Plan Amendment

City of Glendale — Regular Meeting (2021-01-21)

View PDF Item b Meeting page

Extracted text (via pymupdf) 18562 characters
City of Glendale 
Substantial Annual Action 
Plan Amendments  
 
FYs 2016-17, 2017-18, 2018-2019 & 2019-20 
Glendale Community Revitalization Division 
5850 W Glendale Ave, Glendale, AZ 85301 
623.930.3670 • revitalization@glendaleaz.com 
 
Public Comment Period 
 
January 8, 2021 through February 7, 2021

City of Glendale Combined FYs 2016-17, 2017-18, 2018-19 and 2019-20 
Annual Action Plans Substantial Amendment #1 
 
Public Comment Period: January 8, 2021 to February 7, 2021 
 
INTRODUCTION  
 
The City of Glendale’s HUD Annual Action Plans (AAP) detail the community’s funding strategy to expend 
Community Development Block Grant (CDBG), Emergency Solutions Grants (ESG), and HOME 
Investment Partnerships Program each year.  The Plans implement the goals of the City’s Five-Year 
Consolidated Plan by funding allocations to specific activities that advance these goals, and are 
developed through significant public input, analysis, and planning.  
 
Title 24 Section 91.505 of the Code of Federal Regulations stipulates that communities shall amend their 
approved plans whenever they make one or more of the following decisions:  
 
1. To make a change in its allocation priorities or a change in the method of distribution of funds;  
2. To carry out an activity, using funds from any program covered by the Consolidated Plan 
(including program income) not previously described in the action plan; or 
 
3. To change the purpose, scope, location, or beneficiaries of an activity. 
 
 
The Regulation further requires that jurisdictions identify in their Citizen Participation Plans the criteria 
they will use for determining what constitutes a substantial amendment. As a member of the Maricopa 
HOME Consortium the City follows the Consortium’s FY 2015-19 Citizen Participation Plan. Consistent 
with these requirements, the City identified three criteria that will require a substantial amendment:  
 
1. Changes in the use of CDBG/ESG funds from one eligible activity to another; or 
2. An activity is undertaken that was not previously included in the Consolidated Plan or 

subsequent Annual Action Plans; or 
3. More than twenty percent of an activity budget is proposed to be reallocated to another eligible 
program activity. 
 
 
The proposed substantial amendment triggers all three of these criteria, including: 1. changing the use 
of CDBG funds from one eligible activity to another; 2. creation of a new activity not previously included 
in existing Annual Action Plans; and 3. reallocation of 20% or more in CDBG funds from one activity to 
another eligible activity.  
 
CONTENT OF THE SUBSTANTIAL AMENDMENT  
 
With this Substantial Amendment, the City proposes to reallocate $456,381.93 in Community 
Development Block Grant (CDBG) funds from various activities to a new activity that will allow the City 
to complete a variety of public improvements.  Reallocation of these funds is necessary to realign final 
activity expenditures with existing Annual Action Plan allocations and repurpose unexpended funding 
from completed or cancelled activities.  The following tables outline the changes to the PYs 2026-17 
through 2019-20 Annual Action Plans by funding year, original recipient, activity name, original 
allocation and proposed final reallocation.

FY 2016-17 Annual Action Plan Revised Allocations 
  
  
Organization and Activity Name 
Original Action Plan 
Allocation 
Revised Action Plan 
Allocation 
COG - Public Housing - ADA Accessibility 
 $                                -    
$                  1,408.78  
COG - Code Enforcement - Payroll 
 $                 62,552.00  
$                        39.27  
Arizona YWCA Metropolitan Phoenix Facility Renovations 
 $                 55,334.00  
$                45,525.03  
Boys and Girls Clubs of Metro PHX - Facility Improvements 
 $                 10,440.00  
$                  7,542.29  
COG - Parks and Recreation - ADA Modifications  
 $                 61,906.00  
$                15,424.71  
COG - Parks and Recreation - Community Center Renovations 
 $                 57,612.00  
$                57,199.37  
COG Community Action Program - Eviction Prevention Program 
 $                 67,863.00  
$                63,144.00  
St. Mary's Food Bank Alliance - Senior Home Delivery Program 
 $                 15,661.00  
$                15,427.00  
Aid to Adoption of Special Kids (AASK-AZ) - Mentoring Program 
 $                 10,440.00  
$                  8,782.23  
COG - Revitalization - Planning and Administration 
 $               440,157.00  
$             321,401.35  
COG - Revitalization - Rehab Program delivery 
 $               220,222.00  
$             125,757.15  
Central Arizona Shelter Services (CASS) - Floor Resurfacing 
 $                                -    
$                     199.81  
COG - Parks and Recreation - Sands Park Play Plaza 
 $                                -    
$                  1,635.88  
Glendale Women's Club - Historic Clubhouse Restoration 
 $                                -    
$                     513.66  
COG - Community Action Program - Eviction Prevention Program 
 $                                -    
$                18,568.00  
COG - Revitalization - Residential Rehabilitation Program 
 $               354,000.00  
$             348,208.04  
COG - Economic Development - Visual Improvement Program 
 $                 52,202.00  
$                53,699.40  
Rebuilding Together - Safe at Home ADA improvements 
 $                                -    
$                     136.10  
Habitat for Humanity - Emergency Home Repair Program 
 $                                -    
$             170,804.51  
COG - Public Housing - Picnic Benches & Seats 
 $                                -    
$                  1,400.45  
COG - Parks and Recreation - O'Neil Park 
 $                 60,000.00  
$                60,600.40  
COG - Various Departments - Physical improvement projects (NEW): 
 $                                -    
$             150,971.57  
Total 2016-17 Reallocated Funds: 
 $            1,468,389.00  
$          1,468,389.00  
 
 
 
FY 2017-18 Annual Action Plan Revised Allocations 
  
  
Organization and Activity Name 
Original Action Plan 
Allocation 
Revised Action Plan 
Allocation 
Central Arizona Shelter Services (CASS) - Floor Resurfacing 
$                  62,602.00 
$                 62,309.41 
COG - Parks and Recreation - Sands Park Play Plaza 
$                103,287.00  
$              103,000.00 
Chrysalis Shelter for Victims of Domestic Violence - Victim Services 
$                  15,483.00  
$                   9,462.27 
Valley Life - Counseling for Adults with Developmental Disabilities 
$                    5,183.00  
$                      581.25 
Hope for Hunger - Hunger Fighters 
$                  25,783.00  
$                 23,465.86 
COG - Community Action Program - Eviction Prevention Program 
$                  66,985.00  
$                 45,967.00 
A New Leaf, Inc. - Faith House Emergency Shelter Operations 
$                  30,933.00  
$                 27,274.55 
COG - Revitalization - Planning and Administration 
$                454,070.00  
$              376,358.01 
COG - Various Departments - Physical improvement projects (NEW) 
$                                  -    
$              115,907.65 
Total 2017-18 Reallocated Funds: 
$                764,326.00  
$              764,326.00 
 
 
 
FY 2018-19 Annual Action Plan Revised Allocations 
  
  
Organization and Activity Name 
Original Action Plan 
Allocation 
Revised Action Plan 
Allocation 
Sojourner Center - DV Campus Beautification 
$                    9,590.00  
$                              -    
St. Mary's Food Bank Alliance - Glendale Home Delivery Program 
$                  10,000.00  
$                              -    
Gompers - Employment First 
$                  15,100.00  
$                              -    
COG - Community Action Program - Eviction Prevention Program 
$                  50,000.00  
$                49,975.00  
Glendale Works - Homeless Workforce Development Program 
$                  41,158.00  
$                16,773.78  
Chrysalis Shelter for Victims of Domestic Violence - victim services 
$                  10,000.00  
$                  8,444.58  
Sojourner Center - Court liaison 
$                  15,000.00  
$                10,607.26  
COG - Revitalization - Planning and Administration 
$                495,035.00  
$             381,581.67  
COG - Various Departments - Physical improvement projects (NEW) 
$                                 -    
$             178,500.71  
Total 2018-19 Reallocated Funds: 
$                645,883.00  
$             645,883.00

FY 2019-20 Annual Action Plan Revised Allocations 
  
  
Organization and Activity Name 
Original Action Plan 
Allocation 
Revised Action Plan 
Allocation 
COG - Revitalization - Youth Internship Program 
 $                 11,002.00  
 $                             -    
COG - Various Departments - Physical improvement projects (NEW) 
 $                                -    
 $               11,002.00  
 Total 2019-20 Reallocated Funds: 
 $                 11,002.00  
 $               11,002.00  
 
In total, $456,381.93 in CDBG funds are proposed for reallocation to physical improvement activities 
that may include, but are not limited to: water, sewer, street, curb/gutter, and sidewalk improvements, 
lighting, ADA improvements, streetscape enhancements, drainage, facility improvements and other 
possible infrastructure, right-of-way and neighborhood enhancements.  Specific activities that may be 
completed include architectural, engineering, permitting and planning costs, environmental review 
costs, as well as construction and construction management expenses. 
 
Other Plan Amendment Components 
 
In addition to the reallocation of funding described in the previous section, the City also proposes to 
change the scope of the following three activities: 
 
2016-2017 Annual Action Plan:  Activity 9 – COG Visual Improvement Program VIP (page 30) – $52,202  
 
The Activity name will be changed to Downtown Glendale Street Lighting, and the activity Description 
section will be revised to:  Per 24 CFR 501(c), the City of Glendale will install café-style street lighting in 
the Downtown area.  Funding will be available for architectural, engineering, consulting, 
planning/permitting fees, environmental review costs, construction and construction management 
expenses. 
 
Proposed beneficiaries and the total funding allocation will remain the same and qualify for under the 
Low/Moderate Income CDBG National Objective as an area benefit OR as a Slum/blight area benefit. 
 
2017-2018 Annual Action Plan: Activity 10 – COG Visual Improvement Program (VIP) (page 33) – $51,791 
 
The Activity name will be changed to Downtown Glendale Street Lighting, and the activity Description 
section will be revised to:  Per 24 CFR 501(c), the City of Glendale will install café-style street lighting in 
the Downtown area.  Funding will be available for architectural, engineering, consulting, 
planning/permitting fees, environmental review costs, construction and construction management 
expenses. 
 
Proposed beneficiaries and the total funding allocation will remain the same and qualify for under the 
Low/Moderate Income CDBG National Objective as an area benefit OR as a Slum/blight area benefit. 
 
2018-2019 Annual Action Plan: Activity 5 – COG Visual Improvement Program (VIP) (pages 32-33) – $100,000 
 
The Activity name will be changed to Downtown Glendale Street Lighting, and the activity Description 
section will be revised to:  Per 24 CFR 501(c), the City of Glendale will install café-style street lighting in 
the Downtown area.  Funding will be available for architectural, engineering, consulting, 
planning/permitting fees, environmental review costs, construction and construction management 
expenses.

Proposed beneficiaries and the total funding allocation will remain the same and qualify for under the 
Low/Moderate Income CDBG National Objective as an area benefit OR as a Slum/blight area benefit. 
 
CITIZEN PARTICIPATION  
 
In accordance with 24 CFR 91.105(c)(3), the City adhered to its Citizen Participation Plan in order to 
obtain input on the proposed Substantial Amendment.  
 
A copy of the Substantial Amendment is available for public review anytime on the City of Glendale’s 
website at www.glendaleaz.com/communityservicesplans or weekdays between the hours of 8:00 AM 
and 5:00 PM at the following locations: 
 
1. Reference desk at the Glendale Main Public Library, 5959 W. Brown Street 
2. Reference desk at the Velma Teague Library, 7010 N. 58th Avenue 
3. Reference desk at the Foothills Library, 19055 N. 57th Avenue 
4. Reference desk at Heroes Regional Park Library, 6075 N. 83rd Avenue 
5. Glendale Community Revitalization Division, 5850 W. Glendale Avenue, Suite 107 
6. Glendale Public Housing Authority, 6842 N. 61st Avenue 
7. Glendale Community Action Program Office, 5850 W Glendale Ave, Suite B38 
 
The Community Revitalization Division will hold a public hearing on Thursday, January 16, 2021 at 6:30 
PM in Room B3 of Glendale City Hall or via Zoom.  This meeting will occur concurrent with the regularly 
scheduled Community Development Advisory Committee meeting. Following the 30-day public 
comment period and public hearing, the Glendale City Council is expected to take action on this 
Substantial Amendment at a regular meeting on Tuesday, February 9, 2021 or Tuesday, February 23, 
2021.  
 
A copy of the public hearing notice is presented in Exhibit 1. A summary of citizen comments received at 
the public hearing and responses to these citizen comments are presented in Exhibit 2.

PLAN  
EXHIBIT 1
 
 
PUBLIC COMMENTS & PUBLICATION of 30-DAY COMMENT PERIOD AND PUBLIC HEARING  
 
Summary of public responses received within 30-day comment period with staff responses: TBD  
 
Summary of comments received and discussion at January 21, 2021 Public Hearing: TBD  
 
PUBLIC NOTICE 
 
NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING and 30-DAY COMMENT PERIOD ON THE PROPOSED 
SUBSTANTIAL AMENDMENT 1 TO THE 2016-17, 2017-18, 2018-19 & 2019-20 HUD 
ANNUAL ACTION PLANS  
 
Notice is hereby given that the City of Glendale, Arizona proposes to amend its Fiscal Years 
(FYs) 2016-17, 2017-18, 2018-19 and 2019-20 HUD Annual Action Plans, under the 2015-2019 
Five-Year Consolidated Plan. This Substantial Amendment will include the proposed 
realignment and reallocation of $456,381.93 in CDBG funds from completed or canceled 
activities to a new activity that will allow the City to complete various physical improvement 
projects. 
 
This Substantial Amendment will be available for a 30-day public comment period beginning 
Friday, January 8, 2021 and close on Sunday, February 7, 2021.  All residents, property and 
business owners, partnering agencies and other stakeholders of the City of Glendale are 
encouraged to submit written comments or questions regarding the proposed Substantial 
Amendment to Matthew Hess, Community Revitalization Administrator, at Glendale City Hall, 
5850 W. Glendale Ave, Suite 107, Glendale, AZ 85301, or by email at 
revitalization@glendaleaz.com. 
 
A copy of this Substantial Amendment and the related Annual Action Plans are available for 
public review at:  www.glendaleaz.com/communityservicesplans 
 
or weekdays between the hours of 8:00 AM and 5:00 PM at the following locations: 
 
1. Reference desk at the Glendale Main Public Library, 5959 W. Brown Street 
2. Reference desk at the Velma Teague Branch Library, 7010 N. 58th Avenue 
3. Reference desk at the Foothills Library, 19055 N. 57th Avenue 
4. Reference desk at the Heroes Park Library, 6075 N. 83rd Avenue 
5. Glendale Community Revitalization Division, 5850 W. Glendale Avenue, Suite 107 
6. Glendale Public Housing Authority, 6842 N. 61st Avenue 
7. Glendale Community Action Program Office, 5850 W Glendale Ave, Suite B38 
 
A public hearing will take place at the Community Development Advisory Committee on 
Thursday, January 21, 2021 at 6:30pm.  The Community Development Advisory Committee 
meetings will be closed to the public until further notice. This action follows guidelines from the 
federal government stating that no more than 10 people should gather in a room at the same 
time. 
 
To Watch or Listen Live

From a personal computer, tablet, or smart phone device: 
https://glendaleaz.zoom.us/j/97127565376?pwd=SFlUSmJnYUlJbXRUQ29Ca0VyRUdGZz09 
Meeting ID: 971 2756 5376 
Passcode: 649221 
By telephone at any of these numbers: 
1 669 900 6833 
1 253 215 8782 
1 346 248 7799 
1 929 205 6099 
 
CITIZEN COMMENTS 
 
Email Comments 
To submit comments on a meeting agenda item, or to comment in the Call to the Public for non-
agenda items, please email CDAC@glendaleaz.com. The deadline for submitting comments is 
Thursday, January 21, 2021 at 4:00 p.m. Please note, that only emails received by that time will 
be considered and included in the record.  Staff will read the first five minutes of your written 
comments for agenda items, and the first three minutes of your written comments for Call to the 
Public, non-agenda items. Your entire email will be included into the record. 
 
Recorded Comments 
Residents can submit recorded comments on a voting meeting agenda item, or to comment in 
the Call to the Public for non-agenda items, by calling 623-930-4530 and leaving a voicemail 
recording of your comments. The deadline for submitting comments is Thursday, January 21, 
2021 at 4:00 p.m. Please note, that only voicemails received by that time will be considered and 
included in the record. Staff will play the first five minutes of your comments for agenda items, 
and the first three minutes of your comments for Call to the Public, non-agenda items. 
 
2015-2019 CITY OF GLENDALE CONSOLIDATED PLAN SUBSTANTIAL AMENDMENT TO 
THE 20 
FOR SPECIAL ACCOMMODATIONS 
  
City facilities are wheelchair accessible. For special accommodations, please contact 
Matthew Hess at the Community Revitalization Division, phone (623) 930-3670, at least 
three (3) working days prior to the hearing. Hearing-impaired persons, please use the 
AZ Relay Service number 711, or Glendale TDD (623) 930-2197. 
 
Asistencia en espanol:  Para que le interpreten la solicitud en espanol, llame al (623) 930-3670. 
 
Publish: The Glendale Star January 7, 2021 and January 14, 2021STANTIAL AMENDMENT TO 
THE 2018/19 ACTION PLAN