PowerPoint Presentation (Updated 4/6/2023)
Extracted text (via pymupdf)
53165 characters
Council Workshop FY23-24 Budget Discussion April 6, 2023 Budget Calendar 2 Item Date Workshop #1 – Budget Overview / Revenues / Five-Year Financial Forecasts February 14, 2023 Workshop #2 – FY24-33 Capital Improvement Plan March 7, 2023 Workshop #3 – (All Day) FY24 Operating Budget Department Presentations April 4, 2023 Workshop #4 – (All Day) FY24 Operating Budget Department Presentations April 6, 2023 Workshop #5 – FY24 Final Budget Workshop April 18, 2023 Voting Meeting – Tentative Budget Adoption May 9, 2023 Voting Meeting – Final Budget Adoption / Property Tax Levy June 13, 2023 Voting Meeting – Property Tax Adoption June 27, 2023 Operating Budget Presentation Schedule 3 April 4, 2023 April 6, 2023 Public Affairs/Communication Community Services Budget and Finance/Non- Departmental Organizational Performance Audit Human Resources and Risk Management Field Operations Transportation Development Services Water Services City Attorney City Court Mayor & Council City Manager’s Office/Code Compliance Engineering Parks and Recreation Police Department Fire Department Innovation and Technology Economic Development City Clerk Agenda 4 1) Follow Up Items from April 4, 2023 Workshop 2) FY23-24 Summary of Personnel Changes 3) Department Presentations Follow Up Items – General Fund Positions 5 General Fund Position Additions 46 Total Ongoing Budget Amount $4,072,495 Change in Operating Budget 6 FY23 Adopted Budget $546,413,506 FY24 Baseline Budget (Less One-Time) $507,079,575 FY24 Salary and Benefit Increases $ 36,672,994 FY24 Service and Supply Increases $ 31,938,661 FY24 Internal Charges Increases $ 9,266,499 FY24 Operating Budget Request $584,957,728 Follow Up Items – Parks and Recreation 7 • Sports Field Rental Revenue – $200k/year • Contract Monitor Position Duties – Park Maintenance Division – 8 ongoing service contracts for essential park maintenance functions, plus 8-10 project related contracts annually – Contract Monitor would assume the administrative tasks associated with contracts – contract development, negotiations, tracking, auditing, and contract expenditures, allowing field staff to focus on maintaining parks Follow Up Items – Engineering 8 Why is Engineering’s R-Rollup 25% of their budget? Salaries (Reduced by Chargebacks) $2,276,333 65% Services and Supplies $ 348,930 10% Internal Charges $ 865,000 25% Salaries (Full) $5,501,159 82% Services and Supplies $ 348,930 5% Internal Charges $ 865,000 13% Summary of Personnel Changes 9 Enterprise Funds # of Positions Community Services (Housing) 1 Field Operations (Landfill) 2 Water Services 1 Total Enterprise Funds 4 Internal Service Funds # of Positions Innovation and Technology 5 Field Operations (Fleet) 1 Total Internal Service Funds 6 Total All Funds # of Positions General Fund 46 Enterprise Funds 4 Internal Service Funds 6 Special Revenue Funds 11.5 Total 67.5 General Fund # of Positions City Manager’s Office – Code Compliance 2 Communications 1 Community Services 6 Development Services 2 Economic Development 1 Field Operations 5 Fire Services 8 Human Resources 2 Parks and Recreation 7 Police Services 12 Total General Fund 46 Special Revenue Funds # of Positions Highway User Revenue Fund 3 Transportation Sales Tax 8.5 Total Special Revenue 11.5 Public Affairs April 6, 2023 11 Mission Statement The mission of the Public Affairs Department is to develop and implement comprehensive strategies and programs that effectively and accurately communicate the city’s key messages to their targeted audiences. Public Affairs $968,999 3 FTEs Public Affairs FY24 Operating Budget Request Total FY24 Operating Budget $968,999 $535,918 55% $191,676 20% $241,405 25% Salary Operating Internal Services 12 Public Affairs Goals, Objectives & Performance Measures 13 Strategic Objective Improve Purposeful Communication Department Strategic Initiative Successfully advocate the city’s position on issues at the Arizona Legislature, United States Congress, and other governmental bodies. Intended Result Legislative awareness and impact. Performance Measures FY2021 Actual FY2022 Actual FY2023 Estimate FY2024 Target Total number of bills posted 1350 1510 1757 1950 Number of bills tracked that have a direct impact to City and have received staff input 325 335 299 340 Number of new laws being enacted 335 347 446 398 Public Affairs Goals, Objectives & Performance Measures 14 Strategic Objectives Improve Purposeful Communication Improve Stakeholder Engagement Department Strategic Initiative Proactively pursue an enhanced presence on regional and national committees, work cooperatively with local and regional partners/agencies, and strategically position Glendale’s projects for regional funding and support. Intended Result Glendale projects are funded and completed in the appropriate times. Performance Measures FY2021 Actual FY2022 Actual FY2023 Estimate FY2024 Target Total number of regional and national committees on which Glendale elected officials are serving 22 23 24 22 Public Affairs Goals, Objectives & Performance Measures 15 Strategic Objectives Improve Purposeful Communication Improve Stakeholder Engagement Increase Innovation Solutions Department Strategic Initiative Proactively engage residents and council through targeted communication strategies and the use of creative outreach methods. Intended Result The public and the Council are informed of the City’s legislative agenda and bills being considered by the Legislature that would have a direct impact on the city or neighborhoods. Performance Measures FY2021 Actual FY2022 Actual FY2023 Estimate FY2024 Target Number of Legislative Link subscribers 210 199 215 241 Number of legislative reports posted to the website 14 19 18 17 Public Affairs FY23 Accomplishments 16 Continued to lead regional efforts to introduce legislation authorizing Maricopa County to call an election for the extension of Proposition 400, the region’s half-cent sales tax dedicated solely for transportation Introduced legislation on behalf of the City Council to reform public posting requirements. Introduced legislation on behalf of the Glendale Police Department to allow cities to charge staff time for redacting police body camera footage. Assisted Luke AFB with state legislation to prohibit private drone operations on or over the military instillation Public Affairs FY23 Accomplishments 17 Increased City and Legislative relationships through frequent planned interactions between City Councilmembers and state House and Senate members. Hosted a 2023 Legislative Dinner that brought 13 of Glendale’s 18 legislators to Glendale for a roundtable discussion with the City Council. Assisted Glendale City Courts in advocating for the Veteran’s Court by facilitating a tour and round table discussion with the City Council and Senator Kyrsten Sinema. Public Affairs FY23 Accomplishments 18 Established and maintained communication with the new Governor’s Office and state agency staff to ensure continuity of service for the residents of the City of Glendale and the State of Arizona. Secured a commitment of $1.33 million of federal funding in FY23 for improvements to three community centers and/or recreation centers located in the 85301 zip code Secured a commitment of federal funding in FY23 for improvements to the Luke Air Force Base Child Development Center. Public Affairs FY24 Supplemental Requests 19 General Fund Media Center Utilities $ 45k Cell Phones for Public Affairs and Communications $ 1k 20 QUESTIONS? Communications April 6, 2023 22 Mission Statement The mission of the Communications Department is to provide innovative and creative communication solutions to promote the City’s core services, initiatives and mission. Communications $1,926,747 12.5 FTEs Communications FY24 Operating Budget Request Total FY24 Operating Budget $1,926,747 $1,545,687 80% $281,745 15% $99,315 5% Salary Operating Internal Services 23 Communications Goals, Objectives & Performance Measures 24 Strategic Objectives Improve Purposeful Communication Improve Stakeholder Engagement Increase Innovation Solutions Department Strategic Initiatives Increase outreach and provide city news and information about the City’s programs, services, and amenities with the use of creative outreach methods. Implement new web content management system to better serve our digital audience and increase visitors to City websites. Intended Result Improved communications and transparency with residents, stakeholders, community partners, businesses and visitors. Performance Measures FY2021 Actual FY2022 Actual FY2023 Estimate FY2024 Target Social media presence - the number of people who see our posts on all digital channels including Vimeo, Facebook, Instagram, Twitter and YouTube 3,356,000 3,450,000 3,550,000 3,555,000 Number of Facebook Live reports “look live” videos or social media broadcasts of city events 162 170 175 175 Average social engagements per post 84 90 95 100 Average positive sentiment 23% 25% 27% N/A Number of website pageviews* 5,249,579 5,350,000 5,450,000 5,500,000 *FY18 & FY19 include numbers from other city websites (Library, CVB, & Civic Center) FY20 & FY21 include only the main site Communications FY23 Accomplishments 25 The Glendale Media Team produced a constant stream of outstanding content including a video that rose above and beyond anything that has ever been produced before. The high standard of excellence resulted in an Emmy award win as well as a nomination and three national awards of excellence in the 3CMA, City County Communications awards. Did constant excellent media relations work for a record number of media requests due to the Super Bowl. Continued to do communications for a variety of major city announcements. Planned together with City Manager’s Office, organized and implemented successful City Manager’s all-staff event for Kevin Phelps to provide important updates to employees. Planned a successful Council Installation ceremony event which included planning and implementing many different aspects of work that is needed to create a special ceremony for our city elected officials. Communications FY23 Accomplishments 26 Continued to populate a comprehensive website landing page with Glendale- specific information for the Super Bowl. Created a comprehensive online Glendale media kit where anyone now has access to a variety of high- resolution city photos, a wide variety of quality b-roll, some fun facts, general information about Glendale, maps and more. Continued to enhance the monthly employee news communication with upgrading the look and content of the Employee Express as an important tool for communicating to our staff an appealing look. Provided promotional wording and videos and media outreach about Glendale Glitters. Handled media requests and did media coaching with those who did interviews. Began to take our short videos and make them into full shows for the cable station and Facebook. An example of this is our video series “Have You Been Here?” which showcases areas of the city that are a great place to visit. Communications FY23 Accomplishments 27 Produced numerous videos for Economic Development to help them achieve their growth goals. Spread the word with media and videos about the excitement of LIVE @ Murphy Park concerts. Continued to produce a variety of promotional videos and a video showing behind the scenes of what they do. Played a big role in Gratitude month once again with videos and other elements to help employees feel appreciated and valued. Did the same for the Success Factors awards and played a part to make it a live event for our HR department. Assisted departments with creating video assets to help them with recruiting and have produced a big variety of them to help HR attract good people. Communications FY24 Supplemental Requests 28 General Fund Cell Phones for Public Affairs and Communications $ 7k New FTE – Video Editor/Photographer $ 60k FTE Reclass – PIO to Communications Director $ 28k 29 QUESTIONS? Community Services April 6, 2023 31 Mission Statement We build community thorough impactful services. Community Services $42,282,803 103.5 FTEs Library Revitalization Housing Community Action Program Community Engagement Community Services FY24 Operating Budget Request Total FY24 Operating Budget $42,282,803 $11,191,460 26% $29,558,708 70% $1,532,635 4% Salary Operating Internal Services 32 Community Services Goals, Objectives & Performance Measures 33 Strategic Objectives Optimize Processes & Services Improve Community Experience Department Strategic Initiative Key department managers will continue to enhance the programs and services offered to Glendale residents through a variety of diverse activities which preserve the health, safety, and livability of the community. Intended Result All patrons of the Community Services Department receive excellent customer service. Performance Measures FY2021 Actual FY2022 Actual FY2023 Estimate FY2024 Target Public Housing Program Occupancy Rate 97% 98% 98% 98% Housing Choice Voucher Management Assessment Rating 86% 85% 100% 100% Households Served through Public Housing Programs 1,390 1,379 1,453 1,502 Household Served through Crisis Assistance Programs 2,466 3,241 1,903 1,500 Individuals who obtained permanent housing through the Homeless Master Services Agreement NA 852 1,000 1,000 Owner-occupied homes rehabilitated for low-income households 127 60 75 75 Households assisted through the Tenant Based Rental Assistance Program (TBRA) NA 42 46 75 Digital Library Materials Utilization Rate (per resident) 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 Community Services Goals, Objectives & Performance Measures 34 Strategic Objectives Increase Stakeholder Engagement Improve Purposeful Communication Improve Resource Alignment Improve Community Experience Department Strategic Initiative Improve strategic outreach and partnerships in support of programs and services to benefit Glendale residents. Intended Result Increased number of community volunteers and external partnerships. Performance Measures FY2021 Actual FY2022 Actual FY2023 Estimate FY2024 Target Community Engagement Volunteer Activities 45 100 100 125 Community Volunteer Hours (Service Projects) 1,850 6,000 6,500 7,000 Community Volunteer Hours (Library Services) 3,237 16,265 20,289 23,000 Community Services Partner Organizations 172 227 305 330 Community Services FY23 Accomplishments 35 130 homeless households re-housed (in-house programs) 1,000 homeless households re-housed (partner programs) 37,000 homeless services since June 2021 5,400 households remained stably housed during pandemic 1,300 units of affordable housing in the pipeline $1 million invested in neighborhood and community improvements 175 attendees at the Dementia Friendly Resource Fair $245,000 invested in Ocotillo Rose neighborhood (Super Bowl event) 23% increase in hydration services during 2022 Heat Relief Community Services FY23 Accomplishments 36 400 employees contributed $50,000 in employee giving campaigns 22,000 outdated, damaged, low-demand items removed from library collection 25% increase in 2022 Summer Reading Program $500,000 invested in 7 building projects to improve libraries Community Services FY24 Supplemental Requests 37 General Fund New FTE - Community Services Program Coordinator $ 21k Automated Materials Handler $175k Automated Materials Handler $192k FTE Reclass Prg Mgr to Community Engagement Prg Mgr $ 10k New FTE (.5) Public Service Assistant (10) $283k Increased Security Costs $ 45k Pilot Program Front Yard Landscaping $125k Car Allowance $ 3k Community Services FY24 Supplemental Requests 38 Home Grant HUD Grant Funding (HOME) $4.0M Neighborhood Stabilization HUD Grant Funding $850k CDBG Community Revitalization CDBG-CV1 Grant $713k Community Revitalization CDBG-CV3 Grant $504k Community Services FY24 Supplemental Requests 39 Emergency Shelter Grant Emergency Shelter Grant $ 24k Community Revitalization ESG-CV1 Grant $ 57k Community Revitalization ESG-CV2 Grant $500k Housing Public Activities Increase Housing Assistance Payments $1.8M New FTE – Comm Svc Program Coordinator $ 97k Citywide Standby Pay Increase $ 7k 40 QUESTIONS? Budget and Finance Department April 6, 2023 42 Budget and Finance $12,815,904 74.5 FTEs Budget and Finance Lease Payments/Other Fees Mission Statement The Budget and Finance Department provides financial management services with integrity and accountability while improving service levels, managing costs, and leveraging information across City departments. Budget and Finance FY24 Operating Budget Request Total FY24 Operating Budget $12,815,904 $8,386,467 65% $3,440,187 27% $989,251 8% Salary Operating Internal Services 43 Budget and Finance Goals, Objectives & Performance Measures 44 Strategic Objective Improve Resource Alignment Department Strategic Initiative Employ strong fiscal management practices that encourage sustainable fiscal decision-making. Intended Result Prudent fiscal stewardship Performance Measures FY2021 Actual FY2022 Actual FY2023 Estimate FY2024 Target Bond ratings for general obligation bonds Standard & Poor's: Moody's Investor Services: Fitch Ratings: AA- Aa1 AAA AA- A1 AAA AA A1 AAA AA A1 AAA Bond ratings for Water and Sewer revenue bonds Standard & Poor's: Moody's Investor Services: Fitch Ratings: AA A1 n/a AA- A1 AA AA A1 AA AA A1 AA Annualized amortized cost basis return on portfolio (net of fees) 2.5% 2.61% 3.2% 3.9% Number of grants received through Grants Administration 50 38 30 40 Compliance with Council adopted Financial Policies (# complied with/# of policies) 6/7 7/7 6/7 7/7 Budget and Finance Goals, Objectives & Performance Measures 45 Strategic Objective Improve Resource Alignment Department Strategic Initiative Provide accurate and timely financial analysis, forecasting, and reporting. Intended Result Prudent fiscal stewardship Performance Measures FY2021 Actual FY2022 Actual FY2023 Estimate FY2024 Target Maintain a +/- 5% variance in general fund revenue forecasts from the final actual revenue to the adopted budget +5% +5% +5% +5% % of month-end reports completed within 10 business days 75% 75% 100% 100% Obtain the GFOA Certificate of Achievement for Excellence in Financial Reporting Yes Yes Yes Yes Obtain the GFOA Distinguished Budget Presentation Award Yes Yes Yes Yes Budget and Finance Goals, Objectives & Performance Measures 46 Strategic Objective Optimize Processes & Services Department Strategic Initiative Perform customer service and procurement activities effectively, accurately, and timely. Intended Result Improved levels of service Performance Measures FY2021 Actual FY2022 Actual FY2023 Estimate FY2024 Target % of vendor invoices paid within 30 days of invoice date 93% 85% 90% 90% % of employees receiving electronic W-2’s 60% 59% 65% 65% Number of vendor protests upheld 5 2 0 0 Number of RFP’s and IFB’s issued 46 35 35 45 % of contract renewals completed on-time 100% 80% 98% 100% % of sole source/special procurements processed within 10 days 95% 70% 90% 100% % of call center calls answered within 1 minute 60.5% 54% 80% 80% % of call center calls abandoned <=9.4% 11% <=2.5% <=2.5% Number of sales tax audits/reviews completed 87 181 120 120 Budget and Finance FY23 Accomplishments 47 • 2022 Government Finance Officers Association’s Distinguished Budget Presentation Award • 2021 Government Finance Officers Association’s Award for Excellence in Financial Reporting • Implemented a successful Munis upgrade Budget and Finance FY24 Supplemental Requests 48 General Fund External Audit Contract $ 50k Debt Book Online Software $ 5k Bethune & Associates – Collections contract $ 10k Valley Collection Service – Collections contract $ 20k Temporary Pay Increase $ 15k FTE Reclass – IT Systems Analyst Sr. $ 13k FTE Reclass – Customer Service Supervisor $ 39k Car Allowance $ 3k 49 QUESTIONS? Non-Departmental April 6, 2023 51 Non-Departmental $9,420,163 0 FTEs Mission Statement The Budget and Finance Department provides financial management services with integrity and accountability while improving service levels, managing costs, and leveraging information across City departments. Non-Departmental FY24 Operating Budget Request Total FY24 Operating Budget $9,420,163 $365,000 4% $9,043,467 96% $11,696 0% Salary Operating Internal Services 52 Non-Departmental Budgeted Items 53 • 2024 Final Four Expenditures • AZSTA Sales Tax Rebates • Memberships – Westmarc – League of Arizona Cities and Towns – Maricopa Association of Governments (MAG) – National League of Cities 54 QUESTIONS? Organizational Performance April 6, 2023 56 Mission Statement We make Glendale a more effective government for its residents through effective decision-making utilizing data, analytics, and strategic initiatives. We increase transparency and champion continuous improvement through data governance and performance management programs. Organizational Performance $711,248 3 FTEs Organizational Performance FY24 Operating Budget Request Total FY24 Operating Budget $711,248 $494,099 70% $187,500 26% $29,649 4% Salary Operating Internal Services 57 Organizational Performance Goals, Objectives & Performance Measures 58 Strategic Objectives Improve Stakeholder Engagement Increase Innovation Solutions Strengthen Workforce Culture Strengthen Workforce Development Improve Tools & Technology Department Strategic Initiative Implement a programmatic approach to data governance designed to make city data actionable and increase the use of data in decision-making, recommendations, and telling the story of our work. Intended Results City data is open by default, reliable, and easily accessible internally and externally. Actionable intelligence is used routinely in analysis and reporting. The city has a number of employees with strong data analytics capabilities, actively uses data to share the impact of our work, and strategically implements new systems and data collection Performance Measures FY2021 Actual FY2022 Actual FY2023 Estimate FY2024 Target Participation and publication of citywide data inventory. Target: 100% of departments participate Comprehensive data inventory published and updated at defined intervals 100% Yes 96% Yes 85% 100% Educate organizational data stewards on business intelligence and analytics principles Target: 100% of data stewards receive initial training 100% 100% 100% 100% Organizational Performance Goals, Objectives & Performance Measures 59 Strategic Objectives Improve Community Experience Improve Resource Alignment Improve Purposeful Communication Improve Stakeholder Engagement Optimize Processes & Services Increase Innovation Solutions Strengthen Workforce Development Strengthen Workforce Culture Improve Tools & Technology Department Strategic Initiative What Works Cities Certification Intended Results Data driven governance to increase resident satisfaction Community engagement to improve neighborhoods Address the most pressing issues the city is facing through the analysis of data and implementation of programs that work Performance Measures FY2021 Actual FY2022 Actual FY2023 Estimate FY2024 Target Number of defined certification criteria achieved and maintained. Target: 51% of criteria achieved and maintained by the end of 2023 60% 67% N/A 86% Organizational Performance FY23 Accomplishments 60 • Balanced Scorecard Tier II Development/Implementation • Data Governance – Data Analyst Networking Group • Open Data • Performance Dashboards • Community Involvement Organizational Performance FY24 Supplemental Requests 61 General Fund Community Survey $ 40k Car Allowance $ 3k 62 QUESTIONS? Audit Department April 6, 2023 64 Mission Statement To provide internal audit services through detailed queries and testing to strengthen controls, identify potential risks, improve processes, verify compliance, and ensure the City of Glendale operates with transparency in the best interests of its residents. Audit Department $604,347 1 FTE Audit Department FY24 Operating Budget Request Total FY24 Operating Budget $604,347 $199,576 33% $391,700 65% $13,071 2% Salary Operating Internal Services 65 Audit Department Goals, Objectives & Performance Measures 66 Strategic Objective Improve Resource Alignment Department Strategic Initiative Develop a risk-based audit plan that strengthens internal controls and reduces organizational risk. Intended Result Audit resources are allocated to the areas that pose the greatest risk to the city. Performance Measures FY2021 Actual FY2022 Actual FY2023 Estimate FY2024 Target Number of Audits Completed 12 14 12 10 % Audit Recommendations Accepted by Management 97% 100% 100% 100% % Annual Audit Plan Completed* 55% 65% 75% 75% *There will always be rollover of some engagements from one audit plan to the next, which is reflected in the audit plan completion percentages above. Due to the timing of when audits begin, they may not be completed until the following fiscal year. For example, five FY22 audits were completed in FY23. There will be three or four FY23 audits that will not be completed until FY24. Moving forward, tracking the percentage of audit plan engagements started and/or deferred may be a better indicator of workload across yearly audit plans. Audit Department FY23 Accomplishments 67 • Participated in two Peer Reviews of other audit departments (Toronto, Ontario; Gainesville, Florida) under guidelines published by the Association of Local Government Auditors • In process of implementing automated analytics in our audit software to move toward continuous monitoring of selected controls Audit Department FY24 Supplemental Requests 68 General Fund Car Allowance $3k 69 QUESTIONS? Human Resources April 6, 2023 71 Mission Statement We improve the lives of the people we serve every day. Human Resources $65,145,876 27 FTEs Organizational Development Employee Relations Employment Services Compensation and Benefits Risk/Worker’s Compensation Human Resources FY24 Operating Budget Request Total FY24 Operating Budget $65,145,876 $4,251,662 7% $60,646,431 93% $247,783 >0% Salary Operating Internal Services 72 Human Resources Goals, Objectives & Performance Measures 73 Strategic Objectives Strengthen Workforce Culture Strengthen Workforce Development Department Strategic Initiatives 1. Obtain top level management support for diversity initiatives. 2. Form a Diversity Committee to develop, communicate and implement a diversity strategy. Intended Result Foster and influence a climate of mutual respect and inclusiveness that is open, creative and people centered. Performance Measures FY2021 Actual FY2022 Actual FY2023 Estimate FY2024 Target Number of organizational diversity events held 1 in person/4 virtual 3 in person/4 virtual 7 10 Number of diversity training opportunities held 10 on-line 12 on-line 14 17 Number of employees attending diversity training/events 182 273 300 350 Our employee diversity ratio reflects the Glendale community **See below **See below **See below **See below *New Hires FY20/21 Actual – White 55.95%, Black 4.76%, Hispanic Latino 30.95%, Asian 1.79%, Native Hawaiian and other Pacific Islander .60%, American Indian 0%, 2 Or More Races 2.98% *New Hires FY21/22 Actual - White 44.97%, Black 5.29%, Hispanic Latino 37.04%, Asian 3.70%, Native Hawaiian and other Pacific Islander .53%, American Indian 1.06%, 2 Or More Races 3.17% **Community and Employee Ratios FY20/21 Actual – White 60.0% Community (61.17%EE), Black/AA 4.94% Community (4.93%EE), Hispanic/Latino 27.30% Community (26.68%EE). Asian 2.53% Community (2.49%EE), American Indian .80% Community (.85%EE), Native Hawaiian and other Pacific Islander .40% Community (.32%EE), 2 Or More Races 1.26% Community (1.06%EE) **Community and Employee Ratios FY21/22 Actual - White 44.8% Community (61.17%EE), Black/AA 7.3% Community (4.93%EE), Hispanic/Latino 39.0% Community (26.68%EE). Asian 4.4% Community (2.49%EE), American Indian 1.6% Community (.85%EE), Native Hawaiian and other Pacific Islander .10% Community (.32%EE), 2 Or More Races 9.4% Community (1.06%EE) Human Resources Goals, Objectives & Performance Measures 74 Strategic Objective Improve Resource Alignment Department Strategic Initiatives 1. Collaborate with employees, stakeholders and healthcare organizations to review options for implementing a fiscally sustainable health plan. 2. Develop a plan to promote greater participation in the wellness program. Intended Result Maintain a fiscally sustainable employee benefits program that provides high quality healthcare which promotes and enhances the well-being of employees. Performance Measures FY2021 Actual FY2022 Actual FY2023 Estimate FY2024 Target Cost increases remain at or below the medical trend. 7-1-20 3.8% below medical trend 7-1-21 2.3% below medical trend 7-1-22 2.4% below medical trend Stay below medical trend Increase enrollment in the wellness program. 485 13% decrease in enrollment 556 Introduction of new incentives, increased points 538 Increased points to 25,000 5% increase in enrollment Human Resources Goals, Objectives & Performance Measures 75 Strategic Objectives Improve Resource Alignment Improve Asset Management Department Strategic Initiative 1. Monitor external market on regular basis to ensure competitiveness. 2. Complete job studies as appropriate in a timely manner to ensure classifications are current. 3. Comply with appropriate federal and state laws. 4. Complete classification and compensation study to determine critical areas requiring attention. Intended Result Implement and maintain a competitive non-represented compensation structure, policy, practices, and philosophy to attract, motivate and retain highly skilled employees. Performance Measures FY2021 Actual FY2022 Actual FY2023 Estimate FY2024 Target Reduce turnover for non-represented employees 11.8% 12.13% 13.49% 8.0% Salary ranges are within +/- 5% of the average midpoint for comparative organizations Study not conducted At +/-5% 7-1-22 Study not conducted Remain at +1/- 5% Human Resources Goals, Objectives & Performance Measures 76 *The Experience Modification Rate is an indicator of how well a workers’ compensation program is performing as compared to other similar business types within a State (in our case against other cities within Arizona) **Due to nature of litigation & workload outside counsel was needed Strategic Objectives Improve Resource Alignment Improve Asset Management Department Strategic Initiatives 1. Utilize risk avoidance, risk reduction, risk transfer and risk retention strategies to protect against losses that would negatively impact City assets and its ability to provide ongoing services. 2. Manage property and liability claims to minimize costs. 3. Promote employee safety awareness programs. Intended Result Provide and maintain a low risk, safe environment for City of Glendale employees and its citizens. Performance Measures FY2021 Actual FY2022 Actual FY2023 Estimate FY2024 Target Utilize in-house counsel 50% (when practical) to reduce legal fees. Open (filled/served) Closed (settled, prevailed or dismissed) Internal counsel assigned Outside counsel assigned 39%in house** 22 22 13 20 68% in house** 10 18 18 10 50% 50% *Experience Modification Rate for Workers’ Compensation Claims at 1.0 or less. The average for city and county employers is 1.04% 1.21 Has not been calculated by ICA yet 1.0 1.0 Maintain total operating cost of risk at < 3% .017% 1.62% <3% <3% Human Resources FY23 Accomplishments 77 • Phoenix Business Journal Healthiest Employer Finalist • First Glendale 5K run • Successful Munis Upgrade • Moved to 95% online benefit enrollments • Executed the second annual Success Factors Excellence Awards incentive program, with 34 winners and 28 semi-finalists • Successfully launched PERFORM for employee evaluations in September, with 1773 evaluations in process and 1559 completed • Successfully implemented LEARN, a learning management system, for all departments and employees. Since January’s launch, we have seen 1466 course enrollments and 822 completed courses Human Resources FY23 Accomplishments 78 • The Risk Management Division completed training all departments in inputting Incidents into the Origami claims case management system • The OSHA employee injury information was fully automated in Origami allowing Risk Management staff to generate the OSHA 300 and 300A reports from the system • 91% of hearing testing of employees was completed on-sight reducing the time employees are away from the workplace Human Resources FY24 Supplemental Requests 79 General Fund Human Resources Temporary Personnel $100k New FTE – Human Resources Technician $ 94k New FTE – Human Resources Analyst $108k Car Allowance $ 3k Risk Management Self Insurance Origami System $145k Risk Management Trust Fund Increase $1.1M Human Resources FY24 Supplemental Requests 80 Workers Compensation Self Insurance Origami System $145k NEW FTE – Fire Health & Fitness Coordinator $ 56k Worker’s Compensation Trust Fund Increase $939k Benefits Trust Wellness Programs $ 50k HR Employee Benefits Increase $2.2M 81 QUESTIONS? Field Operations April 6, 2023 83 Mission Statement We improve the lives of the people we serve every day through environmentally sound collection and disposal of solid waste, and fiscally prudent management of the city’s assets. Field Operations $67,302,911 190 FTEs Facilities Landfill Solid Waste Fleet Field Operations FY24 Operating Budget Request Total FY24 Operating Budget $67,302,911 $21,389,117 32% $38,061,116 56% $7,852,678 12% Salary Operating Internal Services 84 Field Operations Goals, Objectives & Performance Measures 85 Strategic Objective Optimize Processes & Services Department Strategic Initiative Collect and dispose of all Solid Waste as scheduled Intended Result Provide excellent service to all customers by effectively and efficiently managing solid waste collected; reduce missed collections; and increase efficient disposal and processing services. Performance Measures FY2021 Actual FY2022 Actual FY2023 Estimate FY2024 Target Residential containers missed pickup – reduce by 5% 397 504 453 430 Increase compaction of garbage at Landfill by 1% - Measured in pounds per cubic yard compaction 1,600 1,785 1,785 TBD* *North Cell/South Cell Split – Measure to be Revised and Evaluated Next Fiscal Year Field Operations Goals, Objectives & Performance Measures 86 Strategic Objective Optimize Processes & Services Department Strategic Initiative To manage fleet operations and vehicle assets in the most cost effective and efficient manner possible optimizing resources and minimizing downtime while providing safe and reliable transportation to all City departments. Intended Result Maintain a consistent level of achieving/surpassing key performance indicator targets to reach a maximum efficiency with available resources. Performance Measures FY2021 Actual FY2022 Actual FY2023 Estimate FY2024 Target Fleet Vehicle and Equipment Preventative Maintenance (PM) Compliance 450 vehicles past due for PM 446 vehicles past due for PM 358 vehicles past due for PM 350 vehicles past due for PM Fleet Direct Labor Rate 80% 76% 83% 85% Fleet Downtime Rate <5% 6% <5.2% <5% Field Operations Goals, Objectives & Performance Measures 87 Strategic Objective Improve Asset Management Department Strategic Initiative Improve HVAC Preventative Maintenance Schedule Compliance Intended Result Industry standard of care requires 80% of on time completion rate of PM work orders. Performance Measures FY2021 Actual FY2022 Actual FY2023 Estimate FY2024 Target Number of PMs Required during period * N/A 141 550 730 Number of PMs Completed during period ** N/A 133 440 585 Percentage of PMs Completed N/A 94.3% 80% 80% Field Operations FY23 Accomplishments 88 • Serve 55,700 residential and 1,100 commercial accounts for solid waste and recycling • Landfill expansion to north • Asset management for Facilities- completed over 1,750 preventive and 3,800 corrective maintenance work orders • Maintenance and repair of almost 1400 fleet assets with a replacement value of over $111,000,000 • Fleet Management named top 50 Government Leading Fleets Field Operations FY24 Supplemental Requests 89 Electricity General Fund $386k Library $ 53k Landfill $ 5k GRPSTC $ 30k Safety Boot Allowance General Fund $ 2k Landfill $ 2k Solid Waste $ 5k Fleet $ 1k Field Operations FY24 Supplemental Requests 90 Security Services Solid Waste $ 30k Landfill $ 38k Software Annual Service Fee Solid Waste $ 170k Landfill $ 20k Radios-Annual Fees & Repairs Solid Waste $ 5k Landfill $ 1k Field Operations FY24 Supplemental Requests 91 Solid Waste 3 FTE Reclass Equip. Operator Lead $ 17k FTE Reclass - Equipment Operator II $ 37k Auxiliary Equipment $ 40k Citywide Standby Pay Increase $ 4k Fuel Surcharge Update Diesel Price Trend 93 $2.25 $2.75 $3.25 $3.75 $4.25 $4.75 $5.25 $5.75 $6.25 Jan Feb March April May June July Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec West Coast Diesel Price Comparison 2019-2023 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 $3.86 Nov. 2021 $6.15 $5.24 Aug. 2022 $4.53 Amount to be covered by surcharge Fuel Cost Recovery 94 Reduce the Fuel Surcharge from $1.54 to $0.90 Recover FY22 actual shortfall ($85K) and FY24 projected ($522K) with a fuel surcharge from July 2023 to June 2024 ($606,000 total over 12 months) • FY24 Surcharge: $0.90/household per month, reduction of $0.64/household/month • Review in FY25 Budget process Field Operations FY24 Supplemental Requests 95 General Fund City Wide - Janitorial Prof and Contractual $380k City Wide - Natural Gas $ 19k Promenade at Palmaire $ 60k Bank of America Garage $175k New FTE - Cemetery Service Worker $ 69k Cemetery - Landscaping $ 25k Cemetery - Purchases for Public $ 30k New FTE – CIP Eng. Project Manager $123k New FTE – Contract Monitor $100k New FTE – Planner Scheduler $ 92k Field Operations FY24 Supplemental Requests 96 General Fund New FTE – Trades Worker/Electrician $ 92k Facilities – Office Supplies $ 4k Facilities – Professional Development $ 54k Facilities – Key Management System $ 6k Facilities – Uniform Supplies $ 25k Facilities – Replace Tablets for Technicians $ 11k Citywide Standby Pay Increase $ 22k Car Allowance $ 6k Field Operations FY24 Supplemental Requests 97 GRPSTC Natural Gas $ 1k FTE Reclass - Trades Worker $ 7k Professional Contractual $ 22k Building Maintenance & Repair $ 19k Line Supplies $ 4k Field Operations FY24 Supplemental Requests 98 Landfill Credit Card Fees $ 25k Gov’t Permits and Fees $ 20k 3 FTE Reclass Equip. Operator Lead ($ 78k) New FTE - Field Operations Program Manager $104k FTE Reclass Field Ops Administrator $ 35k New FTE Account Specialist $ 73k Advertising – Recycling Program $ 89k Field Operations FY24 Supplemental Requests 99 Fleet Services Diesel Exhaust Fluid $ 51k Contract Equip. Maintenance/Repair $ 25k Contract Equip. Accident/Repair $ 25k Tire Capping $ 15k Vehicle Supplies/Parts $ 50k Motor Fuel $600k New FTE - Fleet Business Operations Analyst $108k GPS Equipment $ 85k City Wide Standby Pay $ 13k Parts Room Hours $ 18k Field Operations FY24 Supplemental Requests 100 Equipment Replacement (VRF) Vehicles - COPS Grant 3 Police Officers $156k Vehicles - MROP Program $390k Vehicle - Administrator, Code Compliance $ 41k Vehicle - Facilities – Contract Monitor $ 36k Vehicle (2) - Parks Service Worker – Irrigation $144k Vehicle (3) - Parks Service Worker $141k Vehicle - Facilities – Trades Worker/Electrician $ 55k Vehicle - Police Technical Services Administrator $ 56k 101 QUESTIONS? Transportation April 6, 2023 103 Mission Statement Ensure safe and efficient circulation of vehicular, bicycle and pedestrian traffic, to minimize pollutant air emissions, and to promote economic development throughout the City. Transportation $37,995,771 117.75 FTEs Transit Traffic Engineering & Operations Airport Street Management Transportation FY24 Operating Budget Request Total FY24 Operating Budget $37,995,771 $13,035,428 34% $20,238,013 53% $4,722,330 13% Salary Operating Internal Services 104 Transportation Goals, Objectives & Performance Measures 105 Strategic Objectives Optimize Processes & Services Improve Asset Management Improve Community Experience Department Strategic Initiative Expend $20.8M per year (not including bonds for ARP) to implement the City’s Pavement Management Program using in- house design, construction administration, and inspection services. Intended Result The $20.8M multi-year Pavement Management Program to address the roadway pavement condition by implementing pavement management strategies Performance Measures FY2021 Actual FY2022 Actual FY2023 Estimate FY2024 Target Reconstructions $11.5M $9.2M $9.2M $3.7M Rehabilitation (Mill & Overlay) $2.5M $0M $0M $2M Preservation (Slurry Seal, Crack Seal, etc.) $12.7M $12.2M $14.7M $15.1M Total $26.7M $21.4M $23.9M $20.8M Oversight of Pavement Management Program 182 miles 130miles 119 miles 115 miles Transportation Goals, Objectives & Performance Measures 106 Strategic Objectives Optimize Processes & Services Improve Asset Management Improve Community Experience Department Strategic Initiative Complete improvement projects on schedule and budget by leveraging federal funding. Intended Result To provide a safe and efficient multimodal transportation system. Performance Measures FY2021 Actual FY2022 Actual FY2023 Estimate FY2024 Target % signalized intersections connected to the central signal system (204 signalized intersections, and five HAWKs) 91% 93% 97% 99% Flashing Yellow Arrow Installation Program – Number of intersections updated – (44 locations) 33 33 33 44 Complete three school zone construction projects each year (total of 11) 4 6 8 11 Complete conversion of illuminated street name signs at four intersections to LED technology 15 16 31 35 Install enhanced detection at 7 signalized intersections per year 18 24 34 41 Transportation FY23 Accomplishments 107 • $11.4M Grant Funds Secured in FY23 • 3 Miles of Arterial Reconstruction • 119 Miles Pavement Rehabilitation & Treatment • Developed a Citywide Landscape Plan • Airport Taxiway & South Apron Reconstruction & Rehabilitation • Airport Eastside Masterplan and Rates & Fees Study • Advanced Adaptive Traffic Management Systems in the Sports & Entertainment District • Upgraded TMC and Equipment at 184 Intersections Transportation FY23 Accomplishments 108 • Alive @ 25 program for High Schools • Glendale Family Bike Ride • Launched On-demand Micro-transit Service Transportation FY24 Supplemental Requests 109 General Fund Right of Way Maintenance-Landscape Plan $ 68k Graffiti Removal Contract Services $ 15k Highway User Revenue Fund Signs & Markings Thermoplastic Machine &Trailer $102k New FTE – Temporary Service Worker to Reg. FTE $ 39k Streets Maint. – Bobcat Loader & Trailer $128k Graffiti Removal – Truck Bed Topper $ 9k Right of Way Maintenance – Chipper $ 89k New FTE – Temp Service Worker to Reg FTE (2) $ 42k Citywide Standby Pay Increase $ 12k Transportation FY24 Supplemental Requests 110 Transportation Sales Tax Glendale On Board Audit $231k Fixed Route Bus Services $216k New FTE – Transportation Deputy Director $236k Reclass .75 Dispatcher Router to 1.0 Mgmt. Analyst $ 68k Overtime increase $ 3k New FTE – Temp Education Specialist to Reg FTE $ 42k New FTE – Temp Admin Support to Reg. FTE $ 25k New FTE – Temp Transit Operator to Reg. FTE (4) $145k Reclass .75 Lead Transit Rep to 1.0 Lead Transit Rep $ 17k New FTE – ITS Technician $164k Transportation FY24 Supplemental Requests 111 Airport Special Revenue Airport Landscape Maintenance $ 3k Airport Tractor Replacement $ 82k Airport Temporary Pay & Equipment $ 63k 112 QUESTIONS? Development Services April 6, 2023 114 Mission Statement Development Services provides exceptional customer service to create a quality environment, ensure safe development, and preserve our Glendale community. Development Services $7,763,894 53 FTEs Building Safety Planning Development Services FY24 Operating Budget Request Total FY24 Operating Budget $7,763,894 $6,108,394 79% $1,063,494 14% $592,005 7% Salary Operating Internal Services 115 Development Services Goals, Objectives & Performance Measures 116 *Calls included due to COVID-19 Strategic Objective Optimize Processes & Services Department Strategic Initiative Provide complete and timely review using our newly published time frames to speed projects to completion in an inclusive and open process Intended Result Glendale customers receive superior customer service Performance Measures FY2021 Actual FY2022 Actual FY2023 Estimate FY2024 Target Number of service requests filed 377 197 655 450 Number of filed cases 444 230 415 300 Planning customers/visits assisted at the Development Services Center counter and telephone calls * 9,792* 9,850* 11,000 15,000 Development Services Goals, Objectives & Performance Measures 117 Strategic Objective Optimize Processes & Services Department Strategic Initiative 95% of all plan review submittals are completed within two review cycles Intended Result Thorough and expedient review of construction plans support the development of our community Performance Measures FY2021 Actual FY2022 Actual FY2023 Estimate FY2024 Target Number building permits issued 7,604 9,764 9,900 8,500 Number of plan reviews completed 7,080 8,741 9,100 8,000 Number of plan reviews completed electronically 7,080 8,741 9,100 8,000 % of submitted plans approved at first review 74% 79% 82% 85% % of submitted plans approved at second review 22% 19% 17% 14% % of submitted plans requiring 3 or more reviews 4% 2% 1% 1% Development Services FY23 Accomplishments 118 Annexation of (9 cases) 1.08 sq miles; grand total of 67.4 sq miles Notable Planning Projects Include: o Chicken N Pickle o Shops @ Olive Marketplace o Andretti Indoor Karting Residential Design Approval o 1,384 multifamily units o 1,554 single family lots (Final Plats/House Products) Current Construction Plan Review o 4.4 million square feet of new industrial development o 632,000 square feet of commercial developments o 2,654 of Multi-Family Units Development Services FY23 Accomplishments 119 Permitted or Under Construction o 9,764 permits have been issued o 18.4 million sq ft of industrial development in construction in the Loop 303 Corridor o 3,825 Multi-Family Units Innovative Customer Service o Pre-Application meetings (online and in person) o Pre-Construction meetings (on jobsite) o Pre-Certificate of Occupancy meetings (on jobsite) Development Services FY23 Accomplishments 120 Notable developments issued a Certificate of Occupancy : o Sweetwater Music (Logistics) o Popstroke (Experiential Entertainment) o Enviro-Log (Recycling, Clean Fuel) GIS DATA o 696 Acres added (1.08 sq miles) o 23 Plats/15 Minor Land Divisions,1,777 New Parcels o 1,974 New Assigned Addresses (Maintaining 119,946 total) Development Services FY24 Supplemental Requests 121 General Fund General Plan Rewrite $500k ARCGIS Software $ 6k Cost of Service Study $ 85k New FTE – Administrative Support Assistant $ 64k New FTE – Development Services Representative $ 77k Reclass Building Safety Official to Deputy Director $ 20k Reclass Planning Manager to Deputy Director $ 0k Car Allowance $ 3k 122 QUESTIONS? Water Services April 6, 2023 124 Mission Statement The Water Services Department provides customers with safe, reliable, high quality water, wastewater, and storm water services to ensure the health, vitality and sustainability of our community. Water Services $72,788,474 214 FTEs Plant Operations System Operations Environmental Programs Administration Support Water Services FY24 Operating Budget Request Total FY24 Operating Budget $72,788,474 $27,606,487 38% $34,804,070 48% $10,377,917 14% Salary Operating Internal Services 125 Water Services Goals, Objectives & Performance Measures 126 Strategic Objectives Improve Resource Alignment Increase Purposeful Communication Improve Community Experience Department Strategic Initiatives Recharge 2,000 acre feet of Central Arizona Project (CAP) water and available effluent. Reduce production per capita. Convert grass landscape to xeriscape landscape. Educate users about conservation and sustainability programs. Intended Result Sustain today’s resources for future availability. Performance Measures FY2021 Actual FY2022 Actual FY2023 Estimate FY2024 Target CAP water recharged (acre foot) 732 2,500 0 0 Effluent recharged (acre foot) 5,185 6,544 6,900 7,000 Gallons Produced per Capita per Day (GPCD) 153 143 142 142 # of water/wastewater samples analyzed by Water Quality Laboratory (WQL) 9,008 9,264 7,300 8,000 Square footage of converted landscape 101,337 121,881 100,000 105,000 # of students in Youth Education Program 904 2,508 1,000 1,500 # of participants in Green Living Series 571 716 540 600 Water Services Goals, Objectives & Performance Measures 127 Strategic Objectives Improve Asset Management Improve Resource Alignment Department Strategic Initiatives Deliver water to meet demand. Maintain O&M cost. Intended Result Customers receive 24/7 water and wastewater services efficiently and economically. Performance Measures FY2021 Actual FY2022 Actual FY2023 Estimate FY2024 Target Amount of water delivered in billion gallons 14.8 13.6 12.4 13.8 Water O&M cost per 1,000 gallons $0.89 $0.97 $1.14 $1.18 Amount of sewage treated in billion gallons 6.0 6.2 6.1 6.3 Wastewater O&M cost per 1,000 gallons $1.57 $1.46 $1.76 $1.79 Water Services Goals, Objectives & Performance Measures 128 Strategic Objectives Improve Asset Management Improve Resource Alignment Department Strategic Initiative Maintain O&M costs. Replace and rehabilitate lines. Exercise main valves. Clean 235 (1/3 of 707 total) miles of sewer lines. Maintain a rate of <1.0 for Sanitary Sewer Overflow per 100 miles of line. Intended Result Water distribution and wastewater collection systems are operated efficiently and economically. Performance Measures FY2021 Actual FY2022 Actual FY2023 Estimate FY2024 Target Distribution O&M cost per 1,000 gallons $0.50 $0.58 $0.74 $0.73 # of water line miles replaced of total 994 1.6 1.0 0.0 1.0 # of valves exercised of total 26,349 19,000 14,906 14,193 12,500 # of fire hydrants flushed of total 9,091 8,900 9,010 9,091 9,091 Collection O&M cost per 1,000 gallons $0.59 $0.60 $0.72 $0.73 # of sewer line miles replaced of total 708 0.2 1.5 1.1 1.0 % of 235 miles of sewer line cleaned 64% 96% 100% 100% # of Sanitary Sewer Overflow per 100 miles <1.0 0.14 <1.0 <1.0 Water Services FY23 Accomplishments 129 Pyramid Peak Water Treatment Plant’s (PPWTP) Expansion and Improvements Project was selected as a finalist for the 2023 Real Estate Development (RED) - Public Works Project of the Year Award. RED Awards are the Academy Awards of Arizona’s commercial real estate industry that honors projects completed in the 2022 calendar year. The City of Glendale was also selected for its operational excellence as the AZ Water Association’s 2023 Large Plant of the Year. Completed the design and drilling for the Arrowhead Hospital (COG-50) and Sierra Verde Park (COG-51) Wells. The need for the construction of these two wells was identified during an evaluation for additional groundwater supply in the Water Services Department’s Groundwater Well Program. Water Services FY23 Accomplishments 130 Designed and started construction on two inter-connections with adjacent cities in the north end of the city to provide additional sources of water in a time of outage. Project has been awarded up to $2 million in Federal funding for inter- connection. Water Services FY24 Supplemental Requests 131 Water Fund Increase for Raw Water Costs – Water $849k Increase for Chemical Costs – Water $2.2M Increase for Water Meters Costs – Water $750k Increase for Equipment Maintenance – Water $220k Increase for Water Conservation – Water $100k Increase for Overtime Costs – Water $127k Citywide Standby Pay Increase – Water $ 92k Car Allowance – Water $ 3k Water Services FY24 Supplemental Requests 132 Sewer Fund Increase for Chemical Costs – Sewer $286k Increase for 91st Avenue WWTP Costs $207k Increase for Equipment Maintenance – Sewer $100k Increase for Overtime Costs - Sewer $ 32k Citywide Standby Pay Increase – Sewer $ 33k 133 QUESTIONS?