1020.2026.TCRS.MEETING.MINUTES

Town of Fountain Hills — Town Council (2026-11-17)

View PDF Meeting page

Extracted text (via pymupdf_layout) 156814 characters
TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS
MINUTES OF THE REGULAR SESSION
OF THE FOUNTAIN HILLS TOWN COUNCIL
October 20, 2026
A Regular Session of the Fountain Hills Town Council was convened at 5:31 p.m.
Members Present: Mayor Gerry M. Friedel: Vice Mayor Gayle Earle;
Councilmember Rick Watts; Councilmember Peggy McMahon; Councilmember
Brenda J. Kalivianakis; Councilmember Hannah Larrabee; Councilmember Allen
Skillicorn
Staff Present: Town Manager Rachael Goodwin; Town Attorney Timothy La
Sota; Deputy Town Clerk Angela Padgett-Espiritu

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
Post-Production File
Town of Fountain Hills
Town Council Meeting
October 20, 2026
Transcription Provided By:
eScribers, LLC
* * * * *
Transcription is provided in order to facilitate communication accessibility and may not
be a totally verbatim record of the proceedings.
* * * * *
Page 1 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
MAYOR FRIEDEL: I'd like to call this meeting to order. Would you please rise for the
Pledge of Allegiance?
ALL: I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America, and to the republic
for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Thank you. And if you choose to remain standing -- is Pastor Keith
Pavia (ph.) here tonight? I don't see him in the crowd, so what we'll do is we'll take a
moment of silence. Thank you.
Town Clerk, could I get a roll call, please?
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Mayor Friedel.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Present.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Vice Mayor Earle.
EARLE: Present.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember Kalivianakis.
KALIVIANAKIS: Here.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember Watts.
WATTS: Present.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember Larrabee.
LARRABEE: Here.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember McMahon.
MCMAHON: Here.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember Skillicorn.
SKILLICORN: Here.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: All is present. We have a quorum.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Thank you. We'll move on to the summary of our current events by
the town manager.
Rachael?
GOODWIN: Mayor, thank you. Given that this is our last meeting until November 17th,
we won't be meeting on Election Day. I have quite a few updates that kind of covers
that time frame, so bear with me.
Page 2 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
All right. Starting off first, I want to take a moment to recognize Councilmember Rick
Watts on your appointment -- you look surprised -- on your appointment as our next
vice mayor as of November 1. Congratulations. We appreciate your willingness to take
on this additional leadership role, and look forward to working with you in this capacity.
And a special thank you also to our outgoing vice mayor, Gayle Earle, for your service
over the last ten months. Absolutely.
If you have not already been notified, I want to make sure that we share an important
weather reminder. The National Weather Service is forecasting potentially significant
storms in our area beginning tomorrow and continuing into Thursday. I've seen
different reports. There's different models out there, but it is expected to have periods
of heavy rainfall, thunderstorms, and possible hail with a potential flash -- with potential
for flash flooding, strong winds. And there is a flood watch currently in effect from
Wednesday through Thursday evening.
We encourage everyone to keep an eye on the weather, secure any loose outdoor
items, and use extra caution when traveling. As always, please never attempt to drive
through flooded roadways or washes.
This past weekend, we celebrated and contributed to our annual Make a Difference Day,
so I want to thank everyone who participated. I know several members of our council
were there, so thank you. It's always wonderful to see so many residents, community
organizations, and volunteers come together to make a positive impact on Fountain
Hills.
A special thank you to our Community Services team for coordinating the effort, and to
everyone who gave their time to help make our community a better place.
Tomorrow, Wednesday, October 21st, we'll be hosting another open house regarding
the transition of our new solid waste provider, Universal Waste Systems. We had one
last Saturday, I believe, and this will be the second. The meeting will take place from 4
to 6 at the community center.
Residents are encouraged to stop by, ask questions, and learn more about what to
expect when the new service begins on February 1st.
Page 3 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
On Friday, as long as we don't get washed away, we will have Spooky Blast this
Saturday, October 24th, at Four Peaks Park. It's always a fun opportunity for families to
celebrate Halloween right here in Fountain Hills with games, candy, inflatables,
entertainment, and a costume contest. We encourage everyone to come out and enjoy
the festivities.
Personally speaking -- what's that? I believe it starts at 6. I'm going to give a -- I should
double-check that for you.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: It's dark at 6.
GOODWIN: It is dark at 6. It may start as early as 5. Let me double-check for you,
Mayor, but it is a very, very busy event. It is a very well-attended event. It is a fantastic
time. So I encourage you to come out at any point during the evening.
Also happening this Saturday is the DEA National Prescription Drug Take Back Day from
10 to 2 here in the Town Hall lobby.
It's a great opportunity for residents to safely dispose of unused, unwanted, or expired
prescription medications. It's a simple way to help prevent accidental poisonings and to
keep potentially dangerous -- dangerous medications out of the wrong hands. The
program is free and anonymous, and residents can drop items here, but please note
that no creams, liquids, needles, or sharps are accepted. If you need more information,
you can hop online to the DEA Take Back website.
Election information. I'm sure Bev and Angelo (ph.) would like me to make sure I share
this. It's a quick reminder that the ballot drop box is here at Town Hall and is available
Monday through Thursday from 8 to 5 through Monday, November 2nd. It is upstairs
on our 2nd floor. On Election Day, Tuesday, November 3rd, the Town Hall ballot drop
will be available from 6 a.m. to 7 p.m. Town Hall is a ballot drop-off location only, not
an in-person voting location.
In-person voting at Fountain Hills United Methodist Church begins this Friday, October
23rd, from 9 to 5, and additional voting dates and hours leading up to Election Day. The
community center will also serve as an in-person voting and ballot drop-off on Monday,
November 2nd, from 9 to 5, and Election Day from 6 to 7. Residents can find complete
Page 4 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
schedule, voting location, and hours on the town's website.
All right. Rolling, rolling right along into November. The hiking challenge kicks off
November 1st. It runs through the end of the month. Participants can complete six
designated -- designated hikes or log a total of 35 miles. It's a great opportunity to get
outside and enjoy our beautiful trails and take advantage of the cooler weather. And
you get a commemorative T-shirt.
The Farmers Market and Arts on the Avenue Fountain Hills also returns on Wednesday,
November 4th. That is an exciting day because I know many, many people are excited
for the different foods and products that come with that. The market runs from 10 to 2,
and we'll continue Wednesdays through the season into April. Movie in the Park, an
update. Our last Movie in the Park was rained out, so unfortunately -- but it was
changed. So Toy Story 5 will be rescheduled for Friday, November 6th, at Four Peaks
Park. We hope families will join us for a fun evening outdoors.
And then one final reminder as we look ahead to Veterans Day on Wednesday,
November 11th. Fountain Hills has a wonderful tradition of coming together on the
veterans -- at the Veterans Memorial in Fountain Park at 9 a.m. to recognize and honor
the men and women who have served our country. We encourage residents to join us
and take time that day to honor our veterans, reflect on their service and sacrifices, and
express our appreciation to the many veterans and military families who call Fountain
Hills home. I see a number of you in our audience, so thank you.
Mayor, with that, that is everything I have. That's a lot.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: We have a lot going on in our town. Thank you.
Now we'll move on to proclamations, awards, and recognitions. And I will start out the
evening with the Mayor's Business Spotlight. So I have a lot to share on this Mayor's
Business Spotlight because this -- this restaurant, Phil's Filling Station, has been with us a
long time. So let me give you some details.
I'm delighted to recognize Phil Rodakis, owner of Phil's Filling Station Grill, as part of the
Mayor's Business Spotlight. For nearly three decades, Phil's Filling Station has become a
cornerstone gathering place in Fountain Hills. Since purchasing the business in 1997 and
Page 5 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
later establishing -- establishing it as Phil's Filling Station, Phil has created a place where
residents, visitors, families, and friends can come -- come together over good food and
good conversation.
With its distinctive nostalgic atmosphere, extensive Coca-Cola collection -- anybody that
hasn't been there, you need to stop by there -- and welcoming patio near the Fountain
Hills fountain, Phil's has become one of the community's most recognizable and beloved
gathering places in our town.
What makes Phil's history -- story unique is his journey behind the business. Phil grew
up around the restaurant industry, learning firsthand from his grandfather's diner in the
Bronx, and later working in his uncle's restaurant and bar. He began his own career as a
line cook and worked his way into the restaurant management, gaining the experience
and knowledge that would eventually help him fulfill his dream of opening his own
restaurant right here in Fountain Hills.
In 1994, Phil moved to Fountain Hills with his family. Just three years later, he
purchased what was then Jimmy's Filling Station. By 1999, the restaurant had become
Phil's Filling Station, and over the years, it has grown into a true Fountain Hills
institution.
Phil's has become known for bringing people together outside the dining room. Cruising
at Phil's has created a popular gathering place for classic car enthusiasts, residents, and
visitors, bringing people together to enjoy beautiful automobiles, food, and fellowship.
Events like these add to the character of our community and give people another
opportunity to connect with their neighbors and the community. The legacy Phil has
built is more than just the restaurant. It's also reflected in his dedication to the
community he calls home.
Over the years, Phil and his business have supported local organizations, charitable --
charitable events, community events, and fundraisers. And I know this firsthand
because whenever Phil is asked, he's always there. When business owners invest in
Fountain Hills, they become part of the community, the community's story, and help
make our town a stronger and more connected place.
Page 6 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
Phil's is also a family business in the truest sense.
Phil's children, Johnny (ph.) and Alyssa (ph.), have been involved in the restaurant over
the years, continuing a tradition that began when Phil himself learned the business from
family members of his own family. That sense of family is something customers can feel
when they walk through the doors. Through nearly three decades of service, Phil has
built a business that holds a special place in the Fountain Hills community. It's a place
where neighbors meet, families celebrate milestones, visitors discover a little piece of
Fountain Hills, and longtime residents return again and again.
On behalf of the Town of Fountain Hills, congratulations to -- to you, and thank you,
Phil, Phil Rodakis, and the entire Phil's Filling Station family for nearly 30 years of serving
our community. It's my honor to recognize Phil's Filling Station as this month's Mayor's
Business Spotlight.
Phil, come on down.
RODAKIS: Well, you want me to say a couple of words? You said it all for me. So you
didn't leave anything out. I just want to thank everybody for supporting me over these
years, and hopefully you'll continue supporting us for the rest. Thank you very much.
Thanks again.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Thank you.
The next recognition is our Mayor's Veteran of the Month, and it's my distinct honor to
honor Specialist Stephen Messel, U.S. Army, retired. Stephen was transferred to
Vietnam in August of 1971 and assigned to the 196th Infantry, F Troop, 17th Cavalry. He
was in combat from August 1971 until January 1972. He was transferred to the Open
Mess as their controller and served there until his return to the States in 1972. The
Open Mess was responsible for the operations of all the various clubs for enlisted men,
noncommissioned officers, and officers in the Da Nang area of Vietnam.
Upon his return to the States, he was a clerk in training -- he was a clerk in the training
brigade at Fort Knox facility until discharge in March of 1973. Stephen moved to
Fountain Hills in 2014 and has been an active member of the Fountain Hills community
since then. Stephen was the VFW Post 7507 quartermaster for seven years, earning
Page 7 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
both the All-State and All-American designation. The mayor and council are honored to
present Stephen with this Veteran of the Month recognition.
Stephen, come on over.
MESSEL: I -- I don't know if I really deserve this award, but I'm going to accept it
anyway. I was -- I was the first lottery guy when they were doing away with the draft.
And when I left the service in '73, it was a volunteer army, and they had done away with
the draft. So that was my contribution to it.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Okay. Next we have a proclamation that's going to be read by our
vice mayor for the Cities and Towns Week.
Vice Mayor?
EARLE: Thank you, Mayor. "Whereas the citizens of Fountain Hills depend on the town
to provide essential services that ensure safety, quality of life, and community well-
being. And whereas Arizona cities and towns deliver vital programs such as public
safety, utilities, parks, sanitation, and recreation that enrich daily life. And whereas,
through participation and cooperation, citizens, community leaders, local businesses,
and municipal staff can work together to ensure that services provided by the Town of
Fountain Hills can remain exceptional elements of the quality of life of our community.
"Now, therefore, the Town of Fountain Hills joins with Arizona League of Cities and
Towns and fellow municipalities across Arizona in proclaiming October 18th to 24 of
2026 as Arizona Cities and Towns Week."
And I'd like to present this to our town manager.
GOODWIN: Thank you.
(Pause)
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Thank you.
Next we have October as Italian American Heritage Month. "Whereas the Town of
Fountain Hills honors and celebrates the rich heritage, traditions, and contributions of
Italian Americans whose dedication, talent, and cultural legacy have enriched our nation
and our local community. And whereas Italian American Heritage Month provides an
opportunity to reflect upon and commemorate the achievements of generations, past
Page 8 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
and present, who have preserved and promoted Italian cultural, social, and economic
heritage.
"Now, therefore, the Mayor and Council hereby proclaim October as Italian American
Heritage Month and encourage all residents to join in celebrating the significant
contributions of our Italian Americans to our community." And I believe we have some
people in the audience to come on up and accept this and maybe say a couple words.
UNIDENTIFIED SPEAKER: Thank you, Mayor. Thank you, Town Council and town staff,
for making this possible. And thank you to all the members of my Fountain Hills Italian
Interest Group for coming here. I started this group five years ago in honor of my
parents who came here from Italy, and when I was born, they instilled in me, one, I'm an
American, two, I'm an Italian, and three, to remember and honor all those who made
this possible.
After my father died, I lost almost everything, and it was my best friends and the
members of Fountain Hills Italian Interest Group that were there for me, because that's
what Italian American culture does. We help each other, we help our community, and
most importantly, we remember our traditions and culture, and we pass that on.
So I dedicate this to all of them, to my parents, to Italian Americans who are in town and
all across the United States, to Italians in Italy, and most importantly, to all you
members and residents of Fountain Hills that you live each day as us Italian Americans
do, to help each other out, support each other, support your community, and most
importantly, live each day as if it was its last, because that's what life's all about, is
helping each other. Thank you very much. And grazie a tutti.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: And tonight the fountain will be lit in the Italian colors. So in honor of
your day. And next we have the future vice mayor reading the Veterans Day
proclamation.
Rick?
WATTS: Is that when I grow up or what? "Veterans Day. Whereas the Town of
Fountain Hills proudly honors the men and women who have served in the United
States Armed Forces. And whereas our community is grateful for the sacrifices of our
Page 9 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
veterans in protecting the freedoms we cherish, and whereas, the Veterans Day reminds
us to uphold the values of liberty -- liberty, justice, and unity for future generations,
now, therefore, the Mayor and Council of Fountain Hills hereby proclaim November
11th, 2026 as Veterans Day and encourage all citizens to join in honoring our veterans
with respect and gratitude."
I think we've got representation in the audience for the acceptance of the proclamation.
If you would come on up.
(Pause)
UNIDENTIFIED SPEAKER: On behalf of VFW Post 7507, I'd like to thank the mayor and
the council for this award and proclamation, and we will post it on our Wall of Honor.
And also, we'd like to encourage everybody in the community to come out next month
and support us at the Arts Festival. Thank you.
UNIDENTIFIED SPEAKER: Thanks.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: And the next proclamation we have will be read by Councilwoman
Hannah Larrabee, Red Ribbon Week.
LARRABEE: Thank you, Mayor. "Whereas alcohol and drug abuse continue to challenge
our nation, and prevention requires a united effort. And whereas the East Valley Young
Marines inspire youth to live healthy, drug-free lives through leadership and service.
And whereas Red Ribbon Week gives us all the opportunity to show our commitment to
a drug-free lifestyle.
"Now, therefore, the Mayor and Town Council of Fountain Hills proudly proclaim
October 23rd through the 31st, 2026 as Red Ribbon Week." Red Ribbon Week, sorry.
"And encourage everyone to participate in drug prevention activities this week and all
throughout the year." And I believe we have the East Valley Young Marines here to
accept the proclamation.
UNIDENTIFIED SPEAKER: On button would be good. I just want to say thank you to
everyone who came out, and also don't do drugs, support your veterans, and serve in
your communities. And if you want to support the Young Marines in going to honor
Pearl Harbor this December, you can go to the website evym.org. Thank you.
Page 10 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
UNIDENTIFIED SPEAKER: Do you want to do it now?
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Thank you. And now we'll have a couple of additional announcements
from our town manager.
GOODWIN: Yes, Mayor. Thank you.
You asked what time Spooky Blast was. I wanted to make sure we got this on the
record, that Spooky Blast is from 5 to 8 at Four Peaks Park on Friday. And then I also
had an inquiry. I wanted to clarify too that if we have rains or if you want to take
precautions, we do have sandbags free and available to the public at Fire Station 1,
which is the fire station there along Palisades. They are self-access, but they are behind
the building. We have all the materials there. So if you want to take those precautions,
those are available to everyone in our community also.
Mayor, thanks for those additional items.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: You're welcome. We'll move on now to our consent agenda.
KALIVIANAKIS: Motion to approve the consent agenda.
MCMAHON: Second.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: I have a motion and a second. Can I get a roll call, please?
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember Skillicorn.
SKILLICORN: Yes.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember McMahon.
MCMAHON: Aye.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember Kalivianakis.
KALIVIANAKIS: Aye.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember Watts.
WATTS: Aye.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember Larrabee.
LARRABEE: Aye.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Vice Mayor Earle.
EARLE: Aye.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Mayor Friedel.
Page 11 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Aye.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Motion passes unanimous.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Thank you. And now we'll move on to our regular agenda. So I'm
going to open a public hearing with consideration of possible action relating to
Ordinance 26-12, repealing the Zoning Ordinance Chapter 17, Wireless
Telecommunications.
Rachael?
GOODWIN: Mayor, thank you. This is sort of a follow-up to some of the action that was
taken at our meeting two weeks ago. This is continuing to amend our ordinances so
that they are all in alignment. Most of the action that was taken last week, I believe, is
in Chapter 16. This is Chapter 17. So we're working to, again, create that alignment.
We've worked with a consultant to help revise these and create -- and meet all legal
requirements for these ordinances.
With that, I will turn it over to John, and he can walk us through any other details.
WESLEY: Mayor, councilmembers, good to be with you again this evening. As the town
manager said, this is a companion to a discussion we had at your last meeting, where we
talked about the small -- small cell wireless ordinance covering the -- the smaller towers
and antennas. And this particular ordinance now deals with the rest of the wireless
telecommunication provisions in our ordinances, specifically what we have in the zoning
ordinance.
And so again, just a little quick background, the council directed P&Z and -- and the staff
to work on this a little bit over a year ago. And we began the process with the
commission in March of 2025 and made some progress there, but recognized it would
be beneficial to have a -- a professional group help us with the process, some that were
really well versed in all the legal matters. So the McCollough law firm was hired to assist
in the -- the final review and -- and drafting of these ordinances for the Chapter 717
changes.
We held a work session with the P&Z Commission back in July to review them and get
some initial input from them, and then they held a public hearing on September 14th to
Page 12 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
review that and receive comments from the public. At that time, they were able to take
action and recommend approval with a few modifications that we'll highlight as we go
through this.
So again, the goals that we have here, we want to have a good, robust, complete
wireless network system in town. It's beneficial to our citizens, but at the same time,
we want to have one that is, you know, fully compliant with the laws, but also respects
the local character and needs of the community and protects properties and property
values in neighborhoods, and then has a clear process to go through and is transparent
for the public to follow. So those are some of the goals we had in the drafting of the
ordinance and preparing the modifications that you have this evening.
So I'll take just a few minutes here and step through the major provisions of the
ordinance, and our consultant, again, is available online to help answer any questions
you may have later.
So going through the different sections of the ordinance, Section 1 has the purpose,
intent, and applicability of the ordinance. So this is pretty basic to most ordinances, and
here does set forth the basic requirements and goals that we have, striving to balance
the needs of the industry with the needs of the town. And the -- the backbones of it
were the same, but they added some additional statements in there on the purpose of
what we're trying to accomplish with the ordinance that makes it clearer and more
definitive.
Next, Section 1702 provides definitions. Again, these are important for anybody
administering the code to understand what is meant by different terms in there, or
related things that might not be directly in the ordinance, but -- but impact the
development of the wireless network. 80 new definitions were added compared to
what we have in our existing ordinance. As a result of the P&Z Commission review and
their recommendation, we added a new ordinance -- a new definition for mobile or
temporary towers, and also clarified the definition that we had for the preexisting
towers.
Section 1703 gives the basic requirements for development of a wireless facility. It
Page 13 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
covers a lot of general items as listed here with aesthetics and light and noise and so
forth. It's also a key place in the ordinance where it sets the distance requirements.
Our current ordinance has a minimum standard of 300 feet that a tower has to be from
residential zone districts. This revised ordinance increases that to 500 feet from any
residential zone or use. The section also provides information on the equipment and
buildings that often go with towers, as well as colocation.
P&Z, when they discussed this, they added one additional item here in terms of the
setbacks and put in a setback from daycare facilities and schools, the same 500 feet as
from residential.
Section 1704 deals with the different types of applications we can get. And basically,
there are two types. We can have administrative applications, and those are ones that
are -- are maintenance and upkeep and replacement of antennas on existing towers, as
long as it's really not changing anything about the size and nature of the tower.
Everything else, for new towers or expansions of existing towers that go beyond those,
would come to council.
So one change from the current ordinance is that the current ordinance would allow
administrative review of new towers if they are in a nonresidential area, at least 300
feet from residential. Again, this proposed ordinance would require all new towers to
come before public review. And then the P&Z, again, made one little change here in
terms of further definition of the submittal requirements for temporary towers.
Section 1705 gets into the actual submittal requirements and the review procedures
that take place with wireless communication facilities.
And so again, this one includes some basic requirements that we need to see in each
application, and some things were added, such as the fire safety and decommissioning
and detailed electrical plans and the FCC compliance that we didn't have currently.
Also, in that section, it again has additional items that are required under the new code,
just so we can clearly evaluate the antennas, the towers, their impact in the surrounding
that they will be in.
This section also provides for the shot clocks requirement. So again, through FCC rules,
Page 14 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
there are certain time frames in which we have to review and act on cell towers and
antennas. And so it's very clear on what those are in the ordinance that we have to
meet. If those aren't met, then the towers can be considered approved.
The section also gets into, again, the processing and review of applications. It tells what
specifically needs to be in the application. And you can see here some of the items that
were added over what we have today in our ordinance, just to, again, ensure how it's
going to work with the addition to the surrounding properties. So requiring a property
impact evaluation, looking at the compatibility with the neighborhood, the fall zones,
and other adverse impacts that might be created.
And then this section also includes providing some information with regard to the
factual determinations that need to be made in approving a tower that is compliant
with the TCA, for example, environmental review, historic impacts, and tribal sites.
The next section of the ordinance covers operation and maintenance of the facility. So
once it's there, we want to make sure it continues to be maintained in a way that's
compliant with both the local rules as well as state and federal rules. And so this sets
forth those requirements, as well as requiring some bonding to help cover any
maintenance expenses that might come up, the regular testing, the indemnification and
decommissioning plan.
In this section, P&Z added a couple of items. One was to set the amount on the bond to
be 125 percent of an engineer's estimate, as well as putting in a notice for corrective
action, a cure period, if there is a violation.
Section 1707 addresses nonconforming uses, and so this is for towers that might be out
there that don't conform to the new codes. There's no change to this particular section.
1708 is a new section that deals with retention of consultants. As we have worked to
make this ordinance more comprehensive and ensure it's compliant with the different
federal laws and court rulings and so forth, it's become a little bit more complicated
than the staff has the ability to fully understand and implement. So the -- the ordinance
now provides for the town to hire a consultant, and also provides for the applicants to
put forth a deposit agreement where they pay for the cost of the consultant.
Page 15 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
And so that is the new ordinance. Planning and Zoning Commission recommends
approval. If you have questions, I can try to answer, again, but I believe Vanessa and/or
Scott are available on the phone to provide the real background and detail.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Before I call on the first question, I want to remind the council you hit
the left button to get in queue for questions and discussion. Thank you.
MCMAHON: Thank you. I have a couple questions, or really clarifications, if you don't
mind. I'm concerned once again that this -- this ordinance is premature because I know
the federal communications is coming down with Build America, Eliminating Barriers to
Wireless Stock -- to Wireless Deployments. And that is anticipated to come out, I think,
November 3rd of this year. So I know it's going to change a lot and affect these. So my
concern is this is premature because eventually we're going to have to change this
depending, you know, based on those rules.
Also, I have a couple questions about some of the provisions that you're changing. The
ordinance requires a 500-foot setback from residents and zoning districts. What's a
zoning district? It's not -- I didn't find it in the definitions. So what is intended by that?
WESLEY: So Mayor, Councilmember, it's 500 feet from any residential zone or use. And
so the zoning districts are clearly outlined in the zoning ordinance. So all the residential
ones, single and multifamily, apply, or an actual residential use that occurs on a
property.
MCMAHON: Okay. So it's residential?
WESLEY: Yes.
MCMAHON: Okay. Thank you. Also, I asked you this question before, they're
underground equipment vaults. And there's a requirement in 1703C that requires that
they be underground. So I have concerns about -- because to me, from what I've read
and look at, it increases the risk to utility workers, maintenance personnel, firefighters,
and other first responders.
You know, it's from what it says that -- it says that -- that the risks involved confined
spaces, extreme toxic smoke, projectile manholes, heat buildup, electrocution hazards,
flooding, and potential battery-related thermal runaway. It also has to be in compliance
Page 16 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
with OSHA. So I am concerned about that, if this is true, that there is an increase in a
higher risk with -- with these boxes being underground.
WESLEY: Mayor, Councilmember, I asked the fire chief to see if he might have some
comments on that. We'll see if he can come and provide those. But it hadn't come up
previously as being a concern, and a number of communities do already require vaults
of this type for a variety of purposes that are similar to this.
MCMAHON: So he's not -- he's not concerned with that, or does he want to speak to it,
or no? Or do you want to wait?
UNIDENTIFIED SPEAKER: I think he doesn't.
MCMAHON: Okay. That's unfortunate. When you go through the approval process for
these, it's an SUP, so there's notice, public hearing, et cetera?
WESLEY: That's correct.
MCMAHON: Okay. And also, some of the wording, and this is just one word out of
many, in 1705H to J, it introduces subjective approval criteria. For example, H asks
whether the installation shall inflict a significant adverse impact on neighboring
property. To me, inflict is a negative connotation and kind of judgmental.
So I'm wondering if concepts such as aesthetic impact and compatibility may be better
worded, maybe more soft wording for that than just automatically saying it's going to
inflict. Just to me, inflict is like inflicting harm or whatever the case may be.
But again, I'm not in support of this right now because I -- I know the FCC is going to
come down with new rulings and rules on this. And it's -- it's -- even though there might
be language in there that says this is going to change, you know, accordingly, it -- it
doesn't manifest the changes that are coming up. And you're still going to have to come
back and -- and review it one more time again. Thank you.
EARLE: I have a question, Mayor. Under our rules of decorum, Section 6.4 B,
"Councilmembers, once recognized, shall limit remarks to no more than two minutes."
Are we going to continue to follow our rules of procedure?
MAYOR FRIEDEL: We will follow that, and we will make sure that questions are asked
during the question session and discussion is under discussion session. So --
Page 17 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
EARLE: But two minutes each time, and then everybody gets a turn?
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Yeah.
EARLE: Okay. Thank you.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Two minutes each time.
KALIVIANAKIS: Would that be two minutes for question or -- yeah. Yeah.
WATTS: Thank you, John.
A question, the de facto SUP, when it comes back to council, will we be returned with a
recommendation either to support or deny or approve or deny? And will that also be
supported with an engineer's recommendation at that point, so -- so we're not
completely relying on the council's technical expertise and to understand the ins and
outs of the ordinance itself, but also the engineer's recommendation will come back for
their consideration?
WESLEY: Mayor, Councilmember, yes. The consultants that we hire, with their
engineers and experts in the area, will provide much of the commentary and direction
for council to make their decision on whether, again, to approve, deny, or approve with
conditions.
WATTS: Thank you.
KALIVIANAKIS: Thank you, Mr. Mayor.
Yeah, I'll keep my questions very brief tonight. They're not directed at you, John, but
the attorneys on the phone. I'm just curious.
This has been a product that's been done for many years under the scrutiny of three --
three lawyers, the Campanelli law firm, and now the McCollough law firm. It seems like
that the Trump administration is currently pursuing multiple initiatives, and this is hot
off the presses today, and regulations aimed at removing telecommunications
deployment barriers and cutting regulatory tape.
The status as of today is that the push to remove telecom -- telecom barriers is currently
at its peak legislative and administrative phase, while the executive branch, Donald
Trump, has already used the FCC and the NTIA to unilaterally bypass many legacy rules
regarding telecommunications. The permanent -- permanent codification framework is
Page 18 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
sitting and actively being pursued right now in House and Senate committees and
subcommittees. So my question to you is that, do you anticipate that this national
regulation is going to impact the -- the work product that you've prepared for us today?
EARLE: Point of order. Is that an appropriate question to our -- Mr. Wesley here?
WESLEY: I believe she directed the question to you.
EARLE: Oh, did you? Okay. Thank you.
MCCOLLOUGH: Would you like for me to answer that question?
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Please.
MCCOLLOUGH: This is Scott McCollough. Very well. Yes. The -- the FCC did do a
proposed rulemaking, including on wireless barriers. That was over a year ago. The
comment cycle on that closed quite some time ago. I was just checking the FCC's
agendas. It is not on the October 29th agenda, so it would not be taken up then. We do
not yet have the agenda for the November 19th meeting. We do recognize that the
Commission may act in that proceeding.
I will point out that virtually every local governmental entity and organization that
submitted comments in that proceeding or came out very strongly against it. The
Council of Mayors, Councils of Governments, the counties were all unified in opposition,
and that is likely one of the reasons why the Commission has not yet acted. Now, we do
not yet know what the Commission is going to do. There are some aspects to that
proposal that could be implemented immediately, primarily when it comes to what we
call eligible facilities requests. They had specific rules for those that it could, in theory,
adopt.
The second part of that order was really, however, just a series of questions. And in
order to do the sorts of things that were just described a little while ago, which would at
least potentially take away from local jurisdictions' authority, we do not yet have rules,
and so the Commission, as a matter of administrative law, is going to have to do a
supplemental notice of proposed rulemaking, receive comments, and then take the
matter up again sometime in the future.
So yes, it is possible it will act. The things it can do in the short term are very limited and
Page 19 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
would not much, if at all, affect the ordinance here. Any changes by the Commission
that are more broad could, in theory, affect this ordinance, but that's not going to
happen for quite some time.
KALIVIANAKIS: It's -- it's my understanding that right now there's bipartisan support in
the Congress to push for these barriers to be removed. I know that when we drafted
this ordinance, one of the founding things that we said was we wanted to be the model
code throughout the country, just to set the toughest limits for telecommunications
companies.
I think that's still what we drafted here and what you helped draft. Last week, when I
questioned you, you mentioned that some of this is legally defensible. Sometimes you
said the case law suggests.
Those -- those seem to me words that indicate litigation, that what we're proposing
here has a good chance of surviving litigation. Shouldn't we be writing drafts to avoid
litigation and maybe caution, maybe be more conservative in our approach to this so it
doesn't get litigated and Fountain Hills isn't the one that's going to pay the legal bills for
municipalities, possibly all over the country?
MCCOLLOUGH: I hear two separate questions there. One dealt with what's before
Congress. It was a bill before Congress, and specifically the House, H.R. 2289. It was
pulled down after significant opposition from all of the Democrats and enough
Republicans to make it clear that that bill was not going to pass out of the House. The
Senate has yet to actually propose, certainly vote out of committee, any such bill. So
there may be some sentiment in Congress for taking away local jurisdiction authority,
but there's not a viable bill vehicle for it, as far as we can tell.
Now, in terms of litigation, when you are drafting an ordinance of this sort, you do have
to make some judgment calls. And we had perceived that the organization's marching
orders to us was to draft an ordinance that, as much as was possible, preserved your
authority. That said, we are going to have all and exercise all of the authority that we
have left under federal and state law. The way that we built this ordinance, it preserves
that.
Page 20 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
But it's very important to remember that you will be applying this ordinance in specific
cases, and in each case, you will have the facts of that case before you. Within that part
of the ordinance, there is lots of flexibility for you to make the determinations that you
think best for your community. If you think that a particular facility proposal is a good
idea and belongs there, or perhaps should be approved, but with some changes, you
have the flexibility to do that.
In terms of litigation, and I'm going to try not to get too complicated here, you really
have two acts in the federal statute that are in play, Section 253 and Section 332(c)(7).
Any challenge to the ordinance that you promulgate today would have to go under
Section 253, and the courts that have looked at those treat those as facial challenges to
the ordinance. In order to win, you have to show that the ordinance will always operate
in an illegal fashion. If your lawyers can show that there is ever an instance where it
would work in legal fashion, then the facial challenge fails.
Where any litigation might arise, my prediction, and I've done this all over the country
on virtually every side of this in terms of interests, my experience is that the real,
meaningful challenges in litigation arise after a permit decision. And so again, I will tell
you that when you have a permit before you, you will have specific facts, and you have
an extraordinary amount of discretion under this ordinance to make the findings that
you think best and to achieve the outcome that you think should obtain for your
community. And under those circumstances, I'm fairly comfortable that we can defend
your ordinance.
KALIVIANAKIS: And -- and I -- and I appreciate that. But defending it means letting a -- a
court and a judge decide. And so that's something I'm trying to avoid. I guess my last
question, and this is something that we did talk about two weeks ago, is we were
writing this ordinance under threat by AT&T. They sent a legal letter that said that if
they feel like we are outside the bounds of the norm, that we will be sued. Do you -- do
you think if a telecom giant like AT&T were to pursue this litigation, that this would
stand up on its own?
MCCOLLOUGH: Again, this is a two-part answer. If you write an ordinance that
Page 21 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
presupposes that you will lose any actual permit decision and you back off from
exercising, or at least reserving the authority that you have under federal law, you have
essentially delegated to the wireless companies the decision on where this stuff goes
and what it looks like. The way we wrote it, we -- we keep that power with you. Now,
can I say that the wireless company that may be dissatisfied with the permit decision
will never file a challenge to it? No, I cannot. In fact, I make my living in such things.
They do happen.
But while I'm wearing my hat as a counsel to the town, I -- I -- I will tell you that I am
fairly confident that in a permit case, if you follow the ordinance, if you follow the
evidence, if you make reasonable, well-articulated decisions, I think you will be able to
defend it.
Now, does that mean you will pay costs, the cost of your lawyers? Yes, it does. You
won't pay the wireless companies' fees. You will bear your own. But the alternative is
just giving the store away, allowing somebody else to make the decision. When we
were retained, we were told, you want to be the ones to make these decisions.
Sometimes that means you have to go through litigation.
KALIVIANAKIS: Okay. Okay.
MCCOLLOUGH: Now, on the AT&T letter -- on the AT&T letter, they did not threaten,
because I have that letter, they did not threaten anything about an ordinance. The
letter that they wrote had to do with the moratorium. And when we were engaged, we
said in no uncertain terms, you should not do a moratorium. So the issue that AT&T
raised in its letter, it never came to pass because we agreed with them. You should not
have done a moratorium.
KALIVIANAKIS: Okay. And thank you for that. And -- and what I'll just conclude with
saying that, you know, I -- I understand that this council did hire you to perform certain
legal work, and it seems like you -- you did exactly what they told you to do. So my
question to you on this isn't questioning your work product. I think you did exactly what
the town asked for. So I appreciate that. I appreciate all the effort that you put into this
because I agree that's what you said. You'll do what we ask for and you did it. So thank
Page 22 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
you for your thoughtful answers.
MCCOLLOUGH: Happy to do it. We're privileged to work with the -- with the town
council here.
WATTS: I want to say that a little bit differently, that nothing precludes the applicant
from submitting an application in totality. Nothing precludes the town administrative
staff from looking at it, analyzing it, and sending it up to town council for -- for final
review in conjunction with an engaged expert.
You still have the opportunity to say the juice isn't worth the squeeze in this situation.
We're right on the razor's edge of being able to support or deny something. So right up
until that eleventh hour, total control is still in our hands. Is that a good summary, John,
of where we're at today?
WESLEY: Mayor, Councilmember Watts, I believe that is a good way to summarize it.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Do we have any comment cards? Town Clerk?
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Yes, Mayor. The town received six online comment cards with the
position of against, and we have one request to speak, and it is Lori Troller.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: And you had asked for an additional 30 seconds?
TROLLER: 30 seconds. Good evening, Mayor, Council. Lori Troller, resident. I've got
nine items. First is on page 5. I want to clarify that there is no protection for OTARD
devices. I just want to make sure that is intentional. Page 6, we define adequate
coverage using the verbiage significant gap. I'd consider specifically defining that as a
quarter mile.
On page 7, we talk about the balloon test. It's defined at four hours, then again on page
43 as eight hours and a weekend. I'd like to update both of those to eight hours for
seven days. Also on page 43, about the balloon test, is it's only done for structures over
100 feet. I'd like to upgrade that to 20 feet.
On page 9, I'd like to remove the definition for board adjustment. It's not used
anywhere else in the ordinance. Page 11, there's a -- a numbering issue, a bulleting
issue. We go, it's the last item for colocation. We have a sub-bullet number 2, but
never bullet 1. Page 25, we're discussing the general rules for placement, and we don't
Page 23 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
mention the historic land. I'd like that included there. It is elsewhere in the ordinance,
but not on page 25. Then also on page 25. It's one of those first things. I think Rick was
talking about this. It mentions town council when decisions come back to town council.
I just want to make sure that -- I don't know if we need verbiage that says it's
appropriate that town council also uses consult to telecom lawyers. I don't know if we
want to include that.
It's about page 32. There's discussion on the minimum antenna height at 8.5 feet. I
think that's a cut-and-paste verbiage from broadband stuff. I think we can strike that
whole paragraph. Page 31, we talk about noise, and then we do a call out to code in 11-
1-7. I don't think that's the right code reference where we're talking about 70 -- 70
decibels. And then in the last meeting for Chapter 19, there was an oversight on Rick's
part. My concerns were dismissed, and I look forward to future discussions on that.
And then finally, I'd like to thank the council.
Through this five-year process, I'd like to thank Rick Watts for four years of dedication
and diligence on the topic. You're truly appreciated. I also want to thank this mayor,
Gerry, Hannah, Allen, Gayle, Rachael, for your support and taking the time to
understand some of the technical aspects so you have the confidence to give this town
the technology venue that protects our property values and our safety. Vanessa and
Scott, I thank you for bringing your expansive experience to the aspects from the
national, the circuit of appeals, state, and local perspective and assisting John with
putting this together.
And John, for getting through the thick and thin of this five-year trip, weathering the
uncomfortable politics, and for championing the learning curve on this one, and I think
you can safely retire if you wanted to accomplish writing the toughest ordinance going.
And I can't forget Peg. Thanks for pointing out to me what wasn't obvious to people.
Thank you.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Okay. Before we continue discussion, I'm going to close the public
hearing, and the council can begin discussion, two minutes each.
MCMAHON: Thank you. We just listened to a resident talk and direct the town council
Page 24 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
to make many, many changes in an ordinance, and I'm not sure that that is appropriate.
I think it's up to the council to make those changes. I don't -- if there's that many
changes and there's for us to consider even. And we haven't addressed the
dangerousness of the underground vaults. I don't think that this should pass right now.
I think that we need more time to take a look at it before moving forward with it and
with all the changes. Thank you.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Thank you.
WATTS: I listen to the comments by the speaker, but first I want to say thank you to
John. I mean, it really is John's diligence, the tenacity to stay engaged, to push back on
not only comments, but on both attorneys, on Scott and Vanessa. The push and pull
was something to watch. So we tried to get the most we could. We got pushback from
the attorneys on a couple of issues. And to John's credit, he stayed the course. So
thank you, John, for that.
The list of -- of things that were just discussed or mentioned are something that I think
going forward we ought to consider as amendments. I want to get this ordinance
passed. I want to get it in place. And then I want to talk about making amendments as
we go down the road.
They are important, but if there's such a word as consequentiality of the ordinance as it
stands today, 80 pages and having a little more than half a dozen items that are minor in
nature. Sorry, Lori, but I want to get this done without stalling any longer. So final
thoughts. Thanks, John.
EARLE: Thank you. My question is to our attorney. Is it within code or legal that we can
make changes tonight and say that this person, Lori Troller, who's spent a lot of time on
this, I know, really has researched this, that we can say we want to make those changes
and pass that tonight in this ordinance?
UNIDENTIFIED SPEAKER: But I would say that we would have to review some of them
closely. Some of the changes that she has requested can be done rather quickly, but
some of the other ones that she referenced may need a deep dive. And one thing I do
want to point out is that, you know, with respect to the OTARDs, I know it's an unhappy
Page 25 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
situation, but those are preempted by federal law. And so therefore, those have to be
accepted. And there -- there is nothing that town can do about that.
LA SOTA: Well, Mr. --
UNIDENTIFIED SPEAKER: And then I also wanted to speak -- oh, go ahead.
LA SOTA: Mr. Mayor, Councilmember, I mean, if you want to make a change, you could
offer -- you could offer a change from the dais. There were quite a few suggested. But I
mean, you -- you certainly can make changes from the dais. It's -- it's sort of a
cumbersome process, but that is within your purview, if that's what you would like to
do. Or you could wait and -- and sort of maybe try to get all of them later in a follow-up.
EARLE: Do I have any time left on my two minutes?
Well, it doesn't count when they're talking. So then my question is to the council or --
am I on cam? Let's see. Getting this passed now and then -- then doing the deep dive
into what those items were she's talking to, then we could do an amendment in the
near future. Okay. Thank you.
KALIVIANAKIS: Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Yeah, I agree that Ms. Troller has done a great
deal of work on this for many years. And even at this late hour, she needs extra time to
point out all the flaws in this document.
She is literally making my case that I made last week and I will continue to make this
week. This document is rife with misannotations, misspellings, misnomers. It's -- it's a
slop. It looks bad. It's very sloppy. I would rather pass a good, clean bill than a bad bill
that's going to need -- need all this massaging in the future. That's one of the things I've
talked about to the town manager for years, is passing ordinances that are subject to
dual interpretations and are sloppily done.
And this is exactly what we're doing tonight.
In addition to all -- all the errors, you know, application fee provision fears inconsistent
with Arizona law, the document gives the town too much discretion, more than Arizona
law provides. I've got detailed analysis on all of this, but these are really concerns I
have.
The ten-year renewal language deserves very close scrutiny. It seems to be out of
Page 26 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
compliance. The relocation provisions, again, needs to be complied with -- with Arizona
law. The letter of credit requirement is enormous and needs justification. This
document appears to create a second regulatory approval system, a dual track for
telecommunications company. Mr. La Sota, did you have any -- this seems to have a
different regulatory system than -- than the usual process.
LA SOTA: Mr. Mayor or Councilmember? Mr. Mayor, Councilmember, I mean, I think
it's -- it's a -- it's a regulatory document. I think it outlines a process for going through it,
obviously, that consultants have explained. And -- and you said it, that they did what
the town asked them to do. I mean, I think it follows sort of a standard regulatory
framework.
KALIVIANAKIS: Okay. And those are the comments I had. And I'd like to -- to do is say
that I -- I would like to put a motion to table this so we can further look at it and just
discuss Ms. Troller's problems, the problems that the vice mayor has -- has determined,
which would be a long, long laundry list of amendments that I don't think we could
adequately prepare tonight. Why don't we take a month? Why don't we look at the
document? Why don't we clean it up, have a discussion, maybe a work session, and --
and go from there? Do I get a second?
MCMAHON: Second.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: We have a motion and a second to table. Can we get a roll call vote,
please?
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember Kalivianakis.
KALIVIANAKIS: Aye.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember Watts.
WATTS: Nay.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember Skillicorn.
SKILLICORN: No.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember McMahon.
MCMAHON: Aye.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember Larrabee.
Page 27 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
LARRABEE: Nay.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Vice Mayor Earle.
EARLE: Nay.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Mayor Friedel.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Nay.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Motion fails, five to two.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Thank you.
LARRABEE: Thank you, Mayor. I'd like to move to approve as written.
UNIDENTIFIED SPEAKER: Second.
MCMAHON: Thank you, I appreciate it. I object -- and I object to any consideration of
public, you know, drafting our ordinances or regulatory documents like that, et cetera.
I've not seen that happen before.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: We're not -- we're not taking those changes tonight.
MCMAHON: Okay.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: As -- as written.
MCMAHON: Thank you. I appreciate the clarification.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: You're welcome.
SKILLICORN: Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Yeah, I'm going to support this this evening as
drafted. I would recommend that we do like a trailer ordinance to just -- and these are
clerical that we're talking about, so I don't think it's going to be that big a deal. But I
would recommend a future agenda item to just go over those clerical parts that are out.
And I noticed that Councilman Watts was furiously writing them down, so I don't see
that being an issue. So I will support this.
MCMAHON: Gerry, what about looking at the vaults? I mean, I think that that's
something, the underground vaults, that really has to be addressed based on my
research that I did. And I noticed the chief isn't weighing in on that, but I think it's
serious consideration.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: I think the vaults were addressed by -- many municipalities have them
around the country, and they know how to deal with it. So I don't see that as a
Page 28 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
significant risk. They're the professionals. They've dealt with it time and time again.
We're not the only one with requiring vaults. They're actually in use all over the place.
Am I correct, John? Yeah. I thought so. Okay.
KALIVIANAKIS: My only comment is it's kind of a point of order. If we're going to direct
staff to do a shadow amendment, then I think that should be brought up in future
business. I don't think it could be brought up at this time.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: I don't think he was looking for a vote on that.
UNIDENTIFIED SPEAKER: I don't think she's wrong.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: All right. So we --
WATTS: I think my only comment is about the vaults, and having been involved with
OSHA and all the OSHA requirements and how thick the book of rules are with OSHA
and how the enforcement actions go, and having had firsthand knowledge, OSHA is real
strict and protects the heck out of workers with shoring, with confined space, with all of
the things that were mentioned.
And they are legitimate concerns, but they are very stringently enforced by OSHA. And
if you breach those laws, the fines are horrendous. So I would defer to OSHA and
making sure that we follow their guidelines. And I think that's addressed in the
ordinance as well.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: We have a motion and a second. Can we get a roll call, please?
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember Skillicorn.
SKILLICORN: Yes.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember Larrabee.
LARRABEE: Aye.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember McMahon.
MCMAHON: Nay.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember Kalivianakis.
KALIVIANAKIS: Nay.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember Watts.
WATTS: Aye.
Page 29 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Vice Mayor Earle.
EARLE: Aye.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Mayor Friedel.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Aye.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Motion passes, five to two.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Thank you. Moving on to regular agenda item B, consideration and
possible action regarding Ordinance 26-16, amending subdivision ordinance.
Rachael?
GOODWIN: Mayor, once again, this is yet another companion piece to our conversation
to align our subdivision ordinance. John will walk us through those changes as well.
WESLEY: Mayor, councilmembers, this is fairly simple and straightforward, but as the
Planning and Zoning Commission looked at the wireless telecommunication ordinance
and the provisions there, looking to the future with some of the undeveloped land in
town, they felt it would be important in the future, as we go through a planning process,
for developers to consider that up front, where cell towers may go, and to show that
then on the preliminary plats, so staff and future buyers in the area would have some
idea up front.
So this is a very simple amendment to the subdivision ordinance to add a provision that
would require for any subdivision of land of 50 acres or greater that they indicate in the
preliminary plat where cell towers may go. It doesn't obligate them to put those towers
in. It just gets that early idea and understanding of what may happen.
MCMAHON: Thank you very much. I have a couple questions, John, if you don't mind.
I'm trying to understand what the purpose of this is and what the town is trying to solve
in requiring this, that the permit and the developer designate a place for future
telecommunications. I mean, I have concerns with that, that it's expensive for the
developer, the topography might not be there. It might be the -- the -- might not be the
best site, et cetera. So I don't understand why you're saying 50 acres is requiring this,
but yet 49 and 49.5 are. Is there a reason why it's 50 acres? And is there a reason -- and
what is the reason for requesting this?
Page 30 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
WESLEY: Mayor, Councilmember, again, the reason to request it is rather than have the
location of towers be determined sometime in the future after homes are already built
and people establish their -- their homes without the thought that a cell tower may
come in.
By identifying those locations up front, then the future developers, the future property
owners can come into that knowing there's the possibility of where those cell towers
may go. So it keeps the public more informed up front. 50 acres, there's maybe not a
lot of magic to that, but it does start to get enough of a development size that having a
cell tower within it becomes a possibility.
Probably not a need to go any smaller, but if you want to make that a little bit larger,
that -- that would certainly be appropriate.
MCMAHON: Thank you, but I still -- I still don't understand why it's necessary that we
do this. It's like waving a red flag, so -- so to speak, given how over the history of our
discussions with cell towers and 5G and they're not wanted, I don't understand why it's
up to the developer to put -- and I must be missing something because I don't
understand why it's up to the developer to put it in -- in their plan and through their
permit process. And that may not even ever occur on that property. And given the --
the changes that's going to come up over the future in technology, may never be
needed.
Also, if the developer decides not to develop that property, does it transfer? Does it run
with the land? You know, does the next developer have to redo the same thing? I
mean, I don't think there's clarity, some clarification in this that I think is necessary,
because if he doesn't want that or want to allow a cell tower, then how did he get out of
this requirement?
WESLEY: So Mayor, Councilmember, a couple of things there.
MCMAHON: Thank you.
WESLEY: Preliminary plats expire after a year if they're not followed up with the -- with
a final plat. So they're -- they're that early look. They're the idea of how the property
may develop and give us that direction going forward. But if they don't move forward,
Page 31 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
then it all dies.
Also, it is the initial subdivider looking at the land and how they think it's going to be
developed and where they're laying out the lots and the streets and so forth, and -- and
identifying where a tower may go. It's not obligating a tower to be there. It just, again,
informs the staff and the council, the public around there, up front, where that may go,
so they can make plans accordingly if it should come in.
MCMAHON: Thank you for your time.
SKILLICORN: Thank you, Mr. Mayor, Director Wesley. You know, this seems like it's
smart, it's proactive, it's forward-looking. So if you want to do me a favor, thank
Planning and Zoning for suggesting this. It's -- it's a good idea. And on that note, I make
a motion to approve as drafted.
UNIDENTIFIED SPEAKER: Second.
WATTS: A quick question. I think in the spirit of disclosure, this was intended much like
real estate disclosures, multi-pages, roofing issues, structural foundation issues,
accidents. So all we're doing is saying it needs to be disclosed to potential buyers, pure
and simple. And secondly, it's a space that's going to be allocated for the future if the
data supports the necessity.
So if there isn't a necessity, and we've got qualifiers there that says the tower needs to
have empirical data, then it won't go in, period. But we've disclosed it, and we don't
have any pushback from homeowners. So thank you.
EARLE: Thank you, Mayor. I just want to thank you for the planning for the future. I
think this is a smart move. Thanks.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: And I'll add, I always think it's nice to give notice. So we have a
motion and a second. Can we get a roll call, please? I'm sorry, any speaker cards on this
one?
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Yes, Mayor.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Oh, oops.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: And the town received six online comment cards with the position
of against, and we have one requesting to speak, and she has declined.
Page 32 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Okay. So now we can move forward with the roll call vote.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Correct.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Thank you.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Thank you. Councilmember McMahon.
MCMAHON: Nay.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember Watts.
WATTS: Aye.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember Skillicorn.
SKILLICORN: Yes.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember Kalivianakis.
KALIVIANAKIS: No.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember Larrabee.
LARRABEE: Aye.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Vice Mayor Earle.
EARLE: Aye.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Mayor Friedel.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Aye.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: One quick question. Councilmember McMahon, may I have your
vote again? Was it nay?
MCMAHON: Nay.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Thank you. Motion passes, five to two.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Thank you. We'll move on to agenda item 9C regarding a proposed
ordinance related to Sharia law presented at the request of Councilman Skillicorn.
Rachael?
GOODWIN: Mayor, I'm going to defer to Councilman Skillicorn to take the lead on the
discussion, and we'll be here to answer any questions or take any direction.
SKILLICORN: Thank you, Mr. Mayor, Town Manager. Yeah, so I made the suggestion
and made the motion to consider this. And you know, I just want to give some, like,
kind of underground and also expectations. So the Town of Fountain Hills has very
Page 33 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
limited authority on big issues. You know, effectively, we are noncharter. We're just a
town according to the Arizona statutes and Constitution. You know, we don't have
great -- great authority. We actually have limited authority. So you know, we can
control things like roads and sidewalks and our right-of-way. And you know, and that's
really it.
But we can make a statement on that, that we agree with current Arizona law. We can
make a statement that we agree with the Senate Bill 1018 that was vetoed by Governor
Hobbs. And we also can really set the tone for the, you know, the values and protecting
freedom. And that's really what I wanted to do with this.
So my suggestion, and I did send over basically a -- like a proclamation or a resolution
over to the town attorney, effectively that we just honor Arizona state law about
honoring United States and state law and not foreign law. There's just a couple
provisions of that. We just basically codify those state laws. And then also, there's just
a note saying that we support SB 1018, which was vetoed by Katie Hobbs. That was a
legislation that passed both the House and Senate that would add Sharia law in the
same context as foreign law for the state.
MCMAHON: Already in our Constitution.
KALIVIANAKIS: Thank -- thank you, Mr. Mayor. Yeah, since there's no staff report on
this, and since the town manager already said that it was legitimate to -- to question the
person that put this on the agenda, which would be you, Councilmember Skillicorn, you
said that this is going to protect our values and our freedom. Could you elaborate on
that?
SKILLICORN: I don't feel the need to explain myself in this situation.
KALIVIANAKIS: So you -- you make an allegation that it's going to hurt our values and
not protect our freedom, and you've got no comment whatsoever to make? Your lack
of a comment tells us everything we need to know. My second question, can you
identify a single case in Fountain Hills where Sharia law has been invoked to override the
Arizona or U.S. Constitution?
SKILLICORN: Mr. Mayor, Councilperson, I can't think of any. But again, we do things
Page 34 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
forward-looking. And just like the last ordinance, we decided to do something forward-
looking, even though, you know, there are no 50-acre plats in front of us today. We
decided to adopt that. So it's no different.
KALIVIANAKIS: So what evidence do you have that this is a current or a foreseeable
problem that a municipality should be dealing with?
SKILLICORN: Mr. Mayor, Councilperson, when I look at the acts of violence and
terrorism in France over the weekend, I have every example I need.
KALIVIANAKIS: Do you understand that Sharia literally means the path to the watering
place and is the fundamental religious law, moral code, and spiritual path of Islam? Do
you understand what Sharia is? And do you understand that the founding of this
government in America was based on religious freedom? And are you suggesting today
that we pick and choose religions to -- to codify and to exclude? Is that what you want
us to do here tonight?
SKILLICORN: Mr. Mayor, Councilperson, that is not my intention at all. I recognize
freedom. I recognize religious freedom. I also recognize our ability to express that we
support Arizona law.
KALIVIANAKIS: That doesn't make any sense to me. Why should the -- why should the
town council act -- why should the town council act on this without a staff report
identifying a problem, analyzing the existing law, and explaining what this ordinance
would accomplish?
SKILLICORN: Mr. Mayor, Councilperson, is it appropriate to have a staff report for
something that's up for discussion? We don't -- we don't need staff to tell us what we
can discuss, do we? Is that what you're suggesting?
KALIVIANAKIS: We have no guidance on this other than we're here to protect our values
and our freedom, which doesn't make any sense to me. Would you apply the same
standard?
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Brenda, you're out of time. I'm sorry, but we got a --
KALIVIANAKIS: This is a question and answer period, Gerry.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: I know.
Page 35 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
KALIVIANAKIS: I get a minute to ask, and he gets unlimited time to answer.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Two minutes to each speaker. I mean --
KALIVIANAKIS: That's during the next phase after the call --
EARLE: Point of order.
KALIVIANAKIS: This --
EARLE: Point of order.
KALIVIANAKIS: You've already admitted that this phase we can ask --
EARLE: Point of order.
SKILLICORN: Once a point of order is made, the mayor needs to rule on that point of
order, either to deny it or to acknowledge it.
EARLE: Okay. Rules of decorum 6.4.
KALIVIANAKIS: Can we have the town attorney weigh in on this?
EARLE: "Councilmember, once recognized, shall limit remarks to no more than two
minutes." It does not say at what point. It's whenever we're speaking.
KALIVIANAKIS: That is after the call of the public. Can we --
EARLE: No, it is not. Point of order.
SKILLICORN: There is -- there is a point of order for the mayor to rule on.
LA SOTA: Mayor, Councilmember, it's the chair's decision whether to accept the point
of order. I think it is subject to challenge and a vote of the full body, but it's -- it's his
initial judgment whether to agree with the point of order or not.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Brenda, we need to move on. We have a lot of comment cards, I'm
sure, on this -- on this subject as well, and we have other council members that want to
weigh in as well. So we'll go back to you.
KALIVIANAKIS: Okay. I think I made my point.
MCMAHON: This is the Q&A, right? And we get an opportunity to make a comment
afterward, correct? Thank you very much. Also, I wanted to ask if you're going to allow
Martin Quezada to have some time to speak or not. To have Martin, who is the -- Mr.
Quezada, who is the attorney for CAIR, et cetera, he's in the audience, and I would hope
he would have some time to speak. Thank you.
Page 36 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Councilmember?
LARRABEE: Thank you, Mayor. And Mayor, just to be clear, because it's typically not
allowed to directly address a councilmember, I am permitted to?
MAYOR FRIEDEL: You join it through the chair.
LARRABEE: Got it. Thank you. So through the chair, Councilman Skillicorn, my
understanding for this proposal was that the language is simply that foreign or religious
law does not supersede the law of the land. Is that accurate?
SKILLICORN: Mr. Mayor, Councilwoman, you know, that is really it. I mean, just as it
restates and codifies Arizona law, I did add the -- the paragraph or sentence about that
we would support 1018, not unlike our legislative reports in the past.
LARRABEE: Thank you. And does the language of your proposal specifically name a
religion?
LA SOTA: Mayor, may I interject? This item is agendized for discussing whether --
whether the town should consider an ordinance. There's no real ordinance on the table
now. So I think specific --
LARRABEE: Understood.
LA SOTA: I think probably -- I think the discussion is, should the town consider such an
ordinance, not really as to what the specific ordinance is.
LARRABEE: Okay.
LASOTA: Thank you.
LARRABEE: Thank you, Town Attorney.
SKILLICORN: Just to be concise, can I finish and just make a final -- is that fine?
MCMAHON: You just told me I couldn't talk about it, and you accuse that of other
people, so why don't you respect that?
SKILLICORN: The mayor decided.
LARRABEE: Thank you, Town Attorney, and I will save the rest of my questions for the
next meeting.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Town Clerk, do we have any comment cards?
KALIVIANAKIS: I -- I have a motion to make at this time pursuant to Town Code Section
Page 37 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
5.2.
EARLE: Point of order. This is a discussion only. There's no motion.
KALIVIANAKIS: Pursuant to Section 5.2 of the Fountain Hills code, I have the right, by
right, to make a motion to give the speakers representing the Muslim community ten
minutes to address. That would be Martin Quezada, the attorney for CAIR, and Azza
Abuseif, the executive director. And I would ask for a second.
MCMAHON: Second.
KALIVIANAKIS: So all we're -- all we're voting on here is whether we're going to give
these -- these gentle people a chance to speak for ten minutes on behalf of CAIR to
make their argument and ask us what we're doing here tonight. Can I get a roll call
vote?
SKILLICORN: Can I ask a clarification?
MAYOR FRIEDEL: That's not up to you.
SKILLICORN: Can I ask a clarification? Is that okay?
MAYOR FRIEDEL: We have a question of clarification. Go ahead.
SKILLICORN: Ten minutes total or ten minutes for each individual?
KALIVIANAKIS: I'm not speaking on their individual. I'd be speaking for -- for them as a
representative of CAIR to allocate ten minutes. We've already given extra time on the
telecommunications ordinance to speakers. I think this would just be a kind gesture
to -- to let them address this with this council.
SKILLICORN: May I follow up? Mr. Mayor, would it be okay to -- typically, you make a
motion like this, it would go right to roll call, but I think it's fair to discuss this particular
ten minutes. I think I would like to hear a little more of why or why not we would not
want to do that. Is -- is that fair?
KALIVIANAKIS: Well, I think we have a motion and a second. Can we have a ruling on
that?
LA SOTA: Mr. Mayor, Councilmember, I think this should be treated as a privileged
motion where it's voted on without debate.
KALIVIANAKIS: Thank you.
Page 38 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
LARRABEE: I do have a point of clarification. I apologize, Mayor. Thank you. Have the
speakers already turned in a -- a card to speak on this agenda item?
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: We did receive one from Martin Quezada. What was the -- can you
please refresh my memory, who was the other speakers?
KALIVIANAKIS: Yeah. Her name is Azza. A-B-U-S-E-I-F. I'm sorry, I didn't have my
speaker on. Azza, A-B-U-S-E-I-F. She's the executive director of CAIR. And I think my
motion would supersede a comment card.
LARRABEE: I understand. I was just asking.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: I -- I do not see that. I see other members of CAIR requesting to
speak. I'm not seeing -- unless it's -- can you pronounce her last name? I see a Sumaya
Bade (ph.).
KALIVIANAKIS: No, this was A-B-U-S-E-I-F.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Let me see.
KALIVIANAKIS: Would -- would my motion supersede comment cards?
MAYOR FRIEDEL: No.
KALIVIANAKIS: No? So we would give the whole time to Martin if this was approved,
then. I'm willing to go along with that.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: (Indiscernible).
KALIVIANAKIS: No, no, no.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Mayor, I do not see that person as part of the list of cards to speak
at this moment.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Okay. So here --
EARLE: Thank you. Can I have a point of clarification too? Is this -- now, I know we
normally limit to 30 minutes, and are we then not going to let anybody else speak?
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Right. We're going to give Martin the time to speak.
EARLE: But then we would still have more time, another 20 minutes for other people to
speak if they want to, because it's a total of 30 minutes if we give him ten minutes.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Yeah.
EARLE: As long as they filled out forms.
Page 39 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
MAYOR FRIEDEL: So he would be -- yeah, he would be representing CAIR, I believe. Is
that what you want, Brenda?
KALIVIANAKIS: Yes, Mr. Mayor. We just give him ten minutes initial shot, and then --
MAYOR FRIEDEL: He would speak --
KALIVIANAKIS: Then we can just go the rest of the speaker cards as the 30 minutes will
allow.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Okay. So we need to vote on that anyway. We have a motion and a
second to allow Martin ten minutes, and then the -- the remaining 20 minutes will be
split up between the -- the cards that you have, because we allow 30 minutes total. So
is that -- is that -- that's fair?
KALIVIANAKIS: Very fair. Thank you, Mr. Mayor.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Okay. All right. So we have a motion and a second on that. Can we
get a roll call?
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Sure. Councilmember McMahon.
MCMAHON: Aye.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember Kalivianakis.
KALIVIANAKIS: Aye.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember Larrabee.
LARRABEE: I don't support silencing everybody else, so no.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember Watts.
WATTS: No.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Councilmember Skillicorn.
SKILLICORN: No.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Vice Mayor Earle.
EARLE: Aye. I do want to hear it.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Mayor Friedel.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Aye.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Motion passes, four to three.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: All right. So we'll start with Martin.
Page 40 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Sure. That sounds good. And just for the record, though, the town
did receive eight online comment cards with a position of against. We also received one
written card tonight with a position of against. So first up, Martin.
MCMAHON: We also received over 100 emails.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Martin, you have ten minutes.
QUEZADA: Okay. Thank you, Mr. Mayor, members of the council. I appreciate the
opportunity to have that extra time as well. I'm going to speak on behalf of -- of my
executive director, Ms. Abuseif. So it'll be just -- just myself.
And I'm not going to take up the full ten minutes so we can hear from some of the other
speakers this evening. But again, Mr. Mayor and members of the council, for the
record, my name is Martin Quezada, and I am the attorney and the civil rights director
for the Council on American-Islamic Relations, Arizona's chapter. And we are, as CAIR
Arizona, we are the state affiliate of the largest Muslim civil rights organization in the
nation.
We did send you a letter back on, I believe it was September 21st, after the last council
meeting, or not your last one, but the one before that, where this agenda item was
requested. I hope you all had a chance to review that letter, take a look at that. We do
stand behind everything that was in that letter, and we want to emphasize those points
again tonight. Our main -- our main request for you this evening is that you do not
move forward in drafting this ordinance. We do not think that this is necessary. We do
not think it's appropriate. And we think that there are some legal implications if this
were to move forward as well.
Before I move on to kind of my formal comments, I did want to touch on just a few of
the -- a few of the issues that were raised earlier during this conversation. In regards to
Senate Bill 1018, if that were to be included in a future resolution that this council were
to move forward, Senate Bill 1018 was passed by the House and the Senate earlier this
year. It was vetoed by the governor in June of this year. Senate Bill 1018 no longer
exists. It is not a living proposal at this point anymore.
So if you were to put that into any type of resolution at this point forward, you're
Page 41 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
basically saying that you're supporting an issue that no longer exists. That issue would
have to be proposed again next year and by a new legislature that -- that takes office
after this November's elections. But Senate Bill 1018, after it was vetoed, it is a -- it is
officially dead as a legislative proposal.
In regards to -- I believe one of your members mentioned that there was no -- no single
incident that could be recalled about Sharia law being -- being an issue here in this
town, and that -- that is 100 percent true.
Each of the proposals like this one that is being debated here tonight, the one that was
proposed in Florida, the one that was proposed in Oklahoma, each of the sponsors of
each of those proposals also said that they had heard no record whatsoever of any type
of instance where Sharia law or Sharia in general, in any way, shape, or form, was
impacting legal decisions, was interfering with the Constitution, was interfering with the
laws of this land, because that problem does not exist.
So I would like to get into my -- my -- my formal comments now. And as I mentioned
before, on -- on September 15th, a member of this council asked for a, quote/unquote,
"Florida-style ban on Sharia law." That was not a request on a ban on any particular
crime. It was not a request about a ban on any particular criminal incident. That was a
request of a ban on a religion's guidance for how its members live.
And it's important to understand what Sharia is if you are going to propose this. Sharia
is how the Muslim community prays.
Sharia is how they fast during Ramadan, much like Christians observe Lent. And it is
how -- Sharia is how they give to the poor, much like church tithing in the religions I
assume many of you practice as well. It is the same kind of thing as canon law for
Catholics or the halakha for Jewish families, and I haven't heard anybody or anyone
propose an ordinance to try to ban those issues. The Town of Fountain Hills does not
have a Sharia problem.
Oklahoma adopted a similar ban in -- in the early 2000s. A district court struck that
down. The 10th Circuit Court of Appeals upheld that, striking down that law as well.
There is legal precedent that this is not allowed. And Arizona law already bans the
Page 42 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
enforcement of foreign or religious law that violates the constitutional rights.
So again, if you're going to put forward a proposal that is trying to codify state law, you
actually cannot codify state law. State law is already codified. Otherwise, it wouldn't be
state law. So you would just simply be making a statement that you -- that you believe
in a law that already exists. That law already does exist.
When the governor vetoed Senate Bill 1018 in June, she warned that it would cost
taxpayers millions in a lawsuit if the state were to lose. This town would surely lose too
if we did have to take it to court, and this town would pay for it and its taxpayers would
pay for it. But there's an additional cost that I want you to be aware of, and I hope that
you will be aware of, that does not show up in any legal bill. And that's -- I want you to
think about a Muslim mother who hears her elected officials debate her faith as a
threat. She starts to wonder whether the deputy -- the deputy that shows up at her -- at
her door will see her as a victim or see her as a suspect.
If that's the case, she's not going to report the man who harassed her at a grocery store.
She's not going to report the break-in in her home or her neighbor's home, and she's
not going to come forward as a witness if she does see another crime. Your deputies
police behavior. They do not police belief. And they've spent years earning trust in your
community.
A proposal like this would put all of that trust at risk. And because rhetoric does not
stay rhetoric, rhetoric translates into action. Sooner or later, it will show up at
someone's door. And this type of rhetoric has already shown up at people's doors
throughout this past calendar year as these issues have been debated at the state level.
And I could give you plenty of examples of how this rhetoric has turned into dangerous
and violent action at the front doors and the -- the -- the -- the doors of -- of houses of
worship of Muslim families in this community.
So how we all handle disagreement about religious issues or political issues in general,
that matters. And we are also aware that -- that this conversation isn't just happening
here. It happens on social media. You may see posts online about -- about Sharia.
And -- and we want you to know that -- that the town should think about how it wants
Page 43 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
to be seen in regards to these matters and how it wants to be perceived about these
matters.
CAIR Arizona as an -- as an organization -- and this is in conclusion, Mr. Mayor and
members of the council -- we would much rather build something with this town and
with this council than -- we would much rather build than fight against it.
But we will defend our community both in this chamber and in court if we have to.
So in conclusion, I want to ask one more time, there's no need to bring this issue
forward. There's no need to put this in writing in a resolution. It's only repeating what
is already state law.
And if this brings -- if this does move forward, it only brings harm to this community.
And we want to see the Town of Fountain Hills thrive rather than deal with these issues.
Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Thank you, members of the council. I don't know if it's
appropriate, but I'm happy to answer any questions.
EARLE: Is it appropriate? No.
QUEZADA: Thank you.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Please, no disruptions. Thank you. Next speaker, please.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Matthew Corrigan.
CORRIGAN: Mayor and Council, Matthew Corrigan, Fountain Hills, Arizona. It was
August 26th of this year, 2026, in an interview with Glenn Beck. Glenn Beck is a radio,
TV host, and political commentator. The interview with -- was with Donald J. Trump.
And in that interview, he said -- this is the president now -- he would absolutely prohibit
Sharia law in the United States. I'm in favor of the U.S. Constitution. We have one form
of law, one form of justice, and one right for all people. All citizens of the United States
live under those constitutional rights.
This is a different issue. Sharia law is its own separate institution. We only have one
form of justice, one form of law. So I support the U.S. Constitution. I do not support
Sharia law.
And as to CAIR, I recognize that they are an unindicted coconspirator in the 2017 Holy
Land Foundation. That is a fact. So all the issues aside, it's important that we stand on
Page 44 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
the U.S. Constitution only. And in that Constitution, we know that we have the right of
freedom of faith. That's religion. And I can read it to you, but you all should know it, I
hope. And it doesn't involve anything -- words about Sharia law. So matter of fact, it
indicates that we should not establish, you know, we do not in this country establish or
prohibit religion. That's an important point.
And we know about freedom of the press, freedom of assembly, the right to petition the
government, which is what we're all doing here tonight, in a manner. This is a very bad
idea, allowing Sharia law in any component to come into Fountain Hills. The
Constitution is what we live by. The rule of law is what we live by. Those are my
thoughts. Thank you very much.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Please, no disruptions. Let's be respectful. We need proper decorum
in this room. Next speaker, please.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Linda Ciommo (ph.).
CIOMMO: Thank you, Mr. Mayor, councilmembers. My name is Linda Ciommo. I am a
resident, and I want to thank Mr. Corrigan because he just made the points for me. We
do live under a Constitution that guarantees us freedom of religion, freedom of the
press, freedom of speech. We also have the first article of the Constitution, which says
Congress will create no laws, no laws regarding the establishment of a religion, nor
restricting the free practice thereof.
Let's call this what it is. This ordinance has nothing to do with the law. As you've
already heard, the law of the land is the Constitution and Arizona codes. So this does
nothing to reinforce those because they are already the law of the land. All this does is
to tell those who practice their religion by following certain laws of their religion that
has nothing to do with the law of the land that they're not welcome in this community.
That's what this is trying to do. It has nothing to do with the laws.
I'm not surprised that Mr. Skillicorn or even Ms. Larrabee want to pass this. I am
surprised at Mr. Watts. These two will not be here after December. Mr. Watts will. So
when the lawsuit is filed because this council passed something that tells a particular
religion that we don't want you here in -- in Fountain Hills, and the taxpayers end up
Page 45 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
having to pay for that lawsuit, they'll be gone. The rest of you will be here experiencing
the consequences of what you decide tonight. Let's kill this tonight. You don't even
need to consider this in the future. Vote no. Thank you.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: I will not ask again. Please be respectful. Next speaker, please.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Tan Jaquani (ph.).
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Before -- before the speaker speaks, since Rick Watts was named in
there, I'm going to give him a chance to respond.
You have a minute, Rick.
WATTS: One minute?
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Yeah.
WATTS: Okay. In response to what someone said, you don't know how I'm going to
vote. My no was specific to not listening to the attorney. The attorney brought up
some interesting points. I think you can address this without an ordinance. I think you
can address it by how we've done numerous times in the past, by saying, by way of a
resolution, making sure that our government, our state government, knows our
position. So a resolution without naming Sharia. I'm not a supporter of Sharia, but I am
an absolute supporter of religious freedoms.
I mean, whether it's Catholic canon, whether it's the Jewish -- I can never pronounce the
name, so my apologies for that. But we all have things that we live by, and I respect
those things.
I would not for a moment support using the name Sharia in any type of a resolution, but
I would support saying that we are going to honor the federal, state, the Bill of Rights, all
27 of the amendments, and we're going to honor those moving forward. And that
would be the position that I would ask the council to move forward. So I just want to
make sure that you don't think I'm going to vote for this. I hope you don't, but you don't
know yet. So don't assume before you hear my vote.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Thank you. Next speaker, please.
JAQUANI: Good evening, Mayor and the members of the council. So my name is Tan
Jaquani. I'm a Muslim resident of neighboring Scottsdale. I'm a -- can you hear me? I'm
Page 46 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
sorry, I'm short. Okay. So I'm a Muslim resident of neighboring Scottsdale. I am not
wearing a scarf. I am a Muslim. For 20 years, I've been an active supporter of this
community. I and my group of friends from Scottsdale, we come here to hike your
beautiful trails. I regularly eat at your restaurants, and I contribute to your local
economy.
My connection to this town is also deeply spiritual. I have attended multiple Pray Well
Together interfaith Thanksgiving gatherings. And what I observed, well, in that scenario,
in that space, is that I see a Fountain Hills rooted in mutual respect, warmth, and shared
faith. We have multiple faiths. So I'm very confused and disturbed by the proposed
ordinance. Like many people have questioned, is there any real incident, real crime that
happened to trigger this ban? And what did you intend for this ban to do? Truly, I want
to know, what did you intend for the ban to do? What would it do for your community
here, for all of us surrounding you?
We love you all, and I see you all working diligently to make your town great with all the
ordinances you try to pass to make everything safe for zoning, and that when this came
up, it is so intense. Everyone is nervous. I see the couple sitting on the side of me very
nervous, afraid that she would be asked to put on the scarf. That's not true. I've never
been forced by my husband to wear a scarf. That's -- that's just what you may hear from
the news, but it's not, really not that.
So I don't want to take more of the time. I just want to say that I want to invite all of
you to visit our mosque. It's just ten minutes away from here on Via Linda and 122nd
Street. Visit us sometime and share kebabs and curries with us and get to know each
other better. It's my true invitation to all of you. And I just want to say that I'm sitting
here looking at the iconic fountain that you have in front of the -- behind the mayor. I
want to -- I see it as a beautiful symbol of peace and prosperity for Fountain Hills and --
and all of us. So thank you so much.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Thank you. Next speaker.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Rosina Khan.
KHAN: Hi. Good evening. Can you hear me? Hi. Good evening, Mayor and
Page 47 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
councilmembers. My name is Rosina Khan, and I'm a Muslim and an American. I've
lived in Mesa and Scottsdale for almost 20 years, and this is the first time I've ever stood
at the podium at a council meeting. Tonight, I felt compelled to come because I'm
troubled and quite frankly, saddened. I intend to be direct and to the point. I may not
live in Fountain Hills, but I'm your neighbor. What's decided in this room is felt by
Muslim families across Arizona and across America.
The agenda reads, "a proposed ordinance related to Sharia law." I still can't tell you
what purpose it serves. There is no Sharia court in Fountain Hills, none in Arizona. And
as a Muslim, I have never gone to one, and I answer to no one but the laws of the land.
I don't need to tell you this. This is the Constitution.
You guys already know this. So quite frankly, the best I can assume is that this serves a
political agenda or is designed to stir up fear. An ordinance against something that
doesn't exist is like building a flood wall in the desert. It protects no one and serves no
purpose. What it does is point fingers at your Muslim neighbors.
So what's Sharia in my life? Well, it's why I give charity. It's why I fast. It's why I keep
my word. It's my conscience. Catholics have canon law. Jewish families live by halakha.
Nobody's proposing to ban those laws, and nobody should. One of my many roles is
serving on the HOA board in Scottsdale. Really proud of that. And it's taught me what it
means to make rules for neighbors, and that I can't target one family in our community
because their faith or values are different from mine. Neither can you.
Right now, hate against Muslims is on the rise, and it lands on real people. We've been
here before. Irish Catholics were told they couldn't be Americans because they
answered to the Pope. Jewish families were questioned about their loyalty and
patriotism. Latter-day Saints were also at one time called a threat, and the governor of
Missouri ordered them be driven from the state. These are just some examples. Every
one of those fears was wrong. Every one of those communities helped to build this
country, and every apology came too late.
So fear is not leadership. This ordinance solves no problem, and it creates a real one. It
tells Muslim families they aren't welcome. So I'm asking you for something better.
Page 48 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
Instead of writing this ordinance about Sharia, get to know us. Come and meet your
Muslim neighbors. Visit our mosque. Ask us questions, because connection is how fear
ends. And I believe this town is better than this. So please vote no. Thank you.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Next speaker.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Kim Bartman (ph.).
BARTMAN: Kim Bartman, Fountain Hills. I asked you to reconsider whether our town
truly needs to vote to ban Sharia. Before considering a vote for this Sharia ban, we
should ask, what problem are we trying to solve? Has something happened in our town
that makes this necessary?
What would this vote accomplish that our existing laws do not already cover? Great
leadership means bringing people together, treating everyone fairly, and making
decisions based on facts rather than fear.
Although we may have different beliefs, we all want safe neighborhoods, happy
families, and a community where everyone feels welcome. Our laws should apply
equally to everyone, regardless of religion.
Sharia is a set of Islamic religious and moral teachings that many Muslims follow in their
personal lives, emphasizing kindness, honesty, charity, and caring for others.
Many Muslims in Western countries, it guides personal and religious practices rather
than replacing the laws of their country. Our Constitution and Arizona laws protect
everyone's rights, and religious rules cannot replace American law.
Singling out one religion can create fear, mistrust, division while making innocent people
feel unwelcome. Everyone deserves equal rights and protection regardless of their
faith.
If our existing laws already protect us, we should have a clear, compelling reason
spending our town's time and resources on another vote. Our council should focus on
real problems and solutions that benefit all residents, not measures that divide our
community. I urge you to choose understanding over judgment -- judgment and unity
over division.
We can uphold our laws while treating every person with dignity and respect. Please do
Page 49 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
not support a measure that targets one religion without a clear and compelling reason.
Stand for fairness, religious freedom, and all the people you were elected to represent.
And by the way, the -- the folks here that are here tonight, some of the -- the outreach
that they do and the stuff they do for even Extended Hands Food Bank, for our 9/11
food drive. And I would cry too, because you guys are, you know, this -- this couple here
is so rude and saying really hateful, bigoted things.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Next speaker.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Shelby Blecher (ph.).
BLECHER: Good evening, Mr. Mayor, Town Council. Shelby Blecher, resident of
Fountain Hills, speaking on my own behalf. We heard tonight about Sharia law and the
way, but let's talk about the Quran. And the Quran is the primary foundation and
source of Sharia, providing the core divine principles, ethical guidance, and direct legal
commandments upon which Islamic law is built.
Now, there are a lot of contradictions in the Quran, but how do you reconcile the part of
Quran 9.5 that says, "And when the sacred months have passed, then kill the polytheists
wherever you find them, and capture them and besiege them, and sit in wait for them
at every place in ambush.
But if they should repent, establish prayer, and give zakat, then let them on their way.
Indeed, Allah is forgiving and merciful." Killing people if they don't repent and establish
prayer, et cetera, it's coercion. Now, I did some reading about Sharia law by the Foreign
Policy Association, an article written by Cassandra Clifford.
"The practice of Sharia law has frequently left women and girls with legal shortcomings
that have forced them to live in fear, especially in instances of rape. Rape is often
treated as instances of adultery. Traditionally, criminal sanctions for sexual relations
outside of wedlock are death by stoning if the accused is married and 100 lashes if they
are unmarried. Sharia law, it is often required that the crime be validated by witnesses.
In the case of rape, it has to be witnessed by four Muslim males, or there is fear of risk
that the victim may be charged with adultery."
Now, these are not my words. This is what I've read, like I said, in the Foreign Policy
Page 50 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
Association. The girl was charged and stoned to death. And -- and it was just -- I mean,
it's awful. Are we going to not protect our children? There are parts of Sharia law that
scare me to death. There are no parts of Jewish law that scare me at all. I don't have
any knowledge of any Jewish laws that tell you you can go out and kill somebody if they
won't convert.
Now, all this being said, I am usually the guy that stands up here and says Fountain Hills
needs to be the town, the shiny town up on the hill that leads. Not in this case.
I'm really asking that the council defer to state law first and wait for state law to rule on
this before we take a position. We should not be providing a reason to the state saying,
yeah, we want to -- we want to support this ban on Sharia law, so please go ahead and
pass it. No, I think this is too inflammatory. There are way too many problems. I think
we should wait and let the legislatures in the state capital rule on this. And then we can
say whether or not we want to follow it and support it. Thank you very much for my
time.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: We have time for one more speaker.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Reverend David Felten.
FELTEN: Good evening. Reverend David Felten from the Fountains United Methodist.
And boy, I would love to talk to my previous speaker about the things he hasn't read in
the Bible.
Once upon a time, Mullah Nasruddin was sitting near the gates of Baghdad when a
stranger approached him. Excuse me, the man said, business requires me to move to
Baghdad. What is the city really like? Nasruddin asked, what was the place like where
you came from? Oh, it was wonderful. Neighbors were kind to one another. People
looked out for children. They shared what they had. They were generous and
welcoming. I hated to leave. Nasruddin smiled. Well, then you will love Baghdad.
Welcome.
Later, another stranger approached Nasruddin with the same question, and again he
asked, what was the place like where you came from? Terrible. People were selfish and
dishonest. Nobody trusted anybody. Everybody was suspicious of everybody else. I
Page 51 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
couldn't get away fast enough. Nasruddin nodded. Then you will hate Baghdad. Best
you move on to another city. Nasruddin understood something about communities.
We tend to bring the place we came from with us.
As an Arizona native, I dare say I'm one of the few in the room. I usually am in Fountain
Hills. I've watched people come to this state my entire life, and most have brought their
gifts, cultures, traditions, families, and hopes, and Arizona is the richer for it. But some
arrive carrying old baggages, fears, grievances, and prejudices, and then they try to
unpack them here and tell the rest of us what we ought to be afraid of, too. No, thank
you.
Fountain Hills' motto is All That Is Arizona. I sometimes wonder if our town council
knows what all really means. I would hope all includes our Muslim neighbors because
they are already a part of Arizona. They are our doctors and teachers, business owners
and students, coworkers and friends.
They are our neighbors. So perhaps the question before us tonight isn't really about
Sharia. Perhaps the better question is, what baggage are you bringing through the
gates? Welcome or suspicion? Neighborliness or fear? The generous, diverse Arizona
that we are still trying to become? Or somebody else's old prejudices packed up and
brought here as baggage?
I know which Fountain Hills that I want. And if someone comes here determined to
make our Muslim neighbors objects of suspicion, perhaps Mullah Nasruddin has the
best advice. There are other cities you might feel comfortable in. But here in Fountain
Hills, if we really mean all that is Arizona, then let's have the courage to mean all. Thank
you.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: We'll move on to council discussion. This is two minutes each, period.
Councilman?
SKILLICORN: Thank you, Mr. Mayor. I realize we won't be any vote. We're just giving
direction to staff, so I just want to be crystal clear what I would like to direct staff to do.
And what I would love is if the town attorney could draft a resolution that represents
our intent here, but also does not overstep any authority, does not, you know, run us
Page 52 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
into any legal challenges, and -- and spend some time and really ponder what the best
course of action is for this resolution, not only protect the town, but also protect the
intent that we're looking for. And I think it's just to honor Arizona law. And I did still
include the SB 1018 in that.
LARRABEE: Thank you, Mayor. I'd like to echo the same direction. I agree, and I'm
going to try my best to keep under the two minutes. If I get cut off, I'll talk about it next
time we talk about this.
The question was posed several times of why this might bear repeating, right? What is
the real-world example? I'm not going to go into Europe. Most of you have heard it
before, but I will go into what's going on in America. In Dearborn, Michigan, where
there are now famously five calls to prayer per day publicly broadcasted, the First
Amendment cited for this practice is not so evenly distributed. Four pastors were
recently arrested for having voluntary conversations with festivalgoers.
The Islamic Tribunal, based in Dallas, Texas, has operated since 2014.
There is a current investigation into whether they have impersonated court official
documents or otherwise misled people that they are an official court. They are on
record having publicly advertised themselves as an authority over, quote, "all aspects of
Muslim life" and asserted that their decisions carry the approval of the Texas judicial
system, allegedly describing all rulings as final. While all religious organizations reserve
the right to handle doctrinal matters internally, moral matters, no religion has the ability
to take the place of a judicial court.
Similar tribunals already exist in other states as well. For a brief, incomplete list, we
have the Islamic Dispute Resolution Services of California, the Sharia Council of Southern
California, Islamic Council America, servicing mainly Midwestern America, Internal
Council of Michigan in the Dearborn-Detroit areas, the North American Islamic Trust,
which additionally holds titles of hundreds of mosques around the United States, and
the Assembly of Muslim Jurists of America, which we'll touch on in a moment if I have
time.
There is advocacy for Sharia law in the United States. CAIR, for example, their founder,
Page 53 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
Omar Ahmad, he disputes this and claims it was paraphrased, but I question what the
paraphrasing was of. No one seems to be able to provide the original quote. The quote
that the journalist defended was, "Islam isn't in America to be equal to any other faith,
but to become dominant. The Quran should be the highest authority in America, and
Islam the only accepted religion on earth." The Assembly of Muslim Jurists of America,
which boasts a core network of 500 to 600 imams --
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Time. Time. Time.
UNIDENTIFIED SPEAKER: Time. Gavel.
LARRABEE: I'll talk about it later.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: I'll ask you to leave if you interrupt again.
Vice Mayor?
EARLE: Thank you, Mayor. I feel for everyone in this room because there seems to be a
lot of fear. And I -- I'm not clear on, are we talking about religion or are we talking
about true government law?
I don't take kindly to feeling like I need to take the knee because someone's threatening
that we're going to be sued, a lawsuit, or that we're bringing harm to our community. I
don't know exactly what the attorney meant by that.
But I also see that Sharia law, my understanding of what I'm hearing here, if we're
talking about religion, we have no business regulating that. We don't regulate canon
law. We don't regulate Jewish law. And we have freedom of religion in our country. It
was founded on that.
So if we're talking about, which we should be talking about here, just law, we don't --
my -- my support is leaving this with the state. The Arizona law, ARS 12-3103, already
prohibits enforcing any foreign law that conflicts with our constitutional rights, and it
applies here without any action from us. So therefore, I give no direction to staff on this
item.
MCMAHON: Thank you very much. Thank you, everybody, for coming tonight. And just
know that your voices have been heard and your concerns deserve to be acknowledged
and thoughtfully considered by everybody in the room.
Page 54 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
And for many of us, this agenda item may be difficult to discuss, and it has been for me,
particularly given the negative associations and discriminatory connotations that
surround the subject of Sharia law. However, I believe that we can also approach this
discussion as an opportunity to learn and develop a better understanding of a subject
that may be unfamiliar to all of us.
And I know that researching this, that I've learned a great deal about Sharia law, and the
process has left me humbled, I have to say.
It has reminded me of the importance of looking beyond assumptions, seeking
knowledge, and making an effort to understand perspectives and traditions that may
differ from our own. And firstly, the Constitution belongs to all of us, including Muslim
friends and neighbors who have the same fundamental right to religious freedom as
you, me, and everyone else.
You know, as has been shared before, Sharia law is not a statutory law in the sense that
one might think. It's a way of life through a broad religious and ethical tradition that
Muslims interpret and practice in different ways. It may guide personal beliefs, it may
guide prayer, it may guide fasting, dietary practices, charity, family life, business ethics,
and moral ethics. It's a path.
It's a way of life. It's similar, has been stated, to the canons of Catholicism and halakha
for Jewish Americans. Both traditions preserve sacred teachings, interpret -- interpret
religious obligations, prayer, moral conduct, and transmit beliefs across generations for
practices in everyday life.
And further, the government may not single out Sharia or Muslims for special legal
restrictions while treating comparable conduct or religious practices differently for
others. Existing Arizona law already provides circumstances in which foreign law
conflicts with constitutional rights, state or federal, our Constitution prevails.
No one should be treated as an alleged extremist group and/or threat merely for being
Muslim. Arizona Globe article 923 referencing Skillicorn's extremist Muslim comments.
And no elected official's personal beliefs should take precedence over personal
fundamental constitutional rights. Freedom of religion, freedom of speech are not
Page 55 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
privileges reserved for one faith or political viewpoint.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Time.
MCMAHON: They are reserved for all of us.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Thank you.
MCMAHON: I think this is a shame that we're even talking about it, and it shouldn't go
any further. Thank you very much. I appreciate it.
KALIVIANAKIS: Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Two minutes. You know, I heard one of the
council members talk about fear. I think that was well said. Selling fear is the honorable
tradition of politicians. They do it all the time. They say, is this town better than this? I
heard that tonight. We're going to answer that question tonight. Is this town better
than this? I recognize a troubling principle when I see it, the tendency to turn a minority
into a target, to make people feel that somehow they don't quite belong in this
community. The English-only ordinance comes to mind, and the last election cycle
brought up some foul nastiness.
We have Muslim residents that live in Fountain Hills. These people are our neighbors.
They deserve the same respect, security, and sense of belonging that anybody that lives
here or visits here does. The government should solve problems, not manufacture
suspicion. I only ask that we extend this other freedoms and dignity and fair treatment
to everybody, including our Muslim friends, because the test of a community isn't how it
treats people that look like us, think like us, or believe what we believe. It's how it
treats those that don't. Thank you, Mr. Mayor.
WATTS: I think this is a great opportunity to make lemonade out of lemons. And as
corny as that sounds, I think we have the opportunity to craft a statement, a resolution,
without identifying a religion, without identifying any House bills that didn't pass,
without identifying vetoes, and welcome everybody. Welcome everybody into town
and say you are more than welcome.
We want you here. And we're going to continue to support the law of the land by way
of the Constitution, Bill of Rights, and the state Constitution. We're going to do
everything in our power to honor and uphold that. So making lemonade out of lemons,
Page 56 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
to me, seems to be the practical solution here.
I didn't want to listen to the attorney because I pretty much had my mind made up. I
heard what he had to say, somewhat in alignment. I don't like the overtones of the
threats. That's -- that's personal.
So -- but on the other hand, I'm Catholic. Every religion knows and has a history in one
way, shape, or form of doing things that were not appropriate, the religious wars over
centuries, the biblical references that have had in the Old Testament, somewhat in the
New Testament, all of the things that have occurred.
But we are in today, and today we should make lemonade out of lemons by welcoming
people, saying you are welcome to come here until proven otherwise, and then we'll let
the laws of the land take care of that situation at that time. But right now, I'd -- I'd
support a simple letter that says, come on down. We want you here. We welcome you.
We want you to be our neighbors. And that's my position. Thank you.
MCMAHON: No, I just was going to say that, you know, listening to Rick, we as a council
and as a town, we already support, you know, it's obvious that we do. And it's -- it's --
it's who and what we are, and it's town policy. It does not need to be codified, in my
opinion. Thank you.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: And I'll add that Sharia is a religious and moral code or path of
guidance, while Muslim is a person who practices the religion of Islam. I will give no
direction tonight.
MCMAHON: Are we supposed to say whether we will or not? I will give no direction
tonight.
KALIVIANAKIS: I would give no direction tonight.
WATTS: To the contrary, I give a direction to write a favorable letter saying, come on
down, welcome, that we're here in support of -- of you by way of the laws that exist
today.
EARLE: I'll just confirm no direction. Thank you.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Okay. Thank you. This item was scheduled for discussion only, and --
and there's no action to be contemplated. So we have provided the direction by way of
Page 57 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
no direction, and we'll move on to the next agenda item, which is our discussion, 9D,
regarding the ordinance amending the Town -- Town of Fountain Hills Code, Chapter 16,
Streets and Sidewalks, by adding Article 16-4, Automated License Plate Readers.
Rachael?
GOODWIN: Mayor, if you recall, this item was tabled at our last meeting requesting
more discussion, so it has been brought back for discussion tonight. The proposed
ordinance that was part of that item is still attached. So again, we're here to answer
questions and take any direction from council.
As a reminder, the item was originally presented and requested by Councilmember
Skillicorn, so he may want to take the lead to resume the conversation. Ultimately, I
believe it was Rick -- or Councilman Watts who requested the motion to table. So I'll
turn it over to whoever would like to take the lead on that conversation.
SKILLICORN: Yeah, it's -- it's -- I guess it's just for discussion at this point. I'm going to
kind of hold my comments and see what the discussion is.
EARLE: Thank you, Mayor. So my discussion is I would like to have the ordinance voted
on for action at the next meeting with the -- as written, except for -- let's see, I had here
the removal of the recital that states other towns, but everything else the same.
GOODWIN: Okay, so the whole paragraph?
EARLE: The whole paragraph, yeah. No, no, that's just my -- my discussion, direction,
whatever. That's what I'm asking.
KALIVIANAKIS: We usually do that after the call to the public.
EARLE: No, this --
UNIDENTIFIED SPEAKER: No, it's on the agenda.
EARLE: We're talking about this because it's an agenda item.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Right.
LARRABEE: I would just like to say that I agree with Councilmember -- Councilmember
Earle. I'm having a lot of trouble talking today. I'm sorry. I agree with those comments,
and I would like to see this for action in the next meeting.
SKILLICORN: Thank you, Mr. Mayor. And Mr. Mayor, Vice Mayor Earle, and I just -- can
Page 58 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
you point out the paragraph? I'm actually trying to look it up right now. And I also
realized that we made a motion and a second, and I want to say that you made the
motion, and you already added this amendment, and there was a second on it. So you
know, that's -- that's probably procedurally -- that is the one -- that is the motion that
was tabled. So -- but just to refresh my memory of which paragraph that is.
EARLE: Okay. May I -- may I? Okay. Thank you, Mayor. It was whereas --
SKILLICORN: Oh, I got it. Sorry to interrupt you, Mr. Mayor, Councilwoman. I see it
now. It wasn't other towns. It was specifically mentioned.
EARLE: It says whereas --
SKILLICORN: Ten. Yes.
EARLE: Okay. That -- that one.
SKILLICORN: Yes, that -- that is actually quite helpful.
EARLE: Said we stand on our own. We don't need to talk about other towns. Thank
you.
SKILLICORN: And I -- I stand for any other questions or --
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Thank you.
MCMAHON: Thank you very much. I'm not for moving this forward at all because I
don't see the -- the need right now or you know, a substantial need for it. But -- and
they are very, very expensive -- expensive systems to put in and maintain, and we don't
have the budget for it now. And I don't anticipate having the budget for it in the future.
I think those funds could be better spent on streets, et cetera. I really do.
Plus, you know, the Maricopa County Sheriff's Department would have to deal with it a
lot. They have had absolutely no input on this at all. And I -- I think that this is out of
the scope of the round.
If for some reason this moves forward, I think at a minimum we ought to hear a
presentation from the Maricopa County Sheriff's Office. Some of the research I've done,
most of the towns that have this have their own private police departments. It doesn't
deal too much with them, the sheriff's department. I'm not for moving this forward. I
don't think we need it -- need it right now for a lot of reasons, privacy, et cetera. And
Page 59 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
my direction would be to not do anything with it. Thank you.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: While I agree we don't have the budget for it, we're the ones that
would be responsible for paying for it, so I think it really is our decision and within our
scope. I don't see any reason we can't pass it. It's -- it's basically -- it's a nonevent.
However, if we ever needed to reapproach it, we could certainly do that at that point in
time. So I'll move on and --
KALIVIANAKIS: Thank you, Mr. Mayor. And you kind of just made my point. Just like
we've been talking about all day, we're writing ordinances in anticipation of something
that hasn't happened, that if it does happen, we'll happen to have an ordinance on the
book. Once again, we're creating a solution. We're not addressing a problem. Fountain
Hills doesn't have Flock cameras. We have no plans to install Flock cameras. And to my
knowledge, Maricopa County Sheriff's Office hasn't approached us about setting them
up in this town. So I'm struggling to understand why we would direct staff in the
sheriff's office.
And on that note, I did write the town manager, and I asked that if we are going to have
this conversation, it is imperative that we have the input of Maricopa County Sheriff's
Office to see what they think about this issue. It's imperative. And also, I'd like a staff
report so the staff can digest the pros and cons of this.
And again, we're served up an ordinance with no staff report, written by a council
member with no discussion other than it might be a good idea. There might be a
legitimate policy discussion to have if something happens in the future. I agree with
that. Right now it feels like we're just debating a hypothetical issue.
This is like something you do in high school or college where you have a debate team,
and you argue one way or the other way, and then see -- see who wins, or moot court in
law school. It's just arguing for the sake of arguing. Our staff's time is valuable.
Maricopa County's time is valuable. Our town attorney's time is very valuable. I would
prefer that we spend time addressing actual issues from our town.
If you know the pros of Flock cameras, crime solving, real-time alerts, cross-jurisdiction
coordination, vehicle identification, you know, people with Alzheimer's or dementia that
Page 60 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
are driving around, the families are like, we have to get this person back. There's a lot of
reasons to have it. There's a lot of cons, mass surveillance, tracking, privacy,
constitutional concerns, police misuse, stalking, high costs, security and vandalism of the
equipment. Again, you can make two good sides for this, but -- but what we have to do
is why assign staff --
LARRABEE: Point of order.
KALIVIANAKIS: -- this much --
LARRABEE: If we cut off some, we should cut off all.
KALIVIANAKIS: Well, it's only 14 seconds, but I'll be quiet, Hannah, because you told me
to.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Councilmember Skillicorn?
SKILLICORN: Thank you, Mr. Mayor. There was something brought up about law
enforcement, specifically Maricopa Sheriff. And, you know, and I am completely
supportive of law enforcement, our sheriff, the police departments. But I will also
stipulate that it's pretty safe to say that the Maricopa County Sheriff's Department
would not support this.
And I'm okay with that, because I think the -- the concerns of protecting privacy will
outweigh their lack of support for this. And -- and frankly, I have not had a conversation
with the -- with Sheriff Sheridan about this, but I'm happy to -- I'm happy to text him and
ask him. And I certainly expect him to say that he would not support this.
But that doesn't change my opinion, and that doesn't change the fact that I'm here to
protect the privacy of people. And I hope that this council also wants to protect the
privacy of people. And it's not just law enforcement. I don't like the idea of private
companies encroaching on our right-of-way.
I don't like private companies controlling the data and compiling lists, and we don't
know how long that information is going to be complied. We also don't know what they
do with that data and who they sell it to. And I really want to respect the privacy of
people. And I'm sure that many people don't want the idea of Big Brother watching
them either. And that's why this was drafted.
Page 61 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
And you know, again, we have had, you know, a couple days' opportunities to discuss
this. And so Mr. Mayor, procedurally, I'd like to ask the town attorney, I know this was
tabled. A motion was made, it was seconded, it was an action item. You know, what is
the next step here? It seems odd that a tabled item comes back as a nonagendized
action item.
LA SOTA: Mr. Mayor, Councilmember, I think what happened is the -- the third person
said they wanted it brought back for discussion, I think in response to some council
comments. But I think there have been three people tonight who have said that -- that
they want it brought forward as an action item. So I think under the rules of procedure,
I think it's brought forward as a -- as an action item at a subsequent council meeting.
SKILLICORN: Okay. And Mr. Mayor, just as a, you know, one thought, I know this was
something that I brought up twice, and I think that the -- the seconds and thirds weren't
consistent across. So there was, you know, there was more than just three, you know,
that offered a second for the new agenda item. That's all.
WATTS: I think I'd like to know more information. And I think that's the reason that we
didn't have the information. We still don't have it. MCSO, whether they give us the
pros and cons, how are we going to put bumpers around what can and can't be the
ingress and egress into the town? What can we control?
Who owns the -- I mean, there's a plethora of questions that have not been answered
yet. So I would like more input. I'd like to hear from MCSO, and I'd like to know the
financial aspects of it, how we're going to be able to do it without that information. So I
can't support the ordinance as it stands today, but I certainly don't want the
infringement on my right to privacy.
I don't want it -- in one part of the country, the -- the automatic license plate readers
were integrated into Ring cameras. I don't want the Ring cameras looking at people up
and down my street and then being able to access that information. So we've got to
find a way to put bumpers around some of this. How do we do that? Is there an aspect
that could be beneficial to the town? Maybe.
What's the impact if it's $25,000 per license plate reader for -- between the solar aspect,
Page 62 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
the installation, the -- the groundwork that has to be done, all of those things? That's a
lot of money that I know we don't have money for at this point. So I'd like more
information. And then I think we should move forward based on that information.
Then we got something tangible.
MCMAHON: Thank you, Rick. I appreciate your comments. And I did speak briefly with
Maricopa County Sheriff's Office, and they don't know enough about it, I don't think. No
insult intended. They didn't say they were against it. That's an assumption that I don't
think it's been said, at least not in my conversations. So I -- I -- if this moves forward,
and it sounds like it's going to, I would like a lot more information on it too, because I
know federal law is affected by these as well. Thank you.
EARLE: Okay. Sorry, I turned it off. Okay. So just for transparency, I looked into this
stuff, and my own understanding was the item was tabled after my motion at the last
meeting, and a tabled item can still be alive till the end of the following meeting, which
is tonight.
But something along those lines happened so that that can't happen. We'd have to be
voting on it tonight. But I kind of got tired of fighting it. So that's why I don't know if
that can still happen, or else I will accept that we have it at the next meeting.
LA SOTA: Mayor, Councilmember, it's not agendized for action tonight, so I wouldn't
advise taking action on it.
KALIVIANAKIS: Thank you, Mr. Mayor. I'll be brief. There are two -- two things said that
I'd like to question, and one of them was a private company comes in and puts these
things on and violates all of our privacy. Could a private company come onto Fountain
Hills right-of-ways and property and install these cameras?
GOODWIN: Not without our permission. Sorry, not without our authorization.
KALIVIANAKIS: Right. They can't do it anyway, so why are we talking about it? That's
my first point. They can't come onto our property and install the readers like was
insinuated. And the second thing is with the town attorney, to put an item on the
future agenda, it takes three, but I think tonight it would take four. Four. And you said
it would take three to go forward. I think this would be a consensus vote, and I think we
Page 63 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
would need four to get a consensus to go forward. Am I correct?
LA SOTA: Mayor, Councilmember, the rules of procedure, I think, always provide the
avenue for three members of the council to bring something forward. I would say it's
similar to -- I mean, most -- most municipalities have a provision like that.
Most courts have a provision where something less than a majority is what's taken to
take up an issue. The U.S. Supreme Court's four. I think the Arizona Supreme Court's
three. So it's less than a majority. Your rules of procedure always allow three members
to bring an item forward, and you have a future agenda item. So I think once three have
spoken, it goes on the agenda.
KALIVIANAKIS: Okay, and maybe I can -- maybe we can get the town manager to weigh
in on this, but I've been on this council for four years, and at this point, consensus
means four. At the end of the night, you can put it on a future agenda for three. And
either I'm really confused or I'm right.
GOODWIN: This is part of where all of this confusion is lying with this agenda item in
general, just so we know, just to be clear that there's been motions and then
subsequent motions and then tabling and different things. So I believe I want to second
what Vice Mayor Earle said, which is transparency. I want to make sure we get this right
and everybody comes back with expecting, and I know what needs to come back, and
our staff knows what needs to come back.
So to answer your question, yes, consensus would mean four. However, I'm going to
caveat that, because at the same time, he's also correct in that we have a future agenda
item, and my assumption would be there would be a motion at the future agenda to
say, I'd like to see this come back with these edits, and it would be supported by two
others. So it's sort of six one way, half a dozen the other. We're still getting to the end
result, whether it happens on this item or it happens on item 12.
KALIVIANAKIS: Yeah. And I -- I just want us to follow the correct procedure. I -- I -- so
and going forward, I would hate to establish a precedent that something gets agendized,
comes for discussion, and then three people can get the ordinance written. That should
take four.
Page 64 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
GOODWIN: If we do not have consensus on that at this item, then yes, it would come
back at item 12.
KALIVIANAKIS: Thank you.
GOODWIN: I'd like to follow up with that, if -- if I may, Mayor, is that we also have a
number of folks who would like to hear from MCSO. I count three this evening. We can
certainly work with MCSO to be -- to be part of that and be back on our November 17th
agenda as part of this item, assuming this item comes back. Is that what we would like
to see? Okay. I can certainly work with them.
I don't believe it'll be Lieutenant Vance (ph.) that will be doing that presentation, unless
you'd like me to volunteer you. There's probably someone else within the -- the district
or within the sheriff's office that probably has more authority or more familiarity with
license plate reading cameras, so I can certainly reach out to organize that. Is there any
other direction from this item? And I believe there may be some public comment.
There may be some speaker cards.
SKILLICORN: Thank you, Mr. Mayor. And I don't know if a little liberty is -- is necessary,
but I know that Councilman Watts had, you know, some questions. I still stipulate that I
believe that whoever the representative from MCSO would not oppose this. That
doesn't change my opinion on it.
And I don't even know if that's worth the time because they're probably going to say
that they don't support it. They'll rattle off a bunch of reasons, which may be quite
legitimate, but I don't think that overweighs privacy concerns. And I don't know if that's
worth their time or our time here, but you know, that's -- that's neither here nor there.
But I know Councilman Watts, you know, he mentioned a couple of things.
So I mean, I think we're all in agreement that we want to -- so the Ring cameras do not
apply. That's on private property. We don't have any control of that. We have control
over the right-of-way and town-owned property, and that would be it. And this is an
ordinance that would not allow them to be in here in the future. So they -- they should
ask for our permission to put them in, right?
But this would actually have the policy come from the board, because this could be
Page 65 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
done by, you know, calling up and just being allowed to by someone on staff. This is
very different. This would be the policy of the board. The board would set the policy.
And I do not recall off the top of my head what your other questions were. So if you
don't mind sharing, more than happy to discuss.
WATTS: My concerns were the financial aspect, the data acquisition, what we're going
to do with it, who it's available to, what it can integrate to, the positives and the
negatives. And you may be right about MCSO not having an opinion, but that doesn't
mean they can't help us craft bumpers around what we've already proposed in the
ordinance. Maybe it is just, like I said, on the ingress, egress to the town at various
points. Maybe that has some benefits. But I think it's worthy of staff looking into it a
little further, understanding the financial aspects.
And yeah, they got to get a permit if they wanted to put something on private property,
but that doesn't preclude them from soliciting individuals and saying, can I access your
Ring camera? So there's things like that that I think are worthy of discussion to figure
out whether or not we can -- what we should do. I'm not an advocate for automated
license plate readers. I like the -- the -- I like my privacy. So having said that, I want to
do it right to make sure we don't do something -- that we do something that's beneficial
to the town and not injurious to us.
SKILLICORN: And Mr. Mayor, Councilman Watts, you first -- you first mentioned was
financial. So this would be an ordinance that prevents the automatic license plate
reader companies, the private corporations that come in, they would not allow them to
utilize right-of-way in town park property. So for us, there would be no financial impact.
We wouldn't be paying them anything. They wouldn't be paying us anything. There'd
be no financial impact. We do not have the power --
MCMAHON: Is this part of the ordinance that we're not supposed to be talking about?
SKILLICORN: It's agendized for discussion, and I would appreciate you not interrupting
me, please.
UNIDENTIFIED SPEAKER: Ordinance is attached.
SKILLICORN: If you're -- if you're confused, Councilwoman, you can read the ordinance.
Page 66 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
MCMAHON: I can do what?
SKILLICORN: You can read the ordinance. So the power -- the town does not have the
power to regulate what people can do with their property, with their Ring cameras. So
we do not have the authority to tell homeowners they cannot use their Ring cameras or
sell the data or whatever. We can only police ourselves. So really there's, you know, no
financial ramifications here to the town, because we are prohibiting them, and we do
not have the power to prohibit the people from having their own on their own property.
Does that help answer that?
WATTS: To some degree. I still think that we ought to get a little more information and
understand the overall impact, what we should do, what we shouldn't do. And I really
haven't gotten the opinion from the town attorney what the ordinance is today in his
estimation. Is it enforceable? Should we do it? I think there's more questions than
answers right now. I appreciate what you said. I just want more, and I want to be
proactive, but I want to be proactive in a constructive way.
SKILLICORN: Okay. And Mr. Mayor, Councilman, this was -- this was actually more done
with the previous, you know, Jen Wright, Attorney Wright. And there's actually -- this
is -- this is the fourth revision to it to kind of find the balance of what would be
something that would fit Fountain Hills but not be, you know, too -- too overly
aggressive. That's kind of where this balance was struck. More than willing to share,
you know, the discussions and notes with -- with both Attorney La Sota and yourself.
That's not a problem.
WATTS: I'd love to see that. And I think that's what we should do so we can move it
forward, getting more input from the staff, getting your information, and then --
SKILLICORN: No problem.
WATTS: -- get it back on the agenda and do it again.
SKILLICORN: No problem. So there is -- there is a question of how to agendize this in
the future. And I -- I do want to ask. So this was tabled, and I would think you'd take a
tabled item and you would put it back on the agenda as -- as it was. So it was agendized
as action. It had a first and a second. I don't know who agendized it as discussion only.
Page 67 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
GOODWIN: I can share a little bit of background there. So when the motion was made
to table for further discussion, because that's exactly what was -- the motion that was
made, the ask to the town attorney was, can we do that? I was always -- I agree, the
impression I had was that we needed to bring it back as -- as it was originally presented.
However, under guidance, we were told, if that was the motion that was made, then to
bring back for discussion was appropriate.
So again, for clarity's sake, it's very helpful to make sure that we know what we're taking
away from the discussion up here. So in the future, I'll be certain to make sure that
everybody understands that that's how things will be coming back based on the motions
that are made. As we talked about, sometimes the language is a little more formal.
Sometimes when you say discussion, discussion means something. Sometimes taking
action or consideration means something different than what you might think. So we
want to make sure that we have the correct language. So we can certainly clarify that
moving forward.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Town Manager, I wonder if it would be -- it appears this is going to
come back, if it would be allowed to have a meeting with the council members that are
interested in hearing MCSO's perspective, have a meeting before the next council
meeting, so they have that information. They're armed with it by the time they come to
the next meeting. Is that something we can do?
GOODWIN: I can certainly reach out to MCSO to find out if that's available. I will say, if
we do have a quorum, we'll need to do it as a public meeting or as a work session or
something in that nature.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: I think you'll probably have three people there, is my guess, but you
can -- so it won't be -- it won't be a quorum.
WATTS: You could do it individually too, much like we do review of building permits and
that kind of thing.
GOODWIN: Sure, we can certainly do that. I just want to be respectful of their time as
well. So let me do a little legwork on that.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: I think you'll have three people that are interested in more
Page 68 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
information.
MCMAHON: And --
KALIVIANAKIS: I'd like to be one of those people, by the way.
MCMAHON: Okay. In that vein, what I wanted -- not to throw a monkey wrench in it,
because there's so much detail. There's a lot of information about this. I was
wondering if we could give the staff the liberty of saying whether or not a work session
might be more in order than just a meeting, so to speak, because they're going to delve
into this.
And I want -- I think that if they think that a work session would be better and more
appropriate for us to have that discussion, then I'd like to be open to that as well.
SKILLICORN: Thank you, Mr. Mayor. You know, this -- this discussion, how it's kind of
evolved, feels to me like a delay tactic. And justice delayed is justice denied. And
there's a couple individuals that have -- have an agenda here politically to disrupt and
delay and try to throw a wrench into the works. And it happens over and over again.
And I'm just concerned that they're trying to delay this past the November 17th
meeting.
KALIVIANAKIS: Oh, the words of the politician. Trying to get information from the
Maricopa County Sheriff's Office and our staff on something that's going to be
agendized and turns into an ordinance is a delay tactic, just because we don't blindly
sign up to the ordinance that you wrote? That's ridiculous. And I -- and I don't
appreciate the fact that you say, just because I want to make an informed vote, that I'm
somehow delaying this, and it's a political stunt. The people that make political stunts in
this town is you, Allen Skillicorn.
EARLE: Point of order. Thank you. Thank you, Mayor.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Okay. I think you have direction on this. Thank you. We'll move on to
the -- any -- any comment cards on this, please?
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Yes, Mayor, we do. We have two. First up is Larry Myers (ph.),
followed by Shelby Blecher.
MYERS: Council, Mayor, Larry Myers, resident. First of all, I'd like to apologize for even
Page 69 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
mentioning that it should have been passed on to the next meeting, because my
intention was that you would discuss and -- discuss and act on it. And I asked you to
pass it as written. I was in favor of passing it as written.
Quite frankly, I don't care what MCSO says.
Long before any of this technology was available, they were enforcing the law, and they
can just go back to enforcing the law. I don't want my data collected and stored by any
private company and possibly sold, unless they want to make a deal with me and give
me a cut. I definitely don't want the government storing my -- my data, because who
knows what they do with it.
And so I don't really care what MCSO says, and neither should you. You should be
protecting me and the rest of the citizens who voted for you all. We're not here to hear
what MCSO has to say about this hotbed of crime in Fountain Hills and whether we need
to track people's license plates coming in and out of this town. We're not here for that.
We're here to discuss private citizens' data being stored by private companies or
government agencies. And I want none of either of it. And I thought the ordinance was
written well enough to be point-blank, say that that's what it is.
Now, we can probably push this off for another five years like we did the 5G with all of
this nonsense that's going on here. And I didn't -- I gave Councilwoman McMahon her
due, because she did have questions.
Why didn't you get the questions answered before we came to this meeting? Or why
didn't you have MCSO present their point of view here at this meeting and then vote on
it? I am totally offended that this was agendized as discussion only, and now we have to
go to another meeting or go to a work session and then get to another meeting, and
God knows when it will take place. But I'm -- I'm -- I wish you would just put the
ordinance in effect.
And this nonsense about not having ordinances because we don't have a problem -- you
write ordinances to keep yourself from having problems. That's why we have the
wireless ordinance. That's why we have all the other ordinances in town. We don't
write them when we have a problem. We write them to keep from having a problem.
Page 70 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
So that theory about all of the ordinances that get put forth is total nonsense.
And I'm just tired of hearing it. I'm tired of hearing it. Ordinances are to protect the
residents of this town and to enforce the town's plan, not -- not to address things that
have happened or are happening. So I wish you would just get on with it. Pass it as --
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Time.
MYERS: As Councilman Skillicorn wrote it with our previous attorney and get on with it.
Thank you.
BLECHER: Mr. Mayor, Councilmember, Shelby Blecher, resident of Fountain Hills.
Privacy rights, crime solving, public property, private property. As many of you know,
the area that I lived in, in L.A., Melrose Village, had 27 Flock cameras there. They're
funded strictly, solely by the residents that lived in that neighborhood. Beverly Grove,
about a half a mile from me, had 40 homes broken into in three months. They begged
the councilmember to use some of her discretionary funds to help fund the Flock
cameras for them. Now, Flock cameras are a special item.
My relationships with people in the LAPD, senior lead officers that have told us that
armed robberies on Melrose solved that same day by being able to find the perpetrator.
Carjackings with a baby in the backseat solved the same day. Various other home
invasions in the Melrose area solved within a couple of days with the use of Flock
cameras. Mark this day in history. I'm going to be agreeing with Councilmember
McMahon twice in one day.
Now, I had a conversation with Sean Dao (ph.), who's a real estate agent, and he told
me that he has access to my driving habits because he's an insurance agent. So I asked
this question to an AI agent, Gemini, is my insurance agent granted access to the Flock
system to review my driving habits and record? And here's the answer I got.
"No, your insurance agent does not have access to the Flock Safety camera system to
monitor your driving habits or your record. Flock Safety operates a closed network of
automated license plate readers, ALPRs, strictly for law enforcement, public safety
agencies, select neighborhood HOAs, and commercial properties. The company
explicitly states that it does not sell or share its data with third parties, including
Page 71 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
insurance companies, private investigators, or repossession companies."
So what Sean Dao had shared with me were third parties that were operating their own
ALPRs that were collecting data and selling them to insurance agencies and whoever the
highest bidder was. $2,500 a camera. The town's not going to have that. There's no
reason to even vote on this.
But if this town started to suffer from armed robberies on the avenue and residents
were en masse robbed, their homes were robbed because they were snowbirds out of
town on whatever, I guarantee you people are going to be sitting there screaming, how
can we catch these people? What can we do to catch these people? Why did we write
an ordinance to ban Flock cameras that would have helped us catch these people?
Thank you.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Any -- any others?
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: No, Mayor.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: So I also -- I also, just to be clear, I also support this coming back on
the 17th.
KALIVIANAKIS: To be clear, I don't -- I don't know if we're taking an informal vote, but I
don't support it.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Okay. Thank you. We'll move on then to the call to the public. Do we
have any speakers?
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: Yes, Mayor, we do. First up is Kim Bartman, followed by Reverend
David Felten.
BARTMAN: Kim Bartman, Fountain Hills. I -- I like what Rick Watts, Councilman Watts,
said about taking lemons and make lemonade.
And I -- there's an opportunity that we could arrange to have the Islamic Speakers
Bureau of Arizona do a work session with you to learn more about Islam and dispel the
myths. We have contact information for Azra Hussain, who's the head of the Islamic
Speakers Bureau. They're also -- just to let you know about, just real quickly, about
what they offer and their kind of just -- their mission real quick.
The Islamic Speakers Bureau of Arizona is a nonprofit, apolitical educational
Page 72 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
organization founded in 1999. It's called ISBA. ISBA is an outreach institution that
provides education about Islam and other faiths, builds cultural awareness, and
promotes interfaith dialogue and collaboration.
And then their mission, using the tools of education, civic -- civic engagement,
constructive dialogue, ISBA will foster communities of respect and mutual
understanding. ISBA reinforces and promotes the American ideals of inclusion and
religious freedom that are all embodied in the First Amendment of the United States
Constitution. And you can either contact Pastor David Felten at the Fountains United
Methodist Church or myself, Kim Bartman, and I would be happy to help arrange that.
Thank you.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Thank you. Next speaker.
FELTEN: Reverend David Felten, the Fountains United Methodist, continuing the
promotion of the Islamic Speakers Bureau of Arizona. I want to point out that this
Thursday night, in relevance to our discussion tonight, that ISBA is offering an online
Zoom session presented by one of their imams, Imam Saraya Ismail (ph.), on how
Muslims understand religious law.
Might be something you might want to dial into. It's at 6:30 p.m. this Thursday night.
You can access it by going to the Islamic Speakers Bureau of Arizona and signing up for
this free Zoom session for one hour.
And I would be happy to receive a phone call from any of you afterwards to discuss any
questions you might have further about the relationship between Islam and Christianity.
To that end, I'd like to invite you personally all to be present on November 22nd, which
is a Sunday afternoon, at 2 p.m. at the Fountains, right here on Fountain Hills Boulevard.
We have our 17th annual interfaith Thanksgiving service celebrating Thanksgiving with
representatives from all the different faith groups here in Fountain Hills, including Islam,
Judaism, LDS, Baha'i, Sikh, Jain.
We have everybody coming out, and we would really love for you to come there and
meet some of your neighbors who are other faiths than what most of the town council
practices.
Page 73 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
And I can guarantee to Councilmember Rick Watts that if you pledge right now to be
there on November 22nd, that I will guarantee you an ice-cold glass of lemonade. I'll
see you there. 2 p.m. There are Catholics there. Plenty of Catholics. I still have 56
seconds to wait.
UNIDENTIFIED SPEAKER: Say yes.
FELTEN: 15300 North Fountain Hills Boulevard. And our website is weputlovefirst.org.
You can find out all about it. I'll look forward to seeing you. Thanks.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Thank you.
PADGETT-ESPIRITU: No, Mayor, no further comments.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Any other speakers? No? Okay. Thank you. We'll move on now with
council discussion and direction to the town manager. Does anybody have anything?
And how about future agenda items? Does anybody have anything?
EARLE: Thank you, Mayor. So I know we did have four people, but I want to just cover
my bases here to make sure that everything is legal and nobody questions it.
So I'm asking on the next -- or I'll say a future agenda, I'm hoping it's next time, that I'm
requesting the staff and the town attorney to review the draft Ordinance No. 26-17
from tonight's agenda packet and bring it back at our next meeting for consideration
and action, with the recital referencing other Arizona jurisdictions deleted. Do I have
the support of two additional council members?
SKILLICORN: Second.
LARRABEE: Third.
EARLE: Thank you.
SKILLICORN: Thank you, Mr. Mayor. I would like to make a motion and hopefully have
two additional council members for a discussion item on policy about zoning for
multiple use and hotels in the downtown district.
LARRABEE: I'd like to hear more, so I second.
SKILLICORN: Fortunately, I cannot -- it's not agendized, so I cannot discuss or answer
questions.
KALIVIANAKIS: I move to adjourn.
Page 74 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
MCMAHON: Thank you. Future agenda items. I know that there's a -- I feel as though,
and this is no insult to anybody, where are we doing the town business?
It just -- I, you know, there's, I think, a lot of projects in the works. I don't think -- I don't
feel like we've seen a lot of things in the last month or so. So I would like to see the
work that the staff's doing and bring those critical items up so that we can take a look at
it and get those projects moved forward. Thank you.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: Okay. We had a motion for adjournment. Do I have a second?
UNIDENTIFIED SPEAKER: Second.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: All in favor?
ALL: Aye.
MAYOR FRIEDEL: We're adjourned. Thank you.
Page 75 of 76

Town of Fountain Hills
OCTOBER 20, 2026 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
Having no further business, Mayor Gerry Friedel adjourned the regular meeting of the
Town Council at 8:30 p.m.
APPROVED:
____________________________________
GERRY FRIEDEL, MAYOR
ATTEST:
_________________________________________
ANGELA PADGETT-ESPIRITU, DEPUTY TOWN CLERK
CERTIFICATION
I HEREBY CERTIFY THAT THE FOREGOING MINUTES ARE A TRUE AND CORRECT COPY OF
THE MINUTES OF THE REGULAR TOWN COUNCIL MEETING OF THE TOWN COUNCIL,
FOUNTAIN HILLS, ARIZONA HELD ON OCTOBER 20, 2026. I FURTHER CERTIFY THAT THE
MEETING WAS DULY CALLED AND HELD AND THAT A QUORUM WAS PRESENT.
_________________________________________
ANGELA PADGETT-ESPIRITU, DEPUTY TOWN CLERK
Page 76 of 76