Ryan Rapp Underwood and Pacheco agreement

City of El Mirage — Regular Meeting (2020-04-21)

View PDF Item 3 Meeting page

Extracted text (via pymupdf) 13595 characters
3200 N. Central Avenue, Suite 2250 
Phoenix, Arizona 85012 
Telephone (602) 280-1000  
Facsimile (602) 265-1495 
 
David L. Niederdeppe  
dniederdeppe@rrulaw.com 
Cynthia K. Kelley 
ckelley@rrulaw.com  
 
April 7, 2020 
 
Sent via email: kbarber@elmirageaz.gov 
Katrina Barber, Board Secretary 
El Mirage PSPRS Local Boards  
10000 n. El Mirage Road 
El Mirage, AZ 85335 
 
Re: 
Engagement and Retainer Agreement 
 
Dear Board Members: 
 
Thank you for the selection of Ryan Rapp Underwood & Pacheco, P.L.C., to represent the 
El Mirage PSPRS Local Police and Fire Boards (“the Boards”).  We recognize that the Police and 
Fire Boards have a choice of legal counsel, and appreciate the confidence you have in our firm. 
 
 
This letter is to confirm our understanding of the representation that Ryan Rapp 
Underwood & Pacheco has undertaken on the Boards’ behalf, its scope and the terms of our 
engagement.  In addition, under our professional rules of ethics, we have an obligation to inform 
the Boards of the firm’s billing practices.  Experience has shown that a letter such as this is useful 
both to the client and to the firm to express our respective expectations and undertakings. 
 
 
We ask that you and the Boards representatives carefully review this letter.  It is intended 
to be a formal Retainer and Engagement Agreement.  If it meets with the Boards’ approval and 
understanding of our respective responsibilities and duties, please sign where indicated and return 
it to us.  Your signature on this Agreement will confirm the Boards’ consent to the terms contained 
herein. 
 
SCOPE OF REPRESENTATION 
 
We understand that Ryan Rapp Underwood & Pacheco, P.L.C., has been retained to 
represent the Boards and their constituent members in connection with their duties and 
responsibilities under the Arizona Public Safety Personnel Retirement System.  The primary 
attorneys engaged in this representation will be David Niederdeppe and Cynthia Kelley. 
 
The attorneys will, as requested, attend meetings relating to the Boards, review materials

El Mirage PSPRS Local Board  
April 7, 2020 
Page 2 
 
prior to the meetings and, if necessary, monitor compliance with open meeting law for those 
meetings attended.  The attorneys will, upon referral of a lawsuit or other legal matter by the 
Boards, provide any necessary legal representation to the Boards and any of its officers, 
employees, or agents as directed by the Boards.  The attorneys agree to perform all necessary legal 
services, including but not limited to investigation, legal research, preparation of legal memoranda, 
pleadings and briefs and making appearances before administrative tribunals and courts, in 
representing the Boards. 
 
 
The Boards and its representatives, as our client, agree to cooperate with, and to timely 
provide assistance and requested documentation and information to us so that we may handle these 
legal matters on its behalf. 
 
FEES AND COSTS AND RETAINER 
 
All matters undertaken by the firm require that the client agree to terms of payment prior 
to the commencement of representation.  In consideration of our services in connection with this 
representation, the Boards agree to pay Ryan Rapp Underwood & Pacheco according to the terms 
set forth in this Agreement.  Any litigation necessitated by this representation is, by its very nature, 
time consuming, uncertain and often expensive.  While the firm will work diligently on the Boards’ 
behalf, no predictions can be made as to the outcome of any particular matter.  We normally send 
billings on a periodic basis, usually monthly.  The periodic bills are to be paid upon presentation, 
and the amounts thereof are applied to the total fee.  If the bills are not promptly paid, we reserve 
the right to withdraw from representation. 
 
 
The normal fee arrangement of the firm is the "reasonable fee" arrangement which is based 
upon the criteria for reasonableness specified in the Rules of Professional Conduct.  The factors 
set forth in the rules include the time required for tasks performed; the difficulty, novelty or 
complexity of the problem presented; the skill required to perform the services properly; the time 
constraints imposed by the clients or the nature of the matter; the amount involved and the results 
obtained for the clients; and the experience, reputation and ability of the lawyer or lawyers 
performing the service.  We have established a normal hourly billing rate for each attorney and 
legal assistant, which is adjusted from time to time.  Attorneys David Niederdeppe and Cynthia 
Kelley will be the primary attorneys in this matter and their hourly billing rate for this 
representation is $275.00.  If necessary, other attorneys may be involved in the matter and if that 
occurs, his/her hourly billing rate will be disclosed to you prior to that attorney commencing work 
on your cases.  In addition to attorneys, there may be legal assistants involved in the matter.  The 
firm's legal assistants are typically billed at rates between $75 and $150 per hour.  In most 
circumstances, the total fee billed to the clients will be calculated primarily on the basis of the 
hourly rates and the amount of time expended for all attorneys and legal assistants involved in the 
matter.  Such hourly totals, however, may be adjusted at the end of any particular case (and 
occasionally on an interim basis) to take account of the various factors described above. 
 
For some cases, the fee arrangement may be a fixed hourly, fixed project, flat, or such other

El Mirage PSPRS Local Board  
April 7, 2020 
Page 3 
 
arrangement as is set forth in writing between the clients and the primary attorney performing the 
work.  In certain instances, modified or hybrid fee calculations may be appropriate as well.  For 
example, in instances where the result achieved is particularly beneficial or advantageous to the 
clients when viewed against the amount(s) at stake or in controversy, the efforts expended and 
other like factors, the application of a “value billing” methodology above and beyond the base or 
customary hourly billing agreement may be appropriate.  Of course, any such hybrid or value 
billing arrangement will be utilized only after prior consultation with, and concurrence of, the 
clients. 
 
 
In addition to fees for legal services, the firm may incur various costs and expenses in 
performing legal services under this Agreement.  These expenses will be itemized in our billing 
statements.  Costs and expenses include, without limitation, filing fees, messenger and process 
services, special mailing expenses, express mail services, copying charges and other reproduction 
costs charged by an outside agency or vendor, expert fees, Westlaw research, long distance 
telephone calls, travel expenses and court reporter charges.  We may send larger copying jobs to 
an outside copying service and charge the Board for such service.  We may ask that the Board pay 
court reporters' fees, outside copying charges and other large charges directly to the provider of 
the service. 
 
 
To aid in the representation, our firm and the Board may agree that hiring expert witnesses, 
appraisers, accountants, consultants or investigators is necessary.  Our firm will select such outside 
experts or entities, after consultation with the Board.  The Board authorizes us to retain and the 
Board agrees to pay the fees or charges of these persons or entities hired by us, either directly to 
the outside person or entity, or to the firm, as appropriate. 
 
 
In the event that the Boards are involved in litigation, it may be possible to seek an award 
of the Boards’ attorneys' fees and costs from the opposing party.  We will pursue such an award if 
appropriate, but we cannot and will not look to such an award as a source of payment for amounts 
owed to the firm under this Agreement.  The Boards are responsible for paying the fees and costs 
as set forth in this Agreement.  If attorneys' fees and costs are awarded, we will reimburse the 
Boards for the amount of the award, or apply the award to fees and costs that are still being accrued 
or owing. 
 
 
We ask and expect payment of our billings on a current basis because delayed payments 
add to our overall costs of providing services to all of our clients.  To avoid burdening our clients 
who do pay promptly with these additional overhead costs, we reserve the right to charge interest 
on any balance which is not paid by the end of the month following the month in which the firm's 
billing statement is dated.  Unless otherwise agreed, payment of each monthly billing statement is 
due upon receipt. 
 
CORRESPONDENCE, PLEADINGS AND DOCUMENTS 
 
 
As a matter of course, the firm will forward to the Boards copies of key correspondence,

El Mirage PSPRS Local Board  
April 7, 2020 
Page 4 
 
and any court pleadings and documents generated or received by us concerning the legal matter 
being handled.  This is an inexpensive and routine way to keep our clients advised of important 
developments and the status of the matter as it progresses.  The Boards should review the 
documents sent to them and contact us with any questions or comments about them.  All 
communications to the Boards are directed to the addresses provided to us.  Because 
communications between the Boards and the firm are critical, we must be kept informed of any 
changes in address, telephone number, and e-mail as appropriate. 
 
RETENTION OF FILES AND FILE DESTRUCTION 
 
 
Given the number of client matters the firm handles, the indefinite retention of each client's 
file is impractical.  Therefore, once any particular matter is completed, the file will be marked 
"closed" by the firm.  The Boards have a right to obtain a copy of the files at any time, but given 
the firm's routine practice of copying clients with correspondence, pleadings and documents, the 
firm will only copy those documents the Boards have not already been sent.  Original documents 
will be returned to the Boards upon the closing of the file.  If the Boards need another copy of the 
file after receiving copies from the firm, we will charge for the cost to re-copy the file.  By 
executing this Agreement, you give the firm the Boards’ permission to destroy any files once they 
have remained closed, with no material activity, for a period of seven years. 
 
CONFLICT OF INTEREST 
 
 
The firm has conducted an internal conflict of interest check based upon the names of the 
persons and/or entities provided to us by you.  No conflict of interest has appeared from this 
internal conflict check.  The Board agrees to continue to provide any additional information to the 
firm regarding the names and identities of any other person or entity involved, or which may 
become involved, in any matters for which we provide representation. 
 
TERMINATION OF REPRESENTATION AND 
CONCLUSION OF MATTERS 
 
 
Once the representation of the Boards in the matters described in this Agreement 
concludes, the firm will have no continuing obligation to represent the Boards in any matter beyond 
the scope of representation as described herein unless an agreement for continued representation 
is reached. 
 
 
The Boards have the right to terminate the firm's representation with or without cause.  
However, should the Boards determine to terminate our services, it must notify us in writing of the 
termination.  Termination of our services does not negate any fees or costs owed to the firm in the 
representation. 
 
 
The firm reserves the right to withdraw as set forth herein if our fees are not paid on a 
timely basis.  The firm also reserves the right to withdraw for any reason permitted or required

El Mirage PSPRS Local Board  
April 7, 2020 
Page 5 
 
under the Code of Professional Responsibility.  In the event the firm determines to terminate the 
representation, the Board will be notified in writing as to the termination, and agree to execute an 
approval of a Motion to Withdraw or Substitution of Counsel, if applicable.  In that event, the firm 
will cooperate in transitioning the matter to another attorney as appropriate. 
 
 
After the Boards’ representatives have had an opportunity to review this Agreement, please 
sign it where indicated and return it to me for our file.  The firm's attorneys will generally not 
proceed to work for a client beyond the initial consultation and initial research until a signed 
Agreement is received from the Boards.  In the event that legal services have been performed and 
costs expended on the Boards’ behalf, it is obligated to the firm for the value of such services and 
costs. 
 
 
We recognize that this Agreement has a formal tone, but we believe that a complete 
understanding of our business relationship helps to assure a mutually beneficial attorney-client 
relationship.  We appreciate this opportunity to be of assistance and look forward to working with 
the Boards. 
 
 
 
 
 
Very truly yours, 
 
 
 
 
 
 
RYAN RAPP UNDERWOOD & PACHECO, P.L.C. 
 
 
David L. Niederdeppe 
 
 
Cynthia K. Kelley 
 
 
I have read and understand the foregoing terms set forth in the Ryan Rapp  
Underwood & Pacheco, P.L.C. Engagement and Retainer Agreement, and approve and 
agree to them as of the date that Ryan Rapp Underwood & Pacheco, P.L.C., first provided 
services to the BoardsLocal Board Chairperson 
 
By:________________________________________ 
Date:_________________________ 
 
Printed Name:______________________________ 
 
Its:________________________________________