Supporting Document (c0c4262e...)
Extracted text (via pymupdf_layout)
145394 characters
Item 14
CITY COUNCll
REPORT
Meeting Date: November 24, 2026
General Plan Element: Land Use
General Plan Goal: Create a sense of community through land uses
ACTION
Shea Homes - SEC of Pima Road & Happy Valley Road
ZN-0003-2026
Request to consider the following:
1. Adopt Ordinance No. 4723 for a Zoning District Map Amendment from Single-family
Residential Environmentally Sensitive Lands (R1-190 ESL) zoning to Single-family Residential
Environmentally Sensitive Lands (R1-35 ESL) zoning, with Amended Development Standards
for a 77-lot subdivision on a +/- 94.8-gross-acre site located at the southeast corner of E.
Happy Valley Road and N. Pima Road.
GoaUPurpose of Request
The applicant's request is to rezone the property to allow for the configuration of a new 77-lot
single-family residential subdivision, with amended development standards.
Key Items for Consideration
• Proposed density 0.81 dwelling units per acre
• Combination of on-lot and tract NAOS
• Existing regional drainage facility along Pima Road
• . Planning Commission heard this case on 10/28/2026 and recommended approval with a vote
of 7-0
OWNER
Happy Peak Inc. ' , ' '
E Happy-Valley·Rd
APPLICANT CONTACT
Berry Riddell, LLC
John Berry
480-385-2753
/ ' ,,I I ' I ', I t I
LOCATION I
Southeast corner of E. Happy Valley Road and N. Pima Road
(APN's 217-05-026E, 217-05-026F, 217-05-026G)
Action Taken _____________ _
City Council Report | ZN-0003-2026
BACKGROUND
General Plan
The General Plan Land Use Element designates the property as Rural Neighborhoods. This
category includes the largest-lot, single-family neighborhoods. Densities in Rural Neighborhoods
are usually one dwelling unit per one or more acres. Within the Environmentally Sensitive Lands
(ESL) areas, native desert vegetation is abundant and special care is needed to preserve open
desert character and environmental features. The goal in Rural Neighborhoods is to retain the
large-lot character while preserving desert vegetation, washes, and natural features. Clustering
of development may be used to achieve this goal. Rural Neighborhoods may also include
equestrian or limited golf course uses.
Zoning
The site is currently zoned Single-family Residential Environmentally Sensitive Lands (R1-190
ESL) zoning and proposes a change to Single-family Residential Environmentally Sensitive Lands
(R1-35 ESL) zoning. Both the R1-190 and R1-35 zoning districts are intended to promote and
preserve residential development. The minimum lot size in the R1-35, although less than one (1)
acre, still results in a low density of population. The principal land use is single-family dwellings
and uses incidental or accessory thereto, together with required recreational, religious and
educational facilities.
Context
The subject property currently consists of 3 vacant parcels located at the southeast corner of East
Happy Valley Road and North Pima Road, extending south to the La Mirada shopping center.
Please refer to context graphics attached.
Adjacent Uses and Zoning
• North: Pinnacle Peak Place residential subdivision, zoned Single-family Residential
Environmentally Sensitive Lands (R1-70 ESL)
• South: La Mirada commercial shopping center, zoned Central Business Environmentally
Sensitive Lands (C-2 ESL)
• East: Solitude residential subdivision, zoned Single-family Residential Environmentally
Sensitive Lands (R1-43 ESL) and Prado Estates residential subdivision, zoned Single
family Residential Environmentally Sensitive Lands (R1 -190 ESL)
• West: Tamarron residential subdivision, zoned Single-family Residential Planned Residential
Development Environmentally Sensitive Lands (R1-43 PRD ESL); Pinnacle Peak
Estates Unit 3 Phase 1 & 2 residential subdivision, zoned Single-family Residential
Planned Residential Development Environmentally Sensitive Lands (R1-43 PRD ESL);
and Pinnacle Paradise residential subdivision, zoned Single-family Residential
Planned Residential Development Environmentally Sensitive Lands (R1 -70 PRD ESL)
Other Related Policies, References:
Scottsdale General Plan 2035, as amended
Zoning Ordinance
Page 2 of 7
City Council Report | ZN-0003-2026
APPLICANT’S PROPOSAL
Development Information
The development proposal is a request to rezone the +/- 94.8 gross acre site to allow for the
configuration of a 77-lot single-family residential subdivision.
• Existing Use: 3 vacant parcels
• Proposed Use: 77 lot residential subdivision
• Project Size: 94.8 acres (gross); 86.1 acres (net)
• Building Height Allowed: 24-feet
• Natural Area Open Space Required: 21.94 acres (per slope analysis)
• Natural Area Open Space Provided: 23.89 acres
• Density Allowed (R1 -190 ESL): 19 lots (0.21 du/ac)
• Density Allowed (R1 -35 ESL): 98 lots (1.04 du/ac)
• Density Proposed (R1 -35 ESL): 77 lots (0.81 du/ac)
IMPACT ANALYSIS
Land Use
The existing zoning on the site would allow for a calculated maximum of 19 residential lots based
on the R1-190 zoning district and the ESL zoning overlay, with locations of the natural area open
space and treatment of washes to be determined. As proposed, R1 -35 zoning would allow for the
application of a 77-lot residential subdivision which includes the site development limitations
that contribute to the reduction of the maximum calculated density of 98 lots under the R1-35
zoning and the ESL zoning overlay.
The proposal also anticipates the use of amended development standards such as lot area, lot
width, and building setbacks. An amended development standards request is allowed under the
provisions of the existing ESL zoning overlay. The Development Review Board, through the
Preliminary Plat process, can approve amended development standards up to a 25% reduction to
encourage sensitivity to site conditions and provide flexibility in site planning. These details
provide some certainty to locations of natural area open space (NAOS) and treatment of washes.
Below is a table for comparison of development standards.
Development R1-190 zoning R1-35 zoning R1-35 zoning
Standard (Existing) (Amended Standards)
Lot Area 190,000 SF 35,000 SF 26,250 SF
Lot Width 300 feet 135 feet 102 feet
Front yard setback 60 feet 40 feet 30 feet
Side yard setback 30 feet 15 feet 12 feet
Rear yard setback 60 feet 35 feet 27 feet
Page 3 of 7
city Council Report j ZN-0003-2026
Transportation/Trails
The proposed subdivision plan provides for one access point onto E. Happy Valley Road and two
onto N. Pima Road. The 3 existing access points onto N. Pima Road were previously planned
during the recent Pima Road improvements. This proposal maintains 2 of the 3 existing access
points onto N. Pima Road and leaves the nprthernmost access to Pima Road unused. The
proposal includes external and internal pedestrian improvements as outlined on the submitted
Pedestrian and Vehicular Circulation Plan. Additional graphics were provided by the applicant at
the Planning Commission meeting for clarity on the ingress and egress configurations proposed
for each of the three vehicular access points. Those vyere referenced in the Planning
Commission’s recommendation and have been included as an additional attached exhibit to the
stipulations.
Water/Sewer
The applicant provided Basis of Design reports for water and sewer, which have been accepted by
the Water Resources Division. The City of Scottsdale is an Arizona Department of Water
Resources designated provider with a 100 years Assured Water Supply and will supply water in
accordarice with City codes, ordinances, and the City’s Drought Management Plan. All
infrastructure upgrades necessary to serve this project will be completed by the applicant.
Fire/Police
The nearest fire station is within 3 miles of the site and located at N. Hayden Road and E. Jomax
Road. The subject site is served by the Foothills Police District, Beat 19. As with any project that
contributes to growth, the fire department and police department continually anticipate and
evaluate resource needs for the city’s budget process.
Open Space
The proposed subdivision plan accounts for providing 23.89 acres of MACS distributed through
the site as a combination of tract MACS (9.48 acres) and on-lot NAQS (14.41 acres), as
represented on the MACS Exhibit provided with the application. The city has installed regional
drainage improvements along the N. Pima Road frontage of this site. As these drainage
improvements haVe been constructed on the site, it qualifies to request a proportional NAOS
reduction based on the overlapping area, per Sec. 6.1060.B.2 of the Zoning Ordinance. The
proposed plan also accounts for a 100-foot average width Scenic Corridor in addition to and
located beyond the regional drainage improvements creating an increased buffer along N. Pima
Road.
School District Comments/Review
The Cave Creek Unified School District has been notified of the development proposal and the
proposed residential density.
HousingGost
Approval of the zoning district map amendment proposed by the applicant enables the
construction of more housing. In conjunction with state law, staff has considered the scope of the
zoning district map amendment and development plan, as well as aspects which would affect the
cost of construction. Staff has not identified any factors that would substantially impact the cost
to construct housing for sale or rent.
Page 4 of 7
City Council Report | ZN-0003-2026
Community Involvement
The City of Scottsdale promotes public participation in the development of the built environment.
The applicant complied with the city’s suggested best practices for public outreach. The applicant
held an open house meeting on January 26, 2026 at the Highlands Church near the site. They
performed additional outreach efforts including door-to-door, HOA contact, and virtual meetings
as summarized in their Citizen Review and Neighborhood Involvement Report.
Staff has received public comments in opposition that generally expresses concern with the
change in number and size of lots from the current zoning designation, and the potential traffic
and utility impacts relative to the proposed number of homes.
A written letter of support was provided from the owner of the commercial shopping center to the
immediate south of this site. The HOA representative from the adjacent Solitude neighborhood
provided a follow up email expressing that the applicant team continued to meet with them and
were able to find an agreeable solution to provide access and utility improvements that would be
beneficial to satisfying initial concerns from the Solitude neighborhood. Additional letters of
support were provided at the Planning Commission meeting, and all are included in the
attachments to this report.
Significant Updates to Development Proposal Since Initial Submittal
The applicant team conducted preliminary outreach to city staff and other interested parties and
made responsive adjustments prior to their official application submittal. As a result, there were
not significant noteworthy changes made to the proposal during the public/staff review period.
Policy Implications
The proposed rezoning results in a density of less than one dwelling unit per acre, consistent with
the site’s Rural Neighborhoods land use designation as outlined in the Land Use Element of the
General Plan.
OTHER BOARDS AND COMMISSIONS
Planning Commission:
Planning Commission heard this case on October 28, 2026 and recommended approval with a
vote of 7-0.
Recommended Approach:
Staff recommended that the Planning Commission find that the proposed zoning district map
amendment is consistent and conforms with the adopted General Plan, and make a
recommendation to City Council for approval, per the attached stipulations.
RECOMMENDATION
Recommended Approach:
Adopt Ordinance No. 4723 for a Zoning District Map Amendment from Single-family Residential
Environmentally Sensitive Lands (R1 -190 ESL) zoningto Single-family Residential Environmentally
Page 5 of 7
City Council Report | ZN-0003-2026
Sensitive Lands (R1-35 ESL) zoning, with Amended Development Standards for a 77-lot
subdivision on a +/- 94.8-gross-acre site located at the southeast corner of E. Happy Valley Road
and N. Pima Road.
RESPONSIBLE DEPARTMENT
Planning and Development Services
Current Planning Services
STAFF CONTACT
Jeff Barnes
Principal Planner
480-312-2376
jbarnes@scottsdaleaz.gov
APPROVED BY
11/5/2026
Jeff BarnesfReport Author Date
11/5/2026
Tim Curtis, AlCP, Deputy Director Planning and Development Date
Services
Planning Commission Liaison
Phone: 480-312-4210 Email: tcurtis@scottsdaleaz.gov
11/06/2026
Erin Perreault, AlCP, Senior Director Date
Planning and Development Services
Phone: 480-312-7093 Email: eperreault@scottsdaleaz.gov
(
Page 6 of 7
City Council Report | ZN-0003-2026
ATTACHMENTS
i
1. Context Aerial
1A. Aerial Close-Up
2. Ordinance No. 4723
Exhibit 1; Zoning Map
Exhibit 2: Stipulations
Exhibit A to Exhibit 2: Conceptual Subdivision Plan
Exhibit B to Exhibit 2: NAOS Exhibit
Exhibit C to Exhibit 2: Ingress and Egress Supplemental Exhibit
3. Existing General Plan Land Use Map
4. Existing Zoning Map
5. Application Narrative
6. Pedestrian and Vehicular Circulation Plan
7. Traffic Impact Summary
8. Community Involvement
9. Correspondence
10. City Notification Map
11. Planning Commission Draft Meeting Minutes October 28,2026
Page 7 of 7
ji
ISm
y' JSTfSs !^'..
^jfgjfwjy I'jnf g fi_,
errr w^Mmi ^Mm
Context Aerial ZN-0003-2026|
Attachment #1
Sts ’S e.
s 'K v^
.r w M-
mm Se.* Desert Vista •*-v ■.Vi -i
i? Rdfet
,J‘^
L1^ % 13*811 vi;
fc'-.'i-i— 'i
>*
.<>
"3^ »'* at; V-TJ -j.
'^1.
r.: S
%% ‘‘"J' '■
m t m m
*yii m
m Jit 4v; ■fi'im 5^- iBUiS ;*
i Sf ^}• V- .'.•t
'•i m
bj
Y.£2
4. «>- <:P
4»*S-*'
if'<■m M Bk ^/nst/tutSBWB ^/nTt y:.
«r
Close-up Aerial n[ ;^^003 20^
Attachment #1A
ORDINANCE NO. 4723
AN ORDINANCE OF THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF
SCOTTSDALE, MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA, AMENDING
ORDINANCE NO. 455, THE ZONING ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF
SCOTTSDALE, BY AND FOR THE PURPOSE OF CHANGING THE
ZONING ON THE “DISTRICT MAP" TO ZONING APPROVED IN
PLAN NO. ZN-0003-2026 FROM SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL
ENVIRONMENTALLY SENSITIVE LANDS (R1-190 ESL) ZONING TO
SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL ENVIRONMENTALLY SENSITIVE
LANDS (R1-35 ESL) ZONING, ON A +/- 94.8-ACRE SITE LOCATED
AT THE SOUTHEAST CORNER OF EAST HAPPY VALLEY ROAD
AND NORTH PIMA ROAD.
WHEREAS, the Planning Commission held a hearing on October 28, 2026; and
WHEREAS, the City Council has considered the probable impact of Zoning Ordinance
No. 4723 on the cost to construct housing for sale or rent; and
WHEREAS, the City Council finds that the proposed developrnent is in substantial
harmony with the General Plan of the City of Scottsdale and will be coordinated with existing and
planned development; and
WHEREAS, it is now necessary that the comprehensive zoning map of the City of
Scottsdale (“District Map") be amended to conform with the decision of the Scottsdale City Council
in Plan No. ZN-0003-2026.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED by the Council of the City of Scottsdale, as
follows:
Section 1. That the “District Map” adopted as a part of the Zoning
Ordinance of the City of Scottsdale, showing the zoning district
boundaries, is amended by rezoning a +/-94.8-acre site, located at the
southeast comer of East Happy Valley Road and North Pima Road,
and marked as “Site” (the Property) on the map attached as Exhibit 1,
incorporated herein by reference, from Single-family Residential
Environmentally Sensitive Lands (R1-190 ESL) zoning to Single-family
Residential Environmentally Sensitive Lands (R1-35 ESL) zoning.
Section 2. That the above rezoning approval is conditioned upon compliance with
all stipulations attached hereto as Exhibit 2 and incorporated herein by reference.
PASSED AND ADOPTED by the Council of the City of Scottsdale, Maricopa County,
Arizona this______ day of______________, 2026.
ATTEST: CITY OF SCOTTSDALE, an Arizona
municipal corporation
By:. By:__________________________
Ben Lane, City Clerk Lisa Borowsky, Mayor
Ordinance No. 4723
Page 1 of 2
19638564
Attachment #2
APPROVED AS TO FORM;
By.lM
E. Santaella, City Attorney
By: Joe Padilla, Deputy City Attorney
Ordinance No. 4723
Page 2 of 2
19638564
O
RIVOJESL fsm (3)<e@ RI^ZOlESr™
im
E.-^HappyA/alley^Roadu
E. La Junta Road
>730o
Q£ £. Whispering
o R1I43 ESI Wind Drive
R1543 RRDIESL E
i It <D
2 CO
Q>
I I
CO
■D E. Desert R11190
R1?35 ESL <N VJsfa Road ESL!(HD)
■z.
2
•E.’wAlamedaiRoadi
Rl!70 ESL E. Mariposa
Grande Drive
Rl^ZO RRDIESL R12.190 ESI
!
!
13 ESL GJ2 O I i
Q.S. ■
17-46 Zoning Oraphlc \ ISL
Zoning |zN-0003-2026|
Ordinance No. 4723
Exhibit 1
Page 1 of 1
Stipulations for the Zoning Application:
Shea Homes - SEC of Pima Road & Happy Valley Road
Application Number: ZN-0003-2026
These stipulations are in order to protect the public health, safety, welfare, and the City of
Scottsdale.
♦Modifications represented in bold text were added by the Planning Commission as part of their
recommendation for approval.
SITE DESIGN
1. CONFORMANCE TO CONCEPTUAL SUBDIVISION PLAN. Development shall conform with the
conceptual subdivision plan, attached as Exhibit A to Exhibit 2. Any proposed significant
change to the conceptual subdivision plan prior to the preliminary plat approval, as determined
by the Zoning Administrator, shall be subject to additional public hearings before the Planning
Commission and City Council. Once the final plat is approved, the development must conform
to the final plat.
2. NATURAL AREA OPEN SPACE AND DRAINAGE BUFFERING. The Preliminary Plat shall provide
Natural Area Open Space (NAOS) and Drainage and Flood Control easements (DFC) in the
configurations shown, including perimeter buffering as represented, bn the conceptual NAOS
Exhibit attached as Exhibit B to Exhibit 2. As represented on the exhibit, the Preliminary Plat and
Final Plat shall provide a minimum of 9.48 acres (of the minimum total 23.89 acres) as tract
NAOS toward the overall required total for the development.
3. LANDSCAPING. The northmost existing culvert bridge along Pima Road that is not proposed for
use as access with this development configuration, shall be relandscaped to the extent
possible with appropriate plant materials similar in type and density of the surrounding regional
drainage improvements area. The Landscape Plans provided with the Preliminary Plat
submittal shall provide details demonstrating conformance with this stipulation.
4. MAXIMUM DWELLING UNITS - DENSITY. Maximum dwelling units shall not exceed 77 dwelling
units (equivalent to 0.81 du/gross acre of the development project)
5. ALTERATIONS TO NATURAL WATERCOURSES. Any proposed alteration to the natural state of
watercourses with a peak flow rate of 750 cfs or less based on the 100 year - 2 hour rain event
shall be subject to Development Review Board approval.
6. ACCESS RESTRICTIONS. Access to the development project shall conform to the Pedestrian
and Vehicular Circulation Plan prepared by Swaback Architects & Planners, dated September
9, 2026.
7. PROTECTION OF ARCHAEOLOGICAL RESOURCES. Any development on the property is
subject to the requirements of Scottsdale Revised Code, Chapter 46, Article VI, Protection of
Archaeological Resources, Section 46-134 - Discoveries of archaeological resources during
construction.
Ordinance No. 4723
Exhibit 2
Pagel of 4
8. GATES. Prior to issuance of any permit for the development project, the property owner shall
submit and obtain approval of construction documents showing gating in compliance with the
Design Standards and Policies Manual.
9. LAND DIViSiON CODE COMPLIANCE. The subdivision shall comply with the City of Scottsdale
Land Division Code.
DEDICATIONS
10. RIGHT-OF-WAY DEDICATIONS. Prior to issuance of any permit for the development project,
the property owner shall dedicate in fee simple to the City of Scottsdale, by the project's final
plat, all existing right-of-way adjacent to the project currently held in easement form.
11. LOCAL RESIDENTIAL PRIVATE STREETS. All local residential private streets shall be contained
within a subdivision tract of land that has no less than a total width of forty (40) feet, and
dedications to the property owners association consisting of property owners within the
subdivision of the development project.
12. SUBDIVISION TRACTS, PRIVATE STREETS, MAINTENANCE, AND LIABLITY. A property owners
association consisting of property owners within the subdivision of the development project
shall own and be responsible for all maintenance and liabilities of all subdivision tracts, private
streets and related infrastructure.
13. MULTI-USE TRAIL EASEMENT. Prior to issuance of any permit for the development project, the
property owner shall dedicate a minimum twenty (20) foot wide Public Non-Motorized Access
Easement to the City of Scottsdale to contain the multi-use trail to be constructed in
accordance with the infrastructure requirements below. The alignment of the easement shall
be subject to approval by the city’s Zoning Administrator, or designee, prior to dedication.
14. SCENIC CORRIDOR LOCATION, EASEMENT, AND IMPROVEMENTS. Priorto issuance of any
permit for the development project, the property owner shall dedicate a minimum one hundred
(100) foot wide continuous Scenic Corridor Easement to the City of Scottsdale along the
development project’s N. Pima Road frontage. Unless otherwise approved by the Development
Review Board, the area within the Scenic Corridor Easement shall be left in a natural condition.
15. PUBLIC NON-MOTORIZED ACCESS EASEMENT. Priorto issuance of any permit for the
development project, the property owner shall dedicate a continuous Public Non-Motorized
Access Easement to the City of Scottsdale to contain the public sidewalk in locations where
the sidewalk crosses onto private property of the development project.
INFRASTRUCTURE
16. CONSTRUCTION COMPLETED. Prior to issuance of any Certificate of Occupancy or
Certification of Shell Building, whichever is first, for the development project, the property
owner shall complete all the infrastructure and improvements required by the Scottsdale
Revised Code and these stipulations.
17. STANDARDS OF IMPROVEMENTS. All improvements (curb, gutter, sidewalk, curb ramps,
driveways, pavement, concrete, water, wastewater, etc.) shall be constructed in accordance
with the applicable City of Scottsdale Supplements to the Maricopa Association of
Governments (MAG) Uniform Standard Specifications and Details for Public Works
Ordinance No. 4723
Exhibit 2
Page 2 of 4
Construction, Maricopa Association of Governments (MAG) Uniform Standard Specifications
and Details for Public Works Construction, the Design Standards and Policies Manual (DSPM),
and all other applicable city codes and policies.
18. STREET IMPROVEMENTS. Prior to issuance of any permit for the development project, the
property owner shall submit and obtain approval of construction documents showing the
construction of the improvements recommended in the Transportation Impact & Mitigation
Analysis prepared by Lokahi, dated August 27, 2026 and as shown on the Ingress and Egress
Supplemental Exhibit, attached as Exhibit C to Exhibit 2.
19. PRIVATE STREETS. Prior to issuance of any permit for the development project, the property
owner shall submit and obtain approval of construction documents showing the construction
of all private streets within the limits of the project in conformance with the city's local
residential ESL, non-trail, cross-section.
20. MULTI-USE TRAIL IMPROVEMENTS. Prior to issuance of any permit for the development
project, the property owner shall submit and obtain approval of construction documents
showing the construction of multi-use trails in the locations and widths shown on the
Pedestrian and Vehicular Circulation Plan prepared by Swaback Architects & Planners, dated
Septembers, 2026.
21. SIDEWALKS. Prior to issuance of any permit for the development project, the property owner
shall submit and obtain approval of construction documents showing the construction of
sidewalks in the locations and widths shown on the Pedestrian and Vehicular Circulation Plan
prepared by Swaback Architects & Planners, dated September 9,2026.
22. POLYMER CONCRETE MANHOLES. Prior to issuance of any permit for the development project,
the property owner shall submit and obtain approval of construction documents showing all
manholes installed on public sewer mains fifteen (15) inches in diameter and larger
constructed of polymer concrete materials per Maricopa Association of Governments (MAG)
Standard Detail 419, MAG Specification Section 744, and the City of Scottsdale Approved
Products List (APL).
23. POLYMER CONCRETE MANHOLES-SPECIAL CONDITIONS. Prior to issuance of any permit for
the development project, the property owner shall submit and obtain approval of construction
documents showing the following manholes constructed of polymer concrete materials per
MAG Standard Detail 419: "one-off" public manholes, being the first manhole upstream of
sewer mains fifteen (15) inches in diameter and larger; manholes with public or private force
main or ejector discharges; manholes on sewer lines with velocity equal to or greater than six
(6) feet per second; deep manholes equal to or greater than ten (10) feet; and drop manholes of
any diameter on public sewer main. Adjustment rings and manhole bases shall also be of
polymer concrete material per MAG Standard Detail 419.
24. SEWER CONNECTION ELEVATION. Prior to issuance of any permit for the development project,
the property owner shall submit and obtain approval of construction documents showing on
site sewer set at an elevation capable of accepting the HV91 lift station flow line, the invert
elevation of which is 2068.63.
25. PUBLIC WATER AND SEWER LINE LOCATION. Prior to issuance of any permit for the
development project, the property owner shall submit and obtain approval of construction
Ordinance No. 4723
Exhibit 2
Page 3 of 4
documents showing all public water and sewer lines located within a minimum of twenty (20)
feet of right-of-way, public utility easement, or water/sewer easement located within a
dedicated tract.
26. DEAD-END WATER DISTRIBUTiON LiNES. Prior to issuance of any permit forthe development
project, the property owner shall submit and obtain approval of construction documents
showing dead-end water distribution lines eight (8) inches to twelve (12) inches in diameter not
exceeding one thousand two hundred (1,200) feet in length. Any proposed length greater than
one thousand two hundred (1,200) feet shall be looped.
27. WATER AND WASTEWATER IMPROVEMENTS. The property owner shall provide all water and
wastewater infrastructure improvements, including any new service lines, connection, fire-
hydrants, and man-holes, necessary to serve the development.
28. FIRE HYDRANT. The property owner shall provide fire hydrant(s) and related water
infrastructure adjacent to lot, in the locations determined by the Fire Department Chief, or
designee.
Ordinance No. 4723
Exhibit 2
Page 4 of4
SUBDIVISION PLAN
I vt
W.A Sfii
'X m sm r.
^MINIMUMlOT'SIZEl
k i>. ■i iv?
f
w
LOT DATA
Lot* SF Lot* SF
J : ]■ 1 39.386 39 27.691
ss'i
2 33,667 40 26,401
k JTjt V 3 31,393 41 26,719
“■v V 3 >■ ,4*i 4 34,781 42 32,444
v».» '■f-U ri4j
5 35,116 43 36,200
s<*: h I. - 6 26,683 44 28,540
r- if 7 26,325 45 26,270
10 8 26,325 46 28,517
< »
f r? 9 33,823 47 38,019
bjt^j 5l
10 32,910 48 38,550
.4^
S’ 11 32,872 49 29,068
2 X- i n. m. 12 26,525 50 26,407
Im ■13 i|'I4ij-I5-!^Wi i 13 26,367 51 26,388
i m 18
14 34,267 52 31,239
wmms: 15 26,612 53 37,591
if-M
m 16 35,176 54 35,500
smtp 17 31.708 55 30,856
/ LSL
18 30,176 56 36,307
I.V
1. 56 19 30,976 57 26,305
■V f. 20 27,285 58 29,633
»• BCiWS m
h3’ 21 26,250 59 31,942
x its
22 26,238 60 31,700
il -i:
M i* 23 26,300 61 26,842
24 30,755 62 26,376
Jm
WffiS 32 1 25 33,248 63 26,377
'/"r EiSQ 37 «
i ■1 26 36,358 64 31,620
t 26,402 31,618
m 28 26,250 66 26,320
ir ^ 4 39,4Q, ,^ 29 26.250 67 29,017
A mi
7 f. 30 31,000 68 29,371
•a 43
M 31 37.843 69 30,020
t i^’l'DRAlNACT^ASEMtNT ft; % tm II 32 26,627 70 32,130
"47
Hf x> 33 26,627 71 36,216
m a
34 26,627 72 30,872
•ii i i
i 35 29,627 73 29,816
mm 9 ■*T. nn 'I! 36 36,437 74 26,304
M -53
49 50 ‘siV-S? r_j Vii 37 34,724 75 26,448
-M 5k ^4;
38 26,873 76 37,265
77 70,171
fella t: STilPfS □ LARGEST LOTS____AVERAGE 36.000 SOFT
HilsggS
K’ RCVCOrTATED OPEN SPACE------ 4.72 ACRES •/-
.'S FW
A* ■/ !oa wm
rt!?i i Y HFV □55 NATIVE OPEN SPACE______^15.17 ACRES «/-
• i*
iYi SCENIC COmiOOR__ .9.04 ACRES*/*
F70j
.
67 68 5 ra DRAINAGE
0
feip*
TOTAL UNITS, 77
atea GROSS PROPERTY SIZE: 94.8 ACRES
20'PIMA
I\\ DENSITY: 0.81 HOME/
0M 0.
LiA C0 - VA REQUIRED NAOS 21.94 ACV-
-ft
PROVIDED NAOS. 23.89 AC+/-
ii 1 mm
0O% INCREASE)
; ■ » ~e>
Ordinance No. 4723 SCALE: r-)00'
iS4#4 a G^rj,v;TL:
. •-;
07.27.2026
Construction, Maricopa Association of Governments (MAG) Uniform Standard Specifications
and Details for Public Works Construction, the Design Standards and Policies Manual (DSPM),
and all other applicable city codes and policies.
18. STREET IMPROVEMENTS. Prior to issuance of any permit for the development project, the
property owner shall submit and obtain approval of construction documents showing the
construction of the improvements recommended in the Transportation Impacts. Mitigation
Analysis prepared by Lokahi, dated August 27, 2026 and as shown on the ingress and Egress
Supplemental Exhibit, attached as Exhibit C to Exhibit 2.
19. PRIVATE STREETS. Prior to issuance of any permit for the development project, the property
owner shall submit and obtain approval of construction documents showing the construction
of all private streets within the limits of the project in conformance with the city's local
residential ESL, non-trail, cross-section.
20. MULTI-USE TRAIL IMPROVEMENTS. Prior to issuance of any permit for the development
project, the property owner shall submit and obtain approval of construction documents
showing the construction of multi-use trails in the locations and widths shown on the
Pedestrian and Vehicular Circulation Plan prepared by Swaback Architects & Planners, dated
Septembers, 2026.
21. SIDEWALKS. Prior to issuance of any permit for the development project, the property owner
shall submit and obtain approval of construction documents showing the construction of
sidewalks in the locations and widths shown on the Pedestrian and Vehicular Circulation Plan
prepared by Swaback Architects & Planners, dated September 9,2026.
22. PCLYMER CCNCRETE MANHCLES. Prior to issuance of any permit for the development project,
the property owner shall submit and obtain approval of construction documents showing all
manholes installed on public sewer mains fifteen (15) inches in diameter and larger
constructed of polymer concrete materials per Maricopa Association of Governments (MAG)
Standard Detail 419, MAG Specification Section 744, and the City of Scottsdale Approved
Products List (APL).
23. PCLYMER CCNCRETE MANHCLES-SPECIAL CCNDITICNS. Prior to issuance of any permit for
the development project, the property owner shall submit and obtain approval of construction
documents showing the following manholes constructed of polymer concrete materials per
MAG Standard Detail419: "one-off" public manholes, being the first manhole upstream of
sewer mains fifteen (15) inches in diameter and larger; manholes with public or private force
main or ejector discharges; manholes on sewer lines with velocity equal to or greater than six
(6) feet per second; deep manholes equal to or greater than ten (10) feet; and drop manholes of
any diameter on public sewer main. Adjustment rings and manhole bases shall also be of
polymer concrete material per MAG Standard Detail 419.
24. SEWER CCNNECTICN ELEVATICN. Prior to issuance of any permit for the development project,
the property owner shall submit and obtain approval of construction documents showing on
site sewer set at an elevation capable of accepting the HV91 lift station flow line, the invert
elevation of which is 2068.63.
25. PUBLIC WATER AND SEWER LINE LOCATION. Prior to issuance of any permit for the
development project, the property owner shall submit and obtain approval of construction
Ordinance No. 4723
Exhibit 2
Page 3 of 4
documents showing all public water and sewer lines located within a minimum of twenty (20)
feet of right-of-way, public utility easement, or water/sewer easement located within a
dedicated tract.
26. DEAD-END WATER DISTRIBUTiON LiNES. Priorto issuance of any permit forthe development
project, the property owner shall submit and obtain approval of construction documents
showing dead-end water distribution lines eight (8) inches to twelve (12) inches in diameter not
exceeding one thousand two hundred (1,200) feet in length. Any proposed length greater than
one thousand two hundred (1,200) feet shall be looped.
27. WATER AND WASTEWATER IMPROVEMENTS. The property owner shall provide all water and
wastewater infrastructure improvements, including any new service lines, connection, fire-
hydrants, and man-holes, necessary to serve the development.
28. FIRE HYDRANT. The property owner shall provide fire hydrant(s) and related water
infrastructure adjacent to lot, in the locations determined by the Fire Department Chief, or
designee.
Ordinance No. 4723
Exhibit 2
Page 4 of4
VIC N TY MAP
1C cono
----- PREIMNARV
UATCHLME-REFER TO L£n NOT FOR
^.^^PYVALLEYF®. CONSTRUCTION
SI i
7 i 1/4 COMO I <, ' Jr.
SECTW11.T4H ! 2L. I
BL n MSS I S SKI
or U -T i
HMOOf\ 9
Sir* f i
g
.1 I
iw* 3 VCNTYHAP i
>»4UB ■»41» -2048J0 S7 T4H nc ^^2
MTS WOMOM*
>—OEIPM !
Sff
(MMCL MSStT~&n
w-Lor IDS I
li) I I n 1
// >20SL» CD U
'km MOS
I/' ms
r LU f|
mst MO rviUK m' FUnK MO la MoiMcr Dnacncxr/nt CO M
I MO 7 >70800 p” •2C44O0 iMSMO WCT HAO^
■»1J0 ■j. wr MBSIMO OIMfll HAAS. U
WOnUD HAOS.
MO /
ss* MO J — — — SCSC COMBO*
•TDKJO MO /;^ %
1 MO
I KMXewa ICBDWl OMMCC CHMCl
-1M7J0
OPEN
m CHMBCl NAOSOATA
FUnCE Ml VIUK Ml MO
' / <8-Uff / TMCT IMS •JMIJB ■?s* 1:1 caoss snt uKk PM MKS
L .O. IC1 9K mk M W /OB
1
’h I uui I ■ft MOS (ra sm musSf 7tJ4 AOB
->»&4e
< m 88 UMD6U8CDMU: 11.7B*aCS
i/ FWUOC snco I BWVIVGOM. s
s mu wct KVCGEUTOI CMOIT. SB SU8t MMYSS FOB u
MO ri ON-LOT 05 » N ; MO onMJ
•TQBUO I QBM
I I, S/C
CJ 'V
je MO g MHK FWnCD 0
z •fi
il -TPISJS oc 1MO IMS OB-iOl W05
< i I i MUtW imic MO 1
K. TOMJO 708JIB MO MO
■r I L-au^ TDJSlSB
cC s- z tn K
z riFiM !l FUMK MO nmifli MO g
:» w fmc MO ■7B74.e -TOMAS TOM
ruTUBE MO C MO
•2O67J0 .T87ZI0 ' NOTES
—
i
i □M. s. n BE A jroo'
FUIWEMO w f -le I FUME ADA 8 ROB) a 4A0B SQUME FOT M MEA
»-ior NAc •TOTZiO !l -IBM 2. NAO^ MEAS ISia ME MEIHMT AW WT K
s «- MTEO KTKDI LOIS MBOB TO F1M. PUH imon SO
la LOW AS M TOTAL NAOS. DCBCAIOB KWH ABK
3 OM-tOI - 4 b'^: I
r -fOMiO 3. MAOJ. lOCXJEO M TMOS TO BE WMBOCD ft
FIWKFW K tmtamtK assocrwh. nacli locateb oh-loi to k
■ -T02LS0 EvSS NO tMAMBB PBOHOM NOPEm 0MB TBTM ETOPlai
MCI
I TO SCCHC CDBRIXie. 1MCH ill K MWIAICB V FLOA
I FUME MO 4. BEQUflCO NAOS BCtMJCtS OUC » BDCCnAlEO ROTBH CT :i|
FUME ME nUE MB ■20N.W 8' BEBMM. OIMHCE OWBCL AtONC BIM M. POT
I TOSBOD •aNW •TBSTa BdSiT hi sconsoAic cm bibb
FWUK HO II w S >C KOUKD NBMUl tWIM OT 1TC SCDK c
TVIUK NO P"- COBBOOB 6 100' ALOW Mm » FBOMOSt AS A s i ill
icgowi DMOg HPBOICICNT OCOPCS HUCM CT TIC
I i BOAO mnAO. Tw abowco scnc cobbbob tms
I CXMlCfO SUCH «M TSE GF t( «<UCD SCOC
C8BBMB FALLS OIRSBE TTC BCGEM BBANNZ
mm USEkCM.
= --•“+ - — ! nnuBt NO FM >1
L|i Ftft3EM^2? / PMA n FBOWME - ijn IF
,7 ;-2ma -lOTQJO ■ICZUO •mym CMAiWEI BCO. SCEMC COBBOOB 0 100' AKXACC B8ITI - NTJOC SF
§ /. -2BSBSB f: BCa SCEMC COBBOOB OUTSOE Oi. - 2N.18 SF
PBCHOCS SCEMC COBBOOB • 47BA8 SF
I 'if. nOWES SCOIC COBBOOB OUISDC LL - IA»4B 8 NKMB
I nAnSi FM NOMBCB SCOC COBBOOB ACME BOTH - (FT
-lOSOJI
11 :4mcc
111 5:72= PBCWSO BWNME OWBCLS ABE WITOO TO BEPUCAIE
FUME n»8 NO NOVNAl WMS MWKB MBSU WN CSnOOH. MOBCvn. t
( :1 < uLOT MOS -TOtSJB NO NO rwi CNiMCL AnaflMC tmAM mxnr coma, bu not k
Ill ::: l.» Oi OCSOCB UMB FWL COISTBIOOHS OMMBS. $0 1TCSE
■104a CTtNBCU MW HM KN ICUOEO M TTC MOS CALCULATDNS
rrn AT 116 THE. nmONB V TIC OWBCLS AC CVEDO) TD K
'\QH-OI *06 ssa£i^ WOES V TIC MOS MH COk AW FBW. FUTIMC.
«£n.
( 1 OH-IOT i
j-
I O NJLO^OMHT
rn MET ‘III
2047 ■asia 2BS4a
11 r W 20C' MB'
■L..J J1 I I
14H. R4E soil: r - 100-
FD BRASS CAP
M mwu Ordinance No. 4723 OF 1 EXH-1
Exhibit B to Exhibit 2
Page 1 of 1
Ingress and Egress Supplemental Exhibit
Happy Valley Road Access
i
& A w i
>1 *0 *. m Wl .Wik i
5
I lappyVaUeyRd
K
mm k- 'i
m
■j*
p. ■»
*. r. !• •/
■7 S,' M m
4
* W; A / m
4^ . V.
Pima Road North Access A
- Right-in-Right out Only H P-* V.
i'
- Deceleration Lane
'S/Ti 1 ^ }
ill'! * 'i III ,1
'=i5 ir 1
ii .-■r;
M
.S'*
K
r-
j ■M
%iIkj 4 I ;5; f
£
I'v IL-I Ks'.
t
Pima Road South Access
i
- Full Access
ia rcv - Deceleration Lane Into Site
j \
- Left Turn Lane Into Site
- Left Turn Laiie Out of Site
mm
! i W'V
7 a.
i ilffiS
X
0
ti i m m
i. VJ
Q 4
P'
I
f.5 s* £€ li *
:IV s .•
y
i
Ordinance No. 4723
Exhibit C to Exhibit 2
Page 1 of 1
NORTH
-g:-
E. Happy Valley RpacI
■o l.-:-
§
ae
D
E
a.
Z
^ite
Rural
Neighborhoods
Rural
Neighborhoods
Developed
Openl
Q.S.
^Commercial space
17-46
Existing General Plan 2035 Future Land Use Map ZN-0003-2026
+/- 94.8-acres of Rural Neighborhoods
Attachment #3
CS)<€0 NORTH
QD<€@IS]i Rl^ZOJESL
(SL E$L!(HDy
E.->Happy*ValleyiRoad
E. La Junta Road
oo
oe E. Whispering
o R1I43JESL
Wind Drive
R1I43 RRDIESL E
a. 0)
4)
Z
x:
Cl 4)
4) o>
■fc: z
Site ■D E. Desert Rlir90
<b^ C
Riy;90JESL CN Vista Road ESL!(HD)
•z.
2
E.~Aiameda-Roadm
R15701ESL E. Mariposa
Grande Drive
R1^l90ESt
Ri;70JRRD]ESL
13JESL
Q.s.
17-46 Zoning Graphic
Existing Zoning ZN-0003-2026
Attachment #4
Shea Homes
Happy Valley Road & Pima Road
Rezoning Project Narrative
'5
fm 'h>
m
-4
U :*■■• ji v*
sT.
mm
t
>:
«
•K' m ■z BMr S
•MM
VERAGE BUILDING SETBACK, i
FROM B.O.C.: 215 ^fk
mi
i
»• ^>1
f
i
1 k*A
4 4 ^'■
k
% 4 I#pii
4 .♦ ■4.' *
t tf m * m
n.',:wm^ fe i f:
.;^/« PEGIOWAL DRA1NAG€ Ci H rt
rw
t -
i:
it / '• -i
.?
1X1 5,
r; is
L'i t
SCCN tc COdftlOOft £ASCMCNT >
(VARIES • AVERAGCKXrV ) ;•••»■ ■€^
^^5?oo^»etwIl I R1-35
4 •» '*■ MINIMUM LOT SIZE------26^50 SOFT
f.-
TOTAL HOMES,______ ___ _____ .77
aif DENSITY .0^1 MOME / AC
i PEDESTRIAN CONNECTION H *■ -*? 5! REQUIRED N AOS.________ 21.94 AC */■
TOCOMMEOCIAL ,•» •A-vvr* %i PROVIDED NADS.________ .23.89 AC */■
v- V
i (K>% R4CREASE)
•ci^E
I :—a-s-aO
20' PIMA scAiSrr^oo
SOUND WALL !- *•;
w
Pre-Application No: ZN-0003-2026
Revised: Oct 2026
Attachment #5
1
REQUEST
On behalf of Shea Homes, this is a request for a rezoning from Rl-190 ESL to Rl-35 ESL on a
94.8+/- gross acre property located at the southeast comer of Happy Valley Road & Pima Road
(the “Property”). The rezoning request is in conformance with the General Plan’s “Rural
Neighborhoods” land use designation with a proposal for gated 77 single-family residential luxury
lot neighborhood on 94.8+/- gross acres (86.10+/- net acres) resulting in a density of 0.81
homes/acre. The Natural Area Open Space (“NAOS”) provided with the development plan
exceeds the requirement by an increase of approximately 2+1- acres through the preservation of
approximately 23.87+/- acres. The request also includes amended development standards
consistent with the Environmentally Sensitive Lands Ordinance (“ESLO”) requirements with a
maximum 25% reduction in lot size and yard dimensions. The City installed a regional drainage
facility along Pima Road, which along with an average 100’ scenic corridor, will result in a buffer
of over 200’ along Pima Road. Lot layout and road placement was thoughtfully designed around
the regional drainage facility, scenic corridor, and wash crossings that traverse the site. Vehicular
access will be provided along both Pima Road (two locations) and Happy Valley Road.
Founded in 1968, Shea Homes is a 4th generation family-owned home builder, highly invested
and dedicated to creating elevated lifestyles throughout Arizona. Their numerous local awards
include, but are not limited to, 2019, 2021,2022, 2024 & 2025 Home Builder of the Year awarded
by the Home Builders Association of Central Arizona. Recent Shea Signature communities in the
area include Signature at Storyrock, Signature at Black Mountain, Signature at the Phoenician, and
Azure at the Ritz-Carlton in Paradise Valley.
2035 GENERAL PLAN CONFORMANCE
“Owr future begins today. Building upon decades of planning and thousands of hours of community
involvement. General Plan 2035 guides the physical development of Scottsdale and acts as a blueprint to
enhance our community aspirations—Exceptional Experience, Outstanding Livability, Community
Prosperity, and Distinctive Character—over the next 20 years. ’’
The General Plan is a tool for guiding future development and contains community goals and
policies on a variety of components that play a role in creating the community in which we live,
work, and enjoy. These goals and policies are broken down into 24 elements. The 2035 General
Plan organizes the 24 elements under the following chapters with a series of goals and policies. A
summary of the development’s conformance to these goals and policies is provided below.
1. Character & Culture 5. Connectivity
2. Sustainability & Environment 6. Revitalization
3. Collaboration & Engagement 7. Innovation & Prosperity
4. Community Well-Being
2
❖ CHARACTER & CULTURE
Character & Design Element
CD 1
Determine the appropriateness of all development in terms of community goals, surrounding
area character, and context
CD 1.1 New and revitalized development should respond to the regional, citywide, and
neighborhood contexts in terms of:
■ Scottsdale’s southwestern, Sonoran Desert characteristics, such as climate, native plants,
topography, and history/culture.
■ Scottsdale as a part of a larger metropolitan area with a unique image, character, and
identity within the regional setting.
■ Relationships and sensitivity to surrounding land forms, land uses, and transportation
corridors.
■ Compatibility with and sensitive integration into established neighborhood character,
including historical preservation policies.
■ Contributions to citywide linkages of open space. Growth Areas, and Activity Areas,
m Creation of new or reinvention of the existing character of an area, when necessary.
■ Physical scale relating to human experience.
■ Visual impacts on and accessibility to public settings, significant natural features, and
neighboring properties.
m Impacts on and sensitivity to the natural environment.
■ Public buildings and facilities that demonstrate the above principles.
CD 1.2 Consider the effects of building height, overall development density, and building
orientation on adjacent neighborhood character, privacy, and viewsheds
CD 1.3 Ensure that all development is a part of and contributes to established Character Types.
CD 1.4 Encourage transitions and blending of character between Character Types, including,
open space areas, building height, massing, and orientation
Response; The team’s site planning efforts over the last year have resulted in a design approach
that is sensitive to the surrounding desert setting and is responsive to both the natural and the built
environmental context. The site plan was created through recognition of the existing constraints
and natural wash corridors that traverse the site. This resulted in a clustered residential
neighborhood design, a reduction in density, and increase in open space. The General Plan defines
clustering as “essentially any development approach that locates buildings in limited areas on
a site and results in a more compact arrangement of buildings on a property. This allows the
remaining land to be used for open space and creates larger blocks of connected open space
3
instead of smaller, individual areas.” While the site plan establishes the lot layout, the more
refined building envelopes depicted on the preliminary grading and drainage plan define the
homesites and preservation of the natural desert predominately on the rear portion of the lots.
The preservation of open space, natural wash corridors and drainageways create a connective
open space network through the site which is achieved by the clustering of homesites. This
is discernible on the site plan through the vegetative pattern indicated along the east and west
perimeters and through the site running east-west between the lots.
Clusterine Exhibit
•r: - *
1
c / I1
Drainage
•'S' isiSLh m 9
* ■A-r- f
Open Space
»^
'li! .1
m K.i
V
.k
4 Open Space
1
»♦! * 4^ T^:
Drainage
smsksE
1
mm v: J. ‘t ISj
v 1
fV
V )
r.. .f; / •I
f kstsm, ± Drainage
■»
I ’■f'A :n
4
Key design considerations include, but are not limited to the following:
• Enhance the visual appearance of, and bring certainty to, a long-standing vacant infill site
along the Pima Road corridor that has been encumbered by a significant regional drainage
channel running along the full extent of the Pima Road streetscape.
• Increase the amount of dedicated NAOS honoring the native desert and wildlife with a
commitment to preserve 27.7% of the site as NAOS (exceeding the required NAOS by
approximately 2+/- acres) resulting in larger perimeter buffers and increased contiguous
open space corridors.
Design a low-scale, single-story residential community with a focus on open space, buffers,
connectivity and desert preservation thereby creating a clustered home layout consistent
with the goals of the ESLO while maintaining a density that is below the 1 dwelling unit
per acre allowed in the General Plan; proposing 0.81 du/ac.
Implement a unified vision and design elements consistent with the surrounding context
that respond to the Southwestern climate and focus on sustainability through site design,
building orientation, material selection, desert preservation, and native landscaping.
Shea Signature Desiens
rm a
L.
GiJl7
- ■■
n
5
CDS
Foster quality design that enhances Scottsdale as a unique southwestern desert and
tourism community through development review processes.
CD 3.1 Strengthen Scottsdale’s economic and environmental attributes, distinctive character,
and attractiveness through collaborative site planning and design.
CD 3.2 Use existing, and adopt new comprehensive polices, guidelines, and design standards for
use in the design and development review process, to ensure public and private development
responds to and enhances the diverse character and contexts within our Sonoran Desert
community.
Response; The proposed unified character of the Property including, but not limited to, site layout,
streetscape, architectural elements, and landscaping design will respect the unique climate, natural
features, and vegetation of the Southwestern desert as identified through the site plan, grading
plan, and landscape plan design.
CD 4
Enhance the design of streets and public spaces to improve Scottsdale’s visual quality,
experience, Sonoran Desert context, and social life.
CD 4.1 Promote contextually compatible streetscapes that correspond with the following
classifications:
■ Natural Streetscapes embody.the.natural.state.of.the.Sonoran.Desert.environment.to.the.
greatest.extent.possible'Zwhile.incorporating.non^motorized.paths.in.the.public.realmj.
Native.plants.and.plant.densities.should.buffer.adjoining.uses?protect.view.corridors?and.
preserve.ru ral.and.desert .contexts!.
CD 4.6 Establish and enhance the visual and physical identity of Scottsdale’s developed open space
corridors.
Response; Streetscapes will be improved to encourage pedestrian comfort, safety, and
accessibility with the proposed design. Within the residential community. Shea Homes will
provide upgraded landscape design packages to the individual homeowner to ensure a quality
landscape setting along the private streetscape. Adjacent to the existing regional drainage corridor
along Pima Road, an average 100’ wide average scenic corridor will be dedicated thereby
providing over 200’ of building setback from the edge of Pima Road. This open space corridor
will provide a visual and physical buffer with pedestrian connectivity within an enhanced natural
streetscape environment. The internal street system is designed to minimize impact, create
6
efficient movement of vehicles, emphasize landscape buffers, and maintain view corridors while
prioritizing pedestrian connectivity.
CDS
Promote the value and visual significance landscaping has on the character of the
community.
CD 5.1 Employ appropriate heat island reduction techniques to reduce the effects of reflective
heat and glare on buildings and paved surfaces.
CD 5.2 To the greatest extent possible, replace dead and dying landscaping with drought
resistant plants to maintain or improve density pattern, shade, and area character.
Response; With approximately 27.7% of the site preserved as NAOS (2+/- acres above the
requirement), the landscape character will include native desert design with a variety of
Southwestern appropriate plants blending with the established desert context that will provide
year-round color, shade, and texture as demonstrated with the conceptual landscape plan.
CD 6
Minimize light and noise pollution.
CD 6.1 Support Scottsdale’s dark sky areas and designation as an Outdoor Light Control City by
reducing light pollution, glare, and trespass where possible, while still attending to public safety
needs.
CD 6.2 Encourage creative, energy-efficient, and high-quality designs for outdoor lighting that
reflect the character of the local context.
Response: Lighting will be designed in a manner that is respectful of the surroimding context
while maintaining wayfinding and safety for residents and visitors in conformance with ESLO
requirements and outdoor lighting parameters. Lighting designs will be commensurate with the
quality and character of the proposed development plan with minimal exterior fixtures and low-
level design with no glare or spillage, further preserving North Scottsdale’s dark skies principles
and honoring views of the night sky.
7
Land Use Element
SITE: Rural Neighborhoods
HAPPY VALLEY RD.
/- %
Future Land Use
Ruroi Neighborhooch I Commercial
Suburban Neighborhoods I Employment; Light Irxluslriol/Otrice
im Urbon Neigr^)orhoods I Enaptoyment; Office
im Mixed-Use Neighborhoods I Culturoi/lmtitutiorxil or Pubfic Use
im Resorts/Tburism I Developed Open Space
RegtoncH Use Overkay I Noturoi Open Space
Sheo Corridor Ovedoy McDowefl Sonoron Preserve
MoyoSupportDBlriclOveflav r_®j S^o..oP.j002»rtUN-»i4
City Boundary Lif>e '■'^*;circle ». Sr.(»•'•< (ttefer to i< S+7N 198» et or.. DC Rat>c^|
orDenOrrser'Is Revrsed to reflect flvough odoptod Novemtset Ge^ot 2022. Pton 1 - , « ^ j Scoltsdole Recommended McDoweB Study Sonoron Boundory Preserve |RSB)
{See Open spoce Elemeni)
LUl
Enhance Scottsdale’s economic viability by encouraging land uses that reinforce the city’s
reputation as the premier international tourist destination in the Southwest and sustain the
city’s role as a regional cultural center and economic hub. Land uses should be compatible
with Scottsdale’s character and physical appearance.
LU 1.1 Encourage land uses that preserve a high quality of life and further define Scottsdale’s
sense of place within the region.
LU 1.2 Celebrate Scottsdale’s desert city image by preserving natural open space and natural
econsystems.
LU 1.3 Promote development patterns that integrate with and reinforce the character of an area.
The city will continually review development patterns to ensure consistency of development in
areas with fragmented or evolving patterns.
8
-and-
LU2
Sensitively transition and integrate land uses with the surrounding natural and built
environments.
LU2.1 Ensure neighborhood "edges” transition to one another through compatible land uses
and development patterns.
LU 2.2 Sensitively integrate low-density development patterns and land uses bordering the
Scottsdale McDowell Sonoran Preserve and other sensitive natural features.
Response: A desert sensitive design that closely examines the natural environment, topography,
vegetation and surrounding conditions of the Property creates a community that clusters residential
development into smaller improved footprints, reduces disturbance, offers more preserved open
space, preserves wash and wildlife corridors, and increases perimeter buffers. The amended
development standards and architectural concepts provide for a significant building setback along
Pima Road, one-story homes, varied building forms, and architectural elements that respond to the
existing desert environment.
LU4
Develop context appropriate land use patterns that support a variety of compatible mobility
choices and services.
LU 4.1 Integrate land uses and transportation systems to allow for a variety of mobility choices.
LU 4.2 Provide opportunities for pedestrian-oriented development, reduced parking demand,
and context appropriate mobility choices.
Response: This Property spans approximately 0.75 miles firom the La Mirada commercial center
north to Happy Valley Road along the east side of Pima Road and constitutes approximately 94.8
+/- gross acres. This area of North Scottsdale is not served by public transit or public travel modes.
However, the Property is uniquely situated directly adjacent to the La Mirada commercial center.
Highlands Church, and the Florence Ely Nelsen Desert Park, along with The Citadel retail center
across Pima Road, providing nearby resources that encourage a range of mobility choices for
residents. Residential next to commercial land uses inherently provides the opportunity for
residents and visitors to walk or bike to nearby restaurants and support services.
9
LU5
Promote land use patterns that conserve resources, including land, clean air, water, and
energy.
LU 5.1 Encourage a variety of compatible mixed-use land uses within or next to Growth and
Activity Areas, along major streets, and within particular Character Areas to reduce automobile
use and improve air quality.
LU 5.3 Minimize environmental hazards and protect the natural character of the desertthrough
sensitive development on Environmentally Sensitive Lands.
Response: The proposed design focuses on larger open space expanses, increased perimeter
buffers, connectivity and desert preservation thereby creating a clustered residential neighborhood
consistent with the goals of the ESLO. The residential community balanced with nearby
commercial support services promotes the conservation of resources, reduced vehicle trips, and
improved air quality.
❖ SUSTAINABILITY & ENVreONMENT
Open Space Element
OSl
Provide four primary public and private open space types: the Scottsdale McDowell Sonoran
Preserve, natural open spaces, developed open spaces, and continuous open spaces.
OS 1.2 Natural Open Space. Provide public and private, natural open spaces to preserve wildlife
habitat, views, and sensitive historical/archeological sites, and, where appropriate, incorporate
areas for passive recreation.
OS 1.3 Continuous Open Spaces. Develop a system of continuous open spaces that connect
citywide and regionally. Such open spaces include washes (inclusive of Vista Corridors),
streetscapes, wildlife corridors, trails, and canals.
Response: Honoring the City’s desire for meaningful connective open space, the site plan allows
for the preservation of continuous open space through the clustering of lots. The site plan also
preserves 27.7% of the site as NAOS (2+/- above the requirement). The open space system will
allow for aggregated NAOS areas, larger landscaped/natural buffers, an enhanced scenic corridor,
preservation of native plants, trail connectivity, and protection of natural wash and wildlife
corridors.
10
NAPS Details
Gross Site Area; 94.80 acres
Net Site Area: 86.10 acres
Required NAPS without Credit: 21.94 acres
Provided NAPS: 23.89 acres
9% more than required
Required NAPS with NAPS Credit for Regional Drainage Facility; 18.37 acres
Provided NAPS: 23.89
30% more than required
OS 2
Fulfill the Scottsdale McDowell Sonoran Preserve initiative to create an integrated desert open
space and wildlife corridor system that connects to the regional Sonoran Desert open space
system.
OS 2.2 Ensure development in proximity to the Scottsdale McDowell Sonoran Preserve respects
its unique location, minimizes impacts to the natural environment, and contributes to the
community’s visual and physical access to open space and the mountains.
OS 2.3 Protect wildlife corridors, habitat, and trail crossings when planning future mobility
routes through and adjacent to the Scottsdale McDowell Sonoran Preserve.
-and-
OS3
Maintain the lush desert character and wildlife corridors by protecting and preserving natural
open spaces.
OS 3.1 Celebrate Scottsdale’s identity as a desert city by preserving existing natural open space,
supporting the preservation of the natural ecosystem, and protecting sensitive environmental
features.
OS 3.2 Protect environmentally sensitive lands from the impacts of development.
OS 3.3 Provide opportunities for people to experience and enjoy the Sonoran Desert and
mountains, while balancing public access and preservation needs.
11
Response: The preservation of NAOS offers both passive and active recreational opportunities
weaved through the community with the integration of a connective multi-use trail within the
scenic corridor. The residential coimmmity design will enhance the natural relationship between
building and landform celebrating the native desert ecosystem, wildlife corridors, natural
topography, and wash features that traverses the Property creating an opportunity for residents to
experience and enjoy the Sonoran Desert. As identified on the NAOS exhibit submitted with the
application, NAOS is provided along the perimeter of the site and within the rear yards of the
residential lots overlapping with drainageways that traverse the Property. The NAOS areas consist
of both undisturbed and re vegetated in conformance with ESLO requirements and are located both
on-lot and in separate tracts.
In addition to the multi-use trail along Pima Road and the adjacent Florence Ely Nelson Desert
Park, the site’s proximity to recreational opportunities within the nearby McDowell Sonoran
Preserve offers an active lifestyle for residents. The Preserve offers niunerous trailheads such as
the Pinnacle Peak, Pima-Dynamite, Tom’s Thumb, and Brown’s Ranch which are all located
within close proximity to the site and provide an abundant network of Preserve trails.
OS 4
Visually and physically connect open spaces to maintain a continuous open space system.
OS 4.1 Develop a public trail and path system that links to other city and regional systems.
OS 4.2 Identify and consider the positive and negative impacts ofproposed projects on
viewsheds.
OS 4.3 As development and redevelopment occurs along transportation corridors, ensure the
preservation of mountain viewsheds, the Sonoran Desert, natural features, and landmarks that
enhance the unique image and aesthetics of major streets through open space buffering. The
following Visually Significant Roadway designations should be applied:
■ Scenic Corridors
■ Buffered Roadways
■ Desert Scenic Roadways
OS 4.4 Encourage the use of drainage areas, Vista Corridors, and transmission line corridors as
open space opportunities.
Response: The Property has natural and physical constraints that guided the site planning efforts.
Natural washes traverse the site and allow for the delineation of open space patterns and buffering
between lots while maintaining view corridors through clustered development patterns. Pima
Road is a “Visually Significant Roadway” and the site plan provides an average 215’ wide building
setback along this edge which consists of the existing regional drainage channel and the proposed
12
scenic corridor. Key design considerations include, but are not limited to, preserving excess NAOS
(approximately 2+1- above the requirement), providing clustered residential design that is low-
scale (one-story) and blends with the natural topography, implementing a unified vision for design
in response to the Southwestern climate such as building orientation, material selection, desert
preservation and native landscaping
OS 6
Design and manage open spaces to relate to surrounding land uses and character.
OS 6.1 Evaluate the design of open spaces with the following primary determinants: aesthetics,
neighborhood and service area needs, public safety, visual and functional connectivity, social
and economic impacts, maintenance requirements, water consumption, drainage considerations,
multi-use. Character Area, desert preservation, and wildlife corridor protection.
OS 6.2 Protect the different priorities and management objectives for each of the Open Space Land
Use categories.
OS 6.3 Aesthetically and sensitively integrate utilities and other public facilities into open spaces.
OS 6.4 Ensure development plans respect existing topography, view corridors, wildlife corridors,
and open space. Where possible, enhance existing viewsheds as areas are developed and
redeveloped.
OS 6.5 Provide ample shade in public open spaces as appropriate for the type of open space.
Response: The built environment will respect the existing topography and native vegetation
through site design, integrated native landscaping, and low-scale, one-story architectural
massing/character while preserving the existing wash corridors, viewsheds and wildlife corridors.
Providing an interactive pedestrian environment is key to creating a thriving commimity and
celebrating the native desert context and North Scottsdale lifestyle. The proposed residential
commimity will provide a direct pedestrian connection to the existing La Mirada commercial
center at the southwest comer of the site. Utilities and similar public facilities will be
inconspicuous and screened appropriately.
Environmental Planning Element
EPl
Protect and enhance Scottsdale’s human and Sonoran Desert habitats.
EP 1.1 Retain Scottsdale’s Sonoran Desert aesthetic values and heritage.
13
EP 1.3 Require developments to retain and integrate the Sonoran Desert ecosystem.
EP 1.4 Preserve local plants, wildlife, and natural resources to maintain the biodiversity and
long-term sustainability of the area’s ecology.
Response: The proposed residential community will preserve and/or relocate existing native plants
and mature trees as well as provide new native and arid-adapted plant material that contributes to
the broader surrounding Sonoran Desert context. Further, the landscape design will utilize plant
species identified in Scottsdale Indigenous Plant List which provides guidance on revegetated
NAOS areas. The design focuses on creating a comfortable and walkable experience for users
within the existing Sonoran Desert context. Trails and open space improvements will respect local
natural resources and wildlife while promoting the long-term sustainability of the area’s ecology.
EPS
Encourage environmentally sound green buildings and low-impact site plans that support
sustainable desert living.
EP 5.2 Increase the use of green infrastructure, including low-impact development (LID)
stormwater management techniques, such as curb openings and permeable pavement.
EP 5.3 Construct durable and sustainable buildings using green building principles.
EP 5.4 Promote passive solar site and building design strategies that recognize and respond to
the Sonoran Desert climate.
EP 5.5 Expand Green Building construction standards to include all new and remodeled
residential and commercial buildings.
Response: The new homes and buildings will meet and/or exceed all International Green
Construction Codes (“IGCC”) sustainability design standards. The use of green infrastructure,
including low-impact development (“LID”) stormwater management techniques will be
emphasized. Experienced in Arizona homebuilding, Shea’s building designs will promote passive
solar through exterior shading and building articulation to minimize direct solar heat gain.
EP7
Identify and reduce heat islands.
EP 7.1 Identify areas most impacted by the heat island effect, and prioritize mitigation for these
areas to reduce heat impacts.
14
EP 7.2 Incorporate development strategies such as shared parking models and the use of "cool
materials” (eg., landscaping, green roofs, reflective pavement, heat reduction asphalt coatings,
permeable concrete, and treated dirt areas) to help reduce the heat island effect.
EP 7.3 Develop and support programs, such as a Tree Canopy Plan, that identify and increase
vegetation and shading in areas of high pedestrian activity.
EP 7.4 Promote the long-term management and maintenance of urban and open area vegetation
and protect and expand the provision of private andpublic open spaces to reduce the heat island
effect.
Response: The mixed-use character of the area inherently promotes environmental sustainability
by offering housing within close proximity to commercial, recreational, and religious land uses.
Integrated pedestrian connectivity encourages walkability and promotes the City’s ‘live, pilay,
work’ General Plan objective. The design includes clustering of home sites to provide more open
space and less asphalt, drought tolerant plant material able to withstand extreme heat conditions
while promoting water conservation and ESLO principles. The City’s IGCC and sustainable
building methods and techniques will be implemented. Color and material selection of the building
finishes will provide reflectivity and reduce heat gain. Building finishes will comply with the
ESLO design standards required by the Zoning Ordinance including limitations on the Light
Reflectance Value (“LRV”); no paint colors shall exceed a LRV of 40%. Building overhangs and
architectural elements will provide recessed fenestration and shaded elements to further reduce
ground temperatures.
Conservation Element
CONSVl
Achieve a sustainable balance between the conservation of natural resources and development
of the built environment
CONSV 1.4 Encourage landscape designs that promote water conservation, prevent erosion,
reduce the heat island effect; and decrease stormwater runoff.
CONSV 1.5 Protect and restore ecosystems that maintain water quality, reduce flooding, and
enhance sustainable resource development.
Response: Plant specifications and accent materials will consist of low-maintenance and drought
tolerant specieS; Improved common areas will focus on tree selection and placement that provide
shade and visual benefits. Shea’s commitment to 21.1% NAOS will promote water conservation,
erosion protection, reduced heat island effect, and decreased stormwater runoff These efforts will
help protect the ecosystem and reduce flooding.
15
CONSV2
Protect and manage Sonoran Desert biodiversity and native ecosystems.
C0NSV2.J Preserve, salvage, and/or restore native plants, wildlife habitat, and natural
resources to maintain the biodiversity and long-term sustainability of the area’s desert ecology
and character.
CONSV 2.2 Encourage landscaping that limits the amount of grass and makes optimal use of
native desert plants.
CONSV 2.3 Maintain natural washes as wildlife movement corridors and avoid disturbances to preserve
habitat linkages.
Response: The proposed residential community will utilize natural and locally sourced plant
materials appropriate for the Sonoran Desert and North Scottsdale setting. As demonstrated with
the development plan, landscape design will emphasize the salvage and re-use of existing native
trees and specimen cacti and limit the disturbance to the greater natural environment consistent
with ESLO principles. Utilizing salvaged plant material to the extent possible will both
aesthetically and environmentally blend the proposed community with the smTounding landscape
and provide mature vegetation and shade for residents while contributing to the long-term
sustainability of the area’s Sonoran Desert ecology and character. New plant material will adhere
to the Arizona Department of Water Resoiurces (“ADWR”) low water use/drought tolerant plant
list, and match or complement species found in the region. Any boulders identified and/or collected
on-site will preserved and/or be repurposed in accordance with ESLO and integrated into the
proposed site design to the extent possible.
CONSV4
Conserve water and encourage the reuse of wastewater.
CONSV4.3 Continue to thoroughly review development impacts on water use and encourage
development design that fosters water conservation.
CONSV4.8 Explore new and evolving water conservation and reuse technologies and use
them as appropriate.
Response: Water conservation techniques will continue to be refined as part of the design
development process, post zoning approval. These methods will likely include, but will not be
limited to, integration of arid-adapted plants, drip irrigation, smart controller systems, nighttime
landscape watering, leak sensors, permeable paving, rainwater and HVAC condensation capture
for landscaping, tankless water heaters, and utilization of low flow faucets and shower heads.
16
CONSV5
Retain and prevent erosion of significant watercourses and water bodies.
CONSV 5.1 Discourage and minimize clearing and grading within sites located in areas
designated as Environmentally Sensitive Lands (ESL).
CONSV 5.2 Maintain existing and promote wise placement of native plants as the primary means
to control erosion and retain Sonoran Desert character.
CONSV 5.5 Manage streams, washes, andfloodplains to maintain their multiple biological,
physical, and social values.
Response: The clustered site design of the residential lot layout will allow for the preservation of
connective open space, with a commitment to preserve 27.7% of the site as NAOS. This open
space system will allow for aggregated NAOS areas, larger landscaped/natural buffers, enhanced
scenic corridor, preservation of native plants and land features, trail cormectivity, and protection
of natural wash and wildlife corridors.
Energy Element
Kl
Promote building and site designs that maximize energy efficiency.
E 3.1 Encourage the use of natural properties and sustainable building systems (e.g., sun,
shade, thick walls, insulation) to reduce the demand for and use of mechanical cooling and
heating systems.
E 3.2 Encourage the use of drought tolerant landscaping to reduce summer solar heat gain.
E 3.3 Promote solar energy opportunities in building and site design.
E 3.4 Incorporate healthy, resource- and energy-efficient materials and methods in design,
construction, and remodeling of buildings.
E 3.5 Orient buildings and lots in ways that minimize summer solar heat gain, maximize roof
solar access and natural ventilation, and limit roof solar access obstructions of neighboring
structures.
E 3.6 Improve the energy efficiency of the building envelope, heating and cooling
systems, lighting, and appliances.
17
Response: Residential lots and building orientation will be designed to encourage abundant
shaded outdoor space and natural ventilation. As part of Shea’s architectural design, building
envelope walls, roofs and windows will include enhanced insulation to reduce heat gain. Drought
tolerant landscape will be integrated throughout in response to the Southwestern climate while still
providing abundant shade and solar relief Energy efficient building systems, HVAC,
interior/exterior lighting, and appliances will be utilized.
❖ COLLABORATION & ENGAGEMENT
Community Involvement Element
CIl
Seek early and ongoing community involvement through broad public input in project and
policy-making discussions.
Cl 1.1 Maximize opportunities for early notification of proposed projects using a variety of
methods.
Cl 1.2 Use public involvement plans to identify and engage interested parties and provide
opportunities for information exchange.
Response: Public participation and community outreach is an important part of the rezoning
process. Our team began neighborhood outreach early in the process and the team maintains on
going dialogue with the community and stakeholders. Feedback fi-om one-on-one meetings, phone
calls, and the open house meeting is shared with City Staff and memorialized in the Public
Participation plan submitted with this zoning application.
❖ COMMUNITY WELL-BEING
The strength of the community relies on the well-being of all of its members. A healthy, livable
community provides both necessary physical and social infrastructure. Although physical
features, such as walkability, good quality housing and health care systems, and access to open
space and recreation facilities can encourage people to make healthier choices, community
well-being relies on more than just a city’s physical form. Health and human services, faith-
based resources, non-profit partnerships, and social relationships are equally important and
collectively help people achieve their basic needs and reach their full potential.
High-quality, safe housing is one core aspect of community well-being. Scottsdale embraces
housing options for people living and working in the city; people at different life stages and
income levels; and people with various social and physical needs. Scottsdale also values
18
housing that enhances the character, diversity, and vitality of the city, and respects the Sonoran
Desert environment. Proactive maintenance and improvement of the existing housing stock,
revitalization of neighborhoods, encouragement of context-appropriate infill housing, and
continued commitment to community safety and sustainability will ensure Scottsdale’s
neighborhoods continue to thrive in the future.
Another critical aspect of community health is recreation facilities as well as programs that
enhance the social, psychological, and physical well-being of citizens. A well-managed,
interconnected system that provides active and passive recreational opportunities should be
available to all ages, on a year-round basis. In addition, open spaces are not merely desirable,
but are integral to the community’s overall physical and social well-being.
2035 General Plan, Page 116
Healthy Community Element
HC3
Build on Scottsdale’s leadership role in wellness and healthful living.
HC 3.1 Provide quality recreation, community events, and neighborhood services that foster
physical activity and encourage healthful living.
HC 3.4 Continue to foster and market Scottsdale as a resort, wellness, rejuvenation, and
healthcare destination.
Response; In addition to the trail system along Pima Road and the adjacent Florence Ely
Nelson Desert Park, the Property’s proximity to recreational opportunities within the nearby
McDowell Sonoran Preserve offers an active, healthful lifestyle for residents. The Preserve
offers numerous trailheads such as the Pinnacle Peak, Pima-Dynamite, Tom’s Thumb, and
Brown’s Ranch which are all located within close proximity to the site and provide an abundant
network of Preserve trails.
Housing Element
HI
Support diverse, safe, resource-efficient, and high-quality housing options.
H 1.1 Maintain Scottsdale’s quality-driven development review standards for new development.
H 1.2 Promote complementary physical design, building structure, landscaping, and lot layout
relationships between existing and new construction.
19
H 1.3 Ensure community dialogue during zoning and the development review processes to
encourage context appropriate development designs.
H 1.5 Encourage a variety of housing densities in context-appropriate locations throughout
Scottsdale to accommodate projected population growth.
H 1.6 Maintain, improve and create high-quality and safe housing for all citizens.
H 1.8 Encourage developments to incorporate the highest possible cost- and quality-effective
level of amenities, sustainable design, durability, and architectural quality.
Response: The proposed residential community will help meet the growing need for housing in
Scottsdale by providing additional residential options, further contributing to the long-term
economic prosperity of the City and surrounding area. Additionally, Shea’s proposed development
plan for this long-standing vacant infill site will support a sustainable economic future as the City
continues to evolve. The proposed lot sizes range fi’om 26,268 s.f to 70,171 s.f, with an average
lot size of 30,985+/- s.f
Recreation Element
BJ.
Provide and enhance recreational opportunities that meet the diverse needs of Scottsdale’s
citizens and visitors.
R 2.5 Develop and maintain a citywide interconnected network of trails to provide valuable
recreation and fitness opportunities for residents and visitors. Where possible, trails should
connect to neighborhoods and serve major destinations.
Response: Given the Property’s close proximity to the McDowell Sonoran Preserve, which offers
over 30,000 acres of protected desert and abimdant trails, there are numerous recreational and
fitness opportunities for residents and visitors to enjoy.
❖ CONNECTIVITY
Circulation Element
01
Design and improve transportation corridors to safely and efficiently move people and
goods.
20
C 1.1 Support the public transit system to assure adequate and affordable access to and within
our community for citizens, employees, visitors, and businesses through the use offuture
technologies and micro-mobility options.
C 1.2 Coordinate transportation and land use planning to enhance an integrated, sustainable
transportation system that promotes livable neighborhoods, economic vitality, safety, efficiency,
mode choice, and adequate parking.
C 1.5 Incorporate strategies and technologies that efficiently move people, improve
transportation system capacity and enhance mobility choices.
C 1.7 Retrofit aging neighborhood infrastructure and streets and create non-motorized
neighborhood connections to enhance livability, safety, accessibility, and comfort
Response: This Property spans approximately 0.75 miles from the La Mirada commercial center
north to Happy Valley Road along the east side of Pima Road and constitutes approximately 94.8
+/- gross acres. This area of North Scottsdale is not served by public transit or public travel modes.
However, uniquely situated directly adjacent to the La Mirada commercial center. Highlands
Church, and the Florence Ely Nelsen Desert Park, along with The Citadel retail center across Pima
Road, there are nearby resources that encourage a range of mobility choices for residents.
Residential next to commercial land uses inherently provide the opportunity for residents and
visitors to walk or bike to nearby restaurants and support services. Regional access is provided
via Pima Road, (north/south). Happy Valley Road and Pinnacle Peak Roads (east/west) and is
situated approximately 4 miles north of the Loop 101 freeway. Vehicular access to/from the
Property will be provided along both Pima Road (two locations) and Happy Valley Road.
01
Reduce the number, length, and frequency of automobile trips to improve air quality, reduce
traffic congestion, and enhance quality of life and the environment
C 2.1 Encourage a mix of land uses that will reduce the distance and frequency of automobile
trips and support mobility choices.
C 2.2 Integrate a variety of mobility choices along local and regional transportation corridors.
C 2.3 Reduce demands on transportation networks by using trip reduction strategies and travel
demand management techniques, including technology and applications, telecommuting,
alternative work schedules, carpooling, and transit/bicycling incentives in order to provide
travelers with effective choices to improve travel reliability.
21
C 2.4 Work with employers to provide incentives and encouragement for trip reduction
strategies.
C 2.5 Promote non-motorized travel for short neighborhood trips.
Response: As mentioned previously, the Property is well situated for local and regional access
while also promoting walkability and access to the trail system along Pima Road and easy
pedestrian access to the adjacent retail and church. The design implements a range of General Plan
goals and policies including the integration of context appropriate and ESLO enhancing site
planning, clustering of residential homes, preservation of natural open space, creating a
comfortable pedestrian realm, and providing sensitive edge buffering. The area’s mixed-use
context wilt reduce trip generation with nearby services and amenities for residents to utilize and
enjoy.
❖ REVITALIZATION
Neighborhood Preservation & Revitalization Element
NPRl
Preserve and enhance the character, identity, and quality of Scottsdale’s diverse
neighborhoods.
NPR 1.1 Support innovative, well-designed, sustainable building construction and rehabilitation
to enhance neighborhood character and identity.
NPR 1.2 New construction and exterior remodels or renovations should sensitively address
neighborhood character and transition areas.
Response: The proposed residential community brings a wide range of design sensitive attributes
to north Scottsdale including, but not limited to, preserving 27.7% of the site as NAOS, providing
a 100’ average scenic corridor along Pima Road (in addition to the existing regional drainage
facility), meaningful perimeter buffering, and sensitive edge transitions while respecting the
natural topography and preserving of native desert vegetation.
NPR 5
Promote neighborhood interaction to help create and maintain strong communities.
NPR 5.1 Preserve existing and create new public gathering spaces within walking distance of
residential areas.
NPR 5.3 Encourage physical and social links between non-residential and residential land uses.
22
Response: By providing a quality perimeter buffering and low-scale single-story homes, the
design minimizes focus on the automobile, promotes walkability, and encourages social
interaction. The proposed residential community adds to the balance of land uses in the area,
bringing certainty to a long-standing vacant site in north Scottsdale.
Cost of Development Element
CODl
As permitted by State Law, require development to pay its fair share of the cost ofpublic
service needs it generates.
COD 1.6 Continue to use water, water resources, and sewer development fees to ensure that new
growth pays for itself without adversely impacting existing customers.
-and-
COD2
Promote development timing guided by the adequacy of existing and/or expandable
infrastructure, services, and facilities.
COD 2.2 Ensure proposed development commits to construction of primary water, wastewater,
and circulation systems, as necessary, before approval.
Response: Consistent with City requirements. Shea is required to submit water and sewer basis of
design reports, as well as a traffic report, to ensure that adequate infrastructure and transportation
systems are in place to serve the proposed residential community. This new residential
neighborhood will comply with all City requirements with respect to water and sewer fees to
ensure that development pays for growth. The estimated value of Shea’s investment for this
proposed residential community is approximately $250+ million.
CONCLUSION
To summarize, in support of the proposed zoning request, the key design considerations are upheld
through context appropriate site planning and design in the following ways:
• Enhance the visual appearance of, and bring certainty to, a long-standing vacant infill site
along the Pima Road corridor that has been encumbered by a significant regional drainage
channel running along the fiill extent of the Pima Road streetscape.
• Increase the amount of dedicated NAOS honoring the native desert and wildlife with a
commitment to preserve 27.7% of the site as NAOS (exceeding the required NAOS by
23
approximately 2+/- acres) resulting in larger perimeter buffers and increased contiguous
open space corridors.
• Design a low-scale, single-story residential community with a focus on open space, buffers,
cormectivity and desert preservation thereby creating a clustered home layout consistent
with the goals of the ESLO while maintaining a density that is below the 1 dwelling unit
per acre allowed in the General Plan; proposing 0.81 du/ac.
• Implement a unified vision and design elements consistent with the surrounding context
that respond to the Southwestern climate and focus on sustainability through site design,
building orientation, material selection, desert preservation, and native landscaping.
24
rcutoiniHii HI1U vtniuuLHn uinuuLHiiuii tlhii
A
■A
.♦ r t-. '.i.
v:
tM
r<vm
% 3
>*4
wMlWliilii^ E HAPPY VALLEY RD|||p|i^B >
t
i-
%
J» % V
■w
m
.* n
'• >--i
V
m r*2 i V
f ii
>■ ■i. > ¥ FV4
ii iC*-¥i
i^ :m V t mmMmm
t 4
a3^ Kt.
r*
%
4t v>
2; ■V-.^ v:
SINGLE FAMILY wm 4./ •* J'
a;?:;:, RESIDENTIAL
PM
j.
1 ’ ^ RESIDENTIAL Kfcitfa
i:
liiOspso5m
f!.f •«
»• r.K
/
A
V-r L- !*'
:i: .• <1 -V^ -----
AW r r
20' PIMA
«• M IKin \A/Al I
•-»' a-Mss®' TO«si
>- K»A
i? * <■ .-A
S.'^i-
o * i;f V
rw. 21-i ?r-- . : .
■ T z ^!t- r.c Ta i»Sii
*:
S
?:i J r; s^ * * T C Q'^ rli
n ■f./r 4* CO A 7
ii
jfCdjIiMER'Ci: 'i
«► -S' !',• »’ V
mm 5i *A 4.V ■*•■? aS. ,» »t
f,
1
tS’U? .. ■ <■ i-'
LEGEND
VEHICULAR CONNECTION 5K
■ii» 8’ PEDESTRIAN CONNECTION
?r,
—'♦■ lo’TRAIL at s'.
____5’ INTERNAL SIDEWALK
A m
Q VEHICULAR ACCESS l1 m M
rnn
GATED ENTRY w: W "S
Vrr-.id s*
Attachment #6
m
Shea Homes
HVR & Pima
11. RECOMMENDATIONS & CONCLUSIONS
The proposed HVR & Pima development is located on the southeast corner of Happy Valley Road
and Pima Road in Scottsdale, Arizona. The proposed development consists of 77 single-family
detached dwelling units and is anticipated to open in the year 2027.
Trip Generation
The proposed development is anticipated to generate 887 weekday trips with 57 trips occurring
during the AM peak hour and 76 trips during the PM peak hour.
Trip Generation Comparison
Compared to the land use of 19 single-family detached dwelling units permitted by right with the
existing R1-190 zoning, the build-out of the proposed HVR 81 Pima development is anticipated to
generate 714 additional weekday trips, with 39 additional trips during the AM peak hour, and 55
additional trips during the PM peak hour.
Future Conditions - Year 2027
All existing study intersections and movements under 2027 build out conditions are projected to
operate at the same LOS as the 2027 no build scenario.
The only new site intersection operating at a lower LOS is the intersection of Pima Road and
Driveway C (9) with westbound left movement operating at LOS F during the AM and PM peak
hours. This condition is typical for unsignalized left out turn movements during peak periods due to
limited gaps in opposing traffic.
Recommendations
In summary, as included in the discussion and analyses throughout this report, the following are the
recommended improvements to be made by the HVR & Pima development:
Happy Valley Road and Driveway A (7)
■ Buildout of a full access driveway along Happy Valley Road, approximately 925
feet east of Pima Road (centerline to centerline).
■ Installation of a stop sign on the northbound approach
■ Buildout of a westbound left turn ingress deceleration lane with 100 feet of
storage
■ Buildout of a westbound left turn egress acceleration lane a total of 150 feet
of length, which includes the reverse curve, vehicle storage area, and opening
Attachment #7 30
Shea Homes
HVR & Pima
Pfma Road and Driveway B (8)
■ Buildout of a RIRO driveway along Pima Road, approximately 175 feet south of
De La O Road (centerline to centerline).
■ Installation of a stop sign on the westbound approach
■ Buildout of a northbound right turn deceleration with 100 feet of storage
• Pima Road and Driveway C (9)
■ Buildout of a full access driveway along Pima Road, approximately 1,775 feet
south of De La O Road (centerline to centerline).
■ Installation of a stop sign on the westbound approach
■ Buildout of a southbound left turn deceleration lane with 100 feet of storage
■ Buildout of a northbound right turn deceleration with 100 feet of storage
In conclusion, the additional traffic generated by the proposed development is expected to result
in minimal traffic-related impacts on the existing roadway network and the surrounding area.
31
BCHNiCAL SOLUTIONS
CITIZEN REVIEW & NEIGHBORHOOD INVOLVEMENT REPORT
Shea Homes- Pima & Happy Valley
July 15,2026
/
Overview
This Citizen Review Report is being performed in association with a request
for a Zoning District Map Amendment from Rl-190 ESL (HD) to RI-35 ESL on
an approximately 94,8+/- acre site located at the southeast corner of
Pima Road and Happy Valley Road. The proposed project would result in
a new luxury, for-sale single-family residential community with significant
setbacks along Pima Road and to the existing residential to the east. The
General Plan land use designation of Rural Neighborhoods would not be
changed as part of this request. This Citizen Review Report \MII be
updated throughout the process.
The entire project team is sensitive to the importance of neighborhood
involvement and creating a positive relationship with property owners,
residents, business owners, homeowners associations, and other interested
parties. Communication with these parties will be ongoing throughout the
process. Work on compiling a list of impacted and interested stakeholders
and neighborhood outreach began prior to the application filing and will
also continue throughout the process.
Community Involvement
The outreach team has been communicating with neighboring property
owners, HOAs, and community members by telephone, one-on-one
meetings, virtual meetings, and door-to-door outreach since August 2025.
The outreach team visited almost 100 surrounding residences to get their
feedback on the project. A significant amount of this feedback was
favorable to this proposal, and several signatures of support were
collected during those visits.
In addition to the door-to-door contact, the outreach team held an
informational virtual meeting on January 21.2026 with the Board of the
Pinnacle Peak HOA, which included the General Manager of Desert
Attachment #8
5111 Noilh Scottsdale Road, Suite 260 • Scottsdale, AZ 85250 • (602) 957-3434 • FAX: (602) 955-4505 • Email: info@techmcalsolutionsaz.com
Highlands. The outreach team also met on December 18, 2025 with the
senior leadership of Highlands Church, which borders the site.
Surrounding property owners, HOAs and other interested parties were
noticed via first class moil regarding the project. The distribution of this
notification adhered to the City’s 1,250’ radius mailing requirements os
specified in fhe Citizen Review Checklist. This notification contained
information about the project, os well os contact information for the
development team. This contact person will continue to provide, os
needed, additional information and the opportunity to give feedback.
The notificofion also contained information regarding o neighborhood
Open House meeting that was held on January 26, 2026 for those who
wished to learn more about the project. The site and time of this meeting
were posted with the Early Notification Sign prior to the Open House.
21 interested people attended the Open House. Questions and
comments arose from attendees regarding building height, density,
traffic, setbacks, open space, sewer infrastructure, and housing product.
Specifically, o few otfendees who live in fhe Solitude community
immediately east of our sife hod quesfions about the effects on their
community's access point on Happy Valley Rood and their sewer
infrastructure. These questions were oil answered by the development
team to the best of their ability at the time. Since then, the development
team has hod o number of meefings wifh the Solitude HOA leadership. As
o result of these meetings, the development team has submitted o
proposal to the City for o reconfigured Happy Valley Rood entry design. In
addition, the development team is working with the HOA leadership to
see if they con assist in addressing the Solitude community's existing sewer
infrastructure issue.
The development team will continue to be accessible by phone and
email subsequent to the Open House to ensure that surrounding property
owners and neighbors hove ongoing opportunities to comment and ask
questions. A vital port of the outreach process is to allow people to
express their concerns and understand issues and attempt to address
them in o professional and timely manner. Again, the entire team realizes
the importance of the neighborhood involvement process and is
committed to communication and outreach for the project.
Attachments:
Notification Letter
Notification List
Affidavit of Posfing
Sign-in Sheets
Comment Cords
5111 North Scottsdale Road, Suite 260 • Scottsdale, AZ 85250 • (602) 957-3434 • FAX: (602) 9554505 • Email: inft)@technicalsolutioiisa2;.com
d ECHNICAL SOLUTIONS
January 14, 2026
Notice of Neighborhood Meeting
Dear Neighbor:
We are pleased to inform you of an upcoming request (845-PA-2025) by Shea Homes to create a
luxury, for-sale single family home, gated residential community on the currently vacant land
located at the southeast comer of Pima Road and Happy Valley Road. The project would include
77 single-family one-story residences on the 94.8+/- acre parcel with significant setbacks along
Pima Road and to the existing residential to the east. The official request is for a Zoning District
Map Amendment from Rl-190 ESL (HD) to R1-35 ESL. The General Plan land use designation
of Rural Neighborhoods would not be changed as part of this request.
You are invited to attend a “come and go” open house to discuss this proposal. The open house
will be held on Monday, January 26,2026 from 5 p.m. to 6 p.m. in the Worship Center Lobby
of the nearby Highlands Church, located at 9050 £. Pinnacle Peak Road.
If you have any questions, please contact the neighborhood outreach team at 602-957-3434 or
info@technicalsolutionsaz.com. The City of Scottsdale Project Coordinator for the project is
Jeff Bames, who can be reached at 480-312-2376 or JBames@ScottsdaleAZ.gov.
Thank you.
Sincerely,
/t-. -
Susan Bitter Smith
President
CONCEPT PLAN
L?3W5 5 >>
.s ft
C HAPPY VALLEY PD
• *.' \l . f .A Ml. ». iJ
A*.I 'jSf/Sli'l
V
i Z * 5
L.y! 4
ISi #4
m
y 7N
mm
h ■V p
K f
•fv I }m ^ ‘*
AVERAGE BUILDING SETBACK A ^ SETBACK' ,> ?“;/
iJa
Y* MpsS
PBODE^CTY LIN^ iA
;{i
1^
> ocI ..dpfci
a.
:•. .♦. ^•■•». .1.^ fl^iifL vTp': -. ^yA'-'y
t r» >
4' V
: ■k f .4 "ii
1
11^
&P<yOMAl DOAlhJAGEC^lANNPL
'I
y it A< ^
.•y ¥■. •Sifc •«
7
% |«a!i
•• Ss •Lja j**
!'4 ,>;
t >8|iii^ r rMm
•# ri ■:f^; 7
K-f
a /,■m
>J
I
•SCENC CODRIDOD f ASFKC^’^tf Jfrrfr!
‘ <vAaiPs AvroASEioo*/! NfiV
\
1
•A
•i ’Ll
• -H:
yr i
h
ty
1 »<'*«
im. ■h
»g
BC^m v-*
i *: iFi n
mm
a
Barnes, Jeff
From: Gregory Cooper <grcooper8@gmail.com>
Sent: Friday, March 6, 2026 12:04 PM
To: Barnes, Jeff
Subject: Proposed re-zoning project
I External Email: Please use caution if opening iinks or attachments!
Dear [Recipient Name],
I am writing to express my opposition to the proposed re-zoning of the vacant land at the southeast
corner of Pima Road and Happy Valley Road. As a resident livingdirectly behind this property, I believe
the current R1 -190 ESL zoning is appropriate and should be maintained.
Transitioning to R1-35 zoning to allow upwards of 75 homes is irresponsible for several reasons. Our
local infrastructure cannot accommodate the estimated 150-200 additional vehicles per day.
Furthermore, my property drains into this land, which contains deep natural run-out areas during heavy
rain; developing this space poses significant drainage concerns. There is also no natural egress from the
property to travel south on Pima Road. Additionally, the proposed zoning would allow for three-story
homes, which are inconsistent with the character of the surrounding neighborhood.
Scottsdale should prioritize preserving natural spaces over developing every available acre. Please let
me know when public hearings will be held or, at a minimum, how I can officially weigh in on this issue.
Best regards,
Greg Cooper
630-917-5058
Attachment #9
1
From: Mike Klavko
To: Prolectinput
Subject: Fwd: Zoning Request Case # ZN-0003-2026
Date: Friday, March 13, 2026 11:24:17 AM
External Email: Please use caution if opening links or attachments!
Begin forwarded message:
From: Mike Klayko <mike.klayko@gmail.com>
Subject: Zoning Request Case # ZN-0003-2026
Date: March 13, 2026 at 11:11:01 AM MST
To: "Projectlnput@scottsdaleaz.gove" <Projectlnput@scottsdaleAZ.gove>
Resubmitting per the Notice I just received
Michael Klayko
Begin forwarded message:
From: Mike Klayko <mike.klayko@gmail.com>
Subject: Zoning Request appiication request
Date: February 2. 2026 at 10:07:05 AM MST
To: "jbarnes@scottsdaleaz.gov" <jbarnes@scottsdaleAZ.gov>
Dear Mr. Barnes,
My wife and I recently attended a Notice of Neighborhood Meeting
on January 26th, 2026, to discuss the request to rezone 94.8 acres at
Pima and Happy Valley. The project request (845-PA-2025) was
discussed, which has requested zoning from Rl-190 ESL to R1-35.
The density would increase from 15 lots to 77 lots.
There was lots of attendance at the Neighborhood meeting, but not
lots of support. 1 am all in supporting development and growth for
greater Scottsdale, but crowding these homes in doesn’t fit well in the
area proposed. We retired and moved here from Wyoming and spent
our life savings in buying our home here. The reason we chose Prado
was the large 5-acre lot, the unobstructed view, and the area directly
to the west of our home being zoned R1-190ESL. We were aware
that at some point in the future, some homes could be developed on
this 95-acre parcel, but with a limited number of homes, we believed
the construction disruption (dust and noise) would be minimal. The
increase in density request would dramatically change that belief.
There are plenty of imdeveloped parcels in the Scottsdale area that
would accommodate this high-density request, and therefore, we
would like you to consider NOT approving the zoning request and
keeping this area a bit more rural as it is currently zoned.
Thank you very much.
Michael Klayko
24162 N 90th Way
Scottsdale, AZ 85225
408-568-0017
Barnes, Jeff
From: Adam Warner <adamwarner@gmail.com>
Sent: Wednesday, April 1, 2026 10:33 PM ,
To: Barnes, Jeff
Cc: Richard Marzan; Seth Greisinger; Ericka Anglin
Subject: Solitude discussion regarding case ZN-0003-2026-Shea Homes
j External Email: Please use caution if opening links or attachments!
Hi Jeff,
Thank you for taking the time to meet with Richard Marzan and me last Wednesday regarding the
proposed Shea Homes development at Happy Valley Road and Pima Road.
Solitude is a 33-home community located directly east of the proposed development. Our HOA was
transferred from the developer to residents approximately six months ago. Richard and I serve on the
board along with Seth Greisinger.
In mid-January, we were notified of the proposed development through a letter from Technical Solutions
inviting us to an open house. Richard and I attended and shared several concerns and potential
solutions; however. Shea Homes did not attend the meeting. The meeting felt largely procedural, with
limited discussion or documentation, and there was no follow-up on the issues raised.
As Solitude transitions from development to long-term community management, we are focused on
safety, infrastructure, and quality of life. Several existing challenges are already impacting our residents
and will be further intensified by the proposed Shea development.
We have no interest in delaying the project if Scottsdale determines it meets City standards and
requirements. However, we respectfully request that appropriate City specialists review the following
concerns:
1. Traffic
Solitude has a single entry/exit at N 90th Way, which already presents safety challenges. Over the past
decade, significant growth from communities to the east—including Skye View, Serrano Canyon,
StoryRock, and others—has dramatically increased traffic along Happy Valley Road. We do appreciate
the Scottsdale’s investments to expand Happy Valley Road to accommodate this increased demand.
Unfortunately, unlike neighboring communities that benefit from roundabouts, turn lanes, or median
refuge points. Solitude residents must often attempt left turns across fast-moving traffic with limited
visibility due to median landscaping. At peak times, some residents avoid turning left altogether and
instead travel east to 92nd Street to safely route back toward Pima Road via Pinnacle Peak Road.
Additional traffic from the Shea development—particularly with another access point on Happy Valley
Road—will further increase risk.
1
We request:
Elimination of the Shea access point on Happy Valley Road
0
At least one signal-controlled exit onto Pima Road
Creation of a median refuge to allow safer left turns from Solitude
2. 92nd Street
92nd Street was previously closed but.is now open, creating a cut-through route from East Happy Valley
Road to Pinnacle Peak Road. In addition, vegetation clearing along this corridor has made natural
washes appear—and function—like roadways.
In November of last year, I rfiet onsite with members of the Scottsdale planning team and the developer
to address the openness created off of 92nd Street into Solitude. Vehicles—including construction
crews, subcontractors, and delivery drivers—continue to enterthe community by bypassing the gated
entrance. In one instance, a mapping platform incorrectly identified a wash as a road, which then began
to be used as an access point into the community.
The HOA and some residents of 91 st Street have increased their planting of vegetation to restore privacy
and discourage access. These efforts have been funded privately by homeowners, through the
association, and in some cases with support from the developer.
With the proposed Shea Homes development, we anticipate increased use of this route by residents
seeking to avoid unsignalized turns onto Pima Road.
We request:
Prohibition of through traffic on 92nd Street, or
Construction of a perimeter wall east of Solitude
Signalized access from the Shea development to reduce cut-through traffic
3. Pump Station
It is our understanding that the existing pump station in Solitude may have resulted from prior drainage
decisions in which water vyas redirected around this undeveloped parcel rather than continuing west.
With the proposed development, we ask that the City reevaluate whether this configuration remains
necessary, as there rhay be an opportunity to eliminate the pump station, simplify drainage, and reduce
ongoing maintenance costs.
4. Separation Between Communities
2
To maintain privacy and security, we request a physical wall between the Solitude and Shea
communities, along with appropriate landscaping.
We are also seeking to avoid a duplication of the experience we have had on the east side of Solitude,
where the absence of a perimeter wall and cleared vegetation has led to unintended access and reduced
privacy. Establishing a defined boundary between the communities will help prevent similar issues.
We appreciate your assistance in directing these concerns to the appropriate City experts for review. Our
goal is to ensure that any approved development supports both existing and future residents in a safe
and sustainable way.
Thank you for your time and consideration.
Kindest regards,
Adam Warner
President
Solitude Property Owners Association
3
Barnes, Jeff
From: Adam Warner <adamwarner@gmail.com>
Sent Wednesday, September 23, 2026 4:04 PM
To: Barnes, Jeff
Cc: Richard Marzan; Seth Greisinger; Robin Desonie
Subject: Shea community - Case ZN-0003-2026
A External Email: Please use caution if opening links or attachments!
Dear Jeff,
In March of this year, I sent you an email indicating some concerns that our Board and residents at Solitude had about
the Shea project proposed for the property at the corner of Pima and Happy Valley. You and your team then graciously
met with us to discuss those concerns.
I am pleased to tell you that subsequent to that meeting, the Shea team has worked with Solitude to develop solutions
for our concerns regarding traffic on East Happy Valley Road and 92nd Street and the potential to decommission the lift
station in Solitude. In an exceptional show of cooperation. Shea has agreed to pay for the significant road work changes
on Happy Valley that will alleviate the safety concerns. That solution appears to have the support of the City traffic team.
In addition. Shea has agreed to provide the access needed to decommission the lift station in Solitude and to provide
the necessary design aesthetics between the two communities. Our conversations have been moving in a very positive
direction.
Shea has been transparent and solutions oriented and we appreciate their partnership We hope this plan which now
includes the proposed traffic solution, the necessary access for the lift station decommissioning, and the respectful
aesthetics between the two communities gets final approval and is put into motion.
Thanks for your support.
Adam Warner
President
Solitude Property Owners Association
630-659-5555
1
Barnes, Jeff
From: Howard Myers <howard.myers@cox.net>
Sent: Tuesday, August 25, 2026 5:26 PM
To: Barnes, Jeff
Subject: ZN-0003-2026
I': External Efnailf Pl^aSe use cautioivif opening Ijriks or attachmerits! i
Jeff
I am writing you in regard to the Shea Homes proposed plan for about 95 acres along Pima Road, case
ZN-0003-2026. First, to rezone to R1 -35 should require a major General Plan amendment. While the
overall density maybe about 1 home/acre, the lot sizes are no where near an acre. Second, this proposal
is way too dense for that area and increases the number of houses by 4 to 5 times what is allowed now.
What is the benefit to the city? None. They aren’t allowing normal water flow and that area has a lot as it
is down hill from the mountains. Historic water flows in that area will prove that and also the fact that the
city built a water collection culvert next to Pima Road to collect the water flows off that property. There is
NO space between lots for water flow and many of the lots are really narrow not providing any place for
water flow around houses and walls. They are proposing large houses on small lots, a very bad mix in this
area. Look at the previous washes to see the impact this development will have on water flow and the
problems it will create up stream. This area was zoned R1-190 to allow large homes while maintaining
acceptable water flows. Bottom line is that this development provides ho benefits to the city but a lot of
negative impacts including water flows, traffic, views, etc. The city doesn’t have to grant every
overzealous request it gets, if there is no clear benefit above negative impacts it creates, is should not go
fonwafd. They could get more house than R1-190 would allow but a R1-130 zoning would be more
corhpatible to the area and allow site planning that goes with the land and maintains water flows.
Thanks for your consideration of these points when reviewing this application. Please include this note in
the public record for this case.
Howard
Howard Myers
Home:
Addr: 6631 E. Horned Owl Trail
Scottsdale, AZ 85266-8511
Phone: 480-473-0109 (home)
480-262-3502 (Cell)
E-mail: howard.myers@cox.net
If you have any other e-mail or phone numbers for me, please use the Home information
above instead.
None of the previous work e-mail or work phone numbers are valid anymore
1
Mayor and City Council Members
City of Scottsdale
3939 N. Drinkwater Blvd.
Scottsdale, Arizona 85251
Dear Mayor and Council Members:
As the representative for the ownership of the La Mirada retail center, I am pleased to
express my strong support for Shea Homes' proposal for the long-vacant parcel on the
southeast corner of Pima Road and Happy Valley.
Having followed the history of this property and its unique development challenges, I
recognize the importance of finding the right solution for this site. Shea Homes has
presented a thoughtful and well-designed plan that is highly compatible with the
surrounding neighborhood while also providing meaningful benefits to the nearby retail
and commercial businesses.
i respectfully urge you to support this proposal. It represents an excellent opportunity to
transform a long-underutilized property into a vibrant neighborhood that will enhance the
Scottsdale community and contribute positively to the area for years to come.
Sincerely,
vic€.-fe.e«,ip£>JT
From: WebServices
Sent: Wednesday, October 28,2026 3:26 PM
To: Planning Commission
Subject: Planning Commission Public Comment
Importance: High
Name: Ryan Orth
Address:
Email: rsorth@comcast.net
Phone:
Comment:
Mayor and members of the Council, thank you for the opportunity to comment about
ZN-0003-2026. I’m not opposed to developing this property. My concern is whether 77
homes, with lots as small as 26,250 square feet, are appropriate for this
environmentally sensitive location. There are two main issues: open space and traffic.
First, the NAOS figures, used to establish the project’s principle benefit, need to be
reconciled. The report says 21.94 acres are required and 23.89 acres are provided—
about 9 percent above the requirement. The applicant claims approximately 30
percent more by using a lower requirement after applying a drainage credit. The
Council and the public deserve one clear calculation showing the requirement, all
credits, and any overlap among NAOS, drainage easements, and the scenic corridor.
Also, 14.41 acres—about 60 percent of the project’s NAOS—^would be located on
private residential lots. Overtime, these areas may face pressure from pools, walls,
grading, landscaping, and expanded backyards. If they count as permanent open
space, they need clear boundaries, homeowner disclosures, and meaningful
enforcement. We should also know how much of the NAOS will remain undisturbed
native desert and how much will be revegetated or used for drainage. Those areas do
not necessarily provide the same environmental value. Traffic is the other major
concern. The development is expected to generate 887 weekday trips—714 more daily
trips than development allowed under the current zoning. This matters because the
City recently made a major investment in widening Pima Road and building the
regional drainage facility. The proposal says access points were planned during those
improvements. But what level of development did the City assume—19 homes, the
proposed 77, the 98 potentially allowed under R1-35, or something else? The added
lane may keep through-traffic moving, but it does not necessarily make entering Pima
Road easier. The applicant’s own study projects Level of Service F for residents
turning left from the southern driveway during both morning and evening peak hours.
That could cause long delays, risky gap-taking, U-turns, or traffic shifting to Happy
Valley Road and nearby routes. It is encouraging that Shea and the Solitude
community have discussed improvements to Happy Valley Road. But the final design,
funding, schedule, and construction requirements need to be binding conditions of
approval. Taken together, these concerns suggest that this plan is trying to place too
many homes on the property. A reasonable compromise would require lots of at least
one acre-—43,560 square feet. Larger lots would mean fewer trips, more room to
preserve washes and native desert, better separation from protected NAOS, and a
development pattern more consistent with the area’s rural character. I respectfully
ask the Council not to approve the R1-35 proposal as presented. Please direct the
applicant to return with one-acre-or-larger lots, enforceable open-space protections,
and traffic improvements based on the actual design assumptions of the completed
Pima Road project. That would allow development, but in a way that better fits the
land, the roads, and the surrounding community. Thank you.
From: WebServices
Sent: Wednesday, October 28,2026 3:32 PM
To: Planning Commission
Subject: Planning Commission Public Comment
Importance: High
Name: Beth Orth
Address: 8664 E Chama Rd
Email: baorth@yahoo.com
Phone: (408) 203-8213
Comment:
In regards to the build at Pima Rd and Happy Valley in Scottsdale, ZN-0003-2026, I’m
not opposed to developing this property. My concern is whether 77 homes, with lots
as small as 26,250 square feet, are appropriate for this environmentally sensitive
location. There are two main issues: open space and traffic. First, the NAOS figures,
used to establish the project’s principle benefit, need to be reconciled. The report
says 21.94 acres are required and 23.89 acres are provided—about 9 percent above
the requirement. The applicant claims approximately 30 percent more by using a
lower requirement after applying a drainage credit. The Council and the public
deserve one clear calculation showing the requirement, all credits, and any overlap
among NAOS, drainage easements, and the scenic corridor. Also, 14.41 acres—about
60 percent of the project’s NAOS—^would be located on private residential lots. Over
time, these areas may face pressure from pools, walls, grading, landscaping, and
expanded backyards. If they count as permanent open space, they need clear
boundaries, homeowner disclosures, and meaningful enforcement. We should also
know how much of the NAOS will remain undisturbed native desert and how much will
be revegetated or used for drainage. Those areas do not necessarily provide the same
environmental value. Traffic is the other major concern. The development is expected
to generate 887 weekday trips—714 more daily trips than development allowed under
the current zoning. This matters because the City recently made a major investment in
widening Pima Road and building the regional drainage facility. The proposal says
access points were planned during those improvements. But what level of
development did the City assume—19 homes, the proposed 77, the 98 potentially
allowed under R1-35, or something else? The added lane may keep through-traffic
moving, but it does not necessarily make entering Pima Road easier. The applicant’s
own study projects Level of Service F for residents turning left from the southern
driveway during both morning and evening peak hours. That could cause long delays,
risky gap-taking, U-turns, or traffic shifting to Happy Valley Road and nearby routes. It
is encouraging that Shea and the Solitude community have discussed improvements
to Happy Valley Road. But the final design, funding, schedule, and construction
requirements need to be binding conditions of approval. Taken together, these
concerns suggest that this plan is trying to place too many homes on the property. A
reasonable compromise would require lots of at least one acre—43,560 square feet.
Larger lots would mean fewer trips, more room to preserve washes and native desert,
better separation from protected NAOS, and a development pattern more consistent
with the area’s rural character. I respectfully ask the Council not to approve the R1 -35
proposal as presented. Please direct the applicant to return with one-acre-or-larger
lots, enforceable open-space protections, and traffic improvements based on the
actual design assumptions of the completed Pima Road project. That would allow
development, but in a way that better fits the land, the roads, and the surrounding
community. Thank you.
From: WebServices
Sent: Wednesday, October 28, 2026 3:28 PM
To: Planning Commission
Subject: Planning Commission Public Comment
Importance: High
Name: Ryan Orth
Address: 8664 E Chama Rd
Email: rsorth@CQmcast.net
Phone: (650) 279-0913
Comment:
Thank you for considering these comments about ZN-0003-2026. I’m not opposed to
developing this property. My concern is whether 77 homes, with lots as small as
26,250 square feet, are appropriate for this environmentally sensitive location. There
are two main issues: open space and traffic. First, the NAOS figures, used to establish
the project’s principle benefit, need to be reconciled. The report says 21.94 acres are
required and 23.89 acres are provided—about 9 percent above the requirement. The
applicant claims approximately 30 percent more by using a lower requirement after
applying a drainage credit. The Council and the public deserve one clear calculation
showing the requirement, all credits, and any overlap among NAOS, drainage
easements, and the scenic corridor. Also, 14.41 acres—about 60 percent of the
project’s NAOS—^would be located on private residential lots. Over time, these areas
may face pressure from pools, walls, grading, landscaping, and expanded backyards.
If they count as permanent open space, they need clear boundaries, homeowner
disclosures, and meaningful enforcement. We should also know how much of the
NAOS will remain undisturbed native desert and how much will be revegetated or
used for drainage. Those areas do not necessarily provide the same environmental
value. Traffic is the other major concern. The development is expected to generate
887 weekday trips—714 more daily trips than development allowed under the current
zoning. This matters because the City recently made a major investment in widening
Pima Road and building the regional drainage facility. The proposal says access points
were planned during those improvements. But what level of development did the City
assume—19 homes, the proposed 77, the 98 potentially allowed under R1-35, or
something else? The added lane may keep through-traffic moving, but it does not
necessarily make entering Pima Road easier. The applicant’s own study projects Level
of Service F for residents turning left from the southern driveway during both morning
and evening peak hours. That could cause long delays, risky gap-taking, U-turns, or
traffic shifting to Happy Valley Road and nearby routes. It is encouraging that Shea
and the Solitude community have discussed improvements to Happy Valley Road. But
the final design, funding, schedule, and construction requirements need to be binding
conditions of approval. Taken together, these concerns suggest that this plan is trying
to place too many homes on the property. A reasonable compromise would require
lots of at least one acre—43,560 square feet. Larger lots would mean fewer trips, more
room to preserve washes and native desert, better separation from protected NAOS,
and a development pattern more consistent with the area’s rural character, i
respectfully ask the Council not to approve the R1-35 proposal as presented. Please
direct the applicant to return with one-acre-or-larger lots, enforceable open-space
protections, and traffic improvements based on the actual design assumptions of the
completed Pima Road project. That would allow development, but in a way that better
fits the land, the roads, and the surrounding community. Thank you.
From: WebServices
Sent: Wednesday, October 28, 2026 3:45 PM
To: Planning Commission
Subject: Planning Commission Public Comment
Importance: High
Name: Dan Fitas
Address: 8655 E Chama Rd
Email: danstincLipp@gmail.conn
Phone: (602)999-7271
Comment:
Scottsdale City Planning Commission Members. 10.28.26 Please consider the
following when reviewing the proposed re-zoning of this parcel as requested by Shea
Homes. This site map looks much the same as the map presented to the neighboring
communities and viewed at Highlands Church earlier this year. At that time many of
my neighbors voiced our objections to the proposed development, as presented.
These are some issues we’ve discussed and considered. • The request to rezone is to
R1-35 ESL (.08 density), (26k sf lots plus 23 acres of NAOS. The lots are side by side
and there appears to be very little NAOS designated between the property lines, it
appears all the NAOS is on the periphery of the project - so these homes are side by
side with a requirement of only 24 ft. between homes based on proposed setbacks. •
The current zoning is R1-190 (4.35 acre lots). • Options to consider that would more
closely resemble existing developments would R1-230 (2.98 acre lots). R1-43 (1 acre
lots). The Bronco development north of Pinnacle Presbyterian Church is zoned R1-43
ESL. (Environmental Sensitive Land), i think this ties into NAOS. Required open space.
The Wildhorse development on Pima rd. is zoned R1-35 ESL. That surprised me,
although it sits on a much larger parcel and seems more consistent with the
surrounding neighborhoods. And the lots in Wildhorse are situated in a more
aesthetically pleasing arrangement. My guess is it also has more NAOS designated in
the parcel. None of the neighborhoods along Happy Valley Road—north, south, or
adjacent to it—or west of Pima Road resemble the proposed project’s side-by-side,
cookie-cutter lots. Comparable lot configurations do not appear until west of Miller
Road, and even many of those neighborhoods more closely resemble Alta Sonora and
nearby developments. The proposed project does not conform to the surrounding
area developments. Traffic and Access Considerations Several additional factors
warrant consideration. When Pima Road was redeveloped, did the City of Scottsdale
design access to this parcel based on its current zoning of 4.35-acre lots? if so, the
proposed project would likely accommodate less than 20 home sites. Access for this
number of homes would be more reasonable, however there is still no availability for
exiting south from the proposed development. Access Roads and Traffic Concerns
Northbound traffic: The access roads over the culvert on the east side of Pima Road
lack deceleration lanes. Vehicles turning into the development would significantly
delay northbound traffic. Southbound access: If the project includes 77 new homes,
how would vehicles exiting the development travel southbound? Neither existing
culvert crossing aligns with roads on the west side of Pima Road; both crossings are
south of De La O and Chama Roads. Southbound Access and a Potential Traffic Signal
Will the City of Scottsdale require or recommend a new traffic signal to allow vehicles
leaving the proposed development to turn southbound onto Pima Road? If so, the
existing culvert crossing would need to be relocated opposite De La O Road. An
additional traffic signal on Pima Road between Pinnacle Peak and Happy Valley Roads
would cause an unacceptable level of congestion. Misrepresentations Comparisons
with Other Shea Homes Developments The proposal compares the Pima Road project
with two Shea Homes developments in North Scottsdale, but neither appears directly
comparable: • Signature at Black Mountain: This development has approximately 15
home sites along a narrow corridor. Its lot sizes do not appear comparable to those
proposed for Pima Road. • Storyrock: This development spans 450 acres—about 4.5
times the size of the proposed Pima Road site—and does not appear to include lots as
small as the proposed 26,250-square-foot lots. At approximately 0.6 acre, the
proposed lots would also be smaller than any in Alta Sonora. Side-Yard Setbacks The
proposal calls for 12-foot side-yard setbacks, which could place neighboring homes
only 24 feet apart. These setbacks appear smaller than those required under R1 -35
zoning, suggesting that Shea Homes is requesting a reduction below the R1-35
standard. These comments reiterate concerns raised at the community input meeting
Shea Homes held earlier this year. The developer appears not to have addressed
them. Please consider these preliminary objections; additional objections will follow.
Thank You, Dan Pitas 602-999-7271
From: WebServices
Sent: Wednesday, October 28, 2026 3:46 PM
To: Planning Commission
Subject: Planning Commission Public Comment
Importance: High
Name: Mitch Roth
Address: 8644 E Chama Rd.
Email: mitchmuse2@gnnail.com
Phone: (480) 629-8071
Comment:
As the President of the Alta Sonora community, which sits directly across the street
from the proposed high-density Shea home development, we oppose providing Shea
Homes a zoning change that would allow them to build 77 homes on small lots. This
area does not have anything of this high density and it would set in motion a bad
prescedent if this is approved. There is ENOUGH expensive housing already in this
area. Thank you. Mitch Roth
Mayor and City Council Members
City of Scottsdale
3939 N. Drinkwater Blvd.
Scottsdale, Arizona 8S2SI
Dear Mayor and Council Members;
I am a current resident in Desert Highlands and have had a long career in the development
business. I strongly support Shea Homes' proposal for the long vacant parcel on the southeast
comer of Pima Road and Happy Valley.
I am aware of this site's unique history and its development challenges. Understanding these
factors, 1 am very impressed with Shea's plan to provide housing that is compatible with the
surrounding neighborhood and respectful of the site's neighbors.
I urge you to support this proposal which provides a great solution to this unique site in
Scottsdale. This new neighborhood will be a welcome addition to our community.
Sincerely,
Buddy Satterfield
Mayor and City Council Members
City of Scottsdale
3939 N. Drinkwater Blvd.
Scottsdale, Arizona 85251
Dear Mayor and Council Members:
I am writing today to show my support for the proposed luxury residential project located on
the southeast corner of Pima Road and Happy Valley Road by Shea Hohnes. I live in the area
and believe the creation of this upscale community with large setbacks from Pima Road is
appropriate for the area and will have a positive impact on the neighborhood. This is exactly
the kind of residential project that we should be supporting in this area of Scottsdale.
Please vote yes for this wonderful request.
Sincerely,
Mt) c/
Mayor and City Council Members
City of Scottsdale
3939 N. Drinkwater Blvd.
Scottsdale, Arizona 85251
Dear Mayor and Council Members:
I am writing today to show my support for the proposed luxury residential project located on
the southeast corner of Pima Road and Happy Valley Road by Shea Homes. I live in the area
and believe the creation of this upscale community with large setbacks from Pima Road is
appropriate for the area and will have a positive impact on the neighborhood. This is exactly
the kind of residential project that we should be supporting in this area of Scottsdale.
Please vote yes for this wonderful request.
Sincerely,
Mayor and City Council Members
City of Scottsdale
3939 N. Drinkwater Blvd.
Scottsdale, Arizona 85251
Dear Mayor and Council Members:
I am writing today to show my support for the proposed luxury residential project located on
the southeast corner of Pima Road and Happy Valley Road by Shea Homes. I live in the area
and believe the creation of this upscale community with large setbacks from Pima Road is
appropriate for the area and will have a positive impact on the neighborhood. This is exactly
the kind of residential project that we should be supporting in this area of Scottsdale.
Please vote yes for this wonderful request.
Sincerely,
Vv.-:s» V rr .
iAL&l A.
5
Mayor and City Council Members
City of Scottsdale
3939 N. Drinkwater Blvd.
Scottsdale, Arizona 85251
Dear Mayor and Council Members:
I am writing today to show my support for the proposed luxury residential project
located on the southeast corner of Pima Road and Happy Valley Road by Shea Homes.
I live in the area and believe the creation of this upscale community with large
setbacks from Pima Road is appropriate for the area and will have a positive impact
on the neighborhood. This is exactly the kind of residential project that we should be
supporting in this area of Scottsdale.
Please vote yes for this wonderhil request.
Sincerely,
AV7J?r A) :<;i
Mayor and City Council Members
City of Scottsdale
3939 N. Drinkwater Blvd.
Scottsdale, Arizona 85251
Dear Mayor and Council Members:
I am writing today to show my support for the proposed luxury residential project located on
the southeast corner of Pima Road and Happy Valley Road by Shea Homes. I live in the area
and believe the creation of this upscale community with large setbacks from Pima Road is
appropriate for the area and will have a positive impact on the neighborhood. This is exactly
the kind of residential project that we should be supporting in this area of Scottsdale.
Please vote yes for this wonderful request.
Sincerely,
/
I" A4/0 U(/'Nyct&\
Mayor and City Council Members
City of Scottsdale
3939 N. Drinkwater Blvd.
Scottsdale, Arizona 85251
Dear Mayor and Council Members:
I am writing today to show my support for the proposed luxury residential project
located on the southeast comer of Pima Road and Happy Valley Road by Shea Homes.
I live in the area and believe the creation of this upscale community with large
setbacks from Pima Road is appropriate for the area and will have a positive impact
on the neighborhood. This is exactly the kind of residential project that we should be
supporting in this area of Scottsdale.
Please vote yes for this wonderful request.
Sincerely,
j6c:>tkscUL-c- A?—
Mayor and City Council Members
City of Scottsdale
3939 N. Drinkwater Blvd.
Scottsdale, Arizona 85251
Dear Mayor and Council Members:
I am writing today to show my support for the proposed luxury residential project located on
the southeast corner of Pima Road and Happy Valley Road by Shea Homes. I live in the area
and believQ the creation of this upscale community with large setbacks from Pima Road is
appropriate for the area and will have a positive impact on the neighborhood. This is exactly
the kind of residential project that we should be supporting in this area of Scottsdale.
Please vote yes for this wonderful request.
Sincerely,
%
A (/) A
Zj/eTr? /
& . 4 7^ h
Mayor and City Council Members
City of Scottsdale
3939 N. Drinkwater Blvd.
Scottsdale, Arizona 85251
Dear Mayor and Council Members:
I am writing today to show my support for the proposed luxury residential project located on
the southeast corner of Pima Road and Happy Valley Road by Shea Homes. I live in the area
and believe the creation of this upscale community with large setbacks from Pima Road is
appropriate for the area and will have a positive impact on the neighborhood. This is exactly
the kind of residential project that we should be supporting in this area of Scottsdale.
Please vote yes for this wonderful request.
Sincerely, ,
Az.-s^s-:i. STS"
Mayor and City Council Members
City of Scottsdale
3939 N. Drinkwater Blvd.
Scottsdale, Arizona 85251
Dear Mayor and Council Members:
I am writing today to show my support for the proposed luxury residential project located on
the southeast corner of Pima Road and Happy Valley Road by Shea Homes. I live in the area
and believe the creation of this upscale community with large setbacks from Pima Road is
appropriate for the area and will have a positive impact on the neighborhood. This is exactly
the kind of residential project that we should be supporting in this area of Scottsdale.
Please vote yes for this wonderful request.
Sincerely,
Ol^dA/
mio. /y ,
1
Mayor and City Council Members
City of Scottsdale
3939 N. Drinkwater Blvd.
Scottsdale, Arizona 85251
Dear Mayor and Council Members:
I am writing today to show my support for the proposed luxury residential project located on
the southeast corner of Pima Road and Happy Valley Road by Shea Homes. I live in the area
and believe the creation of this upscale community with large setbacks from Pima Road is
appropriate for the area and will have a positive impact on the neighborhood. This is exactly
the kind of residential project that we should be supporting in this area of Scottsdale.
Please vote yes for this wonderful request.
Sincerely,
I
^
A
Mayor and City Council Mennbers
City of Scottsdale
3939 N. Drinkwater Blvd.
Scottsdale, Arizona 85251
Dear Mayor and Council Members:
I am writing today to show my support for the proposed luxury residential project located on
the southeast corner of Pima Road and Happy Valley Road by Shea Hornes. I live in the area
and believe the creation of this upscale community with large setbacks from Pima Road is
appropriate for the area and will have a positive impact on the neighborhood. This is exactly
the kind of residential project that we should be supporting in this area of Scottsdale.
Please vote yes for this wonderful request.
Sincerely,
^lo -t? fn,
Mayor and City Council Members
City of Scottsdale
3939 N. Drinkwater Blvd.
Scottsdale, Arizona 85251
Dear Mayor and Council Members:
I am writing today to show my support for the proposed luxury residential project located on
the southeast corner of Pima Road and Happy Valley Road by Shea Homes. 1 live in the area
and believe the creation of this upscale community with large setbacks from Pima Road is
appropriate for the area and will have a positive impact on the neighborhood. This is exactly
the kind of residential project that we should be supporting in this area of Scottsdale.
Please vote yes for this wonderful request.
Sincerely,
2
REQUEST TO SPEAK
i-
Request to Speak cards must be submitted to City Staff BEFORE public testimony begins.
Public testimony is limited to three (3) minutes per speaker.
Additional time MAY be granted to speakers representing two or more persons.
Cards for designated speakers and the person(s) they represent must be submitted together.
NAME {prim) MEETING DATE to'
NAME OF GROUP/ORGANIZATION {ifapplicable) PdJfPt OdA J
ADDRESS ^ j ^(jD itThfltM.__________
ZIP.
HOME PHONE f 5________
WORK PHONE.
E-MAIL ADDRESS (optionalf
1^1 WISH TO SPEAK ON AGENDA ITEM# ^ □ I WISH TO DONATE MY TIME TO
□ I WISH TO SPEAK DURING “PUBLIC COMMENT"* CONCERNING ______________
^Citizens may complete one Request to Speak “Public Comment” card per meeting and submit it to City Staff. “Public Comment” time is
reserved for citizen comments regarding non-agendized items. The Board and Commission may hear “Public Comment” testimony, but is
prohibited by state law from discussing items which are not listed on the agenda.
This card constitutes a public record under Arizona law.
REQUEST fS SPEAK
Request to Speak cards must be submitted to City Staff BEFORE pubiic testimony begins.
]VJ Pubiic testimony is iimited to three (3) minutes per speaker.
Additionai time MAY be granted to speakers representing two or more persons.
Cards for designated speakers and the person(s) they represent must be submitted together.
NAME {print) ^^ ^ to 7Jh
MEETING DATE
NAME OF GROUP/ORGANIZATION {if applicable) PflJTPf OHA J
ADDRESS £ CU:A^AfAr
ZIP
HOME PHONE WORK PHONE_
E-MAIL ADDRESS (optionalf
^ 1 WISH TO SPEAK ON AGENDA ITEM # ^ □ I WISH TO DONATE MY TIME TO
□ I WISH TO SPEAK DURING “PUBLIC COMMENT”* CONCERNING ______________
Citizens may complete one Request to Speak “Public Comment” card per meeting and submit it to City Staff. “Public Comment” time is
reserved for citizen comments regarding non-agendized items. The Board and Commission may hear “Public Comment” testimony, but is
prohibited by state law from discussing items which are not listed on the agenda.
This card constitutes a public record under Arizona law.
REQUEST TO SPEAK
1
Request to Speak cards must be submitted to City Staff BEFORE pubiic testimony begins.
Public testimony is limited to three (3) minutes per speaker.
Additional time MAY be granted to speakers representing two or more persons.
Cards for designated speakers and the person(s) they represent must be submitted together.
NAME (print) ______ (V0AW\ ______________ MEETING DATE
NAME OF GROUP/ORGANIZATION (if applicable)
ADDRESS______hi”
ZIP.
0,50'-5555
HOME PHONE. . WORK PHONE.
E-MAIL ADDRESS (optional)__________________________________________________
I WISH TO SPEAK ON AGENDA ITEM # ^ □ I WISH TO DONATE MY TIME TO
□ I WISH TO SPEAK DURING “PUBLIC COMMENT”* CONCERNING
* Citizens may complete one Request to Speak “Public Comment" card per meeting and submit it to City Staff. “Public Comment” time is
reserved for citizen comments regarding non-agendized items. The Board and Commission may hear “Public Comment" testimony, but is
prohibited by state law from discussing items which are not listed on the agenda.
This card constitutes a pubiic record under Arizona iaw.
REQUEST TO SPEAK
I
Request to Speak cards must be submitted to City Staff BEFORE pubiic testimony begins.
Pubiic testimony is iimited to three (3) minutes per speaker.
e Additional time MAY be granted to speakers representing two or more persons.
Cards for designated speakers and the person(s) they represent must be submitted together.
NAME (print) V/V/ MEETING DATE
NAME OF GROUP/ORGANIZATION (if applicable)_______
ADDRESS ^ WirvdsDT Av€. 0^ZS-7
ZIP.
HOME PHONE. WORK PHONE.
E-MAIL ADDRESS (optional)_________
IzflWISH TO SPEAK ON AGENDA ITEM # □ 1 WISH TO DONATE MY TIME TO
□ I WISH TO SPEAK DURING “PUBLIC COMMENT”* CONCERNING _______________
Citizens may complete one Request to Speak “Public Comment” card per meeting and submit it to City Staff'. “Public Comment” time is
reservedfor citizen comments regarding non-agendized items. The Board and Commission may hear “Public Comment” testimony, but is
prohibited by state law from discussing items which are not listed on the agenda.
This card constitutes a public record under Arizona law.
REQUEST TO SPEM
y
Request to Speak cards must be submitted to City Staff BEFORE public testimony begins.
Public testimony is limited to three (3) minutes per speaker.
Additional time MAY be granted to speakers representing two or more persons.
Cards for designated speakers and the person(s) they represent must be submitted together.
NAME (print) MEETING DATE
NAME OF GROUP/ORGANIZATION (if applicable)
ADDRESS. ZIP.
HOME PHONE. WORK PHONE.
E-MAIL ADDRESS (optional)_____________
3>
01 WISH TO SPEAK ON AGENDA ITEM #, □ I WISH TO DONATE MY TIME TO
□ I WISH TO SPEAK DURING “PUBLIC COMMENT”* CONCERNING
* Citizens may complete one Request to Speak “Public Comment" card per meeting and submit it to City Staff. “Public Comment" time is
reservedfor citizen comments regarding non-agendized items. The Board and Commission may hear “Public Comment" testimony, but is
prohibited by state law from discussing items which are not listed on the agenda.
This card constitutes a public record under Arizona law.
r"
REQUEST TO SPEAK
r
Request to Speak cards must be submitted to City Staff BEFORE pubiic testimony begins.
Public testimony is limited to three (3) minutes per speaker.
Additional time MAY be granted to speakers representing two or more persons.
Cards for designated speakers and the person(s) they represent must be submitted together.
NAME (print) AW^vA MEETING DATE 1Q/2€)
NAME OF GROUP/ORGANIZATION (if applicable)
ADDRESS ^ L<^
ZIP.
HOME PHONE WORK PHONE
E-MAIL ADDRESS (optional)_________________
[^WISH TO SPEAK ON AGENDA ITEM # ^
I WISH TO DONATE MY TIME TO
□ 1 WISH TO SPEAK DURING “PUBLIC COMMENT”* CONCERNING
*Citizens may complete one Request to Speak “Public Comment" card per meeting and submit it to City Staff. “Public Comment” time is
reservedfor citizen comments regarding non-agendized items. The Board and Commission may hear “Public Comment” testimony, but is
prohibited by state law from discussing items which are not listed on the agenda.
This card constitutes a public record under Arizona law.
REQUEST TO SPEAK
mm
Request to Speak cards must be submitted to City Staff BEFORE pubiic testimony begins.
Pubiic testimony is iimited to three (3) minutes per speaker.
Additional time MAY be granted to speakers representing two or more persons.
Cards for designated speakers and the person(s) they represent must be submitted together.
NAME (print) MEETING DATE
NAME OF GROUP/ORGANIZATION (if applicable)
2l4?3C> U. 03^
ADDRESS. ZIP
HOME PHONE. WORK PHONE.
E-MAIL ADDRESS (optionalf
3
I WISH TO SPEAK ON AGENDA ITEM # □ I WISH TO DONATE MY TIME TO
□ I WISH TO SPEAK DURING “PUBLIC COMMENT”* CONCERNING
Citizens may complete one Request to Speak “Public Comment" card per meeting and submit it to City Staff. “Public Comment” time is
reservedfor citizen comments regarding non-agendized items. The Board and Commission may hear “Public Comment” testimony, but is
prohibited by state law from discussing items which are not listed on the agenda
This card constitutes a public record under Arizona law.
From: Seth G <sgreisinger@gmail.com>
Sent: Friday, November 6, 2026 5:40 PM
To: City Council <CitvCouncil(5)scottsdaleaz.gov>
Subject: Shea Homes Proposal (case number ZN-0003-2026)
^External Email: Please use caution if opening links or attachments!
Hi.
As a resident of the Solitude neighborhood, I would like to express my support for the Shea
Homes proposal (Case No. ZN-0003-2026). The proposal incorporates significant traffic
improvements that will benefit the surrounding neighborhoods. Additionally, Shea Homes
has demonstrated a willingness to work collaboratively with our community, making
several meaningful revisions to the project's architectural design and aesthetics in
response to neighborhood feedback and concerns.
Seth Greisinger
Solitude POA (Treasurer)
City Notifications - Mailing List Selection Map
Shea Homes - SEC of Pima Road & Happy Valley Road
^>11.
;-;v I
#.:
i . 'c'* I
US
Rw.
;■ >
/
r .l'■■.,; ■ . I /«■ Mi
m0- irSM:
^•■ishriiir
Labels Pulled Map Legend:
October 7, 2026
Additional Notifications: Site Boundary
Interested Parties List
Adjacent HOA’s
P&Z E-Newsletter Properties within 1250-feet
Facebook
ii^
Nextdoor.com
City Website-Projects in the hearing process ZN-0003-2026
Postcards: 247
Attachment #10
m
■f
X %
SCOTTSDALE PLANNING COMMISSION
KIVA-CITY HALL
3939 DRINKWATER BOULEVARD
SCOTTSDALE. ARIZONA
WEDNESDAY, OCTOBER 28, 2026
•DRAFT SUMMARIZED MEETING MINUTES *
PRESENT: Joe Young, Chair
William Scarbrough, Vice Chair
George Ertel, Commissioner
Michal Ann Joyner, Commissioner
Doug Drake, Commissioner
Barney Gonzales, Commissioner
David Reid, Commissioner
ABSENT: None
STAFF: Tim Curtis
Joe Padilla
Becca Cox
Jeff Barnes
Chris Zimmer
Jack Kelly
Jason McWilliams
CALL TO ORDER
Chair Young called the regular session of the Scottsdale Planning Commission to order at 5:01 p.m.
ROLL CALL
A formal roll call was conducted confirming members present as stated above.
MINUTES REVIEW AND APPROVAL
1. Approval of the September 23, 2026 Regular Meeting Minutes.
Commissioner Joyner made a motion to approve the September 23, 2026 Regular Meeting
Minutes. Second by Commissioner Drake, the motion passed unanimously by a vote of six
(6) to zero (0).
CeNSENTAGEHM
* Note: These are summary action minutes only. A complete copy of the meeting audio is available on the
Planning Commission page on ScottsdaleAZ.gov, search "Planning Commission”
Attachment #11
Planning Commission
Regular Meeting Minutes
October 28. 2026
Page 2 of 2
2. 11-ZN-1986#2 (Mack Industrial Rezonet
Request by owner for a zoning district map amendment to amend development standards
regarding the required landscape setback adjacent to streets, on a +/-95-acre portion of a
+/-124-acre site located at 17771 and 17855 N. Pima Road (APN NO. 215-07-470, 215-
07-471,215-07-472, and 215-07-022P), with Industrial Park, Environmentally Sensitive
Lands (Hillside) Planned Community District (1-1 ESL (HD) PCD) to Industrial Park,
Environmentally Sensitive Lands (Hillside) Planned Community District (1-1 ESL (HD)
PCD) zoning. Staff contact person is Chris Zimmer, 480-312-2347. Applicant contact
person is George Pasquel III, 602-230-0600.
Item No. 2; Moved to Regular Agenda. Commissioner Joyner made a motion for
recommendation of approval to City Council for case 11-ZN-1986#2 after finding that the
PCD criteria have been met and that the proposed Zoning District Map Amendment and
Development Plan are consistent and conform with the adopted General Plan, per the
attached stipulations. Second by Commissioner McCurdy, the motion passed unanimously
by a vote of six (6) to zero (0).
Reguiar Agenda
3. ZN-0003-2026 (Happy Vallevi
Request by owners for a Zoning District Map Amendment from Single-family Residential
Environmentally Sensitive Lands (R1-190 ESL) zoning to Single-family Residential
Environmentally Sensitive Lands (R1-35 ESL) zoning, with Amended Development Standards for a
77-lot subdivision on a +/- 94.8-gross-acre site located at the southeast corner of E. Happy Valley
Road and N. Pima Road. Staff contact person is Jeff Barnes, 480-312-2376. Applicant contact
person is John Berry, 480-385-2753.
Item No. 3; Commissioner Joyner made a motion for recommendation of approval to City
Council for case ZN-0003-2026 after finding that the proposed Zoning District Map
Amendment is consistent and conforms with the adopted General Plan, per the attached
stipulations and an additional stipulation to include the ingress and egress improvements
provided in the presentation by the applicant. Second by Commissioner Gonzales, the
motion passed unanimously by a vote of seven (7) to zero (0).
4. Planning Commission Election of Officers
Item No. 4; Commissioner Reid made a motion for Commissioner Joyner as Chair. The motion
passed unanimousiy by a vote of seven (7) to zero (0).
Commissioner Craig made a motion for Commissioner Brand as Vice Chair. The motion passed
unanimousiy by a vote of seven (7) to zero (0).
ADJOURNMENT
With no further business to discuss, the regular session of the Planning Commission
adjourned at 6:27 p.m.
* Note: These are summary action minutes only. A complete copy of the meeting audio is available on the
Planning Commission page on ScottsdaleAZ.gov, search “Planning Commission”