Extracted text (via pymupdf_layout)
5453 characters
ITEM 9.f. TOWN OF FOUNTAIN HILLS STAFF REPORT Meeting Date: 11/17/2026 Meeting Type: Town Council Regular Meeting Submitting Department: Administration / Administrative Services Prepared by: Tim La Sota, Town Attorney Mark Iacovino, Town Prosecutor Staff Contact Information: Phone: (602) 515-2649?, Email: tim@timlasota.com, townprosecutor@gmail.com Request to Town Council Regular Meeting (Agenda Language) CONSIDERATION AND POSSIBLE ACTION: Relating to Ordinance 26-22, amending the Fountain Hills Town Code, Chapter 11, OFFENSES, ARTICLE 11-1, by adding SECTION 11-1-18, PROHIBITING PUBLIC URINATION OR DEFECATION. Staff Summary (background) I. Why it Would be Advantageous to Have a Municipal Ordinance Prohibiting Public Urination or Defecation. Proposed Ordinance No. 26-22 would establish a municipal prohibition against urinating or defecating in public. The Fountain Hills Town Code currently contains no provision prohibiting public urination or defecation. As a result, when these cases arise, we must rely on State statutes to prosecute them. The two State laws that can be utilized in these cases are Indecent Exposure (A.R.S. Sec. 13-1402(A)) and Disorderly Conduct (A.R.S. Sec. 13- 2904(A)(1). Both of those statutes have serious drawbacks when applied to a Urinating or Defecating in Public case. If the case is prosecuted under the Indecent Exposure statute, the State must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant exposed his/her genitals to another person present and was reckless about whether the other person would be offended or alarmed by the act. This requires proof that the defendant was aware of the presence of others and intentionally exposed his/her genitals without regard to whether the others present would be offended or alarmed. This also requires proof that one or more of the persons present actually saw the defendant’s exposed genitals. In many Urinating or Defecating in Public cases, the others present do not actually see the defendant’s genitals, even though it is clear that the defendant is urinating or defecating. Another problem with the utilization of the Indecent Exposure statute in these cases is that the statute presumes a sexual motivation for the act of exposing one’s self which suggests that the state legislature did not intend for the Indecent Exposure statute to be used in Urinating or Defecating in Public cases. If the case is prosecuted as Disorderly Conduct, the State must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant’s act of urinating or defecating was “seriously disruptive behavior” under the circumstances present and that the defendant engaged in that conduct with the intent to disturb the peace and quiet of others or with knowledge of doing so. This statute requires proof that the defendant was aware of the presence of others and intended to disturb their peace and quiet, or at least was aware that the other’s peace and quiet would be disturbed by their act of urinating or defecating. Depending on the circumstances, public urination or defecation alone may not establish those elements. Although we have successfully prosecuted Urinating or Defecating in Public cases under both the Indecent Exposure and Disorderly Conduct statutes, it would be much simpler, and more fair to both the defendant and to the public, to prosecute these cases under a municipal ordinance that directly prohibits public urination or defecation. II. What Is Covered By the Proposed Ordinance 26-22. The proposed Ordinance 26-22 is a straightforward prohibition of urination or defecation in any public place, or within public view, except by use of a toilet or other suitable facility. A public place is defined, without limitation, as “town-owned parks, washes and hiking trails and any other place open to the public.” That includes sidewalks, private parking lots, vacant lots that are not access restricted and other places where the public may enter. The proposed ordinance classifies a violation as a class one misdemeanor. The penalty provision of the proposed ordinance provides for a mandatory minimum penalty of a $250.00 fine plus an 83% surcharge ($207.50) and court fees ($127.40) for a total minimum penalty of $584.90. The inclusion of a mandatory minimum penalty is not required but would prevent a convicted defendant from receiving a suspended sentence or a de minimis fine. The penalty provision also provides for restitution to the town for any clean-up costs that may be incurred. Related Ordinance, Policy or Guiding Principle A.R.S. § 13-1402(A) and A.R.S. § 13-2904(A)(1)N/A Risk Analysis N/A Recommendation(s) by Board(s) or Commission(s) N/A Staff Recommendation(s) Staff recommends approval of Ordinance No. 26-22, establishing a prohibition against public urination and defecation. The ordinance addresses a gap in the Town Code by providing a clear and enforceable standard, supporting public health and sanitation, and allowing for consistent enforcement and recovery of cleanup costs. The inclusion of a mandatory minimum fine of $250 is discretionary and subject to Council's consideration and direction. Suggested Motion Move to approve Ordinance 26-22, amending Chapter 11, OFFENSES, ARTICLE 11-1 of the Fountain Hills Town Code by adding SECTION 11-1-18 relating to PUBLIC URINATION OR DEFECATION FISCAL IMPACT Fiscal Impact: N/A Budget Reference: N/A Funding Source: N/A ATTACHMENTS 1. Ord. 26-22 - Public Urination or Defecation-Revised