do anything with this. And it is improper for
three council people to direct the town attorney to draft an ordinance. Thank you.
FRIEDEL: Vice Mayor.
EARLE: Thank you, Mayor. I would like to move to adopt the ordinance as presented
with the deletion of the entire whereas paragraph referencing other jurisdictions that
have taken similar action. My reasoning for that is I believe our ordinance should stand
on its own merits based on what is appropriate for Fountain Hills.
LARRABEE: Second.
MCMAHON: It's a violation and breaking laws.
FRIEDEL: Brenda.
KALIVIANAKIS: Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Yeah, I've got concerns about the way this thing
and the process by which this reaches tonight as well. And I -- and I will allude to the
Mayor's email on this, but you know, what -- what they've managed to do here tonight
is they can take three council members, direct the town attorney to write an ordinance.
They can put that ordinance on an agenda. And then without even discussion, except
for a call to the public, they could call the question, have no debate. So it simply goes
from three for future item. They write -- they write it, they call the question. And the
public is completely kept out of the process. That's unacceptable. When we put
something on the future agenda, it should be agendized. The town manager should
discuss it with the mayor, and we should open it up for discussion so people know what
we're voting on. In this case, I don't know what notice Allen personally gave, but this is
not a good process. It's bad public policy.
Page 66 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
In the mayor's letter, he's -- last night it was requested that we have the town attorney
or staff write an ordinance for Flock cameras, one example. This is not how the process
works. We should have an open and transparent discussion first, and the direction to
staff and the town attorney for action. I applauded the mayor for doing that.
We have an October 6th agenda Flock cameras for discussion and direction. After this
happens, and direction will be given to our council staff or the town attorney will follow
the direction, will follow up with action a vote. We must be transparent and also have
the public weigh in as well. I thought that was a thoughtful statement. I thought it was
well delivered. I thought it did make the newspaper. People saw that and it was just
how things should be. We have -- we have just -- this is a bad process and I don't like it.
And then the other thing I don't like is this is once again, with Mr. Skillicorn identifying a
solution where there is no problem. If I wanted to put a license plate reader or camera
on public property, I would be prohibited from doing it. Anybody would be prohibited
from doing it. You just can't do it. It can't be done. And so if law enforcement wants to
put Flock cameras, they want to talk to the council, talk to the manager, talk to the
mayor, I would be willing to do that. And there's a lot of cases that can be made for
Flock cameras and law enforcement. There are also significant privacy issues too, but
that's a discussion that we should have.
And so anyway, I'm going to vote no for this. I think it's nonsense. I don't like the
process, by the way I got here and I don't think it addresses any issue whatsoever.
Thank you.
FRIEDEL: I'm going to ask the town manager to weigh in on this, because I think there's
a misconception. Our code of procedure actually does allow it to happen this way. If
we don't want that in the future, my suggestion is we need to change the code of
procedure so that it comes for discussion, first. Direction is given and then an ordinance
is written.
Yes, I did send the email because I felt that we needed to discuss it. Well, it got out into
the public, I don't know how many weeks ago.
But anyway Town Manager, would you like to weigh in on that with me?
Page 67 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
GOODWIN: I can certainly do that. I have our rules of procedure pulled up, but I don't
have that specific item. However, in our rules, it does indicate that three with -- a
council member, with the support of two more can agendize something for action. It
does not require it to be brought back for discussion. So there is a technical difference
there. I believe it was specifically brought forward by Councilmember Skillicorn for
action, if I recall, based on my review of the meeting.
MCMAHON: That's for action. They're directing -- they're directing the town attorney to
do something. That's not putting it on an agenda. That's something completely
different. And League of Cities requires the body to act on something like that. And in
fact, our rules do say it requires a quorum. So this is misuse of the process, period.
GOODWIN: And what I would suggest is -- and I can't speak for Jen Wright. I know that
she was here. And --
MCMAHON: She's not here at the moment.
GOODWIN: Correct. So that's why I don't want to speak for her. However, it is my
understanding that she took the initiative to say that she reports to each of you
individually and took that direction.
MCMAHON: No, she doesn't. She reports to us as a body. I know that for a fact.
GOODWIN: So there --
MCMAHON: She doesn't represent us anyway.
GOODWIN: I can certainly let our new attorney chime in if he'd like. However, that -- so
that -- those are the rules that we're -- I'm looking towards in terms of our procedures.
If we would like to change that language so that items are brought forth -- brought back
at a discussion before action, we can certainly make that amendment in our rules of
procedure.
From the other perspective, did you want to chime in, Tim?
LA SOTA: Sure. I also revealed the -- reviewed the rules of procedure, and it does allow
three members to bring it straight to the body. If there's an objection to that, it should
be --
MCMAHON: Can you show me where that is?
Page 68 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
LA SOTA: I can.
MCMAHON: Because I think we're saying that they have a right to agendize something.
They don't have the right to direct –
LA SOTA: Well --
MCMAHON: -- substance like that and setting policy. That's a big difference.
LA SOTA: You know, Mayor -- Mr. Mayor and Councilmember McMahon, I think that
the staff, including town manager, town attorney and the staff, I mean, I think they are
here to assist. You know, I think at some point and it's -- this is something that I think
every -- every municipality has to wrestle with. And I think Phoenix actually has a dollar
limit on -- on how much staff time you can occupy by one councilmember. But I mean,
if you came to me and asked my help to -- to write an ordinance that you wanted to
present to council, I would say sure. And I – I think that is consistent with the -- well, I
think it's a courtesy that would be afforded to -- to any councilmember. I mean, the
same as sometimes you ask the town manager for maybe to do a little research for you
on -- on something. I mean, I think individual requests do have their place, if they're --
as long as they're fairly limited.
MCMAHON: I know, but you're basically saying that only three councilmembers are
needed to set policy and direct that policy be drafted up. That is totally against the
Arizona League of Cities and Towns, and I don't see any rule that says that's possible.
That's completely different than what's required a quorum. We act as a body. And yes,
it was agreed that three people can put an item on the agenda. That's it. That's all they
can do. And this is going far beyond that. And it's irresponsible.
FRIEDEL: Councilman Skillicorn.
SKILLICORN: Thank you, Mr. Mayor. So the motion that was made, I would consider
that a friendly amendment and support it. And you know, furthermore, there's a little
bit of discussion. I -- actually kind of reading between the lines because really the
discussion isn't -- has anything to do with anything of substance. The ordinance was
agendized within the -- not only the letter of the rules, but the spirit of the rules.
There's precedence for this. I have introduced many ordinances. Some of them I've
Page 69 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
wrote a hundred percent on my own. Some of them I've employed like Goldwater
Institute to help me draft.
MCMAHON: We're not the Goldwater Institute.
SKILLICORN: This is not the -- not the first time I've done this. And even though that
was a, you know, rude interruption, I've drafted hundreds of pieces of legislation when I
was a legislator.
MCMAHON: That's not the issue before council right now.
SKILLICORN: So --
GOODWIN: Come to order.
SKILLICORN: So on that point, I'd like to make a motion to call the question.
MCMAHON: I don't think this should move forward.
UNIDENTIFIED SPEAKER: There's no debate just to call the question. So second.
EARLE: I'll second that.
MCMAHON: Poor legal advice.
LA SOTA: Once the -- if you got a motion and a second --
FRIEDEL: We have a -- we have to have a roll call vote, please on the call.
UNIDENTIFIED SPEAKER: Actually, there are public comments. Town Clerk?
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Um-hum.
FRIEDEL: Town Attorney should we handle the public comment first?
LA SOTA: Mr. Mayor, I would hear from public comment first and then a call to the
question is obviously a privilege motion, which would be an order at that time.
FRIEDEL: Okay. Comments, please.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Yes, Mayor. The Town received three online comment cards with
the position of against and two requests to speak.
First up is Larry Meyers, followed by Carol Rogala.
MEYERS: The last. Mayor, Council, I would recommend -- first of all, I wouldn't purport
to know these rules, so I'm not going to speak to whether Councilwoman McMahon is
correct or incorrect, but it would seem to me I'm a simple guy. And heck, this issue has
only been around for ten minutes. Two weeks. We take up issues for four weeks, two
Page 70 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
months, five years. If you want to make Councilwoman McMahon happy why don't you
guys table this and then bring it back for discussion and possible action? And then
Councilwoman McMahon's happy. Councilwoman -- or Councilman Skillicorn gets his
thing in front of you guys. And then you can vote on it. And that seems to be a
common sense, logical thing that I would do after I've heard this since I don't know all of
the details, but you all decide. And that's all I have to say on the issue.
But I do support -- I'll be back to support it when it gets voted on. And so if I were -- if
you're doing it tonight, I support the ordinance. Thank you.
ROGALA: Hi there, Council and Mayor. Carol Rogala, resident. Now, I guess there's a
question as to what's going to even happen tonight. But I am speaking in favor of this
ordinance. The reason being the automated plate readers because they have video.
The video is attached to AI search tools and it does constitute like a mass surveillance
problem. And it's a violation of Article 2, Section 8 of the Arizona Constitution, which is
the private affairs clause, and says, "No person shall be disturbed in his private affairs or
his home invaded without authority of law."
The other issue is Scottsdale has 85 of these, and they have a big war going on. And this
was being brought up in their city council meeting tonight. So I think it was very
prescient of Allen to do this and nip this in the bud before we had any.
And then the other thing was just last week on the 1st, federal judge in Oklahoma ruled
evidence submitted from a Flock camera is inadmissible because it -- it was an
unconstitutional search under the Fourth Amendment.
So going along with some of the conversations I've heard tonight about people being
worried about being sued for various things, that is something that -- that is a concern.
And so I'm speaking for it. And I hope that maybe you should table it and -- and do what
the other suggestion was, but I'm for it. Thank you.
FRIEDEL: Okay.
WATTS: Question for the -- the town attorney. In order of priority, does calling the
question get superseded by anything like tabling the question?
LA SOTA: Mr. Mayor and Councilman Watts, it gets preceded by a motion to table or
Page 71 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
something like a -- like a motion to adjourn would -- would have precedence over a call
to question things like that.
WATTS: My conundrum here is that I was the second -- third party to support this, and
I'm still in favor of it with bumpers around it. And I think there is some concern. So I
would like to table the question to -- till we have some discussion about it. A supporter
of removing automatic license plate readers, I'm in favor of. What they have -- what the
industry has done with them is the violations of the Fourth Amendment and other
things. So I want to see if we can't find a common ground. And frankly, I didn't go and
didn't read this. I thought it was discussion, not possible action. So I would make a
motion to table the question. I'm sorry, Allen.
KALIVIANAKIS: I'd second.
FRIEDEL: So we have a motion to table. And we have a first and a second -- a motion
and a second. I'm sorry, can we get a roll call vote on that?
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Sure. Councilmember Watts?
WATTS: Aye.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember Skillicorn?
SKILLICORN: No.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember Larrabee?
LARRABEE: The wording of this was in our agenda. We're in a public meeting right now,
I vote no.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember Kalivianakis?
KALIVIANAKIS: Aye.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember McMahon?
MCMAHON: Aye.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Vice Mayor Earle?
EARLE: No.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Mayor Friedel.
FRIEDEL: I'm in support of this, but I'm also in support of tabling so we can have further
discussion. So I'm -- I'm yes.
Page 72 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Motion to table the item passes, four to three.
FRIEDEL: Vice Mayor, did you have --
EARLE: Oh.
FRIEDEL: All right. We'll move on to the call to the public.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Mayor, we have no one.
FRIEDEL: No one. Okay.
Council directions to the town manager. Anybody have anything? I've -- I've got a -- I've
got a couple of things.
Town manager, we're going to turn the fountain blue on October 7th in recognition of
the memorial for the attacks in Israel. So that will be October 7th.
And then the other thing I wanted to get on the public record was that Rick pulled his
support for the Sharia law conversation or agenda item. So we will have discussion and
direction on October 20th for that item. So that'll be -- that'll be -- that'll be
forthcoming.
KALIVIANAKIS: Just for clarification, if he pulled his support, would that only be two --
two supporting?
FRIEDEL: That's correct. So under my authority we -- we took it from an action item to a
discussion.
KALIVIANAKIS: Okay. Thank you for the clarification.
FRIEDEL: Yeah.
EARLE: Thank you. My question is then what was just tabled? When does that come
back? The next meeting?
GOODWIN: Usually.
EARLE: Okay.
FRIEDEL: Now, we have future agenda items. Does anybody have anything they want to
put on a future agenda?
MCMAHON: No, I just wanted to make sure we were going to light up the fountain all
those different colors that you said.
FRIEDEL: You can ask -- you can ask that question.
Page 73 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
MCMAHON: Do we get to light up the fountain pink?
GOODWIN: I'm certain we can find a date to -- that makes that work this month.
MCMAHON: Thank you.
SKILLICORN: Motion to adjourn?
FRIEDEL: All in favor?
ALL: Aye.
FRIEDEL: So -- so done.
Page 74 of 75

TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
OCTOBER 6, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
Having no further business, Mayor Gerry Friedel adjourned the regular meeting of the
Town Council at 8:15 p.m.
APPROVED:
____________________________________
GERRY FRIEDEL, MAYOR
ATTEST:
____________________________________
ANGELA PADGETT-ESPIRITU, DEPUTY TOWN CLERK
CERTIFICATION
I HEREBY CERTIFY THAT THE FOREGOING MINUTES ARE A TRUE AND CORRECT COPY OF
THE MINUTES OF THE REGULAR TOWN COUNCIL MEETING OF THE TOWN COUNCIL,
FOUNTAIN HILLS, ARIZONA HELD ON OCTOBER 6, 2026. I FURTHER CERTIFY THAT THE
MEETING WAS DULY CALLED AND HELD AND THAT A QUORUM WAS PRESENT.
________________________________
ANGELA PADGETT-ESPIRITU, DEPUTY TOWN CLERK
Page 75 of 75