Presentation

City of Glendale — Regular Meeting (2023-06-27)

View PDF Item 2 Meeting page

Extracted text (via pymupdf) 12599 characters
Glendale, Arizona
June 27, 2023
City Council Work Session:
Land Use Assumptions,
Water and Wastewater Infrastructure 
Improvements Plan

2
Overview
•
Development Fee Basics
•
Land Use Assumptions
•
Infrastructure Improvements Plan
•
Fee Comparison
•
Adoption Timeline

3
Development Fee Basics
• Not a revenue raising mechanism, but a way to meet 
growth-related infrastructure needs
•
It’s a land use regulation
•
Provide infrastructure as growth occurs
• New development’s proportionate share of capital 
cost for system improvements
•
Demographic analysis and development projections
•
Infrastructure needs and cost analysis
• Fee payers must receive a benefit
•
Geographic service areas
•
Accounting and expenditure controls

4
Fee Methodologies
TischlerBise  |  www.tischlerbise.com
•
Cost Recovery Approach (Past)
•
Future development is “buying in” to the cost the community has already 
incurred to provide growth-related capacity
•
Common in communities approaching buildout
•
Incremental Expansion Approach (Present)
•
Formula-based approach based on existing levels of service
•
Fee is based on the current cost to replicate existing levels of service 
(i.e., replacement cost)
•
Plan-Based Approach (Future)
•
Usually reflects an adopted CIP or master plan
•
Growth-related costs are more refined

5
Land Use Assumptions (East Glendale)
Projected housing units and employment based on MAG projections.
2023
2024
2025
2026
2027
2028
2029
2030
2031
2032
2033
Base Year
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
Resident Population
Single Family
181,749
182,552
183,355
183,751
184,146
184,542
184,937
185,333
185,502
185,671
185,840
4,090
Multi-Family
83,107
83,590
84,073
84,729
85,384
86,039
86,694
87,349
87,958
88,566
89,175
6,067
Total
264,857
266,143
267,429
268,480
269,530
270,581
271,632
272,682
273,460
274,237
275,014
10,158
Housing Units
Single Family
57,051
57,306
57,561
57,686
57,812
57,937
58,063
58,189
58,242
58,296
58,349
1,299
Multi-Family
39,879
40,114
40,348
40,666
40,984
41,303
41,621
41,939
42,234
42,529
42,825
2,945
Total
96,930
97,420
97,909
98,353
98,796
99,240
99,684
100,127
100,476
100,825
101,174
4,244
Employment
Industrial
8,250
8,448
8,646
8,855
9,064
9,272
9,481
9,690
9,826
9,962
10,097
1,848
Commercial
26,491
26,760
27,029
27,265
27,501
27,737
27,973
28,209
28,370
28,532
28,694
2,203
Office & Other Services
33,057
33,927
34,796
35,775
36,754
37,733
38,711
39,690
40,739
41,788
42,838
9,781
Institutional
10,987
11,113
11,239
11,319
11,398
11,478
11,558
11,637
11,763
11,889
12,015
1,028
Total
78,784
80,247
81,710
83,213
84,717
86,220
87,723
89,226
90,699
92,171
93,643
14,859
Nonres. Floor Area (x1,000)
Industrial
7,128
7,299
7,470
7,651
7,831
8,011
8,192
8,372
8,489
8,607
8,724
1,596
Commercial
12,477
12,604
12,731
12,842
12,953
13,064
13,175
13,286
13,363
13,439
13,515
1,038
Office & Other Services
10,149
10,416
10,682
10,983
11,283
11,584
11,884
12,185
12,507
12,829
13,151
3,003
Institutional
3,626
3,667
3,709
3,735
3,761
3,788
3,814
3,840
3,882
3,923
3,965
339
Total
33,379
33,986
34,592
35,210
35,829
36,447
37,065
37,684
38,241
38,798
39,355
5,976
East Glendale
10-Year 
Increase
East Glendale is east of 115th Avenue

6
Water Infrastructure Improvements Plan
•
Service Area: East Glendale
•
Components:
•
Water Supply (Plan-Based)
•
Wells (Plan-Based)
•
Water Treatment (Cost Recovery)
•
Distribution Lines (Plan-Based)

7
Water Demand
Residential
19,770,959
59,005
335
Nonresidential
14,244,266
4,463
3,192
Total
34,015,225
63,468
536
Source: Glendale Water Services Department, 2022
Customer Type
Average Day 
Gallons
Accounts
Avg Day Gallons 
per Account
Gallons
Accounts
Gallons
Accounts
2022
34,015,225
63,468
206,025
615
382,996
120
Base
2023
34,364,299
63,806
85,410
255
263,664
83
1
2024
34,713,372
64,143
85,410
255
263,664
83
2
2025
35,062,446
64,481
85,410
255
263,664
83
3
2026
35,373,235
64,690
42,057
126
268,732
84
4
2027
35,684,024
64,900
42,057
126
268,732
84
5
2028
35,994,813
65,110
42,057
126
268,732
84
6
2029
36,305,601
65,320
42,057
126
268,732
84
7
2030
36,616,390
65,529
42,057
126
268,732
84
8
2031
36,876,494
65,659
17,965
54
242,139
76
9
2032
37,136,598
65,788
17,965
54
242,139
76
10
2033
37,396,701
65,918
17,965
54
242,139
76
3,032,403
2,112
435,000
1,299
2,597,403
814
Note: Glendale classifies connections as either residential or commercial. Residential connections inclue 0.75-inch meters 
used for single-family units, and commercial connections include all nonresidential meters and multi-family meters larger 
than 0.75 inches. The model uses single-family units as a proxy for residential connections and nonresidential floor area as 
a proxy for nonresidential connections.
10-Year Increase
Annual Increase
Year
Average Day
Gallons
Total
Accounts
Residential
Nonresidential
Current residential accounts demand 335 gallons per day.
Current nonresidential accounts demand 3,192 gallons per day.
We project future gallons using 
existing demand factors and 
projected development in East 
Glendale.

8
Water Components
Water Supply
(Plan-Based)
Wells
(Plan-Based)
Glendale will use development fees to acquire additional 
water supply.
Glendale will use development fees to construct additional 
wells.
Wells
Cost
New Site COG 50 and COG 51
$14,000,000
Future Well
$8,000,000
Future Well
$8,000,000
Total Cost
$30,000,000
÷ Total Capacity (Average Day Gallons)
9,300,000
 Cost per Gallon
$3.23
   10-Year Increase in Gallons
3,032,403
10-Year Revenue Collections
$9,794,661
Water Supply
Cost
White Mountain Apache Lease Purchase
$8,000,000
- Development Fee Revenue Collections
($4,459,473)
Adjusted Cost
$3,540,527
÷ Total Capacity (Average Day Gallons)
983,000
 Cost per Gallon
$3.60
Water Treatment
(Cost Recovery)
Distribution Lines
(Plan-Based)
Glendale will use development fees to oversize / extend 
distribution lines to serve future development.
Glendale will use development fees to pay debt service. 
Water Treatment
Cost
Cholla Water Treatment Plant
$77,560,000
Oasis Water Treatment Plant
$82,625,598
Pyramid Peak Water Treatment Plant
$47,810,693
Total (Original Cost)
$207,996,291
÷ Total Capacity (Average Day Gallons)
85,000,000
 Cost per Gallon
$2.45
   10-Year Increase in Gallons
3,032,403
10-Year Revenue Collections
$7,429,387
Distribution Line Annual Cost
$240,000
10-Year Total Cost
$2,400,000
   10-Year Increase in Gallons
3,032,403
Cost per Gallon
$0.79
Cost Factors

9
Proposed Water Fees
Cost per Gallon
Water Supply
$3.60
Wells
$3.23
Water Treatment
$2.45
Distribution Lines
$0.79
Development Fee Report
$0.01
Total
$10.08
Residential Gallons per Day
335
0.75-inch
1.00
$3,377
$2,923
$454
1.00-inch
1.67
$5,639
$4,878
$761
1.50-inch
3.33
$11,245
$9,722
$1,523
2.00-inch
5.33
$17,998
$15,558
$2,440
3.00-inch
10.67
$36,030
$31,139
$4,891
4.00-inch
16.67
$56,291
$48,647
$7,644
6.00-inch
33.33
$112,549
$97,259
$15,290
8.00-inch
53.33
$180,085
$155,617
$24,468
1. AWWA Manual of Water Supply Practices M-1, 7th Edition
Meter Size
Capacity 
Ratio1
Proposed
Fees
Current 
Fees
Increase / 
(Decrease)
Fee Component
Demand Indicator
Fees per Meter

10
Wastewater Infrastructure Improvements Plan
•
Service Area: East Glendale
•
Components:
•
Wastewater Treatment (Cost Recovery)
•
Lift Station (Plan-Based)
•
Collection Lines (Plan-Based)

11
Wastewater Flow
Residential
16,038,803
55,548
289
Nonresidential
3,405,586
3,556
958
Total
19,444,389
59,104
329
Source: Glendale Water Services Department, 2022
Customer Type
Average Day 
Gallons
Accounts
Avg Day Gallons 
per Account
Gallons
Accounts
Gallons
Accounts
2022
19,444,389
59,104
96,815
335
375,419
392
Base
2023
19,581,109
59,425
73,682
255
63,038
66
1
2024
19,717,829
59,746
73,682
255
63,038
66
2
2025
19,854,549
60,066
73,682
255
63,038
66
3
2026
19,955,081
60,259
36,282
126
64,250
67
4
2027
20,055,613
60,452
36,282
126
64,250
67
5
2028
20,156,144
60,644
36,282
126
64,250
67
6
2029
20,256,676
60,837
36,282
126
64,250
67
7
2030
20,357,208
61,029
36,282
126
64,250
67
8
2031
20,430,597
61,144
15,498
54
57,892
60
9
2032
20,503,987
61,258
15,498
54
57,892
60
10
2033
20,577,377
61,372
15,498
54
57,892
60
996,268
1,947
375,269
1,299
620,999
648
10-Year Increase
Note: Glendale classifies connections as either residential or commercial. Residential connections inclue 0.75-inch meters 
used for single-family units, and commercial connections include all nonresidential meters and multi-family meters larger 
than 0.75 inches. The model uses single-family units as a proxy for residential connections and nonresidential floor area as 
a proxy for nonresidential connections.
Residential
Nonresidential
Year
Average Day
Gallons
Total
Accounts
Annual Increase
Current residential accounts generate 289 gallons per day.
Current nonresidential accounts generate 958 gallons per day.
We project future gallons using 
existing flow factors and projected 
development in East Glendale.

12
Wastewater Components
Wastewater Treatment
(Cost Recovery)
Lift Station
(Plan-Based)
Glendale will use development fees to pay debt service.
Wastewater Treatment
Cost
Arrowhead Water Reclamation Facility
$42,725,000
West Area Water Reclamation Facility
$114,890,000
91st Ave Wastewater Treatment Plant
$51,074,000
Total (Original Cost)
$208,689,000
÷ Total Capacity (Average Day Gallons)
29,200,000
 Cost per Gallon
$7.15
   10-Year Increase in Gallons
996,268
10-Year Revenue Collections
$7,123,316
Water Treatment
Remaining Principal
Arrowhead Water Reclamation Facility
$5,380,647
West Area Water Reclamation Facility
$9,061,417
91st Ave Wastewater Treatment Plant
$25,355,436
Total Remaining Principal
$39,797,500
10-Year Revenue Collections
$7,123,316
Lift Station
Cost
Expand 67th Ave and ACDC Lift Station
$4,500,000
÷ Additional Capacity (Gallons)
3,348,000
 Cost per Gallon
$1.34
   10-Year Increase in Gallons
996,268
10-Year Revenue Collections
$1,334,999
Glendale will use development fees to construct an 
additional lift station.
Collection Lines
(Plan-Based)
Glendale will use development fees to oversize / extend 
collection lines to serve future development.
Collection Line Annual Cost
$700,000
10-Year Total Cost
$7,000,000
   10-Year Increase in Gallons
996,268
Cost per Gallon
$7.03
Cost Factors

13
Proposed Wastewater Fees
Cost per Gallon
Wastewater Treatment
$7.15
Lift Station
$1.34
Collection Lines
$7.03
Development Fee Report
$0.03
Total
$15.55
Residential Gallons per Day
289
0.75-inch
1.00
$4,494
$1,609
$2,885
1.00-inch
1.67
$7,505
$2,684
$4,821
1.50-inch
3.33
$14,965
$5,346
$9,619
2.00-inch
5.33
$23,953
$8,553
$15,400
3.00-inch
10.67
$47,950
$17,117
$30,833
4.00-inch
16.67
$74,914
$26,739
$48,175
6.00-inch
33.33
$149,783
$53,456
$96,327
8.00-inch
53.33
$239,662
$85,530
$154,132
1. AWWA Manual of Water Supply Practices M-1, 7th Edition
Meter Size
Capacity 
Ratio1
Proposed
Fees
Current 
Fees
Demand Indicator
Fee Component
Fees per Meter
Increase / 
(Decrease)

14
Fee Comparison – Single Family
Single Family (Base Meter)
Water
Water 
Resource
Waste-
water
Total
Apache Junction
$6,994
$3,486
$4,295
$14,775
Buckeye - Central
$7,675
$0
$4,214
$11,889
Buckeye - Tartesso West
$3,717
$0
$7,670
$11,388
Goodyear - South (Updating)
$503
$7,843
$2,538
$10,884
Goodyear - North (Updating)
$503
$7,553
$2,818
$10,874
Gilbert
$4,924
$3,112
$2,586
$10,622
Fountain Hills
$0
$0
$10,000
$10,000
Phoenix - Northeast
$6,330
$0
$3,303
$9,633
Avondale (Updating)
$3,822
$0
$5,808
$9,630
Peoria - West (Updating)
$4,725
$730
$3,157
$8,612
Surprise - SPA 2 (Updating)
$2,836
$3,023
$2,544
$8,403
Chandler
$3,397
$837
$4,024
$8,258
Surprise - SPA 1 (Updating)
$2,985
$3,023
$2,192
$8,200
Glendale - East (Proposed)
$3,377
$0
$4,494
$7,871
Buckeye - North
$7,076
$0
$0
$7,076
Scottsdale
$3,908
$0
$2,609
$6,517
Peoria - East (Updating)
$3,745
$730
$1,913
$6,388
Surprise - SPA 3 (Updating)
$2,486
$3,023
$0
$5,509
Queen Creek
$2,382
$0
$2,901
$5,283
Mesa
$2,220
$0
$2,659
$4,879
Casa Grande - Zone A (Updating)
$0
$0
$4,557
$4,557
Glendale - East (Current)
$2,923
$0
$1,609
$4,532
Tempe - South
$2,496
$0
$2,001
$4,497
Tempe - North
$2,472
$0
$1,994
$4,466
Casa Grande - Zone B (Updating)
$0
$0
$4,443
$4,443
Glendale - West (Current)
$0
$0
$0
$0
Glendale - West (Proposed)
$0
$0
$0
$0

15
Adoption Timeline
• May 17, 2022: Kick-Off Meeting
• June 27, 2023: City Council Work Session
• July 5: LUA & IIP - Advertise (60 days)
• TBD: Stakeholder Outreach
• Sept 12: LUA & IIP - Public Hearing (30 days)
• Oct 24: LUA & IIP - Adoption
• Oct 25: Development Fees - Advertise (30 days)
• Nov 28: Development Fees - Public Hearing (30 days)
• Jan 9, 2024: Development Fees - Adoption (75 days)
• March 25: Development Fees - Effective