10.7.2026 PSJ Subcommittee Minutes
City of Phoenix — Public Safety and Justice Subcommittee (2026-11-23)
Extracted text (via pymupdf_layout)
9140 characters
Phoenix City Council Public Safety and Justice (PSJ) Subcommittee Summary Minutes Wednesday, October 7, 2026 City Council Chambers 200 W. Jefferson St. Phoenix, Ariz. Subcommittee Members Present Subcommittee Members Absent Councilwoman Ann O’Brien, Chair Councilwoman Laura Pastor Councilman Kevin Robinson Councilman Jim Waring CALL TO ORDER Chairwoman O’Brien called the Public Safety and Justice Subcommittee (PSJ) to order at 10:00 a.m. with three members present. Councilwoman Pastor arrived at 10:02 a.m. CALL TO THE PUBLIC None. MINUTES OF MEETINGS 1. Minutes of the Public Safety and Justice Subcommittee Meeting Councilman Robinson motioned to approve the minutes of the September 2, 2026 Public Safety and Justice Subcommittee meeting. Councilwoman Pastor seconded the motion which passed unanimously, 4-0. CONSENT ACTION (ITEM 2) Item 2 was for consent action. No presentations were planned, but staff were available to answer questions. 2. 2027 Neighborhood Block Watch Grant Program (NBWGP) Application Guide and Process Councilman Robinson made a motion to approve Item 2. Councilwoman Pastor seconded the motion which passed unanimously, 4-0. INFORMATION AND DISCUSSION (ITEMS 3-4) 3. Community Assistance Program (CAP) Expansion Implementation Update Program Manager Dolores Ernst and Police Administrator Alexandra Edwards presented this item. Ms. Ernst explained the purpose of the Community Assistance Program (CAP) and provided an overview of the presentation. Ms. Ernst shared staffing and hiring updates as part of the program expansion plan. Ms. Edwards provided an overview of the determination process involved when a call is received from the Phoenix Police Department (PPD) and delegated to CAP. Ms. Edwards provided an example of a call and explained why a CAP response was more appropriate than a PPD response. Ms. Ernst shared a chart displaying the volume of calls transferred from PPD Communications from 2024 to 2026. Ms. Ernst then shared a chart showing the volume of calls for Behavioral Health Units (BHU), noting their function and staffing. Ms. Ernst explained that both officers and firefighters may also ask for a BHU. Ms. Ernst highlighted a ninety-six percent increase in calls from 2024 to 2025. Ms. Ernst provided an outline of BHU responses for August, detailing the number of single-unit responses, responses with Police, responses with Fire, and responses with both Police and Fire. Ms. Ernst then shared a chart detailing Crisis Response Unit (CRU) response from 2024 to 2026 and explained the team's composition and work. Ms. Ernst provided an additional CRU outline, highlighting the number of single responses, responses with Police, responses with Fire, and responses with Police and Fire. Ms. Ernst noted that single-unit responses may be follow-ups to previous calls. Ms. Ernst explained that their response-time goal is less than twenty-five minutes and displayed a graph of response times for both the BHU and CRU from January to August. Both showed response times under twenty-five minutes. Ms. Ernst cited the call example and the importance of having appropriate and timely responders. Ms. Ernst shared that their data is now available on the City Manager's Performance Dashboard. Ms. Ernst reiterated their goal of recruiting and hiring new team members and provided a QR code to apply. Councilwoman Pastor shared her excitement about the program's progress and its role in the community today, including a personal story about how a similar program helped her family. Chairwoman O'Brien highlighted CAP's importance and thanked everyone who has contributed to its creation and success. 4. Heat Related Calls Update Assistant Fire Chief Mark Gonzales, Assistant Fire Chief Raymond Ochoa, Assistant Fire Chief Justin Alexander, and Deputy Parks and Recreation Director Jarod Rogers presented this item. Assistant Chief Alexander thanked the subcommittee for the opportunity to present, specified the dates of the data to be presented, and introduced the presenters. Assistant Chief Alexander provided an overview of the 2026 heat season, including the date range, mean temperature, number of calls for service during that period, and how many days exceeded 100 and 110 degrees Fahrenheit. Assistant Chief Alexander shared a pie chart detailing heat-related calls received during the heat season and noted an increase from last year. Assistant Chief Ochoa explained that a percentage of heat-related calls were due to heatstroke. He explained that firefighters adopted a new method, cold water immersion, after seeking a more effective way to treat these patients. Assistant Chief Ochoa provided a video on the cold-water immersion process. Assistant Chief Ochoa acknowledged and thanked the City departments and healthcare partners for their collaboration. Assistant Chief Ochoa presented a chart detailing the number of heat calls requiring transport and the number of patients who received cold-water immersion therapy from May to August of 2024 to 2026. Assistant Chief Ochoa explained the effectiveness of cold-water immersion treatment based on collected data. Assistant Chief Ochoa shared examples of successful outcomes and plans to expand this treatment, including across the country. Deputy Director Rogers described the role Parks and Recreation plays in enforcing heat warnings by restricting trail use. Assistant Chief Gonzales presented information on the number of excessive heat warning days in 2026 and shared how many patients needed rescue services from trails on those days. He noted that campaigns and trail closures have reduced the number of patients. Assistant Chief Gonzales explained that although they have seen an increase in mountain rescues per year, they've seen fewer mountain rescues during excessive heat warning days. Assistant Chief Gonzales cited their May presentation and a concerning increase in rescues, but shared they soon stabilized those numbers and returned to their 2025 average. Assistant Chief Gonzales provided a chart showing peak rescue hours and explained that not all rescues occurred on restricted trails. Assistant Chief Gonzales shared a chart detailing the demographics of rescued patients and the percentage of rescues due to injury rather than illness. He noted that Arizonans make up the majority of rescues. Assistant Chief Gonzales shared statistics on how often they used additional resources, specifically drone flights and hoist operations. Assistant Chief Alexander provided an overview of their community messaging on heat safety, which can be found on their specified heat safety page. Councilman Robinson thanked the Fire Department for the presentation and their efforts. He then asked whether the bags are reusable or single-use only. Assistant Chief Gonzales answered that the bags are one-time use. Councilman Robinson thanked Assistant Chief Gonzales for his response and highlighted the importance of the public fully understanding what a rescue requires. Councilwoman Pastor thanked the presenters for saving lives. Chairwoman O'Brien asked for clarity on whether the department tracks data for mountain rescues on other mountains in Phoenix. Assistant Chief Gonzales responded that all mountain rescues are tracked, and their focus is on summer heat, with those mountains being the only restricted ones. Chairwoman O'Brien asked how the number of rescues for the other mountains in the summer compares to the ones presented, adding that if they didn't have them, they could send them to her. Assistant Chief Gonzales answered that they do not have the total with them right now. Chairwoman O'Brien asked that the other mountain rescues during the heat period be provided to ensure data can back conversations with residents in every district. She thanked them for their leadership in cold water immersion and their ability to save and preserve lives. Chairwoman O'Brien introduced virtual speaker Ms. Anne Ender and asked her to begin. Ms. Ender thanked all presenters and staff and shared that she met with Councilman Robinson to discuss the volume of mountain rescues in 2026 and has collected data showing this is not a seasonal issue. Ms. Ender asked for future policy discussion for first responders and their risk of exposure. She provided recommendations for consideration such as hard closure to mountain trails until the helicopter is available for use and recommended using existing enforcement authority and evaluating additional cost recovery options to avoid further risks to first responders. . Chairwoman O'Brien acknowledged the topic's importance and expressed thanks. INFORMATION ONLY (ITEMS 5-6) 5. Police Hiring, Recruitment, and Attrition Update Information only. The item was not discussed. No Councilmember requested additional information. 6. Phoenix Fire Department Staffing and Response Time Update Information only. The item was not discussed. No Councilmember requested additional information. CALL TO THE PUBLIC None. FUTURE AGENDA ITEMS None. ADJOURNMENT Chairwoman O’Brien adjourned the meeting at 10:41 a.m. Respectfully submitted, Caitlin Johnston Management Fellow