Supporting Document (2ba37db9...)

City of Scottsdale — Regular Meeting (2026-11-24)

View PDF Meeting page

Extracted text (via pymupdf_layout) 31212 characters
___ _ , - - -- - ----- - - - -
Item 12
CITY COUNCIL
REPORT
Meeting Date: November 24, 2026
General Plan Element: Community Involvement
General Plan Goal: Seek community-wide representation on issues
ACTION
Accept the Audit Committee recommendation for Development Review Board Sunset
Review. Accept the Audit Committee's recommendation and authorize continuation of the
Development Review Board.
BACKGROUND
At its October 21, 2026 meeting, the Audit Committee voted (3-0) to recommend continuation
of the Development Review Board.
In September 2011, the City Council adopted Resolution No. 8823 establishing a Sunset
Review process for its boards and commissions. This resolution directed the Audit Committee
to develop a schedule for reviewing the city's boards and commissions to evaluate whether:
a) The reviewed board or commission is serving its intended purpose;
b) The purpose should be maintained or modified; and
c) The purpose has been served or is no longer required.
Subsequently, the Audit Committee is to recommend to the City Council whether to continue
or terminate the reviewed board or commission.
The Audit Committee confirmed its review process and adopted the current Sunset Review
schedule in May 2024, with the goal of reviewing each applicable board or commission once
every three years. The adopted process requires the City Auditor to notify each board or
commission and its staff liaison of the scheduled review. The City Auditor also collects
background information on the board or commission, including its purpose as stated in City
Code, its annual reports and other information as requested by the Audit Committee, Council
or otherwise deemed relevant. Public comment may also be provided to the Audit Committee
at the scheduled meeting, in written format, or through other means.
For the current review schedule, the Audit Committee has completed 14 Sunset Reviews,
which are listed on page 2.
Action Taken _____________ _

City Council Report | DEVELOPMENT REVIEW BOARD SUNSET REVIEW
Audit Audit
Board/Commission Committee Board/Commission Committee
Review Review Date
Date
Building Advisory Board of Appeals 09/16/2024 Airport Advisory Commission 02/27/2026
Board of Adjustment 09/16/2024 Veterans Advisory Commission 02/27/2026
Environmental Advisory Commission 11/18/2024 Tourism Development Commission 02/27/2026
Historic Preservation Commission 04/11/2025 McDowell Sonoran Preserve Commission 10/21/2026
Human Relations Commission 06/26/2025 Development Review Board 10/21/2026
Judicial Appointments Advisory Board 09/26/2025 Parks & Recreation Commission 12/08/2026
Human Services Advisory Commission 12/12/2025 Planning Commission Jan-Mar2027
Transportation Commission 12/12/2025 Neighborhood Advisory Commission Jan-Mar2027
Paths & Trails Subcommittee (Trans Comm) 12/12/2025 Library Board Jan-Mar2027
ANALYSIS & ASSESSMENT
Policy implications
As provided in Scottsdale’s Zoning Ordinance, Sec. 1.901, Development Review Board’s
purpose is to:
• Review all aspects of the proposed design of a development including, but not limited to,
site planning and the relationship of the development to the surrounding environment and
the community, guided by the Development Review Board criteria.
• Establish design policies and guidelines that support the character and design goals and
policies of the General Plan.
• Recognize the interdependence of land values, aesthetics and good site planning, for it is
a well-known fact that Scottsdale's economic and environmental well-being depends a
great deal upon the distinctive character and natural attractiveness which contribute
substantially to its potential as a recreational resort area and regional trade center.
Further, the ordinance states that development review is intended to enrich the lives of all the
citizens of Scottsdale by promoting harmonious, safe, attractive and compatible development,
and is therefore considered to be in furtherance of public health, safety and general welfare.
Community Involvement
Continuation of this Board allows its members to continue to advise the Council on the City’s
development design matters. Further, this Board allows additional public participation from
Scottsdale citizens and others through its regularly scheduled public meetings.
Page 2 of 3

City Council Report | DEVELOPMENT REVIEW BOARD SUNSET REVIEW
RESOURCE IMPACTS
Staffing, Workload Impact
If continuation is approved, existing city staff will continue supporting the Development
Review Board in meeting its purpose. This support includes serving as staff liaison to schedule
and coordinate board meetings, presenting staff recommendations, maintaining board
records and other such duties. Currently, Planning & Development Area Manager Brad Carr
provides support for the Development Review Board.
OPTIONS & STAFF RECOMMENDATION
Recommended Approach
Accept the Audit Committee’s recommendation and authorize continuation of the
Development Review Board.
Description of Option B
Alternatively, the Council may choose to terminate or modifythe purpose ofthis Board.
Proposed Next Steps
Staff will take any additional steps needed to enact the Council’s action, including notifying
the Development Review Board of the approval or modification of the recommended action.
RESPONSIBLE DEPARTMENTS
City Auditor; Planning & Development Department
STAFF CONTACTS
Shelby Trimaloff. Executive Assistant to the City Auditor, STrimaloff@ScottsdaleAZ.gov
Brad Carr, Planning & Development Area Manager, BCari@ScQttsda^eAZ^ g^^^
APPROVED BY
Lai i Cluff, Cluff, Acting Acting City City, Auditor Date
(480) 312-7851, LCluff@ScottsdaleAZ.gov
ATTACHMENTS
1. Resolution No. 8823
2. Audit Committee marked agenda for October 21,2026 meeting
3. Development Review Board Sunset Review meeting packet
Page 3 of 3

RESOLUTION NO. 8823
A RESOLUTION OF THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SCOTTSDALE.
ARIZONA. DIRECTING THE AUDIT COMMITTEE TO DEVELOP A
SCHEDULE FOR THE PERIODIC REVIEW OF BOARDS AND
COMMISSIONS AND AUTHORIZING THE AUDIT COMMITTEE TO
REVIEW BOARDS AND COMMISSIONS PURSUANT TO THE
ESTABLISHED SCHEDULE AND MAKE RECOMMENDATIONS TO
THE COUNCIL REGARDING THE CONTINUATION OR
TERMINATION OF THE BOARDS AND COMMISSIONS REVIEWED.
WHEREAS, pursuant to Ordinance Nos. 2236. 2304. 2480 and Division 6 of Chapter 2.
Article III of the Scottsdale Revised Code. Section 2-118. the City Council established the Audit
Committee to consult with the City Auditor regarding technical issues, to work to assure
maximum coordination between the work of the City Auditor and the needs of the City Manager
and other charter officers and to perform other duties as required or directed by the City
Council: and
WHEREAS, the City Council desires to establish a schedule for the periodic review of
the City’s boards and commissions to determine whether the boards and commissions are
meeting their intended purpose and whether to continue or terminate such boards and
commissions;
NOW. THEREFORE. BE IT RESOLVED by the Coundl of the City of Scottsdale, as
follows:
Section 1. The City Council hereby authorizes and directs the Audit Cpmmitteie to perform
the following duties pertaining to the City’s boards and commissions;
a) Develop a schedule for reviewing the City’s boards and commissions;
b) Review the City’s boards and commissions in accordance with the established
schedule;
c) Evaluate whether each board and commission reviewed is serving its intended
purpose; wrhetherthe purpose of each board and commission should be maintained
or modified; and whether the purpose of each board and commission has been
served or is no longer required; and
d) Submit to the City Council its recommendations regarding whether to continue or
terminate each board and commission reviewed.
Section 2. Notwithstanding Section 1 of this Resolution, the City Council may terminate a
board or commission at any time.
ATTACHMENT 1
8875244V4

Resolution No. 8823
Page 2 of 2
PASSED AND ADOPTED by the Mayor and Council of the City of Scottsdale this 13“’
day of September, 2011.
ATTEST: CITY OF SCOTT^LE, an
Arizona mupipip^ corporation
Carolyn Jag^r | W.J/'JimUarte
MaVor
APPROVED AS TO FORM:
iceVitashpum
Sty Attorney
By: Jennifer Pollock
Assistant City Attorney
8875244V4

MARKED AGENDA
City of Scottsdale
AUDIT COMMITTEE 30^
**SECOND AMENDED** Regular Meeting- Notice and Agenda
m
[SECOND AMENDED AGENDA: REWORDED Item No. 5 and 6] %
[FIRST AMENDED AGENDA: REWORDED Item No. 1] Jr K
3:30 PM, Wednesday, October 21,2026
City Hall, Kiva Conference Room
3939 N. Drinkwater Blvd., Scottsdale, AZ 85251
Call to Order / Roll Call - 3:34 PM
PRESENT - Councilwoman Maryann McAllen, Chair
PRESENT - Councilman Barry Graham (via video conferencing)
PRESENT- Councilwoman Solange Whitehead (arrived at 3:37 pm)
One or more members of the Audit Committee may attend by telephone, video, or internet conferencing as
allowed by ARS §38-431 (4)
Public Comment-NO SPOKEN OR WRITTEN COMMENTS WERE RECEIVED.
Citizens may address the members of the Audit Committee during Public Comment regarding non-agendized
items and on agendized items when the item is presented. Arizona law prohibits the Audit Committee from
discussing or taking action on an item that is not on the prepared agenda. Public testimony is limited to three
minutes per speaker. Citizens may submit one Request to Speak card per meeting. Written public comment
card may be submitted in-person to city staff for agendized or non-agendized items. Online requests must be
submitted no later than 90 minutes before the start of the meeting.
Meeting presentation slides will be available at least 24 hours before the meeting here.
*1. Approval of June 24. 2026 Regular Meeting Minutes........................................Discussion and Action
COUNCILMAN GRAHAM MOVED FOR APPROVAL OF THE REGULAR MEETING MINUTES OF JUNE
24, 2026. CHAIR MCALLEN SECONDED THE MOTION. MOTION APPROVED 2-0 WITH CHAIR
MCALLEN, AND COUNCILMAN GRAHAM VOTING IN THE AFFIRMATIVE.
2. McDowell Sonoran Preserve Commission Sunset Review............................. Discussion and Action
Staff Contact: Shelby Trimaloff, Exec. Assistant, strimaloff@scottsdaleaz.gov
COUNCILMAN GRAHAM MOVED TO RECOMMEND TO CITY COUNCIL TO CONTINUE THE
MCDOWELL SONORAN PRESERVE COMMISSION. COUNCILWOMAN WHITEHEAD SECONDED
THE MOTION. MOTION APPROVED 3-0 WITH CHAIR MCALLEN, COUNCILMAN GRAHAM AND
COUNCILWOMAN WHITEHEAD VOTING IN THE AFFIRMATIVE.
3. Development Review Board Sunset Review......................................................Discussion and Action
Staff Contact: Shelby Trimaloff, Exec. Assistant. strimaloffOscottsdaleaz.gov
COUNCILMAN GRAHAM MOVED TO RECOMMEND TO CITY COUNCIL TO CONTINUE THE
DEVELOPMENT REVIEW BOARD. COUNCILWOMAN WHITEHEAD SECONDED THE MOTION. MOTION
APPROVED 3-0 WITH CHAIR MCALLEN, COUNCILMAN GRAHAM AND COUNCILWOMAN
WHITEHEAD VOTING IN THE AFFIRMATIVE.
ATTACHMENT 2
Persons who require reasonable accommodation based on language or a disability may contact the City Auditor's Office at (480) 312-7756. Please
6^ request 24-hrs in advance or as early as possible to allow arrangement time. TTY users: AZ Relay Srv (800) 367-8939 to contact City Auditor's Office.

Audit Committee Regular Meeting Agenda
Wednesday, October 21,2026 Page 2 of 2
4. Audit No. 2605. Asset Management of Mobile Computing Devices................Discussion and Action
Staff Contact: Lai Cluff, Acting City Auditor, 480-312-7851, Lcluff@scottsdaleaz.gov
COUNCILWOMAN WHITEHEAD MOVED TO ACCEPT AUDIT NO. 2605, ASSET MANAGEMENT OF
MOBILE COMPUTING DEVICES, AS SUBMIHED. COUNCILMAN GRAHAM SECONDED THE MOTION.
MOTION APPROVED 3-0 WITH CHAIR MCALLEN, COUNCILMAN GRAHAM AND COUNCILWOMAN
WHITEHEAD VOTING IN THE AFFIRMATIVE.
*5. Status and updates to the FY 2026/27 Audit Plan..........................Discussion and Possible Direction
Staff Contact: Lai Cluff, Acting City Auditor, 480-312-7851, lcluff@scottsdaleaz.gov
*6. Possible items for next meeting......................................................Discussion and Possible Direction
Adjournment-4:09 PM
Persons who require reasonable accommodation based on language or a disability may contact the City Auditor's Office at (480) 312-7756. Please
6^ request 24-hrs in advance or as early as possible to allow arrangement time, TTY users: AZ Relay Srv (800) 367-8939 to contact City Auditor's Office.

Y\ a
7*^ CITY AUDITOR
tl^ r- m PHONE 480-312-7756
•f
7447 E. Indian School Rd, Suite 205 WEB ScottsdaleAZ.gov
Scottsdale, AZ 85251 Integrity Line 480-312-8348
@
To: Chair McAllen and Members of the Audit Committee
From: Lai Cluff, Acting City Auditor
Date: October 12,2026
Re: Development Review Board Sunset Review
The Development Review Board’s purpose, as provided in Scottsdale Revised Code Sec. §1.901 of
Scottsdale’s Zoning Ordinance is to:
• Review all aspects of the proposed design of a development including,
but not limited to, site planning and the relationship of the development
to the surrounding environment and the community, guided by the
Development Review Board criteria.
• Establish design policies and guidelines that support the character and
design goals and policies of the General Plan.
• Recognize the interdependence of land values, aesthetics and good site
planning, for it is a well-known fact that Scottsdale's economic and
environmental well-being depends a great deal upon the distinctive
character and natural attractiveness which contribute substantially to
its potential as a recreational resort area and regional trade center.
Further, the ordinance states that development review is intended to enrich the lives of all the
citizens of Scottsdale by promoting harmonious, safe, attractive and compatible development, and
is therefore considered to be in furtherance of public health, safety and general welfare.
Attached are three of the Development Review Board’s most recent annual reports, covering calendar
years 2024, 2023, and 2022.
Resolution No. 8823 states that the Audit Committee is to review and evaluate whether:
• The board or commission is serving its intended purpose;
• The purpose should be maintained or modified; and
The purpose has been served or is no longer required.
ACTION; The Audit Committee is to recommend to City Council whether to continue, modify, or
terminate the board or commission.
Attached: Resolution8823 ATTACHMENT 3
Development Review Board Annual Reports (2024, 2023, 2022)

RESOLUTION NO. 8823
A RESOLUTION OF THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SCOTTSDALE,
ARIZONA. DIRECTING THE AUDIT COMMITTEE TO DEVELOP A
SCHEDULE FOR THE PERIODIC REVIEW OF BOARDS AND
COMMISSIONS AND AUTHORIZING THE AUDIT COMMITTEE TO
REVIEW BOARDS AND COMMISSIONS PURSUANT TO THE
ESTABLISHED SCHEDULE AND MAKE RECOMMENDATIONS TO
THE COUNCIL REGARDING THE CONTINUATION OR
termination of the boards and commissions reviewed.
WHEREAS, pursuant to Ordinance Nos. 2236, 2304, 2480 and Division 6 of Chapter 2,
Article III of the Scottsdale Revised Code, Section 2-118, the City Council established the Audit
Committee to consult vrith the City Auditor regarding technical issues, to virprk to assure
maximum cpordiriation between the work of the City Auditor and the needs of the City Manager
and other charter officers and to perform other duties as required or directed by the City
Council; and
WHEREAS, the City Council desires to establish a schedule for the periodic review of
the City’s boards and commissions to determine whether the boards and commissions are
meeting their intended purpose and whether to continue or terminate such boards and
commissions;
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the Council of the City of Scottsdale, as
follows:
Section 1. The City Council hereby authorizes and directs the Audit Committee to perfonn
the following duties pertaining to the City’s boards and corhmissions;
a) Develop a schedule for reviewng the City’s boards and cortimi^ions;
b) Review the City’s boards and commissions in accordance with the established
schedule;
c) Evaluate Whether each board and commissiorr reviewed is serving its intended
purpose; whether the purpose of each board and commission should be maintained
or modified; and whether the purpose of each board and comnhission has been
served or is rip longer required; and
d) Submit to the City Council its recommendations regarding whether to continue or
terminate each board and commission reviewed.
Section 2. Notwithstanding Section 1 of this Resolution, the City Council may terminate a
board or commissiori at any time.
8875244V4

Resolution No. 8823
Page 2 of2
PASSED AND ADOPTED by the Mayor and Council of the City of Scottsdale this IS*"
day of September. 2011.
ATTEST: CITY OF SCOTTSDALE, an
Arizona mupipip^ adoration
U
Ch-Cf^wV-^
Carolyn Jagi r e
City Clerk Ma;
APPROVED AS TO FORM:
ce Washpum
% Attorney
By: Jennifer Pollock
Assistant City Attorney
V.
6875244V4

Item 12
2024 Annual Report
Development Review Board Annual Report
Prepared by Caitlin Clark, Planning Technician on 12/16/2024
I*'
Approved by the Development Review Board on 1/9/2025
Web Site Address: www.ScottsdaleAZ.gov/boards/development-review-board
Number of Meetings Held: 14 Public Comments: 32
Major Topics of Discussion / Action Taken:
Reviewed all aspects of proposed development applications including site planning and the
relationship of the development to the surrounding environment and community, and approved or
denied development applications as referenced below:
Approval of tbe 2023 Development Review Board Annual Report;
Election of Vice Chair;
Commercial Developments, including: Mountain View Shopping Center, AutoNation Ford
Renovation, Take 5, QuikTrip - One Scottsdale, Storage 365, Vargo Quarter Horses, Paseo Village
Gas Station, Skyport Hangars at Redfield, The Scott Resort Expansion;
Communication Facilities, including: T-Mobile - Pima & Happy Valley, Dish Co-Location, AT&T
- Scottsdale Road & Dynamite;
Educational Developments: none;
Guidelines and Development Standards: Old Town Scottsdale Urban Design & Architectural
Guidelines;
Industrial Development, including: Mack Innovation Park Scottsdale - North Phase;
Medical Facilities: Banner Health Medical Office Building;
Mixed-use Developments, including: Cosanti Commons (preliminary design), Mercado Village
(preliminary design), Paris Baguette on 6'*' Avenue, Windfield Hotel & Residences, Marshall
Living;
Office Development: ASM Scottsdale;
Places of Worship, including: Scottsdale First Assembly Dream Center Building Expansion,
Desert Foothills Lutheran Church;
Public Art Locations, including: Scottsdale 5* Ave Apartments Mural, SMoCA/Scottsdale Public
Art Temporary Work;
Public Facilities and Infrastructure: Scottsdale Road Improvements - Jomax to Dixileta;
Residential Developments, including: Scottsdale & Osborn Residential Health Care Facility,
Legacy North Apartments at Crossroads, Scottsdale Townhomes, Ames Ranch preliminary plat.
Headwaters Residential Healthcare Facility, 38 Oaks preliminary plat. Estates on Hayden
preliminary plat. One Scottsdale PU II Atavia, Street Townhomes, Toll at Cavasson;
Restaurant Developments, including: Taco Bell, IL Bracco, Hawaiian Bros., HTeaO;
Scottsdale programs and policies: Annual Ethics Training.

s
Development Review Board Members
Current Member Attendance:
Member Name Title Present Absent Recused Service Dates
Ed Peaser DRB Member 12 2 0 From jan. toDec.
Michal Ann Joyner DRB Member 6 0 0 From Jan. to May*
& Vice Chair
Jeff Brand Vice Chair 13 1 0 From Jan, to Dec. I
Ali Fakih DRB Member 9 5 3 From Jan, to Dec.
David Mason DRB Member 12 2 0 From Jan, to Dec.
Donna Robinson DRB Member 6 0 0 From Aug. to Dec.**
*Michal Ann Joyner's term ended in May 2024.
**Donna Robinson Joined the Development Review Board in August 2024.
\
Planning Commission Members are rotated in on a three-month rotation
Current Member Attendance:
Member Name Title Present Absent Recused Service Dates
Renee Higgs Commissioner 3 0 0 Fromjun. to Aug.
William Scarbrough Commissioner 4 0 0 From Sep, to Nov.
Joe Young Commissioner 1 0 0 December
Barney Gonzales Commissioner 3 0 0 From Mar. to May
Diana Kaminski Commissioner 3 0 0 From Jan, to Feb.
City Council Members are rotated in on a three-month rotation
Current Member Attendance:
Member Name Title Present Absent Recused Service Dates
Kathy Littlefield Councilmember 4 0 0 From Sep. to Nov.
Betty Janik Councilmember 3 0 0 From Mar. to M^.
Tammy Caputi Councilmember 1 0 0 December
Solange Whitehead Councilmember 2 1 0 From Jun. to Aug.*
Barry Graham Councilmember 2 1 0 From Jan, to Feb.
*6-20-24 Kathy Littlefield substituted for Solange Whitehead.
Subcommittees: None.
Ethics Training: Yes. Computer-based training completed on or before January 31, 2024.
Selected Officers: Yes, on January 4, 2024.
Reviewed Bylaws/City Code: Yes, on January 4, 2024.
Anticipated Key Issues: Nothing noted
Future Signiflcant Work Products: Design Guidelines updates
Upcoming Opportunities, Challenges, or Outcomes: Nothing noted
Additional Comments/Recommendations: If the Board/Commission wishes to add additional
comments or recommendation(s) to the City Council, it can go in this section.

Approved by City Council: 06/25/24
2023 Annual Report
Development Review Board Annual Report
Prepared by Karissa Rodorigo, Planning Specialist on 12/18/2023
Approved by the Development Review Board on 1/4/2024
Web Site Address: www.ScottsdaleAZ.gov/boards/development-review-board
Number of Meetings Held: 19 Public Comments: 41
Major Topics of Discussion / Action Taken:
Reviewed all aspects of proposed development applications including site planning and the
relationship of the development to the surrounding environment and community, and approved or
denied development applications as referenced below:
Election of Vice Chair;
Approval of the 2022 Development Review Board Annual Report;
Commercial Developments, including: Jimmy John’s, Woodbridge Interiors Retail Center,
House of Diamonds - Shea, Scottsdale Gold Bullion and Coin, Earnhardt Hyundai & Genesis North
Scottsdale, Avalon Mammoth Bank, The George Hotel, Caesar's Republic Scottsdale, Legacy
Building "A" Modification, Floor & Decor;
Communication Facilities: including: Verizon PHO Preamble, Verizon PHO Indian Bend &
Scottsdale;
Educational Developments: none;
Guidelines and Development Standards: DSPM Chapter 4 discussions. White paint colors
discussion;
■ Industrial Development, including: Seventh Day Adventist Warehouse Building, FLW Storage,
Storage 365, Key Essentials Hanger/Office Building, Helm Hanger; 82"'* and Princess Drive
Internal Community Storage;
■ Medical Facilities, including: One Scottsdale PU III Medical Office Building and Residential
Healthcare Facility, One Scottsdale PU III, Natural Results Plastic Surgery and Medical Spa;
■ Mixed-use Developments, including: Astria Wong Building, Magnolia Waterside @ Old Town,
Optima McDowell Mountain Village, Scottsdale & Gold Dust, The Artisan;
■ Office Development, including: FEV2 Office Remodel, DC Ranch Corporate Center Office
Building, DC Corp Center Lot 12, DC Ranch Corporate Center - Lot 4;
■ Places of Worship: Madrasa 2"'’ Floor Addition;
■ Public Art Locations, including: Maya Hotel - Public Art, Scottsdale Sun Glob Mural;
■ Public Facilities and Infrastructure, including: North Pima Road Improvements, Hazel & Azure
- Camelback canal bank improvements, Fire Station 612 and Well 160;
■ Residential Developments, including: Replat Tract D Sweetwater Ranch Manor, Palo on 75‘h,
Bella Alba, Artesia, One Scottsdale PU II Grand Peaks, Marshall Four, Hozho at Lone Mountain,
Meridian Art Lofts, MODUS Development 6-Unit, Wildcat Hill, AFB Development;
■ Restaurant Developments, including: Tropical Smoothie Cafe, The Italiano Restaurant, Jack in
the Box #115 Reimage;
■ Scottsdale programs and policies: Annual Ethics Training.

Approved by City Council; 06/25/24
Development Review Board Members
Current Member Attendance:
Member Name Title Present Absent Recused Service Dates
Doug Craig DRB Member 16 3 3 From )an. to Dec.
Michal Ann loyner DRB Member 17 2 0 From Jan. to Dec.
leff Brand Vice Chair 16 3 2 From Jan, to Dec.
Ali Fakih DRB Member 16 3 6 From Jan, to Dec.
David Mason DRB Member 5 0 0 From Sep. to Dec.*
Shakir Gushgari DRB Member 13 0 0 From Jan. to Aug.**
*David Mason joined the Development Review Board in September 2023.
**Shakir Gushgari's term ended in August 2023.
Planning Commission Members are rotated in on a tbree-montb rotation
Current Member Attendance:
Member Name Title Present Absent Recused Service Dates
Renee Higgs Commissioner 3 0 0 From Jan. to Feb.
William Scarbrough Commissioner 5 0 0 From Mar. to May
Joe Young Commissioner 5 0 0 From Jun. to Aug.
George Ertel Commissioner 5 0 0 From Sep. to Nov.
Diana Kaminski Commissioner 1 0 0 December
City Council Members are rotated in on a tbree-montb rotation
Current Member Attendance:
Member Name Title Present Absent Recused Service Dates
Kathy Littlefield Councilmember 3 0 0 From Jan, to Feb.
Betty Janik Councilmember 4 0 0 From Mar. to May
Tammy Caputi Councilmember 5 1 0 From Jun. to Aug.
Tom Durham Councilmember 4 2 0 From Sep, to Nov.*
Barry Graham Councilmember 2 0 0 December
*9-21-23 Barry Graham substituted for Tom Durham.
*10-5-23 Kathy Littlefield substituted for Tom Durham.
Subcommittees: None.
Etbics Training: Yes. Computer-based training completed on or before January 19, 2023.
Selected Officers: Yes, on January 19, 2023.
Reviewed Bylaws/City Code: Yes, on January 19, 2023
Anticipated Key Issues: Nothing noted
Future Significant Work Products: Lighting Design Guidelines, consolidation of Commercial,
Office, Restaurant, and other miscellaneous guidelines
Upcoming Opportunities, Challenges, or Outcomes: Nothing noted
Additional Comments/Recommendations: If the Board/Commission wishes to add additional
comments or recommendatlon(sJ to the City Council, it can go in this section. Nothing noted

2022 Annual Report
Development Review Board Annual Report
Prepared by Mark Kertis, Planning Specialist on 12/29/2022
Approved by the Development Review Board on 1/19/2023
Web Site Address: www.ScottsdaleAZ.gov/boards/development-review-board
Number of Meetings Held: 23 Public Comments: 39
Major Topics of Discussion / Action Taken:
Reviewed all aspects of proposed development applications including site planning and the
relationship of the development to the surrounding environment and community, and approved or
denied development applications as referenced below:
■ Election of Vice Chair;
■ Approval of the 2022 Development Review Board Annual Report;
Commercial Developments, including: McDowell Hayden Retail, Renegade Clubhouse,
Christian Brothers Automotive, Hawkins - CSOK, Sprouts at Papago Marketplace;
• Communication Facilities: none;
Educational Developments: none;
Guidelines and Development Standards: none;
Industrial Development, including: Wild West Storage, Falcon Nest Hanger, New Corporate
Hanger for Set Jet, Project Cactus, Western Technologies Addition, Bicycle Haus Addition,
Scottsdale Auto Storage;
Medical Facilities, including: Healthpeak Scottsdale MOB;
Mixed-use Developments, including: The Kimsey, Craft Mixed Use Development, The
Goldwater, Hazel & Azure - Camelback, Bella Alba;
• Office Development, including: juggernaut, 4240 N. Brown Avenue;
Places of Worship: none;
• Public Art Locations, including; Scottsdale Civic Center Plaza, Soho Phase 2, Drinkwater
Underpass;
Public Facilities and Infrastructure, including: Scottsdale Civic Center Plaza, Rawhide Wash
Flood Hazard Mitigation Project, Ashler Hills Park, North Miller Road Bridge Project, ASR Well
159;
• Residential Developments, including: 26 Oaks, Scottsdale & Mountain View, Artisan
Scottsdale, GH Residences at Cavasson, Vi at Cavasson, One Scottsdale PU II by Streetlights
Residential, Standing Stones, Museum Square, The Osborn Residential Health Care Facility,
Belgravia One Scottsdale PUll, Gentry on the Green, Sereno Canyon Phase 4E, Preserve IV,
Scottsdale & Gold Dust, The Miller, Fiesta Ranch, Troon Golf Villas, Scottsdale 3200 North,
Storyrock Phase 3A Expansion, Rosewood 10, Minnezona Lofts, 94 Hundred Shea - The Village,
Mercado Courtyards, Signature at Stagecoach Pass,;
Restaurant Developments, including: Peeps, Pima Road Drive-Thru Restaurants, Tournament
Players Club (TPCj Expansion, Fiesta Bar & Restaurant, 4439 Saddlebag Restaurant/Bar;
Scottsdale programs and policies, including: Annual Ethics Training.

Development Review Board Members
Current Member Attendance:
Member Name Title Present Absent Recused Service Dates
Shakir Gushgari DRB Member 23 0 0 From Jan. to Dec.
Doug Craig Vice Chair 18 5 1 From Jan. to Dec.
Michal Ann Joyner DRB Member 22 1 0 From Jan. to Dec.
Jeff Brand DRB Member 21 2 2 From Jan. to Dec.
AH Fakih DRB Member 19 4 16 From Jan, to Dec.
Planning Commission Members are rotated in on a tbree-montb rotation
Current Member Attendance:
Member Name Title Present Absent Recused Service Dates
George Ertel Commissioner 6 0 0 From Jan, to Feb.
Barry Graham Commissioner 1 0 0 From Mar. to May*
Barney Gonzales Commissioner 7 0 0 From Jun. to Aug.
Christian Serena Commissioner 4 1 0 From Sep. to Nov.**
Renee Higgs Commissioner 0 2 0 December***
’Barry Graham resigned from planning commissioner on March 23,2022
*4-7-22 William Scarbrough substituted for Barry Graham
*4-21-22 Barney Gonzales substituted for Barry Graham
*5-5-22 George Ertel substituted for Barry Graham
*5-19-22 William Scarbrough substituted for Barry Graham
**11-3-22 William Scarbrough substituted for Christian Serena
***12-1-22 Joe Young substituted for Renee Higgs
***12-15-22 William Scarbrough substituted for Renee Higgs
City Council Members are rotated in on a three-month rotation
Current Member Attendance:
Member Name Title Present Absent Recused Service Dates
Tammy Caputi Councilmember 8 0 0 From Jan. to Feb.
Tom Durham Councilmember 5 1 0 From March, to May*
Linda Milhaven Councilmember 5 2 0 From Jun. to Aug.**
Solange Whitehead Councilmember 5 1 0 From Sep. to Nov.***
Kathy Littlefield Councilmember 2 1 0 December****
*3-17-22 Kathy Littlefieid substituted for Tom Durham
**8-4-22 Tammy Caputi substituted for Linda Milhaven
**8-18-22 Tammy Caputi substituted for Linda Milhaven
***10-20-22 Tammy Caputi substituted for Soiange Whitehead
*’**12-1-22 Linda Milhaven substituted for Kathy Littlefield
Subcommittees: Briefly describe the subcommittee(s) purpose, justification, membership, and
when its work is anticipated to be complete. If no subcommittees, then insert "None"
None
Ethics Training: Yes. Computer-based training completed on or before January 31, 2022
Selected Officers: Yes, on January 6, 2022
Reviewed Bylaws/City Code: Update to the Order of Business section of the Development Review
Board's Rules of Procedure approved by Board Members at the January 6, 2022 hearing
Anticipated Key Issues: Nothing noted

Future Significant Work Products: Lighting Design Guidelines, consolidation of Commercial,
Office, Restaurant, and other miscellaneous guidelines
Upcoming Opportunities, Challenges, or Outcomes: Nothing noted
Additional Comments/Recommendations: If the Board/Commission wishes to add additional
comments or recommendation(s) to the City Council, it can go in this section.
Nothing noted