Extracted text (via pymupdf_layout)
15974 characters
ITEM 9.e. TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS STAFF REPORT Meeting Date: 11/17/2026 Meeting Type: Town Council Regular Meeting Submitting Department: Development Services / Planning Prepared by: Farhad Tavassoli, Senior Planner Staff Contact Information: Phone: 480-816-5139 Email: ftavassoli@fountainhillsaz.gov Request to Town Council Regular Meeting (Agenda Language) PUBLIC HEARING, with CONSIDERATION AND POSSIBLE ACTION: Regarding the REZONE of approximately 3.22 acres generally located at the northwest corner of N. Saguaro Boulevard and E. Paul Nordin Parkway (12800 N. Saguaro Blvd; APN 176-25-560) from C-2 – Intermediate Commercial Zoning District to TCCD – Town Center Commercial Zoning District with the intent to convert a portion of the hotel rooms to residential units (Case RZ26-000003). Staff Summary (background) The owner of the Fountain Park Hotel, located at the northwest corner of Saguaro Boulevard and Paul Nordin Parkway, is requesting a rezoning from C-2 (Intermediate Commercial) to TCCD (Town Center Commercial District). The purpose of the request is to allow the conversion of 46 existing hotel rooms on the top floor of the three-story building into residential units. Under the current C-2 zoning, residential use is not permitted, and hotel rooms must continue to operate as transient-use units with stays limited to 30 days. In 2022, the property owner began efforts to convert parts of the building to residential use by applying for building permits to install kitchenettes. Those permits were issued in early 2023. However, staff later clarified that a Special Use Permit is required before any hotel room can legally be converted to a residential unit. The addition of kitchenettes alone does not create a zoning violation, but residential occupancy cannot occur until a rezoning or other formal entitlement authorizes that use. When a potential buyer of the property began pursuing residential conversions in 2022, staff reviewed the zoning history and found that the property was zoned C-2, not TCCD. The adjacent property had been rezoned from C-2 to TCCD in 2008. Staff found that in 2011 the maps had been changed to include this parcel in the TCCD zoning district. With that correction, the potential buyer proceeded to seek the appropriate entitlement, applying for the Special Use Permit required to establish residential units within the building. Constructed in 2005, the hotel has experienced declining occupancy and operational challenges in recent years. In May 2023, the Planning and Zoning Commission heard a request for a special use permit to allow conversion of the hotel to apartment use. However, the Commission voted 5–1 to recommend denial of the Special Use Permit, primarily due to the desire to preserve the hotel use, unresolved design and livability concerns, questionable affordability claims, and inconsistency with long-term downtown planning goals. The current owner, who purchased the property in 2019, is now proposing another repositioning of the property, including converting 46 hotel rooms into apartment units. The earlier concept from 2022 envisioned converting all 90 existing studio and one-bedroom hotel rooms, along with four short-term rental units. The current rezoning request represents a continuation of that effort by establishing zoning that accommodates residential use within the existing building while the lower floors will continue to operate as hotel rooms. Current Zoning The property has been designated C-2 zoning since the earliest phases of Fountain Hills’ development. Section 12.01 of the Zoning Ordinance states the following with regard to the purpose of this zoning district: D. C-2. Intermediate Commercial Zoning District: The principal purpose of this Zoning District is to provide for the sale of commodities and the performance of services and other activities in locations for which the market area extends beyond the immediate residential neighborhoods. Principal uses permitted in this Zoning District include furniture stores, hotels and motels, restaurants, and some commercial recreation and cultural facilities such as movies and instruction in art and music. This Zoning District is designed for application at major street intersections. This zoning district serves as the Town’s primary commercial zone and accommodates a broad range of commercial uses. Residential uses, however, require approval through either a special use permit or a zone change. In 2023, the applicant sought a special use permit to convert all 90 hotel rooms into residential units, but the Commission recommended denial before the owner withdrew the application. Current Zoning Map; subject property outlined green General Plan The General Plan includes the following Goals and Policies: Neighborhoods Element GOAL 2: Support a housing strategy that encourages a broad range of quality housing types to address current and future housing needs and to support long-term economic vitality. POLICIES 1. Encourage a broad range of housing types affordable to all income ranges and age groups in a manner compatible with adjacent development. 2. Encourage a range of housing types and residential densities and maintain consistency with the existing character of infill areas in conformance with criteria provided in Table 1: Character Areas Plan. 5. Direct higher-density residential and mixed-used development to the Town Center and redevelopment areas such as Shea Corridor as opportunities arise. Character Areas Element GOAL 1: Encourage future development, redevelopment and infill in a manner that will maintain and protect existing neighborhoods, the Town’s economic health, community well- being, and natural environment. POLICIES 1. Achieve and maintain a diverse and sustainable land use mix consistent with our small- town character that supports thriving neighborhoods, environment and economy by attracting and retaining revenue-generating uses that: a. Enhance the Town’s economic vitality; and b. Increase the Town’s revenue base to maintain quality infrastructure, services and amenities. GOAL: 2: Development, redevelopment and infill support Fountain Hills' small-town identity and the distinct character of each area while fostering long-term viability. POLICIES 3. Support a mix of residential, employment, and commercial uses at densities and intensities and in the development form that reflect the small-Town character of Fountain Hills. 5. Strongly encourage a wide range of housing types, densities and prices to support the current and projected populations (particularly families and working professionals) and to ensure the future stock of affordable housing for all income ranges. 6. Require that development, redevelopment, and infill conform with Exhibit 2, Character Areas Plan map, and Table 1. The Fountain Hills General Plan 2020 designates this area as part of the Town Center character area. This area is designed to have a highly integrated mix of uses to provide a vibrant town center. Active ground floor uses are encouraged to provide activity on the street level. Office and residential uses are encouraged on upper floors. GOAL 4: Allow the Town Center to achieve its full potential. POLICIES 1. Market the Town Center to attract a variety of employment, office, cultural, institutional, mixed-use, lodging, commercial, entertainment and recreational opportunities. 2. Attract and retain small and medium-sized businesses to mixed-use projects in the Town Center to promote day and evening activities. 3. Require mixed-use development within Town Center to incorporate commercial or office uses at the street level, with high-density residential on upper floors. Downtown Strategy The subject property is located within the Avenue District as identified in the Downtown Strategy approved by the Town Council in September 2024. The Strategy envisions the Avenue District as the Town’s primary urban core: a walkable, mixed-use environment designed to support continuous activity, enhance pedestrian experiences, and strengthen the cultural and economic heart of Fountain Hills. It emphasizes creating a vibrant setting with active ground-floor uses, shaded gathering areas, and high-quality public spaces that encourage people to dine, shop, and enjoy local events. Downtown Center Map; subject property outlined in black Proposed Zoning and Analysis The applicant has now submitted a request to rezone the property to TCCD - Town Center Commercial District. Section 18.01 states the following with regard to the purpose of this zoning district: Town Center Commercial Zoning District: The principal purpose of this zoning district is to provide for a variety of pedestrian-oriented retail, office, lodging, residential and civic land uses in the Town Center area. The intent of the district is to encourage the development and sustainability of a vibrant mixed-use area where residents and visitors can live, work, shop, dine, be entertained, enjoy community and cultural events and contribute to the economic viability of the Town Center area and the Town as a whole. The current proposal would convert slightly more than half of the units to residential use and includes a request to rezone the property to TCCD, which is consistent with the zoning of the adjacent parcel to the north and much of Plaza Fountainside across Saguaro Boulevard to the southeast. The owner intends to continue operating the remaining rooms as hotel accommodations. With 46 residential units on a 3.22-acre property, the proposed density is 14.3 dwelling units per acre, well below the 48.6 units per acre permitted in the TCCD district. The project would also contain less than 50 percent multifamily residential gross floor area, remaining within the TCCD district’s maximum allowance. The first floor of the building may not be used for residential under the TCCD Zoning District. The General Plan and Downtown Area Specific Plan both emphasize creating an active and vibrant town center. A hotel contributes to this goal by accommodating visitors who come to enjoy the town center, local festivals and events, and Fountain Park. With the remaining phases of Park Place moving toward development, there are no other large sites available in the town center that could support a full-service hotel. According to the applicant’s Best and Highest Use Report from 2023, however, the property has struggled for years as a hotel, while market studies indicate strong demand for smaller apartments that meet the needs of local workers and new residents seeking transitional housing. The General Plan encourages a wide variety of housing options, and one of the challenges identified during economic development planning is the lack of housing options for lower-wage workers. Because many Fountain Hills employers are service-based, and the average service worker earns around $40,000 annually, the limited supply of diverse and attainable housing has made hiring and retaining employees more difficult for local businesses. Increasing housing opportunities within the Town Center would help address this imbalance. Additionally, with several vacant buildings and properties nearby, more residents living within walking distance would bring continuous vitality and support for local businesses. Approval of a rezone from C-2 to TCCD has been granted several times in the Town Center area since the Town Center Commercial District was introduced in 1998. This demonstrates that such rezonings are consistent with established development patterns in the Downtown Area. The Downtown Strategy specifically identifies the Avenue District as a key part of the Town’s primary urban core, and rezoning the subject property as proposed is aligned with that vision. As a result, applying the TCCD zoning to this site would be both contextually appropriate and supportive of the development pattern envisioned for the Avenue District. Citizen Participation Plan The applicant mailed a Notice of Application, attached to this report, to all property owners within 300 feet of the site on August 27. The notice included contact information so that residents could submit comments or ask questions. To date, the Town has received two email inquiries from residents seeking clarification on the proposal. However, as of the publication of this report, no formal comments have been submitted to Town staff. A Citizen Participation Report documenting the results of their outreach efforts is also attached. Related Ordinance, Policy or Guiding Principle Fountain Hills General Plan 2020 Downtown Area Specific Plan Zoning Ordinance Section 2.02, Special Use Permits Zoning Ordinance Chapter 12, Commercial Districts Risk Analysis Staff finds that the proposal meets the criteria in the ordinance for approval of the requested zone change. The additional housing geared to workers in the Town Center area will add a needed housing type envisioned in the General Plan and Downtown Strategy. Recommendation(s) by Board(s) or Commission(s) On October 12, 2026, the Planning and Zoning Commission voted 4–2 to recommend denial of the rezone request. Commissioners expressed concern that eliminating hotel rooms would not serve the Town’s long-term interests. They also noted that combining hotel rooms and residential units within the same building could create inherent operational and compatibility conflicts. Staff Recommendation(s) Staff recommends APPROVAL of Case RZ26-000003, a request to rezone approximately 3.22 acres from C-2 (Intermediate Commercial) to TCCD (Town Center Commercial District) to allow up to 46 residential units on the third floor of the proposed development. It should be noted that denial of the rezoning request would not preclude the property owner from converting the upper-floor space, or all of the building, to other nonresidential uses. Under the existing C-2 zoning designation, a variety of commercial uses are permitted, including medical laboratories, insurance agencies, real estate offices, and similar business and professional services. Under the C-2 district, a Special Use Permit could be requested to convert the entire building to residential uses. The TCCD district requires the first floor to always be a nonresidential use and that at least 50% of the floor area to always be a nonresidential use. Therefore, there is more long-term protection for the Town to limit residential use of this property by rezoning to TCCD. Staff believes that introducing residential units on the upper floor has the potential to strengthen the Town Center by increasing the number of residents within walking distance of retail, restaurant, service, and commercial establishments. This added residential presence could help support existing businesses and contribute to the long-term vitality of the Town Center area. Staff also notes that just because the upper floor units may be converted to allow for longer-term occupancies, the building is still designed and approved for hotel use. At any time, if the market supported it, the upper floor units could be rented out as hotel rooms. Suggested Motion The Council may consider one of the following motions: Move to APPROVE Ord. 26-15 rezoning of approximately 3.22 acres generally located at the northwest corner of Saguaro Boulevard and Paul Nordin Parkway (APN 176-25-560) from C-2 (Intermediate Commercial) to TCCD (Town Center Commercial District), with the stipulation that residential development be limited to 46 dwelling units, located only on the third floor; or, Move to DENY Ord. 26-15 rezoning of approximately 3.22 acres generally located at the northwest corner of Saguaro Boulevard and Paul Nordin Parkway (APN 176-25-560) from C-2 (Intermediate Commercial) to TCCD (Town Center Commercial District). ATTACHMENTS 1. Vicinity Map 2. Aerial Map 3. Applicant Narrative 4. Development Plan 5. Citizen Participation Plan 6. Citizen Participation Letter 7. Citizen Participation Report 8. ORD 26-15